The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. 30/6.00 pm Smti. Namita Sarkar, the claimant respondent herein was going by the left side on the road towards Bhati Abhoynagar near Mailakhala Bridge. At that time, suddenly an Auto Truck bearing registration no. TR01J(TEM)3786 which was renumbered as TR01T1585 hereinafter mentioned as offending vehicle dashed her from the backside and as a result the claimant fell down on the road and sustained injuries in her person including legs, waist, chest, head, backbone. Allegedly, her left leg was totally broken. As such, she is now unable to move without an attendant. The claimant immediately after the occurrence was shifted to the GBP Hospital, Agartala where she undergone treatment as an indoor patient from the date of accident till 25.01.2012 and thereafter also she undergone treatment as an outdoor patient. Allegedly, the claimant is the only earning member of her family and she used to earn Rs.10,000/ per month by rearing cows and selling milk. Her whole family is dependent upon her. In fine, the claimant quantified her claim to the tune of Rs.11,50,000/ under various heads. [4] Due to such accident claimant became permanently disabled to the extent of 50%. In this connection with the aforesaid accident, a specific case vide West Agartala PS case No. 381/2013, u/s 279/337 of the IPC was also registered. [5] After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having g…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
MAC. App. No.60 of 2022
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited
.....Appellant
V_E_R_S_U_S
Smti. Namita Sarkar & Another
.....Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing and delivery
Of judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. B. Majumder, Advocate.
Mr. P. S. Roy, Advocate.
19.07.2023
YES/NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
Heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
also heard Mr. P.S. Roy, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This application has been filed under Section-173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 along with its up to date amendments against the impugned
judgment and award dated 17.12.2021, passed by the learned Member Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala rendering in case
No.T.S.(MAC) 146 of 2016.
[3]
Brief facts leading to this case are that on 16.01.2012 at about
5.30/6.00 pm Smti. Namita Sarkar, the claimant respondent herein was going by
the left side on the road towards Bhati Abhoynagar near Mailakhala Bridge. At
that time, suddenly an Auto Truck bearing registration no. TR01J(TEM)3786
which was renumbered as TR01T1585 hereinafter mentioned as offending vehicle
dashed her from the backside and as a result the claimant fell down on the road
and sustained injuries in her person including legs, waist, chest, head, backbone.
Allegedly, her left leg was totally broken. As such, she is now unable to move
without an attendant. The claimant immediately after the occurrence was shifted to
the GBP Hospital, Agartala where she undergone treatment as an indoor patient
from the date of accident till 25.01.2012 and thereafter also she undergone
treatment as an outdoor patient. Allegedly, the claimant is the only earning
member of her family and she used to earn Rs.10,000/ per month by rearing cows
and selling milk. Her whole family is dependent upon her. In fine, the claimant
quantified her claim to the tune of Rs.11,50,000/ under various heads.
[4]
Due to such accident claimant became permanently disabled to the
extent of 50%. In this connection with the aforesaid accident, a specific case vide
West Agartala PS case No. 381/2013, u/s 279/337 of the IPC was also registered.
[5]
After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
having gone through the material evidence on record, the learned Court bellow has
observed as under:
In the result, claim is awarded in following terms:
Claimant petitioner is entitled to get the award of Rs.2,30,000/- (rupees two
lacs thirty thousand) only with 6% Simple interest per annum from the date of
registration of claim i.e, w.e.f. 21.07.2016 till the date of realization thereof.
The OP No. 2, The Oriental Insurance Company Limited shall, within 30 days
of the date of this award, deposit the entire amount as awarded, in favour of
the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala.”
[6]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the appellant-
insurance company has submitted that the learned tribunal did not apply its
judicious mind and with flagrant disregard of law and justice and in a pervasive
manner has imposed the liability of payment of compensation of Rs.2,30,000/only upon the appellant insurance company and as such, it is not only sustainable
and tenable in the eye of the law but of excessive and harsh and as such, it is liable
to be dismissed.
[7]
The learned tribunal believed the deposition of PW-1 i.e. the
claimant-respondent, who relied the charge sheet dated 28.02.2015 but, solely
basing on their depositions has awarded the liability of payment of compensation
upon the appellant. In this regard, there is no whisper in the impugned judgment
and award under what manner and what is the basis of such belief. The learned
tribunal has been inspired to rely upon the deposition rendered by the witnesses
without any corroboration of any other witnesses and what had been stated in her
affidavit that has been vividly accepted and appreciated as a real truth.
[8]
It has been further contended that the learned tribunal has perversely
determined a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- since the claimant-respondent was a milk seller
as well as she become disable to the extent of 50% wherein she neither produced
the precise income of herself, but a milk seller by profession by way of
documentary evidence nor locomotor regarding her disability to the extent of 50%
was examined and as such, the award to the effect is superfluous and therefore, it
requires for interference. The learned tribunal below has miserably failed to
appreciate the documentary evidence that FIR is the motion of any incident and
the charge sheet is the integral part of the said FIR and both were exhibited and
relied by the respondent and since the contents of the document was proved by the
claimant as well as the appellant, it ought to go in favour of the appellant.
[9]
By awarding any amount under the head of litigation cost of
Rs.5,000/- is all extraneous consideration not contemplated under the statute and
as such, the learned tribunal has committed gross illegality in awarding litigation
cost and that should be quashed. The tribunal most erroneously awarded
compensation under the conventional heads like as future treatment of Rs.50,000/and any interest on this amount are against the terms of the decision of the Apex
Court’s judgment of Pranay Shetty’s case.
[10]
Ignoring the existence of valid driving license inspite of the pleading
in the WS in fixing liability upon the insurance company and the owner as OPW in
his deposition has failed to disclose the name of the driver and also failed to
produce driving license. The owner of the offending vehicle has deposed in his
cross-examination that he did not know the date and time of accident, even though
he could not say who drove the offending vehicle at the relevant time of the
alleged accident.
[11]
The learned tribunal ought to have considered that the facts
involving thereto, wherein, the alleged accident was not established by cogent
evidence at all, basing on the claim petition wherein, the claimant respondent
intentionally described her story after two years of the alleged accident in order to
get compensation for wrongful gain as a source of profit but not just
compensation. The tribunal below ought to have understood that in the facts as
well as the law involved thereto having appreciated the evidence; it is only the
owner of the offending vehicle, who is liable to make the compensation amount
awarded by the learned tribunal.
[12]
Mr. Majumder, learned counsel has further contended that the
tribunal below has erred in law with defiance of guidelines as enunciated by the
Apex Court in 2009 AIR SCW allowed the compensation as a source of profit and
a punitive one which is not at all a just compensation as decided by the Apex
Court wherein, it has been held that the expression which appears to be just in
Section-168 vests a wide discretion in the tribunal in the matter of determination
of compensation. Nevertheless, the wide amplitude of such power does not
empower the tribunal to determine the compensation arbitrarily, or to ignore
settled principles relating to determination of compensation.
[13]
The learned tribunal has passed the judgment by awarding
compensation to be paid by the insurance company to the claimant basing on
sympathy, compassion and pity, a total disregard of decision of the Apex Court in
the said judgment categorically decided that the ratio that a misplaced sympathy
generosity and benevolence cannot be the guiding factor for determining the
compensation.
[14]
In view of above discussions and having gone through the evidence
on record, it would be apposite to revisit the evidence once again. The claimant
has proved documents showing expenditure towards medical treatment only to the
extent of Rs. 7,636/- vide Exbt.6 series. It is a natural phenomena that when a
person met with accident and thereby admitted to hospital the injured remains
under treatment and his/her family members, if any, remains busy in connection
thereto and as such it is not possible for them to preserve all the cash memos and
other treatment related papers showing expenditure towards treatment. Having
regard to such circumstances I find it appropriate to award a sum of Rs. 20,000/
towards cost of treatment.
[15]
Considering the above circumstances including the fact that the
claimant was admitted to hospital at Agartala and undergone treatment as an
indoor patient for about 10 days and thereafter as an outdoor patient. It has been
further proved from the evidence on record that the claimant became disable to the
extent of 50% (Exhibit4). The claimant, as appears from the oral evidence, was a
milk seller and used to rear her cows and since she became disable she is unable to
perform her regular works.
[16]
Now coming to the question of liability, it appears that the accident
occurred due to rash and negligent driving on the part of the driver of offending
vehicle which was insured with the appellant vide Ext.C (the insurance policy). It
follows therefore, the appellant being the insurer of the offending vehicle is liable
to satisfy the award. However, by awarding any amount under the head of
litigation cost of Rs.5,000/-, according to this Court, is not justifiable as such, the
same be deducted from the total amount as awarded by the learned tribunal except
this, the remaining order shall remain unaltered.
[17]
In view of above modification, the present appeal stands partly
allowed. The insurance company shall deposit the awarded amount as assessed by
the learned tribunal within a period of one month, from the date of receipt of the
copy of this order, if not already deposited. Consequently, the claimant is at liberty
to withdraw the same as per procedure. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications
pending, if any, shall stand closed. Draw the award accordingly and thereafter,
send down the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2023.07.25
13:01:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review