Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
MAC. App. No.86 of 2022
Smti. Rumi Das (Namo) & Another
.....Claimant-petitioner-appellants
V_E_R_S_U_S
Sri Chandan Das & Another
.....Opposite parties-respondents
CO(FA) No.16 of 2022
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited
.....Cross-objector-appellant
V_E_R_S_U_S
Smti. Rumi Das (Namo) & 2 Others
.....Claimant-respondents
CO(FA) No.01 of 2023
Sri Chandan Das
.....Respondent-petitioner-cross-objector
V_E_R_S_U_S
Smti. Rumi Das (Namo) & 2 Others
.....Claimant-petitioner-respondents
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of hearing and delivery
Of judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. B. Debnath, Advocate.
Mr. B. Majumder, Advocate.
Mr. D. Debnath, Advocate.
20.07.2023
YES/NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
Heard B. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for the appellants also
heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned counsel and Mr. D. Debnath, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The present appeal has been filed under Section-173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 against the judgment and order dated 21.07.2022 passed by
the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Tribunal No.2, West
Tripura Agartala in connection with case No. TS (MAC) 09 of 2021 for
enhancement of the meager awarded amount to the claimant-petitioners due to
death of their mother, in a vehicular accident. The cross-objection [CO (FA) 16 of
2022] has been filed under Order-41 Rule-22 of the Code of Civil Procedure read
with Section-173 of the M.V. Act, along with its up to date amendments by the
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. against the impugned award dated 21.07.2022 passed
by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.2, West
Tripura Agartala in connection with case No. TS (MAC) 09 of 2021. Further,
another cross-objection [CO (FA) 01 of 2023] has been filed by the respondentO.P. No.1 against the MAC. App. No.86 of 2022 filed by the claimant-petitionerappellants under Order-XLI, Rule-22 of the Civil Procedure Code for absolving
the respondent O.P. No.1 from the liability of payment of the award of
compensation to the O.P. insurance company as would be paid by the O.P.
insurance company to the claimant-appellants as per judgment and order dated
21.07.2022 passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims West Tripura
Agartala in connection with case No. TS (MAC) 09 of 2021.
[3]
Brief facts, leading to this case is that on 16.11.2020 at about 3-30
p.m. Jyotsna Rani Nath along with two other ladies was waiting at water supply
point for taking water at Khasiabari area on Khasiabari-Tilthai Road at that time
one SML Canter Truck bearing registration No.TR-01-AA-1761(herein-after
called the offending vehicle) which was coming from the Chamtilla direction
towards Tilthai Hospital hit the deceased and two other ladies going on the wrong
side of the road as a result of which Jyotsna Rani Nath sustained severe injuries
on her persons and died on the spot. Local people brought her in the Dharmanagar
District Hospital where doctor declared her as dead. Post Mortem examination
was also done over the body of deceased. In this connection Panisagar PS Case
No. 2020 PNS 048 dated 16.11.2020 u/s 279/338/304(A) of IPC was also
registered. Claimant petitioners further stated in their claim petition that the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving on the part of the driver of the
offending vehicle.
[4]
Claimant petitioners also stated that at the time of death deceased
was aged about 44 years and she was a Anganwari Worker under Panisagar ICDS
Project, North Tripura and used to earn Rs. 4,202/- per month. The OP No.1,
owner of the offending vehicle despite of receiving notice did not turn up. Hence ,
the case proceeds ex parte against the OP No.1.
[5]
After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
having gone through the material evidence on record, the learned Court bellow
has observed as under:
“In the result, claim is awarded in following terms :(i) Claimant petitioners are entitled to get the award of Rs.12,38,000/-( rupees
twelve lacs thirty eight thousand) only along with 9% simple interest per
annum from the date of registration of claim i.e, w.e.f. 12.01.2021 till the
date of realization thereof.
The Noticee, Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. shall, deposit the awarded
amount along with interest thereon within one month to this Tribunal.
Noticee, shall be at liberty to recover the amount from the OP in accordance
with law.
Supply a copy of this award free of cost to the parties by not later than 15
days from the date of the award.”
[6]
Mr. B. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that the learned tribunal has failed to appreciate the subject matter on
record and has failed to assess the actual income of the profession of a cloth shop
owner and wrongly hold that the monthly income of the deceased Rs.2,000/- per
month. Actually, the landlady as PW-2 deposed that the deceased paid Rs.2,000/per month as rent for the shop but the learned tribunal wrongly held it as her
income.
[7]
The learned tribunal committed serious error both on point of law
and facts and did not consider the fact as well as submission made in the
examination in chief and claim petition. In the year 2021 a cloth shop owner
would not earn less than Rs.10,000/- per month from the cloth shop. The land
lady of the shop owner of the deceased who examined as PW-2 during trial
deposed that the deceased used to pay her Rs.2,000/- per month as rent for the
cloth shop. From which it can be presumed that the deceased from her business of
cloth shop easily earn more than Rs.10,000/- per month which she contributed to
her family. Moreover, as an Anganwari Worker the deceased used to get
Rs.4,202/- per month as salary. So total monthly income of the deceased was near
about Rs.15,000/- per month. But the learned tribunal wrongly held that the
deceased used to earn Rs.2,000/- per month from the cloth shop and h old that
total monthly income of the deceased was Rs.6,202/- per month.
[8]
He has further contended that the learned tribunal ought not to have
awarded a very meager sum and it should have been awarded as claimed by the
claimant. The finding of the learned tribunal resulting in the impugned award of
very meager amount of compensation is grossly erroneous, perverse and the same
has to be set aside. The learned tribunal has erred in passing the judgment and
making meager amount of award to the claimant. The Hon’ble Apex Court in a
judgment reported in (2014) 2 SCC (Cri) 379 opined to determine the proof of
income of self employed labour in unorganized sector.
[9]
There is no dispute between the parties as to the death of deceased.
According to the claimant petitioners on the relevant date and time deceased
along with two others was waiting for taking water near the water supply point on
Khasiabari-Tilthai Road where she was dashed due to rash and negligent driving
of the driver of the offending vehicle resulting which they met with an accident
and on the same day deceased succumbed to her injuries. From the Charge sheet
[Ext.2(i) to 2(iii)] it reveals that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of the driver namely, Rupak Sarkar of the offending vehicle. Therefore,
this Court finds it appropriate to hold that the death of deceased was caused due
to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the offending vehicle.
[10]
It has been established beyond any shadow of doubt that the death
of deceased was caused due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of
offending vehicle. Therefore, the claimant petitioners being the daughter, and son
of the deceased are entitled to have the compensation under the beneficial
legislation, namely the M.V. Act. Now the question arises is what should be the
quantum of compensation and who is liable to pay the same. In order to decide
and calculate the amount of compensation we find it apposite to have a reference
to a recent judgment of the Honble Supreme Court reported in AIR 2017 SC 5157
(National Insurance Company Limited Vs Pranay Sethi and others) wherein In
Para-61 of that Judgment it was observed:
“61. In view of the aforesaid analysis, we proceed to record our conclusions:
(i) The two Judge Bench in Santosh Devi (AIR 2012 SC 2185) should have
been well advised to refer the matter to a larger bench as it was taking a
different view then what has been stated in Sarla Varma (AIR 2009 SC 3104
) a Judgment by a coordinate Bench. It is because a co-ordinate bench of the
same strength cannot take a contrary view then what has been held by
another co-ordinate bench.
(ii) As Rajesh has not taken note of the decision in Reshma Kumari (AIR)
2013 SC (Supp) 474), which was delivered at earlier point of time, the
decision in Rajesh is not a binding precedent.
(iii) While determining the income and addition of 50 percent of actual salary
to the income of the deceased towards future prospects, where the deceased
had a permanent job and was below the age of 40 years, should be made. The
addition should be 30 percent, if the age of the deceased was between 40 to
50 years. In case the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60 years, the
addition should be 15 percent. Actual salary should be read as actual salary
less tax .
(iv) In case that deceased was self -employed or on a fixed salary, an addition
of 40 percent of the establish income should be the warrant where the
deceased was below the age of 40 years. An addition of 25 percent where the
deceased was between the age of 40 to 50 years and 10 percent where the
deceased was between the age of 50 to 60 years should be regarded as the
necessary method of computation. The established income means the income
minus the tax component.
(v) For determination of the multiplicand, the deduction for personal and
living expenses, the tribunals and court shall be guided by paragraphs 30 to
32 of Sarla Varma which we have reproduced herein before.
(vi) The selection of multiplier shall be as indicated in the table of Sarla
Varma read with paragraph -42 of that Judgment.
(vii) The age of the deceased should be the basis for applying the multiplier .
(viii) The reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely loss of estate,
loss of consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs.15,000/-, Rs.40,000/and Rs.15,000/- respectively. The aforesaid amounts should be enhanced at
the rate of 10 percent in every 3 years.”
[11]
The claimant petitioners have claimed that at the time of death the
deceased was at her age of 44 years. Such claim remained unshaken even not
disputed by the Noticee. Therefore, the age of the deceased at the time of death
can be taken to have been admitted. The claimant petitioners have also proved the
Salary certificate (Ext.3) of the deceased showing that the monthly income of the
deceased was Rs. 4,202/- per month being an Anwanwadi worker under Panisagar
ICDS Project. The deceased used to perform her duties from 8 a.m. to 12 p.m. In
addition the deceased used to run a cloth shop from 1 p.m. to 8 p.m. at Khasiabari
market taking a room on rent from the PW-2(Smt Anima Das) and thereby used
to pay rent @ Rs. 2,000/- per month to the land lady.
[12]
In this count, learned tribunal has erred in appreciating the fact that
the deceased used to pay Rs.2,000/- as rent and it is not her income the amount is
for paying rent. But, the learned tribunal has taken the same amount as her
income from the cloth shop. In this regard PW-2, the landlady of the cloth has
deposed that the deceased during her life time engaged as an Anganwari Worker
under Panisagar ICDS Project, North Tripura. Duty hour of the said work from
8am to 12 pm. She used to run a cloth shop from 1pm to 8 pm at her local
Khasiabari market situated at Khasiabari on Tilthai Road, 08 N.H. Under
Panisagar P.S. North Tripura taking rent a room from her and she used to pay her
Rs.2,000/- per month as rent.
[13]
In view of above and having gone through the deposition of PW-2,
this Court is of the view that the learned tribunal has wrongly assessed the
monthly income of the deceased and which needs to be corrected. The Salary
certificate (Ext.3) of the deceased shows that the monthly income of the deceased
was Rs. 4,202/- per month being an Anwanwari worker and in addition to that,
the deceased used to run a cloth shop and in the year 2021 a cloth shop owner
would not earn less than Rs.6,000/- per month from the cloth shop. Thus, her total
income would be Rs.4,202 + 6,000 = Rs.10,202/- per month rounded off to
Rs.10,000/-. The deceased was being at her age group of 41 to 45 years there
should be 25% addition in her income and the calculation would be as follows:
(I) Income per month = Rs.,10,000/- only.
(II) 25% of above to be added as future prospect: - Rs.2500/- only.
(III)Total of Sl. Nos. I and II above comes to Rs.10,000/- + Rs. 2,500/-=Rs.
12,500/- only.
(IV) one third (1/3) of above to be deducted as personal and living expenses
of deceased: - Rs.12,500/- minus Rs.4,166/- = Rs.8,334/- only.
(V) Compensation after applying multiplier of 14:- Rs. 8,334 x 12 x 14 =
14,00,112/-only.
(VI) Loss of Estate = Rs.15,000/-only.
(VII) Funeral expenses = Rs.15,000/- only.
VIII) Loss of love and affection=Rs. 2,00,000/- only
Thus, total compensation stands at Rs.14,00,112+15,000 +15,000+
2,00,000/- = Rs.16,30,112/- only.
[14]
Now coming to the question of liability, it appears that admittedly,
the vehicle was insured and the same was taken on record. The accident was
occurred on 16.11.2020 and the vehicle was insured up to midnight of 18.08.2021
thus, the insurance company is liable to pay the amount to the claimant. But the
learned tribunal has fastened the liability to pay the compensation upon the owner
of the vehicle wherein, the tribunal has utterly failed in deciding the same. Thus,
this Court finds fault with the observation of the learned tribunal and accordingly,
fastening the liability upon the insurance company to the amount as stated above.
The rate of interest as assessed by the tribunal below seems to be higher in side
accordingly; the same is reduced to 7.5% instead of 9%. Thus, the claimant is
entitled to get the award of Rs.16,30,112/- only along with 7.5% interest from the
date of registration of claim i.e, w.e.f. 12.01.2021 till the date of realization
thereof. Thus, the cross-objection being CO (FA) No.01 of 2023, stands allowed.
[15]
In view of above modification, the present appeal and the cross
objection being CO (FA) 16 of 2022 stands partly allowed and disposed of. The
insurance company shall deposit the awarded amount as assessed by this Court
and the modified amount as discussed above, within a period of one month, from
the date of receipt of the copy of this order, if not already deposited.
Consequently, the claimant is at liberty to withdraw the same as per procedure.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
Draw the award accordingly and thereafter, send down the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
Date: 2023.08.01 17:52:03 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review