Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010771972013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3327]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE SECOND DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SREENIVASA REDDY
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 940/2013
Between:
1. THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REP., BY
ITS BRANCH MANAGER, BRANCH OFFICE OPP: TO
DISTRICT COURT, KADAPA
...APPELLANT
AND
1. MOGAL SALAR BAIG AND ANOTHER, S/O. MAHABOOB
BAIG, OCC: DRIVER, R/O. D.NO. 9/634-1, AGADI STREET,
KADAPA CITY AND DISTRICT.
2. C SREERAMULU REDDY, S/O. CHINNA BALI REDDY, OCC:
OWNER OF LORRY NO. AP-04-V-2445, R/O. D.NO. 1/33,
RAMARAJUPALLI, KADAPA DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Section 30 of the Workmen Compensation
Act, 1923 against the orders dated 27.04.2011 made in
W.C.No.62/2009 passed by the Commissioner for Workmen's
Compensation and Assistant Commissioner of Labour, Kadapa.
IA NO: 1 OF 2013(CMAMP 453 OF 2013)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to condone the delay of 194 days in
filing the appeal.
IA NO: 2 OF 2013 (CMAMP 487 OF 2013)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to stay all further proceedings in
WC.No. 62 of 2009 (F) dt. 27/04/2011 including the withdrawal of
the money deposited before the Commissioner for Workmen's
Compensation and Asst. Commissioner of Labour at Kadapa.
IA NO: 3 OF 2013 (CMAMP 1882 OF 2013)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased To vacate the interim order passed
in CMA.MP.No.487 of 2013 in CMA.SR.No.3169 of 2013 dated:
7/3/2013 and permit the petitioner to withdraw the amount deposited
in W.C.No.62 of 2009, dated: 27/4/2011 on the file of the court of
the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation and Assistance
Commissioner of Labour, Kadapa, without furnishing guarantee and
pass
IA NO: 7 OF 2013(CMAMP 8809 OF 2013)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition,
the High Court may be pleased to pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. V RAGHU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. S ARIFULLAH
The Court made the following:
JUDGMENT
Challenge in this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal filed by the
appellant herein/Insurance Company, is to the Order, dated
27.04.2011, in W.C.No.62 of 2009 on the file of the Commissioner
for Workmen’s Compensation and Assistant Commissioner of
Labour, Kadapa (‘the Commissioner’ for short), whereunder the
Commissioner, dealing with claim for compensation made by the
respondent No.1 herein/applicant for a sum of Rs.5,00,000/-, on
account of permanent disability sustained by him in a motor vehicle
accident, which occurred on 25.02.2009 during night hours,
awarded a sum of Rs.4,19,500/- as compensation.
2.
The parties to this C.M.A. will hereinafter be referred to,
as described before the Commissioner, for the sake of convenience.
3.
Case of the applicant before the Commissioner, in brief,
is that he was working as Driver of the lorry bearing registration
No.AP04 V 2445, belonging to 1st respondent and it was insured
with 2nd respondent-Insurance Company vide Policy No.432706/31/
2009/1444 valid from 06.07.2008 to 05.07.2009, covering the risk of
Driver; that as per the instructions of 1st respondent, the applicant
loaded Barites Powder in the lorry bearing registration No.AP04 V
2445 on 20.02.2009 at Kadapa, and after unloading the same at
Bombay, the lorry was proceeding to Kadapa with a load of parcel
material; that on 25.02.2009 during night hours, while the lorry was
going
to
Kadapa
and
reached
near
Lakshminarayanapur
Chowrastha, the lorry met with an accident due to rash and
negligent driving of driver of opposite coming lorry bearing
registration No.AP29 X 8447, due to which, the applicant sustained
fracture injuries to his both legs and he was admitted in the
Government Hospital, Thandur; that subsequently, he was admitted
in RIMS Hospital, Kadapa and underwent treatment. Basing on the
statement of the injured, a case in Crime No.24 of 2009 of Yalala
Police Station of Rangareddy District was registered against the
driver of the offending vehicle. The applicant took treatment, but the
injuries were not cured and he became permanently disabled
person. The applicant was earning a sum of Rs.4,000/- per month
towards wage and Rs.150/- per day as batta, but due to the injuries
sustained in the accident, the applicant lost his income and became
helpless. Though, the respondents were asked to pay compensation
by issuing legal notice on 08.07.2009, they did not do so. Hence,
the applicant filed the petition seeking compensation for a sum of
Rs.5,00,000/- under the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923 (for
brevity ‘the Act, 1923’).
4.
Respondent No.2/Insurance Company filed counter
denying the employment of applicant under respondent No.1 and
also his earning capacity of Rs.4,000/- per month towards wage and
Rs.150/- towards batta. It is contended that in drought prone area
like Rayalaseema, the lorry drivers would be paid not more than
Rs.1,000/- per month towards wage and batta. The applicant has to
claim compensation against the driver, insured and insurer of the
lorry bearing registration No.AP29 X 8447. Hence, it is prayed to
dismiss the claim petition.
5.
Basing on the above pleadings, the Commissioner
settled the following issues for inquiry:
(1)
Whether the applicant was a Workman as per the
provisions of the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923
and he met with the accident arising out of and in the
course of his employment resulting into disability and
loss of earning capacity?
(2)
What is the age of the applicant at the time of accident?
(3)
What were the wages paid to the applicant at the time
of the accident?
(4)
What is the loss of earning capacity suffered and
permanent disability percentage faced by the injured
applicant?
(5)
What is the quantum of compensation payable to the
applicant?
(6)
Who are liable to pay the compensation to the
applicant?
6.
During the course of inquiry before the Commissioner,
on behalf of the applicant, AWs.1 and 2 were examined and Exs.A1
to A7 were marked. On behalf of the respondents, none were
examined and no document was marked.
7.
The Commissioner, on examining the oral as well as
documentary evidence, and on hearing both sides, vide Order dated
27.04.2012, answered the issues in favour of the applicant and
against the respondents, and awarded a sum of Rs.3,83,520/towards compensation besides stamp duty of Rs.1,000/- by means
of Demand Draft in favour of the Commissioner for Workmen’s
Compensation and Joint Commissioner for Labour, Kurnool, drawn
on State Bank of India, Kurnool, within 30 days from the date of
receipt of the order. It was further ordered that if the respondents fail
to deposit the awarded amount within the stipulated time, they have
to pay the interest at 12% per annum from the date of accident till
realization and also penalty under Section 4-A, 3 (b) of the
Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923. The applicant was directed to
make representation to the Commissioner for the Workmen’s
Compensation and Joint Commissioner of Labour, Kurnool for
release of compensation amount deposited by the respondents. Felt
aggrieved of the said Order, respondent No.2/Insurance Company
filed the present C.M.A.
8.
Now, in deciding the present C.M.A., the point for
determination is whether the Order, dated 27.04.2012, in W.C.No.62
of 2009 on the file of the Commissioner for Workmen’s
Compensation and Assistant Commissioner of Labour, Kadapa, in
awarding the compensation of Rs.3,83,520/-, is sustainable under
law and facts and whether there are any grounds to interfere with
the same?
9.
This Court, while admitting the present Miscellaneous
Appeal, on 07.03.2013 passed interim order in C.M.A.M.P. No.487
of 2013 directing not to disburse the amount as ordered by the
Commissioner in its Order dated 27.04.2011. Aggrieved of the said
Order, the applicant filed C.M.A.M.P.No.1882 of 2013 seeking the
Court to vacate the Order, dated 07.03.2013. This Court vide Order
dated 31.10.2013 passed in C.M.A.M.P.No.1882 of 2013 permitted
the applicant to withdraw 50% of the amount deposited by 1st
respondent apart from 50% of the interest component and penalty
as directed by the Commissioner along with costs of Rs.1,000/- as
awarded by the Commissioner, without furnishing any security.
Aggrieved of the said Order, the respondent No.2/ Insurance
Company preferred the present CMA.
10.
Sri V.Raghu, learned counsel for the appellant herein/
Insurance Company would contend that the Commissioner granted
interest at 12% per annum from the date of petition to till the date of
award, which is not in accordance with sub-section (2) of Section 4A of the Act, 1923. Learned counsel further contends that the
Commissioner did not consider the aspect that the applicant
sustained only 40% physical disability and the loss of earning
capacity shall be equivalent to the percentage of disability,
therefore, the extent of disability should have been determined only
to 40% but not 100%. Learned counsel would further contend that
except issuing the Disability Certificate, the Doctor, who was
examined as AW.2, had not provided treatment to the applicant,
therefore, his evidence cannot be taken into consideration to
adjudicate the percentage of disability of the applicant. The
compensation awarded by the Tribunal is excessive and the
Insurance Company is not liable to pay the same.
11.
On the other hand, it is contention of learned counsel
for respondent No.1/applicant that the Commissioner rightly
appreciated the evidence on record and recorded proper findings
with regard to his employment under respondent No.2/owner of the
lorry and also with regard to the effect on future income of the
applicant subsequent to the accident. Learned counsel would further
contend that the Commissioner rightly fixed the minimum wage of
the applicant at Rs.4,000/- as per G.O.Ms.No.90 LET & F (Lab.II)
Dept., dated 28.09.2007 and G.O.Ms.No.81, Labour, Employment,
Training & Factories (Lab-II) dated 02.2.2020 and computed the
quantum of compensation at Rs.3,83,520/- and they are on correct
lines and there are no grounds to interfere with the impugned
Award. Hence, prays to dismiss the C.M.A.
12.
The contention raised in this appeal as to what is the
actual date for accrual of interest on the compensation arrived at
under the Act, 1923, whether it falls due after thirty days from the
date of accident or only after thirty days from the date of
determination/adjudication of the compensation/claim, is no longer
res integra. A Larger Bench of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Pratap
Narain Singh Deo v. Srinivas Sabata and another1 held that the
employer became liable to pay the compensation as soon as the
personal injury was caused to the workman by the accident which
admittedly arose out of and in the course of the employment. In the
light of the well settled legal position, it is made clear that the
interest on the compensation amount would accrue thirty days after
the date of accident and not from the date of orders. In the appeal
on hand also, the Commissioner directed respondent Nos.1 and 2 to
deposit the compensation within 30 days from the date of receipt of
the order and if they fail so, they were directed to pay interest at
(1976) 1 SCC 289.
12% per annum from the date of accident till realization and also
penalty under Section 4-A, 3 (b) of the Workmen’s Compensation
Act, 1923. Therefore, the interest at 12% per annum from the date
of accident till realization as ordered by the Commissioner holds
good.
13.
The learned counsel for the appellant/Insurance
Company raised a question that the Doctor, who assessed the
disability of the applicant, except issuing the Disability Certificate,
did not provide treatment to him and further, the loss of earning
capacity shall be equivalent to the percentage of disability as
assessed by the Doctor. Therefore, the quantum of compensation
fixed by the Commissioner is improper, excessive and not in
consonance with the provisions of the Act, 1923.
14.
The issues were adjudicated by the Commissioner with
reference to the documents and evidence produced by the
applicant. The factum regarding the accident was established and
the accident occurred during the course of employment. As per the
evidence of applicant as A.W1, he was on duty on 25.02.2009, and
he drove the lorry bearing registration No.AP04 V 2445, belongs to
respondent No.1, which was loaded with parcel material. It is his
evidence that while the lorry was going to Kadapa and when it
reached near Lakshminarayanapur Chowrastha, due to the rash
and negligent driving of the Driver of the opposite coming lorry
bearing registration No.AP29 X 8447, the lorry met with an accident;
as a result, the applicant sustained fracture injuries to his both legs.
15.
It is the evidence of applicant as A.W1 that he was
admitted in RIMS Hospital, Kadapa and underwent treatment for 20
days and in spite of best treatment, the injuries could not be cured
and he sustained permanent disability. According to the evidence of
A.W2, Dr. Challa Sanjeevaiah, who is an Orthopaedic Surgeon, he
deposed in his evidence before the Commissioner that, the
applicant sustained united fracture of shaft of right tibia and due to
the said injury the movements of right knee were restricted and due
to that, there would be difficulty to stand on the affected limb,
difficulty to squat and to sit with crossed leg position.
16.
A perusal of the evidence of A.W2, Doctor coupled with
Ex.A4, Disability Certificate, goes to show that the applicant, being
the Lorry Driver, working under the employment of respondent No.1,
sustained fracture injury and due to such fracture injury, it is difficult
for him to drive the lorry and he is completely prevented from doing
his driving work. Therefore, though the disability of applicant was
assessed by A.W2 at 40% under Ex.A4, fixing compensation on the
basis of loss of 100% earning capacity, holds good, for the reason
that, the disability sustained by the applicant effects on the future
income, as he became unfit for the profession of Driver, which he
was able to perform prior to the accident. Undoubtedly, A.W2 did not
provide treatment to the applicant but, he being an Orthopaedic
Surgeon, is competent to assess the disability sustained by the
applicant.
17.
Coming to the quantum of compensation, though the
applicant claims that he was earning Rs.6,000/- per month, as per
the minimum wages fixed to the Lorry Driver as per the
G.O.Ms.No.90, LET & F (Lab.II) Dept., dated 28.09.2007 and
G.O.Ms.No.81, Labour, Employment, Training & Factories (Lab-II),
dated 02.12.2000, limited the wage of the applicant at Rs.4,000/-.
Therefore, in the circumstances of the case, the Commissioner
rightly assessed the income of the applicant at Rs.4,000/- per month
and
fixed
the
quantum
of
compensation
at
Rs.3,83,520/-.
Admittedly, the applicant is working under the employment of
respondent No.1. There is no dispute that the vehicle, which was
driven by the applicant on the date of accident, was insured with
respondent No.2/Insurance Company. As the vehicle was duly
insured with the respondent No.2, the Commissioner rightly fixed the
liability on respondent Nos.1 and 2, jointly and severally to pay the
compensation.
18.
In the light of the above, this Court does not find any
reasons to interfere with the Order, dated 27.04.2011, in W.C.No.62
of 2009 on the file of the Commissioner for Workmen’s
Compensation and Assistant Commissioner of Labour, Kadapa,
needs no interference.
19.
Accordingly, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No.940 of
2013 is dismissed, confirming the Order dated 27.04.2011 passed in
W.C.No.61
of
by
the
Commissioner
for
Workmen’s
Compensation and Assistant Commissioner of Labour, Kadapa.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending, if
any, in the CMA, shall stand closed.
__________________________
2nd February, 2026
DNB
JUSTICE K.SREENIVASA REDDY
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review