Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010374222019
2026:CGHC:31849
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MAC No. 2321 of 2019
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited Through Divisional Manager, Jail
Road, Kutchery Chowk, Raipur Chhattisgarh. ( Insurence Company Of Truck
Number M. H. 04 F. J. 5902), District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
... Appellant(s)
versus
1 - Kumari Preeti Nishad D/o Bodhram Nishad Aged About 20 Years Permanent Address, Village - Aamgaon, Thana Masturi, District - Bilaspur Chhattisgarh. Present Address - Village Dabanbod, Post Mohbhatta, Thana Bhatapara ( Village ) District - Balodabazar - Bhatapara Chhattisgarh. ( Claimant ),
District : Balodabazar-Bhathapara, Chhattisgarh
2 - Mohammad Safi S/o Mohammad Sadique, Resident - Dafnipura, Thana
Karanja, District - Vasim ( Maharastra ) ( Driver Of Truck Number M. H. 04 F .
J. 5902) (Driver ), Maharashtra
3 - Aziz Khan S/o Mohammad Khan, Resident Village Kinhi, Rakde, Thana
Karanja, District - Vasim ( Maharastra ) ( Registered Owner Of Truck Number
M. H. 04 F. J. 5902) (Owner ), Maharashtra
--- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Sudhir Agrawal along with Ms. Prenana
Agrawal, Advocate
For Respondents No. 1
: Mr. S.P. Sannat on behalf of Mr. Basant
Kaiwartya, advocate
For Respondent No. 2 & 3
None
Hon’ble Shri Sanjay K. Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
27.07.2026
1. This appeal has been filed by the appellant/Insurance Company under
Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (for short “Act of 1988”)
challening the impugned award dated 23.07.2019 passed by the Addi-
tional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Bhatapara, District Baloda Bazar
Bhatapara, Chhattisgarh (for short “Claims Tribunal”) in Claim Case No.
H-36/2016.
2. The learned counsel for the appellant submits that the Tribunal has
erred in fastening joint and several liability upon the Insurance Company despite the admitted fact that the offending truck bearing registration No. MH-04 FJ-5902 did not possess a valid permit to operate in the
State of Chhattisgarh.
3. Learned counsel for the appellant would further submit that the permit
available on record clearly established that it was valid only within the
State of Maharashtra. The Tribunal itself recorded a categorical finding
in paragraph 17 of the award that the permit was effective only for Maharashtra and that no permit had been issued for the place of accident,
namely Pendri Mod, Tarenga Road, Police Station Bhatapara (Rural),
District Baloda Bazar, Chhattisgarh. It is further submitted that the
owner and driver, though they filed a joint written statement, failed to
enter the witness box or produce any valid permit authorizing operation
of the vehicle in Chhattisgarh. The permit seized during police investigation was valid only up to 03.12.2018, and no additional permit was
produced. The appellant's witness, Rajeshwar Dahariya, specifically
deposed that in the absence of a valid permit for operation outside Maharashtra, the vehicle was being operated in violation of the policy conditions and, therefore, the Insurance Company was not liable to indemnify the insured. Therefore, in view of the law laid down by the
Supreme Court in Amrit Paul Singh and Others v. TATA AIG General
Insurance Co. Ltd. and Others1 and K. Nagendra v. The New India
Assurance Co. Ltd. and Others2, the Tribunal erred in fastening liability upon the appellant–Insurance Company and, at the most, ought to
have applied the principle of pay and recover.
4. Learned counsel for respondents would oppose the prayer made by
learned counsel for the appellant.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties, considered their rival submissions made herein-above and gone through the records minutely.
6. The question involved in the present appeal is whether the Insurance
Company can be fastened with liability to satisfy the award when the
offending goods vehicle, though insured, was being plied in the State of
Chhattisgarh without a valid permit, the permit on record being valid
only for the State of Maharashtra, thereby constituting a breach of the
policy conditions.?
7. The material available on record establishes that the offending goods
vehicle was being operated in the State of Chhattisgarh, whereas the
permit produced on record was valid only for the State of Maharashtra.
The owner and driver failed to produce any valid permit authorizing the
vehicle to ply in Chhattisgarh, despite the specific plea raised by the Insurance Company. Thus, there was a clear breach of the permit conditions as well as the terms of the insurance policy.
(2018) 7 SCC 558
2025 INSC 1270
8. The Supreme Court in K. Nagendra (supra), has held that where the
offending vehicle is plied beyond the territorial limits of its permit, the
terms of the permit stand violated. However, since the victim is an innocent third party, the insurer cannot avoid its statutory obligation to satisfy the award. At the same time, the insurer cannot be made to suffer
the consequences of a breach committed by the insured. Balancing
these competing interests, the Supreme Court upheld the application of
the "pay and recover" principle. For ready reference, paragraph 8 to 9
reproduced hereinunder:8. Now, let us consider the instant case. The record
reveals that the offending vehicle did not have the
permit to enter Channapatna City, where the accident took place. This position is not in dispute. Unquestionably, therefore,the terms of the permit
have been deviated.
9.The purpose of an insurance policy in the present
context is to shield the owner/operator from direct
liability when such an unforeseen/unfortunate incident takes place. To deny the victim/dependents of
the victim compensation simply because the accident took place outside the bounds of the permit
and, therefore, is outside the purview of the insurance policy, would be offensive to the sense of justice, for the accident itself is for no fault of his.
Then, the Insurance Company most certainly ought
to pay.
10. At the same time though, when an Insurance
Company takes on a policy and accepts payments
of premium in pursuance thereto, it agrees to do so
within certain bounds. The contract lays down the
four corners within which such an insurance policy
would operate. If that is the case, to expect the insurer to pay compensation to a third party, which is
clearly outside the bounds of the said agreement
would be unfair. Balancing the need for payment of
compensation to the victim vis-à-vis the interests of
the insurer, the order of the High Court applying the
pay and recover principle, in our considered view,
is entirely justified and requires no interference.
9. The issue involved in the present appeal is no longer res integra as in
the matter of Amrit Paul Singh (supra) the Supreme Court has clearly
stated that use of vehicle in public place without a valid permit is a fundamental statutory infraction and observed as under:24. In the case at hand, it is clearly demonstrable from
the materials brought on record that the vehicle at the
time of the accident did not have a permit. The appellants had taken the stand that the vehicle was not involved in the accident. That apart, they had not stated
whether the vehicle had temporary permit or any other
kind of permit. The exceptions that have been carved
out under Section 66 of the Act, needless to emphasise, areto be pleaded and proved. The exceptions
cannot be taken aid of in the course of an argument to
seek absolution from liability. Use of a vehicle in a
public place without a permit is a fundamental statutory infraction. We are disposed to think so in view of
the series of exceptions carved out in Section 66. The
said situations cannot be equated with absence of licence or a fake licence or a licence for different kind
of vehicle, or, for that matter, violation of a condition of
carrying more number of passengers. Therefore, the
principles laid down in Swaran Singh [National InsuranceCo. Ltd. v. Swaran Singh, (2004) 3 SCC 297 :
2004 SCC (Cri) 733] and Lakhmi Chand [Lakhmi
Chand v. Reliance General Insurance, (2016) 3 SCC
100 : (2016) 2 SCC (Civ) 45] in that regard would not
be applicable to the case at hand. That apart, the insurer had taken the plea that the vehicle in question
had no permit. It does not require the wisdom of the
“Tripitaka”, that the existence of a permit of any nature
is a matter of documentary evidence. Nothing has
been brought on record by the insured to prove that
he had a permit of the vehicle. In such a situation, the
onus cannot be cast on the insurer. Therefore, the Tribunal as well as the High Court had directed that the
insurer was required to pay the compensation amount
to the claimants with interest with the stipulation that
the insurer shall be entitled to recover the same from
the owner and the driver. The said directions are in
consonance with the principles stated in Swaran
Singh, (2004) 3 SCC 297 : 2004 SCC (Cri) 733] and
other cases pertaining to pay and recover principle.”
10.Taking into consideration the principles of law laid down by the
Supreme Court in Amrit Paul (supra) and K. Nagendra (supra), this
Court is of the considered opinion that, although the offending vehicle
was being plied in the State of Chhattisgarh without a valid permit and
there was a breach of the permit conditions, the interest of the innocent
third-party claimant deserves to be protected. Accordingly, the appellant–Insurance Company shall satisfy the award in the first instance
and shall thereafter be entitled to recover the amount from the owner
and driver of the offending vehicle (respondents No. 2 & 3), in accordance with law.
11.Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed to the extent indicated hereinabove.
Sd/(Sanjay K. Agrawal)
Judge
Jyoti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review