Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010800942017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3604]
MONDAY, THE 12th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2984/2017
Between:
1. THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REPTD BY ITS
DIVISIONAL MANAGER, RAJAHMUNDRY.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. KAMISETTI SESHA RAO, S/O LATE SATYANARAYANA, HINDU,
AGED 26 YEARS, R/O SREERAMPURAM, RAJANAGARAM MANDAL.
2. KAMISETTI LOVA RAJU, S/O LATE SATYANARAYANA, HINDU, AGED
25 YEARS, R/O SREERAMPURAM, RAJANAGARAM MANDAL
VEERA
VENKATA
LAKSHMI,
D/O.
LATE
3. KAMISETTI
SATYANARAYANA HINDU, AGED 24 YEARS, R/O SREERAMPURAM,
RAJANAGARAM MANDAL.
4. KAMISETTI RAGHAVA, W/O LATE SESHA-RAO, HINDU, AGED 65
YEARS, WIDOW, R/O SREERAMPURAM, RAJANAGARAM MANDAL.
5. J POSIYYA, S/O PEDDA SUBBA RAO, HINDU, AGED 50 YEARS,
DRIVER OF LORRY BEARING NO. AP 31 TT 4086, R/O
BANDAMAMIDI, RAMPACHODAVARAM MANDAL
6. VICECHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR OF GIRIJAN
COOPERAT, OWNER OF THE LORRY BEARING NO. AP 31 TT 4086,
R/O EAST POINT COLONY, OPPOSITE UDA COLONY,
VISAKHAPATNAM. (R- 5 AND 6 ARE NOT NECESSARY)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High CourtAppeal against
the judgment and decree of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal cum VIII
Additional
District
Sessions
Judge
(FTC),
East
Godavari
at
Rajamahendravaram in O.P. No. 491/2012 dt. 24-04-2017 for the following
among other grounds
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(MACMAMP 5268 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
condone the delay of 87 days in representation of the appeal.
IA NO: 2 OF 2017(MACMAMP 5269 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay of all further pros including the execution of the decree and order
passed in OP.491/2012 dt. 24-04-04-2017 on the file of the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal-Cum-IV Additional District & Sessions Judge(FTC) East
Godavari at Rajamahendravaram, pending disposal of the above M.A.C.M.A
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. GUDI SRINIVASU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. N SIVA REDDY
The Court made the following:
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
THE HON’BLE SMT. JUSTICE SUNITHA GANDHAM
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 2984 OF 2017
JUDGMENT:
Assailing the order and decree dated 24.04.2017 in M.V.O.P.No.491 of
2017 passed by the Chairman, Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Tribunal-cumVIII
Additional
District
&
Sessions
Judge
(FTC),
East
Godavari,
Rajamahendravaram, for awarding compensation of Rs.4,88,000/- for the
untimely death of Kamisetti Satynarayana, in a road traffic accident.
2.
The parties are being referred to as „petitioners‟ and respondents‟ as
arrayed in the petition before the Tribunal, for the sake of convenience and
clarity.
3. The case of the petitioners is thus:
(a)
On 29.04.2017 at about 5.00 p.m., while the deceased proceeding on
his motorcycle slowly and by observing the traffic and when he reached near
G.I.E.T Engineering College, one lorry bearing No. AP 31 TT 4086 which was
coming from Rajanagaram, came in a rash and negligent manner, suddenly
turned towards Umar Alisha Cold Storage in a rash and negligent manner, lost
control and dashed against the motor cycle of the deceased and as a result,
Kamisetti Satyanarayana fell down sustained injuries and died on the spot.
(b)
A case in Cr.No.85 of 2012 was registered of the offence under Sections
304-A of Indian Penal Code, against the driver of lorry. The deceased aged
about 40 years, was doing seasonal fruits business, was earning Rs.500/- per
day, as on the date of accident. The petitioner No.1 and 2 are the sons,
petitioner No.3 is the daughter and petitioner No.4 is the mother of the
deceased. Due to the sudden death, petitioners lost their financial support as
well as love and affection. Respondent No.1 is the driver, Respondent No.2 is
owner and Respondent No.3 is insurer of the lorry bearing No. AP 31 TT 4086
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
and as such, all the respondents are jointly and severally responsible to pay
compensation.
4.
Having received summons, respondent No.1remained ex parte.
5.
Respondent No.2 filed counter denying the averments made in the
petition and by contending that the lorry is insured with the respondent No.3,
respondent No.1 had driving license, accident occurred due to the rash and
negligent riding of deceased, there was no negligence on the part of
respondent No.1, owner and insurance company of motor cycle are not
arrayed as parties, and with other formal denials, prayed to dismiss the
petition.
6.
Respondent No.3 filed written statement by denying the material
averments mentioned in the petition, wherein, inter alia contended that the
accident occurred due to the rash and negligent riding of the deceased,
petitioners claimed excessive compensation, respondent No.1 had no driving
license, and with other formal denials prayed to dismiss the petition.
7.
Taking into consideration of the aforementioned pleadings, the learned
tribunal framed the following issues:
1) Whether the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of R1, while R1 driving the lorry bearing No. AP 31 TT
4086?
2) Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation, if so, to
what amount and against whom?
3) To what relief?
8.
During trial, petitioner No.1 examined himself as PW.1 and petitioners
have got examined two independent witnesses as PWs.2 and 3, and filed
Exs.A1 to A4 documents. As against the said evidence, respondent No.2 has
got examined its driver as RW.1 and its employee as RW.2, and respondent
No.3 got examined its employee as RW.3, and filed Exs.X1 and B1
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
documents. At the culmination of the trial, the learned Tribunal allowed the
petition in part awarding compensation of Rs.4,88,000/-.
9.
Being aggrieved by the said Order and decree, respondent No.3
preferred the instant appeal, urging the following grounds:
(i)
The order and decree of the learned Tribunal is contrary to law
and facts, weight of evidence and probabilities of the case.
(ii)
The finding of the learned Tribunal on issue No.1 is not correct
and the learned Tribunal failed to appreciate evidence in proper perspective.
(iii)
The learned Tribunal without considering the material available on
record erroneously awarded compensation.
(iv)
The learned Tribunal failed to consider the aspect that the
petitioner Nos.1 to 3 are majors and they are not entitled for compensation.
(v)
The learned Tribunal failed to consider the aspect that the
investigating officer had filed final report abating the case as the accident
occurred due to rash and negligent riding of the deceased.
(vi)
The learned Tribunal failed to consider the aspect that the
petitioners have not filed any document to show income of the deceased, and
with other formal grounds prayed to allow the appeal.
10.
Heard Sri Gudi Srinivasu, learned counsel for the Appellant and
Sri N. Siva Reddy, learned counsel for the Respondents/Claimants.
11.
On hearing both sides and upon perusing the material available on
record, and including the impugned order dated 24.04.2017, the points that
would arise for consideration are as follows:
(1) Whether Kamisetti Satynarayana died in the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driver of lorry bearing No.
AP 31 TT 4086 i.e., by its driver.
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
(2) Whether the petitioners are entitled for compensation? If so,
to what amount?
(3) Whether the Order and decree dated 24.04.2017in
M.V.O.P.No.491 of 2017 passed by the Chairman, Motor Vehicle
Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-VIII Additional District & Sessions
Judge
(FTC),
East
Godavari,
Rajamahendravaram,
are
sustainable in facts and law?
(4) To what relief?
12. Point No.1:
(a)
Admittedly, petitioners have not filed any cross appeal or X-Objections
challenging the findings of the learned Tribunal, however, being the first
Appellate Court and last fact finding court, this court has to re-appreciate and
re-examine the evidence available on record.
(b)
Now, it is necessary to analyze the evidence on record and to prove
their contentions, petitioner No.1 filed his examination-in-chief in lieu of chief
examination by reiterating the averments mentioned in the petition and
petitioners relied upon the evidence of PWs.2 and 3 coupled with Exs.A1 to
A4 documents.
(c)
As seen from the record, PW1 who is the son of the deceased is not
eye witness to the accident and the available evidence is that of PWs.2 and 3,
who testified that on 29.04.2012 at 5.00 PM, while they were proceeding on
their motor cycle from Diwancheruvu to Rajanagaram, they found the
deceased kamisetti Satyanarayana who was going ahead of their motor cycle
and then, a lorry bearing No.AP 31 TT 4086 which was driven by the
respondent No.1, came in a rash and negligent manner, dashed against the
motor cycle of the deceased and as such, he fell down and died on the spot.
Both the witnesses have categorically stated in one voice that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of respondent No.1.
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
(d)
The learned counsel for the respondent No.3 argued that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent riding of the deceased only and as
such, though the case is registered against respondent No.1, after completion
of investigation, RW3 filed final report alleging that the accident occurred due
to rash and negligent riding of the deceased and to substantiate the version of
respondent No.3, they relied upon the evidence of RW1/Driver and
RW3/Investigating Officer. RW1 testified that he is the driver of respondent
No.2, on 29.04.2012, at about 4.30 PM after unloading the load, while he was
returning to Cold Storage towards G.I.E.T Engineering College, all of a
sudden motor cyclist dashed his vehicle from its behind and died on the spot
and immediately after the accident, he went to Rajanagaram Police Station
and gave report to the Police. In the cross examination, he had categorically
admitted that after commission of accident, he had surrendered before the
police, he does not the contents of Ex.A1, there is no proof to show that he
has given report to police. Having stated that a case in crime No.85 of 2012 is
registered vide Ex.A1, RW.3/Investigating Officer had further stated that the
accident occurred due to the negligence of the respondent No.1 and as such,
after obtaining permission from his officials, he filed Ex.X1/Final report closing
the case as abated. In the cross examination, he had categorically admitted
that he had registered the crime against the respondent No.1 and in Ex.A1
report, it is mentioned that the accident occurred due to the negligence of
respondent No.1 and as per Ex.A2/Inquest report, he had not examined any
independent witness. It is his further evidence that on 30.04.2012, he has
examined two persons and the said two persons are not cited as witnesses in
the inquest report, they belong to different places, he did not examine any of
the students, canteen persons and other independent witnesses who are
present near the scene of offence and he has also not examined cleaner of
the claim lorry.
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
(e)
As seen from Ex.X1/Final report also, absolutely there are no reasons
for coming to conclusion that the accident occurred due to the rash and
negligent riding of the deceased and it is simply mentioned that as per the
evidence of witnesses, accident occurred due to the rash and negligent riding
of the deceased only and that as per the statements of the direct witnesses,
he came to conclusion that there was no fault on the part of respondent No.1.
Had really R.W.3 examined any of the independent witnesses or direct
witnesses, he should have been mentioned the names and details of the said
witnesses.
(f)
In this regard, it is to be noted that in Bimla Devi and Others Vs.
Himachal Road Transport Corporation & Ors1, it is held that strict proof of
an accident caused by a particular vehicle in a particular manner may not be
possible to be done by the claimants and the claimants were merely to
establish their case on the touchstone of preponderance of probability.
Further, the standard of proof beyond reasonable doubt could not have been
applied. In this case, nothing useful material is elicited in the cross
examination of PWs.2 and 3 who are independent witnesses and who have
categorically stated in one voice about the rash and negligent driving of
respondent No.1. As rightly argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner,
the learned Tribunal rightly considered the material placed before it and came
to conclusion that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving
of respondent No.1. So, the evidence of PWs.1 to 3 coupled with Ex.A1, X1
and also the material elicited by the petitioner in the evidence of R.Ws. 1 and
3, this Court, without any doubt, came to conclusion that the accident occurred
due to rash and negligent driving of respondent No.1. As seen from
Ex.A2/Inquest report and Ex.A4/Post mortem report, Kamisetti Satyanarayana
sustained injuries in the accident and succumbed to the said injuries. Hence,
this point is answered in the affirmative and in favour of the petitioners.
2009 INSC 740
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
13. Point No.2:
(a)
As per the version of the petitioners, deceased hale and healthy, aged
about 40 years, doing seasonal fruits business, was earning Rs.500/- per day
and due to the sudden demise, petitioners who are sons, daughter and mother
of the deceased lost their financial support, love and affection. As seen from
Ex.A2/Inquest report and A4/Post mortem report, age of the deceased is
mentioned as 45 years. There is no contra evidence to that effect. So, it can
safely be concluded that the age of the deceased was aged about 45 years,
as on the date of accident and the relevant multiplier is „13‟.
(b).
Learned counsel for the respondent No.3 argued that petitioner Nos.
1 to 3 are major children of the deceased and as such, they are not entitled
for compensation. In Manjuri Bera Vs. Oriential Insurance Company
Limited2, Hon‟ble Apex Court held at Para No.14 as follows:
"14...... In paragraph 16 of the said decision, while adverting to the
provisions of Section 140 of the Act, the Court observed that even if there
is no loss of dependency, the claimant, if he was a legal representative,
major sonwill be entitled to compensation. In the concurring judgment of
Justice S.H. Kapadia, as His Lordship then was, it is observed that there
is distinction between “right to apply for compensation” and “entitlement to
compensation”. The compensation constitutes part of the estate of the
deceased. As a result, the legal representative of the deceased would
inherit the estate. Indeed, in that case, the Court was dealing with the
case of a married daughter of the deceased and the efficacy of Section
140 of the Act. Nevertheless, the principle underlying the exposition in this
decision would clearly come to the aid of the respondent Nos. 1 and 2
(claimants) even though they are major sons of the deceased and also
earning."
(c)
Further, in National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Birender and
others3, it is held that legal representatives of the deceased have a right to
apply for compensation, and in Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co.,
Limited and another Vs. Bipasa Roy and others4 and Balvinder Singh Vs.
2007 ACJ 1279 (SC)
AIR 2020 SC 434
2022 ACJ 1406
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
Vijaya Kumar and others5, it was held that major/married daughters and
sons are entitled for compensation.
(d)
As per the above propositions, married/major sons/daughters who are
also earning and not fully dependents on the deceased, would be still covered
by the expression “legal representative” of the deceased and entitled for
compensation. So, the petitioner Nos.1 to 3, being legal representatives of the
deceased are entitled for compensation.
(e)
So far as income of the deceased is concerned, as rightly observed by
the learned Tribunal, petitioners have not adduced any supportive oral as well
as documentary evidence to show that the deceased doing seasonal fruits
business and was earning Rs.15,000/- per month and having considered the
fact that the accident occurred in the year 2012, the learned Tribunal has
rightly assessed the notional income of the deceased at Rs. 4,000/- per month
and awarded compensation of Rs.4, 88,00/-.
(f)
So far as liability of the respondents is concerned, a finding is already
recorded in point No.1 that the accident occurred due to the rash and
negligent driving of respondent No.1 and as such, respondent No.2 who is
owner of the offending vehicle is vicariously liable for the acts committed by
respondent No.1. It is not in dispute that the insurance policy was in force, as
on the date of the accident and as such, respondent No.3 is liable to indemnify
the liability of Respondent No.2. So, respondent Nos.1 to 3 are jointly and
severally liable to pay compensation.
14. Point No.3:
Upon reappraisal of the evidence on record, and for the foregoing
reasons, this court came to the conclusion that the learned Tribunal rightly
awarded just and fair compensation of Rs.4,88,000/-. For the findings in point
Nos.1 and 2, this court came to conclusion that absolutely there are no
2022 ACJ 1140
SUN, J
MACMA.No.2984 of 2017
reasons to interfere with the order and decree of the learned Tribunal. Hence,
this point is answered accordingly.
15. Point No.4:
In the result, and in view of the findings in point Nos.1 to 3, this Motor
Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is dismissed. There shall be no order as
to costs.
As a sequel thereto, pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand
closed.
_____________________
SUNITHA GANDHAM, J
Dated 12.10.2026
CJP/ knl/vns
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review