Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010580742006
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3396]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE 23rd DAY OF JUNE 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI
PRATAPA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NOs:
1896 & 2004 OF 2006
Between in M.A.C.M.A.No.1896 of 2006:
1. ANNE RAJA RAJESWARI AND 2 OTHERS, W/O LATE
VENKATA KRISHNA PRASAD HOUSE WIFE R/O MIG
122, A.P.HOUSING BOARD, MACHILIPATNAM,
2. ANNE KOTESWARA RAO, S/O LATE VENKATA KRISHNA
PRASAD STUDENT R/O MIG 122, A.P.HOUSING BOARD,
MACHILIPATNAM,
3. ANNE PADMAJA, D/O LATE VENKATA KRISHNA
PRASAD STUDENT R/O MIG 122, A.P.HOUSING BOARD,
MACHILIPATNAM,
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. NADELLA VENKATA LAKSHMI NARASIMHA NAGAPHANI
AND 2 OTHERS, S/O BHASKARA RAO, HINDU DRIVER
OF JEEP AIL 4951
RAMANAGARAM
CHALLPALLI
MANDAL, KRISHNA DIST.
2. THOTTEMPUDI VENKATA KRISHNA RAO, S/O LAKSHMI
NARAYANA, HINDU OWNER OF JEEP AIL 4951
KANTAMANENIVARI
STREET,
RAMANAGARAM,
CHALLLPALLI MANDAL,
3. ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REP. BY
ITS DIVISIONAL MANAGER, DIVISIONAL MANAGER,
ORIENTAL
INSURANCE
COMPANY
LIMITED,
DIVISIONAL OFFICE, P.B.NO.1, RADHA COMPLEX,
...RESPONDENT(S):
Between in M.A.C.M.A.No.2004 of 2006:
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REP.,
BY ITS DIVISIONAL MANAGER, DIVISIONAL OFFICE POST
BOX
NO.1,
RADHA
COMPLEX,
GOPALRAOPET,
GUDIVADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. ANNE RAJA RAJESWARI, W/O.LATE VENKATA KRISHNA
PRASAD HOUSEWIFE R/O.MIG 122, A.P.HOUSING
BOARD, MACHILIPATNAM, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
2. ANNE KOTESWARA RAO, S/O.LATE VENKATA KRISHNA
PRASAD STUDENT OF ENGINEERING (B.E.) R/O.MIG
122, A.P.HOUSING BOARD, MACHILIPATNAM, KRISHNA
DISTRICT.
3. ANNE PADMAJA, D/O.LATE VENKATA KRISHNA
PRASAD
STUDENT
OF
B.SC.
R/O.MIG
122,
A.P.HOUSING BOARD, MACHILIPATNAM, KRISHNA
DISTRICT.
4. NADELLA
VENKATA
LAKSHMI
NARASIMHA
NAGAPHANI, S/O. BHASKARA RAO DRIVER OF JEEP
AIL 4951 R/O. RAMANAGARAM, CHALLAPALLI MANDAL,
KRISHNA DISTRICT.
5. THOTTEMPUDI VENKATA KRISHNA RAO, S/O. LAKSHMI
NARAYANA
OWNER
OF
JEEP
AIL
KANTAMANENIVARI
STREET,
RAMANAGARAM,
CHALLAPALLI MANDAL, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Court to
set aside the order dt.25.5.2006 in O.P.No.304 of 2001 in the
Court of the District Judge, Krishna at Machilipatnam allowing the
appeal.
Counsel for the Appellant/Insurance Company:
MANIMMA MEDIDA
Counsel for the Respondent(S)/Claimants:
NARASIMHA RAO GUDISEVA
The Court made the following:
COMMON JUDGMENT:
1.
These appeals arise out of the award dated 25.05.20061
passed by the Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cumDistrict Judge, Krishna at Machilipatnam2, in M.V.O.P.No.304 of
20013, in awarding compensation of Rs.3,82,500/- against the
claim of Rs.13,00,000/-.
hereinafter called as ‘Impugned award’
hereinafter called as ‘the Tribunal’
hereinafter called as ‘Claim petition’
2.
Since these appeals arise out of same accident and as the
material facts are common, the same are being disposed of by
this common judgment.
3.
The appellants in M.A.C.M.A.No.1896 of 2006, who are
wife and children of one Anne Venkata Krishna Prasad4
respectively,are the claimants before the Tribunal. Dissatisfied
with the quantum of compensation awarded under the impugned
award, they preferred the present appeal seeking enhancement
thereof.The respondent Nos.1 to 3 are the driver, owner and
insurer of the Jeep bearing No.AIL 49515 respectively.
4.
The appellant in M.A.C.M.A.No.2004 of 2006 is the insurer
of the crime jeep.
5.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter
referred to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal.
6.
The case of the claimants, in the petition before the
Tribunal is that:
On 25.12.2000 at about 10.30 p.m., while the
deceased proceeding in crime jeep from Kankpadu
hereinafter called as ‘deceased’
hereinafter referred as ‘crime Jeep’
towards Bandar, when they reached near Davuluru
cross road, the 1st respondent driver of the crime jeep
drove the same in a rash and negligent manner at high
speed, dashed against a culvert wall and fell in the
irrigation channel, resulted the deceased sustained
grievous injuries. Then the deceased was succumbed
to injuries, while shifting to hospital.The appellants
being legal representatives of the deceased claiming
compensation
of
Rs.13,00,000/-
against
the
respondent Nos.1 to 3.
7.
The respondent No.2/owner filed counter, which was
adopted by the respondent No.1/driver, denying the averments in
the petition and pleaded that when the cattle suddenly cross the
road and in-order to avert the same, the accident was occurred,
but not due to the negligent driving of the respondent No.1; that
the respondent No.1 is having valid driving license to drive the
same; that the compensation claimed by the claimants is
excessive, thereby, prayed to dismiss claim petition against these
respondents.
8.
The respondent No.3/insurer filed counter denying the
averments in the petition and pleaded thatthe compensation
claimed by the claimants is excessive, thereby, prayed to dismiss
claim petition against this respondent.
9.
During enquiry before the Tribunal,on behalf of the
claimants, P.Ws.1 to 4 were examined and Exs.A.1 to A.8 and
X.1wereexhibited. On behalf of the respondent No.3, R.Ws.1 and
2 were examined and Exs.B.1 and B.2 were marked.
10.
Upon appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence
on record, the Tribunal held that the accident occurred due to the
rash and negligent driving of the crime jeep by the respondent
No.1 and that Ex.B.1 policy issued in respect of the crime lorry is
in force by the date of incident. Accordingly, a sum of ₹3,82,500/was awarded as compensation to the claimants, together with
interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the date of the claim
petition till the date of realization, payable by Respondent Nos.1
to 3, for the death of the deceased in the accident.
11.
Aggrieved by the quantum of compensation awarded by the
Tribunal,
the
claimants
have
preferred
the
appeal
in
M.A.C.M.A.No.1896 of 2006 seeking enhancement thereof as
well the insurer of the crime jeep also preferred appeal in
M.A.C.M.A.No.2004 of 2006 against the findings of the Tribunal in
fastening the liability on the insurer.
12.
Heard Sri J.Janakirami Reddy, learned counsel for the
appellants/claimants and Sri M.Muralikrishna, learned counsel for
the respondent No.2/insurer.
13.
It is the contention raised by the learned counsel for the
appellants/claimants that the Tribunal erred in calculating the
compensation payable, by not awarding compensation towards
future prospects and by not taking the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs.8,000/-, as per Ex.A.5; and that the Tribunal
awarded a very meagre amount under the remaining heads.
14.
Per
contra,
appellant/insurer
learned
submits
that
counsel
the
appearing
Tribunal,
upon
for
the
proper
appreciation of the material on record, rightly calculated the
compensation payable; that, at the time of the accident, the
deceased was travelling as a private passenger in the crime jeep;
that Ex.B.1 policy, being an Act policy, does not cover the risk of
a private passenger, no premium having been paid to cover such
risk, since the vehicle could not be used for hire; and that the
Tribunal erred in awarding compensation against the insurer
without considering this fact.
15.
The point that arises for determination is: “Whether there
are valid grounds urged by the insurer to interfere with the
findings of the Tribunal, and whether the claimants are entitled to
enhancement of compensation, and if so, to what amount?”
16.
POINT:
It is not in dispute that the deceased died due to the rash
and negligent driving of the crime jeep by its driver, or that no
appeal was preferred by the owner against the findings of the
Tribunal.The insurer contends that, at the time of the accident,
the crime jeep was being used for hire, and the deceased was
travelling as a paid passenger, such that Ex.B.1 does not cover
the risk. This plea, however, was not taken by the insurer in its
written statement, and, apart from a bare contention, no
substantial material was placed before the Tribunal to establish it.
The Tribunal, after elaborate consideration of the material on
record, rightly concluded that the insurer failed to prove that the
vehicle was hired by the deceased at the time of the accident.
The insurer's contention is, accordingly, without merit, and the
appeal preferred by it is liable to be dismissed.
17.
Coming
to
just
compensation,
the
Tribunal,
after
considering the material on record, rightly took the notional
monthly income of the deceased at Rs.3,000/-, the deceased
having worked as Supervisor at R.J. Construction Company for
eight months and having done contract work for three months,
without producing any account to prove his actual income. The
income of the deceased, as rightly taken by the Tribunal, comes
to Rs.36,000/- per annum.
18.
In terms of Constitution Bench decision in National
Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi,6 where the
deceased was self-employed or on a fixed salary and was aged
between 40 and 50 years, an addition of 25% of the established
income is warranted towards future prospects.Applying the
above, and the deceased being aged about 45 years at the time
(2017) 16 SCC 680
of the accident, which is not in dispute, 25% is added towards
future prospects, and the income is determined at Rs.45,000/(Rs.36,000/- + Rs.9,000/-).
19.
As per Pranay Sethi (referred supra), following Sarla
Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation,7 where the deceased
was married, the deduction towards personal and living expenses
is one-third where the number of dependent family members is
two to three.In the present case, there being three claimants
before the Tribunal dependent on the deceased, the deduction
towards personal and living expenses is taken at one-third of the
income, bringing the quantum to Rs.30,000/-.
20.
The multiplier method, being logically sound and legally
well established for quantifying loss of income arising from death,
is applied in terms of Sandeep Khanuja v. Atul Dande &Anr.,8
wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that the choice of
multiplier is determined by the age of the deceased, and that
future prospects are factored into the multiplicand before the
multiplier is applied.
(2009) 6 SCC 121
(2017) 3 SCC 351
21.
The appropriate multiplier applicable to the age of the
deceased, 45 years, in terms of Sarla Verma (referred supra),
is 14, corresponding to the 41–45 age bracket. The loss of
dependency
is,
accordingly,
determined
at Rs.4,20,000/-
(Rs.30,000/- × 14).On the point of conventional heads, this Court
awards Rs.40,000/- towards loss of consortium, Rs.15,000/towards funeral expenses, and Rs.15,000/- towards loss of
estate. The claimants are, therefore, entitled to a total
compensation of Rs.4,90,000/- against Respondent Nos.1 to 3.
22.
A brief exposition of the calculation made to arrive at the
compensation is set out infra:
S.No. Heads
Calculation
The annual income of the Rs.36,000/- per annum
deceased.
25% of above(1) to be (Rs.36,000/- + Rs.9,000/-)
added as future prospects
Rs.45,000/-
1/3rdto be deducted as Rs.30,000/personal
expenses
ofdeceased.
Compensation arrived at (Rs.30,000/- x 14)
on application of multiplier
Rs.4,20,000/14.
Loss of consortium
Rs.40,000/-
Loss of estate
Rs.15,000/-
Funeral expenses
Rs.15,000/-
Total
compensation Rs.4,90,000/awarded(Rows
4+5+6+7)
23.
Therefore, in view of the forgoing discussion, this Court is
of the considered opinion that the award passed by the Tribunal
warrants interference by enhancing the compensation from
Rs.3,82,500/- to Rs.4,90,000/- Accordingly, appeal preferred by
appellants/claimants is liable to be considered partly. Thus, this
point is answered accordingly.
24.
In result, the M.A.C.M.A.No.1896 of 2006 is allowed in part.
The compensation awarded by the Tribunal is enhanced from
₹3,82,500/- to ₹4,90,000/- together with interest at the rate of
7.5% per annum from the date of the claim petition till the date of
realization, with proportionate costs, payable by Respondent
Nos.1
and
jointly
and
severally.
The
Respondent
No.3/Insurance Company shall deposit enhanced compensation
amount, together with accrued interest and proportionate costs,
before the Tribunal within a period of two (2) months from the
date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. Upon such deposit, the
claimant No.1/wifeshall be entitled to receive the enhanced
compensation amount in addition to the amount already awarded
by the Tribunal towards her share and she is permitted to
withdraw the same with interest and costs accrued thereon. The
Tribunal shall proceed to pay the amount in the aforesaid terms,
adjusting the amount, if any, already paid.
25.
The M.A.C.M.A.No.2004 of 2006 is dismissed. There shall
be no order as to costs.
Interim orders granted earlier if any, stand vacated.
Miscellaneous petitions pending if any, stand closed.
________________________________________
Dr.JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
Date: 23.06.2026
Krs
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE VENKATA JYOTHIRMAI PRATAPA
M.A.C.M.A.Nos.1896 & 2004 of 2006
( COMMON JUDGMENT )
DATE: 23.06.2026
Krs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review