Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App.8 of 2023
The Oriental Insurance Company Limited
….…………… Appellant(s)
Versus
Smt. Supriya Guha (Patari) and others
……….. Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Gautam, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Date of hearing and
delivery of judgment & Order
:
14.08.2024.
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes/No.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment and order (Oral)
The present appeal is filed under Section 173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988
read with Section 168 of the Act against the
impugned judgment and award dated 17.08.2022 passed by the learned
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala passed in case
No. T.S.(MAC) 134 of 2016.
[2]
Brief facts of the case as enumerated in the impugned order
passed by the Tribunal below is that on 19.10.2015 at about 11/11.15
p.m. deceased Sanjoy Patari was proceeding towards Belonia town by a
motor bike(Bajaj Pulsar) bearing registration No. TR-03/D-6685 and
when he reached at Bidyapith corner on Belonia-Bankar Road at that time
one Motor Bike(Hero Honda) bearing registration No. TR-01-E-8725 (the
offending vehicle) came with excessive speed from the opposite direction
in negligent manner and dashed the vehicle of the deceased. As a result,
the deceased sustained multiple grievous injuries. Soon after the
accident, deceased was sent to Belonia Hospital where from he was
referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala where he succumbed to his
injuries. Post Mortem examination was also done over the body of
deceased. In this connection, Belonia PS Case No. 139 of 2015 u/s
279/337/304(Part-II) of IPC was also registered. Claimant-petitioners
further stated in their claim petition that the accident occurred due to
rash and negligent driving on the part of the rider of the offending
vehicle.
[3]
It was contended by the Claimant petitioners that at the
time of death deceased Sanjoy Patari was aged about 29 years and he
was a govt. employee as Constable of police attached with the office of
the Superintendent of Police, South Tripura District, Belonia who used to
earn Rs. 20,165/- per month. The claimant petitioners, approached
learned Tribunal seeking compensation due to death of the deceased and
quantified their claim to the tune of Rs.45,61,112/-.
[4]
The OP No.1, owner of the offending Maruti has not
contested the suit by filing written statement and hence, case runs ex
parte against the OP No.1. The OP No.2 by filing written statement
denied all the allegations and contended that on the relevant date of
accident the offending vehicle was insured with the Noticee (Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd.) and put the claimant petitioners in strict proof of their
respective claim. Noticee through his written statement apart from
denying all the allegations also put the claimant petitioners as well as the
OP No.2 in strict proof of their respective claim.
[5]
The learned Tribunal after hearing the parties and on
perusal of relevant evidence on record, vide judgment and award dated
17.08.2022 disposed the case of the claimants in the following manner:
“….9(a). In view of the law laid down in Sarla Varma's case (AIR 2009
SC 3104) for the age group of 26 to 30 the appropriate multiplier is M17.
Besides where the number of dependent family members are
not less than 4 (four in the case at hand),deduction towards personal
and living expenses would be one fourth (1/4).
9(b). Now, in view of the aforesaid principles of law I proceed to
calculate the appropriate compensation in the present case as under:(I) Income per month = Rs.,20,165/- only.
(II) 50% of above to be added as future prospect :- Rs.10,082/- only.
(III)Total of Sl Nos. I and II above comes to Rs.20,165/- + Rs. 10,082/=Rs.30,247/- only.
(IV) one fourth (1/4) of above to be deducted as personal and living
expenses of deceased :- Rs.30,247/- minus Rs.7,561/- = Rs.22,686/only.
(V) compensation after applying multiplier of 17:- Rs. 22,686 x 12 x
17=46,27,944/- only.
(VI) Loss of Estate = Rs.15,000/-only.
(VII) Funeral expenses = Rs.15,000/- only.
(VIII) Loss of consortium=Rs. 40,000/- only.
(IX) Loss of love and affection for the minor son=Rs. 2,00,000/- only.
9(c). Thus, total compensation stands at Rs.46,27,944+15,000
+15,000+ 40,000/- + 2,00,000/-= Rs.48,97,944/- only.
Now coming to the question of liability, it appears that the OP
No.2 rider of the offending vehicle proved the insurance policy(Exbt.C)
that his vehicle was insured with the Noticee, Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd. Accordingly the OP insurer shall satisfy the award. Issue under
consideration accordingly stands answered to the extent as indicated
above.
In view of the issue wise discussion as we had here-inabove, I
order as follows:10.
ORDER
In the result, claim is awarded in following terms :-
(i)
Claimant petitioners are entitled to get the award of
Rs.48,97,944/-(rupees forty eight lacs ninety seven thousand nine
hundred forty four) only along with 9% simple interest per annum from
the date of registration of claim i.e, w.e.f. 04.07.2016 till the date of
realization thereof.
The petitioner No.1 exclusively shall be entitled to get the
amount of Rs. 40,000/- as consortium. Similarly, the claimant-petitioner
No. 2 being minor shall also get the amount as awarded under the head
loss of love and affection. The claimant petitioners shall have equal
share on the rest
amount.
The Noticee, i.e., the Oriental Insurance Company Limited
shall deposit the awarded amount along with interest thereon within one
month
to this Tribunal.
Supply a copy of this award free of cost to the parties by not
later than 15 days from the date of the award.
The case stands disposed off on contest..……”
[6]
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid impugned judgment and
award dated 17.08.2022, the appellant Insurance company has preferred
the instant appeal.
[7]
Mr. P. Gautam, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
insurance company submits that learned Tribunal below committed a
serious error of law and mechanically awarded Rs.2,00,000/- under the
head of love and affection for the minor son of the deceased which is not
defined in accordance with law. He further submits that learned Tribunal
erred imposing 9% interest which is very much higher than the existing
bank rate. He, therefore, urges this Court to set aside the impugned
award passed by the learned Tribunal below.
[8]
To support his contention, Mr. Gautam, learned counsel for
the appellant has placed reliance on the Judgment of Hon’ble Supreme
Court in United India Insurance Company Limited v. Satinder Kaur
Alias Satwinder Kaur and others reported in (2021) 11 SCC 780.
The relevant contents of the said judgment as referred by the learned
counsel, read as under:
“…….(e) Three Conventional heads
28. In Pranay Sethi, the Constitution Bench held that in death cases,
compensation would be awarded only under three conventional heads
viz. loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenses. The Court
held that the conventional and traditional heads, cannot be determined
on percentage basis, because that would not be an acceptable criterion.
Unlike determination of income, the said heads have to be quantified,
which has to be based on a reasonable foundation. It was observed that
factors such as price index, fall in bank interest, escalation of rates, are
aspects which have to be taken into consideration. The Court held that
reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely, loss of estate, loss of
consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs. 15,000/-, Rs. 40,000/and Rs. 15,000/- respectively. The Court was of the view that the
amounts to be awarded under these conventional heads should be
enhanced by 10% every three years, which will bring consistency in
respect of these heads.
a) Loss of Estate – Rs. 15,000 to be awarded
b) Loss of Consortium.
29.
Loss of Consortium, in legal parlance, was historically given a
narrow meaning to be awarded only to the spouse i.e. the right of the
spouse to the company, care, help, comfort, guidance, society, solace,
affection and sexual relations with his or her mate. The loss of
companionship, love, care and protection, etc., the spouse is entitled to
get, has to be compensated appropriately. The concept of nonpecuniary damage for loss of consortium is one of the major heads for
awarding compensation in various jurisdictions such as the United
States of America, Australia, etc. English courts have recognised the
right of a spouse to get compensation even during the period of
temporary disablement.
30. In Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram this Court
interpreted “consortium” to be a compendious term, which encompasses
spousal consortium, parental consortium, as well as filial consortium.
The right to consortium would include the company, care, help, comfort,
guidance, solace and affection of the deceased, which is a loss to his
family. With respect to a spouse, it would include sexual relations with
the deceased spouse.***************************
34. At this stage, we consider it necessary to provide uniformity with
respect to the grant of consortium, and loss of love and affection.
Several Tribunals and High Courts have been awarding compensation for
both loss of consortium and loss of love and affection. The Constitution
Bench in Pranay Sethi (supra), has recognized only three conventional
heads under which compensation can be awarded viz. loss of estate,
loss of consortium and funeral expenses. In Magma General (supra),
this Court gave a comprehensive interpretation to consortium to include
spousal consortium, parental consortium, as well as filial consortium.
Loss of love and affection is comprehended in loss of consortium.
35. The Tribunals and High Courts are directed to award compensation
for loss of consortium, which is a legitimate conventional head. There is
no justification to award compensation towards loss of love and affection
as a separate head.
(c) Funeral Expenses – Rs. 15,000 to be awarded…………..”
[9]
On the contrary, Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for
the claimant respondents opposes the submission made by the learned
counsel for the appellant. He submits that only 40,000/- as consortium
has been awarded to the claimants which is contrary to law. He further
submits that if it is assumed that Rs. 40,000/- as consortium is awarded
to the spouse, the child and parents of the deceased are also entitled to
get Rs.40,000/- each towards filial and parental consortium. To support
his contention, he placed reliance on the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Harpreet Kaur v. Mohinder Yadav reported in AIR
2023 SC 111. The relevant contents of the said judgment as referred by
the learned counsel read as under:
“…….14. In view of the above findings, the appeal deserves to be
allowed. The appellants are entitled to Rs. 25,20,000/- towards loss of
dependency; and the three appellants being the children and mother of
the deceased, are entitled to Rs.40,000/- each towards filial and
parental consortium. The impugned judgment is modified to the above
extent; the rate of interest, and the other components, directed to be
payable, are left undisturbed. The appeal is allowed in these terms,
without order on costs…..”
[10]
Heard the submissions made at the Bar. Perused the
evidence on record.
[11]
Upon hearing the submissions made by the parties and on
perusal of record, this Court is of the opinion that learned Tribunal below
awarded Rs.200,000/- under the head of love and affection for the minor
son of the deceased which is not tenable in the eye of law and the same
is liable to be deleted. Moreover, the interest imposed by the learned
Tribunal @9% per annum, is obviously on the higher side. This Court in
all matters is fixing 7.5% per annum interest to maintain uniformity while
comparing the bank rate of interest which is also much less.
[12]
However, this Court has further observed that the child and
parents of the deceased are also entitled to get Rs.40,000/- each towards
filial and parental consortium.
Now, if the award of Rs.200,000/- under the head of love and
affection for the minor son of the deceased is deleted and the award of
Rs.40,000/- each towards spousal, filial and parental consortium is added
with 10% enhancement, then the compensation awarded to the claimant
respondents stands as under:
RE-CALCULATION
(I) Income per month = Rs.,20,165/- only.
(II) 50% of above to be added as future prospect :- Rs.10,082/- only.
(III)Total of Sl Nos. I and II above comes to Rs.20,165/- + Rs. 10,082/=Rs.30,247/- only.
(IV) one fourth (1/4) of above to be deducted as personal and living
expenses of deceased :- [Rs.30,247/- minus Rs.7,561/-] = Rs.22,686/only.
(V) compensation after applying multiplier of 17:- Rs. 22,686 x 12 x
17=46,27,944/- only.
(VI) Loss of Estate = Rs.15,000/-only.
(VII) Funeral expenses = Rs.15,000/- only.
(VIII) Loss of spousal consortium=Rs. 40,000/- only.
(IX) Loss of filial consortium = Rs.40,000/- only.
(X) Loss of parental consortium = Rs. (2 X 40,000) = Rs. 80,000/only.
(XI) 10% enhancement on the heads of consortium= Rs.[(4 X 40,000) X
10% = Rs. (1,60,000 X 10%) = Rs.16,000/Thus, total compensation stands at Rs.46,27,944+15,000
+15,000+ 40,000/- + 40,000/- + 80,000/- + Rs.16,000/-=
Rs.48,33,944/- only.
[13]
In view of the above, the compensation to be awarded to
the claimants stands at Rs.48,33,944/- (Forty-eight lakh Thirtythree thousand Nine hundred forty-four only along with interest @
7.5% per annum instead of 9% per annum as fixed by the learned
tribunal with effect from the date of presentation of the claim petition till
the date of realization.
Hence, the impugned award passed by the learned Tribunal below
is modified to the extent as indicated above. Apart from the aboveindicated observation, all other aspects of the impugned judgment and
award passed by the learned Tribunal shall remain unaltered.
Thus, the present appeal stands allowed to the extent as indicated
above. As a sequel, miscellaneous application(s) pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi G.
signed by RAJKUMAR
RAJKUMAR SUHANJIT Digitally
SUHANJIT SINGHA
SINGHA
Date: 2024.08.27 13:48:03 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review