The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. No loan or withdrawal shall be permitted in the fixed deposit account nor joint name shall be allowed nor any cheque book, ATM card can be issued against fixed deposit account. However the interest to be credited in the fixed deposit may be released in favour of the claim-petitioners, except minor, as per Bank's norms.” [13] Being aggrieved by the said order dated 18.06.2019 of the tribunal, the appellant herein has preferred the instant appeal. [14] Heard counsel for the parties. [15] It is a case of the appellant-insurance company that the amount which has been considered as notional income is Rs.10,000/- in the absence of the income and income tax return of the deceased. The deceased being a government contractor, though no evidence has been placed before the tribunal to that effect and also with regard to the dependency of the father upon the compensation award has been disputed. [16] During the course of argument counsel appearing for the appellant-insurance company has submitted as against Rs.10,000/fixing a nominal amount of Rs.6,000/- could have been reasonable amount of earning per month. Counsel for the appellant has also relied on a judgment of the apex court in Syed Basheer Ahamed and Others vs. Mohammed Jameel and Another reported in (2009) 2 SCC 225, where the apex court has observed with regard to the monthly income of the deceased in the following manner: “21. I…
04. 06.2019 issued by the Dept. of Labour of Govt. of Tripura, even minimum wages of a Safai Karmachari is Rs.223.00 per day i.e. Rs.6690.00 per month is reasonable according to the counsel for the claimant-respondents and he also submitted that awarding them Rs.6000/- per month would be in lower side considering the income of the deceased person. Moreover, the suggestion made by the appellant counsel that Rs.6000/- could be reasonable is also a guess work without any basis. [18] In view of the above observation, this court feels that the judgment relied by the counsel for the appellant-insurance company is not relevant. Therefore, this court is not inclined to interfere with the impugned judgment and award dated 18.06.2019, passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-02, Gomati Tripura, Udaipur, in No.TS(MAC) 112 of 2014 and confirms the same. [19] Accordingly, the appeal stands dismissed. Dipak Case
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App 82 of 2019
The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Represented by its Divisional Manager,
Agartala Divisional Office, Central Road,
P.S.- East Agartala, District - West Tripura
-----Petitioner(s)
Versus
1. Smt. Poli Majumder (Das)
W/O- Late Rupak Chandra Das,
2. Smti. Rupanjana Das (Minor)
D/O- Lt. Rupak Chandra Das,
3. Smti. Dipali Rani Das
W/O- Sri Dulal Chandra Das,
4. Sri. Dulal Chandra Das
S/O- Lt. Rup Chandra Das,
Vill - Pitra, P.S.- R.K.Pur,
Udaipur, Gomati Tripura.
(The Claimant- petitioner no.2 being minor
represented by her mother the Claimant-petitioner No.1)
5. Sri Sankar Jamatia
Son of Sri Man Mohan Jamatia,
of Noabari, Udaipur, P.O. And P.S. - Killa,
Gomati Tripura District
(Owner of Canter truck bearing Regd. No. TR 03C- 1785)
-----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
Date of pronouncement
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. P Gautam, Adv.
: Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
: 04.03.2022.
: 08.03.2022.
: No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 read with Section 168 of the Act, against the impugned
judgment and award dated 18.06.2019, passed by the Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal-02, Gomati Tripura, Udaipur, in Case No.TS(MAC) 112
of 2014.
[2]
The claim petition discloses the fact that on 01.04.2013 at
about 6.30 hours the deceased Rupak Chandra Das along with one
Dipayan Majumder was coming from Pitra towards Udaipur boarding the
motorbike bearing No.TR-03D-8765 with a moderate speed and on the
way reaching near Sitalabari Bar Tilla, Rajnagar, on call by Upa
Pradhan, Rajnagar Panchayet, namely Indrajit Das, the motorbike was
stopped and kept in stationery mode and the deceased got down from
the motorbike and was talking with the aforesaid Indrajit Das by the
side of the road and suddenly one Canter Truck bearing No.TR-03C1785 came from Udaipur side with abnormal high speed in rash and
negligent manner and dashed the deceased Rupak Chandra Das and as
a result he sustained fatal injuries on his head and other vital parts of
his body resulting to his death and soon after the accident he was taken
to TSD Hospital and considering his condition he was referred to GBP
Hospital after declaring him dead and postmortem examinations was
done at GBP Hospital and thereafter the dead body was handed over to
his relatives.
[3]
It was also stated that the deceased Rupak Chandra Das
was a young energetic and healthy man of 40 years of age and he used
to work as a Government Contractor and also had a shop of grocery
items with Trade License and was also an agent of Rose Vally Chain
Marketing System and used to carry fishery business and out of which
he used to earn Rs.30,000/- per month and was an Income Tax payee.
[4]
It was again stated that the accident took place because of
rash and negligent driving of the aforesaid Canter Truck bearing No.TR03C1785.
[5]
OP No.1, the owner of the Canter Truck bearing No.TR03C-
1785, in his written statement denied all the averments of the claim
petition and pleaded that his Canter Truck bearing No.TR-03C-1785 was
duly insured with the Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd having policy bearing
No. 322700/31/2013/54 with validity from 29.04.2012 to 28.04.2013
and the same was being driven by Nanda Kumar Jamatia having valid
driving license bearing No.TR0320010025279 and his vehicle was also
fit for plying on the road. It was also pleaded that the accident did not
occur because of any of his fault and so he denied his liability.
[6]
OP No.2, the alleged insurer of the aforesaid Canter Truck
bearing No.TR-03C-1785, it its WS denied all the averments of the
claim petition and disputed the age, income, avocation, injuries and
also pleaded that the matter of alleged accident was not reported by the
owner and in absence of policy particulars and other details, OP No.2
could not be made liable to pay compensation and so denied having
insured the aforesaid Canter Truck.
[7]
It was also pleaded that in case of head-on-collision the
drivers of both the vehicles be made equally responsible for the alleged
accident and the rider of motorbike bearing No.TR-03B-8765 was solely
responsible for the alleged accident and so, prayed for dismissal of the
claim petition.
[8]
On the basis of pleadings of parties following issues were
framed by order dated 09.08.2018 :1. Whether Rupak Chandra Das, S/o. Shri Dulal Chandra
Das received injuries in a road traffic accident on
01.04.2013 at about 6.30 hours at Rajnagar Bartilla near
Sitalabari on Pitra-Udaipur Road under RK Pur PS and
same day succumbed to his injuries at GBP Hospital due to
rash and negligent driving by the driver of the vehicle
bearing No.TR-03C-1785(Canter Truck) ?
2. Are the claimants entitled to be compensated under
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. If so, to what extent and who
shall be liable to pay such compensation ?
[9]
While deciding Issue No.1, the tribunal court has observed
that it is evident that the deceased met with an accident on 01.04.2013
because of rash and negligent driving of driver of Canter Truck vehicle
bearing No.TR-03C-1785 resulting to his fatal injuries and consequent
death. Accordingly it is held that the deceased met an accident on
01.04.2013 at around 6.30 hours because of rash and negligent driving
of the aforesaid Canter Truck resulting to the fatal injuries causing the
death of deceased Rupak Chadra Das. Thus, issue No1 is decided in
affirmative in favour of the claimant-petitioners.
[10]
While deciding the issue No.2, the tribunal court has
observed in the following manner:
8.8
In the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Pranay Sethi, AIR 2017 SC 5157 it was held that in case of
deceased who was self employed or having fixed salary,
25% of income should be added as future prospect where
the deceased was between 40 to 50 years and as per the
Judgment of Smt Sarla Verma & ors v Delhi Transport
Corporation & anr, 1/4th of income is to be deducted
towards the personal and living expenses of the deceased
where the number of dependent family members is 4-6,
and again Multiplier is 14 in case of age group between 41
to 45 years, and so,
basing
on
the
aforesaid
Judgments I now proceed to determine the loss of
dependency which are as follows:(a) Monthly income Rs.10,000.00.
(b)
Rs.10,000.00
(monthly
income)
Rs.2500.00(25% future prospect) = Rs.12,500.00.
+
(c) Now after deduction of Rs.3125.00, being 1/4th,
towards the personal and living expenses from
Rs.12,500.00, the same stands at Rs.9,375.00 and thus
yearly income stands at Rs.1,12,500.00 and
(d) After multiplying the same(Rs.1,12,500.00) by
multiplier 14(in case of age between 41 to 45 years, as
per Sarla Verma(Supra), the loss of dependency stands at
Rs.15,75,000.00.
8.9 In addition to the aforesaid amount the claimantpetitioners are also entitled to Rs.15,000/- for loss of
estate and another amount of Rs.15,000/- for funeral
expenses, as per the Judgment passed in NIC vs. Pranay
Sethi(Supra).”
[11]
The tribunal had also discussed elaborately with regard to
determining the liability of insurance company to pay compensation to
the claimant-petitioners.
8.14 Now to determine the question of liability I find from
the evidence of CW. 2 that the aforesaid Canter Truck
vehicle bearing No. TR-03C1785 was newly registered on
30.05.2011 and as per rule the fitness was initially issued
for two years from the date of registration. Again from the
evidence of CW.1 it appears that the aforesaid Canter
Truck had permit for five years from 27.07.2011. In
support of such evidence the vehicle history report and
screen report issued by the DTO., Gomati Tripura has been
submitted and the same were marked as exhibits. Thus;
there is no doubt in holding that the aforesaid Canter
Truck vehicle had valid fitness and permit on the date of
accident, i.e., on 01.04.2013. From the CW.2 it also
appears that the driving license bearing No.TR0320010025279 was issued in favour of Nanda Kumar
Jamatia on 01.02.2001 and was renewed on 30.11.2011
with validity up-to 29.11.2016 for non transport vehicle
and up-to 18.11.2014 for transport vehicle and was
authorized to drive LMV/NT, TRANS and LMV/GV. In
support of such evidence extract copy of driving license
authenticated by the DTO., Gomati Tripura has been
produced and was marked as exhibit.
8.15 In this case the owner, i.e., the OP No.1, has
produced the original certificate of insurance wherefrom I
find that the Canter Truck vehicle bearing No. TR-03C-
1785 had valid insurance coverage from 29.04.2012 to
28.04.2013 under Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd with policy
bearing No.322700/31/2013/54.
8.16. As the vehicle was insured with OP No.2 on the date
of accident so the liability of the owner to pay
compensation is shifted upon the insurer, i.e., the OP
No.2. Thus; the OP No.2, being the insurer of the Canter
Truck vehicle bearing No. TR-03C-1785, is liable to pay the
whole amount of compensation to the claimantpetitioners.
[12]
Finally by the order dated 18.06.2019, the tribunal has
observed in the following manner:
9. The instant application under Section-166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 filed by the claimant-petitioners is
hereby
partly
allowed
and
a
sum
of
Rs.
17,65,000.00(Rupees
Seventeen
Lakh
Sixty
Five
thousand) only along with interest @ 6% per annum from
the date of filing of claim-petition, i.e., from 08.07.2014
till the date of payment, is awarded in favour of claimant –
petitioners as compensation for the death of late Rupak
Chandra Das, in a Road Traffic Accident, as aforesaid, and
this amount of compensation shall be paid by OP No.2, the
insurer of the Canter Truck vehicle bearing No. TR03C1785, within a period of one month.
10. Out of the said amount i.e., 17,65,000.00, a sum of Rs.
3,00,000.00 shall be paid each to claimant-petitioner No.3
and 4, the parents of the deceased(as Rs. 3,00,000.00+Rs.
3,00,000.00). An amount of Rs. 5,00,000.00 shall be paid
to
the
minor
daughter
of
the
deceased,
i.e.,
claimantpetitioner No. 2. The rest amount of Rs.
6,65,000.00 shall be paid to the spouse of the deceased,
i.e., claimant-petitioner No.1.
11. In the event of deposit of the Awarded amount,
Rs.50,000.00 shall be released in favour of each of the
claimant-petitioner No.1, 3 and 4 out of their respective
shares, in their respective bank accounts for enabling
them to meet necessary expenses and the rest amount
shall be kept in fixed deposit schemes in any Nationalized
Bank for five years in the name of the claimant-petitioner
No.1, 3 and 4 separately as per their respective shares.
However as claimant-petitioner No.2 is minor so her entire
share along with interest, shall be kept in a fixed deposit
scheme in a Nationalized Bank for a period of five years or
for the period till attainment of her majority, whichever is
later.
12. No loan or withdrawal shall be permitted in the fixed
deposit account nor joint name shall be allowed nor any
cheque book, ATM card
can be issued against fixed deposit account. However the
interest to be
credited in the fixed deposit may be released in favour of
the claim-petitioners, except minor, as per Bank's norms.”
[13]
Being aggrieved by the said order dated 18.06.2019 of the
tribunal, the appellant herein has preferred the instant appeal.
[14]
Heard counsel for the parties.
[15]
It is a case of the appellant-insurance company that the
amount which has been considered as notional income is Rs.10,000/- in
the absence of the income and income tax return of the deceased. The
deceased being a government contractor, though no evidence has been
placed before the tribunal to that effect and also with regard to the
dependency of the father upon the compensation award has been
disputed.
[16]
During the course of argument counsel appearing for the
appellant-insurance company has submitted as against Rs.10,000/fixing a nominal amount of Rs.6,000/- could have been reasonable
amount of earning per month. Counsel for the appellant has also relied
on a judgment of the apex court in Syed Basheer Ahamed and Others
vs. Mohammed Jameel and Another reported in (2009) 2 SCC 225,
where the apex court has observed with regard to the monthly income
of the deceased in the following manner:
“21. In the instant case, the main grievance of the
appellant is that the High Court erred in reducing the
monthly income of the deceased from Rs.7,000/- to
Rs.4,000/-. More so, when the claim of the appellants was
that the deceased was earning about Rs.20,000/- per
month. It needs little emphasis that insofar as the
question of earnings of the deceased is concerned, the
onus lies on the claimants to prove this fact by leading
reliable and cogent evidence before the Tribunal. A bare
assertion in the claim petition in that behalf is not
sufficient to discharge that onus.”
[17]
Counsel for the respondent-claimants submitted that during
the course of the judicial proceeding, the mother of the deceased also
died and accordingly her share of dependency has been transferred in
favour of the widow and child of the deceased. The father can also be
treated as depended and his right of dependency cannot be denied. And
with regard to the fixing of Rs.10,000/- for consideration basing on the
notification
bearing
No.F.87(1)-LAB/ENF/MW/89/2970-83
dated
04.06.2019 issued by the Dept. of Labour of Govt. of Tripura, even
minimum wages of a Safai Karmachari is Rs.223.00 per day i.e.
Rs.6690.00 per month is reasonable according to the counsel for the
claimant-respondents and he also submitted that awarding them
Rs.6000/- per month would be in lower side considering the income of
the deceased person. Moreover, the suggestion made by the appellant
counsel that Rs.6000/- could be reasonable is also a guess work without
any basis.
[18]
In view of the above observation, this court feels that the
judgment relied by the counsel for the appellant-insurance company is
not relevant. Therefore, this court is not inclined to interfere with the
impugned judgment and award dated 18.06.2019, passed by the Motor
Accidents
Claims
Tribunal-02,
Gomati
Tripura,
Udaipur,
in
No.TS(MAC) 112 of 2014 and confirms the same.
[19]
Accordingly, the appeal stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Dipak
Case
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review