The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. The appellant may also be allowed to withdraw the statutory deposit of Rs.25,000/- deposited before the Registry of this Court. Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC010286672023
2026:GAU-AS:11473
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : MACApp./39/2024
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
A COMPANY REGISTERED UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT. REPRESENTED
BY ITS REGIONAL MANAGER, ULUBARI, GUWAHATI 7, DIST. KAMRUP.
ASSAM
VERSUS
PARAMJIT KAUR AND 5 ORS
W/O LATE PARVENDRA @ PARVENDER @ PARBINDER SINGH,
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHAMMAD NAGAR A, PO AND PS NOORPUR,
DIST BIJNOR, UTTAR PRADESH,
PRESENT ADDRESS
BASISTHA CHARIALI, GUWAHATI, PS BASISTHA, DIST KAMRUP METRO.
ASSAM
2:SMTI. SATNAAM KAUR
W/O SRI MANJEET SINGH
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHAMMAD NAGAR A
PO AND PS NOORPUR
DIST BIJNOR
UTTAR PRADESH
PRESENT ADDRESS
BASISTHA CHARIALI
GUWAHATI
PS BASISTHA
DIST KAMRUP METRO. ASSAM
3:SRI MANJEET SINGH
F/O LATE PARVENDRA @ PARVENDER @ PARBINDER SINGH
Page No.# 2/10
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHAMMAD NAGAR A
PO AND PS NOORPUR
DIST BIJNOR
UTTAR PRADESH
PRESENT ADDRESS
BASISTHA CHARIALI
GUWAHATI
PS BASISTHA
DIST KAMRUP METRO. ASSAM
4:SRI HARPREET SINGH
S/O SRI MANJEET SINGH
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHAMMAD NAGAR A
PO AND PS NOORPUR
DIST BIJNOR
UTTAR PRADESH
PRESENT ADDRESS
BASISTHA CHARIALI
GUWAHATI
PS BASISTHA
DIST KAMRUP METRO. ASSAM
5:SRI KUSUM DEVI
W/O SRI RAJEEV KUMAR
RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO. 06
JAYANAGAR SIX MILE
B/L 5
PS DISPUR
DIST KAMRUP M GUWAHATI
6:MD. SAFIT ALI
S/O LATE SAIF ALI
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SATDOLA
KALITAKUCHI
PO AND PS HAJO
DIST KAMRUP ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. S K GOSWAMI, MR. R SHARMA
Advocate for the Respondent : A G CHOUDHURY (r-1), MRS S ACHARYA (R-6),MRS. S
KHATANIAR (R-6),MS. B SAIKIA (R-6)
Page No.# 3/10
Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/241/2024
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.
A COMPANY REGISTERED UNDER THE COMPANIES ACT. REPRESENTED
BY ITS REGIONAL MANAGER
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI 7
DIST. KAMRUP. ASSAM
VERSUS
PARAMJIT KAUR AND 5 ORS
W/O LATE PARVENDRA @ PARVENDER @ PARBINDER SINGH
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHAMMAD NAGAR A
PO AND PS NOORPUR
DIST BIJNOR
UTTAR PRADESH
PRESENT ADDRESS BASISTHA CHARIALI
GUWAHATI
PS BASISTHA
DIST KAMRUP METRO. ASSAM
2:SMTI. SATNAAM KAUR
W/O SRI MANJEET SINGH
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHAMMAD NAGAR A
PO AND PS NOORPUR
DIST BIJNOR
UTTAR PRADESH
PRESENT ADDRESS
BASISTHA CHARIALI
GUWAHATI
PS BASISTHA
DIST KAMRUP METRO. ASSAM
3:SRI MANJEET SINGH
F/O LATE PARVENDRA @ PARVENDER @ PARBINDER SINGH
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHAMMAD NAGAR A
PO AND PS NOORPUR
DIST BIJNOR
Page No.# 4/10
UTTAR PRADESH
PRESENT ADDRESS
BASISTHA CHARIALI
GUWAHATI
PS BASISTHA
DIST KAMRUP METRO. ASSAM
4:SRI HARPREET SINGH
S/O SRI MANJEET SINGH
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE MAHAMMAD NAGAR A
PO AND PS NOORPUR
DIST BIJNOR
UTTAR PRADESH
PRESENT ADDRESS
BASISTHA CHARIALI
GUWAHATI
PS BASISTHA
DIST KAMRUP METRO. ASSAM
5:SRI KUSUM DEVI
W/O SRI RAJEEV KUMAR
RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO. 06
JAYANAGAR SIX MILE
B/L 5
PS DISPUR
DIST KAMRUP M GUWAHATI
6:MD. SAFIT ALI
S/O LATE SAIF ALI
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SATDOLA
KALITAKUCHI
PO AND PS HAJO
DIST KAMRUP ASSAM
-----------Advocate for : MR. S K GOSWAMI
Advocate for : appearing for PARAMJIT KAUR AND 5 ORS
Page No.# 5/10
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE YARENJUNGLA LONGKUMER
ORDER
Date : 13-08-2026
The instant appeal under section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 has
been preferred against the judgment and award dated 18.09.2023 passed by
the learned member, MACT No.3 Kamrup (M) Guwahati in MAC Case
No.1755/2019.
2.
Heard the learned counsel for the appellant Mr. S.K. Goswami. Also heard
the learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 Ms. A.G Choudhury and Ms.
B. Saikia, learned counsel for the respondent No.6.
3.
This appeal arises out of the MAC Case No.1755/2019 where the
respondent No. 1 to 4 as claimants had filed the claim petition before the MACT
No.3 Kamrup (M) Guwahati claiming compensation for the death of Parvendra @
Parvender @ Parbinder Singh as a result of motor vehicle accident which
occurred on 01.07.2019 at about 8.30 AM at Khanapara near Ganesh Mandir.
4.
The learned Tribunal passed the order dated 18.09.2023 directing the
appellant company to pay an amount of Rs.15,07,472/- as compensation along
with 9% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition. Being aggrieved
the appellant is before this Court on the following ground:(i)
The Tribunal failed to appreciate the fact that the claimant did not
examine any eye witness regarding involvement of the offending vehicle.
(ii)
That the claimant exhibited FIR dated 04.07.2019 filed by one
Gurmeet Singh which clearly discloses that one unknown city bus caused the
alleged accident at Khanapara near Ganesh Mandir and original G.D. entry dated
Page No.# 6/10
01.07.2019 also discloses the fact that one unknown city bus hit 2 persons, but
there is no evidence on how the involvement of the vehicle bearing registration
No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra City Bus) was ascertained and a claim was filed
claiming compensation for the same as the claimant has not examined any
witnesses nor the Investigating Officer of the case to prove the involvement of
the vehicle in question.
(iii)
That the claimant did not examine any eye witness but the learned
Tribunal while deciding the issue No.1 came to a finding that the vehicle bearing
registration No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra City Bus) was involved in the accident.
(iv)
The Tribunal came to a finding contrary to the evidence on record, as
appellant company has examined defense witness and exhibited 5 documents,
including a letter of the owner of the vehicle B/R No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra City
Bus) as exhibit-B stating and disclosing that her vehicle was not involved in the
alleged accident. However, the learned Tribunal did not take the same into
consideration.
5.
The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that by not examining
the Investigating Officer, the claimant has failed to establish cogent evidence
that the vehicle No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra City Bus) was involved in the accident
and that it was the offending vehicle.
6.
The learned counsel for the appellant has relied on the case of Kamlesh
and Others vs Attar Singh and Others reported in (2015) 15 SCC 364
wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court has stated that a charge-sheet cannot be
conclusive evidence regarding involvement of a particular vehicle. The learned
counsel also relied on the case of Sithara N.S and others vs Sai Ram
General Insurance Company Limited reported in (2025) INSC 1425,
Page No.# 7/10
wherein the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal on the ground that the
appellant had failed to prove the involvement of the offending vehicle driven by
the respondent and that the chargesheet alone was not conclusive evidence.
7.
The
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
fairly
submits
that
the
claimant/respondent had suffered loss due to the demise of her husband in a
motor vehicle accident and no doubt they are entitled to compensation under
the Motor Vehicle Act. However in view of the fact that the involvement of the
vehicle No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra City Bus) has not been proved by the claimants
before the tribunal, the learned counsel prays that this appeal may be disposed
of by referring the matter to the Special Investigation Team, Assam constituted
in accordance with the observation made in the case of Safiq Ahmad vs ICICI
Lombard General Insurance Co.Ltd in Special Leave Petition No.1110/2017, to
investigate the facts and circumstances regarding the accident which happened
on 01.07.2019 at Khanapara near Ganesh Mandir. The learned counsel also
referred to the order passed by this Court on 16.06.2026 in MACApp.59/2025,
wherein similar directions has been given by this Court as the negligence on the
part of the driver of the offending vehicle could not be proved by the claimants.
8.
Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondents/claimants submits that
even though in the first G.D. entry and the FIR it was entered that it was an
unknown vehicle which had caused the accident, however, during the
subsequent investigation it has been found that it was vehicle No.AS-01/JC-2683
(Ultra City Bus) which had caused the accident and therefore charge-sheet was
filed against the driver of the said vehicle. The learned counsel also submits that
the DW 1/insurance investigator had admitted that he did not file any
investigation report and therefore his deposition was purely hearsay. The
investigator failed to exhibit the investigation report. The learned counsel
Page No.# 8/10
further submits that even though the insurer had exhibited the letter written by
the owner of the vehicle to the effect that her vehicle is not involved, the insurer
has not examined the owner of the vehicle and therefore, the letter was not
proved. The learned counsel submits that the fact of the accident i.e.
involvement of the vehicle No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra City Bus) has been proved
and therefore prays that this Court may not interfere with the impugned
judgment and award dated 18.09.2023.
9.
I have duly considered the submissions made by the learned counsel for
the parties and perused the records and also the impugned judgment and order
dated 18.09.2023 in MAC Case No.1755/2019.
10.
Upon going through the impugned judgment, it is seen that the
claimants/respondents had exhibited the G.D. entry and the FIR which shows
that the offending vehicle was an unknown vehicle. No doubt after further
investigation, the charge-sheet shows that the vehicle No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra
City Bus) was involved in the accident. However, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Sithara N.S (supra) has held that the absence of the registration
number in the FIR or complaint lodged immediately after the accident is not, by
itself, fatal to the claim and FIR is not expected to contain every detail, however,
the claimants must establish the specific identity of the vehicle/driver, with the
caveat that the connection of the accident with the said vehicle must be
established through cogent and reliable evidence. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
also held that a charge-sheet cannot automatically be created as conclusive
proof that the vehicle was involved in the accident. The case of Sithara N.S
(supra) has laid down the core legal issue that while re-affirming that MAC
proceedings are decided on the preponderance of probabilities rather than proof
beyond reasonable doubt presumption alone without credible evidentiary basis
Page No.# 9/10
is insufficient. The Hon’ble Supreme Court therefore concluded that the liability
cannot be based on presumption and must be based on cogent and reliable
evidence.
11. This Court is therefore of the view that the Tribunal could not have arrived
at a finding that the vehicle No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra City Bus) was involved
merely
because
the
charge-sheet
said
so,
particularly
when
the
claimants/respondents had not produced any source from which the police
subsequently identified the vehicle.
12. The learned Tribunal did not consider the fact that there was no eye
witness who had identified the vehicle and the charge-sheet was the only
evidence linking the vehicle No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra City Bus) to the accident.
The claimant was herself cross-examined as PW 1 and she has stated that she
did not see the accident. Therefore, there was a serious evidentiary gap as the
claimant was not able to prove how the vehicle No.AS-01/JC-2683 (Ultra City
Bus) was identified as the offending vehicle.
13. In view of the above finding, the impugned judgment and order dated
18.09.2023 passed by the learned MACT No.3 Kamrup (M) Guwahati in MAC
Case No.1755/2019 is quashed and set aside.
14. The matter is referred to the Special Investigating Team Assam constituted
as per the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Safiq Ahmad vs
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co.Ltd in Special Leave Petition No.1110/2017
to investigate the facts and circumstances with regard to the accident which
occurred near Ganesh Mandir on 01.07.2019 at Khanapara.
15. The Registry shall send back the case records to the learned MACT No.3
Kamrup (M) Guwahati and on receipt of the same, the learned Tribunal shall
Page No.# 10/10
proceed with the matter as per the direction of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the case of Safiq Ahmad (supra) and shall make an endeavor to dispose of the
petition upon receipt of the report of the SIT. Registry shall forward a copy of
this judgment and order to the Special Investigating Team for compliance of the
direction. The parties shall appear before the learned Tribunal on 17.09.2026.
16. The appellant may also be allowed to withdraw the statutory deposit of
Rs.25,000/- deposited before the Registry of this Court.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review