Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 24-09-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE P.T. ASHA
AND
THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE N. MALA
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
CNR:{HCMA013680752018}
AND
CMP NO. 22816 OF 2018
The Oriental Ins Co Ltd
Suba Govindam Building Imperial Road,
Cuddalore,
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. S.Kalaiselvi@selvi
All Are Permanently Residing At O.No.196,
N.No.218, Vellazha St., Azhitchikudi,
Chidambaram Tk, Now At Sudarsanam St.,
Manjakuppam Cuddalore Tk.
2. K.Srinivasan
All Are Permanently Residing At O.No.196,
N.No.218, Vellazha St., Azhitchikudi,
Chidambaram Tk, Now At Sudarsanam St.,
Manjakuppam Cuddalore Tk.
3. S.Elayaraja
All Are Permanently Residing At O.No.196,
N.No.218, Vellazha St., Azhitchikudi,
Chidambaram Tk, Now At Sudarsanam St.,
Manjakuppam Cuddalore Tk.
4. Smalathy
All Are Permanently Residing At O.No.196,
N.No.218, Vellazha St., Azhitchikudi,
Chidambaram Tk, Now At Sudarsanam St.,
Manjakuppam Cuddalore Tk.
5. G.Jegannathan
No.2, Cop.Co, Homes Jaswanth Nagar,
__________
Page1 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
Mugappair West, Chennai 37, Sankarapuram
Tk, Villupuram Dt.
..Respondent(s)
Prayer: Appeal is filed under section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, to set aside
the decree and judgment dated 09th of July, 2018, made in MCOP
No.2320/2014 on the file of the MACT(Principal District Judge), Cuddalore.
For Appellant(s):
Mr.K.Vinod
For Respondent(s):
Mr. A.G.F.Terry Chella Raja for R1 TO R4
R5 ---NA
JUDGMENT
(Judgment of the Court was delivered by P.T.Asha J.)
The 2nd respondent/Insurance Company is the appellant before this
Court, challenging the Award passed by the Principal District Judge (Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal), Cuddalore, in M.C.O.P. No.2320 of 2014.
2. The brief facts are set out hereinbelow, and the parties are referred to in
the same ranking as before the Tribunal.
3. The petitioners, who are the parents and siblings of the deceased,
S.Muthu @ Muthuvel, filed the above claim petition seeking compensation of a
sum of Rs.5,00,00,000/-.
__________
Page2 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
4. The case of the petitioners is that, on 03.02.2014, at about 08.00 a.m.,
the deceased was riding a motorcycle bearing Registration No. TN-18-T-1705
on the Puthur-Chennai Road at Chittoor Kadria Village. At that time, a man
suddenly crossed the road. In order to avoid hitting the said person, the
deceased turned the vehicle, as a result of which the motorcycle capsized and
the deceased sustained grievous injuries and multiple fractures all over his body
and head. He was immediately taken to the CHC Hospital, Puttur, and thereafter
shifted to SVRRGGH Hospital, Tirupati. Subsequently, he was referred to CMC
Hospital, Vellore, for advanced treatment. However, on the way to CMC
Hospital, the said S. Muthu succumbed to his injuries.
5. The petitioners would submit that the accident had arisen out of and in
the course of the employment of the deceased. Therefore, they had filed the
claim petition under Section 167 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
6. The 2nd respondent/Insurance Company filed a counter inter alia
contending that the accident had occurred solely on account of the negligence of
the deceased himself. They contended that the deceased did not possess a valid
driving licence and that he was driving the vehicle in a rash and negligent
manner. Since the deceased himself was at fault, the petitioners were not
entitled to claim compensation.
__________
Page3 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
7. The Tribunal had framed the following points for determination:(i) Whether the accident had happened due to the rash and negligent
driving of the 1st respondent’s vehicle rider?
(ii) Whether the petitioners are entitled to get the compensation as
alleged by them?
(iii) To what other reliefs, the petitioners are entitled?
8. To prove their case, the petitioners examined P.W.1, the 1st petitioner,
and P.W.2, an eye-witness, and marked Ex.P1 to Ex.P8. On the side of the
respondents, R.W.1, one Jeganathan, was examined and Ex.R1 was marked.
9. The Tribunal below, taking into consideration the evidence of P.W.2
that the accident had occurred due to the sudden crossing of a man and also
considering the contents of the FIR, observed that the accident had occurred
when the deceased was riding the 1st respondent's vehicle and, therefore,
concluded that the accident had occurred out of and in the course of his
employment in the 1st respondent's office. Consequently, the Tribunal held that
the 2nd respondent, being the insurer of the 1st respondent's vehicle, was liable
to pay the compensation.
10. As regards the quantum of compensation, the Tribunal fixed the
monthly income of the deceased at Rs.12,500/-, added 40% towards future
__________
Page4 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
prospects, adopted a multiplier of 18, and deducted 50% towards the personal
expenses of the deceased. Ultimately, the Tribunal awarded a sum of
Rs.19,85,000/- as compensation. Aggrieved by the said Award, the 2nd
respondent/Insurance Company has preferred the present appeal before this
Court.
11. The main grievance of the 2nd respondent is that the Tribunal had
erred in coming to the conclusion that the accident had occurred out of and in
the course of the employment of the deceased, particularly when there was no
evidence to establish the same.
12. The learned counsel for the 2nd respondent would submit that the
evidence of R.W.1, as well as the materials available on record, would clearly
establish that the accident had occurred solely on account of the negligence of
the deceased. Therefore, the finding of the Tribunal that the accident had
occurred while the deceased was riding the motorcycle in the course of his
employment and that the 2nd respondent, being the insurer of the 1st
respondent's vehicle, was liable to pay the compensation, is erroneous.
13. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners would submit that
the accident had occurred out of and in the course of the employment of the
deceased and, therefore, the claim could be treated as one arising under the
__________
Page5 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
Workmen's Compensation Act.
14. Heard the learned counsel appearing on either side and perused the
materials available records.
15. A perusal of the evidence of P.W.2, Karthikeyan, who claims to be an
eye-witness to the accident, would show that, though he claims to have
witnessed the accident, he had not lodged the FIR. In his cross-examination, he
had stated that the deceased was riding the motorcycle with Jeganathan, the 1st
respondent who is the owner of the vehicle, seated as the pillion rider. However,
he had merely stated that the accident occurred at about 08.00 a.m. and had not
deposed as to the manner in which the accident had occurred.
16. The 1st respondent, who was the pillion rider and the owner of the
motorcycle, was examined as R.W.1. In his evidence also, he had not described
the manner in which the accident had occurred.
17. The 2nd respondent/Insurance Company marked Ex.R1, which is the
investigator's report. The Investigator had referred to the statement given before
the police. R.W.1 had given a statement under Section 161 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure before the police authorities, wherein he had stated that the
accident occurred when he and the deceased were returning to Chennai after
__________
Page6 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
having Darshan at Tirupati. When they were travelling on the Puthur–Chennai
Road at Chittoor Kadria Village, a man suddenly crossed the road. In order to
avoid hitting the said person, the deceased suddenly applied the brakes, as a
result of which the accident occurred.
18. It is not in dispute that the accident occurred while the deceased and
R.W.1 were travelling on the motorcycle and that, in an attempt to avoid hitting
a person who had suddenly crossed the road, the deceased applied the brakes,
resulting in the accident. Consequently, the deceased sustained grievous injuries
and subsequently succumbed to the same.
19. The claim petition has been filed seeking compensation by treating
the accident as one arising out of and in the course of the employment of the
deceased. However, the statement given by R.W.1. under Section 161 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, which forms part of Ex.R1, clearly shows that the
deceased and the 1st respondent were returning to Chennai after having Darshan
at Tirupati. Such a journey, by no stretch of imagination, can be construed as a
journey arising out of and in the course of employment.
20. Therefore, the finding of the Tribunal that the accident had occurred
out of and in the course of employment is far-fetched and not supported by any
evidence or material on record.
__________
Page7 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
21. In fine, the above Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is allowed and the
judgement and decree passed by the Principal District Judge (Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal), Cuddalore in MCOP No.2320 of 2014 dated 09.07.2018 is set
aside. No costs.
22. It is informed that the 2nd respondent/Insurance Company has
deposited the entire Award amount. In view of the judgement and decree passed
by the Principal District Judge (Motor Accident Claims Tribunal), Cuddalore in
MCOP No.2320 of 2014 dated 09.07.2018 having been set aside, the 2nd
respondent/Insurance Company is permitted to withdraw the entire Award
amount lying to the credit of M.C.O.P. No.2320 of 2014, on the file of the
Principal District Court (Motor Accident Claims Tribunal), Cuddalore.
(P.T.A.,J.) (N.M.,J.)
24-09-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
SHR
To
1.The Principal District Court (Motor Accident Claims Tribunal),
Cuddalore.
2. The Section Officer,
VR Section, Madras High Court.
__________
Page8 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
P.T.ASHA J.
AND
N.MALA J.
SHR
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
AND
CMP NO. 22816 OF 2018
24-09-2026
__________
Page9 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 3052 of 2018
__________
Page10 of 10
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review