The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. In the light of the aforesaid principle and the facts enumerated here-in-above, which have been pleaded and submitted before this Court by the review petitioner, I find the present review application is devoid of merit being frivolous and has caused the sheer wastage of valuable time of this Court. None of the above parameters has been fulfilled in this review petition.
16. Accordingly, the review petition filed by the petitioners/ ONGCL stands dismissed with a cost of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only . Out of this Rs.1,00,000/-, Rs. 50,000/-(Rupees fifty thousand) shall be paid to the Tripura State Legal Services Authority, Rs.25,000/-(Rupees twenty five thousand) to the Tripura High Court Bar Association and the balance of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) shall be paid to the Dharmanagar District Court Bar Association.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
REVIEW PET 49 OF 2023
The Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd., Tripura Asset
Vrs.
Sri Rapji Ali & Ors.
Present:
For the petitioner(s)
For the respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Counsel.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate.
: None.
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
20.09.2023
Order
The present review petition has been filed by the petitioner, the
Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Limited (ONGCL, for short) under Section
114 read with Order XLVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for review
of the order dated 06.09.2023 passed in I.A. No.01 of 2023, arising out of
Cont. Cas.(C) No.79 of 2023, whereby direction has been issued to the
Registry of this Court to disburse the amount to the respective workers under
the employer/contractor on proper verification of their identity.
2.
To put shortly, the review petitioner filed a writ petition before
this Court bearing WP(C) No.679 of 2020. While disposing of the said writ
petition, this Court had passed a direction at Para 4, which is reproduced
hereunder:
“[4] In view of such legal position, I direct the contractors,
respondents No.6 and 7 to pay the minimum wages to their workers in
a regular manner, and the arrears, if any, shall be paid within a period
of 3[three] months from the date of receipt of the copy of this order. It
is made clear that if the contractors fail to pay and comply the
direction of this Court, then, the ONGC being the principal employer
shall pay the prescribed minimum wages in a regular manner and
shall pay the arrears within the said period of three months and also
shall recover the same from the contractors.”
3.
Subsequently, the said order was modified vide order dated
14.09.2021 passed in I.A. No.02 of 2021 arising out of WP(C) No.679 of
2020(D/O) and thereafter while disposing of earlier Cont. Cas.(C) No.69 of
2021 vide order dated 01.02.2022, the workers were directed to furnish fresh
particulars on being asked by the ONGCL.
4.
The writ petitioners, who are the respondents of this review
petition, filed two contempt applications registered as Cont. Cas.(C) No.69 of
2023 and Cont. Cas.(C) No.79 of 2023. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel
appearing on behalf of review petitioner/ONGCL has candidly submitted that
the writ petitioners had not impleaded the Contractors, i.e. the respondent
Nos.14 and 15 in those Contempt applications. Learned senior counsel would
contend that the writ petitioners never raised any claim as regards their dues
out of their wages to the Contractors.
5.
This Court passed an order on 07.08.2023 in Cont. Cas.(C) No.79
of 2023 holding that there was willful disobedience of the order dated
26.04.2021 passed by this Court in WP(C) No.679 of 2020 by the respondentcontemnors, i.e. the review petitioners and directed the Asset Manager,
ONGCL and other respondents to appear before this Court in-person on
14.08.2023 at 10.30 am positively. However, it was clarified that if the order
dated 26.04.2021 is complied with by the respondent-contemnors, then, their
appearance before this Court would stand dispensed with.
6.
Learned senior counsel for the review petitioner submits that to
save themselves from the proceedings, the contemnor-review petitioner had
complied the order passed by this Court and deposited Rs.58,50,000/- to the
Registry of this Court. Thereafter, in response to another Interlocutory
Application, being I.A. No.01 of 2023, arising out of Cont. Cas.(C) No.79 of
2023(D/O) filed by the review petitioner, this Court by order dated 06.09.2023
directed the Registry of this Court to disburse the amount to the respective
workers under the employer/contractor on proper verification of the identity of
the individual petitioners.
7.
In the instant review petition, the main point urged by the review
petitioner is that this Court while passing the directions as stated above, did
not ascertain any specific amount to be paid to each of the writ
petitioners/workers. Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel has submitted that unless
the specific amount to which each of the writ petitioners are entitled is
ascertained and also the dates and period the writ petitioners worked under
each of the Contractors is ascertained, as they claimed in their letter dated
25.10.2021, the review petitioner/ONGCL would not be in a position to
realize any amount from any of the Contractors since the writ petitioner had
not impleaded any of the Contractors for any period earlier than 2017.
8.
I have considered the submissions made by Mr. Deb, learned
senior counsel appearing for the review petitioner/ONGCL. The crux of the
submission of learned senior counsel is that it is the duty of the Court to
ascertain the specific amount to be paid to each of the writ
petitioners/workers, otherwise, it would be difficult for ONGCL to recover the
said amount from the respective Contractors.
9.
In my opinion, the grounds stated in the review petition and
submitted before this Court are wholly frivolous and cannot be entertained in
the review petition. These points raised in the present review petition were
never raised during the course of hearing of the original writ petition. The
review petitioner/ONGCL has come up with entirely new facts which cannot
be the subject matter to review the judgment and order passed by this Court in
the original writ petition. According to me, this is a sheer wastage of Court’s
valuable time.
10.
Needless to say, the review petitioner/ONGCL being the
principal employer must be the custodian of the agreement/contract entered
with the respective Contractors. It is the review petitioner who paid bills
raised by the Contractors and all documents as regards the payments and the
accounts thereof are lying with the ONGCL. The Court must not enter into the
dispute between the ONGCL being the principal employer and the
Contractors. As I said, the review petition is the abuse of the process of law
for which suitable cost is to be imposed upon the ONGCL.
11.
Order XLVII, Rule 1 under which provisions have been made for
review of judgment is reproduced here-in-below:
“1. Application for review of judgment - (1) Any person considering
himself aggrieved (a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is allowed, but from
which no appeal has been preferred,
(b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is allowed, or
(c) by a decision on a reference from a Court of Small Causes, and
who, from the discovery of new and important matter or evidence
which, after the exercise of due diligence was not within his
knowledge or could not be produced by him at the time when the
decree was passed or order made, or on account of some mistake or
error apparent on the face of the record, or for any other sufficient
reason, desires to obtain a review of the decree passed or order made
against him, may apply for a review of judgment to the Court which
passed the decree or made the order.
(2) A party who is not appealing from a decree or Order may apply
for a review of judgment notwithstanding the pendency of an appeal
by some other party except where the ground of such appeal is
common to the applicant and the appellant, or when, being
respondent, he can present to the Appellate Court the case on which
he applies for the review.
1[Explanation-The fact that the decision on a question of law on
which the judgment of the Court is based has been reversed or
modified by the subsequent decision of a superior Court in any other
case, shall not be a ground for the review of such judgment.]”
12.
As I discussed in the preceding paragraphs, the review petitioner
has urged certain directions from this Court which they never raised at the
time of hearing of the main writ petition. Further, the review
petitioner/ONGCL has failed to justify that there is any error apparent on the
face of the record. The grounds raised by the review petitioner do not come
within the purview of the expression “any other sufficient cause”. The review
petitioner also could not detect the mistake in the judgment. As I said earlier,
the review petitioner had filed two Interlocutory Applications seeking
clarification of the judgment and order which were dealt with in terms of their
prayer made in those Interlocutory Applications.
13.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Kamlesh Verma Vrs. Mayawati &
Ors., reported in (2013) 8 SCC 320 while dealing with a review application
has discussed the scope and ambit of Order XLVII, Rule 1 of CPC and has
summarized the principles as under:
“20. ……..When the review will not be maintainable:
(i) A repetition of old and overruled argument is not enough to reopen
concluded adjudications.
(ii) Minor mistakes of inconsequential import.
(iii) Review proceedings cannot be equated with the original hearing
of the case.
(iv) Review is not maintainable unless the material error, manifest on
the face of the order, undermines its soundness or results in miscarriage
of justice.
(v) A review is by no means an appeal in disguise whereby an
erroneous decision is reheard and corrected but lies only for patent error.
(vi) The mere possibility of two views on the subject cannot be a
ground for review.
(vii) The error apparent on the face of the record should not be an
error which has to be fished out and searched.
(viii) The appreciation of evidence on record is fully within the
domain of the appellate court, it cannot be permitted to be advanced in
the review petition.
(ix) Review is not maintainable when the same relief sought at the
time of arguing the main matter had been negatived.
14.
It is now settled law that scope of review as contemplated under
Order XLVII, Rule 1 of CPC is very limited and review must be confined
strictly to the grounds enumerated in the order itself. In other words, an
application for review only would lie if there is an error apparent on the face
of the records or any other sufficient reason and permitting the same would
cause
failure
of
justice.
There
cannot
be
re-hearing
of
the
petition/application/appeal, re-appraisal of findings or evidence on record.
15.
In the light of the aforesaid principle and the facts enumerated
here-in-above, which have been pleaded and submitted before this Court by
the review petitioner, I find the present review application is devoid of merit
being frivolous and has caused the sheer wastage of valuable time of this
Court. None of the above parameters has been fulfilled in this review petition.
16.
Accordingly, the review petition filed by the petitioners/ ONGCL
stands dismissed with a cost of Rs.1,00,000/- (Rupees one lakh) only . Out of
this Rs.1,00,000/-, Rs. 50,000/-(Rupees fifty thousand) shall be paid to the
Tripura State Legal Services Authority, Rs.25,000/-(Rupees twenty five
thousand) to the Tripura High Court Bar Association and the balance of
Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) shall be paid to the Dharmanagar
District Court Bar Association.
17.
The cost, thus imposed, shall be deposited to the said
organizations within a period of 7(seven) days from the date the review
petitioner/ONGCL shall receive a copy of this order.
Supply a copy of this order to the learned counsels of the parties
to the lis forthwith.
JUDGE
signed by SANJAY GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2023.10.03 17:29:57 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review