Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
$
"
!#
"
%%
& '
(
& '
(
)*
%%
)
*
Digitally signed
by LUCYGRACE
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
" #
$%&% '
(
%(
(
)
%
"
$
*% (
)
'! ', ('(%
(
+
-2-
)
)
-*
)
'! '& (' . & ( (' %
)
*
%'
" #
$%&% '
%*
$(
)
$
%
"
$
*% (
(
$%&% '
)
',
' ('(*
)
)
(+
-*
)
'! '& (' -
& ( (' %
)
-3-
)
,/
' ,&
' $
%' ''' $
(/
)
"
1232 4552463 472 478389: .;< .= <12 >;?:@29< 49?
4A47? ?4<2? '! '& (' - 89
.=
<12
??8<8.946
464C;74:8
298.7
. & ( (' % .9 <12 =862
8B86
;?:2
49?
466.A89: <12 D648@ 52<8<8.9 89 547<
. (' &!& (' - 83 =862? CE <12
93;749D2
)
.@549E
D146629:89: <12 684C868<E <. 54E <12 D.@52934<8.9 <. <12
D648@49<
49?
)
. ('
** (' &
=862?
CE
<12
D648@49< 322F89: 29149D2@29< .= D.@52934<8.9
(
).7 <12 34F2 .= D.9B29829D2 <12 547<823 A.;6?
C2 72=2772? 43 <12 D648@49< 49?
72352D<8B26E
93;749D2
.@549E
-4-
*
<
'& ', ('
2:9
<12
D432
.=
<12
D648@49<
<12 D648@49< A43 <74B26689: 89 4
.
$(
$
% =7.@
;92 46.9: A8<1 <12 :..?3
<14<
7;DF C24789:
434B4F46E49
49:64 <.
< 83 463. 3<4<2? <14<
D648@49< A43 <74B26689: 46.9: A8<1 127 3.9
.9
<12
4B4938??4554
< 83 463. 3<4<2? <14< <12 B218D62 89 G;23<8.9 @2< A8<1 49
4DD8?29< 47.;9? '* *' 4 @
46C.72
4DD8?29<
318=<2? <.
.68D2
.918
4<<4 .=
.98
<4<8.9 68@8<3 49? .9 4DD.;9< .= <12 348?
<12 D648@49< 143 3;3<4892? =4<46 89>;7823 49?
18B4@
.358<46 4<
49? <12724=<27 318=<2? <.
.918
46C.72 =.7 =873< 48?
;92 =.7 =;7<127 <724<@29<
< 83
<12 D432 .= <12 D648@49< <14< <12 4662:2? 4DD8?29< A43
.DD;772? .9 4DD.;9< .= <12 7431 49? 92:68:29D2 .9 <12
547< .= <12 ?78B27 .= <12 B218D62 89 G;23<8.9 49? 43 3;D1
<12 D648@49< 143 572=2772?
. & ( .= (' % 322F89:
D.@52934<8.9
93;749D2
327B8D2
.=
9.<8D2
7235.9?29<
. ($
.@549E 29<272? 45524749D2 49? =862? ?2<4862?
-5-
A78<<29 3<4<2@29<
?29E89: <12 4B27@29<3 @4?2 89 <12
D648@ 52<8<8.9
%
432? .9 <12 5624?89:3 .9 72D.7? <12
78C;946
=74@2? <12 833;23 =.7 8<3 D.938?274<8.9
,
9 .7?27 <. 23<4C6831 127 D432
<12 D648@49<
2H4@892? 127326= 43
49? <12 ?.D<.7 43
@47F2?
H3
, ?.D;@29<3 43
<.
,
. .746 2B8?29D2
A43 4??;D2? CE <12 7235.9?29<$ 93;749D2
1.A2B27
( 49? :.<
.@549E
@47F2? <12 D.5E .= <12 893;749D2 5.68DE 43
H
72D.7?
466.A2?
78C;946 4=<27 D.938?2789: <12 @4<27846 .9
CE 8<3 >;?:@29< 49? 4A47? ?4<2? '! '& (' <12
D648@
D.@52934<8.9 .=
52<8<8.9
547<
49?
4A47?2?
3 ' ,! ''' $ 46.9: A8<1 89<2723< 4< ,/
5 4 =7.@ <12 ?4<2 .= 52<8<8.9 <866 72468I4<8.9 49? ?872D<2?
7235.9?29<
. ($ 93;749D2
.@549E <. ?25.38< <12 348?
D.@52934<8.9 )22689: 4::782B2? CE <12 348? >;?:@29< 49?
4A47?
<12
93;749D2
.@549E
572=2772?
)
-6-
. (' &!& (' - G;23<8.989: <12 684C868<E =43<292? .9 8<
127243
. ('
<12
D648@49<
572=2772?
)
** (' & 322F89: 29149D2@29< .= D.@52934<8.9
&
14B2 1247?
45524789: =.7 <12
93;749D2
354668 624792? D.;9326
.@549E 49?
;C;
2<4:;??4 624792? D.;9326 45524789: =.7 <12 D648@49<
!
354668 624792? D.;9326 45524789: =.7
<12 93;749D2
.@549E CE 72=27789: <. <12 D.@56489< 4<
H ( 49? <12 D147:2 3122< 4< H3 * 49? * 4 D.9<29?2?
<14< <12 D648@49< 83 4 :74<;8<.;3 543329:27 89 <12 B218D62
89 G;23<8.9 49? <1272=.72 4A47?89: .= D.@52934<8.9 <. 4
:74<;8<.;3 543329:27 ?.23 9.< 47832 49? <1272=.72 3.;:1<
=.7 89<27=2729D2 .= <183
.;7< <. 2H.9274<2 <12 93;749D2
.@549E =7.@ <12 684C868<E <. 54E D.@52934<8.9 <. <12
D648@49<
'
27 D.9<74
4C;
D.;9326 45524789: =.7 <12 D648@49<
D7.33$2H4@894<8.9 .=
2<4:;??4
624792?
CE 72=27789: <. <12
3;C@8<<2? <14< 43 <12 D648@49<
-7-
143 318=<2? 127 1.;32 .9 4DD.;9< .= <12 C2724B2@29< 89
<12 =4@86E
312 D499.< C2 D.938?272? 43 4 :74<;8<.;3
543329:27
14< 4547< 624792? D.;9326 45524789: =.7 <12
D648@49< 564D23 726849D2 .9 <12 >;?:@29< .= <12
;572@2
.;7< 89 <12 D432 .=
!
##
"
.90C62
$%
%
?4<2?
"
- '- ('(%
49?
D.9<29<2? <14< <12 D432 .9 149? 83 =4876E D.B272? CE <12
>;?:@29< .= <12
.90C62
;572@2
.;7< 89 <12 4C.B2 D432
49? <1272=.72 3.;:1< =.7 ?83@83346 .= <12 455246 572=2772?
CE <12 93;749D2
.@549E
93.=47 43 <12 G;49<;@ .= D.@52934<8.9 83
D.9D2792? 8< 83 47:;2? CE <12 624792? D.;9326 45524789:
=.7 <12 D648@49< <14< <12 4A47? .= D.@52934<8.9 @4?2 .9
B478.;3 124?3 4< 5474:7451 (( .= <12 8@5;:92? >;?:@29<
CE <12
78C;946 72G;8723 <. C2 29149D2? 89 <183 455246
83 463. 47:;2? <14<
<12
<
78C;946 =4863 <. 4A47? <12
D.@52934<8.9 <.A47?3 6.33 .= 4@298<823 49? <1272=.72
3.;:1< =.7 89<27=2729D2 .= <183
.;7<
-8-
(
9 <12 68:1< .= <12 3;C@8338.93 @4?2 CE <12
624792? D.;9326 45524789: =.7 <12 547<823 49? .9 D472=;6
D.938?274<8.9 .= <12 @4<27846 .9 72D.7? 8< A.;6? 89?8D4<2
<14< <12 D648@49< A43 <74B26689: 89 4
.
$(
$
%
7;DF C24789:
2:9
< 83 463. =.7<1D.@89: =7.@ <12 D7.33$
2H4@894<8.9 .=
A18D1 724?3 43 ;9?27
!"# $ %"
"
&'
+, ( -
."# ,$
."# ,$
,
-
&4
$ %+6 *
;8
("
"
-
" %+6 *
<
+, (
- ( 5" % *
(
( &89
,
-
$
& "
:* 5$
1 !"
- < - = ! *5" & "
1 > ?@
'
3 *
" - ( 5"
: "
*("
/ 0 1 " 2 (
-
."# '
()
,"
/
/ '
-
%" 7
,"
$A
;9?276892? CE @2
*
27;346 .= <12 4=.72@29<8.92? ?25.38<8.9 .=
89 <12 D7.33$2H4@894<8.9 @4F23 8< D6247 <14< <12
D648@49< 46.9: A8<1 127 3.9 14B2 318=<2? <1287 1.;32 49?
A272 D477E89: <1287 :..?3 89 <12 B218D62 89 G;23<8.9
9 <183
-9-
72:47? .9 D472=;6 D.938?274<8.9 .= <12 A78<<29 3<4<2@29<
=862? CE <12
93;749D2
93;749D2
.@549E
8< 4552473 <14< <12
.@549E 143 9.< <4F29 4 352D8=8D 5624 <14< <12
D648@49< 83 4 :74<;8<.;3 543329:27 89 <12 B218D62 89
G;23<8.9
9 <14< B82A .= <12 @4<<27
4@ .= <12 B82A <14<
<12 =4D<;46 4352D<3 .9 72D.7? A.;6? D62476E 89?8D4<2 <14<
<12 D648@49< 83 9.< 4 :74<;8<.;3 543329:27
.9JC62
;572@2
;574 4< 5474:74513
"
)*
.;7<
<. , 126? 43 =.66.A3
!
+,
89 <12 D432 .=
& "'
(
-
!
&
. /
!
1 )*
,
"
-
- 10 -
"
#
$#
%
&
"
! "
(
'( ))*+ , !
.
/
7 4
"4
!
'(0110+ 0 -
0.*/
""
#
! ./
93 " 5
( 3
'(01 1+ -
8 3
%
<183
/
'(01 .+
/ )*
"
2 3
!
;
#
"
'(01 ,+ 0 -
.
!
'(011 + * -
'
:
(
-
)/
:
"
8 '
.)&/
:
!
+$2-4
##
9 B82A .= <12 D.9D6;38.9 46724?E 4778B2? 4< CE
.;7< <14< <12 D648@49< 83 9.< 4 :74<;8<.;3 543329:27
4@ .= <12 B82A <14< <12 G;23<8.9 .= 684C868<E 493A272?
- 11 -
CE <12
78C;946 83 >;3< 49? 57.527 A18D1 ?.23 9.< 72G;872
89<27=2729D2 CE <183
,
.;7<
93.=47
4A47?2? CE <12
<12
G;49<;@
78C;946 83 D.9D2792?
( @4F23 8< D6247 <14<
.=
D.@52934<8.9
<12 2B8?29D2 .=
<12 D648@49< 143 3;==272?
=74D<;72 .= 314=< .= 78:1< <8C84 49? =8C;64 8 2
4@5;<4<8.9
143 D4;32? 527@4929< ?834C62@29< <. <12 D648@49< 49? 8<
83 463. =.7<1D.@89: =7.@
H
9 <14< B82A .= <12
@4<<27 <4F89: 89<. D.938?274<8.9 <12 :;8?268923 648? ?.A9
CE <12
4794<4F4
<4<2
2:46
27B8D23
;<1.78<E 43 <. <12
89D.@2 .= <12 89>;72? =.7 <12 7262B49< 5278.? 8 2
83 <. C2
3 - %'' 527 @.9<1
3 <12 D648@49< A43 4:2?
E2473 <12 @;6<856827 .= K *J 4?.5<2? CE <12
49? 57.527
(
('
8<
-
78C;946 83 >;3<
4F89: 89<. D.938?274<8.9 <12 2B8?29D2 .=
A1. ?25.32? <14< <12 D648@49< 143 3;==272? <12
?834C868<E <. 49 2H<29< .= &'/
<12 ?834C868<E 83 <. C2
D.938?272? 4< &'/ );7<127 89 <27@3 .= <12 64A 648? ?.A9
CE <12
.9JC62
;572@2
3#
"
.;7< 89 <12 D432 .=
!3
:
- 12 -
725.7<2? 89 *
<,
<12
(%/
D648@49<
57.352D<3
1;3
D.938?2789: <12 4:2 .=
C2
4??2?
<.A47?3
=;<;72
<12 6.33 .= =;<;72 89D.@2 A.;6? C2
-' ''' $
-
<.
3 - %'' L (%/ H ( H * H &'/
E 6..F89: 89<. <12 89>;7E 3;3<4892? CE <12
D648@49< 312 @8:1< 9.< C2 4C62 <. ?. 49E A.7F 4<6243< =.7
4 5278.? .= <1722 @.9<13 49? 4DD.7?89:6E <12 D648@49< 83
29<8<62? =.7 4 3;@ .=
3 (( %'' $
3 - %'' H*
<.A47?3
6.33 .= 89D.@2 ?;789: 648? ;5 5278.?
&
.=
3*
78C;946 143 4557.5784<26E 4A47?2? 4 3;@
%'' $ <.A47?3 @2?8D46 2H529323 A18D1 922?3 9.
89<27=2729D2
!
D147:23
93.=47
<12
D.9D2792?
CE
4<<29?49<
49?
D.9B2E49D2
6..F89:
89<.
<12
89>;7823
3;3<4892? CE <12 D648@49< <12 D648@49< 83 29<8<62? =.7 4
3;@ .=
('
3 (% ''' $ ;9?27 <12 348? 124?
4B89: 4778B2? 4< 4 D.9D6;38.9 <14< <12 D648@49<
3;==272?
&'/
.=
?834C868<E
.9
4DD.;9<
.=
<12
- 13 -
4@5;<4<8.9 <12 D.@52934<8.9 <.A47?3 5489 49? 3;==2789:
A.;6? C2
(
%' ''' $
);7<127 <12 D648@49< 83 29<8<62? =.7 4 3;@ .=
'' ''' $ <.A47?3 6.33 .= 4@298<823
((
29D2 <12 D648@49< 83 29<8<62? =.7 <12 @.?8=82?
D.@52934<8.9 ;9?27 ?8==2729< 124?3 43 C26.A
489 49? 3;==2789:
2?8D46 2H529323
.33 .= =;<;72 89D.@2
<<29?49< 49? D.9B2E49D2 D147:23
.33 .= 4@298<823
.33 .= 89D.@2 ?;789: 648? ;5 5278.?
.<46
3 %' ''' $
3 * %'' $
-' ''' $
3 (% ''' $
3 '' ''' $
3 (( %'' $
+ ,# #
)
1;3 <12 D64@49< 83 29<8<62? =.7 <.<46 D.@52934<8.9
.=
3 % '( ''' $ A8<1 89<2723< 4< ,/ 527 499;@
(*
93;749D2
4B89:
4778B2?
4<
D.9D6;38.9
<14<
<12
.@549E 143 =4862? <. 57.B2 <12 4352D<3 43 <.
<12 D648@49< 83 4 :74<;8<.;3 543329:27 89 <12 B218D62 89
G;23<8.9
)
. (' &!& (' - =862? CE <12
93;749D2
.@549E 83 684C62 <. C2 ?83@8332? 49? 4DD.7?89:6E
)
- 14 -
. ('
** (' & =862? CE <12 D648@49< ?2327B23 <. C2
466.A2? 89 547<
(
9 <12 723;6< <12 =.66.A89: .7?27 83 54332?
)
. ('
** (' & =862? CE <12 D648@49< 83
466.A2? 89 547<
.=
12 D648@49< 83 29<8<62? =.7 <.<46 D.@52934<8.9
3 % '( ''' $ A8<1 89<2723< 4< ,/ 527 499;@ =7.@ <12
?4<2 .= 52<8<8.9 <866 72468I4<8.9 43 4:4893<
4A47?2? CE <12 78C;946
.;7< ?4<2? (( '! ('(%
. ('
' ,! ''' $
.A2B27 43 527 <12 .7?27 .= <183
<12 D648@49< 45526649< 89
)
** (' & 83 9.< 29<8<62? =.7 89<2723< =.7 <12 ?264E2?
5278.? .= ( % ?4E3 89 =8689: <12 455246
235.9?29<
. ($ 93;749D2
.@549E
?872D<2? <. ?25.38< <12 29<872 D.@52934<8.9 A8<189 38H
A22F3 =7.@ <12 ?4<2 .= 72D285< .= 4 D27<8=82? D.5E .= <183
>;?:@29<
8B
.932G;29<6E
<12 93;749D2
)
. (' &!& (' - =862? CE
.@549E 83 ?83@8332?
- 15 -
B
12 4@.;9< 89 ?25.38< @4?2 CE <12 93;749D2
.@549E C2=.72 <183
.;7< 8= 49E C2 <7493@8<<2? <. <12
78C;946 =.7 ?83C;732@29<
-)
&
(
"
83<
.
.
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review