Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010688612010
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench Sr.No:-3
[3584]
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL
NO: 1913 of 2010
The New India Assurance Company Ltd.
Vs.
Dasari Anuradha and Others
Advocate for Appellant:
...Appellant
...Respondent(s)
**********
GANESH PALADUGU
Advocate(s) for Respondent(s): SIVA RAMA KRISHNA KOLLURU
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 1st July 2026
JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
This appeal is preferred by appellant/Insurer under Section
173 of M.V. Act, assailing the judgment and order dated
24.02.2010 in M.V.O.P. No.424 of 2004, passed by learned
II Additional District
Judge,
Visakhapatnam,
by
which
the
compensation for a sum of ₹41,00,000/- came to be awarded with
proportionate costs and interest thereon @7.5% from the date of
petition till the date of judgment.
2.
For convenience sake, the parties will hereinafter be
referred to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal.
3.
Facts leading to filing of present appeal are as follows:
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
(a)
One Mr.Dasari Pardhasaradhi, along with his friend
Joginaidu and relative Sai Surendra were proceeding in Maruthi
Van from Lankelapalem to Scindia for the purpose of distributing
wedding invitations of his brother. They were also accompanied
by Mr.Gururam Maheswararao and Saradi Satyanandarao, in
another car following them behind. On 29.03.2002, at about 04.00
p.m., upon reaching Ramakrishnapuram Junction, gas tanker
bearing number AP 16X 3649, which was proceeding in front of
their car, had suddenly stopped on the road without following
traffic rules. Resultantly, the Maruti Van, which was behind the
gas tanker and being driven by Mr.Dasari Pardhasaradhi (herein
after, referred to as ‘deceased’) dashed against the tanker and
thereby both the deceased as well as one of his friends, due to
severe injuries, succumbed thereto on the spot. Sai Surendra
sustained injuries and was shifted to hospital for treatment.
(b)
Mr. Gurram Maheswararao, who was following them in
another vehicle, immediately lodged a report before concerned
police and Crime No.39 of 2002 came to be registered for
offences under Sections 304-A and 338 of IPC against the driver
of the tanker. The police, upon investigation of the case, have
eventually filed charge sheet against the driver of the tanker.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
(c)
The deceased studied B.E. Mechanical Engineering and
underwent Marine Engineering apprenticeship and worked as
Marine Engineer for some time at Bombay.
At the time of
accident, he was working as Engineer in a shipping company
namely Anglo Eastern Management Limited, Hong Kong and was
earning about $2428, equivalent to ₹1,09,260/-.
(d)
At the time of accident, the deceased was aged about 33
years and was survived by wife and minor son. Deceased's wife,
minor son, father and mother approached the Tribunal seeking
compensation for a sum of ₹1,01,88,4000/-.
(e)
Driver and owner of the tanker involved in accident, who
were arrayed as respondents 1 and 2 remained ex parte. The
insurer of tanker / 3rd respondent filed counter opposing the claim.
(f)
It was pleaded firstly that even deceased himself
contributed to the alleged accident as he had driven Maruti Van in
a rash and negligent manner and thereby dashed into the tanker
which was proceeding in front of the car. That apart, the income
of deceased and age have also come to be denied and disputed.
(g)
Further, it is also pleaded that as deceased claimed to be
working for foreign company which was on contractual basis, the
sum claimed was clearly unsubstantiated and exorbitant.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
(h)
Based on the aforesaid pleadings, the Tribunal has framed
following issues:
1. Whether the accident occurred on account of the rash and
negligent driving of the vehicle by its driver and whether it
resulted in death of the victim?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled for the compensation? If
so, to what amount?
3. Which of the respondents are
liable to pay the
compensation?
4. To what relief?
(i)
In support of the case, claimants have examined P.W.1 to
P.W.6 and got marked Exs.A1 to A32 and X1. On the other hand,
3rd respondent – Insurer examined R.W.1 to R.W.3 and got
marked Exs.B1 to B4.
(j)
The
Tribunal,
upon appreciation of
both oral
and
documentary evidence, has come to conclusion that the accident
has occurred on account of the rash and negligent driving of the
driver of gas tanker and that there was no negligence on the part
of the deceased. Further, it was also held that the driver of tanker
had valid driving license at the time of accident and therefore
there was no violation of terms and conditions of policy for
denying the liability.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
(k)
Finally coming to the aspect of quantum of compensation,
upon appreciation of evidence on record has considered and
fixed the monthly salary of deceased as ₹30,000/- and after
deducting 1/3rd of it towards personal expenses and taking age of
deceased as 33 years, adopted multiplier of 17 and ultimately
determined loss of earnings for ₹40,80,000/-. Further, the Tribunal
has awarded ₹15,000/- towards loss of estate in favour of
1st claimant and ₹5,000/- towards funeral expenses and thereby
in total awarded compensation of ₹41,10,000/- along with interest
@7.5% from the date of petition till the date of award. The
respondents were held to be jointly and severally liable to pay
aforesaid compensation. Of which, the 1st claimant – wife was
held to be entitled to ₹20,00,000/- and 2nd claimant – minor son
for ₹16,10,000/-, towards their share of compensation and 3rd and
4th claimants, parents of the deceased, were apportioned
₹2,50,000/- each.
(l)
Assailing the award, insurer has preferred present appeal.
4.
Heard Sri Ganesh Paladugu, learned counsel for appellant
and Sri Siva Rama Krishna Kolluru, learned counsel for
respondents.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
5.
Learned counsel for appellant mainly contended that the
findings of the Tribunal in holding that there was no contributory
negligence on the part of deceased is contrary to material
evidence on record and thus the same suffers from perversity.
Elaborating, he would contend that even as per the evidence of
P.W.3 and P.W.4, who were eye witnesses to the incident, the
Maruthi Van driven by deceased has dashed into gas tanker from
behind, which itself clearly goes to suggest that the deceased
himself was self-negligent in causing the accident. Therefore, the
Tribunal ought not to have held that it was the driver of gas
tanker, who alone was negligent in causing the accident. Except
for the above, no other grounds have been urged challenging the
quantum of compensation determined.
6.
(a)
Learned counsel for respondents/claimants, on the
other hand, tried to support the order of Tribunal to the extent of
findings, which held that there was no contributory negligence
attributable to the deceased and that the driver of tanker alone
was responsible for causing the accident. However, with respect
to the quantum of compensation, he contends that inasmuch as
there were 4 claimants, the Tribunal ought not have deducted
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
1/3rd towards personal expenses rather made deduction of 1/4th.
Further, the Tribunal has also not awarded future prospects.
(b)
Insofar as the income of deceased, learned counsel tried to
persuade this Court that the amount of ₹30,000/- as determined
by the Tribunal is far less and that there is no basis for the
Tribunal to arrive at such meagre amount when the income has
been clearly established to be ₹1,09,260/- under Ex.A5 - salary
certificate, as corroborated by PW2 - Chief Engineer, who was
working in Anglo Eastern shipping company. Therefore, he would
urge that the compensation be appropriately modified taking into
consideration the income as demonstrated under Ex.A5 and by
making appropriate deduction of 1/4th of the same towards
personal expenses, besides granting future prospects and other
statutory benefits such as consortium etc., following the ratio laid
down by Hon'ble Apex Court in National Insurance Company
Limited v. Pranay Sethi and others1.
(c)
He also contented that respondent/claimants have not
preferred
independent
appeal
seeking
enhancement
of
compensation nor filed cross objections to the appeal preferred
by insurer, however, by placing reliance on judgment of
(2017) 16 SCC 680
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
co-ordinate bench of this Court in The National Insurance
Company Limited v. E.Suseelamma and others 2, would urge
this Court to determine just and fair compensation accordingly.
7.
We have considered respective submissions made by
respective counsels and also gone through the material on
record.
8.
The following points arise for our consideration:
“1. Whether the Tribunal was right in holding that there was
no contributory negligence on the part of the deceased
and thereby, fixing entire liability on the insurer alone and
whether the Tribunal
has awarded just and fair
compensation to the claimants/respondents in the light of
the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the
parties?
2. To what relief?”
9.
The Tribunal, on appreciation of evidence, in particular, the
eye witnesses to the accident i.e., P.W.3 and P.W.4, coupled with
documentary evidence i.e., FIR – Ex.A1 and charge sheet –
Ex.A30, has come to conclusion that the accident has occurred
on account of negligence of driver of gas tanker alone and the
deceased had no role in the process. The Tribunal also has found
that in absence of any rebuttal evidence, in particular the driver of
MANU/AP/1282/2023
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
gas tanker, who is best witness to speak of the manner in which
accident has occurred, discredited the plea of contributory
negligence as set up by the insurer. The witnesses of Insurer, i.e.,
R.W.1 to R.W.3, who are Motor Vehicle Inspector and
Administrative Officer, since were found to be not trustworthy
witnesses to speak of the manner in which accident has occurred,
the Tribunal has come to conclusion that there was absolutely no
rebuttal evidence on aforesaid issue. The finding of Tribunal with
regard to the aspect of negligence of the driver of tanker in
causing the accident, in our opinion, is appropriate. In the
absence of any other rebuttal evidence from the insurer, there is
no reason for us to disbelieve the version of claimants/witnesses
as rightly appreciated by the Tribunal. This issue, therefore, is
answered against the insurer.
10.
In E.Suseelamma’s case2, the Coordinate Bench of this
Court, after analyzing various precedents on the subject,
ultimately held that claimants/respondents are entitled for just
compensation and the appellate court can always enhance the
amount of compensation even in the absence of appeal or cross
objections by such claimants.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
11.
Following the aforesaid view so expressed, we now
proceed to examine the merits or otherwise of the quantum of
compensation.
12.
Learned counsel for respondents/claimants has taken us
through the evidence of P.W.2 and Ex.A5 to buttress that the
salary of ₹30,000/- as determined by Tribunal is far less and
rather
the
salary
ought
to
have
been
determined
in
commensurate with the evidence available on record. Dealing
with the aforesaid aspect, the Tribunal upon appreciation of the
evidence of P.W.2 and also the salary certificate marked under
Ex.A5 has found that the deceased was not on permanent job,
rather he was on contract basis working with a private company
with a duration of 8 months in a year. Considering his
engagement in overseas and vis-à-vis salary, the Tribunal has
ultimately fixed his earnings reasonably at ₹30,000/- per month. It
is also found that since the employment was not on permanent
basis and there was no certainty of further engagement, the
salary came to be reasonably assessed as above. We, therefore,
do not intend to substitute with any other view than the one
arrived at by the Tribunal, since the same is found to be
reasonably fixed. However, as rightly contended by learned
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
counsel for claimants, the Tribunal has applied deduction of 1/3rd
rather 1/4th towards personal expenses and ignored to grant
future prospects. The Tribunal has also committed error in
applying multiplier of 17 rather than it ought to have applied
multiplier of 16 following the dicta laid down by Apex Court in
Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation 3. We therefore
modify the award in the following terms:
Compensation
Heads
Monthly Income
Yearly Income
Future Prospects
(Age being 33 years)
Deduction (1/4)
Multiplier (16)
Loss of Income of the
deceased
Loss of Estate
Loss of Funeral
Expenses
Loss of Consortium
(2009) 6 SCC 121
In Accordance
with:
Amount Awarded
₹30,000/₹3,60,000/40% of ₹3,60,000/- =
₹1,44,000/5,04,000 – 1,26,000 =
₹3,78,000/3,78,000 x 16 =
₹60,48,000/-
National Insurance
Co. Ltd. V. Pranay
Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Para 37, 39, 41, 42
and 59.4
₹60,48,000/₹18,150/(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
₹18,150/(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
48,400 x 4 = ₹1,93,600/(with 10% increase every
3 years from 2017)
National Insurance
Co. Ltd. V. Pranay
Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680
Para 37, 39, 41, 42
and 59.4
United India
Insurance Co. Ltd.
V. Satinder Kaur,
(2021) 11 SCC 780
Para 37.12
Rajwati alias Rajjo
and Ors v. United
India Insurance
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
Company Ltd. and
Ors.
2022 SCC OnLine
SC 1699
Para 34
Sadhana Tomar &
Ors. Ashok
Khushwaha & Ors.
2025 SCC OnLine
SC 554
Para 17
₹62,77,900/-
Total
13.
In the result, MACMA filed by the insurer is dismissed,
however, compensation is enhanced over and above granted by
the Tribunal to the claimants as just and fair compensation in the
following terms:
i)
The
claimants/respondents
are
granted
enhanced
compensation of ₹62,77,900/- as just and fair, with interest
@ 7.5% per annum thereon from the date of claim petition
till realization;
ii)
Out
of
the
enhanced
compensation
amount,
1st petitioner/wife of the deceased is entitled to a sum of
₹30,00,000/-, 2nd petitioner/son of deceased is entitled to a
sum of ₹25,00,000/- and 3rd and 4th petitioners/father and
mother of deceased are entitled to a sum of ₹3,88,950/each.
HCJ & CGR, J
MACMA No.1913 of 2010
iii)
The appellant to deposit the amount as aforesaid with
interest
and
costs,
adjusting
the
amount
already
deposited/paid if any, before the Tribunal within one month.
iv)
On such deposit being made, the claimants shall be entitled
to withdraw the same in the proportion as per the award,
failing which, the amount shall be recovered as per law.
14.
With the above observations, the present appeal stands
disposed of. No costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending in this case, if
any, shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J
ss
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review