Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010690232022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
THURSDAY, THE 10th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 551/2022
Between:
1. THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REPRESENTED
BY
ITS
DIVISIONAL
MANAGER,
DIVISIONAL
OFFICE,
GOVERNMENT ARTS COLLEGE ROAD, SRIKAKULAM TOWN,
POST, MANDAL AND DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH STATE, PIN 532001.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. SMT EMIRISETTY RATNALU RATNALAMMA, W/O LATE APPARAO,
AGED 52 YEARS,HINDU, HOUSEHOLD DUTIES, RESIDENT OF
HOUSE NO.1-13-A, C/O SHARIFA BEGUM, AYYAPPA SOCIETY,
MADHAPUR,
SERILINGAMPALLY, HYDERABAD,
TELANGANA
STATE, PIN NO.500 081 (AADHAAR NO.9723 9611 6961)
2. EMIRISETTY VEERANCHI, S/O LATE APPA RAO, AGED 31 YEARS,
HINDU, PRIVATE EMPLOYEE, RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO.1-13-A,
C/O SHARIFA BEGUM,
AYYAPPA SOCIETY, MADHAPUR,
SERILINGAMPALLY, HYDERABAD,
TELANGANA STATE, PIN
NO.500 081 (AADHAAR NO.9007 8354 6921)
3. SMT MALI ANNAPURNA, W/O PRADEEP MALI, D/O EMIRISETTY
LATE APPA RAO, AGED 34 YEARS, HINDU, HOUSEHOLD DUTIES,
C/10, BANJARA SAMAN APPARTMENTS, ROAD NO.12, OPPOSITE
TO STATE BANK OF INDIA, BANJARA HILLS, KHAIRATABAD,
HYDERABAD, TELANGANA STATE, PIN NO.500 034 (AADHAAR
NO.7395 1933 3088).
4. KUNA RAVI KUMAR, S/O LATE KRISHNA RAO, AGED 48 YEARS,
HINDU, KALINGA BY CASTE, FORMER M.L.A., AND FORMOER
GOVERNMENT WHIP, R/AT SANTHINAGAR COLONY, BEHIND
GOVERNMENT ARTS COLLEGE, SRIKAKULAM TOWN, POST,
MANDAL ANDDISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH STATE, PIN NO.532
001, OWNER OF LORRY (TIPPER) BEARING REGISTRATION
NO.AP 30 U 1706.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC before the High Courtmemorandum
of appeal being aggrieved by the decree and judgment passed in
M.V.O.P.No.263 OF 2018, dated 15-03-2022, on the file of Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal -cum- The Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum1 st Additional District Judge, SRIKAKULAM
IA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to condone the delay of 183 days in filing the appeal against
M.V.O.P.No.263 OF 2018, dated 15-03-2022 on the file of Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal -Cum- The Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum1 st Additional District Judge, SRIKAKULAM and to pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to stay of operation of the Judgment and Decree made in
M.V.O.P.No.263 OF 2018 dated15- 03-2022 on the file of The Chairman,
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum- 1 st Additional District Judge,
SRIKAKULAM pending disposal of the above appeal in the interest of justice
pending disposal of the above appeal in the interest of justice and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2023
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to receive the Mentioned documents as additional evidence in
MVOP.No.263 of 2018 on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal - cum The Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal - Cum - 1st Additional District
Judge, Srikakulam
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. AMANCHARLA SATISH BABU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. ARAVALA RAMA RAO
2. VARUN BYREDDY
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 551/2022
JUDGMENT:
The New India Assurance Company Limited filed the present appeal
against the order and decree dated 15.03.2022 passed in M.V.O.P.No.263 of
2018 by the Chairman, Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-I Additional
District Judge, Srikakulam, whereby and whereunder the Tribunal granted
total claim amount of Rs.8,00,000/- (Rupees Eight Lakhs only) as against the
claim of Rs.8,00,000/- towards compensation, on account of the death of the
deceased Emirisetty Apparao, in a motor accident that occurred on
20.02.2005.
2.
Appellant is the insurer. Respondent Nos.1 to 3 herein are the
claimants/petitioners. Respondent No.4 herein is the owner of the driver of the
offending vehicle.
3.
For the purpose of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they
are arrayed before the Tribunal.
4.
The case of the claimants, in brief, is that on 20.02.2005 at about 8.00
p.m., the deceased, Emirisetty Apparao, was returning to his home on his
Kinetic King motorcycle bearing No.AP 30 C 9160, with one Bugatha
Venkateswara Rao travelling as pillion rider. When they reached Challapeta
Junction on B.T. Road, within the limits of Gara Mandal, Srikakulam District, a
Tipper Lorry bearing No.AP 30 U 1706, coming from the opposite direction,
was driven by its driver, Tarra Bodenna, in a rash and negligent manner and
hit the motorcycle. As a result of the accident, the deceased died on the spot,
while the pillion rider, Bugatha Venkateswara Rao, succumbed to his injuries
at the Government Hospital, Srikakulam, on the same day. One Simma Rama
Mohan Rao, the then Panchayat Secretary, Ampolu, Gara Mandal, lodged a
report before the Sub-Inspector of Police, Gara Police Station. On the basis of
the said report, Crime No.12 of 2005 was registered against the driver of the
offending Tipper Lorry for the offence punishable under Section 304-A of the
Indian Penal Code. After investigation, the police filed a charge-sheet before
the learned Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Srikakulam, against Tarra
Bodenna, alleging that his rash and negligent driving was responsible for the
accident and the resultant deaths. It is the further case of the claimants that
the deceased was aged about 40 years at the time of the accident, was hale
and healthy and had been carrying on fruit business for about 12 years prior to
his death.
5.
Respondent No.1/ owner of the offending vehicle filed his counter
denying the material allegations of the claim petition and further contended
that the deceased was not wearing a helmet and was not possessing a valid
driving license. It was further alleged that the deceased was riding the
motorcycle at high speed and in a negligent manner and might have dashed
against a stone, resulting in the accident. It was also contended that the
offending Tipper Lorry bearing No.AP 30 U 1706, an Ashok Leyland heavy
goods vehicle of 2004 model, was being driven in accordance with the Motor
Vehicles Rules and had not been involved in any mishap. The owner further
contended that the claim petition was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties
and that the claimants had failed to produce the registration certificate,
insurance particulars, fitness certificate and other relevant documents relating
to the motorcycle. A further objection was raised regarding the maintainability
of the claim petition on the ground that the claimants had earlier filed
M.A.C.No.25 of 2006 before the District Judge-cum-I Additional Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, Gajapati, Parlakhemundi, Odisha, claiming
compensation of Rs.5,00,000/-. According to the owner, the said proceedings
were subsequently dismissed and the claimants, after pursuing restoration
proceedings, filed a memo seeking withdrawal of the matter on 27.12.2017. It
was therefore contended that the subsequent claim petition filed before the
Tribunal at Srikakulam, arising out of the same accident and cause of action,
was barred by the principles of res judicata, Order II Rule 2 and Order XXIII of
the Code of Civil Procedure. It was accordingly prayed that the claim petition
be dismissed.
6.
The insurance company filed its counter denying the material
allegations of the claim petition and also contended that the accident occurred
due to the negligence of the deceased himself and, therefore, the deceased
was a tort-feasor and the claimants were not entitled to compensation from
the insurer. The insurer initially stated that it was not in a position to admit the
existence of a valid policy covering the offending vehicle unless the claimants
furnished the necessary particulars and the owner produced the policy. It was
further contended that the insured had failed to comply with the statutory
obligations under Section 134(c) of the Motor Vehicles Act and that the
concerned police authorities had also failed to forward the relevant documents
to the insurer as contemplated under Section 158(6) of the Motor Vehicles
Act. The insurer disputed the income and dependency pleaded by the
claimants and contended that the alleged monthly income of Rs.10,000/- was
not supported by documentary evidence. It was also contended that the
claimants were required to establish their status as legal representatives and
dependants of the deceased. The insurer further pleaded that the driver of the
offending vehicle did not possess a valid and effective driving licence as on
the date of the accident and that the owner had thereby committed a wilful
breach of the terms and conditions of the insurance policy. The insurer
consequently claimed protection under Sections 147, 149, 158(6) and 170 of
the Motor Vehicles Act and Section 64VB of the Insurance Act. It was finally
contended that, in any event, the compensation claimed was excessive and
that the insurer's liability, if any, was subject to the terms and conditions of the
insurance policy and the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act.
7.
Basing on the above pleadings, the following issues were settled for
trial:
1. Whether the deceased/Emirisetty Apparao, S/o late Latchanna
died on 20.02.2005 at about 8 P.M., on G.T.Road, Challapeta
junction, Gara mandal due to rash and negligent driving of Tarra
Bodenna who was the driver at the time of accident and who
worked under Respondent No.1-owner of Lorry (tipper) bearing
No.AP 30 U 1706 ?
2. Whether the petitioners are entitled to claim any compensation
for the death of the deceased/Emirisetty Apparao, S/o late
Latchanna, If so, to what amount and from which of the
respondents 1 & 2 ?
3. Whether this petition is bad for non-joinder of necessary party ?
4. To what relief?
8.
During the course of trial, on behalf of the petitioners, the 1st petitioner /
wife of the deceased herself is examined as p.W.1 and got examined one
Surala Paparao, as P.W.2 and got marked Exs.A-1 to A-5. On behalf of the
respondents, Legal Officer of respondent No.2/Insurance Company was
examined as R.W.1 and one S.Chinnammadu, Junior Assistant, RTO office,
examined as R.W.2 and got marked Exs.B.1 and Exs.X-1 to X-5.
9.
After hearing both parties and after considering the oral and
documentary evidence on record, the Tribunal allowed the claim petition by
awarding total claim of Rs.8,00,000/- towards compensation at the rate of 9%
per annum from the date of petition till the date of realization against the
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2. The 2nd respondent / Insurance Company is
directed to deposit the above compensation amount with interest and costs
within two months from the date of this order.
10.
Aggrieved by the said award, the respondent No.2/insurer preferred this
appeal contending that the Tribunal failed to appreciate the earlier litigation
initiated by the claimants before the competent Tribunal in Odisha. It is
submitted that the claimants had earlier filed M.A.C.No.25 of 2006 before the
District Judge-cum-I Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Gajapati,
Parlakhemundi, claiming compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- arising out of the very
same accident. The said proceedings were ultimately not pursued and a NIL
award came to be passed. Though the claimants preferred restoration
proceedings, they subsequently filed a memo seeking withdrawal of the matter
on 27.12.2017. According to the learned counsel, the subsequent filing of
M.V.O.P.No.263 of 2018 before the Tribunal at Srikakulam, on the same
cause of action, amounted to an abuse of the process of law and was barred
by the principles of res judicata and limitation. It is further contended that the
Tribunal failed to properly appreciate the evidence of R.Ws.1 and 2 and
Exs.X-1 to X-5 and, therefore, the award is liable to be set aside.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel for the claimants supported the order of the
Tribunal. It was contended that the earlier proceedings had not culminated in
an adjudication of the claim on merits and, therefore, the principles of res
judicata would have no application. Reliance was placed upon the judgment in
Jagdish v. Rahul Bus Service and Others1, wherein the relevant principles
relating to res judicata and dismissal of proceedings without adjudication on
merits were considered.
12.
Now the point for consideration is:
Whether the order of the Tribunal needs any interference?
2015 SCC OnLine HP 1137
POINT:
13.
The principal issue raised by the appellant is that the claim petition filed
before the Tribunal at Srikakulam was not maintainable in view of the earlier
proceedings initiated by the claimants before the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal at Gajapati, Parlakhemundi, Odisha. The record discloses that the
claimants had earlier instituted M.A.C.No.25 of 2006 claiming compensation in
respect of the very same accident. The said proceedings were not adjudicated
on merits. The subsequent restoration proceedings culminated in restoration
of the earlier proceedings, but ultimately the claimants filed a memo stating
that they did not wish to prosecute the matter, and the proceedings were
closed. The doctrine of res judicata is founded upon the principle that a matter
which has already been finally adjudicated by a competent court should not be
permitted to be reopened between the same parties. A necessary ingredient
for application of the doctrine is, however, a prior adjudication of the matter in
issue on merits.
14.
In Jagdish v. Rahul Bus Service and Others, the Himachal Pradesh
High Court, after considering the relevant precedents, observed that dismissal
of proceedings for default, without adjudication of the rights of the parties,
does not ordinarily amount to an adjudication on merits so as to operate as
res judicata. The said judgment also considered the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Sheodan Singh v. Daryao Kunwar, reported in AIR 1966 SC
1332, as well as the judgment in Erach Boman Khavar v. Tukaram Shridhar
Bhat and Another, wherein it was reiterated that, for attracting the doctrine of
res judicata, there must be a conscious adjudication of the issue and an
expression of opinion on the merits.
15.
In the present case, there is no material before this Court to establish
that the earlier claim petition was finally adjudicated on merits after
consideration of the evidence relating to the accident, negligence and
entitlement to compensation. On the contrary, the material on record indicates
that the earlier proceedings were not prosecuted to a decision on merits.
Therefore, merely because the claimants had earlier instituted proceedings
arising out of the same accident, the subsequent claim petition cannot, in the
facts of the present case, be rejected solely on the ground of res judicata.
16.
Coming to the issue Nos.1, it can be observed that the 1st claimant who
is the wife of the deceased got examined herself as P.W.1 and she deposed
with regard to the nature of the accident and categorically deposed that the
claimant/ deceased husband used to do seasonal fruit business by taking
topes on lease basis for a continuous period of 3 to 5 years in and around
Srikakulam by residing in Nizamabad village of Gara Mandal and in that
process, the deceased husband used to engage labour to lookafter the crop
and after collection of crop, he used to export the same to Visakhapatnam
also. On 20.02.2005 she came to know that while returning to his home the
deceased allowed one Bugatha Venkateswara Rao as pillion rider on his
motor cycle and when reached Challapeta junction of Gara Mandal at about
20.00 hours, a Tipper lorry bearing No.AP 30 U 1706 which is coming from
opposite direction driven by one Tarra Bodenna in a rash and negligent
manner hit the passing motor cycle because of which, he died on the spot and
the pillion rider was succumbed to injuries in the Government hospital,
Srikakulam on the same day. Basing on the report given by the then
Panchayat secretary, Ampolu, Gara Mandal, Sub Inspector of Police, Gara
Police Station registered the same as a case in Crime No.12/2005 for the
offence under Section 304-A of IPC against the driver of the Tipper Lorry
bearing No.AP 30 U 1706.
17.
In support of her case, she got marked Exs.A-1 to A-5. Further, she got
examined P.W.2 who is an eye witness to the accident. P.W.2 categorically
deposed that due to rash and negligent driving of the Tipper lorry, the accident
occurred on 20.02.2005 at 20.00 hours in which both the rider and pillion rider
of motor cycle died when the tipper lorry hit the motor cycle on the opposite
direction. Considering the evidence of P.Ws.1 and 2 coupled with Exs.A-1 and
A-5- certified copy of the charge sheet in Cr.No.101 of 2005 on the file of the
Court of Judicial First Class Magistrate, Srikakulam, which is filed against the
driver of the Tipper lorry bearing No. AP 30 U 1706, the Tribunal answered the
issue No.1 in favour of the claimants holding that the accident occurred due to
rash and negligent driving of the driver of Tipper lorry bearing No.AP 30 U
1706 i.e., the 1st respondent, which in the opinion of this Court, needs no
interference and hold good.
18.
Coming to the quantum, The Tribunal assessed the income of the
deceased at Rs.6,000/- per month, taking his daily income at Rs.200/-.
However, there is no documentary evidence establishing that the deceased
was earning Rs.10,000/- per month as pleaded by the claimants. The accident
occurred on 20.02.2005. In the absence of reliable documentary evidence
regarding the actual income of the deceased, the income has to be assessed
on a reasonable basis having regard to the period of the accident and the
material available on record. The learned counsel for the insurer rightly
contended that, in the absence of proof of income, the minimum wages
applicable at the relevant time ought to be taken into consideration. The
record discloses the minimum wage applicable to an unskilled worker as
Rs.114.87 per day, which may be rounded off to Rs.115/- per day.
Accordingly, the monthly income of the deceased is taken at Rs.3,450/(Rs.115/- × 30).
19.
As the deceased was aged 40 years as on the date of accident, he is
entitled for an additional amount of 40% of his income towards his future
prospects as held by the Apex Court in “National Insurance Company Vs.
Pranay Sethi2”, as such the future prospects of the deceased would come to
Rs.4,830/- (Rs.3450 + Rs.1830). As there are three dependants in the present
case, 1/3rd should be deducted towards personal and living expenses. After
deducting 1/3rd, the earnings of the deceased would come to Rs.3,220/(Rs.4,830 – 1,610). After applying the appropriate multiplier i.e. „15‟ for the
age group of 35 to 40 years, as per the decision of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in
2018 ACJ 2782
“Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation3”, the loss of dependency
would come to Rs.5,79,600/- (Rs.3220 x 12 x 15).
20.
Apart from the same, the claimants are also entitled to Rs.15,000/-
under the head of loss of estate, Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses and
the 1st claimant is entitled to Rs.40,000/- towards consortium, which in the
opinion of this Court, needs no interference.
21.
In view of the same, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal under
different heads and the amounts awarded by this Court are as follows:
Sl.
No.
Head of the claim
1.
2.
Loss of dependency
Towards
consortium
(wife)
Loss of estate
Towards
funeral
expenses
Towards loss of estate
Total
3.
3.
4.
Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal
in Rs. Ps.
9,00,000-00
40,000-00
Amounts now
awarded by this
Court
Rs. Ps.
5,79.600-00
40,000-00
15,000-00
15,000-00
15,000-00
15,000-00
9,70,000-00
15,000-00
6,49,600-00
(since the claim of the
claimants is Rs.8.00
lakhs, the
compensation
awarded is restricted
to that amount only)
22.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the finding of the Tribunal regarding
the occurrence of the accident due to the rash and negligent driving of the
driver of Tipper Lorry bearing No.AP 30 U 1706 is affirmed. The finding that
the earlier proceedings bar the present claim on the principle of res judicata is
rejected, as the earlier proceedings did not culminate in an adjudication on
2009 ACJ 1298
merits. However, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is found to be
excessive and is accordingly re-determined at Rs.6,49,600/-.
23.
In the result, the Motor Accidents Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is partly
allowed to the extent of reducing the compensation from Rs.8,00,000/- to
Rs.6,49,600/- (Rupees Six Lakhs Forty-Nine Thousand Six Hundred only).
The compensation amount shall be apportioned among the claimants in the
same manner and ratio as ordered by the Tribunal. There shall be no order as
to costs in the appeal.
As a sequel, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, in this case,
shall stand closed.
__________________
JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
Dated 10.09.2026
KA
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 551/2022
Dated 10.09.2026
KA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review