Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for Judgment :05.12.2025
Date of Pronouncement
:03.03.2026
Date of uploading
:03.03.2026
APHC010729612012
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3520]
TUESDAY,THE THIRD DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 4221/2012
Between:
1. THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, KADAPA., REP.BY
ITS DIVISIONAL MANAGER, DIVISIONAL OFFICE, NAGARAJUPETA,
KADAPA.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. MANJULA VIJAYA KUMARI AND 5 OTHERS, W/O SRINIVASULU
HOUSE WIFE R/OSETTYVARIPALLI VILLAGE, MUDDANUR MANDAL.
NOW R/O D.NO.9/247-A,
2. MANJULA VENKATA DILIP KUMAR, S/O SRINIVASULU MINOR,
R/OSETTYVARIPALLI VILLAGE, MUDDANUR MANDAL. NOW R/O
D.NO.9/247-A,
3. MANJULA KAVITHA, D/O SRINIVASULU MINOR, R/OSETTYVARIPALLI
VILLAGE, MUDDANUR MANDAL. NOW R/O D.NO.9/247-A,
4. MANJULA VENKATA SAI TARUN, S/O SRINIVASULU MINOR, PET. 2
TO 4 ARE REP.BY THEIR MOTHER -1ST PETITIONER
R/OSETTYVARIPALLI VILLAGE, MUDDANUR MANDAL. NOW R/O
D.NO.9/247-A,
5. MANJULA
PEDDA
VENKATESU,
S/O
KONDAIAH
COOLIE
R/OSETTYVARIPALLI VILLAGE, MUDDANUR MANDAL. NOW R/O
D.NO.9/247-A,
6. M/S SHIV SHAKTHI CONSTRUCTIONS, REP.BY ITS MANAGER,
OWNER OF LORRY NO. AP 11 T 4543 R/O 6-2-318/5/1, ROAD NO.14,
BANJARA HILLS,
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying thet the Highcourt may be
pleased toset aside the order dated 21st October, 2011 passed in MVOP.No.
217 of 2006 on the file of the MACT Cum Family Court cum VI Addl. District
Judge, Kadapa
IA NO: 1 OF 2012(MACMAMP 2330 OF 2012
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
condone the delay of 28 days in filing the appeal
IA NO: 2 OF 2012(MACMAMP 2683 OF 2012
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
suspend the operation of the Order dated 21st October, 2011 passed in
MVOP.No .2176 of 2006 on the file of the MACT cum Family Court cum VI Addl.
District Judge, Kadapa.
IA NO: 3 OF 2012(MACMAMP 7691 OF 2012
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the interim stay granted in MACMA.MP.No. 2683 of 2012
in
MACMA(SR).No. 16517 of 2012, dt. 24/04/2012
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. T V P SAI VIHARI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. J SESHAGIRI RAO
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
M.A.C.M.A.No.4221 of 2012
JUDGMENT:
Introductory:
1.
Respondent No.2 / The New India Assurance Company Limited in
M.V.O.P.No.217 of 2006 on the file of Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cumFamily Court-cum-VI Additional District Judge, Kadapa (for short <the learned
MACT=) feeling dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation of Rs.7,92,000/with interest at the rate of 6% per annum awarded by the learned MACT as
against the claim made for the death of one Manjula Srinivasulu (hereinafter
referred to as <the deceased=), filed the present appeal.
2.
Claimant No.1 is the wife, claimant Nos.2 to 4 are the children and
claimant No.5 is the father of the deceased.
3.
Respondent No.1 before the learned MACT is the owner of the Lorry
bearing No.AP 11 T 4543 (hereinafter referred to as <the offending vehicle=).
Respondent No.2 is the insurer.
4.
For the sake of convenience, the parties will be hereinafter referred to as
the claimants and the respondents with reference to their status before the
learned MACT.
Case of the claimants:
5(i).
On 12.11.2005, while the deceased was travelling on his motor cycle
bearing No.AP 04 J 8217, when it was near Shilpa Kalavedika of Madapur, the
offending vehicle, driven by its driver came in a rash and negligent manner and
dashed the motor cycle, causing the accident and instantaneous death of the
deceased.
(ii).
A case in Crime No.332 of 2005 was registered for the offences under
Section 304-A IPC and a charge sheet was laid against the driver of the
offending vehicle.
The deceased was hale and healthy, aged 34 years and
working as a Labour Contractor, earning Rs.15,000/- to Rs.20,000/- per month.
Due to his sudden demise, the family became orphans. Hence, they are entitled
for just and reasonable compensation. Respondent No.1 is the owner of the
offending vehicle. Respondent No.2 is the insurer. Hence, both are liable to pay
compensation.
6.
Respondent No.1, being the owner of the offending vehicle, remained ex
parte before the learned MACT.
Case of respondent No.2 / Insurance Company:
7(i).
The claimants shall prove the pleaded accident, negligence of the driver of
the offending vehicle, death of the deceased due to the accident, age, occupation
and income of the deceased.
(ii).
The negligence of the deceased in riding the motor cycle is the cause for
the accident. He suddenly tried to cross the road where there was heavy traffic.
Therefore, there is no liability for the owner and Insurance Company of the
offending vehicle.
(iii).
In any event, the Insurance Company is not liable to pay compensation.
Findings of the learned MACT:
8(i).
Considering the evidence of eye-witness-P.W.2, the learned MACT found
that the negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle is the cause for the
accident and the defence of the Insurance Company contra cannot be
appreciated, as none are examined on behalf of the respondents. Therefore,
both respondents are jointly and severally liable.
(ii).
The age of the deceased is >42? years as per Ex.A5. As per Ex.A6, the age
of the deceased is >30? years. The 1st identity card was issued in the year 2004
and even then the age of the deceased is mentioned as 42 years in the L& T Ltd.
document. Therefore, the age is accepted at >43? years with reference to the
date of accident. For want of proof such as income tax returns etc., the income
of the deceased is accepted at Rs.6,000/- per month.
If 1/4th is deducted
towards the personal expenditure, net income of the deceased comes to
Rs.4,500/- per month and Rs.54,000/- per annum. The Multiplier applicable is
>14?.
Then
the
petitioners
/
claimants
are
entitled
for
Rs.7,56,000/-
(Rs.54,000/- X 14) under the head of loss of dependency, Rs.15,000/- towards
loss of estate, Rs.3,000/- towards transport charges, Rs.3,000/- towards funeral
expenses and claimant No.1, being the wife, is entitled for Rs.15,000/- towards
loss of consortium. In all, the claimants are entitled for Rs.7,92,000/- as
compensation.
9.
Heard
both
sides
extensively.
Perused
the
record.
Thoughtful
consideration is given to the arguments advanced by both sides.
Arguments in the appeal:
For the appellant / Insurance Company:
10(i). The learned MACT erred in taking the income of deceased at Rs.6,000/per month based on identity cards vide Ex.A5 and Ex.A6 and in failing to insist
upon proof such as income tax returns, thereby, disbelieving the income claimed
by the claimants.
(ii).
The compensation awarded by the learned MACT is excessive.
(iii).
Negligence of the deceased cannot be ignored.
For the claimants:
11(i). The claimants are entitled for more compensation than what is awarded.
(ii).
There is no bar to awarding more compensation in this appeal, although
the claimants did not choose to file an appeal.
(iii).
Requires no interference.
12.
The points that arise for determination in this appeal are:
1) Whether the accident occurred due to the negligence of the driver of the
offending vehicle and whether the compensation of Rs.7,92,000/- awarded
by the learned MACT under the impugned order and decree dated
21.10.2011 in M.V.O.P.No.217 of 2006 is just and reasonable or whether it
requires any modification, and if so, to what extent?
2) What is the result of the appeal?
Point No.1:
(i) Negligence:
Statutory Guidance:
13(i). As per Section 176 of the Motor Vehicles Act, the State Governments are
entitled to make rules for the purpose of carrying effect to the provisions of the
Motor Vehicles Act.
(ii).
In relation to claims before the learned MACT, Rule 455 to Rule 476 of the
A.P. Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, vide Chapter No.11, provides comprehensive
guidance. As per Rule 476 of the A.P. Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, the Claims
Tribunal shall proceed to award the claim based on the registration certificate of
the vehicle, insurance policy, copy of FIR and Post-mortem certificate etc.
Precedential Guidance:
14.
The Hon?ble Apex Court in Bimla Devi and others vs. Himachal Road
Transport Corporation1, in para 15 observed as follows:
“15.
In a situation of this nature, the Tribunal has rightly taken a holistic
view of the matter. It was necessary to be borne in mind that strict proof of an
accident caused by a particular bus in a particular manner may not be
possible to be done by the claimants. The claimants were merely to establish
their case on the touchstone of preponderance of probability. The standard
of proof beyond reasonable doubt could not have been applied. For the said
purpose, the High Court should have taken into consideration the respective
stories set forth by both the parties.=
15.
There is no evidence on the part of the Insurance Company. The driver of
the offending vehicle is not examined, whereas the eye witness, P.W.2, clearly
stated about the occurrence of the accident and the negligence of the driver of
the offending vehicle. The findings of the learned MACT are well reasoned and
no grounds are found to interfere with the findings of the learned MACT with
regard to negligence.
(ii). Quantum of compensation:
Precedential guidance:
16(i). For having uniformity of practice and consistency in awarding just
compensation, the Hon?ble Apex Court provided guidelines as to adoption of
multiplier depending on the age of the deceased in Sarla Verma (Smt.) and Ors.
2009 (13) SCC 530
vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Anr.2 and also the method of calculation
as to ascertaining multiplicand, applying multiplier and calculating the
compensation vide paragraph Nos.18 and 19 of the Judgment.
(ii).
Further, the Hon?ble Apex Court in National Insurance Company Ltd. vs.
Pranay Sethi and Others3 case directed for adding future prospects at 50% in
respect of permanent employment where the deceased is below 40 years, 30%
where deceased is between 40-50 years and 15% where the deceased is
between 50-60 years. Further, in respect of self-employed etc., recommended
addition of income at 40% for the deceased below 40 years, at 25% where the
deceased is between 40-50 years and at 10% where the deceased is between
50-60 years.
Further, awarding compensation under conventional heads like
loss of estate, loss of consortium and funeral expenditure at Rs.15,000/-,
Rs.40,000/- and Rs.15,000/- respectively is also provided in the same Judgment.
(iii).
Further in Magma General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Nanu Ram and
Others4, the Hon?ble Apex Court observed that the compensation under the head
of loss of consortium can be awarded not only to the spouse but also to the
children and parents of the deceased under the heads of parental consortium
and filial consortium.
2009 (6) SCC 121
2017(16) SCC 680
(2018) 18 SCC 130
Just Compensation:
17. In Rajesh and others vs. Rajbir Singh and others5, the Hon?ble Supreme
Court in para Nos.10 and 11 made relevant observations, they are as follows:
10. Whether the Tribunal is competent to award compensation in
excess of what is claimed in the application under Section 166 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, is another issue arising for consideration in
this case. At para 10 of Nagappa case [Nagappa v. Gurudayal Singh,
(2003) 2 SCC 274 : 2003 SCC (Cri) 523 : AIR 2003 SC 674] , it was
held as follows: (SCC p. 280)
<10. Thereafter, Section 168 empowers the Claims Tribunal to >make
an award determining the amount of compensation which appears to it
to be just?. Therefore, the only requirement for determining the
compensation is that it must be >just?. There is no other limitation or
restriction on its power for awarding just compensation.=
The principle was followed in the later decisions in Oriental Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Mohd. Nasir [(2009) 6 SCC 280 : (2009) 2 SCC (Civ) 877 :
(2009) 2 SCC (Cri) 987] and in Ningamma v. United India Insurance Co.
Ltd. [(2009) 13 SCC 710 : (2009) 5 SCC (Civ) 241 : (2010) 1 SCC (Cri)
1213]
11. Underlying principle discussed in the above decisions is with regard
to the duty of the court to fix a just compensation and it has now
become settled law that the court should not succumb to niceties or
technicalities, in such matters. Attempt of the court should be to equate,
as far as possible, the misery on account of the accident with the
compensation so that the injured/the dependants should not face the
vagaries of life on account of the discontinuance of the income earned
by the victim.
(2013) 9 SCC 54
18(i). As per Ex.A2-Inquest Report and Ex.A3-Post-mortem Certificate, the age
of the deceased is >34? years. As per Ex.A5-identity card issued by L&T, the age
of the deceased is mentioned as >42? years as on the date of its issuance for the
period from 03.11.2004 to 02.12.2004. As per Ex.A6-identity card issued by JMC
Products, Hyderabad, the age is mentioned as >30? years and the date of joining
is mentioned as 15.05.2005. But, as per Ex.A5, it was valid from 03.11.2004
itself. Therefore, there is no consistency in the age mentioned in various
departments i.e. Ex.A2-Inquest Report, Ex.A3-Post-mortem Certificate, Ex.A5
and Ex.A6-identity cards.
(ii).
The identity cards, when compared to the official documents prepared in
the routine course vide Ex.A2 and Ex.A3, cannot be given more credence, as
Ex.A2-Inquest Report and Ex.A3-Post-mortem Certificate are consistent.
Therefore, the age of the deceased can be taken as >34? years.
19(i).
With regard to income of the deceased, as rightly observed, no proof is
filed. The solitary oral evidence of P.W.1 is that of an interested witness. The
evidence of P.W.2 has nothing to do with the income of the deceased.
Therefore, the income taken by the learned MACT at Rs.6,000/- can be
considered as reasonable.
(ii).
However, considering the age of the deceased and the nature of
employment, the learned MACT ought to have added 40% towards future
prospects, whereby the income should have been considered as Rs.8,400/- per
month. On deduction of 1/4th towards personal expenditure, the contribution of
the deceased to the claimants comes to Rs.6,300/- per month and Rs.75,600/per annum, which can be taken as multiplicand. The multiplier applicable to the
age group of >34? years is >16?. Then the contribution of the deceased to the
family under the head of loss of dependency comes to Rs.12,09,600/(Rs.75,600/- x 16).
20.
Further,
the
claimants
are
entitled
for
compensation
under
the
conventional heads i.e. Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses, Rs.15,000/towards loss of estate and Rs.40,000/- each to claimant Nos.1 to 4 towards loss
of consortium viz. claimant No.1-spousal consortium and claimant Nos.2 to 4parental consortium. Claimant No.5 died pending litigation.
21.
In view of the reasons and evidence referred above, the entitlement of the
claimants for reasonable compensation in comparison to the compensation
awarded by the learned MACT is found as follows:
Head
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
Loss of dependency
Loss of estate
Loss of Consortium
Compensation
awarded
by
the learned MACT
Fixed by this
Court
Rs.7,56,000/-
Rs.12,09,600/-
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.1,60,000/-
@ towards
claimant No.1
@ Rs.40,000/- each to
claimant Nos.1 to 4
(iv)
Funeral expenses
Rs.3,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
(v)
Transportation
Rs.3,000/-
-Nil-
Total compensation awarded
Interest (per annum)
Rs.7,92,000/-
Rs.13,99,600/-
6%
6%
22.
For the reasons aforesaid and in view of the discussion made above, the
point framed is answered concluding that the claimants are entitled for
compensation of Rs.13,99,600/- with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from
the date of petition till the date of realization and the order and decree dated
21.10.2011 passed by the learned MACT in M.V.O.P.No.217 of 2006 require
modification accordingly.
{{{{
Granting of more compensation than what claimed, if the claimants are
otherwise entitled:23.
The legal position with regard to awarding more compensation than what
claimed has been considered and settled by the Hon?ble Supreme Court holding
that there is no bar for awarding more compensation than what is claimed. For
the said proposition of law, this Court finds it proper to refer the following
observations of the Hon?ble Supreme Court made in:
(1)
Nagappa vs. Gurudayal Singh and Others6, at para 21 of the judgment,
that –
<..there is no restriction that the Tribunal/Court cannot award compensation
amount exceeding the claimed amount. The function of the Tribunal/Court is
to award <just= compensation, which is reasonable on the basis of evidence
produced on record.=
(2003) 2 SCC 274
(2)
Kajal vs. Jagadish Chand and Ors.7 at para 33 of the judgment, as
follows:<33. We are aware that the amount awarded by us is more than the amount
claimed. However, it is well settled law that in the motor accident claim
petitions, the Court must award the just compensation and, in case, the just
compensation is more than the amount claimed, that must be awarded
especially where the claimant is a minor.”
(3) Ramla and Others
vs. National Insurance Company Limited and
Others8 at para 5 of the judgment, as follows:<5. Though the claimants had claimed a total compensation of Rs 25,00,000
in their claim petition filed before the Tribunal, we feel that the compensation
which the claimants are entitled to is higher than the same as mentioned
supra. There is no restriction that the Court cannot award compensation
exceeding the claimed amount, since the function of the Tribunal or Court
under Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is to award <just
compensation=. The Motor Vehicles Act is a beneficial and welfare legislation.
A <just compensation= is one which is reasonable on the basis of evidence
produced on record. It cannot be said to have become time-barred. Further,
there is no need for a new cause of action to claim an enhanced amount. The
courts are duty-bound to award just compensation.=
24.
Awarding more compensation than what is claimed and awarding
compensation to the claimants even in the absence of any appeal or cross
objections by the claimants require examination.
2020 (04) SCC 413
(2019) 2 SCC 192
Enhancement of compensation in the absence of appeal:
25(i). Whether the compensation can be enhanced in the absence of an appeal
or cross appeal by the claimant. The legal position as to powers of the Appellate
Court particularly while dealing with an appeal in terms of Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, where the award passed by the learned MACT under
challenge at the instance of the Insurance Company (Respondents) and bar or
prohibition, if any, to enhancing the quantum of compensation and awarding just
and reasonable compensation, even in the absence of any appeal or cross
objections was considered by the Division Bench of this Court in a case between
National Insurance Company Limited vs. E. Suseelamma and others9 in
M.A.C.M.A. No.945 of 2013, while answering point No.3 framed therein vide,
para 50 of the judgment, which reads as follows:
50. In our considered view, the claimant/respondents are entitled
for just compensation and if on the face of the award or even in the
light of the evidence on record, and keeping in view the settled legal
position regarding the claimants being entitled to just compensation
and it also being the statutory duty of the Court/Tribunal to award just
compensation, this Court in the exercise of the appellate powers can
enhance the amount of compensation even in the absence of appeal
or cross-objection by the claimants.
2023 SCC Online AP 1725
(ii).
The observations made by the Division Bench of this Court in National
Insurance Company Limited vs. E. Suseelamma and others (9 supra) case
are in compliance with the observations of the Hon?ble Apex Court in Surekha
and Others vs. Santosh and Others10.
(iii).
In Surekha and Others vs. Santosh and Others (10 supra) case, in Civil
Appeal No.476 of 2020 vide judgment dated 21.01.2020, a three-Judge Bench of
the Hon?ble Supreme Court observed that <it is well settled that in the matter of
Insurance claim compensation in reference to the motor accident, the Court
should not take hyper technical approach and ensure that just compensation is
awarded to the affected person or the claimants=. While addressing a case where
the High Court has declined to grant enhancement on the ground that the
claimants fail to file cross appeal above observations are made.
Point No.3:
26.
In the result,
(i)
The appeal is dismissed.
(ii)
However, the compensation awarded by the learned MACT in
M.V.O.P.No.217 of 2006 at Rs.7,92,000/- with interest at the rate of
6% per annum is modified and enhanced to Rs.13,99,600/- with
interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till the
date of realization.
(2021) 16 SCC 467
(iii)
Claimants are liable to pay the Court fee for the enhanced part of the
compensation, before the learned MACT.
(iv)
Apportionment:
(a) Claimant No.1 / wife of the deceased is entitled for Rs.6,49,600/with proportionate interest and costs.
(b) Claimant Nos.2 to 4 / children of the deceased are entitled for
Rs.2,50,000/- each with proportionate interest.
(v)
Respondents before the learned MACT are liable to pay the
compensation. However, Respondent No.2 is liable in view of the
insurance policy.
(vi)
Time for payment /deposit of balance amount is two months.
(a) If the claimants furnish the bank account number within 15 days
from today, the respondents shall deposit the amount directly into
the bank account of the claimants and file the necessary proof
before the learned MACT.
(b) If the claimants fail to comply with clause (vi)(a) above, the
respondents shall deposit the amount before the learned MACT
and the claimants are entitled to withdraw the amount at once on
deposit.
(vii)
There shall be no order as to costs, in the appeal.
27.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the appeal shall
stand closed.
____________________________
A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA, J
Date:03.03.2026
Knr
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
M.A.C.M.A.No.4221 of 2012
03.03.2026
Knr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review