Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No.26 of 2023
The National Insurance Company Ltd
(To be represented by Divisional Manager),
Agartala Divisional Officer, 42, Akhaura Road,
P.O.–Agartala, District–West Tripura, Pin-799001
----Insurer Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Nandalal Rupini,
S/O Sri Panchadhan Rupini
2. Smti Hema Malini Rupini
W/O Sri Nandalal Rupini,
Both are residents of Atuk Thang Bari, Jirania
P.S.-Jirania, District-West Tripura
----Claimant-respondent(s)
3. Smti Pinki Das (Deb),
W/O Late Shibu Deb
4. Sri Subhajit Deb,
S/O Late Shibu Deb
Both are resident of Das Para, Amarpur,
P.S. – Ampi, District – Gomati.
Sl.No.3 & 4 (Owners of TR-01-J-6882, Motor Cycle)
----Owner respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. A. K. Deb, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
None.
Date of hearing
:
11.01.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
25.01.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The National Insurance Company Limited as an
appellant has preferred this appeal under Section 173 of M.V.
Act
challenging
the
award
dated
05.01.2023
passed
in
connection with Case No. T.S.(MAC) 81 of 2017 by Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal (Tribunal No.2), Agartala, West Tripura
District. The appellant by the memo of appeal has prayed for
modification of the award.
2.
The gist of the appeal in short, is that the
respondent claimant-petitioners have filed one claim petition
under Section 166 of M.V. Act claiming compensation of
Rs.26,40,000/- (Rupees Twenty-six lakh forty thousand only)
with 14% interest for the death of their minor son, Bisesh
Rupini who died due to a vehicular accident. The said accident
occurred on 20.04.2017 at about 10:30 hrs at Champaknagar
bazaar under Jirania PS due to rash driving of motor cycle
bearing No. TR-01-J-6882. At the time of accident, said Bisesh
Rupini
was
walking
on
foot
with
his
grandmother
at
Champaknagar bazaar and after the accident the deceased was
brought to Jirania Hospital with multiple grievous injuries on
different parts of his body and thereafter he was referred to
AGMC and GBP Hospital at Agartala and on 21.04.2017, he
succumbed to injuries. On that issue, a case bearing Jirania P.S.
case No.19/2017 under Section 279/338 of IPC & 184/187 of
the
M.V.
Act
was
registered.
Further,
according
to
the
respondent claimant-petitioners, deceased was 10 years old at
the time of his death and was a student of Class-V.
3.
The OP respondents No.3 and 4 being the owners
of motorcycle bearing No.TR-01-J-6882 contested the claim by
filing their joint written statement and denied all the allegations
made in the claim petition and also contended that on the
alleged day, the offending motorcycle was insured with the
National Insurance Co. Ltd. i.e. the present appellant covering
the period of alleged incident and submitted that if any liability
arises that would be borne by the O.P. Insurance Company.
4.
The present appellant as O.P No.2 being the
insurer of the motorcycle No.TR-01-J-6882 by filing written
statement denied the accident and submitted that the claim
petition
was
not
maintainable
and
baseless
and
further
submitted that if any terms and conditions of the insurance
policy is violated then the OP No.2 i.e. the Insurance Company
shall not be liable to pay any compensation as per Section
149(2) of M.V. Act and further submitted that on the alleged
day, the offending motor bike was not involved in any accident
as
such
the
claimants
compensation and further
were
not
entitled
submitted that
to
the
get
any
claim was
excessive and exorbitant.
5.
Learned Tribunal on the basis of the pleadings of
the parties framed the following issues:
I) If the death of deceased Bishesh Rupini was
caused on the alleged date, time and place due to road traffic accident n
the rash and negligent riding of the rider of alleged motor bike? If so are
the claimant petitioners entitled to get compensation?
II) What should be amount of compensation and
who shall be held liable to pay the compensation?
6.
To substantiate the claim petition, the respondent
claimant-petitioner No.2 was examined herself as PW1 and
relied upon some documentary evidence which were marked as
exhibits before the Learned Tribunal:
1) Certified copy of FIR, ejahar, post mortem and
final report in c.w. Jiraniai PS case No.19 of 2017 in 13 sheets-[Ext.1(i) to
1(xii)];
2)
Photocopy
of
Adhar
Card
of
the
deceased
(compared with the original)-(Exbt-2);
3) Photocopy of Adhar Card of PW1 (compared with
the original)-(Exbt-3)
On the other side, the respondent O.P. owner
examined one Litan Dey as OPW-1 and relied upon some
documentary evidences:
1. Original copy of screen report in respect of
vehicle bearing No.TR-01-J-6882 (Motor Bike)-Exbt.A;
2. Photocopy of policy of insurance in respect of said
vehicle (compared with the original)-Exbt.B;
3. Photocopy of driving license of OPW1(compared
with the original)-Exbt.C.
7.
Learned Tribunal after considering the evidence on
record and also after hearing both the sides finally determined
the compensation of Rs.10,05,000/- (Rupees Ten Lakh five
thousand only) with 9% simple interest per annum from the
date of registration of the claim i.e. w.e.f. 05.05.2017 till the
date of realization with a further direction to the Insurance
Company to deposit the amount within a period of one month.
8.
Challenging
that
award
the
appellant
has
preferred this appeal under Section 173 of M.V. Act. It is to be
noted here that at the time of hearing Learned Counsel for the
appellant
submitted
determined
the
that
amount
the
of
Learned
Tribunal
compensation
and
wrongly
awarded
excessive and exorbitant amount, which needs to be modified.
Learned Counsel for the appellant further submitted that the
Learned Tribunal relying upon the judgment of this Court in
Akinchan Chakraborty and another v. Oriental Insurance
Co. Ltd. and anr., (Case No. MAC App. No.96 of 2013
decided on 03.06.2016) wherein the Hon’ble High Court
relied upon another decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Kishan Gopal & Anr vs Lala & Ors reported in 2013, ACJ
2594, assessed the notional income of the deceased (who was
aged about 10 years and was a student) at Rs.30,000/- per
annum in place of Rs.15,000/- and applying multiplier of 15
granted compensation of Rs.4,50,000/- as pecuniary damage
and further awarded
a
sum of Rs.50,000/- for
loss of
expectation of life and sum of Rs.5,000/- for funeral expenses
calculated amount of compensation of Rs.4,50,000/- and
thereafter added Rs.50,000/- towards loss of expectation of life
and Rs.5,000/- for funeral expenses but without application of
proper mind and in absence of any settled principle of law
further awarded Rs.5,00,000/- towards love and affection which
according to Learned Counsel for the appellant was not justified
and beyond the settled principles of law. So, Learned Counsel
urged before the Court for intervention by modifying the award.
9.
As already stated none appeared on behalf of the
respondents to contest this present appeal. I have heard
argument of Learned Counsel for the appellant and also gone
through the record of the Learned Tribunal below. There is no
dispute on record in respect of accident on the alleged date and
time also in respect of death of the deceased on that date and
time. Further, there was no dispute on record that at the time
of death the deceased was aged about 10 years old and was a
school-going student.
10.
Relying upon the aforesaid judgment of the High
Court and also relying upon the judgment of Kishan Gopal
(supra),
Learned
Tribunal
below
determined
the
notional
income of the deceased at Rs.30,000/- per annum and along
with that amount applied multiplier as 15 and calculated
compensation
amounting
to
Rs.4,50,000/-
which
in
my
considered view, Learned Tribunal below rightly adopted and
decided and after that Learned Tribunal below with that amount
awarded Rs.50,000/- towards loss of expectation of life and
Rs.5,000/- as funeral expenses. That amount also in my
considered view Learned Tribunal below rightly determined and
Learned Counsel for the appellant at the time of hearing also
did not submit anything regarding the aforesaid amount of
compensation awarded.
11.
Now, in respect of loss of love and affection,
Learned Tribunal below awarded Rs.5,00,000/-. In this regard,
Learned Counsel for the appellant relied upon one citation of
the
Hon’ble
Insurance
Supreme
Court
Company
Limited
of
India.
vs
In
United
Satinder
Kaur
India
alias
Satwinder Kaur in Civil Appeal No.2705 of 2020 reported
in (2021) 11 SCC 780 wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court in para
34 and 35 has observed as under :
“34. At this stage, we consider it necessary to
provide uniformity with respect to the grant
of consortium, and loss of love and affection.
Several Tribunals and the High Courts have
been awarding compensation for both of loss
of consortium and loss of love and affection.
The Constitution Bench in Pranay Sethi
(2017) 16 SCC 680, has recognized only three
conventional
heads
under
which
compensation can be awarded viz. loss of
estate, loss of consortium and funeral
expenses. In Magma General (2018) 18 SCC
130, this Court gave a comprehensive
interpretation to consortium to include
spousal consortium, parental consortium, as
well as filial consortium. Loss of love and
affection
is
comprehended
in
loss
of
consortium.
35. The Tribunals and the High Courts are
directed to award compensation for loss of
consortium,
which
is
a
legitimate
conventional head. There is no justification to
award compensation towards loss of love and
affection as a separate head.”
From the aforesaid citation of the Hon’ble Apex
Court, it appears that Hon’ble Apex Court discarded to award
compensation towards love and affection as a separate head.
But here in the case at hand, the Learned Tribunal below
awarded compensation of Rs.5,00,000/- towards loss of love
and affection to the claimant-petitioners which in my considered
view Learned Tribunal below wrongly decided ignoring the
principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. So,
this amount needs to be modified as awarded by the Learned
Tribunal. But at the same time, in the aforesaid judgment
Hon’ble Supreme Court in para 30, 31, 32 and 33 further
observed as under:
“30. In Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd v.
Nanu Ram :(2018) 18 SCC 130 this Court
interpreted
“consortium”
to
be
a
compendious
term,
which
encompasses
spousal consortium, parental consortium, as
well as filial consortium. The right to
consortium would include the company, care,
help, comfort, guidance, solace and affection
of the deceased, which is a loss to his family.
With respect to a spouse, it would include
sexual relations with the deceased spouse.
31. Parental consortium is granted to the
child upon the premature death of a parent,
for loss of parental aid, protection, affection,
society, discipline, guidance and training.
Filial consortium is the right of the parents to
compensation in the case of an accidental
death of a child. An accident leading to the
death of a child causes great shock and agony
to the parents and family of the deceased.
The greatest agony for a parent is to lose
their child during their lifetime. Children are
valued for their love and affection, and their
role in the family unit.
32. Modern jurisdictions world over have
recognized that the value of a child’s
consortium far exceeds the economic value of
the compensation awarded in the case of the
death of a child. Most jurisdictions permit
parents to be awarded compensation under
loss of consortium on the death of a child. The
amount awarded to the parents is the
compensation for loss of love and affection,
care and companionship of the deceased
child.
33. The Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is a
beneficial legislation which has been framed
with the object of providing relief to the
victims, or their families, in cases of genuine
claims. In case where a parent has lost their
minor child, or unmarried son or daughter,
the parents are entitled to be awarded loss of
consortium
under
the
head
of
filial
Consortium. Parental Consortium is awarded
to the children who lose the care and
protection of their parents in motor vehicle
accidents. The amount to be awarded for loss
consortium will be as per the amount fixed in
Pranay Sethi (2017) 16 SCC 680.”
From the above principle of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court, it appears that the respondent claimantpetitioners being the parents of the deceased are entitled to get
filial consortium. In pursuance of the judgment of National
Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi and others
reported in (2017)16 SCC 680 in para 52 wherein the Hon’ble
Apex Court decided to award loss of consortium of Rs.40,000/along with funeral expenses and loss of estate. So, in the
present case Filial consortium Rs.40,000/- x 2 i.e. 80,000/which the claimant-petitioners are entitled to get from the
appellant and the respondent claimant-petitioners are also
entitled to get Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses. But the
Tribunal below has awarded only Rs.5,000/-. So, an addition of
Rs.10,000/- will be added with the compensation awarded by
the Learned Tribunal, as funeral expenses.
12.
So,
after
hearing
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant and also after going through the record of the Learned
Tribunal below, it appears that the respondent claimants are
entitled to get the compensation as follows:i) Income(30,000 x 15) :
Rs.4,50,000/-
ii) Loss of expectation
:
Rs.
50,000/-
iii) Funeral Expenses
:
Rs.
15,000/-
iv) Filial Consortium
(40,000 x 2)
:
Rs.
80,000
Total compensation to be paid :
13.
Rs.5,95,000/-
In the result, the appeal filed by the insurer-
appellant is partly allowed with modification that the respondent
claimant-petitioners shall entitled to get award of Rs.5,95,000/(Rupees Five Lakhs ninety-five thousand only) with 9% simple
interest per annum from the date of registration of claim
petition i.e. 05.05.2017 till the date of realization in place of
Rs.10,05,000/- as awarded by the Learned Tribunal. The rest
operative portion of the award of the Learned Tribunal below
regarding disbursal of amount shall remain unchanged. The
Insurance Company shall comply with the order within a period
of one month from the date of passing of this judgment.
A copy of the judgment be given to the Learned
Counsel for the appellant for immediate compliance free of cost.
14.
With this observation, the appeal stands disposed
of. Send down the LCR alongwith a copy of this judgment.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMITA Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.01.29
DATTA
13:18:13 -08'00'
Deepshikha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review