Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
MAC. App. No.24 of 2022
1.
The National Insurance Company Ltd. (to be represented by Senior
Divisional Manager) Agartala Divisional Office, 42 Akhaura Road,
P.O. Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN-799001.
…..Noticee-insurer-appellant
-V E R S U S-
1.
Sri Biplab Debnath, son of Sri Sunil Debnath, Village & P.O. East
Nalchar (School Para), P.S. Melaghar, District: Sepahijala
.....Claimant-respondent
2.
Sri Sunil Sarkar, son of late Nitish Kanta Sarkar of South Nalchar,
P.S. Melaghar, District: Sepahijala.
Owner of Motor Bike No. TR-01-AD (Tem)-2351.
.....O.P. Owner-respondent
3.
Sri Sankar Sarkar, son of Sri Sunil Sarkar of South Nalchar, P.S.
Melaghar, District: Sepahijala.
Rider of Motor Bike No. TR-01-AD (Tem)-2351.
.....O.P. Rider-respondent.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
:
Mr. A. K. Deb, Advocate.
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
YES/NO
Judgment and order dated 2nd May, 2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. A. K. Deb, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
and Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel a appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This appeal has been filed under Section-173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 against the judgment and award dated 15.09.2021 passed in
T.S. (MAC) 29 of 2018 by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Court No.5, Agartala, West Tripura for modification towards just and
proper compensation.
[3]
The brief fact of the claimant-respondent’s case, inter-alia, is that
on 28.11.2016 at 9.30 am while claimant was talking with his friend in front of
shop of one Chandan Das of Nalchar in the Western side of AgartalaSonamura Road under Melaghar PS, Sepahijala District at that time rider of the
motor
bike
TR-01-AD(TEM)2351(Hero
Hunk)
came
towards
south
from North side with very high speed in rash and negligent manner and dashed
claimant. Due to accident claimant sustained grievous injury and got
treatment in four hospitals for long time and ultimately lost his vision and
became blind and also permanently paralyzed his legs and lower body and
sustained huge cost for treatment. It is also pleaded that in connection
with the accident Melaghar PS Case No.83/2016 dated 29.11.2016 under
section 279/338 of IPC was registered against the rider of the motor bike Sri
Sankar Sarkar. It is further pleaded that claimant was 29 years old on the date
of accident and self employed having own shop and electronic goods business
and was earning Rs.25,000/- per month and due to the accident
lost his 100% income.
[4]
The owner-respondent and the rider-respondent of the motor bike
No. TR-01-AD (Tem)-2351 by filing joint written statement contested the case
of claimant by denying all the contents of the claimant and, inter alia, pleaded
that the offending bike was insured with OP No.3 (Noticee), the National
Insurance Company Limited. The OP No.1 and 2 denied the fact of accident,
income of claimant, sustaining cost and expense for treatment by claimant and
injury of the claimant including disability of claimant. Thus, OP No.1 and 2
prayed for dismissal of the case of the claimant.
[5]
After lodging the claim petition, it was registered vide case No.
T.S (MAC) 170 of 2019 and notices had been served upon the opposite parties
of the case. The OP No.1 owner of the offending vehicle has contested the suit
by filing written statement and denied all the allegations of the claimants and
also stated that on the date and time of accident the involved vehicle was duly
insured with the opposite party No.2. OP No.3 (Noticee), the National
Insurance Company contested the case of claimant by filing written statement
denying the plea of the claimant and, inter alia, pleaded that the claim of the
claimant is highly exorbitant and put the petitioner in strict proof of
accident, injury, treatment, expenses, valid driving licence, permit and
insurance policy etc. It is pleaded that claimant failed to furnish full particulars
and therefore, the case of the claimant is liable to be dismissed.
[6]
The learned Tribunal after hearing the parties and on perusal of
the material evidence on record has observed as under:
“OP No.3, National Insurance Company Ltd. is directed to deposit the
awarded compensation of Rs.81,40,000/- (Rupees Eighty one lakhs forty
thousand) only within 30 days from today with interest thereon at the rate
of 8% per annum with effect from date of filing of the claim application
i.e., from 20.02.2018 to till realization of the full.
Considering the expenditure sustained for treatment and disability of
claimant 50% of the amount of claimant to be fixed deposited for five
years. The remaining amount of compensation are to be released in
favour of the claimants in his bank account. The interest on the fixed
deposit can be withdrawn by claimant. However, in case of necessity, the
Tribunal can be approached for withdrawal of fixed deposited amount.
On maturity of the fixed deposits the Banker shall credit the amounts to
the sole SB Accounts of claimants without any further order from the
Tribunal”
[7]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment and award
dated 15.09.2021 passed in T.S. (MAC) 29 of 2018 by the learned Member,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.5, Agartala, West Tripura, the
present appeal has been preferred by the appellant-insurance company.
[8]
Mr. A. K. Deb, learned counsel appearing for the appellant-
insurance company has submitted that the learned tribunal has committed
wrong in considering the facts as well as oral and documentary evidence and
principles as held by the Apex Court. Though the Motor Accident Act is a
beneficial social legislation, but it not a bonanza or for the purpose of benefit.
Thus, as per principle held in (2011) SCC 343, Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and
another by the Apex Court, the learned tribunal in order to award just and
proper compensation, the learned tribunal ought to have made summary
enquiry properly to remove any doubt arising out of the facts of the case and
presiding officer of a Court should not simply sit as a mere umpire at a contest
between two parties and declare at the end of the combat between two parties
and declare at the end who has lost and that there is a legal duty of his won,
independent of the parties to take an active role in the proceedings in finding
the truth and administering justice.
[9]
There creates doubt as to genuineness of the claim petition filed
by the claimant since it appears that FIR/written complaint filed by the father
of the claimant-respondent was registered under Sections-326/34 IPC vide
Melaghar P.S. Case No.2016 MLG.083 and the OP No.1 and OP No.2 being
the owner and rider of the motor bike also stated in their joint written statement
that claimant respondent being a literate person, has filed the claim petition by
putting his thumb impression instead of putting signature and moreover, in
respect of lodging FIR, the IO stated in the charge sheet that informant
inadvertently lodged the FIR under Sections-326/34 of IPC.
[10]
In the impugned award, OPW Sri Arup Kumar Dey, as Senior
Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd., in support of judgment of trial of
criminal case deposed that evidence given by the PW-1 and 2 in the present
claim petition is not believable since the said witnesses in their evidence of
criminal case did not depose anything about the rash and negligent driving
except deposing that offending bike was driven with high speed.
[11]
He has further contended that the learned tribunal awarded total
medical cost Rs.6,88,244/- on the basis of some undated unsigned and unsealed
bills and only on the basis of receipts showing purchase of medicine which
have not been supported with prescriptions of the alleged four hospitals. The
learned tribunal has awarded Rs.5,00,000/- as future medical expenses where
in support of this aspect there is no evidence of the medical witness i.e. PW.5
and thus, the learned tribunal ought not to have considered any amount for
future treatment as per principle held by the Apex Court.
[12]
The learned tribunal has also wrongly allowed Rs.1,00,000/- to
the effect that claimant may not have kept receipts. The appellant insurer also
raised objection stating that it is not believable that in ILS hospital any food
can be supplied for any patient from outside the hospital, but claimant-
respondent submitted bill dated 24.12.2016 of Saha Food Center claiming as
cost of purchase of apples for a quantity of 2 Kgs. per day.
[13]
The learned tribunal held that income certificate issued by the
Dy. Collector and Magistrate, Melaghar showing monthly income of
Rs.23,654/- as owner of shop of electrical goods is not believable as no
material is placed before the tribunal i.e. to say that income certificate was
issued on the basis of proper particulars and materials in support of decisions
passed by this Court. Without supporting of any cogent document and only by
guess work and on the basis of Exbt.3 document showing that injured had a
business of electrical goods, wrongly held that a shop owner can earn
Rs.20,000/- per month. But, said Exbt.3 document/registration certificate of
business also cannot be taken into consideration since the said document has
been taken into evidence without examination of either the issuing authority or
any staff of that authority. Moreover, the monthly income as assessed by the
learned tribunal by guess work may not be the actual income without deducting
professional tax, taxable income and day to day establishment cost.
[14]
In view of above, let us discuss the core issue once again. PW.1
Sri Biplab Debnath deposed that on 28.01.2016 at 9.30 am he was talking with
his friend Sri Govinda Debnath(PW.2) in front of shop of Chandan Das of
Nalchar Bazar situated in the western side of Agartala- Sonamura Road under
Melaghar PS and at that time the offending motor bike TR-01-AD-(TEM)2351
(Hero Hunk) came towards South from North side and dashed him with very
high speed in rash and negligent manner. PW.1 also deposed that in connection
with the accident a criminal case vide Melaghar PS Case No.216/MLG/083
dated 29.11.2016 was registered against the rider of the bike Sri Sankar Sarkar
for offence under section 279/338 of IPC and after completion of investigation
I.O. submitted charge sheet against the rider of the offending bike for offence
under section 279/338 of IPC. PW.1 also deposed that due to the accident he
sustained grievous injury and got treatment in four hospital and ultimately due
to the accident he became blind and his leg and lower body were paralyzed and
doctor issued disability certificate.
[15]
PW.2 Sri Govinda Debnath, the eye witness of the accident
corroborated the evidence of PW.1 on material particulars by deposing that on
28.11.2016 at 9.30 am while he was talking with his friend Biplab
Debnath(Claimant/PW.1) in front of the shop of Chandan Das of Nalchar
Bazar situated in the west side of Agartala-Sonamura Road under Melaghar PS
at that time all on a sudden the offending motor bike TR01AD (TEM)
2351(Hero Hunk) came towards south from North side and dashed claimant
with a very high speed in rash and negligent manner and the accident occurred
due to the rash and negligent driving of the rider of the offending motor bike
and, accordingly, a criminal case was registered under Melaghar PS vide case
No. 2016/MLG/083 dated 29.11.2016 against the rider of the offending motor
bike. PW.2 also deposed that due to the accident claimant suffered physical
discomfort, pain, mental agony and ultimately became a permanent physical
disable person by lossing his eye vision and became blind and his two legs and
lower body became paralyzed and doctor issued disability certificate.
[16]
Thus, considering the above mentioned evidence, this Court feels
the evidence of PWs about the rash and negligent driving of the offending bike
is believable being corroborative and cogent. As regards the point of acquittal
in criminal case, I am of the view that in criminal cases allegation is required to
be proved beyond reasonable doubt. In cases of claim of compensation under
M.V. Act rash and negligent driving is not required to be proved strictly and
beyond reasonable doubt. Thus, acquittal in a criminal cannot be a ground to
say that there was no rash and negligent driving in respect of claim case for
compensation under M.V. Act.
[17]
That apart, from Ext.1 series, the FIR and charge sheet, I find,
police filed charge sheet after investigation against the rider of the offending
bike for rash and negligent driving. Hence, rash and negligent driving can be
said to be proved as evidence of PW.1 and 2 are corroborated by FIR and
charge sheet. From Ext. 1 series, the injury report it can be found that claimant
sustained head injury and grievous injury due to road traffic accident. From
Ext.5, the disability certificate, it can be found that claimant sustained 100%
injury on his both eyes and 80% injury on his spine and claimant was
paralyzed. From Ext.6 to 11 series, it can be found that claimant sustained
multiple injuries and got treatment in various hospitals. Where such kind of
multiple injury is sustained by the claimant requiring long treatment in various
hospitals, it can be said that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent
driving with the help of maxim res ipsa loquitur (the thing speaks for itself)
unless contrary is proved.
[18]
In this context, Ld. Counsel for the respondent submitted that
from the evidence of PWs and from documentary evidence, it is proved that
claimant, the respondent herein sustained huge expenditure for treatment and
became disable person having 100% disability of both eyes and 80% disability
of spine and paralyzed. It is also submitted that where disability is more than
70 percent the same is to be treated as 100% loss of income and relied on the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Anand son of Sidheshwar Dukre v.
Pratap son of Zhamnnappa lamzane and Anr, whereby, it is held that where
driver sustained 75% permanent disability and as a result, being not able to
drive lost his job as arriver and monthly salary, the driver is entitled to
compensation of 100% loss of income. Thus, it is submitted that claimantrespondent is entitled to get compensation of Rs.1,22,80,000/- as claimed.
[19]
It is further submitted that final bill was only Rs.4 lakh and
something and not more and claimant claimed excessive bill. It is also
submitted that claimant submitted bill of Saha Food Center dated 24.12.2016
and claimed bills of apple per day 2 kg and the same is not believable specially
as outside food is not allowed in the ILS hospital. It is further submitted that
accident occurred on 28.11.2016 and claimant was discharged on 22.12.2016
and, therefore, six months bill for 2 kg apple each day is not believable. It is
submitted that some undated, unsigned and unsealed bills are filed and,
therefore, the same are not reliable. It is lastly submitted that plane tickets are
shown twice and another set of plane tickets of other persons are filed but not
accompanied with claimant as claimant came to Agartala earlier and, therefore,
claimants are not entitled to such amount.
[20]
Moreover, in this case the rider of the offending bike (OP No.1)
has failed to give evidence to prove the fact that there was no rash and
negligent driving on his part. OP.2, the rider of the offending bike is the best
person to say about his driving but he withheld himself from giving evidence.
Thus, adverse inference goes against him. Neither OP No.1, the owner nor OP
No.3(Insurance Company), the Noticee prayed for adducing OP No.2 as a
witness to prove the fact that there was no rash and negligent driving. That
apart, Op No.1 and 2 filed joint written statement but failed to disclose the true
occurrence of the accident as to how and why the accident occurred. The same
goes against them. No witnesses of the accident are produced by Ops to prove
the fact that there was no rash and negligent driving of the offending motor
bike. Thus, negligence on the part of the rider of the offending bike can be
inferred.
[21]
In this respect, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pushpabai
Parshottam Udeshi and Others v. M/s. Ranjit Ginning and Pressing Co. Pvt.
Ltd. And another, AIR 1977 SC 1735 = (1977) 2 SCC 745 held as under:
“6. The normal rule is that it is for the plaintiff to prove negligence but as
in some cases considerable hardship is caused to the plaintiff as the true
cause of the accident is not known to him but is solely within the
knowledge of the defendant who caused it, the plaintiff can prove the
accident but cannot prove how it happened to establish negligence on the
part of the defendant. This hardship is sought to be avoided by applying
the principle of res ipsa loquitur. The general purport of the words res ipsa
loquitur is that the accident"speaks for itself" or tells its own story. There
are cases in which the accident speaks for itself so that it is sufficient for
the plaintiff to prove the accident and nothing more. It will then be for the
defendant to establish that the accident happened due to some other cause
than his own negligence.”
[22]
Therefore, considering all this aspect, this Court is of the view
that the claimant-petitioner, the respondent herein got injured as a result of
accident on 28.11.2016 at about 0930 hours at Nalchar Bazar in front of shop
of one Chandan Das situated west side of Agartala- Sonamura road under
Melaghar PS, Sepahijala District due to rash and negligent driving of rider of
the Motor Bike bearing No.TR-01-AD(Tem)-2351.
[23]
This Court finds that the Hon'ble Apex Court in Raj Kumar vs
Ajay Kumar & Anr, dated 18.10.2010 in Civil Appeal No..8981 of 2010
(Arising out of SLP (C) No. 10383 of 2007), reported in (2011) 1 SCC 343
laid down method of determination of compensation in injury cases and held as
follows:
“5. The heads under which compensation is awarded in personal injury
cases are the following : Pecuniary damages (Special Damages)
(i) Expenses relating to treatment, hospitalization, medicines,
transportation, nourishing food, and miscellaneous expenditure.
(ii) Loss of earnings (and other gains) which the injured would have made
had he not been injured, comprising : (a) Loss of earning during the period
of treatment;
(b) Loss of future earnings on account of permanent disability.
(iii) Future medical expenses. Non-pecuniary damages (General
Damages) (iv) Damages for pain, suffering and trauma as a
consequence of the injuries. (v) Loss of amenities (and/or loss of
prospects of marriage). (vi) Loss of expectation of life (shortening of
normal longevity). In routine personal injury cases, compensation will
be awarded only under heads (i), (ii) (a) and (iv). It is only in serious cases
of injury, where there is specific medical evidence corroborating the
evidence of the claimant, that compensation will be granted under any of
the heads (ii)(b), (iii), (v) and (vi) relating to loss of future earnings on
account of permanent disability, future medical expenses, loss of
amenities (and/or loss of prospects of marriage) and loss of expectation of
life. Assessment of pecuniary damages under item (i) and under item
(ii)(a) do not pose much difficulty as they involve reimbursement of
actuals and are easily ascertainable from the evidence. Award under the
head of future medical expenses - item (iii) -depends upon specific
medical evidence regarding need for further treatment and cost thereof.
Assessment of non-pecuniary damages - items (iv), (v) and (vi) involves
determination of lump sum amounts with reference to circumstances
such as age, nature of injury/deprivation/disability suffered by the
claimant and the effect thereof on the future life of the claimant. Decision
of this Court and High Courts contain necessary guidelines for award
under these heads, if necessary. What usually poses some difficulty is the
assessment of the loss of future earnings on account of permanent
disability - item (ii)(a). We are concerned with that assessment in this
case. Assessment of future loss of earnings due to permanent
disability ...........
9. Therefore, the Tribunal has to first decide whether there is any
permanent disability and if so the extent of such permanent disability.
This means that the tribunal should consider and decide with reference to
the evidence: (i) whether the disablement is permanent or temporary; (ii)
if the disablement is permanent, whether it is permanent total disablement
or permanent partial disablement, (iii) if the disablement percentage is
expressed with reference to any specific limb, then the effect of such
disablement of the limb on the functioning of the entire body, that is the
permanent disability suffered by the person. If the Tribunal concludes that
there is no permanent disability then there is no question of proceeding
further and determining the loss of future earning capacity. But if the
Tribunal concludes that there is permanent disability then it will proceed
to ascertain its extent. After the Tribunal ascertains the actual extent of
permanent disability of the claimant based on the medical evidence, it has
to determine whether such permanent disability has affected or will affect
his earning capacity.
10. Ascertainment of the effect of the permanent disability on the actual
earning capacity involves three steps. The Tribunal has to first ascertain
what activities the claimant could carry on in spite of the permanent
disability and what he could not do as a result of the permanent ability
(this is also relevant for awarding compensation under the head of loss of
amenities of life). The second step is to ascertain his avocation, profession
and nature of work before the accident, as also his age. The third step is to
find out whether (i) the claimant is totally disabled from earning any kind
of livelihood, or (ii) whether in spite of the permanent disability, the
claimant could still effectively carry on the activities and functions, which
he was earlier carrying on, or (iii) whether he was prevented or restricted
from discharging his previous activities and functions, but could carry on
some other or lesser scale of activities and functions so that he continues
to earn or can continue to earn his livelihood. For example, if the left hand
of a claimant is amputated, the permanent physical or functional
disablement may be assessed around 60%. If the claimant was a driver or
a carpenter, the actual oss of earning capacity may virtually be hundred
percent, if he is neither able to drive or do carpentry. On the other hand, if
the claimant was a clerk in government service, the loss of his left hand
may not result in loss of employment and he may still be continued as a
clerk as he could perform his clerical functions; and in that event the loss
of earning capacity will not be 100% as in the case of a driver or
carpenter, nor 60% which is the actual physical disability, but far less. In
fact, there may not be any need to award any compensation under the head
of `loss of future earnings', if the claimant continues in government
service, though he may be awarded compensation under the head of loss
of amenities as a consequence of losing his hand. Sometimes the injured
claimant may be continued in service, but may not found suitable for
discharging the duties attached to the post or job which he was earlier
holding, on account of his disability, and may therefore be shifted to some
other suitable but lesser post with lesser emoluments, in which case there
should be a limited award under the head of loss of future earning
capacity, taking note of the reduced earning capacity. It may be noted that
when compensation is awarded by treating the loss of future
earning capacity as 100% (or even anything more than 50%), the need to
award compensation separately under the head of loss of amenities or loss
of expectation of life may disappear and as a result, only a token or
nominal amount may have to be awarded under the head of loss
of amenities or loss of expectation of life, as otherwise there may be a
duplication in the award of compensation. Be that as it may. ..............
13. We may now summarise the principles discussed above: (i) All
injuries (or permanent disabilities arising from injuries), do not result in
loss of earning capacity. (ii) The percentage of permanent disability with
reference to the whole body of a person, cannot be assumed to be the
percentage of loss of earning capacity. To put it differently, the percentage
of loss of earning capacity is not the same as the percentage of permanent
disability (except in a few cases, where the Tribunal on the basis of
evidence, concludes that percentage of loss of earning capacity is the same
as percentage of permanent disability). (iii) The doctor who treated an
injured-claimant or who examined him subsequently to assess the extent
of his permanent disability can give evidence only in regard
the extent of permanent disability. The loss of earning capacity is
something that will have to be assessed by the Tribunal with reference to
the evidence in entirety. (iv) The same permanent disability may result in
different percentages of loss of earning capacity in different persons,
depending upon the nature of profession, occupation or job, age,
education and other factors.”
[24]
Expenses relating to treatment, hospitalization, medicines,
transportation, nourishing food, and miscellaneous expenditure In this
connection, PW.1, the claimant and PW.2, the friend of claimant deposed that
due to the accident claimant sustained multiple injuries and got treatment in
four hospitals at Nalchar PHC, Sepahijala, Tripura; TMC and Dr. B. R.
hosptial, Hapania, AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala; and ILS hospital,
Agartala and due to the accident claimant lost his eyes and became blind and
both legs and lower of body of claimant became paralyzed permanently. After
observing the findings of the learned Court below regarding the compensation
on different heads, I am of the opinion that the compensation as assessed by
the Court below is just and proper and there should not be any inference.
[25]
In this case, from the evidence of PWs and from the medical
documents especially from disability certificate marked Ext.5 and especially
from evidence of PW.5 Dr. Dipti Bikash Roy, I find, claimant sustained
permanent disability to the extent of 100% to his eyes and claimant became
100% blind and claimant lost of walking capacity for his whole life and
his disability of spine is 80% and he is paralyzed. From the evidence of PWs
and from Ext.3, I find, claimant had a business of electronic shops. In my
opinion, the disability of the claimant caused his 100% loss of income. A blind
and unable to walk shop owner cannot run his business. Thus, claimant lost
100% income due to the disability from the accident dated 28.11.2016.
[26]
Earlier, the learned Single Judge in MAC. App. No.02 of 2010
regarding proof of income has held as under:
“[10] I have highlighted all these pointes to emphasize the fact that in a
Court of law, even before a Tribunal no reliance can be placed on such a
certificate because such certificate has no statutory backing to it. Such a
certificate is not issued to under any authority of law and as such no Court
should blindly follow the certificate and the income must be assessed on
the
basis of the evidence led by the parties and not on the basis of such
certificates.
[11] As far as the present case is concerned, the claimant was aged about
59 years at the time of the accident. He no doubt was running a ration
shop and he may have invested money in a rubber plantation but I do not
feel that he could have been earning any amount from the rubber
plantation because the same was only about one year. Be that as it may,
keeping in view the fact that the claimant was almost 60 years of age, it
could reasonably be expected that he would be earning about Rs.10,000/per month from such ration shop.”
[27]
The income certificate issued by Dy. Collector and Magistrate,
Melaghar showing income of claimant as Rs.23,654/- per month is accepted in
the light of the certificate issued by the Revenue Department. In this regard I
have interacted with Government Advocate for his assistance; in reply to this
he has submitted that he is the competent authority to cause an inquiry through
Taluka Officials/Revenue Officer to issue certificate regarding proof of income
and since it is statutory power vested upon them, this Court accepts the same.
However, this Court is not inclined to alter the monthly income of the claimant
as assessed by the learned tribunal.
[28]
Now, this Court has to decide who will take the liability of
compensation. In this context, from Ext. B, the Insurance Certificate, I find, the
offending
bike
Engine
No.KC13EGGHK00221,
Chassis
No.MBLKC13ELGHK00-070 was insured with the OP No.3, the National
Insurance Company Ltd from 25.10.2016 to 24.10.2017 covering the date of
accident on 28.11.2016. From Ext. D, the Registration certificate, I find, the
offending vehicle TR-07A-7089, Engine No.KC13EGGHK00221 and Chassis
No.MBLKC13ELGHK00070 was registered. From Ext. A, the temporary
registration certificate, it can be said that offending bike was registered on the
date of accident. Thus, as the offending vehicle was insured with the OP No.3,
the National Insurance Company Ltd., I am of the view that Insurance
Company (OP No.3) is liable to pay compensation.
[29]
Regarding the interest @8% though normally, this Court is fixing
the interest @7.5%, having special consideration to the facts and circumstances
of the case in view of 100% disability of both eyes and 80% disability of spine
and paralysis, the interest @8% stands confirmed. The learned Court below has
awarded Rs.5,00,000/- for future medical expenses which, according to this
Court, is not justifiable. Thus, this Court is of the opinion that for future
medication and medical attendance facility, it would be just and proper if the
amount is reduced from Rs.5,00,000/- to Rs.1,00,000/- and accordingly the
same is ordered. The argument on the point of FIR, complaint and charge-sheet
to say that it is not a case of accident but it is a case of personal grudge and
fight between the claimant and the respondent-owner, is not accepted and on
the point that the claimant is literate but put his thumb impression, it cannot be
a reason for rejecting the claim and allowed the appeal on that ground.
[30]
In the light of the above, this Court is of the view that the
learned Court below has assessed the compensation in a reasonable and
justifiable way. But towards the head of future medical expenses, the
claimant would be entitled to get Rs.1,00,000/- instead of Rs.5,00,000/as awarded by the learned tribunal and rest of the award shall remain
unchanged. In view of above discussion and observation, the present
appeal stands allowed and disposed of to the extent as indicated above.
The insurance company shall deposit the awarded amount within one
month from the date of receipt of the copy of this order and on such
deposit; the claimant is at liberty to withdraw the same unconditionally.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
Draw the decree accordingly and thereafter, send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review