The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. 3. Considering all the aspects of the matter, keeping in mind the settled guidelines in the case of Kerala SRTC Vs Susamma Thomas, (1994) 2 WP(C) No. 142 of 2013 decided by the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura, etc., it is ordered that 50% of the amount of compensation with interest shall be invested in long term fixed deposit in the name of the claimant petitioners for at least 5 years. The rest 50% share of each claimant petitioners shall be released to the claimant petitioners through their individual savings Bank Account held with any nationalized Bank. Also interest that will accrue on the Fixed Deposit amounts may from time to time be paid to the claimant petitioners through their savings bank account.” [5] Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment and award dated 25.11.2022 passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sepahijala District, Bishalgarh in connection with T.S. (MAC) No.33 of 2017, the present appeal has been preferred by the appellant insurance company. [6] Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and also going through the observation made by the learned tribunal below, this Court is of the that the scooty while driving, from behind the truck has came and caused the accident and due to which, death has taken place and accordingly, the claim petition was filed. On behalf of the claimant three witnesses and relevant…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
MAC. App. No.27 of 2023
The National Insurance Company Ltd.
….. Appellant
-V E R S U SSmti. Mana Kanya Debbarma @ Man Kanya Debbarma and 3 Others
.....Respondents.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. A. K. Deb, Advocate.
Mr. T. D. Majumder, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. D. Chowdhury, Advocate.
YES/NO
Judgment and order dated 29th January, 2025
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. A. K. Deb, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
also heard Mr. T. D. Majumder, learned senior counsel and Mr. S. D.
Chowdhury, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This is an appeal filed under Section-173 of Motor Vehicles Act,
against the award dated 25.11.2022 passed by the learned Member, Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Sepahijala District, Bishalgarh in connection with
T.S. (MAC) No.33 of 2017.
[3]
The facts in brief are That on 05.01.2017, Binoy DebBarma, son
of claimant petitioners was expired due to rash and negligently dash given by
TR-01-B-1916 (Truck) at 3.30 p.m. to the Scooty No.TR-07-9466 near
S.B.I.Branch, while said Binoy DebBarma, as pillion rider, was returning to his
house with the rider, Bikash DebBarma. Both were succumbed to their injuries
on 05.01.2017. After accident parents of deceased Binoy DebBarma filed claim
petition U/S.166 of the M.V. Act claiming compensation of Rs.45,13,000/which was registered as T.S.(MAC) 33 of 2017. But Ld. Member, Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal, Sepahijala District, Bishalgarh, most illegally
converted the claim petition from Section-166 to Section-163(A) of M.V. Act
since the claimants could not prove rash and negligent driving of the offending
truck vehicle and even there having no prayer. But, the learned Court below
awarded compensation of Rs.20,36,000/- with 6% interest w.e.f. 16.02.2017
vide award dated 25.11.2022 without following 2nd schedule of Section-163(A)
fixing liability upon O.P.No.2, National Insurance Company Ltd. and
O.P.No.4, the United India Insurance Co. Ltd. jointly and severally.
[4]
The learned Tribunal after hearing the parties and on perusal of
the material evidence on record has observed as under:
“17. In the result, the application u/s 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act
converted into an application u/s 163A of the MV Act, 1988 is hereby
allowed.
17.1. The claimant petitioners are awarded a sum of Rs. Rs.20,36,200/(Rupees Twenty lacs thirty six thousand two hundred) only as
compensation in this case for the death of their son Binoy Debbarma
which they shall receive in equal share i.e. 50% each. The OP No. 2, the
National Insurance Company Ltd. and OP No. 4, the United India
Insurance Company Ltd., Insurers of the scooty bearing no. TR07-9466
and the truck vehicle bearing no. TR-01-B-1916 respectively are jointly
and severally liable to pay the compensation along with simple interest @
6% per annum on the compensation amount from the date of filing this
claim case (i.e. 16.02.2017) until realization. The awarded amount be
transferred by the OP No. 2 & 4 by way of RTGS/NEFT directly to the CD
account of this Tribunal bearing No. 8105050326247 held with the Tripura
Gramin Bank, Office Tilla Branch, Bishalgarh within 30 (thirty) days from
today.
17.2. The OP No. 2 & 4 shall give notice of the deposit of the
compensation amount to the claimant and shall also file a compliance
report with this Tribunal within 15 days of the deposit.
17.3. Considering all the aspects of the matter, keeping in mind the settled
guidelines in the case of Kerala SRTC Vs Susamma Thomas, (1994) 2
SCC 176, as well as case law in Smt. Rupa Roy Vs TSLSA and others in
WP(C) No. 142 of 2013 decided by the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura,
etc., it is ordered that 50% of the amount of compensation with interest
shall be invested in long term fixed deposit in the name of the claimant
petitioners for at least 5 years. The rest 50% share of each claimant
petitioners shall be released to the claimant petitioners through their
individual savings Bank Account held with any nationalized Bank. Also
interest that will accrue on the Fixed Deposit amounts may from time to
time be paid to the claimant petitioners through their savings bank
account.”
[5]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment and award
dated 25.11.2022 passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Sepahijala District, Bishalgarh in connection with T.S. (MAC) No.33
of 2017, the present appeal has been preferred by the appellant insurance
company.
[6]
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties
and also going through the observation made by the learned tribunal
below, this Court is of the that the scooty while driving, from behind the
truck has came and caused the accident and due to which, death has taken
place and accordingly, the claim petition was filed. On behalf of the
claimant three witnesses and relevant documents were examined and
exhibited and the insurer of the scooty i.e. the National Insurance
Company Ltd have submitted their written statement during trial and for
the purpose of reference, the same may be extracted hereunder:
“4. OP No. 2, the National Insurance Company filed W/S on their behalf
and contented that the claim petition is not maintainable and it is frivolous,
baseless and highly speculative and there is no cause of action for the
claimant petitioners to file the instant case against the answering OP No.2.
It is also stated that the liability of answering OP, if any, will always
subject to terms and conditions of policy of Insurance, the Provisions of
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and the rules made thereunder as amended from
time to time. The answering OP did not yet receive any report from the
concerned PS nor any information regarding the alleged accident from the
owner of the scooty bearing no. TR-07-9466. The OP No. 2 also denied
each and every statement, averment and allegations made in the claim
petition except those which are specifically admitted in the W/S and the
claimant petitioners are put to strictest proof. The answering OP have no
knowledge as to whether the rider of the scooty had any valid licence at
the time of accident and the claimants are put to strictest proof that the
rider had valid licence at the time of alleged accident. Further answering
OP is not liable to indemnify any loss or damages sustained by the policy
holder, if the policy condition is violated and breach of policy condition
especially relating to the driving licence and use of the vehicle shall entitle
the answering OP to avoid the liability as per section 149(2) of the MV
Act. The OP No. 2 also specifically denied the age of deceased was 23
years or that he had welding business or that his monthly income was
Rs.18000/- per month or that his employers was Sri Parimal Das or Ashim
Sarkar and the claimant petitioners are required to prove the same by
cogent documentary evidence. Also OP No. 2 stated that amount of
compensation sought at Rs.45,13,000/- is highly exorbitant and excessive.
OP No.2 stated that from the descriptions of claim petition it is crystal
clear that the scooty bearing No. TR-07-9466 had no fault in the alleged
accident and the Truck bearing No. TR-01-B-1916 which was coming
from the back side of the scooty with excessive speed and rash and
negligent manner suddenly dashed the scooty for which the accident
occurred and so the petitioners are not entitled to get any compensation
against the answering OP No.2.”
[7]
It is seen from the record that the scooty was hit from behind
by the truck which was insured by another insurance company i.e. United
India Insurance Company Ltd. and the policy was valid at the time of
accident and in their support they have also filed their written statement.
But the learned Court below while considering the case of the claimant
has converted Section-166 to Section-163A is one line argument made by
the learned counsel appearing for the appellant i.e. the National Insurance
Company Ltd.
[8]
The learned counsel appearing for the respondent-claimant
has submitted that the learned Court below has not committed any error in
conversion since it is a beneficial legislation and it is well within the
jurisdiction of the Court and by following the judgment of the Gujarat
High Court in case of Oriental Insurance Company Ltd v. Chintharbhai
Sibbabhai and Others, reported in 2003 (1) GLH 394 and Narshiji
Nagaji Majirana v. Manigilal Amturam Bishnoi, reported in AIR 2004
Guj. 157.
[9]
The learned counsel appearing for the respondent-insurance
company (insurer of the truck) submits that they are not liable to pay the
compensation as there is no rash and negligence on their part. It is seen
from the evidences and records that the United India Insurance Company
Ltd. has not made any whisperer in their defence on this point but
whereas, there is a categorical averment made in the written statement
filed by the National Insurance Company Ltd. and they have not adduce
any evidence by entering in the witness doc and on the strength of
investigating report only, they tried to advance their submissions.
[10]
Viewed from any angle, this Court is of the considered view
that since the accident has occurred from behind the scooty, it cannot be
said that it is a case of contributory negligence and therefore, the entire
liability is fasten upon the United India Insurance Company Ltd. Insofar
as the quantum of compensation is concerned, it shall remain intact and
only the liability of paying the compensation as awarded by the learned
Court below shall be paid by the United India Insurance Company Ltd.
Further, whatsoever amount is paid by the National Insurance Company
Ltd., the same may be recovered from the United India Insurance
Company Ltd. Accordingly, the finding as arrived at by the learned Court
below is modified to the extent as indicated above.
[11]
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed. Draw the decree accordingly and thereafter, send down the
LCRs forthwith.
T. Amarnath Goud, J
A.Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
GHOSH
Date: 2025.02.05 15:43:36
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review