Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
MAC. App. No.77 of 2022
1.
The National Insurance Company Limited, represented by its
Divisional Manager, Agartala, Divisional Office, A. K. Road, Agartala,
P.O. & P.S. West Agartala, District: West Tripura.
[Insurer of the vehicle bearing No.TR-01-L-1631 (Bolero Maxi)]
….. Appellant
-V E R S U S-
1.
Sri Sribastab Sinha, son of Sri Milan Sinha, resident of villageGopinagar, P.O. & P.S. Bishalgarh, District: Sepahijala Tripura.
.....Claimant-respondent.
2.
Jahangir Hossain, son of Sandu Miah, resident of village Latiachhara,
P.O. & P.S. Bishalgarh, District: Sepahijala Tripura.
[Owner of vehicle bearing No. TR-01-L-1631 (Bolero Maxi)]
.....Owner-respondent
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
:
Mr. S. Debnath, Advocate.
Mr. Alik Das, Advocate.
YES/NO
Judgment and order dated 13th July, 2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. S. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
insurance company also heard Mr. Alik Das, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents.
[2]
This appeal has been filed under Section-173 of the Motor Vehicles
Act, 1988 against the impugned judgment and award dated 07.04.2022 passed by
the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sepahijala District, Bishalgarh, in
connection with T.S. (MAC) 206 of 2015.
[3]
The case in brief is that the claimant petitioner, the claimant-
respondent herein, is on 17.06.2015 at about 1800 to 1830 hours at Gopinagar, on
Bishalgarh-Nabasantiganj Road, when the victim was in front of his house at
Nabasantiganj on Bishalgarh road left out from his residence and in front of his
house at Nabasantiganj, at that time one Mahindra Max bearing registration no.
TR-01-L-1631 coming from Nabasaktiganj market side towards Bishalgarh
dashed the claimant respondent by going into extreme outside of the road and
thereafter lost control of the vehicle and fell in a road side tank. After the accident
the driver of the Max vehicle fled away from the spot and the local people
including TS MAC 206 of 2015 the family members of the claimant shifted him to
Bishalgarh hospital and he was referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital on the same
date i.e. 17.06.2015 and admitted there as an indoor patient. On the next date he
was referred to ILS Hospital. But for better treatment, the family members of the
injured person shifted him to Kolkata in Flemming Hospital where he was
admitted in the hospital on 18.04.2015 to 02.07.2015 as an indoor patient. Due to
the said accident the claimant received injuries on his person especially on his
head and eyes. At the time of discharge he was not totally cured and he was
advised to attend Flemming hospital after one month and till that day his treatment
is continuing.
[4]
It is also claimed that the victim Sri Sribastab Sinha is an able
bodied active man of 26 years and he was an electrician by profession and also
completed Diploma course in ITI. He was performing his various works
throughout the area including some Govt. works. His monthly income is
Rs.15,000/- and he was contributing earning towards his family members. He was
also a job seeker in Electric Department and it was expected that he would make
more and more contribution towards his family had he not injured due to the said
accident. In all, the claimant has prayed for compensation to the tune of Rs.20
lacs.
[5]
In reply, the owner of the vehicle has contested the case by filing
written statement stating that the claim of the claimant-respondent regarding
treatment in various hospitals due to the accident and the accident taking place
due to negligent driving by the driver of the vehicle No.TR-01-L-1631 Maxi is
strongly denied and disputed by OP No. 1. The OP No. 1 has also denied the
averment of the claimant regarding his age, the monthly income of Rs.50,000/- as
an Electrician by occupation and thus asserted that the claim of the claimant is
also exorbitant.
[6]
The learned Tribunal after hearing the parties and on perusal of the
material evidence on record has observed as under:
“11. In the result, the application u/s 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act is
allowed.
11.1. The claimant petitioner(victim) namely Sri Sribastab Sinha is awarded a
sum of Rs. Rs.17,75,100/(Rupees seventeen lacs seventy five thousand one
hundred) only along with a simpleinterest @ 6% per annum on the above
amount from the date of filing this claim case (i.e. 11.08.2015 ) until
realization, as compensation in this case. The OP No.2, the National Insurance
Company Ltd. being the insurer of the offending vehicle bearing No. TR-01L-1631(Bolero Maxi Truck) is hereby directed to pay the said amount of
compensation to the claimant within a period of 30 (thirty) days from today.
The awarded amount be transferred by the OP Insurance Company by way of
RTGS/NEFT directly to the CD account of this Tribunal bearing No.
8105050326247 with IFSC Code -PUNBORRBTGB held with the Tripura
Gramin Bank, Office Tilla Branch, Bishalgarh.
11.2. The OP National Insurance Company Ltd. shall give notice of the
deposit of the compensation amount to the claimant and shall also file a
compliance report with this Tribunal within 15 days of the deposit.
11.3. Since future loss of income is awarded and the compensation awarded
also includes the bulk amount regarding the already incurred expenses by the
claimant petitioner who is a literate person, keeping in mind the settled law in
Kerala SRTC Vs Susamma Thomas (1994) 2SCC 176, as well as case law in
Smt. Rupa Roy Vs TSLSA and others in WPC No. 142 of 2013 decided by
the Hon'ble High Court of Tripura, etc., in regard to disbursement ofthe
compensation award, it is directed that 50% of the awarded amount shall be
kept in fixed deposit for at least 5 years and the rest 50% with the accrued
interest thereon shall be paid immediately to the claimant petitioner through
his individual Savings Bank Account held with any nationalised Bank.
11.4. The claimant petitioner is directed to produce the savings Bank Pass
Book as well as Aadhaar Card and PAN Card and 2 passport size photographs
and specimen signature of herself before this Tribunal on the next date fixed
for report of compliance of the award by the OP Insurance Company.
11.5. Furnish a copy of this Award expeditiously and not later than 15 days
from today to the claimant petitioner (hard copy) as well as to the OP No. 2,
the National Insurance Company Ltd. through their email (soft copy).
11.6. Also send a copy of this Award to the concerned Trial Court of the
Magistrate in which the criminal case for rash or negligent driving against the
driver of the offending vehicle may be pending, if any.”
[7]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment
and award dated 07.04.2022 passed by the learned Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, in connection with T.S. (MAC) 206 of 2015, the present appeal has been
preferred by the appellant-insurance company.
[8]
Mr. S. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for the appellant-
insurance company has stated that the tribunal below committed grave error of
law and in defiance of the settled proposition of law as decided by the Apex Court
as well as this Court and most illegally and in a perverse manner passed a punitive
and exorbitant award against the insurance company which is not sustainable in
the eye of law. Without any definite proof of income and documentary evidence
determined the monthly income of the claimant-respondent to the extent of
Rs.10,000/-pm.
[9]
The tribunal below without applying his judicious mind most
illegally and in a perverse manner without any definite proof of income and
without any supporting evidence whimsically decided the monthly income of the
claimant respondent to the extent of Rs.10,000/- pm which is liable to be set aside.
The learned tribunal in flagrant disregard of law and failure of justice and in
defiance of settled proposition of law in an arbitrary and perverse manner by his
own whims most illegally and beyond his jurisdiction accepted 40% functional
disability, in contrary to the disability certificate issued by the District Disability
Medical Board, West Tripura Agartala wherein, it has been mentioned that the
claimant-respondent sustained low vision disability to his single eye to the extent
of 30%.
[10]
The learned tribunal committed a grave error of law while assessing
and determining the loss of earning capacity of the claimant-respondent resulted
from 30% partial disability of his one eye to the 40% is perverse and arbitrary and
unsustainable in the eye of law and in this way vitiated the entire approach of the
judgment and award ad is liable to be set aside. The learned tribunal ought to have
considered that the disability certificate issued by the District Disability Board
West Tripura recommended assessment after 5 years but, the Court below
considering the contradicted statement of the doctor who adduced his evidence as
PW-2 decided the functional disability to the extent of 40%.
[11]
The appellant insurance company denied the assertions of the
claimant regarding age, injury, lodging of criminal case with the Bishalgarh PS,
nature and injury sustained by the claimant and submitted that the claimant have
to prove all these facts. It has been further stated that the owner of the vehicle has
to produce all documents of the vehicle including the Driving Licence of the
driver and the valid Insurance Policy in original for the vehicle No. TR-01-L1631. The appellant stated that that they are liable to pay any compensation to the
claimant and the contention of the claimant is baseless having no ground at all and
so the appeal may be allowed. However, their last stated that if this Tribunal fixes
any liability against the Insurance Company, the rate of interest should be below
6%.
[12]
On perusal of the documentary evidence, namely, Exhibit-1 to
Exhibit 4 it is very clear that the said victim Sribastab Sinha had sustained injuries
on 17.06.2015 due to vehicular accident caused by the driver of the vehicle
bearing No. TR-01-L-1631(Mahindra Maxi) on Bishalgarh-Naba Saktiganj road
for which Bishalgarh PS case No. 68 of 2015 under Sections-279/338 of IPC and
Section-187 of MV Act was registered on the written ejahar filed by the brother of
the claimant-respondent Sri Sibeswar Sinha vide Exhibit-1 and final report/charge
sheet No. 90 of 2015 dated 27.08.2015 of Bishalgarh PS for offence under
Sections-279/338 of IPC along with section 183/187 of MV Act against the driver
namely Sasankar Shil alias Sankar alias Subhas Shil was filed vide Exhibit-2.
[13]
From Exhibit-6, injury report of the victim issued from Bishalgarh
S.D. Hospital , it appears that the claimant Sribastab Sinha was taken to that
hospital on 17.06.2015 with multiple trauma following RTA and 3 numbers of
injuries on his person have been noted in this injury report. From Exhibit-5,
another medical injury report issued from AGMC & GBP Hospital it appears that
Sribastab Sinha was admitted in that hospital on 17.06.2015 at 8.34 p.m. in MS I
Ward after referred from Bishalgarh SD Hospital and a lacerated wound on left
front parietal area of scalp which was grievous in nature was sustained by
Sribastab Sinha and he was referred to ILS Hospital on 18.06.2015 for further
treatment.
[14]
The Court has to make a judicious attempt to award damages, so as
to compensate the claimant for the loss suffered by him. Such compensation is
what is termed as just compensation. The compensation should not be assessed
very conservatively, but on the other hand, compensation should not be assessed
in so liberal a fashion to make it a bounty to the claimant. The Court while
assessing the compensation should have regard to the degree of deprivation and
the loss caused by such deprivation.
[15]
During argument learned counsel for the claimant respondent urged
that proper compensation be awarded to the claimant based on his monthly
income as he was an electrician at the time of accident and that his family consists
of his parents including the claimant-respondent. Broadly speaking, while fixing
the amount of compensation payable to a victim of an accident, the damages have
to be assessed separately as pecuniary damages and special damages. Pecuniary
damages are those which the victim has actually incurred and which are capable of
being calculation in terms of money.
[16]
From the Exhibit 6, it appears that just after the accident the
claimant was attended to Bishalgarh Sub Divisional Hospital on 17.06.2015 and
after some treatment there he was referred to AGMC for further management.
From Exhibit 5, it appears that the claimant was admitted in AGMC & GBP
Hospital on 17.06.2015 at 8.34 p.m. and he was referred to ILS Hospital, Agartala
on 18.06.2015 for further treatment. Considering the gravity of the injury and for
the purpose of better treatment his family members shifted him to Kolkata
Flemming Hospital and he was admitted in the Flemming Hospital on 18.06.2015
and treated there till 02.07.2015 as an indoor patient and in course of treatment in
that hospital a major operation was conducted. He also stated that even after
discharge he was still continuing his treatment and plastic surgery was conducted
on his face and head. For the purpose of treatment near about Rs. 4 lacs has
already been spent.
[17]
The claimant-respondent in his pleadings as well as oral evidence
claimed that when the accident happened he was earning Rs.15,000/- per month
by way of his occupation as an Electrician and that he is a Diploma from ITI.
However, he has not produced any documentary evidence regarding his monthly
earning. It is not in dispute that at the time of accident the claimant was about 25
years old ( his date of birth was on 01.06.1989) as recorded in Exhibit-8 and also
as per his Admit Card of his Madhymik Examination in 2007 which is found on
record. So in absence of any documentary evidence regarding his monthly
income, the tribunal has to make an assessment, mostly by way of guess work.
Having regard to the age and educational qualification and the oral evidence of the
claimant, this Court is of the opinion that the amount as assessed by the tribunal
below is just and proper. In this regard, the principle as laid down in a case of
Ramchandrapp v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Company
Limited, reported in (2011) 13 SCC 236, wherein, the Court held thus:
“13. In the instant case, it is not in dispute that the appellant was aged about
35 years and was working as a Coolie and was earning `4500/- per month at
the time of accident. This claim is reduced by the Tribunal to a sum of `3000/only on the assumption that wages of the labourer during the relevant period
viz. in the year 2004, was `100/- per day. This assumption in our view has no
basis. Before the Tribunal, though Insurance Company was served, it did not
choose to appear before the Court nor did it repudiated the claim of the
claimant. Therefore, there was no reason for the Tribunal to have reduced the
claim of the claimant and determined the monthly earning a sum of `3000/per month. Secondly, the appellant was working as a Coolie and therefore, we
cannot expect him to produce any documentary evidence to substantiate his
claim. In the absence of any other evidence contrary to the claim made by the
claimant, in our view, in the facts of the present case, the Tribunal should
have accepted the claim of the claimant. We hasten to add that in all cases and
in all circumstances, the Tribunal need not accept the claim of the claimant in
the absence of supporting material. It depends on the facts of each case. In a
given case, if the claim made is so exorbitant or if the claim made is contrary
to ground realities, the Tribunal may not accept the claim and may proceed to
determine the possible income by resorting to some guess work, which may
include the ground realities prevailing at the relevant point of time. In the
present case, appellant was working as a Coolie and in and around the date of
the accident, the wage of the labourer was between `100/- to 150/- per day or
`4500/- per month. In our view, the claim was honest and bonafide and,
therefore, there was no reason for the Tribunal to have reduced the monthly
earning of the appellant from `4500/- to `3000/- per month. We, therefore,
accept his statement that his monthly earning was `4500/-.”
[18]
On consideration of all the facts and circumstances including the
fact that the claimant is still capable of earning by way of doing any other suitable
job/work even if he cannot effectively do the work of Electrician after the accident
and also it might be that the claimant is in a position to undertake the work of
Electrician but he may not be able to produce the amount of work which he could
do before the accident.
[19]
In the light of the above, this Court is of the view that the
learned Court below has assessed the compensation in a reasonable and
justifiable way. In view of above discussion and observation, the present
appeal stands dismissed consequently, the award of compensation as
assessed by the learned tribunal stands affirmed. The insurance company
shall deposit the awarded amount within one month from the date of receipt
of the copy of this order, if not already deposited and on such deposit; the
claimant-respondent is at liberty to withdraw the same unconditionally. As a
sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed. Draw the
decree accordingly and thereafter, send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
signed
ANJAN Digitally
by ANJAN GHOSH
2023.07.25
GHOSH Date:
12:57:32 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review