The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. The LA Collector, West Tripura District, Agartala ---Pro-forma-Respondent For Petitioner(s) For Respondent(s) Date of hearing and date of judgment and order Whether fit for reporting : Mr. B. N. Majumder, Sr. Adv. Mr. P. Debbarma, Adv. : Mr. S. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv. Mr. U. K. Majumder, Adv. : 03.05.2023. : No HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD Judgment & Order (Oral) This is an appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, read with Order XLI of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 against the judgment and award dated 08.11.2019, passed by Ld. LA Judge, West Tripura Judicial District, Agartala in Case No. MISC (L.A) 57 of 2016. [2] The appellant submitted that Government acquired certain lands under Notification No.F.9(12)-REV/ACQ/VI/07 dated 12.10.2007 for the purpose of construction of road from Banikya Chowmuhani to Industrial Growth Centre Gate. [3] The compensation of the acquired land (0.035 acres) was assessed by the LA Collector @ Rs.5 lakhs per kani and total amount of Rs.67,993/inclusive of other statutory benefits was awarded to the original claimants. [4] Being dissatisfied, the claimants prayed for reference through their attorney and ultimately to court of Land Acquisition Judge (Court No.1), West Tripura Judicial District, Agartala. [5] The claimants claimed the value of land @ 40 lakhs per kani. According to the claimants, the acquired land was a road side …
08. 11.2019 by the LA Judge, West Tripura Judicial District, Agartala in Case No. Misc (LA) 57 of 2016. [14] Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted through his plaint that after the trial the Ld. Reference Judge passed the judgment and award dated 08.11.02019, whereby the compensation was enhanced to the rate of Rs.30,00,000/- (rupees thirty lakhs) per kani only for the acquired. The claimants will also get 30% solatium, and 12% further enhanced amount of compensation upon the said enhanced land value computing from the date of notification under section 4 of LA Act, 1894 upto the date of award by collector or the date of taking possession of land whichever is earlier, as per section 23(2) and section 23(1-A) of the Act respectively. The claimants will further get interest @ 9% per annum from the date of taking over possession for one year and thereafter @ 15% per annum after expiry of said one year till payment upon said excess amount of compensation as per section 28 of the Act. As per law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mehrawal Khewaji Trust, Faridkot & Ors. vs. State of Punjab & Ors. 2012 AIR SCW 2822 , the interest will also be counted on additional amount as awarded under section 23(1A) above the upon the solatium awarded under section 23(2) of the Act. The claimants will also get Rs.1000/- as cost under section 27 of the A…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
LA App 02 of 2023
The Managing Director, TIDC,
Industry Building, 3rd Floor,
Gurkhabasti, Police Station, New Capital
Complex, West Tripura
---Appellant
Versus
1. Sri Uttam Paul,
2. Sri Goutam Paul,
3. Sri Soutam Paul,
All sons of Late Sunil Chandra Paul, All are residents of Khas Noagaon,
Radhakishorenagar, Banikya Chowmuhani, PS; Bodhjungnagar,
District: West Tripura
4. Smti Sikha Rani Paul
W/o Late Jatindra Debnath
W/o Sri Adhir Paul
Resident of Durganagar, PS: Rani Bazar, District: West Tripura
---Respondent
5. The LA Collector, West Tripura District, Agartala
---Pro-forma-Respondent
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
and date of
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. B. N. Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. P. Debbarma, Adv.
: Mr. S. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.
Mr. U. K. Majumder, Adv.
: 03.05.2023.
: No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order (Oral)
This is an appeal under Section 54 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894,
read with Order XLI of Civil Procedure Code, 1908 against the judgment and
award dated 08.11.2019, passed by Ld. LA Judge, West Tripura Judicial District,
Agartala in Case No. MISC (L.A) 57 of 2016.
[2]
The appellant submitted that Government acquired certain lands
under Notification No.F.9(12)-REV/ACQ/VI/07 dated 12.10.2007 for the purpose
of construction of road from Banikya Chowmuhani to Industrial Growth Centre
Gate.
[3]
The compensation of the acquired land (0.035 acres) was assessed
by the LA Collector @ Rs.5 lakhs per kani and total amount of Rs.67,993/inclusive of other statutory benefits was awarded to the original claimants.
[4]
Being dissatisfied, the claimants prayed for reference through their
attorney and ultimately to court of Land Acquisition Judge (Court No.1), West
Tripura Judicial District, Agartala.
[5]
The claimants claimed the value of land @ 40 lakhs per kani.
According to the claimants, the acquired land was a road side land as the
acquisition was done for widening the road from Banikya Chowmuhani to
Industrial Growth Centre and several institution like Cattle firms, Growth centre
NEPCO, TSR Headquarters, Banikya Chowmuhani Bazar, R.K Nagar PHC, Dugra
Chowdhury Para, School, Colleges, Bodhjungnagar Police Station, Post Office etc.
were nearer to the acquired land. They also stated that for the same purpose,
some lands of another mouja called R.K. Nagar mouja were also acquired which
fall on another side of said road and a common proceeding was taken up by L.A.
Collector as lands under said both the moujas bear similar advantages and
potentiality. It is further stated that the acquired land had high potential value
having all urban facilities conjoined with that land. It is also mentioned that the
acquired land is situated within 2nd schedule land i.e. tribal land and thus,
sufficient sale deeds are not available there, but according to the claimants, some
lands of adjacent R.K. Nagar mouja were also acquired for the same purpose
wherein sale transaction took place and said RK Nagar mouja is situated on one
side of the road and Laxmipur mouja is situated on the other side of the road
having similar potential value and similar land valuation. The initiation of common
proceeding for Laxmipur mouja and RK Nagar Mouja is also admitted by the LA.
Collector.
[6]
The LA Collector in his counter statement stated that the acquired
land is 15 km away from Khayerpur Bazar as well as National Highway and 6km
away from Bazar, and the acquired land is situated within rural area where only
one small market having some shops at Banikya Chowmuhani, has developed.
However, LA Collector admitted that there is a school namely, Rajib Gandhi H. S.
School located in the south of the proposed road which is little bit away from
Banikya Chowmuhani and that some homesteads, office of ARDD Department and
some paddy field are also available on both sides of the proposed road. According
to him, the acquired land had no potential value and modern facilities are also not
available in that locality. LA Collector however admitted that sufficient sale deeds
are not available in Laxmipur mouja as it falls within second schedule land for
which they also collected sale deeds from RK Nagar mouja to assess the
compensation and also called for one enquiry report from SDM, Sadar regarding
prevailing land valuation of that area. It is further stated that the LA Collector
considered 7 nos. of sale deeds before determining the compensation and
sufficient compensation was awarded. The requiring department also supported
the version of LA Collector stating that just and proper compensation was awarded
to the claimants by the LA Collector after considering seven nos. of sale
transactions of that area and also considering report of SDM, Sadar. Apart
therefrom, the LA collector also collected further sale instances to arrive at just
decision. Thus according to them, sufficient award was given.
[7]
Based on records the hearing the parties, the following issues were
framed thereafter(1) Is the award passed by LA Collector inadequate, if so, what should be the
just amount of compensation and who is/are liable to pay the same?
(2) To what other reliefs are the parties entitled?
[8]
The LA Judge, had the occasion to observe that the claimants proved
copy of Sale Deed No.1-447 dated 11.01.2005 under Exbt.1 by which a land area
of 0.01 acre of vitti class from R.S. Plot No.2181/8909 was sold out for
Rs.75,000/- (Rs.30,00,000/- per kani). By Exbt.2 i.e. the Sale Deed No.1-117
dated 04.01.2002 a land area of 0.01 acre of viti class was sold out from R.S. plot
No.2181/8909 for Rs.50,000/- i.e. Rs.20,00,000/- per kani. Similarly vide Exbt.3
i.e. the Sale Deed No.1-118 dated 04.01.2002 a land area of 0.01 acre of class viti
was sold out from R.S. Plot No.2181/8909 for Rs.50,000/- per kani. The Opposite
Party did not prove any Sale Deed in this case. All the sale transactions was
relating to land under R.K. Nagar Mouja but our present acquired land is Laxmipur
mouja. In the assessment note, L.A. Collector has mentioned the following :“This is a common proceeding for determination of the value of land
measuring 0.632 acre in mouja Laxmipur sheet
No.1/p
&
land
measuring 0.785 acre in mouja R.K. Nagar sheet No.3/p respectively
under Sadar Sub-Division in the method as indicated under section 23 of the
L.A. Act for construction of road from Banikya Choumohani to
Industrial Growth Centre Gate.
The common proceeding has been taken up for the reason that the
land of both the projects of Laxmipur sheet No.1/p & in mouja R.K. Nagar
sheet No.3/p possess similar advantages, character & potential possibilities.
Notifications u/s.4 of the L.A. Act in respect of the
land
under
Laxmipur sheet No.1/p was issued by the Govt. in the Rev.
Deptt.
Vide
No.F.9(12)-REV/ACQ/VI/2007 dated 12.10.2007 and
declaration
u/s.
of
the
L.A.
Act
was
also
issued
vide
No.9(12)-REV/ACQ/VI/2007 dated 26.12.2007.
Similarly, Notifications u/s. 4 of the L.A. Act in respect of the land
under
mouja
R.K.
Nagar
sheet
No.3/p
was
issued
vide
No.F.9(8)-REV/ACQ/VI/2007 dated 04.10.2007 and
the
declaration
U/S.6
of
the
L.A.
Act
issued
by
the Rev.
Deptt.
Vide
No.F.9(8)-REV/ACQ/VI/2007
dated 26.12.2007.
Notifications
&
Declarations
of
both
the proceedings
as
issued
were
duly
published in the local dailies.”
[9]
L.A. Collector awarded compensation for acquired lands under
Laxmipur Mouja and R.K. Nagar Mouja @ Rs.5,00,000/- per kani for commercial
class of land and @ Rs.4,00,000/- per kani for non-commercial class of land. Thus,
it is evident that whatever rate will be given in respect of acquired land under R.K.
Nagar Mouja, similar rate should be given in respect of acquired land under
Laxmipur Mouja. The lands under both the moujas, according to L.A. Collector,
appears similar potential value.
[10]
Earlier awards were passed in some cases by Ld. L.A. Judge, West
Tripura, Agartala which were ultimately challenged before the Hon'ble High Court
in said L.A. APP No.35/2014, L.A. APP. 04 of 2014, C.O.(FA) No.06 of 2014, L.A.
APP No.05 of 2014, L.A. APP No.11 of 2015 and L.A. APP No.13 of 2015 and the
Hon'ble High Court by a common judgment dated 03.01.2018 passed in L.A. APP.
No.35 of 2014 was pleased to observe as follows :“Having considered all aspect of the matter, this Court is of the
view that the acquired land under the commercial category or
referred as the commercial area shall bring the rate at Rs.30,00,000/per kani whereas the acquired land land fallen in the non commercial
category or as referred as the non commercial area shall bring the rate at
Rs.20,00,000/- per kani. For purpose of enhancement the development
index vis-a-vis the acceleration of rate has been considered having
due regard to the sale deeds (Exbt.1 series). Hence, the appellant and the
cross objector shall get the rate in terms of the above.
In view of this, L.A. App. No.04 of 2014 and L.A. App. No.05 of 2014
are dismissed. All the appeals and the cross objection filed by the referring
-claimant-appellants are allowed in terms of the above inference.
It
is
made clear that the rate as declared above is applicable for the
acquired land concerned with the appeals and the cross objection
filed by the referring claimants.”
[11]
In the said judgment sale exemplars under present Exbt.1, Exbt.2
and Exbt.3 were also discussed and appreciated. In our present case the award
given by the L.A. Collector was @ Rs.12,50,000/- per acre i.e. @ Rs.5,00,000/per kani treating the acquired land to be commercial class of land. Thus, in view of
the judgment of Hon'ble High Court, the present claimants are also entitled to get
compensation for the acquired land @ Rs.30,00,000/- per kani. Said decision or
determination of compensation was made by a higher court which is not only
binding upon the parties but it is also binding on this Court as a matter of judicial
discipline and as such the same is required to be maintained in the present case
also.
[12]
Finally, by the order dated 08.11.2019, the LA Judge, West Tripura
Judicial District, Agartala has passed the following order:
Now, therefore, the reference is allowed. The claimants are entitled
to get compensation @ Rs.30,00,000/- (rupees thirty lakhs) per kani only for the
acquired. The claimants will also get 30% Solatium, and 12% further enhanced
amount of compensation upon the said enhanced land value computing from the
date of notification under section 4 of L.A. Act, 1894 upto the date of award by
Collector or the date of taking possession of land whichever is earlier, as per section
23(2) and section 23(1-A) of the Act respectively. The claimants will further get
interest @ 9% per annum from the date of taking over possession for one year and
thereafter @ 15% per annum after expiry of said one year till payment upon said
excess amount of compensation as per section 28 of the Act. As per law laid down by
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Mehrawal Khewaji Trust, Faridkot & ors. V. State of Punjab
& ors.,2012 AIR SCW 2822, the interest will also be counted on additional amount as
awarded under section 23(1A) above and upon the solatium awarded under section
23(2) of the Act.
The claimants will also get Rs.1000/- as cost under section 27 of the
Act. The Opp. Party no.1 is also made jointly and severally liable to make the
payment along with Opp. Party no.2.
It requires to mention here that though Uttam Paul has claimed
himself to be the attorney of other claimants but no deed of power of attorney
has been proved by him in this case.
[13]
Being aggrieved by the judgment and award dated 08.11.2019
by LA Judge, West Tripura Judicial District, Agartala in Case No. Misc (LA) 57 of
2016, the appellant has approached this court for staying the impugned the
judgment and award dated 08.11.2019 till disposal of the instant appeal and
subsequently for setting aside
the
impugned judgment and order dated
08.11.2019 by the LA Judge, West Tripura Judicial District, Agartala in Case No.
Misc (LA) 57 of 2016.
[14]
Mr. B. N. Majumder, learned senior counsel appearing for the
appellant has submitted through his plaint that after the trial the Ld. Reference
Judge passed the judgment and award dated 08.11.02019, whereby the
compensation was enhanced to the rate of Rs.30,00,000/- (rupees thirty lakhs)
per kani only for the acquired. The claimants will also get 30% solatium, and 12%
further enhanced amount of compensation upon the said enhanced land value
computing from the date of notification under section 4 of LA Act, 1894 upto the
date of award by collector or the date of taking possession of land whichever is
earlier, as per section 23(2) and section 23(1-A) of the Act respectively. The
claimants will further get interest @ 9% per annum from the date of taking over
possession for one year and thereafter @ 15% per annum after expiry of said one
year till payment upon said excess amount of compensation as per section 28 of
the Act. As per law laid down by Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mehrawal Khewaji
Trust, Faridkot & Ors. vs. State of Punjab & Ors. 2012 AIR SCW 2822 , the interest
will also be counted on additional amount as awarded under section 23(1A) above
the upon the solatium awarded under section 23(2) of the Act. The claimants will
also get Rs.1000/- as cost under section 27 of the Act. The Opp. Party No.1 is also
made jointly and severally liable to make the payment along with Opp. Party No.2.
[15]
It is also contended by Mr. B.N. Majumder, learned senior counsel
that the impugned judgment and award suffers from illegality. According to him,
the learned court below has erred in both facts and law and passed the impugned
judgment and award most illegality. He further contended that the learned court
below did not consider that the land acquired did not have amenities of modern
facilities like electricity, water supply, telephone, post office, market, school,
hospital, govt. office etc.
[16]
On the contrary, Mr. U. K. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for
the respondents while objecting to the averment as advanced by the counsel for
the appellant has stated that the judgment and award dated 08.11.2019 is just
and proper and needs no interference by this court.
[17]
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on record. It is evident
from the record that the lower court was of the view that the claimants are
entitled to get compensation @ Rs.30,00,000/- (rupees thirty lakhs) per kani only
for the acquired. The claimants will also get 30% Solatium, and 12% further
enhanced amount of compensation upon the said enhanced land value computing
from the date of notification under section 4 of L.A. Act, 1894 upto the date of
award by Collector or the date of taking possession of land whichever is earlier, as
per section 23(2) and section 23(1-A) of the Act respectively. The claimants will
further get interest @ 9% per annum from the date of taking over possession for
one year and thereafter @ 15% per annum after expiry of said one year till
payment upon said excess amount of compensation as per section 28 of the Act.
[18]
In view of the above observation and finding of the Court below, this
Court is of the opinion that the award as reached by the Court below vide
judgment and award dated 08.11.2019 is based on valid reasons and findings and
the same needs no interference.
[19]
In view of the above, this instant appeal is dismissed. The judgment
and award dated 08.11.2019 passed in Misc(L.A.)57 of 2016 is upheld as the
same is just and proper.
[20]
Stay order, if any, stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any, also
stands disposed of. Return the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review