Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP No.18 of 2023
The Managing Director,
North Bengal State Transport Corporation,
North Bengal Bus Depot, Malaguri, Pradhan Nagar,
P.O and P.S- Coochbihar, District-Coochbihar,
Siliguri, West Bengal-736101,
(owner of vehicle bearing registration NO.WB-632270,Bus).
…….Opposite Party-Appellant.
Versus
1. Smt. Nilu Saha,
W/O. Late Sanjit Saha.
2. Ms. Nandita Saha,
D/O. Late Sanjit Saha.
3. Master Raj Saha,
S/O. Late Sanjit Saha,
All are residents of South Dhaleswar, near Water supply Road,
P.O- College Tilla, P.S. East Agartala, District- West Tripura799004 (Claimant-respondent No.2 and 3 being minor are
represented by their natural guardian, mother Smt. Nilu Saha).
……..Claimant-Respondents.
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. T.K. Deb, Adv,
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Alik Das, Adv,
Date of Hearing
:
18.01.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
25.01.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICEBISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment &Order
The
Managing
Director,
North
Bengal
State
Transport Corporation Limited is present before the High
Court as appellant. The appellant has preferred this appeal
under Section 173 of Motor Vehicles Act challenging the
award dated 24.08.2022 passed in T.S.(MAC) 46 of 2014
by Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.1, West
Tripura, Agartala for modification of the award impugned.
Before analyzing the appeal on merit, let us visit the
subject matter of the case.
02.
The respondent claimants have filed one
petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act
claiming compensation by an amount of Rs.49,00,000/(Rupees forty nine lakhs only) for the death of one Sanjit
Saha in a vehicular accident on 27.01.2012 at around
1330 hours while said Sanjit Saha was coming from
coochbihar City to BSF Camp at Sonari by riding his bicycle through coochbihar Alipur Road and on the way the
offending vehicle bearing No.W.B-63-2270(Bus) of
North
Bengal State Transport Corporation being driven by the
driver rashly and negligently dashed against the said Sanjit
Saha for which he sustained grievous injuries on his head
and other parts of his body and was shifted to coochbihar
Hospital by BSF authority. Since the physical condition of
the victim was deteriorated, so, he was referred to Siliguri
Hospital. But on 31.01.2012 in course of his treatment, the
victim succumbed to his injuries in Siliguri Hospital.
Further according to the respondent-claimants, at the time
of death deceased was aged about 44 years and he used
to earn Rs.23,093/- (Rupees twenty three thousand and
ninety three only) per month and hence, the respondentclaimants filed the claim petition. The appellant as O.P.
inspite of receiving summons although appeared but did
not file any written statement and as such by a judgment
dated 12.04.2016 an amount of Rs.34,92,341/- along with
9% interest was awarded against the present appellant
from the date of filing the petition till payment. After that,
a condonation petition was filed but that was also rejected
and thereafter, the present appellant preferred a revision
petition before the High Court and the High Court vide
order dated 19.06.2020 passed in CRP 99 of 2019 set
aside the order passed in the condonation petition and
directed the Court to hear the application under Order IX
Rule 13 of CPC to set aside exparte award dated
12.04.2016 and the present case was restored to file
before the Learned Tribunal and the appellant contested
the proceeding by filing written statement. Before the
Learned Tribunal the following issues were framed:
“(1)Did deceased Sanjit Saha die in a road
traffic accident occurred on 27.01.2012 at
1330 hours near BSR Campus Sonari of 181
Bn. BSF on Cooch Behar, Alipurduar Road
under Kotwali P.S., Cooch Behar, West
Bengal out of use of vehicle bearing
registration No.WB-63-2270 (Bus) due to
rash and negligent driving by its driver?
(2) Are the petitioners entitled to get
compensation, as prayed for and if so, to
what amount and who is liable to pay the
same?
(3) To what other reliefs the parties are
entitled?”
03.
To substantiate the case the respondent claimant-
petitioner No.1 Nilu Saha was examined as PW-1 and relied
upon some documents which were marked as exhibits in the
case, on the other hand, on behalf of the appellant one
Sampad Das, UD Clerk of North Bengal State Transport
Corporation was examined as OPW-1 and he also relied upon
some documents which were marked as exhibits-A to H and
finally, Learned Tribunal after hearing both the sides passed
an award for an amount of Rs.34,92,341/- along with 9%
interest per annum from the date of filing the petition till
recovery and challenging that judgment the appellant is
before the High Court by filing this appeal.
04.
In course of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
appellant submitted that the Learned Tribunal
without
making any observation and findings allowed the claim
petition which needs to be interfered with and there was no
eye witness of the alleged occurrence of offence and the
claimant-petitioner No.1 was at Agartala at the time of
accident, so although she later on filed a claim petition, so,
legally there is no scope to place any reliance upon the FIR
laid
by
the
claimant-petitioner
No.1.
Further,
Learned
Counsel drawn the attention of the Court referring the postmortem report of the deceased and submitted that there is
no indication that the deceased expired due to road traffic
accident rather from the contents of the post mortem report,
it appears that the deceased expired due to head injury
which was ante mortem in nature and according to Learned
Counsel this injury could sustain by any other means but the
claimant-petitioner has failed to prove that the deceased
succumbed to his injuries due to the road traffic accident of
the offending vehicle of the appellant. Learned Counsel
further drawn the attention of the Court that the claimantpetitioner before the Learned Tribunal save and except Voter
ID Card could not produce any other documentary evidence
to substantiate the age of the deceased but the Learned
Tribunal determined the age of the deceased as 45 years at
the time of death and applied multiplier 13 but according to
the appellant at the time of accident the age of the deceased
would be 46 years and in that case multiplier would be 14,
which the Learned Tribunal failed to consider at the time of
determination of compensation. Learned Counsel further
submitted that only the salary certificate was produced by
the claimant-petitioner in support of their claim but the
Issuing Authority of the salary certificate was not produced
to prove the salary certificate. So, legally there is no scope
to place any reliance upon that and finally, Learned Counsel
for the appellant submitted that since the respondentclaimants failed to prove their case before the Learned
Tribunal, so, urged he before this Court to set aside the
award passed by the Learned Tribunal. On the other hand,
Learned Counsel for the respondent-claimants submitted that
on the day of alleged accident the respondent claimantpetitioner No.1 was available at Siliguri and she laid the FIR
on the same day i.e. on 27.01.2012 and on the issue of
accident, a police case was registered vide Kotwali P.S case
No.50 of 2012 under Section 279/338/427 of IPC and finally
the case was ended in charge-sheet.
05.
Furthermore, according to Learned Counsel for
the respondent-claimants, the accident report as relied upon
by the appellant O.P. before the Learned Tribunal clearly
shows the involvement of the offending vehicle of the
appellant O.P. in connection with the matter and the Learned
Tribunal after taking into consideration all aspects rightly and
reasonably delivered the award in favour of the respondentclaimants of the case which needs no interference and urged
before the Court to uphold the judgment of Learned Tribunal.
06.
I have heard arguments of both the sides and
gone through the record of the Learned Tribunal below.
There is no dispute on record that the alleged accident took
place on 27.01.2012 and due to that accident, the deceased
victim
sustained
severe
injuries
and
ultimately,
he
succumbed to his injuries on 31.01.2021. It is also on record
that earlier the Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal by an exparte award dated 12.04.2016 awarded a
sum of Rs. 34,92,341/-(Rupees thirty-four lakhs ninety-two
thousand three hundred forty-one only) with 9% interest per
annum which was challenged before the Hon’ble High Court
and later on, as per direction of the Hon’ble High Court, the
present appellant contested the case and adduced evidences.
Thereafter, by a fresh judgment dated 24.08.2022 the
concerned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West
Tripura, Agartala also awarded the said amount in favour of
the respondent-claimants of the case.
07.
In course of hearing of arguments, Learned
Counsel for the appellant raised some issues which I have
discussed above. I have gone through the record of the
Learned Tribunal below and it appears that on the day of
accident i.e. on 27.01.2012, the respondent claimantpetitioners No.1 laid one FIR to Officer-in-Charge of Kotwali
P.S., Cooch Behar. Showing her address at Government
Quarter No.8, Type-II, 181 Bn. B.S.F., Sonari, District Cooch
Behar and on the same day the Officer-in-Charge of the said
P.S. at about 2125 hours registered kotwali P.S. case No. 50
of 2012
under
Section 279/338/427
of
IPC.
So, the
submission of Learned Counsel for the appellant cannot be
accepted that no FIR was laid on the day of alleged accident.
Learned Counsel for the appellant further submitted that no
eye witness was examined, who were present to the P.O. at
the time of accident. In this regard, it is submitted that we
are dealing with a compensation case not a Criminal Trial so
it is the subject matter of the Police Authority to investigate
the criminal case and thereafter to file charge sheet or final
report as the case may be. But in the given case we are to
see as to whether the respondent-claimants are entitled to
compensation or not. It is on record that during trial the
respondent claimant-petitioners before the Learned Tribunal
relied upon FIR, seizure list, Post mortem examination report
and the copy of charge sheet and from the charge sheet it
appears that regarding the alleged incident after completion
of investigation the I.O. of that case laid charge sheet under
Section 279/338/427/304(A) of IPC against the driver Shri
Hari Mahanta. And from post mortem examination report
further, it appears that on the basis of Matigara P.S. U/D
Case No.83 of 2012 the concerned Medical Officer conducted
post mortem over the dead body of the deceased and from
the report of I.O., further, it appears that “from the
mechanical examination of the vehicle it also appeared to
him that the accident occurred due to other than mechanical
failure”. Now, if we go through the exhibited documents
relied upon by the appellant, further, it appears that on the
alleged day that is on 27.01.2012, the accident occurred due
to collision of the deceased with the offending vehicle of the
appellant who was on a bi-cycle and for that a case was
registered
(Exhibit-B,
sheets)
and
other
exhibited
documents like Exhibit-A is the certificate of registration,
Exhibit-B is the accident and enquiry report, Exhibit-C is the
letter of Divisional Manager, NBSTC, Cooch Behar, Exhibit-D
is the certificate of insurance, issued by the Managing
Director NBSTC, Cooch behar, Exhibit-E is the circular of the
Government
of
India,
Exhibit-F
is
the
order
dated
21.06.1960 of the Home Department, Government of India.
Exhibit-G is the office order dated 16.02.1982 of General
Manager, NBSTC, Cooch Behar, Exhibit-H is the fitness
certificate. So, from the exhibited documents relied upon by
the parties, it can be conclusively come to the conclusion
that on 27.01.2012 the accident occurred and due to that
accident, the victim Sanjit Saha succumbed to his injuries.
08.
In course of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
appellant relied upon one judgment of our High Court in MAC
Appeal No. 04 of 2020 wherein in Para 3, Hon’ble High Court
opined (“Police investigation cannot be the sole basis
for deciding negligence in Motor Accident case”).
Relying upon the same, Learned Counsel for the
appellant submitted that on the basis of this judgment of the
High Court, since the respondent claimants only relied upon
the
charge
sheet,
so
simply
on
the
basis
of
police
investigation no award can be granted, and Learned Tribunal
committed
serious
compensation.
error
in
calculating
or
awarding
09.
In this regard, it is further submitted that to
substantiate the claim and the defence, it appears that both
the contesting parties have adduced their evidences before
the Learned Tribunal below and after going through the oral
as well as documentary evidence, the Learned Tribunal below
allowed
the
application
of
the
respondent
claimant-
petitioners and awarded accordingly and furthermore, it
appears that the appellant as opposite-party respondent
before the Learned Tribunal could not raise any circumstance
to disbelieve the evidence on record of the claimantpetitioner in this respect. So, the citation as referred cannot
be accepted at this stage by this Court.
10.
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in (2018) 5 SCC 656
Mangla Ram vs. Oriental Insurance Company Limited
and Others dated 06.04.2018 in Para 25 and 26 observed
as under:
“25. In Dulcina Fernandes:(2013) 10 SCC
646, this Court examined similar situation
where
the
evidence
of
claimant‟s
eyewitness was discarded by the Tribunal
and that the respondent in that case was
acquitted in the criminal case concerning
the accident. This Court, however, opined
that it cannot be overlooked that upon
investigation
of
the
case
registered
against the respondent, prima facie,
materials showing negligence were found
to put him on trial. The Court restated the
settled principle that the evidence of the
claimants ought to be examined by the
Tribunal
on
the
touchstone
of
preponderance of probability and certainly
the standard of proof beyond reasonable
doubt could not have been applied as noted
in Bimla Devi:(2009) 13 SCC 530. In paras
8 & 9 of the reported decision, the dictum
in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Shila
Datta:(2012) 3 SCC (Civ) 798, has been
adverted to as under:(Dulcina Fernandes
Case: (2013) 10 SCC 646, SCC p. 650)
“8. In United India Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Shila Datta:(2012) 3 SCC
(Civ) 798 while considering the
nature of a claim petition under
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 a
three-Judge Bench of this Court
has culled out certain propositions
of which Propositions (ii), (v) and
(vi) would be relevant to the facts
of the present case and, therefore,
may be extracted hereinbelow:
(SCC p. 518, para 10)
10.(ii) The rules of the pleadings
do not strictly apply as the
claimant is required to make an
application in a form prescribed
under the Act. In fact, there is no
pleading where the proceedings
are suo motu initiated by the
Tribunal.
(v)Though
the
Tribunal
adjudicates
on
a
claim
and
determines the compensation, it
does not do so as in an adversarial
litigation. …
(vi)The Tribunal is required to
follow such summary procedure as
it thinks fit. It may choose one or
more persons possessing special
knowledge
of
and
matters
relevant to inquiry, to assist it in
holding the enquiry.‟
9. The following further observation
available in para 10 of the Report would
require
specific
note:
(Shila
Datta
case:(2012) 3 SCC (Civ) 798, SCC p. 519)
„10. … We have referred to the
aforesaid provisions to show that
an award by the Tribunal cannot
be
seen
as
an
adversarial
adjudication between the litigating
parties to a dispute, but a
statutory
determination
of
compensation on the occurrence of
an accident, after due enquiry, in
accordance with the statute.‟
In para 10 [Dulcina Fernandes and Ors.
(2013) 10 SCC 646], the Court opined that
non- examination of witness per se cannot
be treated as fatal to the claim set up
before the Tribunal. In other
words, the
approach of the Tribunal should be holistic
analysis of the entire pleadings and
evidence by applying the principles of
preponderance of probability.
26. In the above conspectus, the appellant
is justified in contending that the High
Court
committed
manifest
error
in
reversing the holistic view of the Tribunal
in
reference
to
the
statements
of
witnesses
forming
part
of
the
charge-sheet, FIR, jeep Seizure report in
particular, to hold that Jeep No.RST-4701
driven by respondent No.2 was involved in
the accident in question. Indeed, the High
Court was impressed by
the Mechanical
Investigation Report (Ext. 5) which stated
that only a scratch mark on the mudguard
of the left tyre of the
vehicle had been
noted. On
that
basis,
it proceeded to
observe that the same was in contradiction
to the claim of the appellant claimant,
ruling out the possibility of involvement
of the vehicle in the accident. This
conclusion is based on surmises and
conjectures and also in disregard of the
relevant fact that the vehicle was seized
by the police after investigation, only after
one month from the date of the accident
and the possibility of the same having
been repaired in the meantime could not
be ruled out. In other words, the reasons
which weighed with the High Court for
reversing the finding of fact recorded by
the Tribunal upon holistic analysis of the
entire evidence, about the
involvement
of Jeep No. RST 4701 in the accident,
cannot
be
countenanced.
For,
those
reasons
do
not
affect
the
other
overwhelming circumstances and evidence
which has come on record and commended
to the Tribunal about the involvement of
the subject jeep in the accident in question.
This being the main edifice, for which the
High Court allowed the appeal preferred by
Respondents 2 & 3, it must necessarily
follow that the finding of fact recorded by
the Tribunal on the factum of involvement
of Jeep No. RST 4701 in the accident in
question will have to be restored for
reasons noted hitherto.”
11.
Further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in (2023)
SCC OnLine Mad 5467 in Malaravan vs Praveen Travels
Private Limited and Others dated 18.08.2023 para No.28
and 31 observed as under:
“28. The Parliament in its wisdom has
ensured that the hapless victims of motor
accidents
need
not
depend
upon
stakeholders in Court for the purpose of
initiation of proceedings. The proceedings
itself is initiated on the basis of the report
filed by the Police Authorities. In effect, the
petition under Section 166 is only a
reminder to the Court that the police have
already filed the Detailed Accident Report
containing all the requisite details like the
First Information Report, Interim Accident
Report, First Accident Report and therefore,
it has to take up the said report as a claim
petition. In other words, the claim petition
is only a reminder to the Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal to perform its duty under
Rule 21 Annexure XIII of Central Motor
Vehicles Rules and to process the claim
petition.
31. A reading of Section 166(4) shows that
if any report of the accident is forwarded to
it under Section 159, the same shall be
treated as an application for compensation.
It is no more the discretion of the police.
Rule 4(A)(5)(1) of the Tamil Nadu Rules
read with the Central rules make it
mandatory. It has now become a statutory
duty of the Police to sent a report. It is
pertinent to point out that the amendment
under Section 166(4) does not speak about
the Interim Accident Report(IAR), First
Accident
Report(FAR)
and
Detailed
Accident Report(DAR) but speaks about
“any report that has been sent by the
police.” Therefore, even if an FIR sent by
the police to the Tribunal, the same should
be treated a Claim Petition.”
From the above law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in the aforenoted cases, it appears that the approach
of the tribunal should be holistic analysis of the entire
pleadings
and
evidence
by
applying
the
principles
of
preponderance of probability. Even the Hon’ble Apex Court
also observed that even if an FIR is sent by a police to the
tribunal, the same should be treated as a claim petition.
Here in the case at hand, from the documentary evidence on
record, it appears that soon after the accident an FIR was
laid,
case
was
registered
and
after
completion
of
investigation the I.O. laid charge sheet against the driver of
the offending vehicle of the appellant and after considering
oral/documentary evidence on record Learned Tribunal below
awarded
compensation
in
favour
of
the
respondent
claimants. So, in view of the principles of law laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court it cannot be said that no
compensation can be granted based on police investigation.
12.
Learned Counsel for the appellant in course of
hearing of argument further relied upon another citation of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Rangammal vs.
Kuppuswami & Anr. dated 13.05.2011 reported in (2011)
12 SCC 220 Para 34 observed as under:
“34. It has been further held by the
Supreme Court in State of J&K vs.
Hindustan Forest Co. (2006) 12 SCC 198
wherein it was held that the onus is on the
plaintiff to positively establish its case on
the basis of the material available and it
cannot rely on the weakness or absence of
defence to discharge the onus.”
Referring the same Learned Counsel submitted
that it was the duty of the respondent claimant-petitioners to
establish its case on the basis of material evidence but the
respondent-claimants before the Learned Tribunal could not
produce material evidence on record to substantiate the
claim. To counter this submission raised by Learned Counsel
for the appellant, Learned Counsel for the respondentclaimants submitted that the respondent-claimants could
well prove their case before the Learned Tribunal and the
Learned
Tribunal
after
considering
all
the
facts
and
circumstances awarded the compensation in favour of the
claimants. So, at this stage, this plea cannot be taken into
consideration. To this point, it is observed that Learned
Tribunal after considering oral/documentary evidence on
record of both the sides, concluded the trial and awarded
compensation in favour of the respondent-claimants. So, the
submission of Learned Counsel cannot be accepted.
13.
Learned Counsel for the appellant further referred
another judgment of our High Court reported in (2013) 2
TLR 917 in Bani Biswas vs Juthika Bhowmik and Ors. in
para no 4 Hon’ble the High Court observed as under:
“4. Under the Law of Torts, basically, the
first person who is liable is the wrongdoer.
In this case, the wrongdoer is the driver
and once the driver is liable, the owner
becomes liable by applying the principle of
vicarious liability which means that the
master is liable for the negligent acts of his
servant. As far as the Insurance Company
is concerned, it becomes liable to pay the
compensation in view of the contract of
insurance entered into by it with the
insured agreeing to indemnify the insured
for the compensation, if any, payable by the
insured. Obviously, the award can only be
made once it is found that the driver was
negligent. If there is no negligence, then no
award under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act can be passed. Once the driver
is negligent, the owner becomes vicariously
liable and the Insurance Company under
the contract of indemnity becomes liable to
pay the awarded amount.”
Referring the same Learned Counsel submitted
that the respondent-claimants could not prove that the
Tribunal was negligent. So, there was no scope on the part
of the Tribunal to award any compensation but the Learned
driver in absence of cogent evidence on record awarded
compensation in favour of the respondent-claimants. It is on
record that the Learned Tribunal below considering the
oral/documentary evidence on record specifically Exhibit-3
where it was specifically mentioned that on the alleged day
the accident was occurred due to over speed rash and
negligent driving of the NBSTC Bus bearing No.W.B-63-2270
by its driver. So, there is no scope to disbelieve that part of
evidence and it cannot be said that there was no negligence
on the part of the driver on the alleged date and time at the
time of the accident.
14.
submitted
Finally,
that
Learned
Learned
Counsel
Tribunal
for
in
the
appellant
determining
the
compensation applied multiplier 14 because treating the age
of the deceased as 45 years, which Learned Tribunal wrongly
calculated and according to the Learned Counsel for the
appellant on the date of death, the age of the deceased
should be 46 years and in that case in pursuance to the
judgment of Sarla Verma(SMT) And Others vs. Delhi
Transport Corporation and Another, multiplier would be
13 not 14 and submitted before the Court to take note of
that fact and to modify the award accordingly. In this regard,
in para no 42 of dated 15.04.2009, reported in (2009) 6
SCC 121 of Sarla Verma(supra), Hon’ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“42. We therefore hold that the multiplier
to be used should be as mentioned in
column (4) of the table above (prepared by
applying Susamma Thomas:(1994) 2 SCC
176, Trilok Chandra:(1996) 4 SCC 362 and
Charlie:(2005) 10 SCC 720, which starts
with an operative multiplier of 18 (for the
age groups of 15 to 20 and 21 to 25 years),
reduced by one unit for every five years,
that is M-17 for 26 to 30 years, M-16 for 31
to 35 years, M-15 for 36 to 40 years, M-14
for 41 to 45 years, and M-13 for 46 to 50
years, then reduced by two units for every
five years, that is, M-11 for 51 to 55 years,
M-9 for 56 to 60 years, M-7 for 61 to 65
years and M-5 for 66 to 70 years.”
From the above, it appears that as per the
principle laid down in the aforesaid judgment the multiplier
would be 14 if the deceased was in between 41-45 years on
the date of death and multiplier would be 13 if the deceased
was in between 46-50 years on the date of death. Here in
the case, Learned Tribunal below applied multiplier treating
his age as 45 years on the date of death.
15.
As per Exhibit-6 Voter ID card relied upon by the
respondent-claimants, it appears that on 01.01.2007 the age
of the deceased was 40 years, so on 01.01.2012 his age
would be 45 and the accident occurred on 27.01.2012 and
the deceased died on 31.01.2012. So, it appears that
Learned Tribunal below rightly determined multiplier 14 in
determining the compensation and in this case as submitted
by Learned Counsel for the appellant M-13 could not be
applied for determining the amount of compensation.
16.
Thus, after hearing both the sides and going
through the evidence on record, it appears that Learned
Tribunal
below
rightly
and
reasonably
determined
the
amount of compensation in favour of the respondentclaimants which needs no interference by this Court in this
appeal.
Accordingly, the appeal filed by the appellant is
dismissed on contest with costs. Pending application, if any,
also stands disposed of. The judgment and award dated
24.08.2022 passed by Learned Tribunal, is accordingly
upheld and affirmed. The appellant is asked to comply the
judgment within a period of 30 days from the date of the
judgment.
Send
down
the
LCR
along
with
a
copy
judgment.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMITA Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.01.29
DATTA
14:27:45 +05'30'
Purnita
of
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review