Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 09-09-2026
CORAM
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE M.JOTHIRAMAN
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
AND
CMP No. 16700 of 2022
The Manager
M/s Royal Sundaram General Insurance Company
Ltd, Sundaram Towers, No.46, Whites Rd,
Royapettah, Chennai 600 014
..Appellant(s)
Vs
1. Selvi
W/o Late. Chinnaraj, Res at Kullampatti
village, Kokkarapatti Post, Pappireddipatty Tk,
Dharmapuri Dt
2. Santhiya (Minor)
D/o Late. Chinnaraj, Res at Kullampatti village,
Kokkarapatti Post, Pappireddipatty Tk,
Dharmapuri Dt (respondents 2 and 3 are minors
rept by mother and NF 1st respondent)
3. Suriya (Minor)
S/o Late. Chinnaraj, Res at Kullampatti village,
Kokkarapatti Post, Pappireddipatty Tk,
Dharmapuri Dt (respondents 2 and 3 are minors
rept by mother and NF 1st respondent)
4. Rajammal
W/o Ponnusami Res at Kullampatti village,
Kokkarapatti Post, Pappireddipatty Tk,
Dharmapuri Dt
__________
Page1 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
5. Ponnusami
S/o Ponnusamy Res at Kullampatti village,
Kokkarapatti Post, Pappireddipatty Tk,
Dharmapuri Dt
6. T.Tamil Selvan
S/o Tamilarasan No.4/115, Adhigarapatti post,
Pappireddipatti Tk, Dharmapuri Dt
..Respondent(s)
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
Prayer: This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed against the
Judgment and Decree made in MCOP No. 65 of 2012 dated 16.02.2018 on the
file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Subordinate Court, Harur.
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
For Appellant(s):
Mr. M.B.Raghavan
For M/s.M.B.Gopalan Associates
For Respondent(s):
Mr.M.Sivakumar-for RR1 to 4
JUDGMENT
Unsuccessful Insurance company has preferred this appeal, challenging
the negligence fixed on the part of the driver of the offending vehicle.
2. The 1st claimant is the wife, 2nd and 3rd claimants are minor children,
and 4th and 5th claimants are parents of the deceased Chinnaraj.
__________
Page2 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
3. According to the claimants, on 30.04.2012 at about 15:30 p.m., the
deceased Chinnaraj was going to his native place in Naripalli, to
Bairnaickanpatti Road, riding Hero Honda motorcycle bearing Registration
No.TN 29 AW 0390 on the left side. At that time, a Maruti Alto car bearing
registration No. TN 29 AW 3561 came from Bairanaickenpatti to Naripalli,
driven by its driver in a rash and negligent manner, and suddenly dashed against
the deceased Chinnaraj. As a result of sudden impact, the deceased Chinnaraj
was thrown out and consequently, he sustained fatal injuries on his head and all
over body. Due to the head injuries, he was admitted in Government Hospital,
Harur, and then shifted to Government Medical College Hospital, Dharmapuri.
Consequently, deceased Chinnaraj died on 30.04.2012. According to the
claimants, the deceased was aged about 35 years and he was an astrologer and
he was earning not less than Rs. 10,000/- per month. The 1st respondent being
the owner of the offending vehicle remained ex-parte before the Tribunal. The
2nd respondent is the Insurer of the offending vehicle.
4. The 2nd respondent/Insurance Company has filed a counter statement
wherein it has been stated that the averments in the claim petition regarding the
manner of accident and the alleged responsibility of the driver of the first
respondent's car are not at all admitted, and the claimants are put to strict proof
of the same. The claimants have suppressed the real manner in which the
accident occurred and given false statement. The accident was solely occurred
__________
Page3 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
due to the rash and negligent driving of the two-wheeler rider, namely the
deceased. In the charge sheet filed by the police clearly shows that the first
respondent car was parked at the extreme left side of the road, while so, the
rider of the Hero Honda motorcycle, namely the deceased came from opposite
direction to the car at a high speed and lost control over his vehicle and hit
against the 1st respondent parked vehicle, and he himself invited his death. As
per final report made by the Kottapatti police, deceased alone was shown as
accused. Therefore, the Tort-feasor cannot claim compensation as a victim.
5.On behalf of the claimants, 1st claimant herself examined as PW-1, one
Karthikeyan was examined as PW-2, and one Thangaraj was examined as
PW-3. Ex.P1 to Ex.P18 were marked. On the side of the respondents, RW-1 and
RW-2 were examined. Ex.R1 to Ex.R6 were marked.
6. Upon appreciation of evidence adduced on either side, the Tribunal
found that as per Ex.P1-the FIR, Criminal case was registered against the 1 st
respondent’s car driver. The 1st respondent did not come forward to dispute the
claim of the claimants denying the averments made in the claim petition. The
Ex.P-10- certified copy of the charge sheet shows that charge sheet has been
laid down as against the first respondent. As per Ex. P-6 reveals that there was a
valid insurance policy in subsistence between the 1 st respondent and the 2nd
__________
Page4 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
respondent therein on the date of accident. As per Ex.P7, the 1st respondent,
who drove the vehicle had valid driving license on the date of accident. Ex.R1 is
the alleged requisition letter given by the Inspector of Police for the 1st
respondent's vehicle for inspection, and Ex.R-2 is the alleged requisition letter
given by the Inspector of Police for the deceased's driven vehicle for inspection.
Ex.R5 is the signature of the Inspector of Police, Kottapatti in the alleged final
report filed against the deceased as charge abated. Exhibit R-5 is not marked
through the author of the document, and it has been marked through the present
Inspector of Police who was examined as RW-1. RW-1 in his cross-examination
categorically deposed that he has given opinion that the signature found in the
Xerox copy Exhibit R-5 resembles that of the previous investigating officer.
RW-1 also admits that there are no eyewitnesses deposed regarding the rash and
negligence driving of the deceased. As per rough sketch-Ex.R3, the accident
occurred on the left side road of the deceased, and on the right side road, the
first respondent’s driver drove the vehicle. When it is so, just because the first
respondent vehicle had damages on the front left side, it cannot be presumed
that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligence of the deceased.
Finally, the Tribunal concludes that the accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving of the first respondent, who is the owner of offending vehicle
and as such the 1st respondent is liable to pay compensation to the claimants,
and 2nd respondent/Insurance company, being the insurer of the Alto car at the
time of accident, is liable to indemnify the first respondent. With regard to the
__________
Page5 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
quantum of compensation, the learned Tribunal has fixed the monthly notional
income of the deceased at Rs.6,500/- in the absence of proof for monthly
income. By applying the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in “Sarla
Verma and Pranay sethi cases, adopted the multiplier “16”, and deducted
1/4th income for personal expenses of the deceased thereby computed the
compensation of Rs.9,36,000/- under the head of loss of dependency. The
Tribunal has also awarded the compensation on other heads as per the details
given below:
S.No.
2.
5.
Compensation awarded under the head
Loss of dependency (Rs.6,500/- - 1/4 X 12
X 16).
Future Prospectus
Loss of consortium to the 1st claimant
Loss of Love and Affection to the 2 to 4
claimants
Funeral expenses
Loss of Estate
Total
Amount in Rs.
9,36,000.00
3,74,000.00
40,000.00
30,000.00
15,000.00
15,000.00
14,10,400.00
7. Aggrieved over the same, the insurance company has preferred the
appeal, challenging the negligence fixed on the part of the driver of the
offending vehicle.
8.The learned counsel appearing for the appellant insurance company
would submit that the Tribunal failed to appreciate that the investigating officer
__________
Page6 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
had resorted to creating two charge sheets and two rough sketches, one in favor
of the victim, later fraudulently for the purpose of claim and in such manner, the
appellant has been wrongfully roped in the issue. Further, the Tribunal has erred
in disregarding the oral and documentary evidence adduced on the side of
appellant which clearly established that sketch produced as Ex.P-3 was
fabricated. The accident occurred due to the rash and negligent act of the
deceased alone and the same has been clearly established through the evidence
of RW-1 and the final report has also been laid as against the deceased in
Exhibit R-5. Hence, he seeks to set aside the award dated 16.02.2018 in MCOP
NO.65 of 2012 passed by the Tribunal.
9. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents/
claimants would submit that on appreciation of evidence adduced on either side,
the Tribunal has rightly concluded that the accident occurred only due to the
rash and negligent act of the driver of the first respondent’s Alto Car. The
document relied upon by the appellant in respect of Ex.R5, is only a signature of
the then Inspector of Police, Kottapatti, wherein it has been stated that final
report has been filed as against the deceased as charge abated. The contents of
the Ex.R5 has not been established in a manner known to law. However, the
claimants have placed the certified copy of the final report obtained from the
concerned Judicial Magistrate Court, and the same was marked as Ex.P10
__________
Page7 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
wherein it has been clearly stated that the case has been registered and final
report has been laid down under sections 279 and 304(A) IPC as against the first
respondent therein. The RW-1 in his examination categorically admits that he
has given only an opinion that the signature found in Ex.R5 resembles to the
then Investigating Officer, Kottapatti. He has also admitted that no eyewitness
were examined to establish the factum of rash and negligence on the part of
deceased. Hence, the Tribunal has rightly awarded the compensation after
considering the entire evidence placed by both sides, and the award passed by
the Tribunal does not warrant interference.
10.This court, considered the submissions made on either side and
perused the records carefully.
11. According to the claimants, on 30.04.2012 at about 15:30 p.m., the
deceased was going to his native place in Naripalli to Bairanaickenpatti Road
in his two-wheeler bearing registration number TN-29-AW-0390 on the left
side. At that time, a Maruti Alto car bearing registration number TN-29-AW
-3561 came from Bairanaickenpatti to Naripalli, driven by its driver in a rash
and negligent manner, and suddenly dashed against the claimant's two-wheeler
and caused the accident. Ex. P-1 is the copy of FIR filed against the driver of
car Maruti car bearing registration number TN-29-AW-3561. The same was
__________
Page8 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
registered on 1.5.2012 at 10 hours. The FIR came to be registered as per
complaint lodged by the deceased’s father narrating the accident. Ex.P.6-is the
Insurance Policy of the 1st respondent’s vehicle insured with the appellant
herein. As per the Policy, it is seen that the policy is in force from 25.03.2012 to
24.03.2013. As such, at the time of the accident, the 1 st respondent’s Car had
valid insurance with the appellant Insurance Company. As per Ex.P7, the 1 st
respondent had the valid driving licence to drive the Car. As per Ex.P8-MVI
Report, the front left side part of the Car was damaged. As per Ex.P9-MVI
Report, the front side of the two wheeler got damaged. As per Ex.P10-certified
copy of the charge sheet filed against the 1st respondent on the file of the
Judicial Magistrate Court, Harur under Section 279, 304(A) IPC, which reveals
that when the deceased was traveling in his Hero Honda Motor Cycle on the left
side of the road from Naripalli to Bairnaickanpatti, the 1st respondent who rode
his Car in a rash and negligent manner, dashed against the deceased and caused
the accident. According to the appellant, the accident had occurred due to rash
and negligent driving of the deceased and charge sheet was filed only as against
the deceased and the same has been confirmed under Ex.R5.
Hence, the
claimants are not entitled to the compensation as sought in their claim petition.
In this regard, on behalf of the Insurance Company, R.W.1 -the Inspector of
Police, Kottappatty was examined through him Ex.R1 to Ex.R6 came to be
marked. A perusal of Ex.R1, shows the alleged requisition letter given by the
Inspector of Police, Kottapatty, for the 1 st respondent’s vehicle for inspection
__________
Page9 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
and as per Ex.R2, the alleged requisition letter given by the Inspector of Police,
Kottapatty, for the deceased driven vehicle for inspection. Ex.R3-Rough Sketch
shows the scene of occurrence. Ex.R5 shows that the signature of the Inspector
of Police, Kottapatty, in the alleged final report filed against the deceased
wherein it has been stated that the Final report filed as against the deceased as
abated since he died. It is relevant to point out that Ex.R5 was not marked by its
author; rather, the same was marked by the succeeding Police Inspector who
was examined as R.W1. R.W1 in his deposition, has categorically deposed that
he has given opinion that the signature found in the Xerox copy Exhibit R-5
resembles that of the previous investigating officer. RW-1 also admits that there
are no eyewitnesses deposed regarding the rash and negligence driving of the
deceased. Further, he has admitted in the cross examination that he was not
aware of the contents of the documents marked under Ex.R1 to R4. At the point
of time, he was not in the duty.
12. A perusal of Ex.R3-Rough Sketch and Ex.R6-FMB Sketch, shows
that the accident occurred on the left corner sketch-, the accident occurred on
the left side road of the deceased, and on the right side road of the first
respondent’s driver vehicle. When it is so, just because the first respondent
vehicle had damages on the front left side, it cannot be presumed that the
accident occurred due to the rash and negligence of the deceased. Further, the
__________
Page10 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
evidence of R.W1 is not sufficient to establish the case of the
appellant/Insurance company that the accident had occurred due to rash and
negligent driving on the part of the deceased and the Insurance company failed
to examine the 1st respondent being the Car owner to establish the negligence on
the part of the deceased. Further, the Appellant/Insurance Company has not
taken any steps to file any document to substantiate their contentions and the 1 st
respondent did not appear before the Tribunal and he was set exparte therein.
The oral evidence of P.W1 to P.W3 along with documentary evidence under
Ex.P1, Ex.P8 to Ex.P10 clearly proves that the accident took place due to the
rash and negligent driving of the driver of the Car not driven by the deceased.
Though the appellant herein had contended that the accident had occurred due
to rash and negligent driving of the deceased based on the evidence of R.W1
and Ex.R5, it is not sufficient to prove their contention without examining the
1st respondent therein. Under such circumstance, the burden of proof lies on the
Appellant/Insurance Company to rebuttal the oral evidence of P.W.1 to P.W.3
and the documentary evidence under Ex.P1 Ex.P1, Ex.P8 to Ex.P10. But, the
Appellant/Insurance company failed to prove their case by way of oral and
documentary evidence. Hence, there is no infirmity and irregularites in the
fidings of the Tribunal in fixing the liability on the Appellant having come to
the conclusion that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving
of the 1st respondent’s car driver. However, there is no dispute raised with
regard to the quantum of compensation on either side. Considering the entire
__________
Page11 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
M.JOTHIRAMAN J.
Lbm
evidence adduced on either side, it is seen that the Tribunal has awarded the
compensation in fair and proper manner and does not warrant interference.
13. In the result, the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal stands dismissed,
confirming the award dated 16.02.2018 in MCOP No.65 of 2012 passed by the
Tribunal. The Appellant/Insurance Company is hereby directed to deposit the
entire award amount, after deducting the amount already deposited, if any,
within a period of four weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this Judgment.
The manner and mode of disbursement of compensation shall be as per the
order of the Tribunal. On such deposit, the claimants/respondents herein are
entitled to withdraw the same, after filing appropriate application before the
Tribunal in the manner known to law. No costs.
09-09-2026
Index: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Lbm
CMA No. 2153 of 2022
AND
CMP No. 16700 of 2022
__________
Page12 of 12
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review