The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. As against the same, the delay in the instant facts in filing the LPA is 916 days and as such the consideration to condone can be made only if there is reasonable explanation and the condonation cannot be merely because the appellant is public body. The entire explanation noticed above, depicts the casual approach unmindful of the law of limitation despite being aware of the position of law. That apart when there is such a long delay and there is no proper explanation, laches would also come into play while noticing as to the manner in which a party has proceeded before filing an appeal. In addition in the instant facts not only the delay and laches in filing the appeal is contended on behalf of the respondents seeking dismissal of the instant appeal but it is also contended that there was delay and laches in filing the writ petition itself at the first instance from which the present appeal had arisen. In that view, it would be necessary for us to advert to those aspects of the matter and notice the nature of consideration made in the writ petition as well as the LPA to arrive at a conclusion as to whether the High Court was justified.” Here in the given case, after hearing both the sides and on perusal of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court, it appears that the present applicant-appellant only could properly explain the period regarding delay for obtainin…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
I.A. No.01 of 2024
In L.A. App. No.53 of 2024
Land Acquisition Collector,
West Tripura District, Agartala.
-----Applicant(s)
Versus
Sri Manik Lal Modak & Ors.
-----Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. P. Gautam, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, DSGI,
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
01/10/2024
Learned Counsel, Mr. P. Gautam is present for the
applicant-appellant. Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh is present for
the claimant-respondent Nos.1 to 3. Learned DSGI, Mr. Bidyut
Majumder is present for the respondent No.4.
Heard
the
contesting
parties
yesterday
i.e.
on
30.09.2024.
This present applicant-appellant has filed appeal under
Section 54 of L.A. Act challenging the judgment and award dated
31.01.2023 delivered by Learned L.A. Judge, Court No.4, West
Tripura, Agartala in connection with case No.Misc. (L.A.) 130 of
2016 and along with the memo of appeal another application
under Section 5 of Limitation Act was filed for condoning delay of
394 days in preferring the appeal.
In course of hearing of argument regarding application
for condonation of delay, Learned Counsel for the applicantappellant submitted before the Court to pass appropriate order in
accordance with law.
On
the
other
hand,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent-claimants referring the application in para Nos.2 and 3
submitted that the grounds as mentioned in the application have
not been clearly explained by the applicant-appellant and in
absence of ‘proof of sufficient cause’, there is no scope to allow
the delay condone application filed by the applicant-appellant and
Learned Counsel further submitted that the applicant-appellant
was supposed to explain each days delays in preferring the
appeal, but the same is absent in the application filed and
furthermore, the Requiring Department who ought to have made
the payment refused to prefer any appeal, thereafter, the L.A.
Collector without any basis decided to prefer appeal in this case.
So, Learned Counsel urged for dismissal of this application with
costs.
Learned DSGI in course of hearing did not submit
anything against the application for condonation of delay filed by
the applicant-appellant. For the sake of clarity, let us see what
grounds were mentioned in the application for condonation of
delay by the applicant.
In the application, it was submitted that the period of
limitation for filing appeal was 90 days and as such the same was
supposed to be filed on or before 02.05.2023 but the applicantappellant could not do the same. According to the applicantappellant, after the judgment, the applicant-appellant applied for
certified copy of the judgment on 14.02.2023 and thereafter, the
certified copy of the judgment was received on 01.03.2023 and
after obtaining the certified copy the same was sent to the office
of Learned G.A. on 20.03.2023, but the Learned G.A. returned
back the file on 23.03.2023 and later on, on 24.03.2023 a case
file along with other records were sent to the Office of Learned
G.P. for views and the Learned G.P. opined that appeal may be
preferred before the High Court by the Requiring Department and
returned back the file on 01.04.2023. After that, the case file was
sent to the Requiring Department for preferring appeal. But on
26.05.2023 the Requiring Department informed that they are not
interested to prefer an appeal before the High Court challenging
the judgment dated 31.01.2023 passed in Misc. (LA) 130 of 2016.
Thereafter, the case file was again placed before the District
Magistrate & Collector, West Tripura District on 04.07.2023 and on
31.07.2023 detailed note was given by D.M. & Collector in
connection with this case and accordingly, a letter was sent on
25.08.2023 to the Requiring Department again for preferring an
appeal and another reminder letter was issued to the Requiring
Department on 05.10.2023 but the Requiring Department by a
reply letter dated 03.11.2023 requested the L.A. Collector to
recover the amount from the referring claimants and as such the
Officer-in-Charge of Law Cell gave his note on 06.11.2023 and a
synopsis of the case was drafted on 20.11.2023 and by a note
dated 24.11.2023 the same was sent to Law Department for
instructions and decisions and the Law Department on 30.11.2023
gave its decision to prefer an appeal challenging the judgment as
aforesaid and consequently, the Principal Secretary, Revenue
Department passed an order on 06.01.2024 directing
the Land
Acquisition Collector to prefer an appeal. After that the case file
was sent before the Learned Government Advocate, High Court of
Tripura on 03.02.2023 and subsequently, on 05.03.2024 the case
record was handed over to the Learned Counsel, Mr. P. Gautam
for preferring appeal but due to health problem, Learned Counsel
could not prepare the draft in time and lastly, on 31.05.2024 the
appeal was preferred.
These are the grounds as mentioned in the application
for condonation of delay.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for
the claimant-respondents in support of their contention relied
upon one citation of the Hon’ble Apex Court reported in University
of Delhi vs. Union of India and Ors. dated 17.12.2019 reported in
(2020) 13 SCC 745 wherein in para Nos.23 and 24, Hon’ble the
Apex Court observed as under:
“23. From a consideration of the view taken
by this Court through the decisions cited
supra the position is clear that, by and large,
a liberal approach is to be taken in the
matter of condonation of delay. The
consideration for condonation of delay would
not depend on the status of the party,
namely, the Government or the public bodies
so as to apply a different yardstick but the
ultimate consideration should be to render
even-handed justice to the parties. Even in
such case the condonation of long delay
should not be automatic since the accrued
right or the adverse consequence to the
opposite party is also to be kept in
perspective. In that background while
considering condonation of delay, the
routine explanation would not be enough but
it should be in the nature of indicating
“sufficient cause” to justify the delay which
will depend on the backdrop of each case
and will have to be weighed carefully by the
Courts based on the fact situation. In Katiji:
LAO v. Katiji: (1987) 2 SCC 107 the entire
conspectus relating to condonation of delay
has been kept in focus. However, what
cannot also be lost sight of is that the
consideration therein was in the background
of dismissal of the application seeking
condonation of delay in a case where there
was delay of four days pitted against the
consideration that was required to be made
on merits regarding the upward revision of
compensation amounting to 800%.
24. As against the same, the delay in the
instant facts in filing the LPA is 916 days and
as such the consideration to condone can be
made only if there is reasonable explanation
and the condonation cannot be merely
because the appellant is public body. The
entire explanation noticed above, depicts the
casual approach unmindful of the law of
limitation
despite
being
aware
of the
position of law. That apart when there is
such a long delay and there is no proper
explanation, laches would also come into
play while noticing as to the manner in
which a party has proceeded before filing an
appeal. In addition in the instant facts not
only the delay and laches in filing the appeal
is contended on behalf of the respondents
seeking dismissal of the instant appeal but it
is also contended that there was delay and
laches in filing the writ petition itself at the
first instance from which the present appeal
had arisen. In that view, it would be
necessary for us to advert to those aspects
of the matter and notice the nature of
consideration made in the writ petition as
well as the LPA to arrive at a conclusion as
to whether the High Court was justified.”
Here in the given case, after hearing both the sides and
on perusal of the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court, it appears that the present applicant-appellant only could
properly explain the period regarding delay for obtaining the
certified copy of the judgment/award but the other grounds as
mentioned in the application for delay could not be explained
properly. No sufficient cause could be explained in this regard,
rather it appears that the Requiring Department, who was
supposed to make payment of the compensation to the referringclaimants at one point of time decided not to prefer any appeal
but again they asked the present applicant-appellant to recover
the amount from the respondent-claimants. In addition to that on
perusal of the application, further it appears that the file was
moved to the Office of Government Advocate on different
occasions and in all the occasions the file was kept without any
proper explanation pending for view and lastly when the case was
entrusted to Mr. Gautam, it was asserted that due to illness he
could
not
prefer
the
appeal
in
time.
In
this
regard,
no
documentary evidence is also enclosed which shows that the
entire matter was dealt in a very casual manner without any
proper explanation. Even in course hearing, Learned Counsel for
the applicant-appellant did not submit anything rather left the
matter to the discretion of the Court for passing appropriate order
which
shows
that
he
had
also
nothing
to
say
regarding
condonation of delay.
Situated thus, after hearing the rival parties and also
after perusal of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
aforenote case, it appears that in the given case, the applicantappellant has failed to give any satisfactory explanation or failed
to show any sufficient cause to justify the delay in preferring the
appeal. Hence, the application for condonation of delay deserves
no merit and accordingly, it stands dismissed being devoid of
merit.
The I.A. accordingly stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
DATTA
Date: 2024.10.01 16:23:59
+05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review