Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.44 of 2016
1.
The Krishi Vigyan Kendra
Represented by the In-charge,
Krishi Vigyan Kendra
Project of Indian Council of Agricultural Research(I.C.A.R),
Birchandra, Manu, P.S. & P.O-Santirbazar, South Tripura.
2.
The Union of India,
Represented by the Secretary
To the Government of India,
Department of Agriculture, New Delhi.
------ Appellants
Versus
1.
Sri Biplab Kr. Majumder,
S/O Late Sushil Ch. Majumder.
2.
Sri Pradip Kanti Majumder,
S/O- Late Sushil Ch. Majumder.
Both are residents of Village- Birchandranagar,
P.O.-Takmacherra, P.S-Shantir bazaar,
Dist.-South Tripura, Tripura.
3.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the District & Collector,
South Tripura, Udaipur,
P.O & P.S- R.K. Pur, South Tripura.
4.
The Additional District Magistrate & Collector,
South Tripura, Udaipur,
P.O. & P.S- R. K. Pur, South Tripura.
------ Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, DSGI.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Suman Bhattacharjee, Adv,
Mr. Karnajit De, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing
& delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
15.09.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order (Oral)
This second appeal under Section 100 of CPC is preferred
challenging the judgment dated 29.03.2016 and decree dated
30.03.2016 delivered by Learned District Judge, South Tripura,
Belonia in connection with Case No.TA/10/2010. By the said
judgment and decree, Learned First Appellate Court affirmed the
judgment
dated
16.07.2010
and
decree
dated
23.07.2010
delivered by Learned Civil Judge(Junior Division), Belonia, South
Tripura in connection with case No.T.S. No.12 of 2009.
2.
Heard Learned DSGI Mr. Bidyut Majumder appearing on
behalf of the appellant-defendants and also heard Learned Counsel
Mr. Suman Bhattacharjee appearing on behalf of the respondentplaintiffs No.1 and 2 and further heard Learned Addl. G.A. Mr. Karnajit
De appearing on behalf of respondent-defendants No.3 and 4.
3.
At the time of admission of this appeal, the following
substantial questions of law were formulated by this Court vide order
dated 10.04.2017:
4.
i)
Whether the allotment order issued by the SubDivisional Officer is valid under the provisions of Tripura
Land Revenue and Land Reforms (Allotment of land)
Rules, 1962?
ii)
Whether during the pendency of the proceeding for
cancellation of the allotment before the Collector, South
Tripura, a Civil Court has the jurisdiction to declare the
right and title on possession of the plaintiffs in view of
the bar imposed by Section 44 of the TLR and the LR
Act, 1962?
At the time of hearing of this appeal, Learned DSGI appearing
on behalf of the appellant-defendants submitted that for proper
adjudication of this appeal, one more substantial question of law is
required to be formulated. In this regard, after hearing both the sides,
it appears that the substantial questions of law formulated by order
dated 10.04.2017 would cover the relevant point as raised by Learned
Counsel for the appellants. As such, no further substantial questions
of law was framed.
However, Learned DSGI, Mr. Majumder further drawn the
attention of the Court that the respondents No.1 and 2 filed one suit
for declaration with consequential relief, for perpetual injunction,
before the Court of Learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Belonia,
South Tripura which was numbered as TS/12/2019. In the said suit,
the present appellants contested the same by filing written statement
and adduced evidence on record and finally after conclusion of trial,
Learned Trial Court decreed the suit in favour of the respondentplaintiffs No.1 and 2, excepting issue No.3 Before the Learned Trial
Court, the respondent-plaintiffs could not produce and prove the order
of allotment on the basis of which, suit land was allotted in favour of
the deceased father of the respondent-plaintiffs No.1 and 2 and in
absence of the order of allotment, Learned Trial Court decreed the
suit in favour of the said respondents, and challenging that judgment,
the present appellants, who were the defendants in the main suit,
preferred an appeal before the Court of Learned Additional District
Judge, Belonia, South Tripura which was numbered as T.A. No.10 of
2010 and by the judgment dated 21.03.2011, Learned Additional
District Judge being the First Appellate Court allowed the appeal and
was pleased to set aside the judgment dated 16.07.2010 delivered by
Learned Trial Court and the consequential decree was prepared
accordingly. After that, the respondent-plaintiffs preferred second
appeal before this High Court, which was numbered as RSA No.23 of
2011, and this High Court, by judgment dated 09.10.2015, was
pleased to set aside the judgment dated 21.03.2011 and decree dated
25.03.2011 delivered by Learned Additional District Judge, Belonia,
South Tripura in connection with case No.T.A. No.10 of 2010, and
remanded back the matter again to the Learned District Judge, South
Tripura, Belonia for deciding the matter afresh based upon evidence
on record within a period of 4(four) months. Thereafter, Learned
District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia, heard both the sides and by
another judgment dated 29.03.2016, was pleased to uphold the
judgment dated 16.07.2010 delivered by Learned Trial Court, and
challenging that judgment, the original defendants as appellants have
preferred this second appeal again before this High Court.
5.
Learned DSGI, Mr. Majumder further drawn the attention of
the Court that in absence of document of title, simply on the basis of
Khatian, there was no scope on the part of the Learned First Appellate
Court to grant decree in favour of the respondent-plaintiffs. As such,
the judgment dated 29.03.2016 delivered by Learned District Judge,
South Tripura, Belonia is perverse in the eye of law, which needs to
be interfered with. Learned DSGI further submitted that from the
documents which were relied upon by the present appellants before
the Learned Trial Court, and were marked as Exhibits, it is crystal
clear that the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs and even the
present respondent-plaintiffs have/had no possession over the suit
land at any point of time, and in absence of any specific relief for
granting decree of recovery of possession as required under Section
34 of the Specific Relief Act, there was no scope on the part of the
Learned Trial Court to grant decree in favour of the respondentplaintiffs.
6.
Furthermore, Learned DSGI, Mr. Majumder again submitted
that in view of Section 44 of Tripura Land Revenue and Reforms Act,
where there was clear bar to entertain any suit on the part of the Civil
Court, but the Learned Trial Court without dismissing the suit granted
decree
in
favour
of
the
respondent-plaintiffs,
which
was
not
permissible in the eye of law.
7.
In support of his contention, Learned Counsel for the
appellants relied upon one judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of
India reported in (2019) 10 SCC 259 [titled as Prahlad Pradhan
& Ors. vs. Sonu Kumhar & Ors.] wherein in para No.5, Hon'ble the
Supreme Court observed as under:
“5. The contention raised by the appellants is that since
Mangal Kumhar was the recorded tenant in the suit
property as per the Survey Settlement of 1964, the suit
property was his self-acquired property. The said
contention is legally misconceived since entries in the
revenue records do not confer title to a property, nor do
they have any presumptive value on the title. They only
enable the person in whose favour mutation is recorded, to
pay the land revenue in respect of the land in question.
[Bhimabai Mahadeo Kambekar v. Arthur Import & Export
Co., (2019) 3 SCC 191 : (2019) 2 SCC (Civ) 21; Narasamma
v. State of Karnataka, (2009) 5 SCC 591 : (2009) 2 SCC
(Civ) 582; Balwant Singh v. Daulat Singh, (1997) 7 SCC
137; Sawarni v. Inder Kaur, (1996) 6 SCC 223] As a
consequence, merely because Mangal Kumhar's name was
recorded in the Survey Settlement of 1964 as a recorded
tenant in the suit property, it would not make him the sole
and exclusive owner of the suit property.”
Referring the same, Learned DSGI submitted that entry in
revenue records does not confer any title to a property, and as such,
in absence of valid title, there was no scope on the part of the
Learned First Appellate Court to grant any decree in favour of the
respondent-plaintiffs.
8.
Reference was also made on another judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court reported in (2012) 8 SCC 148 [titled as Union of
India vs. Ibrahim Uddin & Anr.] wherein in para No.58, Hon'ble
the Apex Court, observed as under:
“58. In the instant case, the suit for declaration of title of
ownership had been filed, though Respondent 1-plaintiff
was admittedly not in possession of the suit property. Thus,
the suit was barred by the provisions of Section 34 of the
Specific Relief Act and, therefore, ought to have been
dismissed solely on this ground. The High Court though
framed a substantial question on this point but for
unknown reasons did not consider it proper to decide the
same.”
Referring
the
same,
Learned
DSGI
appearing
for
the
appellants drawn the attention of the Court that from the enquiry
reports which were adduced by the present appellants before the
Learned Trial Court and were marked as Exhibits, it was clear that the
respondent-plaintiffs have/had no possession over the suit land at any
point of time and as such, in absence of any specific relief under
Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, there was no scope on the part of
Learned First Appellate Court and the Learned Trial Court to grant any
decree in favour of the respondent-plaintiffs.
9.
Learned DSGI further referred another citation of Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India reported in (1996) 6 SCC 223 [titled as
Sawarni (Smt) vs. Inder Kaur (Smt) & Ors.], wherein in para
No.7, Hon'ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“7. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and
having scrutinised the judgment of the trial Judge as well
as that of the lower appellate court, we find sufficient force
in all the contentions raised by the learned counsel for the
appellant. At the outset, it may be noticed that the plaintiff
had filed the suit claiming half interest for herself and
claiming half interest in favour of the husband and sons of
Roori and, therefore, the learned Additional District Judge
was wholly in error to hold that the plaintiff could not have
filed the suit in question. In view of the rival stand of the
parties the main question that arose for consideration was
whether Roori was the daughter of Gurbax Singh or Inder
Kaur, Defendant 5 was the daughter of the same Gurbax
Singh? The learned trial Judge after elaborate discussion of
the evidence on record both oral and documentary came to
the positive conclusion that it was Roori who was the
daughter of Gurbax Singh as alleged by the plaintiff and not
Inder Kaur. The lower appellate court without focusing its
attention on the weighty reasons advanced by the trial
court and without examining the materials on record in
that respect even did not set aside the said finding of the
trial Judge and yet reversed the decree of the trial Judge.
We have no hesitation to come to the conclusion that the
said judgment of the Additional District Judge is wholly
unsustainable in law. The crucial point being as to who was
the second daughter of Gurbax Singh, namely Roori or
Inder Kaur, and the trial Judge having come to the positive
conclusion that it was Roori who was the second daughter
of Gurbax Singh, the lower appellate court was not justified
in not considering the material evidence as well as the
reasons advanced by the trial Judge and merely coming to
the conclusion that the evidence on the file does not prove
Roori to be the daughter of Gurbax Singh. Further, the
lower appellate court has not come to any positive finding
that Inder Kaur was the daughter of Gurbax Singh. He has
been swayed away by the so-called mutation in the
revenue record in favour of Inder Kaur. Mutation of a
property in the revenue record does not create or
extinguish title nor has it any presumptive value on title. It
only enables the person in whose favour mutation is
ordered to pay the land revenue in question. The learned
Additional District Judge was wholly in error in coming to a
conclusion that mutation in favour of Inder Kaur conveys
title in her favour. This erroneous conclusion has vitiated
the entire judgment. That apart, as it would be seen, the
learned trial Judge had considered the oral evidence
adduced on behalf of the parties to establish the respective
stand as to who was the second daughter of Gurbax Singh
and on perusal of the same came to the conclusion that it
was Roori who was the second daughter of Gurbax Singh.
The Additional District Judge has not even discussed
anything about the said oral evidence and the reasonings
advanced by the learned trial Judge in coming to the
conclusion that it was Roori who was the second daughter
of Gurbax Singh. Non-consideration of the oral evidence
adduced by the parties, by the lower appellate court
vitiates the ultimate conclusion on the question whether
Roori was the daughter of Gurbax Singh or not. It is further
seen that Gurdip Kaur, widow of Gurbax Singh had
executed a Will in respect of the entire estate in favour of
the plaintiff and Roori and after the death of Gurdip Kaur a
succession certificate had been issued by the civil court
under the Indian Succession Act, 1925 in favour of the
plaintiff and the said Roori. The said succession certificate
and rights flowing therefrom cannot be ignored. Admittedly
no attempt has been made by Defendants 1 to 4 to annul
the succession certificate on the grounds available under
the Succession Act. The Additional District Judge
committed serious error of law in not considering the said
Will and the succession certificate in question which
unequivocally clinches the matter and thereby the ultimate
judgment of the Additional District Judge is vitiated. The
High Court also was in error in not examining these
questions and dismissing the second appeal in limine.”
Referring the same, Learned DSGI for the appellants further
drawn the attention of the Court that entry in revenue records does
not create or extinguish title, nor has it any presumptive value on
title. Here in the case at hand as already stated the respondentplaintiffs could not produce or prove any document of title in favor of
their ownership over the suit land and as such, just on the basis of
khatian, they cannot claim any title over the suit land but the Learned
Courts below misconceived or misinterpreted the settled position of
law and granted decree in favour of the respondent-plaintiffs which
needs to be interfered with.
10.
Learned DSGI appearing on behalf of the appellants also
referred another citation of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India
reported in (2019) 6 SCC 82 [titled as Jagdish Prasad Patel
(Dead) through Legal Representatives & Anr vs. Shivnath &
Ors.] wherein in para Nos.15 and 44, Hon'ble the Apex Code
observed as under:
“15. Section 58 of the Evidence Act, no doubt, postulates
that the things admitted need not be proved. However, the
proviso to Section 58 of the Evidence Act gives full
discretion to the court to require the facts admitted to be
proved otherwise than by such admission. When the
respondent-plaintiffs have filed the suit for declaration of
their title, the respondent-plaintiffs cannot isolate few
sentences in the written statement and take advantage of
only those parts of the written statement which are
favourable to them. The written statement filed by the
appellant-defendants has to be read in toto. It is pertinent
to note that in para 2 of the written statement, the
appellant-defendants averred that the lands were in the
ownership of Ram Raj Singh at the time of the settlement,
but because he was not in a position to cultivate the same
himself, the lands were given to the father of the
respondent-plaintiffs for cultivation on the basis of Bataicrop sharing. It is further averred that the then Halkedar
cancelled the lease in respect of disputed lands and the
same were auctioned in which the bid of the defendants'
father Gaya Din was accepted and the disputed lands were
transferred in his name in the sale in Samvat 1986 i.e.
1929 A.D. The lease of the lands was issued in the name of
Gaya Din. The admission of the defendants as to the lease
of the plaintiffs' father was the lease earlier granted in
favour of the forefathers of the respondents. In the light of
the pleadings and the oral and documentary evidence
adduced by the defendants, notwithstanding the admission
in the written statement, the burden lies upon the
respondent-plaintiffs to prove that the patta-lease
continues to be in their favour and that they are the
holders of patta and that they are in continued possession
of the suit properties.
44. In the suit for declaration of title and possession, the
respondent-plaintiffs could succeed only on the strength of
their own title and not on the weakness of the case of the
appellant-defendants. The burden is on the respondentplaintiffs to establish their title to the suit properties to
show that they are entitled for a decree for declaration. The
respondent-plaintiffs have neither produced the title
document i.e. patta-lease which the respondent-plaintiffs
are relying upon nor proved their right by adducing any
other evidence. As noted above, the revenue entries relied
on by them are also held to be not genuine. In any event,
revenue entries for few khataunis are not proof of title; but
are mere statements for revenue purpose. They cannot
confer any right or title on the party relying on them for
proving their title.”
Referring the same, Learned DSGI submitted that it is already
established beyond doubt that the respondent-plaintiffs before the
Learned Trial Court could not produce and prove any document in
support of their title over the suit land. So, in such a situation, the
ownership of the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs cannot
confer any title of ownership over the suit property as claimed by the
respondent-plaintiffs.
11.
Finally, in summing up, Learned DSGI for the appellants
submitted that since the Learned First Appellate Court overlooked the
title of the respondent-plaintiffs which they failed to prove before the
Learned Trial Court and granted decree in favour of the respondentplaintiffs for which the decree delivered by Learned First Appellate
Court cannot be sustained in the eye of law. and furthermore, there
was no scope on the part of the Civil Court to entertain the suit during
pendency of the revenue proceeding for cancellation of allotment and
since the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs and the respondentplaintiffs did never possess the suit land and as such, as per guideline
of the Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms Allotment of Land
Rules 1962, the allotment was liable to be cancelled for which the
revenue authority rightly drawn up the proceeding which is still
pending for adjudication and in such a situation, the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate Court is perverse, not binding upon the
present appellants and cannot be sustained as per law and as such,
the same is liable to be set aside and dismissed.
12.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel for the respondent-
plaintiffs, Mr. Suman Bhattacharjee first of all drawn the attention of
the Court, referring the plaint, wherein the respondent-plaintiffs,
sought for declaration of the revenue proceeding pending before the
Revenue Court as illegal, void, inoperative and without jurisdiction.
Learned Counsel also drawn the attention of the Court referring the
written statement submitted by the appellant-defendants before the
Learned Trial Court, wherein in para No.23(C) and 23(E), the
appellants specifically admitted the title of predecessor of the
respondent-plaintiffs over the suit land, and as such, according to
Learned Counsel for the respondent-plaintiff in view of Section 58 of
Indian Evidence Act at this stage, there is no scope on the part of the
present appellants to raise this issue that the judgment of Learned
Courts below are perverse on the ground that the document in
respect of title over the suit land could not be produced and proved by
the respondent-plaintiffs. Learned Counsel further submitted that by
the act of the appellant-defendants, the appellants are/is estopped
from raising this issue before this Court at this point of time.
13.
Learned Counsel further drawn the attention of the Court,
referring the judgment dated 09.10.2015 delivered by this High Court
in connection with RSA No.23 of 2011 titled as Sri Biplab Kr.
Majumder & Anr. vs. The State of Tripura & Ors., wherein this
High Court discussed all the relevant points and in para No.14 of the
said judgment, this High Court observed as under:
“14. The plaintiffs instituted the suit claiming title over the
suit land by virtue of an order of allotment but no such
order of allotment proved by the plaintiffs. Nothing also
stated by the plaintiffs in their pleadings or evidence as to
why they did not and/or could not produce the order of
allotment. They claimed their title based on Exbts.1, 2 and
3 which are finally published khatians and those khatians
show that those were prepared pursuant to allotment of
land in the name of Sushil Chandra Majumder.
Admittedly, the revenue authority initiated proceeding for
cancellation of allotment which suggests that there was an
order of allotment and otherwise there was no question of
having initiating a proceeding for cancellation of allotment.
The defendants could not come out with any better
document to show that the suit land was settled in their
names than that of the plaintiffs who have come up before
the Court with finally published khatians which have
presumptive value as per Section 43(3) of the TLR & LR
Act, 1960. So the plaintiffs have established their right,
title and interest in the suit land by producing the khatians
which are documents of better appreciation than that of
the documents produced by the defendant No.4. The
defendant No.4 only relied on Exbt.A, i.e. a true copy of
handing over and taking over of possession but the copy
shows that the possession was handed over by Deputy
Collector, Santirbazar Revenue Circle to the Superintendent
of Agriculture, Bagafa on 29.01.1985 and there is an entry
at the bottom handing and taking over dated 28.03.1985
and the handing over was done by Superintendent of
Agriculture and there is nothing in that copy as to who had
taken over the possession. Any way Exbt.A is a true copy
and not the original document. Those two persons have not
been examined. So the defendant No.4 could not come out
with any better document to controvert the finally
published khatians prepared in the name of Sushil Chandra
Majumder and subsequently in the name of the plaintiffs.
The trial Court as well as the appellate Court, as it appears
put lot of emphasis on Exbt.4, Exbt.8, Exbt.9, Exbt.10,
Exbt.B, Exbt.C, Exbt.D, Exbt.E and Exbt.F. Those are some
official communications between the revenue officials and
those official communications cannot be accepted as a
basic evidence to decide the issue of possession in the
absence of those persons examined about the factual
position they have found. Those official communications
may be considered while appreciating the other evidence
on record.
I am quite surprised and astonished to see that the trial
Court as well as the appellate Court did not at all consider
the oral evidence on record to decide as to who was in
possession of the suit land at the time when the suit was
instituted and before that when the cause of action as
alleged arose.”
Learned Counsel also submitted that the appellants relied
upon some exhibited documents like Exhibit-A to Exhibit-F, some
official
communications but
those
official
communications
were
marked subject to objection and no reliance can be placed upon them
as because the author of those communications were not cited as
witness by the appellants before the Learned Trial Court and those
documents could not establish any better title of the appellants over
the suit land than that of the respondent-plaintiffs.
14.
Learned Counsel Mr. Bhattacharjee again submitted that since
the appellants admitted the ownership of the predecessor of the
respondent-plaintiffs over the suit land, so, the plea taken by the
Learned Counsel for the appellants cannot be accepted at this stage.
In support of his contention, Learned Counsel for the respondentplaintiffs relied upon one citation of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
reported in (2020) 6 SCC 387 [titled as Bhagwat Sharan (Dead
through Legal Representatives) vs. Purushottam & Ors.],
wherein in para No.27, Hon'ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“27. The doctrine of election is a facet of law of estoppel. A
party cannot blow hot and blow cold at the same time. Any
party which takes advantage of any instrument must
accept all that is mentioned in the said document. It would
be apposite to refer to the treatise Equity—A Course of
Lectures by F.W. Maitland, Cambridge University, 1947,
wherein the learned author succinctly described principle
of election in the following terms:
“The doctrine of election may be thus stated : that he
who accepts a benefit under a deed or will or other
instrument must adopt the whole contents of that
instrument, must conform to all its provisions and
renounce all rights that are inconsistent with it….”
This view has been accepted to be the correct view in
Karam Kapahi v. Lal Chand Public Charitable Trust [Karam
Kapahi v. Lal Chand Public Charitable Trust, (2010) 4 SCC
753 : (2010) 2 SCC (Civ) 262] . The plaintiff having elected
to accept the will of Hari Ram, by filing a suit for eviction of
the tenant by claiming that the property had been
bequeathed to him by Hari Ram, cannot now turn around
and say that the averments made by Hari Ram that the
property was his personal property, is incorrect.”
Learned Counsel further referred another citation of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in this aspect reported in (2013) 5
SCC 470 [titled as Rajasthan State Industrial Development and
Investment
Corporation
&
Anr.
vs.
Diamond
and
Gem
Development Corporation Ltd. & Anr.], wherein in para No.15 and
16, Hon'ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“I. Approbate and reprobate
15. A party cannot be permitted to “blow hot-blow cold”,
“fast and loose” or “approbate and reprobate”. Where one
knowingly accepts the benefits of a contract, or
conveyance, or of an order, he is estopped from denying
the validity of, or the binding effect of such contract, or
conveyance, or order upon himself. This rule is applied to
ensure equity, however, it must not be applied in such a
manner so as to violate the principles of what is right and
of good conscience. [Vide Nagubai Ammal v. B. Shama Rao
[AIR 1956 SC 593] , CIT v. V. MR. P. Firm Muar [AIR 1965
SC 1216] , Ramesh Chandra Sankla v. Vikram Cement
[(2008) 14 SCC 58 : (2009) 1 SCC (L&S) 706 : AIR 2009 SC
713] , Pradeep Oil Corpn. v. MCD [(2011) 5 SCC 270 :
(2011) 2 SCC (Civ) 712 : AIR 2011 SC 1869] , Cauvery
Coffee Traders v. Hornor Resources (International) Co. Ltd.
[(2011) 10 SCC 420 : (2012) 3 SCC (Civ) 685] and V.
Chandrasekaran v. Administrative Officer [(2012) 12 SCC
133 : (2013) 2 SCC (Civ) 136 : JT (2012) 9 SC 260] .]
16. Thus, it is evident that the doctrine of election is based
on the rule of estoppel—the principle that one cannot
approbate and reprobate is inherent in it. The doctrine of
estoppel by election is one among the species of estoppels
in pais (or equitable estoppel), which is a rule of equity. By
this law, a person may be precluded, by way of his actions,
or conduct, or silence when it is his duty to speak, from
asserting a right which he would have otherwise had.”
Relying upon the principle of doctrine of election, Learned
Counsel for the respondent-plaintiffs submitted that there is no scope
for the appellants at this stage to take a reverse opinion like “blow hot
and blow cold” at the same time.
15.
Learned Counsel Mr. Bhattacharjee referred another citation
of Hon'ble Calcutta High Court reported in 1964 SCC OnLine Cal
166 [titled as Jatindra Nath Malik vs. Sushilendra Nath Palit]
wherein in Para No.13, Hon'ble the High Court of Calcutta observed as
under:
“13. The submission that the above decisions are to be
distinguished on the ground that they are decisions on the
Bengal Tenancy Act is of no avail to Mr. Banerjee because
in my view, the same principle would apply to the
presumption of correctness of the Record of Rights finally
published under the Estates Acquisition Act, 1953. I am
therefore of opinion that it is not for the parties, relying on
the presumption of correctness of the record of rights
validly prepared under the West Bengal Estates Acquisition
Act, 1953 and the Rules made thereunder, to prove the
foundation or basis of the correctness of the entries of the
record of rights. I, however, like to add that the said
presumption would relate only to the entries recorded, as
authorised by the said Act and the Rules framed thereunder
and not otherwise. Accordingly I hold that the entries in
the disputed record of rights in favour of the appellant are
correct and the evidence adduced on behalf of the plaintiff
respondent did not rebut the said presumption of
correctness attached to them. The first contention of Mr.
Dutt therefore succeeds.”
Learned Counsel also referred another citation of Hon'ble
Gauhati High Court reported in 1997 SCC OnLine Gau 102 [Uttam
Kumar Sen vs. Gita Das Choudhury], wherein in Para No. 12,
Hon'ble Gauhati High Court observed as under:
“12. It is not in dispute that a finally published khatian is
prepared after doing some preliminary works at certain
stages viz. bujarat attestation etc. In the instant case,
there is nothing on the record to show that the present
appellants or any one on their behalf raised any sort of
objection before the survey settlement officer at any of
those stages about the entries. The contention of the
defendants in this regard was that they for the first time
came to know about the record of rights only after
institution of the suit. The survey operation started as far
back as in the year 1964 and the finally published khatian
Ext. 1 was prepared on 20.3.68. The contention of the
defendant was that he sent plaintiff to the office of the
Survey Settlement for presentation of his case, but taking
advantage of that the plaintiff in collusion with the officials
of the survey settlement office got his name entered into
the khatian. The courts-below after discussion of the
evidence rejected the plea and I also find no infirmity in
the finding. There is nothing on record to show the
answering defendants made any sort of enquiry in respect
of the record of rights even though it was averred that the
plaintiff was sent to the office of the survey settlement for
presenting the case on behalf of defendant No. 1.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that in
deciding this appeal the provision of Section 43(3) of TLR and LR Act
may be considered which provides “every entry in the record of rights
as finally published shall, until the contrary is proved, be presumed to
be correct”.
16.
Learned Counsel further referred another citation of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported in (2010) 1 SCC 466
[titled
as
Kattinokkula
Murali
Krishna
vs.
Veeramalla
Koteswara Rao & Ors.] wherein in para No.15, Hon’ble the Apex
Court observed as under: (relevant part)
“24. It is a settled principle of law that evidence beyond
the pleadings can neither be permitted to be adduced nor
can such evidence be taken into consideration.
***
***
***
***
***
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that the plea
taken by the appellants at this stage cannot be accepted as the same
was beyond the pleading and evidence on record of the appellantdefendants.
17.
Finally,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent-plaintiffs
submitted that the appellant-defendants have failed to project the
case for consideration by this Court and the substantial questions of
law formulated stands against the appellants of this case and Section
44 of TLR & LR Act does not support the case of the appellantdefendants
and
as
such,
Learned
Counsel
Mr.
Bhattacharjee
submitted that there is no scope to interfere with the judgment and
decree delivered by the Learned First Appellate Court. So, Learned
Counsel urged for dismissal of this appeal with costs.
18.
Learned
Addl.
G.A.
representing
the
State-respondents
submitted that there is no role of the respondents No.3 and 4 in
deciding this appeal and urged before this Court to pass appropriate
order in accordance with law.
19.
Now, before coming to the conclusion of this appeal, let us
discuss about the subject matter of dispute amongst the rival parties.
The respondent-plaintiffs filed one suit before the Learned Trial Court
i.e. Learned Civil Judge(Junior Division), Belonia, South Tripura which
was registered as T.S. No.12 of 2009 for a decree of declaration with
consequential relief and for perpetual injunction with the fact that
their predecessor Sushil Chandra Majumder (since dead) was allotted
land measuring 1.10 acres of Khas land in the year 1975 by the
Government and accordingly vide allotment case No.69, Khatian
bearing No.1168 was published in the name of their predecessor.
After getting allotment, he started enjoying possession over the same
by planting different types of trees, etc and when the survey was
completed, finally published khatian was prepared and issued in the
name of the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs namely Sushil
Chandra Majumder and said Sushil Chandra Majumder during his
lifetime was under peaceful possession of the same without any
obstruction from any corner. According to the respondent-plaintiffs,
the defendant No.4 i.e. the appellant herein who was having some
land adjacent to the allotted land of the predecessor of the
respondent-plaintiffs, approached the predecessor of the plaintiffs to
vacate the allotted land but he refused for which the appellant
approached O/C Manpathar O.P. and O/C, Shantir Bazar P.S. as well
as SDO, Belonia to take possession of the same and also approached
the District Collector, South Tripura to initiate a revenue case for
cancellation of the allotment order in favour of the predecessor of the
respondent-plaintiffs which is still pending for disposal and in the
meantime, said defendant No.4 i.e. the appellant herein on several
occasion tried to dispossess the predecessor of the respondentplaintiffs from the suit land but failed. Thereafter, said Sushil Chandra
Majumder expired on 02.04.2007 leaving behind the respondent-
plaintiffs as his legal heirs and accordingly after his death, they
approached to the revenue authority for mutation of the said land in
their name and accordingly, revenue authority mutated the said land
in their favour finding them in possession. The appellant-defendants
on 27.12.2008 again tried to dispossess the respondent-plaintiffs from
the said land i.e. the allotted land but their efforts were frustrated due
to timely resistance. Finding no way, the respondent-plaintiffs filed
the suit.
The defendant No.4 i.e. the appellant herein contested the
suit by filing written statement denying the claim of the respondentplaintiffs and took the plea that the predecessor of the respondentplaintiffs and after his death the respondent-plaintiffs did never
possess the suit property but the said defendant did never deny the
title of the predecessor of the plaintiffs and later on the plaintiffs. It
was further submitted that in the year 1985 Government allotted
31.54 acres of land in favour of the appellant to construct a research
centre which includes the suit land and since then the said defendant
was enjoying the same peacefully but in the year 1997, when the
predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs tried to enter into the suit
property, that time, they could know that the allotment of the same
was made in favour of the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs
and after that, they approached to the District Collector, South
Tripura for cancellation of allotment which is still pending for disposal.
As the other defendants did not contest the suit, so, the suit
proceeded ex parte.
20.
Learned Trial Court on perusal of the pleadings of the parties
framed the following issues:
1. Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form?
2. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get a decree
declaring their right, title and interest as well as
confirmation of possession over the suit land?
3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get a decree
declaring the revenue proceeding No.-09/07 under Rule
15(VII) of TLR & LR Rule 1962 in the Court of Addl.
District Magistrate & Collector, South Tripura Udaipur as
illegal, void and inoperative?
4. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get a decree for
perpetual injunction against the defendants and their
agents as prayed for?
5. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get any other relief
and if so up to what extent?
21.
Before the Learned Trial Court, one of the respondent-
plaintiffs and his 4(four) other witnesses were examined and the
respondent-plaintiffs relied upon some documents which were marked
as Exhibit-1 to Exhibit-10.
On the other hand, on behalf of the appellant, one Arvind
Kumar Singh, Chailafru Mog, Kanja Mog, Vanubala Debnath, Laduang
Mog were adduced who were examined as DWs-1 to 5 and the
appellant-defendant relied upon some documents which were also
marked as Exhibit-A to Exhibit-F subject to objection by the
respondent-plaintiffs.
For the sake of convenience, the name of witnesses and the
exhibits of the rival parties are mentioned herein below:
(A) Plaintiffs' Exhibits :i) Ext.1:- Certified copy of Khatian No.1168 of
Mouja-B.C. Nagar.
ii) Ext.2:- Certified copy of finally published
Khatian No.647 of Mouja-B.C. Nagar.
iii) Ext.3:- Mutated Khatian No.647 of Mouja-B.C.
Nagar.
iv) Ext.4:- Certified copy of enquiry report of
D.C.M., Santir Bazar, dated 08.10.2003.
v) Ext.5:- Certified copy of order in connection
with Revenue case No.16/04.
vi) Ext.6:- Certified copy of order in connection
with Revenue case No.09/07.
vii) Ext.7:- Certified copy of local notice.
viii) Ext.8:- Certified copy of letter dated
18.05.2007 of S.D.M., Santir Bazar addressed
to D.M., South Tripura, Udaipur.
ix) Ext.9:- Certified copy of enquiry report dated
29.03.2007.
x) Ext.10:- Certified copy of enquiry report
dated 28.07.2009.
(B) Plaintiffs' Witnesses :i) PW.1 Sri Biplab Kumar Majumder.
ii) PW.2 Tapan Sen.
iii) PW.3 Sunil Dey.
iv) PW.4 Jadugopal Datta.
v) PW.5 Nirmal Das.
(C) Defendant's Exhibits :i) Ext.A:- True copy of the handing over and
taking over of the
suit
land
dated
28.03.1985.
ii) Ext.B:- One photo copy of the letter dated
10.04.2007 by the Sr. Deputy Magistrate
addressed to the S.D.M., Santir Bazar.
iii) Ext.C:- One report of the D.C.M., Santir Bazar
dated 08.10.2003.
iv) Ext.D:- one photo copy of the letter dated
23.10.2002 of District Magistrate, South
Tripura.
v) Ext.E:- True copy of the enquiry report dated
25.09.2002 of S.D.M., Belonia.
vi) Ext.F:- A letter dated 23.03.2004 of S.D.M.,
Belonia addressed to the District Magistrate,
South Tripura.
(D) Defendant's Witnesses :i) DW.1 Arvind Kr. Singh.
ii) DW.2 Chailafru Mog.
iii) DW.3 Kanja Mog.
iv) DW.4 Vanubala Debnath.
v) DW.5 Laduang Mog.
22.
Finally, after conclusion of trial, Learned Trial Court decided
all the issues excepting issue No.3 in favour of the respondentplaintiffs. The operative portion of the judgment and decree dated
16.07.2010 runs as follows:
O_R_D_E_R
“In the result, the plaintiffs succeed and this Title Suit is
accordingly decreed partly on contest with costs.
It is hereby declared that the plaintiffs have right, title and
interest over the suit property and the possession of the
plaintiffs over the suit property is confirmed. Further the
defendants are restrained permanently from entering into
the suit property and from disturbing the peaceful
possession of the plaintiffs.
Prepare the decree accordingly.
This Title Suit stands disposed on contest.”
Challenging that judgment and decree, the present appellant
preferred appeal before the Court of Learned Addl. District Judge,
South Tripura, Belonia who by judgment and order dated 21.03.2011
allowed the appeal and reversed the judgment of the Learned Trial
Court. The operative portion of the judgment and order dated
21.03.2011 delivered by the Learned First Appellate Court runs as
follows:
10.
***
***
***
***
***
***
For the reasons stated above, in my considered opinion, the
learned court below was in error in declaring the title of
the plaintiffs over the suit land and so also their
possession. So, the judgment and decree cannot stand and
are quashed and set aside accordingly.
12. Prepare decree accordingly.
13. Send back the L. C. Record along with a copy of this
judgment and the documents of the defendant No.4
contained in the trunk with lock to the court below.
23.
After that, the respondent-plaintiffs preferred second appeal
before this High Court which was numbered as RSA No.23 of 2011
and this High Court after hearing both the sides by judgment dated
09.10.2015 was pleased to set aside the judgment of the Learned
First Appellate Court and remanded back the matter to the Learned
District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia with a direction to deliver a
fresh judgment after considering the oral/documentary evidence on
record within a period of 4(four) months.
Thereafter, Learned District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia by
judgment and decree dated 29.03.2016 after hearing both the sides
uphold the judgment dated 16.07.2010 delivered by the Learned Trial
Court. The operative portion of the judgment and order dated
29.03.2016 delivered by the Learned District Judge in connection with
T.A. No.10 of 2010 runs as follows:
ORDER
“12. In view of the decision arrived at issue-wise, it is
ordered that the respondents (plaintiffs No.1 and 2) have
right, title and interest over the suit property and
possession of the respondents (plaintiffs No.1 and 2) over
the suit property is confirmed. Further, the appellants
(defendants) are restrained permanently from entering
into the suit property and from disturbing the peaceful
possession of the respondents (Plaintiffs No.1 and 2).
13. In the result, appeal is dismissed of on contest.
14. Prepare decree accordingly.
15. Send back the L.C. Record along with a copy of this
judgment to the court below.”
Challenging
that
judgment,
the
appellants
have
again
preferred this second appeal before this Court.
24.
I have heard detailed argument of Learned Counsel of both
the sides and also gone through the judgments delivered by the
Learned First Appellate Court as well as the Learned Trial Court and
also perused the exhibited documents.
Admittedly, the Government of Tripura in the year 1975
allotted
land
measuring
1.10
acres
under
Mouja
and
T.K.-
Birchandranagar, Revenue Circle-Shantirbazar in favour of one Sushil
Chandra Majumder(since dead) i.e. the predecessor of the present
respondent-plaintiffs appertaining to old CS plot No.1213/2233 and
1213/2234 through PB No.59 and the said land was allotted in favour
of said Sushil Chandra Majumder vide allotment case No.69. On
perusal of said Khatian No.1168(Exbt.-1), it appears that in the
remarks column there was only reflection of one hut. There was no
other entry of possession of any other person save and except the
possession of said deceased Sushil Chandra Majumder. Said khatian
was finally published on 31.12.1992 in Khatian No.647(Exbt.-2)
wherein similar quantum of land was recorded showing hal CS Plot
No.1966 land measuring 0.50 acres, 1966/3093 land measuring 0.07
acres, 1966/3094 land measuring 0.28 acres, 1967 land measuring
0.25 acres (in total land measuring 1.10 acres). In the finally
published khatian also, there was no reflection of possession of any
other
person
save
and
except
said
deceased
Sushil
Chandra
Majumder over the suit land. In this regard, Section 43(3) of TLR & LR
Act is very much relevant. Meaning thereby, entry in the record of
right shall be presumed to be correct until the contrary is proved.
On perusal of Exbt.-1 (Khatian No.1168) and Exbt.-2 (Khatian
No.642), it appears that since 1975 to till 1992 except said Sushil
Chandra Majumder no other persons were there as possessor over
said land i.e. the suit land measuring 1.10 acres. Later on after the
death of said Sushil Chandra Majumder in the year 2007 the said land
was mutated in favour of the respondent-plaintiffs i.e. the original
plaintiffs of the suit in the same Khatian against the same CS plots
wherein also the revenue authority did not record the name of any
other persons as possessors excepting the name of the respondentplaintiffs. Had there be any other person/persons than definitely their
names could have been reflected in the relevant column of possession
in the Khatian.
Now,
admittedly
before
the
Learned
Trial
Court
the
respondent-plaintiffs could not produce and prove the order of
allotment of the suit land issued in favour of Sushil Chandra
Majumder but by the admission of the appellant No.1 in their written
statement in para No.23(c) and 23(e) and in view of Section 58 of the
Indian Evidence Act the appellant No.1 is estopped from raising the
plea that the Khatian does not confer any title in absence of
production and proving of original allotment order. Because there is
no any contrary evidence on record from the side of the appellant that
the suit land was never allotted in the name of the predecessor of the
respondent-plaintiffs. There is also no contrary evidence on record
from the side of the appellants that since 1975 some other persons
including the appellant has/have/had been possessing the suit land. It
is the settled position of law that entry in revenue records does not
confer any title. In this regard, reliance was placed by the appellants
on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court and this High Court
also but the subject matter of disputes of these cases are completely
different from the present case. In those cases, decision was based
for want of any deed of title or related document but here in the case
at hand the suit land was originally Govt. khas land which was later
on allotted in favour of the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs
and thereafter the same was recorded in the name of present
respondent-plaintiffs as owner-cum-possessor by way of mutation.
25.
At the time of hearing and before the Learned Trial Court also
the appellants relied upon some documentary evidences which were
marked as Exbt.-A to Exbt.-F. I have also perused the same. It
appears that land measuring 31.54 acres was handed over to the
appellant
which
was
received
by
the
then
Superintendent
of
Agriculture, Bagafa, South Tripura on 29.01.1985. Perhaps the same
land was adjacent to the suit land belonging to the respondent-
plaintiffs. The appellants relied upon said exhibited documents in
support of their claim but those documents are certain official
communications and the authors of those communications were not
cited as witness by the appellant before the Learned Trial Court. So,
simply on the basis of marking of those documents as Exhibits with
objection, the appellants cannot take the plea that the appellant No.1
has/had valid title than that of the respondent-plaintiffs over the suit
land or they had valid possession over the suit land by adducing oral
evidence on record.
26.
It is also the admitted position in this case that a revenue
proceeding for cancellation of the suit land before the appropriate
revenue authority was/is still pending for disposal. The respondentplaintiffs before the Learned Trial Court in the plaint sought for
declaring the revenue proceeding as void and illegal but the Learned
Trial Court at the time of deciding issue No.3 decided the same
against the respondent-plaintiffs on the ground that Civil Court has
got no jurisdiction to interfere with the revenue proceeding. In this
regard, at the time of hearing Learned Counsel for the appellants
drawn the attention of the Court referring Section 44 of TLR & LR Act
which provides as under:
“44. Jurisdiction of civil courts to decide disputes.-(1)
When a notification under section 26 directing the revenue
survey of any local area with a view to settlement of the
land revenue and to the preparation of a record of rights
connected therewith or the revision of any existing
settlement or record of rights in any local area has been
published after the enforcement of the Tripura Land
Revenue and Land Reforms (Fifth Amendment) Act, 1979,
no civil court shall entertain any suit or application for the
settlement or determination of land revenue or the
incidence of any tenancy to which the record of rights
relates, and if any suit or application, in which any of the
aforesaid matters is in issue, is pending before a civil court
on the date of publication of the notification in the Official
Gazette, it shall be stayed and it shall, on the expiry of the
period for filing application for revision under section 45, or
when such application has been filed within time on expiry
of the period prescribed under section 94 for filing an
appeal under section 93 against the order disposing of such
application or when an appeal has been filed under the
section within time, as the case may be, on disposal of such
appeal, abate so far as it relates to any of the aforesaid
matters.
(2) No civil court shall entertain any suit or application
concerning any land if it relates to alteration of any entry in
the record of rights finally published, revised, corrected or
modified under any of the provisions of this Chapter or
Chapter VIII of this Act consequent upon the notification
issued under section 26 after the enforcement of the
Tripura
Land
Revenue
and
Land
Reforms
(Fifth
Amendment) Act, 1979.”
On bare perusal of the said provision, it appears that the
jurisdiction of Civil Court is ousted only when a notification under
Section 26 of TLR & LR Act was published regarding revenue survey of
any local area. But here in the case at hand the appellants or the
State-respondent could not produce/prove any notification under
Section 26 of the TLR & LR Act before the Learned Trial Court to
substantiate the bar of jurisdiction of the Civil Court in view of the
notification issued under Section 26 of TLR & LR Act, 1960. Nor the
appellants or the State filed any prayer before the Learned Trial Court
for staying further proceeding of the suit till disposal of the revenue
proceeding, taking the plea of pendency of any such notification.
27.
Situated thus, in the considered opinion of this Court the
decision of Learned Trial Court in respect of issue No.3 and also the
Learned First Appellate Court in respect of same issue was not proper
and the same is interfered with and accordingly the same is declared
as void, inoperative and not binding upon the respondent-plaintiffs on
the ground that Civil Court had the authority/jurisdiction to entertain
the suit and to decide the issue. Furthermore, to counter the issue
there was no contrary evidence on record from the side of Staterespondents also.
Even to counter the same, Learned Addl. G.A. for the Staterespondents in course of hearing of argument did not submit
anything.
28.
I have also gone through the evidence on record of the
contesting parties and it appears that the appellants as defendants by
adducing oral/documentary evidence on record failed to project any
case of their possession to disbelieve the case of the respondentplaintiffs. The citations as referred by Learned Counsel for the
appellants are distinguishable in facts with the present case as such,
the same cannot be applied in this case rather the citations as
referred by the respondent-plaintiffs appears to be more relevant for
decision of this present appeal.
The appellants on the basis of some official communications
tried to draw the attention of the Court showing their possession and
ownership over the suit land but those official communications are
also contrary to each other and in absence of evidence on record of
the author of those communications or evidence of possession over
the suit land, no inference can be drawn in favour of the appellants.
Furthermore, settlement operation also passes through different
stages. The appellants by adducing oral/documentary evidence on
record could not establish any title of them over the suit land better
than that of the respondent-plaintiffs and as such, in the considered
opinion of this Court there is no infirmity or perversity in the
judgment delivered by Learned First Appellate Court.
29.
In our State during settlement operation, huge quantum of
lands were allotted to the different persons by the State Government
by issuing allotment orders and in pursuance of those allotment
orders, Khatians have been prepared in the names of the respective
allottees. But sometimes during settlement operation some village
rustic persons, for their ignorance, could not collect the copy of order
of allotments or for any reason, those copy of order of allotments
were not supplied to the respective allottees by the Department,
resulting which in the civil suit, the parties concerned cannot produce
the copy of allotment orders to prove their title. But it is the admitted
position that on the basis of these allotment orders Khatians are being
prepared during settlement operation finding the actual allottees in
possession after observing different stages of settlement including
field verification. Situated thus there is no scope to take any inference
that the party/parties who are possessing allottee lands have/had no
title over the land under their possession. This issue needs to be
addressed by the State Government. Learned Advocate General may
be requested to take up the matter with the respective department of
the Government to ensure supply of copy/certified copies of the
allotment orders to the persons in the event of filing of application, to
enable the parties to submit the same to the Courts in case of need.
In view of the situation, all the civil Courts be asked to pass
appropriate order in the light of the judgment passed by this Court
until and unless the contrary evidence is proved when the title of
holder of allottee land is questioned before any civil Court.
30.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-defendants
stands dismissed on contest with costs being devoid of merit. The
judgment
dated
29.03.2016
and
decree
dated
30.03.2016
delivered by Learned District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia in
connection with Case No.TA/10/2010 upholding the judgment
dated 16.07.2010 and decree dated 23.07.2010 delivered by
Learned Civil Judge(Junior Division), Belonia, South Tripura in
connection with case No.T.S. No.12 of 2009 is hereby upheld and
the same is accordingly affirmed.
However, since it is discussed and decided that the Learned
Trial Court and Learned First Appellate Court committed error in
deciding issue No.3 of the suit, so, the revenue proceeding pending
before
the
appropriate
revenue
authority
bearing
No.09/07
accordingly stands quashed and set aside and answered in favour of
the respondent-plainitffs.
With the aforesaid observation, the present appeal stands
disposed of.
Prepare decree accordingly. In the event of deposit of
adjournment cost of Rs.5,000/- by the respondent-plaintiffs within 10
days, the decree would come into operation.
Registrar (Judl.) be asked to circulate the copies of judgment
to all the civil Courts across the State for their information.
Also, a copy of this judgment be supplied to Learned
Advocate General, State of Tripura for information and necessary
action.
Send down the records to the Learned Trial Court and the
Learned First Appellate Court along with a copy of this judgment and
order.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.09.18
A DATTA 17:20:39 -07'00'
Deepshikha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review