Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:42163
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. : 679 of 2025
Reserved on : 05.08.2026
Decided on : 30.09.2026
Uploaded on : 30.09.2026
The Katohar Khurd Cooperative Agriculture Services Ltd.
& Anr.
…Petitioners
Versus
Pardeep Kumar Gautam & Ors.
…Respondents
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
Yes.
For the petitioners
Mr. Gurinder Singh Parmar,
Advocate.
For the respondents
:
:
Mr. R.K. Gautam and Mr.
Pawan Gautam, Advocates, for
respondents No. 1 to 5.
Virender Singh, Judge
Petitioners have filed the present petition,
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, for
quashing/ setting aside the order dated 06.09.2025,
passed by the Court of learned Civil Judge, Court No. II,
Amb, District Una, H.P. (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
learned trial Court’), in Civil Suit No. 13612024, in case
titled as “Pardeep Kumar Gautam & Ors. Versus The
Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2026:HHC:42163
Katohar Khurd Cooperative Agriculture Service Society
Ltd. & Ors.”.
2.
By way of order dated 06.09.2025, the learned
trial Court has dismissed the application under Order 7
Rule 11 CPC read with Section 151 CPC and Section 76 of
the Himachal Pradesh Cooperative Societies Act, 1968,
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’), filed by the petitioners
defendants.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties to the
present lis, are, hereinafter referred to, in the same
manner, as were, referred to, by the learned trial Court.
4.
Facts in brief, leading to the filing of the present
appeal, before this Court, may be summed up, as under:
4.1
The plaintiffs have filed a suit for declaration to
the effect that the order dated 09.08.2023, vide which, the
Nomination Forms of plaintiffs No. 1 and 2 were rejected by
defendant No. 2, in an illegal manner and further
declaration to the effect that the election dated 25.08.2023,
of the Katohar Khurd Cooperative Agriculture Service
Society Ltd. Katohar Khurd, Tehsil Amb, District Una, H.P.
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
‘the
Society’),
whereby
defendants No. 4 to 9 were declared as elected members of
2026:HHC:42163
the Society by him in an illegal and unconstitutional
manner, as the election dated 25.08.2023 was not
conducted by defendants No. 2 and 3, as per the schedule
of the election programme in the fair and transparent
manner and the whole process of election be declared null
and void, being illegal, invalid, unwarranted, wrong,
erroneous and not binding upon the plaintiffs and the
members of the Society.
4.2
In addition to this, they have also filed suit for
mandatory injunction, thereby directing defendant No. 11
to dissolve the Managing Committee of the Society,
immediately
and
to
appoint
Administrator
from
the
Cooperative Department, to run the day to day functioning
of the Society under his supervision till the fresh election of
the Society and in the alternative, during the pendency of
the
case,
further
permanent
prohibitory
injunction
restraining defendants No. 4 to 10 from functioning the
day to day affairs of the Society.
4.3
The suit has been filed on the grounds that the
plaintiffs are the members of the Society, created under the
statute to provide the facility to the members and poor
farmers of villages.
The whole area of the CAS Katohar
2026:HHC:42163
Khurd is covered under I to VII Wards. Plaintiffs No. 1 and
2 have contested the election of the Society, from Wards
No. 4 and 7, and their nomination papers were wrongly
rejected in an illegal manner by defendant No. 2, in
connivance with defendants No. 4 to 10.
4.4
According to the plaintiffs, the said election
dated 25.08.2023, of the Society was assailed by availing
the statutory remedy under Section 72 of the Act, by
disputing the said election, before defendant No. 11 and
the said matter is still pending for final adjudication. The
reference of the said election dispute was submitted by the
plaintiffs in the office of defendant No. 11, on 27.08.2023.
As per Rules 91 of the HP Cooperative Societies Rules,
1971 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’), the said
election dispute is to be adjudicated within a period of four
months.
However, defendant No. 11 has not taken any
action, despite repeated requests made by the plaintiffs.
The first date of hearing in the election matter was fixed on
20.01.2024, by defendant No. 11, after about six months.
Thereafter, defendants No. 1 to 4 sought time to file reply
and the proceedings were fixed for 12.02.2024. Nobody on
behalf of defendants No. 1 to 4 put appearance on
2026:HHC:42163
12.02.2024 and the A.R. Cooperative Societies, Una, has
intimated that case is now listed for 11.03.2024.
4.5
It is the further case of the plaintiffs that the
tenure of the members of the Managing Committee is five
years and election as per Act and Rules, was due in the
month of March, 2022, but the same was not conducted at
the instance of the vested interest of defendants No. 4 to
10, who were coopted as a member of the Society on
10.09.2021 and 08.12.2021 and they continued to hold the
post beyond the statutory period of three months, as
prescribed under the provisions of Rule 38(5) of the Rules,
at the instance of Managing Committee of the Society. Vide
letter dated 30.07.2022, issued by the office of the Worthy
A.R.C.S., Una, to the President of the Society, by informing
that no approval of the coopted members by the Managing
Committee of the Society had been obtained. By leveling
the allegations against defendants No. 4 to 10, that they
have interfered in the election programme and they have
done various bungling in preparation
of voters list
deliberately and with malafide intentions.
4.6
It is their further case that defendant No. 1 was
under obligation and duty bound to prepare the Ward wise
2026:HHC:42163
tentative voters list of the members of the Society at the
first instance and to circulate the said tentative voters list
upon the Notice Board and other various known public
places, such as, office of the Gram Panchayat, Mahila
Mandal Bhawan, Patwar Khana, School premises, temple
situated in the area of the Society, but said compliance has
not been done by defendant No. 1. However, on the Notice
Board of the Society, the notice was fixed on 16.07.2023,
that too, for a short time, as plaintiff No. 1 came to know
that his name has wrongly shown in the tentative list at Sr.
No. 241, against Ward No. 5 of the Society.
Thereafter,
plaintiff No. 1 had received a communication dated
18.07.2023, from the Managing Committee in an illegal
manner by informing him that his permanent address, as
detected from his Adhar Card, is at Delhi, when he opened
the shareholder account in the Society and he was
requested to supply the permanent address of the area of
the Society.
Thereafter, plaintiff No. 1 had raised
objections against the tentative voters list and submitted
the same to defendant No. 1 on 22.07.2023 and copy was
forwarded to defendant No. 11 on 18.07.2023.
2026:HHC:42163
4.7
In addition to this, the other voters of the
Society had also filed objections against the tentative voters
list, to defendants No. 1 and 11.
On 24.07.2023,
defendant No. 11 had issued directions to defendant No. 1,
thereby directing her to supply the justified information to
Pawan
Gautam,
Pardeep
Gautam,
Smt.
Rajeshwari
Gautam and Smt. Indu Gautam, with respect to their
objections against the tentative voters list.
4.8
Thereafter,
plaintiff
No.
had
submitted
explanation in his reply dated 03.08.2023, by annexing
documentary proof, to show that he is a permanent
resident of Village Katohar Kalan and having agricultural
land in his village, which falls in Ward No. 4, of the Society.
Thereafter, plaintiff No. 1 has filled up his nomination form
on
05.08.2023,
for
contesting
the
election
dated
25.08.2023, by presuming that defendant No. 1 might have
made the necessary corrections in the tentative voters list
of Ward No. 4. The nomination form of plaintiff No. 1 was
accepted by defendant No. 2 and the list prepared by him,
after scrutiny, was placed on the Notice Board of the
Society. On 07.08.2023, plaintiff No. 1 came to know from
the list pasted on the Notice Board of the Society that his
nomination
form was
rejected
2026:HHC:42163
by defendant
No.
2.
Similarly, nomination of plaintiff No. 2, from Ward No. 7
was also rejected. Thereafter, plaintiff No. 1 submitted an
application on 08.08.2023 to defendant No. 2, with the
request to know the ground, upon which, his nomination
was rejected.
The name of plaintiff No. 1 was wrongly
rejected by defendant No. 2, with mala fide intention, at the
instance of defendants No. 4 to 10, by observing that name
was not found in the voters list, including the documents
submitted by plaintiff No. 1, before taking any decision
upon the objections.
4.9
Thereafter, by way of joint representation dated
11.08.2023, plaintiffs made representation to defendant
No. 11 to conduct proper enquiry himself in the election
process of the Society. However, the same has not yet been
done. After receiving the representation, defendant No. 11
sought the report from Block Inspector, Cooperative
Societies, vide letter dated 31.08.2023, but no report was
prepared by the Block Cooperative Inspector.
4.10
Lastly, it has been pleaded that the process of
election dated 25.08.2023, was not conducted as per the
Rules, by defendants No. 1 and 2 and declaration of result
dated
25.08.2023
by
defendant
2026:HHC:42163
No.
is
also
not
sustainable in the eyes of law.
4.11
On the basis of above facts, following relief has
been sought by the plaintiffs:
“Keeping in view the aforesaid peculiar facts and
circumstances, it is, therefore, respectfully prayed that
this Hon’ble Court may kindly be pleased to decree the
present suit with special costs and to set aside, annul
and cancel the impugned order dated 08.08.2023 and
declaration of result dated 25.08.2023, which has not
been conducted in accordance with law and whole
process of the election was out of the law and further
graciously the defendant No. 11 may kindly be directed to
dissolve the present Managing Committee of the CAS
Katohar Khurd and to appoint Administrators, to run the
day to day affairs of the Society till the fresh election of
the Society, during the pendency of the present case, in
this Hon’ble Court and further the defendants No. 4 to 10
may kindly be restrained from interference in the day to
day affairs of the CAS Katohar Khurd, during the
pendency of the present case, in the interest of justice and
the property interest of the Society.”
5.
In the said suit, the defendants have filed an
application under Order 7 Rule 11 read with Section 151 of
CPC and under Section 76 of the Act, for rejection of the
plaint, by citing the provisions of Section 76 of the Act,
which, according to the defendants, goes to the very root of
the case, as suit is not maintainable.
6.
According to the defendants, no notice, as per
Section 76 of the Act, was ever served upon them by the
Society.
In this regard, the defendants have relied upon
the decision of this Court, in “The Jawali, Harijan
2026:HHC:42163
Cooperative Agricultural Society Vs Maghu etc., AIR
1992 Himachal Pradesh 34”, wherein, according to
them, it has been held that in case, no notice has been
served, as required under Section 76 of the Act, the suit is
barred and plaint is liable to be rejected, under Order 7
Rule 11 of CPC.
7.
In addition to this, they have also sought the
rejection of the plaint, on the ground, that as per Section
72 of the Act, if any dispute touching the constitution,
management or the business of a cooperative society
arises, then such dispute shall be referred to the Registrar
for decision and no court shall have the jurisdiction to
entertain any suit or other proceedings in respect of such
dispute.
8.
It is their further case that plaintiffs have
already filed a reference petition under Section 72 of the
Act, on the same cause of action, between the parties to
the lis. Reasserting the bar, as created by Section 72 of
the Act, a prayer has been made to reject the plaint.
9.
This application has been contested by the
plaintiffs, by filing the reply, in which, they have taken the
preliminary
objections
that
the
application
is
not
2026:HHC:42163
maintainable, as the same does not fulfill the ingredients,
and the application lacks complete information.
10.
On merits, the application has been contested
on the ground that in para 15 of the plaint, it is the case of
the plaintiffs that they had issued a legal notice dated
16.03.2024, before filing of the present suit. Those notices
have been refused by defendants No. 2 to 7, as per the
postal receipt and as such, the plea taken by them, for
noncompliance of Section 76 of the Act is liable to be
rejected.
11.
The application has also been contested on the
ground that the reference under Section 72 of the Act, was
made within the stipulated period and same is still pending
adjudication,
for
26.04.2025,
whereas,
it
has
been
mandated by Rule 91(2) of the Rules, that the said election
dispute is required to be adjudicated within a period of four
months. The cause of action of the present suit, as well as,
the proceedings under Section 72 of the Act, are stated to
be based upon different cause of action.
12.
The defendants filed rejoinder to the said reply,
denying the stand, as taken in the reply.
13.
2026:HHC:42163
The said application has been dismissed by the
learned trial Court, vide order dated 06.09.2025.
14.
Defendants No. 1 and 4, are before this Court
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. The scope of
interference, in the order passed by the learned trial Court,
that too, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, is
very limited. The scope of interference under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India, has elaborately been discussed
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in “K. Valarmathi & Ors.
Versus Kumaresan, 2025 INSC 606”. Relevant para 9 of
the judgment, is reproduced, as under:
“Essence of the power under Article 227 being
supervisory, it cannot be invoked to usurp the original
jurisdiction of the court which it seeks to supervise. Nor
can it be invoked to supplant a statutory legal remedy
under the Civil Procedure Code, 1908. For example,
existence of appellate remedy under Section 96 of the
Code operates as a near total bar to exercise of
supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227.”
15.
In a recent decision in “Nandi Infrastructure
Corridor Enterprises Ltd. & Anr. Versus B. Gurappa
Naidu & Ors., 2026 INSC 434”, the scope of interference
has again been explained by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
Relevant paragraph 35 of the judgment, is reproduced, as
under:
2026:HHC:42163
“35. In short, the principles laid down in the above
matters is as follows:
a)
The power of superintendence under Article 227 is
not to be exercised unless there has been an (a)
unwarranted assumption of jurisdiction, not vested in
Court or tribunal, or (b) gross abuse of jurisdiction or (c) an
unjustifiable refusal to exercise jurisdiction vested in
Courts or tribunals.
b)
It is also well settled that the High Court while
acting under this Article cannot exercise its power as an
appellate court or substitute its own judgment in place of
that of the subordinate court to correct an error, which is
not apparent on the face of the record.
c)
The High Court exercising supervisory jurisdiction
does not act as a court of first appeal to reappreciate,
reweigh the evidence or facts upon which the
determination under challenge is based. Supervisory
jurisdiction is not to correct every error of fact or even a
legal flaw when the final finding is justified or can be
supported. The High Court is not to substitute its own
decision on facts and conclusion, for that of the inferior
court or tribunal.”
16.
Being guided by the above decisions, now this
Court would proceed further to determine the fact, whether
the order passed by the learned trial Court, rejecting the
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, vide order dated
06.09.2025, does require any interference, by this Court.
17.
The learned trial Court has negated the plea, as
taken in the application, by holding that as per the
documents annexed with the plaint, compliance of Section
76 of the Act has been done.
18.
At the time of deciding the application under
Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, only the averments as made in the
plaint, as well as, the accompanying documents are to be
taken into consideration.
2026:HHC:42163
The defence raised by the
defendants is not liable to be taken into consideration, as
held by Hon’ble Supreme Court in a recent decision, in
case titled as Karam Singh Versus Amarjit Singh &
Ors., 2025 (4) Recent Civil Reports 747. Relevant para
15 of the judgment, is reproduced, as under:
“15. Before we assess the correctness of the impugned
orders, we must remind ourselves of the basic principles
governing rejection of a plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 of
CPC. Here, the defendants seek rejection of plaint under
clause (d) of Rule 11 (i.e., suit barred by law). Clause (d)
makes it clear that while considering rejection of the
plaint thereunder only the averments made in the plaint
and nothing else is to be considered to find out whether
the suit is barred by law. At this stage, the defense is not
to be considered. Thus, whether the suit is barred by any
law or not is to be determined on the basis of averments
made in the plaint.
11. Rejection of plaint. The plaint shall be
rejected in the following cases:
(a) where it does not disclose a cause of action;
(b) where the relief claimed is undervalued, and
the plaintiff, on being required by the Court to
correct the valuation within a time to be fixed by
the Court, fails to do so;
(c) where the relief claimed is properly valued, but
the plaint is returned upon paper insufficiently
stamped, and the plaintiff, on being required by
the Court to supply the requisite stamppaper
within a time to be fixed by the Court, fails to do
so;
(d) where the suit appears from the statement in
the plaint to be barred by any law;
(e) where it is not filed in duplicate;
(f) where the plaintiff fails to comply with the
provisions of rule 9:
Provided that the time fixed by the Court for the
correction of the valuation or supplying of the
requisite stamppaper shall not be extended
unless the Court, for reasons to be recorded, is
satisfied that the plaintiff was prevented by any
cause of an exceptional nature form correcting the
2026:HHC:42163
valuation or supplying the requisite stamppaper,
as the case may be, within the time fixed by the
Court and that refusal to extend such time would
cause grave injustice to the plaintiff.”
19.
Even otherwise, at the time of deciding the
application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, evidence or merits
of the controversy could be examined, as held by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in a case titled as Eldeco Housing
and Industries Ltd. Versus Ashok Vidyarthi & Ors.,
2023 LiveLaw (SC) 1033.
Relevant para 26 of the
judgment, is reproduced, as under:
“26. However, the fact remains that all the aforesaid
documents, referred to by the respondent in support of
his plea for rejection of the plaint, cannot be considered
at this stage as these are not part of the record with the
Court filed along with the plaint. This is the stand taken
by the respondentdefendant in the application filed
under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. As noticed above, no
amount of evidence or merits of the controversy can be
examined at the stage of decision of the application
under Order VII Rule 11 C.P.C. Hence, in our view, the
impugned order of the High Court passed in the Review
Application deserves to be set aside. Ordered
accordingly.”
20.
The rejection of the plaint has also been sought
in the present case, on account of Section 72 of the Act.
The specific case of the plaintiffs is that the competent
authority is required to decide the said issue within a
prescribed period, which as per the averments, as made in
the plaint, has not been done. In such situation, the said
2026:HHC:42163
contention, has rightly been rejected by the learned trial
Court.
21.
decree
In the present case, plaintiffs have sought a
for
declaration,
to
declare
the
result
dated
25.08.2025, as null and void and also sought the relief to
dissolve the present Managing Committee and to appoint
an Administrator, to run day to day affairs of the Society
and the partial rejection of the plaint is prohibited under
the law, as held in Central Bank of India & Ors. Versus
Prabha Jain & Ors., 2025 INSC 95. Relevant para 24 &
25 of the judgment, are reproduced, as under:
“24. Even if we would have been persuaded to take the
view that the third relief is barred by Section 17(3) of the
SARFAESI Act, still the plaint must survive because there
cannot be a partial rejection of the plaint under Order VII,
Rule 11 of the CPC. Hence, even if one relief survives, the
plaint cannot be rejected under Order VII, Rule 11 of the
CPC. In the case on hand, the first and second reliefs as
prayed for are clearly not barred by Section 34 of the
SARFAESI ACT and are within the civil court’s
jurisdiction. Hence, the plaint cannot be rejected under
Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC.
25. If the civil court is of the view that one relief (say relief
A) is not barred by law but is of the view that Relief B is
barred by law, the civil court must not make any
observations to the effect that relief B is barred by law
and must leave that issue undecided in an Order VII, Rule
11 application. This is because if the civil court cannot
reject a plaint partially, then by the same logic, it ought
not to make any adverse observations against relief B.”
22.
Even otherwise, considering the stand of the
plaintiffs, in the plaint right from challenging their
2026:HHC:42163
nomination form, declaring the result as null and void,
prayer
for
issuing
the
mandatory
injunction
and
permanent prohibitory injunction, the suit cannot be
rejected, under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC.
23.
Considering all these facts, this Court is of the
view that the learned trial Court has rightly considered the
stand taken by the parties and hence, the conclusion
regarding the rejection of the application under Order 7
Rule 11 CPC, does not require any interference by this
Court. Consequently, the petition is dismissed.
24.
Any of the observations, made hereinabove,
shall not be taken, as an expression of opinion, on the
merits of the case, as these observations are confined, only
to the disposal of the present petition.
25.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand(s)
disposed of.
26.
Record be sent back, forthwith.
(Virender Singh)
Judge
30th September, 2026
(Pramod Kumar)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review