Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 8TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 864 OF 2011 (MON)
BETWEEN:
THE KARNATAKA BANK LTD.,
D DEVARAJ URS ROAD,
MYSORE - 570 001
REP HEREIN BY ONE OF ITS
PRINCIPAL OFFICERS AND
SENIOR MANAGER OF
DEVARAJ URS ROAD BRANCH
SRI. T.R. MANJUNATH.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. Y.V. PARTHASARATHY, ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally signed
by
SHARADAVANI
B
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
1.
M/S. VENKATESHWARA DISTRIBUTORS
NO. 82, MEZANINE FLOOR
D. DEVARAJ URS ROAD
MYSORE - 570 001.
REPRESENTED BY ITS PROPRIETOR
SRI. K.N. VENKATSH.
2.
M/S. ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
HAVING ITS DIVISIONAL OFFICE AT
NO. 1, TEJAS COMPLEX,
I FLOOR, P.B. NO 27,
SAYYAJI RAO ROAD,
-2NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
MYSORE - 570 001
REPRESENTED BY ITS
SENIOR DIVISIONAL MANAGER .
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. B.K. MOHAN, ADVOCATE FOR R1;
SRI. C. SHANKAR REDDY, ADVOCATE FOR R2)
THIS RFA IS FILED U/S 96 OF CPC, AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE DATED 28.01.2011 PASSED IN
O.S.NO.307/2004 ON THE FILE OF THE I-ADDL. JUDGE, SMALL
CAUSES AND ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE, MYSORE, PARTLY
DECREEING THE SUIT FOR THE RECOVERY OF MONEY.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
ORAL JUDGMENT
The
captioned
appeal
is
by
the
unsuccessful
defendant No.2-The Karnataka Bank Ltd., (for short,
'Bank') assailing the judgment and decree rendered in
O.S.No.307/2004.
2. For the sake of brevity, the ranks of the parties
are referred as per their ranking before the Trial Court.
-3NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
3. The facts leading to the case are as under:
The plaintiff instituted the suit against the Oriental
Insurance
Company
Karnataka
Bank
Limited
Limited
(defendant
(defendant
No.1)
No.2),
and
seeking
recovery of a sum of Rs.13,87,687.97/- together with
interest at the rate of 18% per annum. The plaintiff claims
to
be
the
proprietor
of
Venkateshwara
Distributors,
engaged in the wholesale distribution of pharmaceutical
and allied products. According to the plaintiff, he had
availed an overdraft facility from defendant No.2 bank,
and as a condition precedent for sanction of the said
facility, the bank
required
him to secure
insurance
coverage for the hypothecated stock.
4. The plaintiff asserts that, in compliance with the
said requirement, defendant No.2 bank arranged for
insurance coverage of the hypothecated goods through
defendant No.1 insurance company and ensured automatic
debit
of the insurance premium
from
the plaintiff’s
account. It is further contended that defendant No.2 had
-4NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
been consistently deducting insurance premiums every
year
towards
renewal
of
the
policy
covering
the
hypothecated stock. According to the plaintiff, it was the
obligation
of
defendant
No.2
to
ensure
continuous
insurance coverage for the goods to their full market
value.
5. It is the further case of the plaintiff that on
07.12.2001, a theft occurred in the godown belonging to
him. A complaint was lodged on the following day, i.e.,
08.12.2001, and after securing the First Information
Report, the plaintiff approached both defendants seeking
indemnification under the insurance policy. However,
defendant No.1 declined to settle the claim on the ground
that the godown from which the theft had occurred was
not covered under the insurance policy. According to the
plaintiff, this repudiation was solely attributable to the
failure of defendant No.2 bank to intimate defendant No.1
about the shifting of the godown and to secure appropriate
insurance coverage. Despite issuance of a legal notice, the
-5NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
claim was not settled, compelling the plaintiff to file the
present suit.
6.
Upon
service
of
summons,
both
defendants
entered appearance and contested the suit. Defendant
No.1 insurance company contended that the insurance
policy covered only the shop premises situated at No.82,
Mezzanine Floor, D. Devaraj Urs Road, Mysore, and not
the godown where the alleged theft occurred. It was
specifically pleaded that the policy did not extend coverage
to the new godown and, therefore, defendant No.1 was
not liable to indemnify the plaintiff for the alleged loss.
7.
Defendant
No.2
bank
also
filed
a
written
statement contesting the claim. While admitting that the
plaintiff had executed an agreement of hypothecation in
respect of the stock, defendant No.2 contended that it was
the exclusive responsibility of the plaintiff to insure the
hypothecated
goods,
particularly
upon
shifting
the
godown. It was specifically pleaded that there was no
-6NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
obligation on the part of the bank to secure insurance
coverage for the goods stored in the newly shifted
godown.
8. On completion of pleadings, the Trial Court framed
the necessary issues and the parties were called upon to
adduce their respective oral and documentary evidence.
9. The plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1 and relied
upon documentary evidence marked as Exs.P.1 to P.35.
On behalf of the defendants, the insurance company
examined its official as D.W.1, while defendant No.2 bank
examined D.W.2. The defendants collectively produced
documents marked as Exs.D.1 to D.45.
10. Upon an overall appreciation of the oral and
documentary evidence on record, the Trial Court answered
Issue No.1 in the affirmative, holding that the plaintiff had
established that defendant No.2 bank had undertaken the
responsibility of effecting insurance coverage for the
hypothecated goods. Issue Nos.2 and 3 were answered
-7NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
partly in the affirmative, with the Trial Court holding that
defendant No.2 was primarily liable to compensate the
plaintiff, having failed to intimate defendant No.1 about
the shifting of the godown and to ensure appropriate
insurance coverage. Consequently, the suit was decreed in
part, directing defendant No.2 bank to pay a sum of
Rs.8,12,572/- with interest at 6% per annum from the
date of the suit till realization.
11.
Heard
the
learned
counsel
appearing
for
defendant No.2 bank and the learned counsel for the
plaintiff. Perused the records.
12. The following points arise for consideration:
i. Whether the judgment and decree passed by the Trial
Court, fastening liability on defendant No.2 bank and
directing payment of Rs.8,12,572/- with interest at 6%
per annum from the date of the suit till realization,
suffers
from
perversity
interference by this Court?
or
illegality
warranting
-8NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
ii What order?
13. Finding on point No.i.
Before this Court adverts to the case on hand, it
would be absolutely necessary to advert to Ex.D.12, which
is a communication addressed by the second defendant
bank to the first defendant Oriental Insurance Company
Limited. The communication would have a direct bearing
on as to who is liable to compensate the plaintiff against
the theft of stock. Therefore, this Court deems it fit to
extract Ex.D.12, which reads as under:
"DATE: 12/7/2002
D.DEVARAJ URS ROAD, MYSORE-1.
KB/MYS/PF460/OR /02-03
THE BRANCH MANAGER,
ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO, LTD,
CHAMRAJA DOUBLE ROAD, MYSORE.
Dear sir,
Reg: working capital facility
Distributors of our branch.
of
M/s
Venkateshwar
With reference to the subject matter we write to inform
you the that above cited customer is enjoying OD facility
-9NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
with us and we have taken the policy with you for the
goods hypothecated to us. an 7th December 2001 a theft
was taken place in the godown of the borrwer and this we
have already informed to you vide our letter dated
8/12/2001. Furhter we inform you that the address given
to at the time of taking policy was No. 82 Mozanine your
office floor D. Devaraj urs road, Mysore. All the bank
correnspondence were with this address only and stock
statement submitted by the is also shwoing the same
address. But the borrower had borrower changed the
godown to No.500/3 B.K. street Devaraj mohalla Mysore
the borroweг 570 001 but and the same had been
intimated to us by by oversight it was not informed to you
and the theft taken place in this godown only.
This is for your kind information."
(EMPHASIS SUPPLIED BY ME)
14. On a careful reading of the extracted portion of
the evidence, it becomes manifest that the plaintiff had
duly intimated the second defendant bank regarding the
shifting of his godown from No.82, Mezzanine Floor, D.
Devaraj Urs Road, Mysore, to No.508/3, B.K. Street,
Devaraj Mohalla, Mysore–570001. The communication
addressed by the Branch Manager of the second defendant
bank to the first defendant insurance company clearly
acknowledges the fact that the bank was fully aware of the
shifting
of
the
godown.
Significantly,
the
said
communication also contains an unequivocal admission
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
that the bank, due to an oversight, failed to intimate the
insurance company about the change in location of the
insured premises.
15. This
admission, emanating
from the official
records of the bank itself, completely demolishes the
defence sought to be raised by the second defendant that
the plaintiff had failed to inform the bank about the
shifting
of
the
godown.
On
the
contrary,
Ex.D.12
conclusively establishes that the plaintiff had discharged
his obligation by intimating the bank about the change in
location, and that the failure lay squarely at the doorsteps
of the bank in not transmitting this vital information to the
insurer.
16.
The
significance
of
Ex.D.12
cannot
be
understated. It constitutes a clear acknowledgment of
lapse and negligence on the part of the second defendant
bank and furnishes contemporaneous evidence that the
repudiation of the insurance claim was not attributable to
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
any omission on the part of the plaintiff, but was the direct
consequence of the bank’s failure to communicate the
material change in risk to the insurance company. Such an
admission, being voluntary and unequivocal, binds the
second
defendant
bank
and
decisively
answers
the
controversy regarding liability.
17. In view of this crucial admission, this Court has no
hesitation in holding that the plaintiff had duly intimated
the second defendant bank regarding the shifting of the
godown, and that the subsequent non-coverage of the
godown under the insurance policy arose solely on account
of the bank’s admitted oversight. Ex.D.12, therefore,
clinches the issue and forms the fulcrum for fastening
liability on the second defendant bank for the loss suffered
by the plaintiff.
18. In the backdrop of such categorical admission, the
crucial question that arises for consideration is whether
the second defendant bank can escape liability after
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
having admittedly failed to communicate the shifting of the
godown to the insurance company. The Hypothecation
Agreement executed by the plaintiff, marked as Ex.D.4,
assumes considerable significance in this regard. A plain
reading of the said agreement demonstrates that once the
stock
stood
hypothecated,
the
bank
was
under
an
obligation to safeguard its own security interest, including
the duty to promptly communicate any change or shifting
of the godown where the hypothecated stock was stored.
19. It is not in dispute that by virtue of the
hypothecation,
the
second
defendant
bank
had
a
subsisting charge and general lien over the hypothecated
stock. It is also an admitted position that the bank had
extended an auto-debit facility towards payment of the
insurance
premium
and
that
the
plaintiff
had
duly
informed the bank about the shifting of the godown.
Despite such intimation and despite the premium having
been
auto-debited
from
the
plaintiff’s
account
and
remitted to the first defendant insurance company, the
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
bank failed to communicate the change of address of the
godown. This omission, in the considered view of this
Court, constitutes a clear breach of the obligation cast
upon the bank under the hypothecation arrangement.
20. The evidence of D.W.2, the official examined on
behalf of the second defendant bank, further fortifies the
plaintiff’s case. In his cross-examination, D.W.2 has
admitted in unequivocal terms that the insurance premium
payable towards coverage of the hypothecated stock was
auto-debited from the plaintiff’s account. He has also
admitted that the policy was renewed on a year-to-year
basis and that, as early as in the year 1999, the bank
records reflected that the plaintiff had shifted his godown
to No.508/3, B.K. Street, Devaraj Mohalla, Mysore. These
admissions clearly establish that the bank had complete
knowledge of the change in location well prior to the theft
in question.
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
21. The plaintiff, having availed an overdraft facility,
executed the hypothecation deed to secure the interest of
the bank. The bank, in turn, had insisted upon insurance
coverage
over
the
hypothecated
stock
and
had
consistently ensured renewal of the policy by auto-debiting
the premium every year. Once the premium stood debited
and remitted to the insurance company, and particularly
when the bank was admittedly aware of the shifting of the
godown, the responsibility to intimate the insurer about
the change in location squarely rested upon the bank. The
Branch Manager’s admission that the failure to intimate
the insurer was due to oversight, as evidenced by Ex.D.12,
conclusively establishes negligence on the part of the
second defendant bank.
22. Though ordinarily it is the insurance company,
having issued the policy, that would be liable to indemnify
the insured for loss caused due to theft, the peculiar facts
of the present case demonstrate that the repudiation of
the claim by the insurer was directly attributable to the
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
lapse on the part of the bank. Having auto-debited the
premium, having renewed the policy year after year, and
having full knowledge of the shifting of the godown, the
second defendant bank cannot be permitted to shirk its
responsibility by shifting the burden onto the plaintiff.
23. The Hon’ble Apex Court in Syndicate Bank v.
Vijay Kuma (1992) 2 SCC 330 has conclusively held
that a bank holding security and exercising control over
insured property owes a duty of care and failure to protect
the security interest, including insurance lapses, results in
bank liability. Further the Hon’ble Apex Court in Canara
Bank v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (2020) 3
SCC 455 held that where insurance is obtained pursuant
to banking arrangements and premium is routed through
the bank, the bank cannot disown responsibility and the
bank
is
treated
as
an
intermediary
with
fiduciary
obligation. It also held that a bank that facilitates
insurance
as
part
of
credit
security
consequences of defective coverage.
cannot
escape
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
24. The Delhi High Court in Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Punjab National Bank 2009 SCC OnLine Del
2461 also emphasized that, if premium is deducted by the
bank and remitted to insurer, the bank is responsible to
ensure correctness of coverage particulars. Failure to
intimate change in location fastens liability on the bank.
25. From the settled legal position emerging from the
aforesaid authorities, it is no longer res integra that when
insurance coverage is insisted upon by a bank as a
condition precedent for sanctioning credit facilities, and
when the bank itself undertakes the responsibility of
ensuring payment of premium by auto-debit from the
borrower’s account and consistently facilitates renewal of
the policy, the bank assumes a clear and enforceable duty
of care. Such duty is not merely contractual in nature but
flows from the fiduciary obligation arising out of the bank’s
control over the security and its conscious involvement in
procuring and maintaining insurance coverage over the
hypothecated stock.
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
26. Once the premium stands debited from the
borrower’s account and is remitted to the insurance
company through the bank, the bank cannot subsequently
disown responsibility by contending that the borrower
alone was required to ensure effective coverage. The act
of
auto-debiting
premium,
coupled
with
the
bank’s
insistence on insurance and its role in renewal of the policy
year
after
year,
responsibility
to
amounts
ensure
that
to
an
assumption
the
coverage
is
of
valid,
effective, and corresponds to the actual location and
status
of
the
hypothecated
goods.
Any
lapse
in
communicating material particulars, such as shifting of the
godown, when the bank admittedly had knowledge of such
change, constitutes negligence attributable solely to the
bank.
27. In the present case, the evidence on record
clearly establishes that defendant No.2 bank had full
knowledge of the shifting of the godown, had continued to
auto-debit the insurance premium, and had renewed the
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
policy without intimating the insurer about the change in
location. The repudiation of the claim by the insurance
company is thus a direct consequence of the bank’s
omission and failure to discharge its duty of care. Having
exercised control over the insurance process and having
benefited from the protection of its secured interest
through insurance, the bank cannot be permitted to shift
the burden of its own lapse onto the borrower.
28. Accordingly, applying the settled principles laid
down by the Supreme Court and the High Courts, this
Court holds that defendant No.2 bank is principally liable
to compensate the plaintiff for the loss suffered on account
of theft of the hypothecated stock. The fastening of
liability on the bank by the Trial Court is therefore legally
sound, supported by evidence, and in consonance with the
established principles governing banker’s responsibility in
matters of insurance of hypothecated goods. No perversity
or infirmity is made out warranting interference.
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
29. In these circumstances, this Court finds that the
Trial Court has rightly fastened liability on the second
defendant bank for compensating the plaintiff towards the
loss suffered on account of theft of stock. The conclusion
arrived
at by the
Trial Court
is supported by the
admissions elicited in the cross-examination of D.W.2 and
the documentary evidence, particularly Ex.D.12, which
clinches the issue beyond any pale of doubt.
30. On an overall appreciation of the oral and
documentary evidence, this Court is of the considered view
that
the
second
defendant
bank,
having
failed
to
communicate the shifting of the godown despite being fully
aware of the same and despite having auto-debited the
insurance premium, is principally liable to compensate the
plaintiff. The findings recorded by the learned Trial Judge
are neither perverse nor illegal. On the contrary, they
reflect a proper appreciation of the evidence on record.
Consequently,
this
Court
finds
no
infirmity
in
the
conclusions reached by the Trial Court while answering
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:1144
RFA No. 864 of 2011
HC-KAR
Issue No.1 in the affirmative and Issue Nos.2 and 3 partly
in the affirmative. Accordingly point no.1 is answered in
Negative.
Finding on point no ii.
31. For the foregoing reasons, this Court passes the
following:
ORDER
The regular first appeal is devoid of merits
and accordingly, stands dismissed.
Sd/(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
HDK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 25
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review