Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 28th September, 2020
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
Petitioners
:
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
versus
Respondents
:
The State of Sikkim and Others
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. K. K. Rai and Mr. B. Sharma, Senior Advocates with Mr. Norden
Tshering Bhutia, Advocate for the Petitioners.
Mr. Hissey Gyaltsen, Assistant Government Advocate for the StateRespondents No.1 and 2.
Mr. Anmole Prasad and Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocates with Mr. Jorgay
Namka, Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, Ms. Yangchen D. Gyatso and Mr. Sagar
Chettri, Advocates for the Respondent No.3.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The learned trial Court, by its Order dated 10.02.2020,
in Title Suit No.01 of 2017 (Karmapa Charitable Trust & Others vs.
State of Sikkim & Others), allowed the petition filed by the
Respondent No.3 under Order VIII Rule 1A(3) read with Section
151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, “CPC”), thereby
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
permitting the Respondent No.3 to file twelve additional documents
2020.09.28
MADAN RAI Date:
12:19:47 +05'30'
at the stage of the said Respondent‟s evidence, after closure of the
evidence of the Plaintiffs and the Respondents No.1 and 2.
Aggrieved by this Order, the Petitioners assail it before this Court
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
under
Article
of
the
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
Constitution
of
India
(for
short,
“Constitution”).
2.
Respondents No.1 and 2 had no counter-affidavit to
file. The counter-affidavit filed by the Respondent No.3 was met by
a rejoinder of the Petitioners.
3.(i)
Advancing his arguments for the Petitioner, learned
Senior Counsel canvassed the contention that Order VIII Rule 1A of
the CPC requires the Respondent to enter all documents that he
bases his defense upon in a list, and to produce it in Court along
with the written statement. If the documents that the Respondent
seeks to rely on are not in his power and possession, he is to
divulge as to who it is with at that time. However, the Respondent
No.3 opted to disregard this provision of law. The learned Trial
Court, for its part, while allowing the Respondent No.3 to file the
additional documents belatedly, it is alleged, failed to appreciate
that the discretion vested on it under the provisions of Order VIII
Rule A1(3) of the CPC cannot be exercised in a routine manner.
That, leave is to be granted only on due consideration of the bona
fides of the party, which is non-existent on the part of the
Respondent No.3. Calling the attention of this Court to the
provisions of Order XVI Rule 1 of the CPC, learned Senior Counsel
contended that the provision mandates that parties furnish in Court
a list of witnesses whom they propose to call, either to give
evidence or to produce documents. That, although the Respondent
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
2020.09.28 12:20:33
MADAN RAI Date:
+05'30'
No.3 had filed his list of witnesses way back on 21.08.2002, the
relevance of the witnesses now sought to be examined or the
documents sought to be produced were not brought to the notice of
either the learned Trial Court or the parties. It was his specific
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
argument that by allowing the petition under Order VIII Rule 1A(3)
of the CPC, the interest of the Petitioners herein are being
jeopardized as it is a belated and mala fide step taken by the
Respondent No.3, when the evidence of the Petitioners‟ witnesses
and that of the Respondents No.1 and 2 have already concluded.
Consequently, it tantamounts to a de novo trial where the
Petitioners will be deprived of the opportunity of refuting the
documents in question, which introduces at this stage an element
of surprise in the lis. That, in fact, one of the documents now being
relied upon by the Respondent No.3 bears the signature of
Shamarpa Rinpoche who has passed on 11.06.2014, thereby,
making it an impossibility for the Petitioners to test the authenticity
of his signature which would thereby prejudice their case. The
Respondent
No.3
through
the
additional
documents
is
now
attempting to legitimize the recognition of the Karmapa identified
by them and also to resurrect the issue of Tsurphu Labrang in an
effort to establish that there was a parallel administration being run
by the said entity, when the matter has already been closed by an
Order of the learned Trial Court and confirmed by a Judgment of
this Court.
(ii)
Training his arguments against the impugned Order,
learned Senior Counsel contended that the learned Trial Court
failed to appreciate that it was the Respondent No.3 who was
required to defend his case and his witnesses cannot introduce
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
2020.09.28
documents or facts which the Respondent No.3 himself is unaware
MADAN RAI Date:
12:21:12 +05'30'
of. That, despite the learned Trial Court having noticed that the
Respondent No.3 sought to introduce new documents without the
leave of the Court which was duly objected to by the Petitioners,
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
instead of rejecting the documents, the Court embarked on a
mission of advising the Respondent No.3 to file an appropriate
application to bring on record the new documents. That, some of
the documents sought to be introduced pertain to a period
subsequent to the cause of action and are irrelevant while some
documents, it is alleged, have been manufactured for the purposes
of this lis and yet others subsequently procured to assist the case
of the Respondent No.3, who, by surreptitiously introducing the
documents without following the relevant procedure prescribed by
law, seeks to cover up any lacunae which may have existed in their
case.
(iii)
It was next contended that the learned Trial Court in
the impugned Order, has wrongly relied on the ratio of Ashok
Sharma vs. Ram Adhar Sharma . The Respondent therein had sought
permission of the Court to summon a witness to prove the date of
construction of the society and on the direction of the Court the
witness had brought the documents. In the instant case, the
witnesses have brought the documents sans such directions. That,
the Respondent No.3 apart from acting mala fide failed to exercise
due diligence at the appropriate stage as provided by law indicating
his lackadaisical conduct, hence the impugned Order for all the
foregoing reasons deserves to be set aside. To augment his
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28 12:21:48 submissions, he relied on the following ratiocination;
MADAN RAI +05'30'
(a)
Ashok Sharma vs. Ram Adhar Sharma (supra)
(b)
Mange Ram vs. Brij Mohan & Ors.2
(c)
Scindia Potteries & Services P. Ltd. vs. J.K. Jain & Anr.3
1 (2009) 11 SCC 47
(1983) 4 SCC 36
2012 SCC Online Del 5296
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
(d)
Ram Sarup Gupta vs. Bishun Narain Inter College & Ors.4
(e)
Nepal Das & Anr. vs. Aditi Deori & Ors.5
(f)
Manguesh Rajaram Wagle vs. Suresh D. Naik6
(g)
Dugaputi Sudhakar Reddy vs. Avulapati Shankar Reddy & Ors.7
(h)
P. Sankaran vs. Dr. Ambujakshan Nair8
(i)
Ram Bihari Yadav vs. State Of Bihar9
(j)
The State of U.P vs. Raj Narain & Ors.10
4.(i)
Resisting the arguments forwarded by learned Senior
Counsel for the Petitioners, learned Senior Counsel for the
Respondent No.3 vehemently contended that the question of
resurrecting the Tsurphu Labrang matter does not arise as in the
first instance it was never closed. The attention of this Court was
drawn to the proceedings before the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Special
Leave
to
Appeal
(Civil)
No.22903
of
2003,
dated
05.07.2004, from the Judgment and Order dated 26.08.2003 in WP
5/03 of this High Court being Tsurphu Labrang vs. Karmapa
Charitable Trust and Others. It was pointed out that although the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that there was no reason to
interfere with the Judgment of this High Court (supra) and
dismissed the Special Leave Petition, it was clarified unequivocally
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28
MADAN RAI 12:22:25 +05'30'
in the same Order that “…the trial court will not take into consideration
any observations made in the impugned order or in the order of the
District Judge dismissing the application.” Learned Senior Counsel
sought to elucidate that the learned Trial Court had at the relevant
time, rejected the application for impleadment of the Tsurphu
(1987) 2 SCC 555
(2011) 5 Gauhati Law Reports 23
2016 SCC Online Bom. 7854
2005(1) A.P.L.J. 245 (HC)
1989 SCC Online Ker. 237
(1998) 4 SCC 517
(1975) 4 SCC 428
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
Labrang as a party in the Title Suit inter alia on grounds that the
Suit was filed by the majority of the Trustees and they sufficiently
represented the case of the Tsurphu Labrang, who had in any
event, failed to show how its interest was involved. The Hon‟ble
High Court while considering the impugned Order of the learned
Trial Court under an application filed by the Tsurphu Labrang under
Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, read with Section 115 of
the CPC, inter alia reiterated that the Tsurphu Labrang had not
been able to indicate how its interest was involved in the Suit. Also,
that the findings of the learned Trial Court were pure findings of
fact which could not be upset by the High Court in its jurisdiction
under Article 227 of the Constitution and thereby dismissed the
petition. That, it is in this context that the Order of the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court (supra) came to be pronounced and should not be
misinterpreted by the Petitioners. That, the rejoinder of the
Petitioners herein seeks to make out that the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in its Order was referring to the „conduct‟ of the Tsurphu
Labrang, but a reading of the said Order reflects that there is
indeed no mention of the „conduct‟ of the Tsurphu Labrang nor was
such an observation made. Hence, the submission of the learned
Senior Counsel for the Petitioners that the matter of Tsurphu
Labrang has been closed is an erroneous submission before this
Court.
(ii)
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28
MADAN RAI 12:22:58 +05'30'
That, the reliance of the Petitioners on the ratio of
Ashok Sharma (supra) before this Court is misplaced as the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court had upheld the order of the Hon‟ble High Court of
Delhi, which while discussing the provisions of Order XVI Rule 1
and Rule 1A of the CPC had set aside the order of the learned Trial
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
Court which had disallowed the witness to furnish additional
documents after closure of Plaintiff‟s evidence and allowed the
documents to be taken on record. That, the allegation of the
Petitioners
herein
that
the
documents
are
manufactured
subsequently is devoid of any proof whatsoever. Merely because
the documents have been allowed by the learned Trial Court after
closure of the evidence of the Petitioners and the Respondents No.1
and 2, does not prejudice the Petitioners‟ case as law affords them
with ample opportunity to controvert the documents at the stage of
cross-examination. The Petitioners by impugning the Order of the
learned Trial Court seek to block relevant and genuine documents
of the Respondent No.3 in order to jeopardize his interests.
(iii)
Learned Senior Counsel put forth the clarification that
the documents were produced by the witnesses voluntarily during
the preparation of their Evidence-on-Affidavit and the Respondent
No.3 was unaware of the existence of such documents, while some
of the documents came into existence post the filing of the Suit.
Besides,
nothing in
law
prohibits a
party
from
introducing
documents in a Suit even if it pertains to the period subsequent to
the cause of action nor are the witnesses to be limited to depose
only on the facts that the party calling them are aware of. The
Petitioners, in fact, received copies of the additional documents as
soon as it was filed by the Respondent No.3 and therefore had
sufficient time to examine the same but raised no objections then
MEENAKSHI
MADAN RAI
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28
12:23:34 +05'30'
and are raising such objections now, rather belatedly. That, the
Petitioners‟ argument that the documents are irrelevant have, in
fact, been met with the reasons and relevance of each of the
documents of the Respondent No.3, in his application under Order
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
VIII Rule 1A(3) read with Section 151 of the CPC. Learned Senior
Counsel walked this Court through the contents of the said petition
filed before the learned Trial Court. That, the learned Trial Court,
by the impugned Order, has given adequate reasons for allowing
the petition of the Respondent No.3 and has observed that though
the Petitioners assail the concerned documents on grounds of its
admissibility, this would not be the appropriate stage for examining
this aspect. That, in view of the reasons posited regarding the
relevance of the twelve documents and the reasoned finding of the
learned Trial Court in the impugned Order, this petition deserves a
dismissal.
Learned Senior Counsel for the
Respondent
No.3
garnered support for his submissions from the following decisions:
5.
(a)
Ashok Sharma vs. Ram Adhar Sharma (supra);
(b)
Mange Ram vs. Brij Mohan (supra);
(c)
Santveer Singh vs. Addl. Civil Judge, Hanumangarh11;
(d)
M/s Sadhu Forging Limited vs. M/s Continental Engines12;
(e)
Bhanumathi vs. Sarvothaman13;
(f)
Rajah R.V.G.K. Ranga Rao vs. Nizams Sugars Limited14; and
(g)
Manguesh Rajaram Wagle vs. Suresh D. Naik15
Learned Assistant Government Advocate for the State-
Respondents No.1 and 2 had no submissions to make.
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28 12:24:08
MADAN RAI +05'30'
6.
Due consideration has been given by me to the rival
contentions advanced by learned Senior Counsel for the parties. I
have also carefully perused all documents placed before me
including the impugned Order and the citations made at the Bar.
2004 SCC OnLine Raj 59
2017 SCC Online Del 10039
2010 SCC OnLine Ker 373
2003 SCC OnLine AP 979
2016 SccOnLine Bom 7854
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
7.
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
While considering the matter, it would be worthwhile to
discuss the ratiocination relied on by learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioners. In Ram Sarup Gupta (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court
had held that all necessary and material facts should be pleaded by
the party in support of the case set up by it. In the absence of
pleadings, evidence if any, produced by the parties cannot be
considered. Having considered this ratio, it is necessary to remark
here that learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners failed to specify
to this Court as to which specific deficit emanated in the pleadings
of the Respondent No.3 over and above which he sought to produce
evidence. Hence, this Judgment is of no assistance to the
Petitioners‟ case. In the case of Nepal Das & Anr. (supra), the Hon‟ble
High Court of Gauhati upheld the Order of the learned Trial Court
rejecting the prayer of the Defendants to produce additional
documents. While discussing Order VIII Rule 1A of the CPC it was
inter alia held that leave has to be granted bearing in mind certain
conditions precedent and that the reasons for granting leave may
vary from case to case. The Hon‟ble High Court also found that
there was complete absence of any discernible explanation from the
materials on record, as to why the Defendants had not filed a list of
documents enlisting therein any of the documents, which they
sought
to
rely
upon
and
thereby
concluded
that
in
the
circumstances aforementioned, the learned Trial Court‟s decision not
to allow the Defendants to produce the documents was wholly
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28
justified and in accord with law. In my considered opinion, the ratio
MADAN RAI 12:24:43 +05'30'
(supra) would not assist the case of the Petitioners herein as
contrary to the findings therein, the Respondent No.3 in his petition
under Order VIII Rule 1A(3) read with Section 151 of the CPC has
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
furnished sufficient grounds to explain the delay in the filing of the
documents, the reasons as to why they could not be filed earlier as
also their relevance. The learned Trial Court as evident from the
impugned Order was satisfied by the grounds furnished by the
Respondent No.3. The Petitioners have also placed reliance on
Dugaputi Sudhakar Reddy (supra), wherein while discussing the
provisions of Order VIII Rule 1A(3) of the CPC, the Hon‟ble High
Court of Andhra Pradesh held that by this provision, the Defendant
is permitted to produce such documents with the leave of the Court
and the same may be received in evidence subject to the
satisfaction of the Court, which shall be granted based on reasons
found to be justifiable, believable and capable of rendering justice
by deciding all issues. The discretion thus vests on the Court to
consider whether the grounds put forth are satisfactory. In Mange
Ram (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court while discussing the
provisions of Order XVI Rule 1 and Rule 1A of the CPC inter alia held
that;
“9. …Marginal note of Rule 1-A reads as
„Production of witnesses without summons‟ and the
rule proceeds to enable a party to bring any witness
to give evidence or to produce documents without
applying
for
summons
under
Rule
1.
………………………..…………………………………….………………….
Rule 1-A of Order 16 clearly brings to surface the two
situations in which the two rules operate. Where the
party wants the assistance of the court to procure
presence of a witness on being summoned through
the court, it is obligatory on the party to file the list
with the gist of evidence of witness in the court as
directed by sub-rule (1) of Rule 1 and make an
application as provided by sub-rule (2) of Rule 1. But
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28 12:25:21
MADAN RAI +05'30'
where the party would be in a position to produce its
witnesses without the assistance of the court, it can
do so under Rule 1-A of Order 16 irrespective of the
fact whether the name of such witness is mentioned
in the list or not.”
(Emphasis supplied)
We may extract the relevant provisions of Order XVI Rule 1 and
Rule 1A of the CPC hereinbelow for easy reference;
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
“Order XVI
Summoning and Attendance of Witnesses
1.
List
of
witnesses
and
summons
to
witnesses.—(1) On or before such date as the Court
may appoint, and not later than fifteen days after the
date on which the issues are settled, the parties shall
present in Court a list of witnesses whom they
propose to call either to give evidence or to produce
documents and obtain summonses to such persons
for their attendance in Court.
(2) A party desirous of obtaining any summons
for the attendance of any person shall file in Court an
application stating therein the purpose for which the
witness is proposed to be summoned.
(3) The Court may, for reasons to be recorded,
permit a party to call, whether by summoning through
Court or otherwise, any witness, other than those
whose names appear in the list referred to in sub-rule
(1), if such party shows sufficient cause for the
omission to mention the name of such witness in the
said list.
(4) Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (2),
summonses referred to in this rule may be obtained
by the parties on an application to the Court or to
such officer as may be appointed by the Court in this
behalf [within five days of presenting the list of
witnesses under sub-rule (1).
1-A.
Production
of
witnesses
without
summons.—Subject to the provisions of sub-rule (3)
of Rule 1, any party to the suit may, without applying
for summons under Rule 1, bring any witness to give
evidence or to produce documents.”
Reverting back to the decision in Mange Ram supra, in light of the
elucidation of the scheme and purpose of Order XVI Rule 1A of the
CPC by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court, it is clear that the ratio holds no
succour for the Petitioners‟ case.
8.
In Scindia Potteries & Services P. Ltd. (supra), the Hon‟ble
High Court of Delhi while considering the provisions of Order VIII
Rule 1A(3) of the CPC, concluded that the Defendant No.1 had failed
to show sufficient cause for belated production of the said
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28
MADAN RAI 12:25:57 +05'30'
documents and no satisfactory reason was offered as to why he
should be granted liberty to place them on record now, besides
demonstrating a complete lack of diligence in seeking permission to
produce the documents in question. That, it could not be stated that
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
he was earlier unaware of the existence of the said documents. This
Judgment, to my mind, clearly does not aid the case of the
Petitioners
herein
being
distinguishable
from
the
facts
and
circumstances put forth by the Respondent No.3 with regard to the
documents sought to be exhibited through his witnesses. The
documents, it is clarified by Respondent No.3, were neither in his
power or possession nor was he aware of their existence to enable
him to produce the documents earlier. On pain of repetition, it may
be stated here that the Respondent No.3 has laboured to explain
that the documents were produced by the witnesses themselves
when their Evidence-on-Affidavit was being prepared, therefore lack
of diligence or lack of promptitude cannot be attributed to the
Respondent No.3 unlike the conduct of the Defendant No.1 in
Scindia Potteries & Services P. Ltd. (supra) as evident from the
observations made therein.
9.
In Manguesh Rajaram Wagle (supra), the Hon‟ble High
Court of Bombay at Goa, while discussing the provisions of Order
XIV Rule 3 and Order VII Rule 14 of the CPC held that the impugned
Order passed by the learned Trial Court would show that it had
considered the case of the Plaintiffs seeking to produce two Files
and had concluded that the Plaintiffs had not stated the relevance of
each of the documents contained in the File. The Hon‟ble High Court
upheld the findings of the learned Trial Court. In this context, I have
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28 12:26:34
MADAN RAI +05'30'
to observe that in the matter at hand, the Respondent No.3 has
cited the relevance of each document in his petition before the
learned Trial Court which was reiterated by learned Senior Counsel
before this Court.
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
10.
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
Reliance was placed on P. Sankaran (supra), this ratio
deals with the provisions of Section 136 of the Indian Evidence Act,
1872 (for short, “Evidence Act”) which lays down that the Judge is
to decide the admissibility of the evidence. It was observed therein
inter alia that when the accused wanted to cite the Counsel
representing the complainant as a witness, the learned Magistrate
should have asked in what manner the evidence would be relevant
for the disposal of the case. The Magistrate should have issued
summons only if he thought that the evidence would be relevant for
the decision. Such a duty is cast on him under Section 136 of the
Evidence Act. By citing this decision, the learned Senior Counsel for
the Petitioners sought to impress upon this Court that it was the
duty of the learned Trial Court to have considered the relevance of
the twelve additional documents before allowing the petition under
Order VIII Rule 1A(3) of the CPC. The learned Trial, in the impugned
Order has mentioned that the question of admissibility of the
documents had not arisen as yet and that the Court had only
considered the grounds pertaining to relevance of the documents.
In Ram Bihari Yadav (supra) relied on by the Petitioners deals with
Sections 3 and 5 of the Indian Evidence Act and it was observed
therein that more often than not the expressions “relevancy” and
“admissibility” are used as synonyms but their legal implications are
distinct and different for more often than not facts which are
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI relevant
2020.09.28
MADAN RAI Date:
12:27:16 +05'30'
may not be admissible, for example, a communication
made by spouses during marriage or between an Advocate and his
client though relevant are not admissible. The Judgment thus makes
a clear distinction between the „relevance‟ of a document and its
„admissibility,‟ setting at rest the perplexity of the Petitioners on this
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
count. Similarly, in State of U.P. vs. Raj Narain and Others (supra) the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court has held that „admissibility‟ presupposes
„relevancy.‟ Pausing here for a minute, it is worth noticing that this
observation
does
not
state
that
„relevancy‟
presupposes
„admissibility‟ as well. In the instant case, the question of
admissibility, as earlier noted, has not arisen as yet as spelt out in
the impugned Order of the learned Trial Court. Hence, the ratio
supra too provides no support to the Petitioners‟ case. In any event,
it may relevantly be remarked herein that a distinction has to be
made by the parties and the learned Courts with regard to
admissibility, relevance and probative value of the documents.
11.
In Ashok Sharma (supra) relied on by both parties, the
learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners sought to emphasize that
the learned Trial Court in the impugned Order failed to appreciate
that the Hon‟ble High Court of Delhi after examining the provisions
of Order XVI Rule 1 and Rule 1A of the CPC, had directed the
documents to be produced and taken on record thereby reversing
the Order of the learned Trial Court which had refused to take the
documents on record. In the instant matter, however, the act of the
witnesses of the Respondent No.3 were voluntary and without any
directions from any Court and therefore could not be taken on
record. On this count, learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent
No.3 had contrarily argued that the reliance by the Petitioners on
this ratio was misplaced. Having perused the
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28 12:27:58
MADAN RAI +05'30'
said Judgment, I am
inclined to agree with the submissions of learned Senior Counsel for
the Respondent No.3 as the Hon‟ble Supreme Court inter alia
observed as follows;
“15. As noted hereinearlier, Order 16 Rule 1 and
Rule 1-A of the Code, if read together, would clearly
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
indicate that it is open to a party to summon a
witness to the court or even may, without applying for
summons, bring a witness to give evidence or to
produce documents. Since Rule 1-A is subject to the
provisions of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1, all that can be
contended is that before proceeding to examine any
witness, who might have been brought by a party for
the purpose, the leave of the court may be necessary.
This by itself would not mean that Rule 1-A was in
derogation of sub-rule (3) of Rule 1. Such document
brought by the said witness can be taken on record
and it is not necessary that the plaintiff must have
filed on record the copies of the said document
earlier.”
The Hon‟ble Supreme Court further went on to discuss the
provisions of law as expostulated in Mange Ram (supra) and
Vidhyadhar (supra) and held that;
“17. While considering the scope of Order 16
Rule 1 and Rule 1-A of the Code, this Court in Mange
Ram v. Brij Mohan [(1983) 4 SCC 36] held that the
court cannot decline to examine the witnesses
produced by the plaintiff nor could the court refuse to
take the documents on record through the witnesses.
…………………………………………………………………………………….…
18. Again in Vidhyadhar v. Manikrao [(1999) 3
SCC 573] this Court following the decision of Mange
Ram v. Brij Mohan [(1983) 4 SCC 36] has also held
that Order 16 Rule 1 and Rule 1-A of the Code
permits the court to pass the order directing the
witnesses to take the documents on record. Only
while dealing with the application for production of
documents under Order 16 Rule 1 read with Rule 1-A
of the Code, what is required was that leave of the
court would be necessary.
..............”
(Emphasis supplied)
Now therefore, in view of the clear exposition of law as obtains in
Order XVI Rule 1 and Rule 1A of the CPC by the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court, it is not necessary for this Court to enter into a prolix
discussion on this legal provision. Suffice it to note that the party
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28 12:28:41 who seeks to examine any other witness sans appearance of their
MADAN RAI +05'30'
names in the list furnished before the Court, is required to show
sufficient cause for the omission and such Court, for reasons to be
recorded, can exercise its discretion and permit the party to call
such witness either by summons or otherwise for the purposes of
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
giving evidence and for production of documents. Concomitant to
this provision are the provisions of Order XVIII Rule 4 of the CPC
which provides as follows;
“4. Recording of evidence.(1) In every case, the
examination-in-chief of a witness shall be on affidavit
and copies thereof shall be supplied to the opposite
party by the party who calls him for evidence;
“…Provided that where documents are filed and
the parties rely upon the documents, the proof and
admissibility of such documents which are filed along
with affidavit shall be subject to the orders of the
Court.
…”
(Emphasis supplied)
On the same lines due consideration is also to be taken of the
provisions of Order XIII Rule 2(3) of the CPC which lays down as
follows;
“3. Rejection of irrelevant or inadmissible
documents.- The Court may at any stage of the suit
reject any document which it considers irrelevant or
otherwise inadmissible, recording the grounds of such
rejection.”
This provision empowers the Court to reject a document at any
stage of the Suit if it is found either to be irrelevant or otherwise
inadmissible. The Court can thus take necessary steps even if no
objection is raised by any party with regard to any document,
should the Court be of the opinion that the document would be of
no assistance in the final and complete adjudication of the issues in
lis.
12.
MEENAKSHI
MADAN RAI
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28 12:29:21
+05'30'
That having been said, we may now refer to and
consider the provisions of Order VIII Rule 1A of the CPC which was
inserted by the amendment of 2002 and came into effect from
01.07.2002. This provides as follows;
“1-A. Duty of defendant to produce documents
upon which relief is claimed or relied upon by him.(1) Where the defendant bases his defense upon a
document or relies upon any document in his
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
possession or power, in support of his evidence or
claim for set-off or counter-claim, he shall enter such
document in a list, and shall produce it in Court when
the written statement is presented by him and shall,
at the same time, deliver the document and a copy
thereof, to be filed with the written statement.
(2) Where any such document is not in the
possession or power of the defendant, he shall,
wherever possible, state in whose possession or
power it is.
(3) A document which ought to be produced in
Court by the defendant under this rule, but, is not so
produced shall not, without the leave of the Court,
be received in evidence on his behalf at the hearing
of the suit.
………..”
(Emphasis supplied)
The emphasis in Rule 1A(1) supra is on the words “possession or
power.” Hence, the provision unambiguously
casts a duty on the
Defendant to produce documents upon which either the relief is
claimed by him or on which he relies upon, when such a document
or
documents
are
in
his
possession
or
power.
Should
the
document(s) not be in his possession or power then the Defendant
shall inform the Court as to in whose power or possession the
document is in. Rule 1A(3) of the CPC requires that when such
document(s) which ought to have been produced by the Defendant
but have not been so produced, cannot be received in evidence on
his behalf without the leave of the Court. It thereby concludes that
should the Defendant fail to file a document in terms of the
provisions of Order VIII Rule 1 of the CPC, he may do so under the
provisions of Order VIII Rule 1A (3) of the CPC, subject to the leave
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI of
Date: 2020.09.28 12:29:58
MADAN RAI +05'30'
the Court. The Court, under this provision, is to exercise its
powers judiciously at the same time considering the bona fides of
the party, the reasons put forth by the party and the relevance of
the document as well as reasons for its non-filing earlier. Should the
Court be satisfied with the grounds furnished by the concerned
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
party then and only then shall it grant leave to the party making the
prayer to file the documents.
13.
The learned Trial Court in the impugned Order while
exercising its discretion under Order VIII Rule 1A (3) of the CPC
allowed the application of the Respondent No.3 on due consideration
of the grounds put forth by the Respondent No.3, which for brevity
are not being reiterated here. The Respondent No.3 has clarified
that he had no inkling as to the existence of these documents for
the reasons already given in his petition filed before the learned
Trial Court. In my considered opinion, this shows the bona fides of
the Respondent No.3.
14.
The Petitioners harbor apprehensions on the count that
as Shamarpa Rinpoche has since passed, the authenticity of his
signature cannot be tested. This is an uncalled for apprehension as
the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 makes adequate provision for such
contingencies. The argument that the case of the Petitioners is
jeopardized by the belated and mala fide steps of the Respondent
No.3 cannot be countenanced as the Petitioners will be afforded
sufficient opportunity to controvert and refute the documents during
cross-examination besides the steps taken by the Respondent No.3
cannot be stated to be mala fide.
15.
MEENAKSHI
MADAN RAI
MADAN RAI
Date: 2020.09.28 12:30:41 +05'30'
The argument advanced by learned Senior Counsel for
the Petitioners pertaining to the efforts of the Respondent No.3 at
resurrecting the Tsurphu Labrang is not being ventured into, in any
event, parties would do well to carefully peruse and consider the
Orders of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Tsurphu Labrang vs. Karmapa
Charitable Trust and Others (supra), to which the attention of this
WP(C) No.12 of 2020
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
Court was invited by learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent
No.3 earlier on.
16.
In conclusion, it is apposite to observe that no fixed
formula can be provided for leave to be granted by the Court under
Order VIII Rule 1A(3) of the CPC. The learned Trial Court herein
deemed it appropriate to grant leave in the facts and circumstances
as obtained in the matter on due consideration of the grounds put
forth
by
the
Respondent
No.3.
I
have
also
given
careful
consideration to the grounds for the belated filing of the documents
by the Respondent No.3 and the reasons enumerated by learned
Senior Counsel for the said Respondent and I am satisfied with the
grounds thus put forward.
17.
While
considering
the
entire
gamut
of
facts
and
circumstances placed before this Court, the relevant provisions of
law, the ratio relied on by the parties and the reasons given by the
Respondent No.3 and by the learned Trial Court in its Order, no
interference is warranted in the impugned Order.
18.
The petition being devoid of merit deserves to be and is
accordingly dismissed and disposed of. Pending applications, if any,
also stand disposed of.
19.
No order as to costs.
20.
Copy of this Judgment be forwarded to the learned Trial
Court for information.
signed by
MEENAKSHI Digitally
MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI
2020.09.28
MADAN RAI Date:
12:31:44 +05'30'
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
28.09.2020
ml/ds
Approved for reporting : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review