Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR
ALI
Digitally signed
by SYED
ROSHAN ZAMIR
ALI
Date: 2026.09.24
19:47:04 +0530
2026:CGHC:41477-DB
CGHC010444672024
Order reserved on 30.06.2026
Order delivered on 24/09/2026
Order uploaded on 24/09/2026
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
TAXC No. 15 of 2025
1. The Joint Commissioner of Income Tax Range-1, Bilaspur
C.G.
... Appellant
versus
1. M/s Jindal Power Limited Kharsia Road, Raigarh C.G. PanAABCJ4683J
... Respondent
For Appellant
:
Mr. Ajay Kumarani, Advocate
For Respondent
:
Mr. Salil Kapoor, Advocate with Ms. Katyayani
Vishnupriya, Advocate
DB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Parth Prateem Sahu,J
& Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sachin Singh Rajput, J
CAV Order
Per Parth Prateem Sahu, J
1. Appellant-revenue has filed this appeal under Section 260A of
the Income Tax Act, 1961 against the order dated 25.6.2024
passed in ITA No.200/RPF/2017 by which learned Income Tax
Appellate Tribunal, Raipur Bench, Raipur (henceforth ‘the
Tribunal’) has allowed the appeal of the respondent assessee
and quashed the reassessment order dated 13.2.2015.
2. Facts of the case, in brief, are that respondent filed e-return of
income for the assessment year 2009-10 declaring income of
Rs.95,29,85,465/-. The Assessing Officer (AO) had selected
the case of respondent for scrutiny. A notice under Section
143 (2) of the Act of 1961 was issued to respondent, to which
reply was submitted. Thereafter, the Assessing Officer passed
an order on 28.12.2011, assessing the income chargeable to
tax for the assessment year 2009-2010. Subsequently, the
Assessing
Officer
(AO)
noticed
that
deduction
and
disallowance under certain heads were wrongly allowed to the
assessee and therefore, taking aid of Section 147 of the Act
of 1961, reopened the assessment for the year 2009-10 after
obtaining sanction under Section 151 (1) of the Act of 1961.
Thereafter, following due process of law, vide order dated
13.2.2015, the AO enhanced the taxable income of
respondent from Rs.9655.13 Lakhs to Rs.23890.05 Lakhs
with book profit of Rs.193131.85 Lakhs.
3. The assessee thereupon preferred an appeal before the CIT
(Appeals) against the order dated 13.2.2015. The CIT
(Appeals) dismissed the appeal and sustained the order
passed by the AO. The assessee then approached the
Tribunal.
The Tribunal after considering the relevant
provisions of the Act of 1961, the principles laid down by
Hon’ble Supreme Court and the High Courts in various
decisions, has arrived at a conclusion that reopening of the
concluded assessment of the assessee was based on mere
change of opinion on the same set of facts of the successor
AO and accordingly, by the order impugned allowed the
appeal of assessee and quashed the reassessment order of
the Assessment Officer for want of valid assumption of
jurisdiction under Section 147 of the Act of 1961. Hence, this
tax appeal has been preferred by the department.
4. Learned counsel for appellant-revenue vehemently argued
that the Tribunal erred in quashing the reassessment order
passed by the AO under Section 147 of the Act of 1961 by
holding it to be based on mere change of opinion and not on
any fresh tangible material, without appreciating the fact that
any inadvertent omission of addition or disallowance of
deduction of income chargeable to tax discovered later on
can constitute a reason to believe that the income chargeable
to tax had escaped assessment.
5. He further submits that the information forming basis for
reopening an assessment need not necessarily be derived
from any external or extraneous source. Such information
may be gathered from the record of the original assessment
itself. Mere fact that the Assessing Officer derives the
requisite information upon a careful and close examination of
the original assessment, record does not by itself, amount to
a mere change of opinion. If any item has escaped from
assessment which was otherwise includible within the
assessment and the Assessing Officer notices it subsequently
by his own investigation or by reason of some information
received by him, cannot be termed as ‘mere change of
opinion’.
Respondent
assessee
had
claimed
100%
depreciation on the DAM, without there being any provision in
the depreciation rate schedule provided under the Act of
1961,
which
resulted
in
allowance
of
inadmissible
depreciation in the sum of Rs.8,50,32,403/-. Further, the then
AO has left the computation of depreciation to be decided on
the basis of sub-section (2) of Section 115JB of the Act of
1961, which means that the AO did not compute total income
to the extent by which Section 115JB could have become
redundant. Even in the reply filed by respondent assessee
the issue of 100% depreciation on dam has not been
explained.
On account of such failure on the part of
respondent to disclose fully and truly all material facts, income
chargeable to tax has escaped assessment within the
meaning of Section 147 of the Act of 1961. Hence, action of
respondent assessee in claiming depreciation, which is
otherwise not allowable, amounts to failure on the part of the
assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts
necessary for the purpose of assessment.
6. In view of the facts as narrated above, present cannot be said
to be a case of ‘mere change of opinion’ because there was
no opinion formed in the first instance, rather it is the case of
satisfaction of income escaping assessment. In support of his
contention, he placed reliance on the decision in case of
Phool Chand Bajrang Lal & another vs ITO, reported in (1993)
203 ITR 456 (SC).
7. Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
respondent assessee opposed the submissions made on
behalf of the appellant-Department and supported the order
passed by the Tribunal. He contended that at the time of
original assessment, respondent assessee had disclosed all
material facts regarding claim for depreciation on DAM,
additional depreciation under Section 32 (ii)(a) of the Act of
1961, disallowance under Section 14A of the Act of 1961,
earned interest and other income during pre-production
period.
In
the
reasons
recorded
for
reopening
the
assessment, which is reproduced in the order of the Tribunal,
nowhere it is mentioned that there is any failure on the part of
the respondent-assessee to disclose fully and truly all
material facts relevant for the purpose of assessment, which
is sine qua non for exercise of power under Section 147 of
the Act of 1961. It is further submitted that in the course of
original assessment proceedings, respondent assessee was
called upon to furnish evidence in support of claim of 100%
depreciation on DAM, who, in turn, furnished the details of
additions of fixed assets on which 100% depreciation was
claimed and only thereafter claim regarding depreciation @
100% was allowed in original assessment proceeding. The
then AO also queried regarding additional depreciation
Section 32 (ii) (a) of the Act of 1961; disallowance made
under Section 14A of the Act of 1961 as also regarding
earned interest and other income, to which reply was duly
submitted by respondent assessee. Thus, it is apparent that
the grounds/reasons on which assessment in question was
sought to be reopened, were infact gone into detail by the
then Assessing Officer while framing the scrutiny under
Section 143 (3) of the Act of 1961 and in course of scrutiny,
the queries were raised with respect to 100% depreciation on
DAM, additional depreciation under Section 32 (ii) (a) of the
Act of 1961, disallowance under Section 14A of the Act of
1961 and income during pre-production period and in
response, all the relevant materials were supplied/furnished
by the respondent and only thereafter the AO framed the
assessment.
8. He further submitted that it is not the case of appellantDepartment that on the basis of any new material/information
collected subsequently, the Assessing Officer has formed an
opinion
that income chargeable to tax has escaped
assessment. In these circumstances, order passed by the
learned Tribunal holding that reopening of assessment for the
year 2009-10, is based on a mere change of opinion by the
subsequent Assessing Officer on the same set of facts as
were before his predecessor in the course of original
assessment does not call for interference.
9.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents available in record of tax appeal.
10. The respondent assessee is doing business of mining and
generation of power. They filed e-return for the assessment
year 2009-10. Case of respondent was selected for scrutiny
and notice under Section 143 (2) of the Act of 1961 was
issued. Respondent assessee participated in the enquiry and
submitted the details called for. On providing necessary
details,
clarification
and
information
to
the AO,
the
assessment order under Section 143 (1) of the Act of 1961
was
passed
on
28.12.2011
on
a
total
income
of
Rs.19,19,78,85,663/-, after making various disallowances.
Respondent challenged the assessment order by filing an
appeal before the CIT (Appeals), who vide order dated
31.3.2014 partly allowed the appeal and determined total
income of assessee at Rs.96,55,13,861/-. Subsequently, on
05.07.2013 a notice under Section 148 of the Act of 1961 was
issued by the AO to respondent assesee through registered
post directing to file its return of income in the prescribed form
for the said assessment year 2009-10 stating that he had
reasons to believe that the respondent’s income chargeable
to tax for the assessment year 2009-10 had escaped
assessment and that he proposed to reassess the income.
Respondent submitted reply requesting to treat the return
filed under Section 139 (1) of the Act of 1961 on 30.9.2009 as
return filed in compliance to the notice under Section 148 of
the Act of 196 and further requested to supply a copy of the
reasons recorded under Section 148 (2) of the Act of 1961 for
reopening the assessment. On completion of reassessment
proceeding, the AO passed the reassessment order on
13.02.2015 under Section 143 (3) read with Section 147 of
the Act of 1961, assessed total taxable income of respondent
assessee at Rs.238,90,05,000/- and raised a demand of
Rs.1,93,13,18,000/-. Thereafter, respondent filed an appeal
before the Tribunal, which came to be allowed vide order
impugned on the ground that reopening of assessment is
based on mere ‘change of opinion’ and not on any fresh
tangible material.
11. Before we proceed further, let us have a look at the Section
147 of the Act of 1971 which deals with reopening of the
assessment. Relevant portion of Section 147 of the Act of
1961 is extracted herein below for ready reference :"147. Income escaping assessment.-If the AO has
reason to believe that any income chargeable to tax
has escaped assessment for any assessment
year,he may, subject to the provisions of ss. 148 to
153,assess or reassess such income and also any
other income chargeable to tax which has escaped
assessment and which comes to his notice
subsequently in the course of the proceedings under
this section, or recompute the loss or the
depreciation allowance or any other allowance, as
the case may be, for the assessment year concerned
(hereinafter in this section and in ss. 148 to 153
referred to as the relevant assessment year):
Provided that where an assessment under subs. (3) of s. 143 or this section has been made for the
relevant assessment year, no action shall be taken
under this section after the expiry of four years from
the end of the relevant assessment year, unless any
income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment
for such assessment year by reason of the failure on
the part of the assessee to make a return under
s.139 or in response to a notice issued under sub-s.
(1) of s. 142 or s. 148 or to disclose fully and truly all
material facts necessary for his assessment, for that
assessment year.
Explanation 1- Production before the AO of account
books or other evidence from which material
evidence could with due diligence have been
discovered by the AO will not necessarily amount to
disclosure within the meaning of the foregoing
proviso".
12. Reading of Section 147 of the Act of 1961 makes it clear that
if the assessing officer has reason to believe that any income
chargeable to tax has escaped assessment for any
assessment year, he may subject to the provisions of Section
148 to 153, assess or reassess such income and also any
other income chargeable to tax which has escaped
assessment and which comes to his notice subsequently in
the course of the proceedings under Section 147 or
recomputed the loss or the depreciation allowance or any
other allowance, as the case may be, for the assessment
year concerned. Proviso to Section 147 lays down that where
an assessment under Section 143 (3) or 147 has been made
for the relevant assessment year, no action can be taken
under Section 147 after expiry of four years from the end of
relevant assessment year unless any income chargeable to
tax has escaped assessment for such assessment year by
reason of the failure on the part of the assessee to make a
return under Section 139 or in response to a notice issued
under Section 142 (1) or Section 148 or to disclose fully and
truly all material facts necessary for his assessment, for that
assessment
year.
In
substance,
aforementioned
two
conditions have to be satisfied before an Income Tax Officer
reopens an assessment and both these conditions must coexist to confer jurisdiction on the Income Tax Officer.
13. Here, it will be useful to understand the meaning and scope of
the phrase "reason to believe" used in Section 147 of the Act
of 1961. In case of The Income Tax Officer, I Ward, District
VI, Calcutta and others vs. Lakhmani Mewal Das, reported
in (1976) 3 SCC 757 Hon’ble Supreme Court had occasion to
examine and explain the scope of phrase ‘reason to believe’
in the context of reopening of assessment on the ground that
income had escaped assessment and it was held thus:“11. As stated earlier, the reasons for the formation of
the belief must have a rational connection with or
relevant bearing on the formation of the belief. Rational
connection postulates that there must be a direct
nexus or live link between the material coming to the
notice of the Income Tax Officer and the formation of
his belief that there has been escapement of the
income of the assessee from assessment in the
particular year because of his failure to disclose fully
and truly all material facts. It is no doubt true that the
court cannot go into the sufficiency or adequacy of the
material and substitute its own opinion for that of the
Income Tax Officer on the point as to whether action
should be initiated for reopening assessment. At the
same time we have to bear in mind that it is not any
and every material, howsoever vague and indefinite or
distant, remote and farfetched, which would warrant
the formation of the belief relating to escapement of
the income of the assessee from assessment. …….
The reason for the formation of the belief must be held
in good faith and should not be a mere pretence.
12. The powers of the Income Tax Officer to reopen
assessment though wide are not plenary. The words of
the statute are “reason to believe” and not “reason to
suspect” The reopening of the assessment after the
lapse of many years is a serious matter. The Act, no
doubt, contemplates the reopening of the assessment
if grounds exist for believing that income of the
assessee has escaped assessment. The underlying
reason for that is that instances of concealed income
or other income escaping assessment in a large
number of cases come to the notice of the Income Tax
Authorities after the assessment has been completed.
The provisions of the Act in this respect depart from
the normal rule that there should be, subject to right of
appeal and revision, finality about orders made in
judicial and quasi-judicial proceedings. It is, therefore,
essential that before such action is taken the
requirements of the law should be satisfied. The live
link or close nexus which should be there between the
material before the Income Tax Officer in the present
case and the belief which he was to form regarding the
escapement of the income of the assessee from
assessment because of the latter's failure or omission
to disclose fully and truly all material facts was missing
in the case. ……………...”
14. In case of Phool Chand Bajrang Lal and another V. Income
Tax Officer and another, reported in (1993) 4 SCC 77
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:“25. ……. It would be immaterial whether the Income
Tax Officer at the time of making the original
assessment could or, could not have found by further
enquiry or investigation, whether the transaction was
genuine or not, if on the basis of subsequent
information, the Income Tax Officer arrives at a
conclusion,
after
satisfying
the
twin
conditions
prescribed in Section 147(a) of the Act, that the
assessee had not made a full and true disclosure of the
material facts at the time of original assessment and
therefore income chargeable to tax had escaped
assessment……..”
15. Reading of above decisions shows that ‘reason to believe' is
a common feature in taxing statutes. The word ‘reason’
means cause or justification and the word 'believe' means to
accept as true or to have faith in it. Before the officer has
faith or accepts a fact to exist there must be a justification for
it. It does not mean a purely subjective satisfaction on the part
of the Income-tax Officer. The reason must be held in good
faith. It cannot be merely a pretence. In other words, the
material on which the AO bases its opinion to reopen
assessment must not be arbitrary, irrational, vague, distant or
irrelevant. It must bring home the appropriate rationale of
action taken by the AO
in pursuance of such belief. If a
conscious application of mind is made to the relevant facts
and material available or existing at the relevant point of time
while making the assessment and again a different or
divergent view is reached, it would tantamount to "change of
opinion". The necessary sequitur is that a mere change of
opinion while perusing the same material cannot be a "reason
to believe" that a case of escaped assessment exists
requiring assessment proceedings to be reopened.
16. Turning back to the facts of present case. Appellant revenue
has filed present appeal assailing the impugned order passed
by the Tribunal mainly on the ground that assessment in
question was sought to be reopened for the reason that
certain part of income of assessee chargeable to tax escaped
assessment on account of failure of the assessee in truly and
fully disclosing the material facts relevant for assessment.
Whereas, it is a specific case on behalf of the respondentassessee that while framing the scrutiny assessment under
Section 143 (3) of the Act of 1961, the grounds/reasons on
which the assessment has been sought to be reopened were
already considered in detail by the then AO, specific queries
were raised with respect to 100% depreciation on dam,
additional depreciation under Section 32 (ii) (a) of the Act of
1961, disallowance under Section 14A of the Act of 1961 and
income during pre-production period and in response, all the
relevant materials were supplied/furnished by the respondent
and only thereafter the AO framed the assessment.
17. Learned Tribunal in the order impugned has reproduced the
reasons which led the AO to believe that income chargeable
to tax escaped assessment during assessment year 20092010, warranting initiation of reassessment proceeding under
Section 147 of the Act of 1961 and the same reads as under:-
“(i) Excess allowance of depreciation: - Assessee
has claimed 100 percent deprecation on dam of
Rs.8,50,32,403/-. In the depreciation rate schedule
of IT Act there is no provision of depreciation on
dam. Thus depreciation of Rs.8,50,32,403/- has
been allowed excessively.
(ii) Disallowance u/s.14A:- Assessee had made
substantial investment in shares and securities
income from which does not form part of total
income. However no expenditure in accordance
with section 14A of the Act was disallowed in this
respect. The disallowance on this account comes
to Rs. 11.53 crores. The same was remained to be
added in the income of the assessee.
(iii) Allowance of additional depreciation:- Assessee
has claimed additional depreciation of Rs. 377.81
crore under section 32(iia) of the Act. The
additional depreciation u/s. 32(iia) of the Act is
applicable to assesses engaged in the business of
manufacture/production of any article/thing of in the
business of generation or generation & distribution
of power. The benefit is extended to the assesses
engaged in the generation or generation and
distribution of power w.e.f. A.Yr. 2013-14. Thus,
assessee is not eligible for additional depreciation
for
the
year
under
consideration
even
the
generation of power cannot be equated with the
production of article or thing. Thus the sum of Rs.
377.81 crore on this count has allowed excessively.
(iv) Irregular disallowance of depreciation for the
pre-production
period
(Before
September):-
Assessee has earned interest and other income
worth of Rs. 3.47 crore (2.06 + 1.41) during pre
production period. The same instead of showing in
P&L account was actually deducted from closing
work in progress. In case of Tuticoran Alkalies
Chemical & Fertilizer Limited (227 ITR 172) the
Supreme Court categorically stated that preproduction interest income should be taken in P & L
Account as other source of income. Thus the said
amount of Rs. 3.47 crore remained to be added in
the income of the assessee.”
18. Perusal of above would demonstrate that the reasons
recorded by the AO for initiation of reassessment proceeding
rest on the information derived from the materials on the
record of original assessment. Hence, in above factual
background, the test is not as to whether there has been an
escapement of income, but whether there exist reasons to
believe that the income chargeable to tax had escaped
assessment, and in the present case there is sufficient
tangible material on record which justifies the prima facie
belief of A.O. regarding escapement of taxable income.
19. In case of Ganga Saran And Sons Pvt. Ltd. Calcutta vs
Income Tax Officer & Ors, reported in (1981) 3 SCC 143,
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held thus:“It is well settled as a result of several decisions of
this Court that two distinct conditions must be
satisfied before the Income Tax Officer can assume
jurisdiction to issue notice under section 147 (a). First,
he must have reason to believe that the income of the
assessee has escaped assessment and secondly, he
must have reason to believe that such escapement is
by reason of the omission or failure on the part of the
assessee to disclose fully and truly all material facts
necessary for his assessment. If either of these
conditions is not fulfilled, the notice issued by the
Income Tax Officer would be without jurisdiction. The
important words under section 147 (a) are "has
reason to believe" and these words are stronger than
the words "is satisfied". The belief entertained by the
Income Tax Officer must not be arbitrary or irrational.
It must be reasonable or in other words it must be
based on reasons which are relevant and material.
The Court, of course, cannot investigate into the
adequacy or sufficiency of the reasons which have
weighed with the Income Tax Officer in coming to the
belief, but the Court can certainly examine whether
the reasons are relevant and have a bearing on the
matters in regard to which he is required to entertain
the belief before he can issue notice under section
147 (a). It there is no rational and intelligible nexus
between the reasons and the belief, so that, on such
reasons, no one properly instructed on facts and law
could reasonably entertain the belief, the conclusion
would be inescapable that the Income Tax Officer
could not have reason to believe that any part of the
income of the assessee had escaped assessment
and such escapement was by reason of the omission
or failure on the part of the assessee to disclose fully
and truly all material facts and the notice issued by
him would be liable to he struck down as invalid.”
20. In case of Phool Chand Bajrang Lal vs Income-tax Officer,
reported in (1993) 4 SCC 77, Hon’ble Supreme Court has
observed thus:“27. From a combined review of the judgments of this
Court, it follows that an Income-tax Officer acquires
jurisdiction to reopen assessment under Section 147(a)
read with Section 148 of the Income Tax 1961 only if on
the basis of specific, reliable and relevant information
coming to his possession subsequently, he has reasons
which he must record, to believe that by reason of
omission or failure on the part of the assessee to make
a true ana full disclosure of all material facts necessary
for his assessment during the concluded assessment
proceedings, any part of his income, profit or gains
chargeable to income tax has escaped assessment. He
may start reassessment proceedings either because
some fresh facts come to light which where not
previously disclosed or some information with regard to
the
facts
previously
disclosed
comes
into
his
possession which tends to expose the untruthfulness of
those facts. In such situations, it is not a case of mere
change of opinion or the drawing of a different inference
from the same facts as were earlier available but acting
on fresh information. Since, the belief is that of the
Income-tax Officer, the sufficiency of reasons for
forming the belief, is not for the Court to judge but it is
open to an assessee to establish that there in fact
existed no belief or that the belief was not at all a bona
fide one or was based on vague, irrelevant and nonspecific information. To that limited extent, the Court
may look into the conclusion arrived at by the Income-
tax Officer and examine whether there was any material
available on the record from which the requisite belief
could be formed by the Income-tax Officer and further
whether that material had any rational connection or a
live link for the formation of the requisite belief.…..”
21. In the matter of Commissioner of Income Tax Delhi vs
Kelvinator of India Limited, reported in (2010) 2 SCC 723, a
three Judges Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court has held
thus:“6. We must also keep in mind the conceptual
difference between power to review and power to
re-assess. The Assessing Officer has no power to
review; he has the power to re-assess. But reassessment has to be based on fulfillment of certain
pre-condition and if the concept of "change of
opinion" is removed, as contended on behalf of the
Department, then, in the garb of re-opening the
assessment, review would take place.
7. One must treat the concept of "change of opinion"
as an in-built test to check abuse of power by the
Assessing Officer. Hence, after 1st April, 1989,
Assessing Officer has power to re-open, provided
there is "tangible material" to come to the conclusion
that
there
is
escapement
of
income
from
assessment. Reasons must have a live link with the
formation of the belief.…..”
22. In case of State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors. v. Aryaverth
Chawl Udyoug and Ors. Reported in 2014 SCC OnLine SC
1205 Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that discovery of
an inadvertent mistake or non- application of mind during the
assessment would not be a justifiable ground to initiate
reassessment proceedings, has observed thus:“27. This court has consistently held that such
material on which the assessing authority bases its
opinion must not be arbitrary, irrational, vague,
distant or irrelevant. It must bring home the
appropriate rationale of action taken by the assessing
authority in pursuance of such belief. In case of
absence of such material, this Court in clear terms
has held the action taken by assessing authority on
such "reason to believe" as arbitrary and bad in law.
In case of the same material being present before the
assessing authority during both, the assessment
proceedings
and
the
issuance
of
notice
for
reassessment proceedings, it cannot be said by the
assessing authority that "reason to believe" for
initiating reassessment is an error discovered in the
earlier view taken by it during original assessment
proceedings. (See DCM v. State of Rajasthan: [1980] 4
SCC 71).
28. The standard of reason exercised by the
assessing authority is laid down as that of an honest
and prudent person who would act on reasonable
grounds and come to a cogent conclusion. The
necessary sequitur is that a mere change of opinion
while perusing the same material cannot be a
"reason to believe" that a case of escaped
assessment exists requiring assessment proceedings
to be reopened…..”
23. In case of Income Tax Officer, Ward No.62 vs. Tech Span
India (P.) Ltd. and another, reported in (2018) 6 SCC 685 ,
Hon'ble Supreme Court held as under:
“14. The language of Section 147 makes it clear that
the assessing officer certainly has the power to reassess any income which escaped assessment for any
assessment year subject to the provisions of Sections
148 to 153………. The said provision was incorporated
in the scheme of the IT Act so as to empower the
Assessing Authorities to re-assess any income on the
ground which was not brought on record during the
original proceedings and escaped his knowledge; and
the said fact would have material bearing on the
outcome of the relevant assessment order.
15. Section 147 of the IT Act does not allow the reassessment of an income merely because of the fact
that the assessing officer has a change of opinion with
regard to the interpretation of law differently on the
facts that were well within his knowledge even at the
time of assessment. Doing so would have the effect of
giving the assessing officer the power of review and
Section 147 confers the power to re-assess and not the
power to review.
24. In case of Radha Krishna Industries vs State of H.P.,
reported in (2021) 6 SCC 771, Hon’ble Supreme Court,
referring to its earlier decision in the matter of Kelvinator of
India Ltd. (supra), has held that the power to reopen an
assessment must be conditioned on the existence of "tangible
material" and that "reasons must have a live link with the
formation of the belief".
25. Recently, in case of Sanand Properties Pvt. Ltd. vs Joint
Commissioner of Income-tax and others, reported in 2026
SCC Online SC 851, which has also been relied upon by
learned counsel for appellant herein, Hon’ble Supreme Court
has observed thus:“68. In the light of the above rival contentions, it is
crucial for us to ascertain whether the "tangible
material" that the Revenue sought to rely upon had
already been considered, appreciated and accepted by
the Revenue in the original assessment orders. If such
"tangible material" had already been relied upon by the
Assessing Officer to form an opinion in the original
assessment orders, then relying upon the same for the
purpose of reopening assessment would amount to
review instead of reassessment, and that would not be
permissible in law, as noted by this court in CIT v.
Kelvinator of India Ltd. However, if the "tangible
material" is extraneous to the original assessment
records, or was present but not considered or acted
upon by the Assessing Officer during the initial
proceedings, such information provides a valid
jurisdictional basis for the Revenue to reopen the
assessment.”
26. Having regard to the aforesaid legal position, this Court now
adverts to the material on record to test whether there was
reason to believe that income had escaped assessment;
whether the AO has tangible material before him for the
formation of that belief and whether respondent assessee had
failed to disclose truly and fully all necessary material facts
during the original assessment proceedings.
27. From the order impugned passed by the Tribunal it can be
seen that in the notice dated 07.12.2011 issued under Section
142 (1) of the Act of 1961 to the respondent assessee during
the original assessment proceedings, the AO has called upon
the respondent assessee to furnish evidence in support of
claim for 100% deprecation on dam, additional depreciation
under Section 32 (11)(a) of the Act of 1961, disallowance
under Section 14A of the Act of 1961 and period interest and
other income during pre-production period. Respondent
assessee submitted reply to aforementioned specific queries
raised at the time of original assessment. The then AO having
satisfied with the genuineness with respect to claim for 100%
deprecation on dam; additional deprecation under Section 32
(ii) (a) of the Act of 1961; disallowance under Section 14A of
the Act of 1961 and deduction of earned interest and other
income
during
preproduction
period,
framed
scrutiny
assessment under Section 143 (3) of the Act of 1961. All
these facts clearly indicate that the then AO before allowing
depreciation/deductions in the original assessment, had
applied his mind and arrived at a conscious decision
thereafter for grant of such deductions.
28. The AO while recording reasons under Section 148 (2) of the
Act of 1961 has observed that he has reason to believe that
income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment in view of
the fact that during original assessment proceeding for
assessment year in question, depreciation rate schedule of
the Act of 1961 there is no provision of deprecation on dam;
no expenditure in accordance with Section 14A of the Act of
1961 was disallowed; an amount of Rs.377.81 Crore towards
additional deprecation was allowed and a sum of Rs.3.47
Corore towards earned interest and other income during
preproduction period remained to be added in the income of
assessee.
29. From the the reasons recorded by the AO itself it is clear that
the reasons to believe are based on information and details
which were available to the AO at the time of the original
assessment proceedings, i.e., assessment records, and not
on any tangible material that has come to the notice of the AO
after passing original assessment order to conclude that there
was an escapement of assessment. The reasons so recorded
by the assessing officer show that reassessment proceedings
has been initiated in view of the fact that the AO while passing
the
original
assessment
order,
had
allowed
such
deductions/depreciation which according to the successor
AO, who initiated such reassessment proceedings, have
resulted in escapement of income chargeable to tax from
being assessed in the original assessment. This shows that
the AO has drawn an inference on the basis of material
already existing on the records of the original assessment
proceedings and has arrived at the conclusion that some
deductions
assessment.
were
erroneously
allowed
in
the
original
30. That apart, while recording the reasons, the AO has nowhere
recorded his satisfaction that such income has escaped
assessment by reason of the omission or failure on the part of
the assessee to disclose fully and truly material facts relating
to claim of depreciation etc. or the assessee had made any
false or untrue statement in the course of original assessment
proceedings. The AO has also not indicated that any fresh
facts had come to light, which were not previously disclosed.
31. Aforementioned facts and circumstances of the case clearly
reflects that there was no failure on the part of the assessee
to make a full and true disclosure of the material facts at the
time of the original assessment and that is why the successor
AO, who recorded the reasons under Section 147 (a) of the
Act of 1961, could not record his satisfaction about any such
failure on the part of the assessee. Recording of such
reasons without a specific satisfaction that such escapement
of income had resulted on account of failure on the part of the
assessee to make a full and true disclosure of the material
facts or any tangible material has come to the notice after
passing original assessment order, cannot confer jurisdiction
to the assessing officer to reopen the assessment under
Section 147 of the Act of 1961.
32. Proceedings for reassessment cannot be initiated merely
because income liable to tax has escaped assessment due to
mistake committed by the Assessment Officer. After the
assessment order is framed, the successor Assessing Officer
cannot at a later point of time reopen the assessment merely
on forming an opinion after examining of the material
disclosed by the assessee that the Assessment Officer, who
had passed the assessment order, had committed an error in
computing the taxable income of the assessee during original
assessment proceeding. It will fall within the purview of
change of opinion, which is not permissible.
33. The upshot of above discussion, therefore, is that the
"reasons to believe" recorded by the AO was totally
unfounded and not bonafide and as such, initiation of
reassessment proceeding by the AO under Section 147 of the
Act of 1961 was patently invalid and without any jurisdiction.
Being so, the view taken by the Tribunal in the order
impugned for setting aside quashing the assessment order of
the AO dated 13.02.2015 was correct and justified.
34. In the result, the appeal is dismissed. No order as to costs.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
roshan/-
Sd/(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review