Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
***
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.6787 of 2018
C.M.A.NO.1141 OF 2018
Between:
1. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, represented by Superintending
Engineer, S. Chandra Sekhara Rao, s/o S. Kotaiah, aced about 55
years, Pulichintala Project Circle, Jaggaiahpet, Krishna District works
with Government of Andhra Pradesh.
...Appellant
AND
$1. M/s. SCLCR 18g Joint Venture and 3 others, 8-2-502/1/a, 1st floor, Jivi
Towers, Road no.7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad -500 034, represented
by the Authorised Signatory and Power of Attorney Holder, D.
Srinivas, s/o D.V. Naidu, aged about 47 years, Executive Director,
M/s. SCLCR 18 g. Joint Venture, 8-2-502/1/a, 1st Floor, Jivi Towers,
Road no.7. Banjara Hills, Hyderabad.
2. Honble Justice J Eswara Prasad, Plot no.1189, Road no.60, Jubilee
Hills, Hyderabad.
3. Honble Justice Motilal B Naik, D.No.11-13-571/a. Haripuram Colony,
S.R. Nagar, Hyderabad.
4. Honble Justice Vamana Rao, Plot Nos, 202 and 203, Mahasiva
Apartments, Hyderabad. ( Respondent Nos.2 to 4 are not necessary
parties to this petition)
...RESPONDENT(S):
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 6787/2018
Between:
Government of Andhra Pradesh, rep by Superintending Engineer, Male
Venkata Ramana S/o.Nagaiah, Pulichintala Project Circle, Jaggaiahpet,
Krishna District works with Government of Andhra Pradesh.
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
...PETITIONER
AND
$ M/S SCLCR 18 G, Joint Venture, 8-2-502/1/A, 1st floor, Jivi Towers,
road No.7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad 500034 rep by the Authorised
Signatory and power of Attorney Holder D.Srinivas S/o.D.V.Naidu aged
about 50 years , Executive director, M/s.SCL-CR 18 G.Joint Venture, 82-502/1/A, 1st floor, Jivi Towers, Road No.7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT
Date of Judgment pronounced on : 06-03-2026
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D. SEKHAR
1. Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
May be allowed to see the judgments?
: Yes/No
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be marked
to Law Reporters/Journals:
: Yes/No
3. Whether the Lordship wishes to see the fair copy
Of the Judgment?
: Yes/No
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
*IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI
* HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D. SEKHAR
+ CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.6787 of 2018
% Dated: 06-03-2026
C.M.A.NO.1141 OF 2018
Between:
1. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, represented by Superintending
Engineer, S. Chandra Sekhara Rao, s/o S. Kotaiah, aced about 55
years, Pulichintala Project Circle, Jaggaiahpet, Krishna District works
with Government of Andhra Pradesh.
...Appellant
AND
$1. M/s. SCLCR 18g Joint Venture and 3 others, 8-2-502/1/a, 1st floor, Jivi
Towers, Road No.7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad -500 034, represented
by the Authorised Signatory and Power of Attorney Holder, D.
Srinivas, s/o D.V. Naidu, aged about 47 years, Executive Director,
M/s. SCLCR 18 g. Joint Venture, 8-2-502/1/a, 1st Floor, Jivi Towers,
Road no.7. Banjara Hills, Hyderabad.
2. Honble Justice J Eswara Prasad, Plot no.1189, Road no.60, Jubilee
Hills, Hyderabad.
3. Honble Justice Motilal B Naik, D.No.11-13-571/a. Haripuram Colony,
S.R. Nagar, Hyderabad.
4. Honble Justice Vamana Rao, Plot Nos, 202 and 203, Mahasiva
Apartments, Hyderabad. ( Respondent Nos.2 to 4 are not necessary
parties to this petition)
...RESPONDENT(S):
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 6787/2018
Between:
Government of Andhra Pradesh, rep by Superintending Engineer, Male
Venkata Ramana S/o.Nagaiah, Pulichintala Project Circle, Jaggaiahpet,
Krishna District works with Government of Andhra Pradesh.
...PETITIONER
AND
$ M/S SCLCR 18 G, Joint Venture, 8-2-502/1/A, 1st floor, Jivi Towers,
road No.7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad 500034 rep by the Authorised
Signatory and power of Attorney Holder D.Srinivas S/o.D.V.Naidu aged
about 50 years , Executive director, M/s.SCL-CR 18 G.Joint Venture, 82-502/1/A, 1st floor, Jivi Towers, Road No.7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT
! Counsel for Appellant
:The learned Advocate General and Sri
Yathindra Dev. D, the learned Government
Pleader, in the office of the Learned Advocate
General, appearing for the appellant.
! Counsel for Respondent
: Sri B. Adinarayana Rao, the learned Senior
Counsel representing on behalf of Sri
Srinivasa Rao Bodduluri, the learned counsel,
appearing for the respondents.
<GIST
:
>HEAD NOTE:
? Cases referred:
2016 (1) ALD 185
2015 (4) ALD 380
(2018) 2 SCC 182 (paras 26 to 29)
(2025) 9 SCC 76
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
2015 (4) ALD 380
2016 (1) ALD 185
(1977) 1 SCC 484:AIR 1977 SC 1701
AIR 1964 SC 669
2015 (4) ALD 380
0 (2003) 3 SCC 472
1(2003) 3 SCC 472
2(2003) 3 SCC 472
3 (2018) 2 SCC 182 (paras 26 to 29)
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
APHC011424862016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3529]
FRIDAY,THE SIXTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1141/2018 & CIVIL REVISION
PETITION NO.6787 OF 2018
C.M.A.NO.1141 OF 2018
Between:
1. THE GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REPRESENTED BY
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER, S. CHANDRA SEKHARA RAO, S/O
S. KOTAIAH, ACED ABOUT 55 YEARS, PULICHINTALA PROJECT
CIRCLE, JAGGAIAHPET, KRISHNA DISTRICT
WORKS WITH
GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
...APPELLANT
AND
1. M/S SCLCR 18G JOINT VENTURE AND 3 OTHERS, 8-2-502/1/A, 1ST
FLOOR, JIVI TOWERS, ROAD NO.7, BANJARA HILLS, HYDERABAD
-500 034, REPRESENTED BY THE AUTHORISED SIGNATORY AND
POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER, D. SRINIVAS, S/O D.V. NAIDU,
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS, EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, M/S SCL-CR 18
G. JOINT VENTURE, 8-2-502/1/A, 1ST FLOOR, JIVI TOWERS, ROAD
NO.7. BANJARA HILLS, HYDERABAD.
2. HONBLE JUSTICE J ESWARA PRASAD, PLOT NO.1189, ROAD
NO.60, JUBILEE HILLS, HYDERABAD.
3. HONBLE
JUSTICE
MOTILAL
B
NAIK,
D.NO.11-13-571/A.
HARIPURAM COLONY, S.R. NAGAR, HYDERABAD.
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
4. HONBLE JUSTICE VAMANA RAO, PLOT NOS, 202 AND 203,
MAHASIVA APARTMENTS, HYDERABAD. ( RESPONDENT NOS.2
TO 4 ARE NOT NECESSARY PARTIES TO THIS PETITION)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal Under Section_____against ordersTo set aside the order dated
02-06-2016 passed in AOP.No.23/2015 on the file of the Hon'ble Principal
District Judge,Krishna,Machilipatnam as well as the Award dated 3-10-2013 of
the Arbitral Tribunal and to pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 766 days in representing the CMA filed against the
judgment and decree dated 02-06-2016 in AOP.No.23 of 2015, on the file of
the Hon'ble Principal District Judge, Krishna at Machilipatnam and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay of all further proceedings in E.P.No. 420 of 2017 in A.O.P.No. 23 of
2015, on the file of the Hon'ble X Additional District and Special Session
Judge. Krishna at Machilipatnam, including the process of auction/sale of
items 1 and 2 of the E.P. Schedule property- Pending disposal of the Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal Petition, and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2019
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
IA NO: 2 OF 2019
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant six months time from the date of expiry of the order dated 23.11.2018
passed in IA No.2 of 2018 CMA No.1141 of 2018
IA NO: 3 OF 2019
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the stay granted on 23-11-2018 made in IA.No.2 of 2018 in CMA
No.1141 of 2018 and pass
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. THE ADVOCATE GENERAL (AP)
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. SRINIVASA RAO BODDULURI
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 6787/2018
Between:
1. GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP BY SUPERINTENDING
ENGINEER,
MALE
VENKATA
RAMANA
S/O.NAGAIAH,
PULICHINTALA PROJECT CIRCLE, JAGGAIAHPET, KRISHNA
DISTRICT WORKS WITH GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
...PETITIONER
AND
1. M/S SCLCR 18 G, Joint Venture, 8-2-502/1/A, 1st floor, Jivi Towers,
road No.7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad 500034 rep by the Authorised
Signatory and power of Attorney Holder D.Srinivas S/o.D.V.Naidu aged
about 50 years , Executive director, M/s.SCL-CR 18 G.Joint Venture, 82-502/1/A, 1st floor, Jivi Towers, Road No.7, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,praying that in the
circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein,the High Court may be
pleased toto set aside the order dated 24.09.2018 passed in EP No.420 of
2017 in AOP No.23 of 2015 on the file of the Hon'ble X Additional District and
Special Sessions Judge, Krishna at Machilipatnam in the interest of justice
and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay of all further proceedings pursuant to the order dated 24.09.2018 in
EP No.420 of 2017 in AOP No.23 of 2015 on the file of the Hon'ble X
Additional District and Sessions Judge, Krishna at Machilipatnam including the
process of auction sale of items 1 and 2 of the EP Schedule property pending
disposal of the CRP and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. THE ADVOCATE GENERAL (AP)
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. K SIVA KUMAR REDDY
Date of Reserved
:
29.12.2025
Date of Pronouncement
:
06.03.2026
Date of Upload
:
06.03.2026
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
The Court made the following Order:
(per Hon’ble Sri Justice R. Raghunandan Rao)
Heard the learned Advocate General and Sri Yathindra Dev. D, the
learned Government Pleader, in the office of the Learned Advocate General,
appearing for the appellant and Sri B. Adinarayana Rao, the learned Senior
Counsel representing on behalf of Sri Srinivasa Rao Bodduluri, the learned
counsel, appearing for the respondents.
2.
The Government of Andhra Pradesh had taken a decision to
construct the Pulichintala Project, for stabilizing the Ayacut in the command
area, under the Nagarjuna Sagar and for various other reasons. One of the
components of this project was the construction of a Dam and ancillary
infrastructure. For this purpose, a tender was issued for execution of the
following work:
"Pulichintala
Project
balancing
reservoir
Head
works
by
construction of Dam from 0 to 1289 M N.O.F., Left and Right side,
Spillway with radial gates arrangements including Civil works for
providing 4 Ferrules with trash rack arrangements for Power
House, river sluices across Krishna river near Pulichinta (V)
Bellamkonda (M) of Guntur and Vazinepalli (V) Mellacheruvu (M)
of
Nalgonda
Districts
on
engineering,
procurement
and
construction E.P.C. turnkey contract basis as per the scope of
work set forth in the bid documents and Operation and
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
Maintenance of the project for 2(two) years after successful
testing and commissioning of the project."
3.
The 1st respondent was the successful bidder, in the tender
process, and the contract was awarded to the 1st respondent. Thereafter, an
agreement was executed, on 30.09.2004, for execution of the said project.
4.
The dispute resolution mechanism, under this contract was as
follows:
19.4 Obtaining Dispute Adjudication Board’s Decision
If a dispute (of any kind whatsoever) arises between the Parties in
connection with or arising out of, the Contract or the execution of the
Works, including any dispute as to any certificate, determination,
instruction, opinion or valuation of the Employer then after a DAB has
been appointed pursuant to Sub-Clauses 20.2 [Apartment of the DAB)
and 20.3 [Failure for Agrees DAED, either Party may refer the dispute in
writing to the DAB for its decision, with a copy to the other Party Such
reference shall state that it is given under this Sub-Clause.
For a DAB of three persons, the DAB shall be deemed to have received
such reference on the date when the chairman of the DAB receives it.
Both Parties shall promptly make available to the DAB all information,
access to the Site, and appropriate facilities, as the DAB may require for
the purposes of making a decision on such dispute. The DAB shall be
deemed to be not acting as arbitrator(s).
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
Within 84 days after receiving such reference, or the advance payment
referred to in Clause 6 of the Appendix General Conditions of the
Dispute Adjudication Agreement, whichever date is later, or within such
other period as may be proposed by the DAB and approved by both
Parties, the DAB shall give its decision, which shall be reasoned and
shall state that it is given under this Sub-Clause. However, if neither of
the Parties has paid in full the invoices submitted by each Member
pursuant to Clause 6 of the Appendix, the DAB shall not be obliged to
give its decision until such invoices have been paid in full. The decision
shall be binding on both Parties, who shall promptly give effect to unless
and until it shall be revised in an amicable settlement or an arbitral
award as described below. Unless the Contract has already been
abandoned, repudiated or terminated, the Contractor shall continue to
proceed with the Works in accordance with the Contract.
If either Party is dissatisfied with the DAB's decision, then either Party
may, within 28 days after receiving the decision, give notice to the other
Party of its dissatisfaction. If the DAB fails to give its decision within the
period of 84 days (or as otherwise approved) after receiving such
reference or such payment, then either Party may, within 28 days after
this period has expired, give notice to the other Party of its
dissatisfaction.
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
In either event, this notice of dissatisfaction shall state that it is given
under this Sub Clause, and shall set out the manner in dispute and the
reason(s) for dissatisfaction. Except as stated in Sub-Clause 20.7
[Failure to Comply with Dispute Adjudication Board's Decision) and
Sub-Clause 20.8 [Expiry of Dispute Adjudication Board's Appointment),
neither Party shall be entitled to attempt any discussion for amicable
settlement of a dispute unless a notice of dissatisfaction has been given
in accordance with this Sub-Clause.
If the DAB has given its decision as to a matter in dispute to both
Parties, and no notice of dissatisfaction has been given by either Party
within 28 days after it received the DAB's decision, then the decision
shall become final and binding upon both Parties.
19.6 Arbitration
Unless settled amicably, any dispute in respect of which the DAB's
decision (if any) has not become final and binding shall be finally settled
as per Indian Arbitration Act, 1996.
The arbitration shall be conducted in the language for communications
defined in Sub-Clause 1.4 (Law and Language).
The arbitrator(s) shall have full power to open up, review and revise any
certificate, determination, instruction, opinion or valuation of (or on
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
behalf of) the Employer, and any decision of the DAB, relevant to the
dispute.
Neither Party shall be limited in the proceedings before the arbitrator(s)
to the evidence or arguments previously put before the DAB to obtain its
decision, or to the reasons for dissatisfaction given in its notice of
dissatisfaction. Any decision of the DAB shall be admissible in evidence
in the arbitration.
Arbitration may be commenced prior to or after completion of the
Works. The obligations of the Parties and the DAB shall not be altered
by reason of any arbitration being conducted during the progress of the
Works.
5.
The 1st respondent had raised certain claims, which were then
referred to a D.A.B (which is referred to in all the proceedings, as the first
Dispute Adjudication Board). The first D.A.B published its decision, on
31.01.2002, accepting some of the claims of the 1st respondent. This decision
was accepted by the appellant and, on the basis of such decision, payments
were made. Thereafter, the 1st respondent again raised disputes on two
counts. Firstly, that the decision of the First Dispute Adjudication Board (1st
D.A.B) was not implemented properly and secondly, on the ground that
additional claims had arisen. These disputes were referred to a Second
Dispute Adjudication Board, (2nd D.A.B). The members of the first D.A.B. were
again constituted as the 2nd D.A.B. The 1st respondent raised 27 claims before
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
the 2nd D.A.B. After hearing both sides and considering their respective
submissions as well as the documents placed before it, the 2nd D.A.B gave its
decision, on 09.01.2012. In this decision, some of the claims were rejected
and some claims were accepted. The appellant, being dissatisfied, gave
notice of its dissatisfaction, dated 03.12.2012. On account of this notice of
dissatisfaction, an Arbitral Tribunal was constituted with two former judges of
the erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh as arbitrators and a former Chief
Justice of the Hon‘ble High Court at Madras as well as the Hon‘ble high Court
of Kerala, as the presiding arbitrator. However, the presiding arbitrator, on
being appointed as the Lok Ayuktha, could not continue and a former judge of
the erstwhile high court was nominated, by both the learned arbitrators, as the
presiding Arbitrator.
6.
The 1st respondent filed a claim statement raising 28 claims, which
are enumerated below:
1)
Compensation for delayed payment of the amounts awarded by
the first DAB;
2)
Compensation for the delay in payments consequent to initial
incorrect implementation of decisions of First DAB, affecting the cash
flow;
3)
Amount due for delayed payment of escalation charges;
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
4)
Amount due towards delay in payment of escalation charges for
labour, other material and oils for the gate works resulting in financial
crunch;
5) Claim towards escalation of cost of steel utilized on work by way of
overlaps and wastage resulting in locking up of finances;
6) Compensation due to delay in payment of bills;
7) Compensation for damages sustained due to fundamental breach of
contract by the department during the entire contract period:
8) Extra expenditure incurred in the extended period of contract due to
prolongation of work;
9) Amount payable towards idle charges of machinery for reduced
progress of work for reasons beyond the control of the contractor;
10) Claim as regards site expenses, overheads and loss of profit;
11) Payment due towards banking charges, consequent to borrowings
from banks to meet the adverse financial position forced on the
claimant;
12) Amount due to extra steel provided in the design of gates and other
Hydro-Mechanical works over and above National Standards;
13) Amount due to extra enforcement steel insisted over that actually
required as per National Standards;
14) Amount due to installation of additional instruments in Dam than
those specified in the agreement;
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
15) Amount due to changes insisted in drawings over and above The
National Standards involving extra quantity of concreting;
16) Payment of extra cost due to change of Penstock dia 5880 M to
6500 MM;
17) Amount due towards non-payment in time for steel placed in the
concrete;
18) Amount towards extra quantity of concrete due to insistence by the
Department to excavate and do concrete beyond the approved levels in
stilling basin Blocks 29 to 33;
19) Unauthorized recovery of Geo-technical services obtained by the
Department;
20) Amount to be compensated for the damages under the category
"Force Majeure";
21) Issue of providing upstream training wall;
22) Compensation for inadequate payment for structural steel contrary
to the agreement provision;
23) Amount due towards payment of steel according to bill of quantities
based on the approved drawing as per IS 9401;
24.) Reimbursement of bank charges incurred for extension of
performance guarantee beyond the original date of completion of work;
25) Additional expenditure forced due to insistence of Bank Guarantee
for advance payment of steel;
26) Irregular recovery of labour cess at 1% from bills;
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
27) Reimbursement of interest on unauthorized amount recovered by
way of interest on mobilization advance beyond extended period of
contract;
28) Expenditure incurred by claimant for second DAB's meetings as per
Annexures-28 and 28.1.
7.
These claims were opposed by the S.E. Pulichintala Project, who
filed a statement of defense, along with documents relevant to the defense.
After completion of pleadings, both parties had stated that they would not
adduce any oral evidence and the claims could be adjudicated on the basis of
the documents filed before the Arbitral Tribunal and on the basis of the
submissions made on these documents. Basing on the above claims, and
contentions raised, on both sides, the Arbitral Tribunal framed the following
issues for consideration.
1) Whether any reference to FIDIC model contract can be made for the
purpose of deciding the present dispute?
2) Whether claims not made before the respondent can be made before
the DAB or the Arbitral Tribunal?
3) Whether claims not made before the DAB can be put forth before the
Arbitral Tribunal?
4) Whether the claims are barred in terms of the contract?
5) Whether the claims are barred by limitation?
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
6) Whether claims which are disallowed by the DAB can be made
before the Arbitral Tribunal and in regard to which of those claims?
7) Whether the decision of the 02nd DAB is liable to be set-aside?
8) Whether any reference to the decision of the 02nd DAB can be made
before the Arbitral Tribunal?
9) Whether the time specified in the contract by which the decision of
The DAB becomes final and binding can be extended with mutual
consent?
10) Whether claimant is entitled for any of the claims?
11) To what relief?
8.
The Arbitral Tribunal, after marking Ex.C.1 to C.293 (Ex.C.90 was
marked subject to proof of relevancy) on behalf of the 1st respondent and
Exs.R1 to R.100 on behalf of Appellant, heard arguments. It appears that
additional documents were filed during the course of these submissions. The
Arbitral Tribunal, in its award, recorded that even these documents were taken
into consideration, though they were not specifically marked, as no objection
was raised, to these documents, by either side. The Arbitral Tribunal after
hearing both sides, passed its award on 03.09.2013. The presiding arbitrator
and one of the learned arbitrators, had passed the majority award. The other
learned arbitrator had passed a separate award, dissenting from the award of
the majority of the Tribunal.
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
9.
The majority award rejected claims 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, 14, 17, 22 and 27
while granting relief in all the other claims. As a result of this award, a sum of
Rs.199.96 crores, approximately, came to be awarded to the 1st respondent.
The minority award rejected claims 2 to 11, 14, 17, 18, 20, 22, 24, 25 and 27.
Relief was granted in the other claims. However, this relief was restricted to
the limits permissible under clause 59 and 69 of APDSS resulting in an award
of Rs.10.95 crores.
10.
The appellant being aggrieved by this award, filed A.O.P.No.23 of
2015, before the Principal District Judge, Krishna District at Machilipatnam.
This petition came to be dismissed by the learned Principal District Judge,
Krishna District, on 02.06.2016. Aggrieved by the said order of dismissal, the
appellant has approached this Court, by way of the present appeal.
11.
The learned Advocate General, as well as Sri D. Yathindra Dev,
appearing for the appellant raised the following broad grounds:
A. The arbitral proceedings as well the proceedings before the trial
court and this court are vitiated by non-joinder of a necessary party, namely
the State of Andhra Pradesh. Even otherwise, the Government of Andhra
Pradesh, which is the ―employer‖ was not made a party.
B.
Preliminary Specifications 59 and 69 of the A.P.D.S.S., which are
part of the contract, restrict the quantum of the compensation that can be
claimed, on account of delay in execution of the contract, or on account of
delay in payment of contract price. However, the majority award, holding that
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
these clauses do not apply, had awarded compensation beyond the limits
prescribed under these clauses.
C. The award of compensation, in relation to various claims was also
assailed.
GROUND A:
12.
The contentions of the learned Advocate General are as follows:
(i)
The contract is between the employer and the Contractor.
Consequently, any dispute would have to be decided between the employer
and the contractor. The term ‗Employer‖ has been defined, in clause 1.1.2.2 of
the contract documents, to be the Government of Andhra Pradesh. Clause
1.1.2.4 stipulates, that the Superintending Engineer is only a representative of
the employer. However, the claims, before the Arbitral Tribunal, were raised
against the Superintending Engineer, without making the Government of
Andhra Pradesh a party before the Arbitral Tribunal. The award passed by the
Arbitral Tribunal would be a nullity and not binding on the Government of
Andhra Pradesh.
(ii)
Article 300, of the Constitution of India, requires that, in any Suits or
proceedings, the Government of Andhra Pradesh shall be sued by the name
of the State of Andhra Pradesh. Any deviation, from this requirement, would
be fatal to the maintainability of the legal proceedings. Further, these defects
cannot be rectified at the appellate stage and such defects can be rectified
only during the pendency of the original proceedings. Reliance is placed, on
the following judgments. General Manager, Central Organization for
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
Railway Electrification, Allahabad and Others., vs. Y. Parthasarathy and
Another1., and Shyamala Reddy, Pavitranagar, Musherabad, Hyderabad
and
Others.,
vs.
M/s.
Hindustan
Petroleum
Corporation
Ltd.,
Secunderabad and Others.2
13.
Sri B. Adinarayana Rao, the learned Senior Counsel appearing
for the 1st respondent would dispute these contentions with the following
submissions:
(i) The question of necessary party was never raised before the
Arbitral Tribunal or the Trial Court. This contention was also not raised in the
grounds of appeal. This contention is being raised, across the bar, in the
course of the oral submissions. Such a plea cannot be raised at this stage, in
view of the judgment of the Hon‘ble Supreme Court in the case of Union of
India vs. Susaka Private Limited and Ors3.
(ii) The judgments, cited by the learned Advocate General, would not
be applicable to the present case in view of the peculiar facts of the present
case. The contract agreement itself refers to the Superintending Engineer as
the employer. It was the Government of Andhra Pradesh, which had submitted
its letter of dissatisfaction to the decision of the 2nd D.A.B which resulted in the
arbitral proceedings. As such, the Government of Andhra Pradesh was very
much a party to the arbitral proceedings. It is on account of such participation,
that the Government of Andhra Pradesh moved the Arbitration O.P before the
2016 (1) ALD 185
2015 (4) ALD 380
(2018) 2 SCC 182 (paras 26 to 29)
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
trial Court, under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act. Apart from this, the present
appeal itself came to be filed by the Government of Andhra Pradesh and as
such, this contention does not arise. The judgment of the Hon‘ble Supreme
Court in ASF Build Tech Private Limited., vs. Shapoorji Pallonji and
Company Private Limited.,4 makes it clear that even parties which are not
directly involved in the arbitral proceedings would be bound by such
proceedings.
Consideration of the Court:
14.
Before considering the applicability of the above judgments, to
the present case, it is necessary to look at the facts of this case. The tender,
inviting bids, was issued by the ―Irrigation and CAD (PW) Department,
Government of Andhra Pradesh, India, hereinafter called ―the employer‖.
However, the contract agreement, executed on 30.09.2004, is between the ―
Project Administrator and Superintending Engineer, Pulichintala Project Circle,
Jaggaiahpeta of Irrigation & CAD Department (hereinafter called ―the
Employer‖) of the one part, And M/s Srinivasa Construction Limited-CR18GJoint Venture, 6-2-913/9/4, 5th floor, Progressive Towers, Khairathabad,
Hyderabad-500 004 (hereinafter called ―the Contractor‖) of the other part‖. The
definition of ―Employer‖ contained in the general conditions of contract, at
clause 1.1.2.2, reads as follows:
(2025) 9 SCC 76
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
Clause
1.1.2.2
“Employer”/“EMPLOYER‖
means
the
Irrigation and Command Area Development Department,
Government of Andhra Pradesh.
The representative of the employer was defined, in clause 1.1.2.4 as
follows:
Clause 1.1.2.4
―Employer‘s
Representative‖
is
the
Superintending Engineer, Pulichintala Project Circle as
designated by the Government of Andhra Pradesh for the
purpose of the Contract.
15.
The definitions in the general conditions of contract defined the
employer to be the ―Irrigation and CAD (PW) Department, Government of
Andhra Pradesh. The contract agreement, executed on 30.09.2004 defines
the employer to be the Project Administrator and Superintending Engineer,
Pulichinthala Project Circle, Jaggaiahpeta of the Irrigation and CAD (PW)
Department. Thus, there is a contradiction between the general conditions of
contract and the contract agreement. In the event of such difference, clause
1.5 of the general conditions of contract stipulates that the priority of
documents shall be in the following manner:
1.5 Priority of Documents
The documents forming the Contract are to be taken as
mutually explanatory of one another. For the purposes of
interpretation, the priority of the document shall be in
accordance with following sequence:
a) the Contract Agreement;
b) Letter of Award, notice to proceed
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
Contractor's Bid
d) Special Conditions of Contract
e) General Conditions of Contract
f) Letter of Tender
g) any other documents forming part of the
Contract.
In view of clause 1.5, the Contract Agreement would have priority, and
the employer, under this contract would be the Project Administrator and
Superintending Engineer, Pulichinthala Project Circle.
16.
The 1st respondent, by letter dated 21.12.2010, had requested
the Superintending Engineer to constitute a Dispute Adjudication Board for
resolution of disputes, some of which were enclosed to that letter. The
Superintending Engineer, by proceedings, dated 13.05.2011, had constituted
the 2nd D.A.B. Thereafter, the claims of the 1st respondent were considered by
the 2nd D.A.B. which gave it‘s decision on 09.01.2012. The parties here, were
1st respondent, as claimant, and the ―Irrigation and Command Area
Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh, represented by Superintending
Engineer, Pulichintala Project, Jaggaiahpeta, as respondent. The notice of
dissatisfaction, with this decision, was issued on 03.02.2012. The notice,
signed by the Superintending Engineer, was issued by the ―Irrigation and CAD
Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh‖.
17.
The claim statement filed before the Arbitral Tribunal describes
the respondent as the Superintending Engineer, Pulichinthala Project Circle.
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
After the award was passed, the appellant had filed A.O.P.No.23 of 2015
before the Principal District Judge, Krishna District. In this application, the
applicant was described as ‗The Government of Andhra Pradesh‘ represented
by the Superintending Engineer. The same description continues in the
present appeal also. In view of the above facts, the employer, in the present
case, applying clause 1.5 of the general conditions of contract, would be the
Superintending Engineer. The proceedings before the Second Dispute
Adjudication Board as well as the Arbitral Tribunal were against the
Superintending Engineer, who is described as the ‗Employer‘ in the contract.
Thereafter, the Government of Andhra Pradesh challenged the award, under
Section 34 of the Act. In view of the objections, raised by the learned
Advocate General, to the maintainability of the appeal, it would have to be
seen whether the application moved under Section 34 of the Act, before the
Principal District Judge, Krishna District and the subsequent appeal, before
this Court, under Section 37 of the Act are maintainable.
18.
and
In Shyamala Reddy, Pavitranagar, Musherabad, Hyderabad
Others.,
vs.
M/s.
Hindustan
Petroleum
Corporation
Ltd.,
Secunderabad and Others.5 A writ petition was filed against the Government
of Andhra Pradesh, among others, before the erstwhile High Court of Andhra
Pradesh. This writ petition was disposed of by a learned single judge. An
appeal was filed against this order. At that stage, the Division Bench hearing
the appeal held that, by virtue of Article 300 and Rule 24 of the Writ
2015 (4) ALD 380
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
proceeding rules, read with Section 79 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908, the
order had been passed against a non-existent party and would be a nullity.
However, the Division bench held that, the defect was curable, at the primary
forum and not at the appellate stage and remanded the matter, back to the
learned single judge, for rectification of the defect. The relevant extract is:
7. Moreover, Section 79 of the C.P.C., also mandated before the
Constitution came into force, the same way. The Court cannot
change it. But, we are in agreement with His Lordship that it is a
curable defect. But the stage of curing in our view is time bound
viz., before final disposal. Had this matter been pending before His
Lordship, then we would have permitted the writ petitioner to apply
for amendment. After the matter is disposed of finally with defect, it
cannot be cured at all. Here, final order has been passed. This
order, in our view, has been passed on an incompetent
proceeding. Therefore, the order is a nullity because the same has
been passed as against a non-existent party. Hence, we set aside
this judgment and on that ground alone, we restore the writ petition
for fresh hearing enabling to remove the defect. In the event, the
1st respondent-writ petitioner takes suitable steps for amendment
of the cause title in accordance with the provision of Article 300 of
the Constitution read with Section 79 of the C.P.C., and the Writ
Rules of this Court within seven days from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order, the Honble trial Judge shall decide the matter
afresh in accordance with law, uninfluenced and without being
swayed by earlier decision and observations. The Honble trial
Judge shall decide the matter in accordance with law within a
period of three months from the date of production of this order.
19.
In General Manager, Central Organization for Railway
Electrification, Allahabad and Others., vs. Y. Parthasarathy and
Another6., the respondents, in the Appeal before the erstwhile High Court of
Andhra Pradesh, had initiated arbitral proceedings against the appellants, by
way of an application, under section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation
Act,1996. This application was allowed and a learned arbitrator was
2016 (1) ALD 185
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
appointed. An appeal filed against this order of appointment was dismissed by
the Hon‘ble Supreme Court. Thereafter, the learned arbitrator, appointed by
the Hon‘ble High Court had passed an award, in favor of the respondents.
Two separate petitions, under section 34 of the Act, were filed by the
appellants. These were disposed of with a modification of the Award. In the
appeals, the appellants contended that the appointment of the learned
arbitrator itself was invalid as the Union of India was not impleaded as a party,
in the application filed under section 11 of the Act. The Division Bench held
that, in suits/proceedings against the Central Government, where it relates to
Railways, the Union of India must be named as a party. The Division Bench
noticed that only the General Manager, railway electrification and the Chief
Project Manager, railway electrification were party to the application, under
section 11 and held that the order appointing the learned arbitrator was not
binding on the Union of India and consequently all the arbitral proceedings
would have to be treated as invalid. The contention that the said issue cannot
be gone into as the Hon‘ble Supreme court had already confirmed the order of
the Hon‘ble High Court, appointing the learned arbitrator, was brushed aside.
20.
The Division Bench, in General Manager, Central Organization
for Railway Electrification, Allahabad and Others., vs. Y. Parthasarathy
and Another had also referred to the Judgments of the Hon‘ble Supreme
Court in Ranjit Mal vas Northern Railway.,7 and The State of Punjab vs
(1977) 1 SCC 484:AIR 1977 SC 1701
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
Okara Grain Buyers Syndicate Limited8. A reading of these two judgments
raise certain significant issues. In Ranjit Mal’s case, an appeal filed against
the removal of an employee of northern railway was rejected by the General
Manager. This rejection was challenged before the Hon‘ble High Court of
Rajasthan. The Writ Petition was rejected on the ground that the Union of
India was not impleaded and the same was affirmed by the Division Bench.
21.
The Hon‘ble Supreme Court, in the appeal filed against the
judgment of the Division Bench had held that the appellant was a servant of
the Union and any order of the Court would have to be enforced against the
Union. The Hon‘ble Supreme Court further held that any order of setting aside
the removal of an employee of the Union would fasten the liability on the
Union and not any other employee of the union including the General
Manager or any other authority in the railway administration. On those
grounds, the Hon‘ble Supreme Court had held that the view of the High Court
that the Union of India was a necessary party was correct.
22.
The State of Punjab vs Okara Grain Buyers Syndicate
Limited., came up before a Constitution Bench of the Hon‘ble Supreme Court.
The issue before the Hon‘ble Supreme Court was whether certain claims
could be enforced against the State of Punjab under the provisions of Section
13 of the Displaced Persons (Debts Adjustment Act), 1951. A contention was
raised that Section 13, which permitted recovery of debts from any person,
AIR 1964 SC 669
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
would not apply to the State of Punjab as the State of Punjab cannot be
described as a person and the claims, raised against the government, would
not amount to a debt. The second contention may not be relevant for the
present case. The Constitution Bench after referring to Article 300 of the
Constitution had held as follows:
21. The learned Advocate-General submitted to us an elaborate and
erudite argument as to whether the State was a corporation in any
sense, the conclusion which he desired us to draw being that though
the State was a body politic, it had not the characteristics of a
corporation. In this connection he referred us to various writers on
Public International Law and on Political Science and to certain
decisions of the American courts. We do not, however, feel called upon
to examine these submissions and pronounce upon their correctness
in view of the conclusion we have reached on a construction of the
provisions of the Act. We would, however, make two observations : (1)
that the mere fact that certain artificial entities like corporations are
brought within the scope of the Act, would not by itself rebut the
presumptive rule of construction that the State is not bound by a
statute unless it is brought within its scope expressly or by necessary
implication, (2) it would not be correct to say that the State is not a
constitutional or even juristic entity for the reason that it does not
partake the characteristics of or satisfy in whole, the definition of a
corporation. The State is an organised political institution which has
several of the attributes of a corporation. Under Article 300 of the
Constitution, the Government of the Union and the Government of a
State are enabled to sue and be sued in the name of Union of India
and of the Government of the State, as the case may be. It would not,
therefore be improper to speak of the Union and the State as
constitutional entities which have attributes defined by the Constitution.
23.
In view of the above observations of the Hon‘ble Supreme Court,
the view of the erstwhile High court of Andhra Pradesh, in Shyamala Reddy,
Pavitranagar, Musherabad, Hyderabad and Others., vs. M/s. Hindustan
Petroleum Corporation Ltd., Secunderabad and Others,9
that the
Government of Andhra Pradesh is a non existent entity is not correct and the
same would have to treated as a judgment, which is per incuriam, to that
2015 (4) ALD 380
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
extent, as the above judgment of the Hon‘ble Supreme Court was not placed
before the Hon‘ble high Court.
24.
In Chief Conservator of Forests, Government of Andhra
Pradesh vs. Collector and Others10., the Hon‘ble Supreme Court had an
occasion, to go into the issue of whether the writ petitions, as well as the
subsequent proceedings before the High Court as well as the Hon‘ble
Supreme Court, were maintainable if such a Writ Petition was filed by the
Chief Conservator of Forest and not the State of Andhra Pradesh. The
Hon‘ble Supreme Court after considering Article 300 of the Constitution as
well as Section 79 of C.P.C, had held as follows:
8. From a perusal of the provision, extracted above, it is evident
that the Government of India as also the Government of a State
may sue or be sued by the name of the Union of India or by the
name of the State respectively, subject, of course, to any
provisions which may be made by an Act of parliament or of the
legislature of such State by virtue of powers conferred by the
Constitution.
12. It needs to be noted here that a legal entity – a natural person
or an artificial person - can sue or be sued in his/its own name in a
court of law or a tribunal. It is not merely a procedural formality but
is essentially a matter of substance and considerable significance.
That is why there are special provisions in the Constitution and the
Code of Civil Procedure as to how the Central Government or the
Government of a State may sue or be sued. So also there are
special provisions in regard to other juristic persons specifying as
to how they can sue or be sued. In giving description of a party it
will be useful to remember the distinction between misdescription
(2003) 3 SCC 472
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
or misnomer of a party and misjoinder or non-joinder of a party
suing or being sued. In the case of misdescription of a party, the
court may at any stage of the suit/proceedings permit correction of
the cause-title so that the party before the court is correctly
described; however, a misdescription of a party will not be fatal to
the maintainability of the suit/proceedings. Though Rule 9 of Order
1 CPC mandates that no suit shall be defeated by reason of the
misjoinder or non-joinder of parties, it is important to notice that the
proviso thereto clarifies that nothing in that Rule shall apply to nonjoinder of a necessary party. Therefore, care must be taken to
ensure that the necessary party is before the court, be it a plaintiff
or a defendant, otherwise, the suit or the proceedings will have to
fail. Rule 10 of Order 1 CPC provides remedy when a suit is filed
in the name of the wrong plaintiff and empowers the court to strike
out any party improperly joined or to implead a necessary party at
any stage of the proceedings.
13. The question that needs to be addressed is, whether the Chief
Conservator of Forests as the appellant-petitioner in the writ
petition/appeal is a mere misdescription for the State of Andhra
Pradesh or whether it is a case of non-joinder of the State of
Andhra Pradesh – a necessary party. In a lis dealing with the
property of a State, there can be no dispute that the State is the
necessary party and should be impleaded as provided in Article
300 of the Constitution and Section 79 CPC viz., in the name of
the State/Union of India, as the case may be, lest the suit will be
bad for non-joinder of the necessary party. Every post in the
hierarchy of the posts in the government set-up, form the lowest to
the highest, is not recognized as a juristic person nor can be State
be treated as represented when a suit/proceeding is in the name
of such offices/posts or the officers holding such posts, therefore,
in the absence of the State in the array of parties, the cause will be
defeated for non-joinder of a necessary party to the lis, in any
court or tribunal. We make it clear that this principle does not apply
to a case where an official of the Government acts as a statutory
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
authority and sues or pursues further proceeding in its name
because in that event, it will not be a suit or proceeding for or on
behalf of a State/Union of India but by the statutory authority as
such.
16. Now, reverting to the facts of the case on hand, we are of the
view that after the said statutory order of the Commissioner of
Survey, Settlement and Land Records, the matter should have
rested there. We have, therefore, no hesitation in coming to the
conclusion that it was not only inappropriate but also illegal for the
Chief Conservator of Forests, though he might have done so in all
good faith, to have questioned the order of the Commissioner of
Survey, Settlement and Land Records before the High Court of
Andhra Pradesh in Writ Petition (C) NO.3414 of 1982. The Chief
Conservator of Forests as the petitioner can neither be treated as
the State of Andhra Pradesh nor can it be a case of misdescription
of the State of Andhra Pradesh. The fact is that the State of
Andhra Pradesh was not the petitioner. Therefore, the writ petition
was not maintainable in law. The High Court, had it deemed fit so
to do, would have added the State of Andhra Pradesh as a party;
however, it proceeded, in our view erroneously, as if the State of
Andhra Pradesh was the petitioner which, as a matter of fact, was
not the case and could not have been treated as such. As the writ
petition itself was not maintainable, it follows as a corollary that the
appeal by the Chief Conservator of Forests is also not
maintainable. We are unable to accept the contention of Ms
Amareswari that merely because the officer concerned had
obtained the permission of the Government to file an appeal,
which is not placed before us, the writ petition and the appeal
should be treated as an appeal by the Government of Andhra
Pradesh. The permission granted to the authority concerned might
be a permission to file an appeal which cannot reasonably be
construed as authorization to file the appeal in his own name,
contrary to law. It would only be a permission to file the appeal in
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
the name of the State of Andhra Pradesh in accordance with the
provisions of the Constitution and CPC. We may also record that
in spite of the pattedars taking objection to that effect at the
earliest, no steps were taken to substitute or implead the State of
Andhra Pradesh in the writ petition in the High Court or in the
appeal in this Court.
25.
It would now be appropriate to consider Article 300, of the
Constitution, on the basis of the aforesaid judgments and the observations
therein. Article 300 of the Constitution of India reads as follows:
300. Suits and proceedings.—
(1) The Government of India may sue or be sued by the
name of the Union of India and the Government of a State
may sue or be sued by the name of the State and may,
subject to any provisions which may be made by Act of
Parliament or of the Legislature of such State enacted by
virtue of powers conferred by this Constitution, sue or be
sued in relation to their respective affairs in the like cases as
the Dominion of India and the corresponding Provinces or
the corresponding Indian States might have sued or been
sued if this Constitution had not been enacted.
(2) If at the commencement of this Constitution—
(a) any legal proceedings are pending to which the Dominion
of India is a party, the Union of India shall be deemed to be
substituted for the Dominion in those proceedings; and
(b) any legal proceedings are pending to which a Province or
an Indian State is a party, the corresponding State shall be
deemed to be substituted for the Province or the Indian State
in those proceedings.
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
26.
This Article, in the light of the above judgments, would have to be
understood to mean that ―the Government of Andhra Pradesh‖ while being
sued or suing, should be described as the ―State of Andhra Pradesh‖. Put
another way, the party to the litigation is actually the Government of Andhra
Pradesh but the said Government of State is to be described as the State of
Andhra Pradesh. Any technical defect, of not naming the appropriate party, in
a case where an employee of the State is arrayed as a party instead of the
State, can be corrected at the primary level and for such matters can be
remanded to the primary level. Further, it is only a case of mis-description
when the party is described as the Government of Andhra Pradesh instead of
―the State of Andhra Pradesh‖. The same can be corrected within the same
proceeding. Where a Statutory authority is a party to the proceedings, there
would be no need, in view of the judgment of the Hon‘ble Supreme Court, in
Chief Conservator of Forests, Government of Andhra Pradesh vs.
Collector and Others11, to implead the State.
27.
In the present case, this Court after completing the hearing in the
matter, had reopened the case for further hearing and pointed out these
aspects to both sides. Sri Yathindra Dev. D, the learned Government Pleader,
in the office of the Learned Advocate General, merely reiterated his
contentions that the proceedings itself would have to lapse. It would be
necessary for the Government of Andhra Pradesh to amend it‘s description to
(2003) 3 SCC 472
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
―The State of Andhra Pradesh‖. No such steps have been taken. The written
submissions, filed from the office of the learned Advocate General, also did
not indicate any intention to amend the cause title or to implead the State.
The Hon‘ble Supreme Court, in paragraph No.16, in Chief
28.
Conservator of Forests, Government of Andhra Pradesh vs. Collector
and Others12., had held that the refusal of the government/appellant to
implead the State of Andhra Pradesh, despite such an issue being raised,
would
be fatal to the appeal. Since no steps were taken to correct the mis-
description of parties, it would have to be held that neither the petition before
the trial Court, under Section 34 of the Act, nor the present appeal, before this
Court, under Section 37 of the Act, are maintainable and this appeal has to be
dismissed, on this short ground.
29.
Sri B. Adinarayana Rao had contended that, in view of the
judgment of the Hon‘ble Supreme court, in Union of India vs. Susaka
Private Limited and Ors13, this issue cannot be raised at this stage. This
Court is not going into that question. Even if such an issue can not be raised,
regarding the maintainability of the Arbitral proceedings, the issue regarding
the maintainability of the application before the trial court and this appeal
would remain.
30.
The learned Advocate General, had contended that the primary
defect in the proceedings before the Arbitral Tribunal requires the award to be
(2003) 3 SCC 472
(2018) 2 SCC 182 (paras 26 to 29)
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
set aside. This contention can be considered by this Court only when there is
a properly constituted appeal before this Court. As there is no properly
constituted appeal before this Court, this contention cannot be considered.
31.
Accordingly, this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is dismissed. In view
of the aforesaid order of dismissal, this Court is not going into any of the other
issues raised in the appeal inasmuch as the appeal is being dismissed on the
ground of maintainability.
32.
C.R.P. No. 6787 of 2018 had been filed against the steps being
taken by the 1st respondent, in E.P. No. 420 of 2017, for recovery of the
amounts due to the 1st respondent, under the Award of the Arbitral Tribunal.
33.
The primary ground raised in this Civil Revision Petition is that the
judgment debtor is described as the Government of Andhra Pradesh and not
the State of Andhra Pradesh. In view of the above observations of this Court,
the said irregularity can be corrected, before the executing court itself. The
further contentions relating to the procedure adopted by the executing court
does not require any interference by this Court. Accordingly, the Civil Revision
Petition is dismissed.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand
closed. There shall be no order as to costs.
_______________________________
R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO, J
____________________
T.C.D. SEKHAR, J
RJS
RRR,J& TCDS,J
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.67878 of 2018
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE R. RAGHUNANDAN RAO
&
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE T.C.D.SEKHAR
CMA.No.1141 of 2018 & CRP.No.6787 of 2018
(per Hon‘ble Sri Justice R.Raghunandan Rao)
06.03.2026
RJS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review