Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 401 of 2021
Date of Decision: 14.03.2024
The Garikhana Masjid Committee
Represented by its Secretary
Garikhana, Lumdiengjri, Shillong,
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya
… Petitioner
–Versus–
1. The State of Meghalaya represented by the Commissioner and
Secretary Education, Shillong.
2. The Directorate of School Education and Literacy, Meghalaya,
Shillong.
3. The Sub- Divisional School Education Officer, Shillong.
4. The School Managing Committee Madrassa Hemayatul Islam, L.P.
School, Shillong
Represented by its President/Secretary
… Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. T.T. Diengdoh, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA (For R 1-3)
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv. (For R 4)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
An order dated 20.08.2021 issued by the I/C Sub-Divisional
School Education Officer, Shillong whereby the Managing Committee of
the Madrasa Hemayatul Islam L.P School, Shillong was approved for a
period of three years w.e.f. 20.08.2021 to 19.08.2024 is under challenged
in this writ petition filed by the petitioner/Committee along with prayer
for approval of an alternate list of Managing Committee members of the
said L.P. School, which list has been forwarded by the petitioner/
Committee to the said Sub-Divisional School Education Officer, Shillong.
2.
Heard Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, learned counsel for the petitioner who
has submitted that the petitioner/Committee was set up under the Societies
Act, 1860 and duly registered on 26.10.2015 with registration number
being No. E.16/5/2015/166 has decided to set up an educational institution
at Garikhana, Shillong on its land and accordingly, the Madrasa
Hemayatul Islam Lower Primary School was established. The same was
later upgraded to upper primary school.
3.
On the said school being recognized by the Government and
coming under the Deficit Grant-In-Aid Scheme, the Managing Committee
of the school was constituted by the general body of the
petitioner/Committee with the same being approved by the Government
as per the relevant rules and regulations.
4.
The learned counsel went on to further submit that sometime in
the year 2017, a group of vested interest surreptitiously formed a
Managing Committee of the school without the knowledge and consent of
the petitioner/Committee. The said constitution of the said Managing
Committee was, however, not given effect to by the respondent No. 3
herein which prompted the Secretary of such Managing Committee to
approach this Court with a petition being WP(C) No. 115 of 2018. This
Court then vide order dated 16.05.2018 had directed the respondent No. 3
to look into the matter and to take necessary action.
5.
On so being directed, the respondent No. 3 enquired into the
matter and came to a finding that the petitioner/Committee is the
sponsoring body of the school. This finding was informed to the ExSecretary, Madrasa Hemayatul Islam Upper Primary School vide
communication dated 30.05.201.The Managing Committee proposed by
the petitioner/Committee was duly approved for a period of three years
w.e.f. 10.11.2018 to 10.11.2021.
6.
It is also the submission of the learned counsel that in course of
its functioning, the Managing Committee, the tenure of which will expire
only on 10.11.2021 was suddenly cut short by three months, with the
respondent No. 3 constituting a new Managing Committee on 20.08.2021
without the knowledge and consultation of the petitioner/Committee.
7.
The petitioner/Committee on coming to know of the constitution
of the said illegal Managing Committee had, on receipt of information
through the Right to Information (RTI) query, petitioned the respondent
No. 3 to put on hold the said newly constituted managing committee and
instead to re-constitute the same with the one proposed by the
petitioner/Committee, however, this request went unheeded, even when
the same request was made to the Commissioner and Secretary, Education
Department and also to the Education Minister of the State Government.
Hence this petition.
8.
The
learned
counsel
has
maintained
that
the
petitioner/Committee is the sponsoring Committee and as such is entitled
to propose the list of Managing Committee members to the relevant
authorities for approval. In this regard, reference is made to the
communication No. SDSEO/GR-2/MC/2018 dated 30.05.2018 issued by
the Sub-Divisional School Education, Shillong to the District School
Education Officer, East Khasi Hills District wherein the subject matter is
with regard to the claim and counter claim by the parties in respect of the
management of the Madrasa Hemayatul Islam U.P. School, Shillong and
the matter having been inquired into, the Enquiry Officer that is, the SubDivisional School Education, Shillong came to the conclusion that the
Garikhana Masjid Committee is the sponsoring body of the said Madrasa
Hemayatul Islam U.P. School, Shillong.
9.
In support of his case the learned counsel for the petitioner has
cited the case of:
i.
Rai Bahadur Anup Chand Hindi High School, Shillong & anr.
v. State of Meghalaya & Ors., 2005 SCC Online Gau 101,
para 4, 5, 6, 12, 13 and 14;
ii. Arya Samaj & Anr. v. State of Meghalaya & Ors., 2021 SCC
Online Megh 34, para 4, 5, 7 and 8.
10.
Finally, the learned counsel has submitted that on the basis of the
above submission and contention, this Court may be pleased to set aside
and quash the impugned order dated 20.08.2021 (Annexure-10 to this
petition) and also to direct the concerned authority to accord approval to
the list of members of the Managing Committee of the Madrasa
Hemayatul Islam L.P. School, Shillong forwarded to the respondent No.
3 vide letter dated 01.11.2021 (Annexure-9).
11.
Per contra, Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, learned GA appearing for the
respondents No. 1, 2 and 3 respectively, while opposing the submission
made by the learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the claim
of the petitioner/Committee that the School Managing Committee
formed by the respondent No. 4 without consulting it should not be
allowed, the same is made without any basis or evidence on record.
12.
It is also submitted that the petitioner/Committee has no locus
standi to file this instant writ petition since any constitution or
reconstitution of the Managing Committee of the said Madrasa Hemayatul
Islam L.P. School does not require any approval from the petitioner’s
Committee. The claim of the petitioner/Committee that it is the sponsoring
body of the said school is also only a mere averment and a disputed
question of fact.
13.
Again, the learned GA has submitted that the reliance of the
petitioner/Committee
on
the
communication
dated
30.05.2018
(Annexure-3) to say that the relevant authority has come to the conclusion
that the petitioner/Committee is the sponsoring body of the Madrasa
Hemayatul Islam L.P. School in incorrect inasmuch as the said report
refers to the management of the Madrasa Hemayatul Islam U.P. School
and not the L.P. School since the management of the U.P. School and the
L.P. School are separate and distinct from each other.
14.
As to the approval of the new Managing Committee vide order
dated 20.08.2021 (Annexure-10), it is the submission of the learned GA
that there is no illegality in the constitution of the Managing Committee
of the Madrasa Hemayatul Islam L.P. School even if the same was
constituted prior to the expiry of the previous Committee since it is the
Secretary of the previous Committee who had requested for constitution
of the new Committee for the various reasons stated in the letter dated
09.08.2021 (Annexue-1 to the counter affidavit of respondent No. 2). In
this context, the proposal of the petitioner/Committee dated 01.11.2021
for formation of a new Managing Committee of the said L.P. School
cannot be accepted in any case since the same has not been done so in
accordance with the Right to Education Act, 2009 and the related rules
thereto.
15.
It is, therefore, prayed that this petition is devoid of merit and the
same be accordingly dismissed.
16.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Sr. counsel for the respondent No.
4/Managing Committee has at the outset submitted that the present
Managing Committee came about basically for the reason that there was
non-cooperation and disinclination of most of the members of the previous
Managing Committee, who in spite of being duly notified of the meetings
held on several dates, failed to attend the same. Therefore, the
stakeholders, including the parents/guardians and teachers, on being duly
notified vide notice dated 15.07.2021, has accordingly constituted the new
Managing Committee on 03.08.2021. Due procedure and adherence to
relevant rules was followed which prompted the respondent No. 3 to
accord approval of the new Managing Committee vide order dated
20.08.2021.
17.
Coming to the competency of the petitioner/Committee to prefer
this instant writ petition, the learned Sr. counsel has submitted that the
present Assam-type structure of the school in question was constructed in
the year 1953-54 by the Managing Committee under the presidentship of
(L) Shiekh Md. Ali Jan and Secretary, (L) Shiekh Md. Shafi at a cost of ₹
8000/- (rupees eight thousand) only being donated by members of the
Muslim community. The School Managing Committee thus became the
sole caretaker of the said property independent of interference by any
outside body including the petitioner/Committee.
18.
The claim of the petitioner/Committee that it is the sponsoring
body of the said school is without any basis and authority, coupled with
the fact that the petitioner/Committee has not even contributed any fund
towards the running of the school, not even for the cost of books and
uniforms of the students which cost was borne exclusively by the
Managing Committee, further submits the learned Sr. counsel.
19.
It is also the submission of the learned Sr. counsel that the
proposed list of members of the new Managing Committee of the school
by the petitioner/Committee, dated 01.11.2021(Annexure-9 of the
petition) is incompetent, firstly, since there was no participation of any of
the stakeholders like parents, teachers and guardians. Secondly, this
incompetency of the petitioner/Committee is apparent as a look at the
Constitution of the petitioner/Committee would reveal that it is strictly a
religious body and is not empowered to venture into secular affairs,
Hence, the claim that it is the sponsoring body of the school with power
to approve the formation of the Managing Committee of the school is not
only against the law but even against the provisions of its own
constitution.
20.
This Court on consideration of the rival claims of the parties,
facts of the case which requires no repetition as the same have been
enumerated herein above, the questions which are required to be answered
are as follows:
i. Whether the petitioner/Committee is the sponsoring body
of
the
Madrasa
Hemayatul
Islam
L.P.
School,
Lumdiengjri, Shillong?
ii. Whether it is mandatory for the constitution of the School
Managing Committee to be firstly approved and proposed
by the sponsoring body?
21.
It is the stand of the petitioner/Committee that in order to achieve
its object to establish a school, in the year 1953 the Madrasa Hemayatul
Islam L.P. School was set up on the land owned and possessed by the
petition/Committee. On the school having received its recognition from
the Education Department, Government of Meghalaya under the Deficit
Grant-in-Aid Scheme, the Managing Committee of the school was also
constituted by the General Body of the petitioner/Committee duly
approved by the competent authority.
22.
This assertion by the petitioner/Committee was refuted by the
respondents when the respondent No. 4 has submitted that the said school
was set up in an Assam-type structure constructed by the then Managing
Committee in the year 1953-54, albeit on the land given to the school by
the then Garikhana Masjid Committee, free of rent and free of cost without
any interference in the day-to-day affairs of the school.
23.
The petitioner/Committee has laid stress on the fact that on the
basis of the enquiry conducted by the Sub-Divisional School Education
Officer, Shillong pursuant to order dated 16.05.2018 passed by this Court
in WP(C) No. 115 of 2018, wherein vide communication dated
30.05.2018, copy of which was issued upon the Secretary of the
petitioner/Committee, the Enquiry Officer has come to a finding that the
petitioner/Committee is the sponsoring body as far as reconstitution of the
Managing Committee of the Madrasa Hemayatul Islam U.P. School,
Lumdiengjri, Shillong.
24.
This was refuted by the respondent No. 4 who has referred to the
Enquiry Report on Madrasa Hemayatul Islam L.P. and U.P. School filed
by Shri. T.S. Lyngdoh, Sub-Inspector of Schools, Shillong and Shri. J.A.
Marwein, Sub-Inspector of Schools, Shillong, which report is annexed as
Annexure-I in the counter affidavit dated 09.05.2022 filed by the said
respondent No. 4 wherein in the said report it has been noted that there is
no record to reveal that the school has a “sponsoring body” and also that
the proposals for reconstitution of the Managing Committee of the School
was usually done so on a proposal made by the outgoing Managing
Committee as per the provision of Rule 4 of Section 11 of the Assam
Education Department Rules adopted by the Meghalaya.
25.
As contended by the respondent No. 4, that nothing in the
constitution of the petitioner/Committee is found to establish the claim
that it is the sponsoring body of the said educational institution, namely,
the Madrasa Hemayatul Islam School, this Court on perusal of the contents
of the constitution of the petitioner/Committee which was brought on
record by the petitioner/Committee by way of additional affidavit, has not
been able to find any reference made, particularly in the aims and
objectives of the Committee as regard the institution and management of
educational institutions, though one of the objectives is to impart religious
education. There being no specific or direct reference to set up schools and
educational institutions, the petitioner/Committee cannot come at this
point of time to claim that it is the sponsoring body of the said school in
question.
26.
In the case of Arya Samaj & Anr. v. State of Meghalaya & Anr.,
(2000) 3 GLT 656, this Court (as it then was) while dealing with the
subject of control over the School Managing Committee by the Arya
Samaj has come to the conclusion that the constitution of the School
Managing Committee is to be done so only in terms of the Memorandum
of Association of the Arya Samaj, wherein the objectives incorporated in
Article 3 of the Memorandum, inter alia, include establishment of schools
and educational institutions. Para 13 of the same being relevant to the case
herein, the same is reproduced as follows:
“13. Article 38 of the Memorandum of Association vests some
restricted powers with the State authorities. It reads as follows:"38. The President of Arya Samaj shall be the President of
the Managing Committee or ad-hoc Committees if
constituted by the Government of all the educational
institutions under the control supervision of the Arya Samaj
Shillong and functioning under the Arya Samaj Shillong."
The provisions of Article 38 clearly show that if the Managing
Committees or ad-hoc committees of the educational institutions
of the Arya Samaj are constituted by the Government, the
President of such committees shall have to be the President of
Arya Samaj only…”
27.
The above demonstrates the fact that for a body organisation such
as the petitioner/Committee herein to be reckoned as a sponsoring body of
an educational institution/school, the same has to be specifically
mentioned in its constitution which is not the case herein. However, as has
been admitted by the respondent No. 4, the claim of the
petitioner/Committee that it is the sponsoring body of the school and
hence is the authority to propose the constitution of the Managing
Committee of the school is an issue of disputed facts which cannot be
raised herein, has to be considered by this Court taking into account the
fact that this issue has to be settled once and for all, although before a
proper forum, more particularly, the civil court of competent jurisdiction.
28.
The answer to the first issue would be that the matter is left to be
decided by a competent court as disputed issues of facts have been raised
as regard the claim of the petitioner/Committee that it is the sponsoring
body of the said school in question.
29.
As to the next issue, since relevant rules have been prescribed as
far as the manner and mode of proposal and approval of the School
Managing Committee is concerned, that is, that it is the for Secretary of
the outgoing Managing Committee to send the proposal to the relevant
authorities in the Education Department of the Government for approval,
therefore, since there is nothing in the law or rules to say that for the
approval of the list of Managing Committee members, the same has to be
proposed and forwarded through or by the sponsoring body, the second
issue has, therefore, to be answered in the negative.
30.
The case of Rai Bahadur Anup Chand Hindi High School,
Shillong(supra) relied upon by the petitioner/Committee with due respect,
has no relevance to the issues raised in this petition, inasmuch as there are
no pleadings as far as the issue of whether the school in question is a
minority school or not. As to the question whether the list proposed by the
petitioner/Committee has to be approved by the relevant authorities, since
the issue of whether the petitioner/Committee is the sponsoring body of
the said school is left to be decided later in a proper forum, the judgment
relied upon will also not help the petitioner/Committee.
31.
In
the
case
of
Arya
Samaj(supra)
cited
by
the
petitioner/Committee, this Court having noticed the fact that the term of
the Managing Committee in question would soon expire in about four
months’ time has decided not to interfere with the constitution of the same
at that point of time and has left the issue agitated before it to be considered
by the relevant authority as and when the reconstitution of the new
Managing Committee occur.
32.
Under similar circumstances apparent in this instant case,
wherein the term of the Managing Committee under scrutiny would expire
in the month of August, 2024, this Court too is not inclined to interfere
with the term of such Managing Committee and would leave the issue as
regard the claim of the petitioner/Committee that it is the sponsoring body
at the said school to be decided by a competent authority as has been
indicated hereinabove as and when the same comes up for consideration.
33.
Consequently, the impugned order dated 20.08.2021 at
Annexure-10 of this petition is not interfered with at this juncture.
Resultantly, the proposed list dated 01.11.2021 (Annexure-9), submitted
by the petitioner/Committee shall not be taken into consideration by the
competent authority.
34.
In view of the above, this petition is disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
14.03.2024
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review