Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 22nd October, 2021
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P.(C) No.38 of 2019
:
Petitioner
The Gangtok Municipal Corporation
versus
:
Respondent
Union of India & Ors.
Application under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India
--------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Jorgay Namka and Mr. Simeon Subba, Advocates for the
Petitioner.
Ms. Sangita Pradhan, Assistant Solicitor General of India for
the Respondent No.1.
Mr. K.T. Tamang, Advocate for Respondents No.2 and 3.
-----------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The Petitioner being a Statutory Body established under
the Sikkim Municipalities Act, 2007, claims that the provisions of
the Employees‟ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act,
1952, (for short the “EPF & MP Act, 1952”) is not applicable in the
State of Sikkim as it was not enforced in compliance to the
provisions of Article 371F of the Constitution of India. It is also the
Petitioner‟s case that the provisions of the EPF & MP Act, 1952, is
not applicable to the Petitioner Corporation. In this circumstance,
the
impugned
Order,
dated
05.07.2019,
passed
by
the
Respondents is illegal and void, hence the prayers in the Petition
which inter alia are as follows;
„(a)
(b)
to hold that the provisions of the Central Act are not
applicable to the Petitioner; and
to hold that the provisions of the Employees‟ Provident
Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 is not
applicable to the Petitioner Corporation; and
W.P.(C) No.38 of 2019
The Gangtok Municipal Corporation vs. Union of India & Ors.
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
(g)
(h)
2.
to hold that the Petitioner is not the principal employer
of the Municipal wards Association/Committee/Samaj
which is a non-profit making NGO as decided by the
Respondents; and
to issue an appropriate writ in the nature of mandamus
or any other writ, order or direction holding that the
proceedings conducted by the Respondents is without
jurisdiction, bad and illegal; and/or
to issue an appropriate writ in the nature of mandamus
or certiorari or any other writ, order or direction
quashing the Order dated 05.07.2019 passed by the
Respondent;
and upon cause/s being shown and after hearing the
parties be pleased to make the rule absolute and/or
pass such other orders;
to pass any other direction/s, relief/s, order/s that may
be deemed fit and proper in the circumstances of this
case;
to allow the costs of the Writ Petition in favour of the
Petitioner.‟
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.2 and 3, while
challenging the Maintainability of the Petition contended that where
an alternative, efficacious remedy is available, the Writ Jurisdiction
of this Court cannot be invoked. That, it is settled law that Petitions
under Writ Jurisdiction are not to be entertained by the High Court
when an efficacious, alternative remedy is available, this being a
Rule of self-imposed limitation, although discretion lies with the
Court to permit a Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution,
despite existence of such a remedy. That, it is also a Rule of policy,
convenience and discretion rather than a Rule of law. Towards this
submission, strength was garnered from the ratio in Commissioner
of Income Tax and Others vs. Chhabil Dass Agarwal1. That, the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in United Bank of India vs. Satyawati Tondon & Others 2
propounded that the High Court overlooked the settled law that it
will ordinarily not entertain a Petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution if an effective remedy is available to the aggrieved
person and that this Rule applies with equal rigour in matters
(2014) 1 SCC 603
(2010) 8 SCC 110
W.P.(C) No.38 of 2019
The Gangtok Municipal Corporation vs. Union of India & Ors.
involving recovery of Taxes, Cess, Fees, other types of Public
Money and the dues of Banks and other Financial Institutions. That,
in the instant matter, Public Money is involved and the Petitioner
must necessarily exhaust the remedies available to it under the
Statute, for which the attention of this Court was drawn to the
provisions of Section 7I and Section 7L of the EPF & MP Act, 1952.
That, in these circumstances, as an efficacious remedy has been
provided by the Statute which has not been exhausted by the
Petitioner, the Writ Petition is not maintainable.
3.
Learned Assistant Solicitor General for the Respondent
No.1, for her part, relied on the submissions put forth by Learned
Counsel for the Respondents No.2 and 3 and had no further
submissions to make.
4.
Contesting the submissions of the Respondents No.2
and 3, Learned Counsel for the Petitioner, while relying on the ratio
of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in M/s. S.K. Nasiruddin Beedi Merchant
Ltd., vs. Central Provident Fund Commissioner and Another 3 and
on
State of H.P. and Others vs. Gujarat Ambuja Cement Ltd. and Another 4,
argued that the Respondents No.2 and 3 have assumed jurisdiction
when they did not possess any, as they were not entitled to issue
Orders such as the impugned one. That, the pivotal contentions of
the Petitioner are that the EPF & MP Act, 1952, is not applicable to
it and the Petitioner is not bound to pay the amount as ordered in
the impugned Order, as the concerned Employees are not that of
the Petitioner Corporation. Hence, the Petition is maintainable.
AIR 2001 SC 850
AIR 2005 SC 3936
W.P.(C) No.38 of 2019
The Gangtok Municipal Corporation vs. Union of India & Ors.
5.
I
have
carefully
heard
the
parties,
perused
the
averments and all documents on record.
6.(i)
At this juncture, it is relevant to notice that the
impugned Order, dated 05.07.2019, (Annexure P20), is one under
Section 7A of the EPF & MP Act, 1952, in respect of M/S Gangtok
Municipal Corporation, for the period April, 2012 to August, 2016
having Diary No.46/2016. In sum and substance, the Order
concludes inter alia as under;
“4. After having quantified the labour payment for a
particular project PF & Allied liability was calculated as to
be(sic) 25.61% of the total wages paid to the labours.
Accordingly
Evaded
Wages
paid
to
Contractors/Contractual employees engaged therein by
the contractors for each financial year have been
calculated.
……”
(ii)
Thereafter, necessary calculations have been made for
the Financial Year 2012-13, Financial Year 2013-14, Financial Year
2014-15 and Financial Year 2015-16. It was further ordered inter
alia as follows;
“And therefore having perused the available records,
submission made by the establishment representative,
report cum statement of dues and deposit filed by
departmental representative cum Area Enforcement
Officer, non-discovery of any counter evidence to the
submitted report/records and due application of mind, I,
Surjeet Kumar in exercise of power vested by(sic) me
under Section 7A of the Act determine the dues to the
tune of Rs 95,45,845 out of which Rs 85,68,430 has been
paid by the establishment and therefore the Balance dues
is Rs 9,77,415 which is quantified as assessed dues for the
inquiry period 04/2012 to 08/2016. The detail of dues and
payment
is
provided
on
next
page:……….……………………………………………………………………………………
Further, the time allowed for 15 days to make the
payment of dues as mentioned above will not absolve the
employer of his liability to pay Penal Interest and Penal
damages contemplated under Section 7Q and 14B of the
Act and the other actions as provided under Section 8 and
14 of the EPF & MP Act, 1952 that may be initiated against
the establishment where the payments are not made
within due date and the department shall be at liberty to
proceed against the establishment for non-submission of
statutory returns within the prescribed time schedule as
W.P.(C) No.38 of 2019
The Gangtok Municipal Corporation vs. Union of India & Ors.
per relevant provisions of the Act and the Schemes framed
there under.
……..……”
(iii)
Section 7I provides for Appeals to Tribunals and
Section 7L to Orders of Tribunal, which are extracted hereinbelow
for easy reference;
“7-I. Appeals to Tribunal.—(1) Any person
aggrieved by a notification issued by the Central
Government, or an order passed by the Central
Government or any authority, under the proviso to subsection (3), or sub-section (4) of section 1, or section
3, or sub-section (1) of section 7A, or section 7B
[except an order rejecting an application for review
referred to in sub-section (5) thereof], or section 7C, or
section 14B, may prefer an appeal to a Tribunal against
such notification or order.
(2) Every appeal under sub-section (1) shall be filed
in such form and manner, within such time and be
accompanied by such fees, as may be prescribed.
…………………………………………………………………………………………
7L. Orders of Tribunal.—(1) A Tribunal may, after
giving the parties to the appeal, an opportunity of being
heard, pass such orders thereon as it thinks fit,
confirming, modifying or annulling the order appealed
against or may refer the case back to the authority
which passed such order with such directions as the
Tribunal may think fit, for a fresh adjudication or order,
as the case may be, after taking additional evidence, if
necessary.
(2) A Tribunal may, at any time within five years
from the date of its order, with a view to rectifying any
mistake apparent from the record, amend any order
passed by it under sub-section (1) and shall make such
amendment in the order if the mistake is brought to its
notice by the parties to the appeal:
Provided that an amendment which has the effect of
enhancing the amount due from, or otherwise
increasing the liability of, the employer shall not be
made under this sub-section, unless the Tribunal has
given notice to him of its intention to do so and has
allowed him a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
(3) A Tribunal shall send a copy of every order
passed under this section to the parties to the appeal.
(4) Any order made by a Tribunal finally disposing
of an appeal shall not be questioned in any court of
law.”
7.
In light of the specific provisions of law and the
observations made in the ratiocinations referred to supra by
Learned Counsel for the Respondents No.2 and 3, in my considered
opinion, before invoking the Writ Jurisdiction of this Court, the
W.P.(C) No.38 of 2019
The Gangtok Municipal Corporation vs. Union of India & Ors.
Petitioner is to necessarily exhaust the remedy available to it under
the Statute.
8.
Writ Petition disposed of accordingly.
9.
No order as to costs.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
22.10.2021
ml
Approved for reporting : Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review