Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for orders : 24.07.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 01.10.2026
Date of uploading
: 01.10.2026
APHC010908952017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3606]
THURSDAY
THURSDAY, THE 1ST DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR
CHINTALAPUDI
C.R.P. Nos.6528 of 2017 & 1801 of 2018
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.6528 of 2017
Between:
1. THE
EXECUTIVE
TADEPALLIGUDEM
ENGINEER,
A.P.
HOUSING
BOARD,
...PETITIONER
AND
1. PRAYAGA SUBRAHMANYA PRABHAKARA CHIRANJEEVI RAO, S/O
LATE SEETHARAMAIAH, DOOR NO. 14
14-11-1,
1, PRAVAGAVARI
STREET, GUNUPUDI.
2. THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER SUBCOLLECTOR, NARSAPUR.
3. THE SBH GRUHAKALPA BRANCH NAMPALLY, HYDERABAD (2 AND
3 ARE NOT NECESSARY
ECESSARY PARTIES)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,praying that in the
circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein,the High Court may be
pleased toBeing aggrieved by the Order dated 04
04-10-2017
2017 passed in E.P. No.
96 of 2009 in L.A.O.P. No. 32 of 1997 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge,
Bhimavaram, the above-named Petitioner presents this Memorandum of Civil
Revision Petition under Section 115 of the C.P.C. for the following, among
other grounds
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(CRPMP 8371 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay of operation of the impugned Docket Order, dated 04- 10-2017,
passed by the Senior Civil Judge, Bhimavaram, in E.P. no. 96 of 2009 in
L.A.O.P. no. 32 of 1997, wherein of the attachment of the Bank Account of the
Petitioner made on 12-09-2017 was made absolute, pending disposal of the
above C.R.P. and pass such other order or orders as may be deemed fit and
proper in the circumstances of the case and in the interests of justice.
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
Vacate the stay granted on 26-12-2017 in CRP No. 6528 of 2017
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. D RANGANATHA KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. M V SURESH
The Court made the following:
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.1801 of 2018
Between:
1. THE
EXECUTIVE
TADEPALLIGUDEM
ENGINEER,
A.P.HOUSING
BOARD,
...PETITIONER
AND
1. PRAYAGA SUBRAHMANYAM PRABHAKARA CHIRANJEEVI RAO
AND ANOTHER, S/O. LATE SEETHARAMAIAH, D.NO.14-11-1,
PRAVAGAVARISTREET, GUNUPUDI.
2. THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER SUB COLLECTOR, NARSAPUR
(RESP R2 NOT NECESSARY)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, praying that in the
circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may be
pleased to setting aside the impugned Order,dated 12-09-2017 in
EP.No.96/2009 in LAOP.No.32 of 1997 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge,
Bhimavaram and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay of operation of the impugned order dated 12-9-2017 passed by the
Sr.Civil Judge, Bhimavaram in EP.No.96 of 2009 in LAOP.32/97 pending
disposal of the above CRP and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2018
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 72 days in filing the above CRP and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. D RANGANATHA KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. M V SURESH
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR
CHINTALAPUDI
C.R.P. Nos.6528 of 2017 & 1801 of 2018
COMMON ORDER:
The Civil Revision Petitions C.R.P.No. 6528 of 2017 and C.R.P.No.
1801 of 2018 are preferred against the orders dated 04.10.2017 and
12.09.2017 passed in E.P. No.96 of 2009 in L.A.O.P. No.32 of 1997 on the file
of the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Bhimavaram.
2.
Andhra Pradesh Housing Board (in short referred as APHB) is the
revision petitioner. Respondent No.1 is the Decree Holder (DHR) and the
respondent No.2 is the LAO (LAO).
3.
Initially, the APHB challenged only the order dated 04.10.2017. During
the pendency of C.R.P. No.6528 of 2017, since the APHB did not challenge
the order dated 12.09.2017, this court granted liberty to the APHB to challenge
the said order. Pursuant thereto, C.R.P. No.1801 of 2018 was preferred.
C.R.P. No.6528 of 2017
4.
The Andhra Pradesh Housing Board has preferred C.R.P. No.6528 of
2017 challenging the order dated 04.10.2017 passed in E.P. No.96 of 2009 in
L.A.O.P. No.32 of 1997, whereby the learned executing court made the
attachment absolute for Rs.76,00,000/-.
C.R.P. No.1801 of 2018
5.
The Andhra Pradesh Housing Board has preferred C.R.P. No.1801 of
2018 challenging the order dated 12.09.2017 passed in the same E.P.,
whereby the learned executing court allowed the E.P. and ordered attachment
under Order XXI Rule 52 CPC, determining the amount due at Rs.27,90,249/-.
6.
These two C.R.Ps. arise out of orders passed on different dates in the
same execution petition. Therefore, this Court is taking up both revisions
together and disposing of them by a common order.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the APHB, Sri D. Ranganath Kumar and
learned counsel for respondent No.1 Sri M.V. Suresh.
Facts of the Case:
8.
The APHB, Hyderabad, sent a requisition for acquisition of lands to an
extent of Ac.31-12 cents in R.S. Nos.257/2A, 259/1, etc., of Gunupudi Village,
Bhimavaram Mandal, West Godavari District, for construction of houses for the
general public. In the said lands, the land of respondent No.1 was also
included in the requisition, to an extent of Ac.0-42½ cents in Survey No.260/2.
A notification under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short,
"the Act") was issued on 10.11.1993, followed by a declaration under Section
6 of the Act vide notification dated 30.12.1993.
9.
Pursuant to the notification, the LAO, respondent No.2 herein,
conducted an enquiry and fixed the compensation at the rate of Rs.7,020/- per
cent, i.e., Rs.7,02,000/- per acre, for the disputed land of respondent No.1.
10.
The claimants, aggrieved by the award of compensation, sought a
reference under Section 18 of the Act to the Civil Court for enhancement of
compensation. Accordingly, the LAO referred the matter to the Reference
Court.
11.
The Reference Court, on appreciation of the material available on
record, concluded that the market value of the acquired land fixed by the LAO
was not just and proper and determined the market value of the acquired land
at the rate of Rs.25,000/- per cent, i.e., Rs.25,00,000/- per acre, and
accordingly awarded the same along with solatium at the rate of 30% on the
market value, additional market value at the rate of 12% on the market value,
and interest at the rate of 9% on the compensation amount from the date of
possession of the land for one year and further interest at the rate of 15% on
the compensation amount till the date of payment, vide order dated
30.10.2006.
12.
The LAO herein preferred L.A.A.S. No.193 of 2007 and the claimants
also preferred L.A.A.S.M.P. No.1595 of 2008 before this Court. This Court
dismissed the appeal/application filed by the LAO and the claimants and
confirmed the orders passed by the Reference Court.
13.
The said order was carried before the Hon’ble Apex Court by the
Andhra Pradesh Housing Board, with the LAO as Respondent No.2. Pending
the said challenge, the Hon’ble Apex Court passed the following interim order:
“This Court has heard the learned counsel for the APHB.
Having regard to the facts of the case, stay of execution
proceedings is granted on condition that the APHB deposits
the entire amount payable under the impugned judgment in
the executing court within two months from today. On deposit
of the amount, the respondents shall be entitled to withdraw
the same on furnishing security to the satisfaction of the
executing court.
List the matters after four weeks.”
14.
As per the aforesaid interim orders, the APHB deposited an amount of
Rs.54,22,814/-, and respondent No.1 withdrew the said amount. An amount of
Rs.2,94,840/- had previously said tohave been deposited by the APHB on
11.05.1997. Respondent No.1 raised objections about the amount deposited
by the APHB and contended that an additional amount is payable.
15.
According to Respondent No.1/DHR, after giving credit for the amount
of Rs.54,22,814/- deposited by the APHB, a sum of Rs.17,34,284/- remained
due. He further calculated interest on the principal amount of Rs.14,76,875/- at
the rate of 15% per annum from 02.11.2011 to 09.08.2016, amounting to
Rs.10,55,965/-. Thus, Respondent No.1/DHR claimed a total additional
amount of Rs.27,90,249/-.
Proceedings before the executing court:
16.
The APHB, the LAO and respondent No.1 filed their respective
calculation memos. Respondent No.1, in the E.P., originally claimed an
amount of Rs.73,95,451/-. Subsequently, in the calculation memo dated
09.08.2016, respondent No.1 claimed that a balance amount of Rs.27,90,249/was payable. The APHB disputed the said calculation and contended that the
amount already deposited was in excess of the amount actually payable.
17.
Respondent No.1 claimed the due amount, whereas the APHB
contended that the amount deposited by it was in excess of the amount
actually payable.
18.
Upon contest, the Executing court held that the calculation memo filed
by the Decree Holder (DHR) was not correct concerning the interest, while the
calculation memo filed by the Judgment Debtor (JDR) was also not in
accordance with the applicable directions. Thereafter, the executing court
arrived at the amount due and payable as follows:
Extracted from the order:
Value of claimant land Ac.0-42 ½ cents @ Rs.25,000/- per
cent.
30% Solatium on Rs.10,62,500/-
Rs.10,62,500-00
3,18,750-00
12% Addl. Market value on Rs.10,62,500/- from date of
notification U/s.4 (1) of L.A.Act, 30-12-1993 to date of award
30-9-1994 (i.e., 10 months 20 days) ........
95,625-00
Total :
14,76,875-00
Interest on Rs.14,76,875-00 from the date of taking
possession to the date of award i.e., 12-05-1982 to 10-111993 at 10% as per orders of the Honourable Supreme
Court of India (11 years 5 months 28 days)
16,97,584-00
Total :
31,74,459-00
Further interest on Rs.14,76,875/- from 11-11-1993 to 2-112011 @ 15% as per order of Honourable Supreme Court of
India (17 years 11 months 22 days)
Rs.39,82,639-00
Total :
71,57,098-00
Amount deposit in Senior Civil Judge Court, Bhimavaram on
02-11-2011.
54,22,814-00
Remaining amount due .............
17,34,284-00
Interest on Rs.14,76,875/- @ 15% p.a., from 02-11-2011 to
9-8-2016 i.e.,(4 years 9 months 5 days)
10,55,965-00
Remaining balance amount to be paid by JDR (L.A.O.)….
27,90,249-00
19.
The learned Judge, providing his reasoning, held that the amount due
and payable is Rs.27,90,249.
20.
Accordingly, he allowed the Execution Petition and ordered issuing
Order 21 Rule 52 of CPC for attachment of the account of JDR upon deposit
of process.
21.
However, upon deposit of process, the learned Judge issued a warrant
of attachment for Rs.76,00,000/- instead of Rs. 27,90,249/-.The same is
extracted hereunder.
“The plaintiff/D.H.R. having applied under Rule 52 of Order
21 of C.P.C., 1908, for an attachment of amount of the DR for
Rs. 76,0,000-00 (This amount relating to Gruhakalpa) on the file
of this court which was amount was elongs to the JDR by Name
1) The Land Acquisition Officer Sub-Collector, Naraspur, 2) The
Executive Engineer, A.P. Housing Board, Tadepalligudem, until
further orders of this court. Further request to without disbursing
the same amount until further orders of this court.
I request you with-hold the said amounts subject to Section
60 C.P.C and the further order of this Court.”
Submissions of Learned Counsels:
22.
SriD. Ranganath Kumar, learned counsel for the APHB argued that
pursuant to the directions of the Hon'ble Apex Court, APHB has already
deposited an amount of Rs.54,22,814/-. Subsequently, while disposing of the
appeals, the Hon’ble Apex Court granted interest at the rate of 10% on the
compensation amount for the period from 12.05.1982 to 10.11.1993 and
modified the order to that extent. However, the D.H.R. has erroneously applied
the old interest and then arrived at a higher calculation. The amount deposited
by the J.D.R. is correct and complies with the directions of the Hon'ble Apex
Court. Even though the J.D.R. has properly deposited the amount, the learned
Judge has ordered that an amount of Rs.27,90,249/- is due, without
appreciating the facts. He further argued that the learned Judge, though
arrived at the due amount of Rs.27,90,249/-, ordered the attachment of the
bank account of the APHB for Rs. 76,00, 000/- vide order dated 04.10.2017,
which is contrary to the findings recorded by the learned Judge.
23.
Learned counsel further submitted that the said order dated 04.10.2017
is challenged under C.R.P. No.6528 of 2017. In the said revision, upon his
contest, this Court passed interim orders confining the attachment to Rs.
27,90,249/-. Learned counsel has taken this Court to the summons of
attachment ordered by the executing court and the interim orders of this court.
Learned counsel submitted that the court erred in attaching an amount of Rs.
76,00,000/-, which is beyond its own observation.
24.
He further argued that the Executing court, after issuance of warrant of
attachment, on receiving the report of execution of warrant attaching the
amount of Rs. 76,00,000/-, recorded the same, made the order absolute and
closed the EP.
25.
Accordingly, the APHB has challenged the said order in the revision,
CRP No.6528 of 2017.
26.
Learned counsel submitted that, due to this attachment, its transactions
were held up and they are unable to meet their financial commitments,
including payment of salaries.
27.
In reply, learned counsel for respondent No. 1, SriM.V. Sureshargued
that the learned Judge has properly arrived at the amount due and payable by
the APHB. The calculation made by respondent No.1 is proper, and there is no
deviation from the decree or the orders passed by the Hon'ble Apex Court.
Discussion:
28.
Heard both learned counsels, and I have perused the record.
29.
In these two revisions, the controversy is that, although both parties
dispute the amount determined by the Execution Court, their grievance is that,
contrary to the amount arrived at, the court ordered attachment for an excess
amount. Without noting this discrepancy, the executing court made the order
of attachment absolute and closed the E.P.
30.
The process of warrant extracted hereunder:
“The plaintiff/D.H.R. applied under Rule 52 of Order 21 of
C.P.C., 1908, for an attachment of the amount of the D.R. for
Rs. 76,00,000/- (this amount relating to Gruhakalpa) on the file
of this court, which amount belongs to the J.D.R., namely: 1)
The LAO, Sub-Collector, Narasapur, and 2) The Executive
Engineer, A.P. Housing Board, Tadepalligudem, until further
orders of this court. Further, the court directed not to disburse
the said amount until further orders of this court.”
31.
The first revision, challenging the above order of attachment, is
C.R.P.No.6528 of 2017. Upon considering the contention of the APHB, this
court has passed interim orders dated 26.12.2017, which are as follows:
“Heard both sides.
Though it is claimed by the petitioner/JDR that an amount of
Rs.2,94,840/- was paid on 11.05.1997, the said aspect was not
reflected in the calculation memo filed by the respondent/DHR.
Even according to respondent/DHR, the balance amount that is
payable by the petitioner/JDR is only Rs.27,90,249/-. But, the
Court below without any application of mind passed order dated
12.09.2017 in EP.No.96 of 2009 attaching the bank account of
the petitioner to an extent of Rs.76,00,000/-.
In view of the same, attachment is confined only to an extent of
Rs.27,90,249/-only.
Learned Standing Counsel for the petitioner/JDR seeks time for
challenging the order dated 12.09.2017 in EP.No.96 of 2009.
Post on 29.12.2017 in Motion List.
Till then, there shall be stay of disbursement of amount to the
DHR.”
32.
This court prima facie found that the amount due is Rs.27,90,249/- only
and effected attachment to that extent only, and stayed further proceedings.
By the time of the orders, the Execution Court had closed the EP, recorded
attachment for an amount of Rs.76,00,000/- absolute and closed the EP.
33.
The impugned order of the Execution Court and the challenge therein
also reflect that the amount of Rs.27,90,249/- is the arrived amount of the
court. However, the learned Judge passed an order attaching the bank
account of the APHB under Order XXI Rule 52 CPC for an amount of
Rs.76,00,000/-.
34.
This is contrary to the orders of the executing court, which appears to be
an apparent error. Therefore, the order of attachment for Rs.76,00,000/cannot be sustained. This requires the interference of this Court.
35.
The record shows that, the learned Judge considered the directions of
the Hon'ble Apex Court while disposing of the land acquisition appeals, the
order of the Reference Court, as confirmed by this Court, were considered.
The Hon'ble Apex Court granted interest 10%on the compensation amount for
the period 12.05.1982 to 10.11.1993 and modified the High Court order only to
that extent.
36.
Pursuant to the interim orders of the Hon'ble Apex Court, the APHB
deposited the amount, which is not in dispute. However, respondent No.1
appears to have calculated the subsequent amount by adding interest at 15%,
though the Hon'ble Apex Court gave no such finding or direction. These
discrepancies in the calculations require further appreciation of evidence.
Without noting the discrepancy, closing the execution proceedings affects the
subject matter itself. Therefore, the order closing the EP and making the
attachment absolute also requires interference, as unless the EP is reopened,
the order of attachment for Rs.76,00,000/- cannot be addressed. Both
impugned orders thus require to be set aside and reopened.
37.
There is a dispute of calculating the due amount, though it is
challenged, in view of the due amount the order which arrived by the execution
court and amount attached are varying, this Court is of the view that these are
answered by this Court considering these factual aspects and then the trial
Court can look into the dispute afresh. Thus, both CRPs i.e. C.R.P.No.6528 of
2017 and C.R.P. No.1801 of 2018, arising out of the orders dated 04.10.2017
and 12.09.2017, require consideration.
38.
With the above discussion, in view of the circumstances and factual
aspects, this court is of the view that, the order of attachment for
Rs.76,00,000/- must be set aside, for the said condition, the closed EP has to
be restored. Accordingly this court inclined to consider both the revision
petitions. The factual aspects upon these orders, would require that, the
execution court shall proceed with the E.P. afresh and adjudicate the claims
and the Execution Court conduct fresh hearing, and decide the subject matter
on merits, after hearing the contentions of both sides as to the rate of interest
pursuant to the orders of the Hon’ble Apex Court. without being influenced by
this court's findings. This court refrains from passing any finding as to the due
amount as it is open to the execution court to adjudicate upon.
Result:
39.
In the result, C.R.P. No. 6528 of 2017 and C.R.P.No.1801 of 2018 are
allowed, with the following directions:
i.
C.R.P.No.6528 of 2017 is allowed, setting aside the order dated
04.10.2017 in E.P.No.96 of 2009 in L.A.O.P.No.32 of 1997, on the file of
the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Bhimavaram, by restoring E.P.No.96
of 2009 in L.A.O.P.No.32 of 1997.
ii.
C.R.P.No.1801 of 2018 is partly allowed, setting aside the order dated
12.09.2017 in E.P.No.96 of 2009 in L.A.O.P.No.32 of 1997, pursuant to
which attachment was issued for Rs.76,00,000/-, and continuing the
attachment to Rs.27,90,249/-. The attachment shall continue till the
Executing Court passes appropriate orders.
iii.
The learned Judge is at liberty to pass appropriate orders afresh on
hearing from both sides as to the actual amount due, following the due
procedure of law, and dispose of the E.P. without being influenced by
the observations of this Court.
iv.
Both parties are directed to approach the Civil Judge (Senior Division),
Bhimavaram, and place their claims and objections.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Interlocutory applications or interim orders pending if any shall stand
closed.
______________________________________
PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR CHINTALAPUDI, J
Dt: 01.10.2026
DSV
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PURUSHOTTAM KUMAR
CHINTALAPUDI
C.R.P. Nos.6528 of 2017 & 1801 of 2018
Dated: 01.10.2026
DSV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review