Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/52
GAHC010186262022
2026:GAUAS:10536-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/227/2023
THE ENGINEERING PROJECT INDIA. LTD .
REPRESENTED BY THE UTPAL PATOWARY, AGM , O/O CORE 3, SCOPE
COMPLEX, 7 INSTITUTIONAL AREA, LODHI ROAD,NEW DELHI 3
VERSUS
THE STATE OF MIZORAM AND 335 ORS E
REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF MIZORAM,
AIZAWL
2:THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF MIZORAM
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
AIZAWL.
3:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER -CUM-DISTRICT COLLECTOR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
LUNGLEI
4:THE UNION OF INDIA
REPRESENTED BY THE JOINT SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS
BORDER MANAGEMENT DIVISION I
NEW DELHI
5:JONE
S/O GURUL CHONDRO
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
Page No.# 2/52
6:MONU BODRO
S/O MERA
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
7:G.CHONDRO
S/O SANDHOI
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
8:P/S
C/O VCP
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
9:BOLU
S/O BANGHA CHONDRO
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
10:CHONDRO KUMAR
S/O SANTI MOY
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
11:PARANSANTI
S/O SANDRO MUNI
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
12:SANDRO MUNI
S/O BODI BUSAYA
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
13:DHONO KUMAR
S/O BOHOMAN
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 3/52
14:CHITTO ROTH
S/O PEDDO
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
15:PREMA RONJON
S/O M. CHAN
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
16:CHONDRO MOHAN
S/O BEKKA
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
17:NILO ROTH
S/O CHANDRO MOHAN
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
18:SANDRO KUMAR
S/O KELLYE
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
19:PAKKI
S/O SONGOSAN
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
20:CHONDRO LAL
S/O SANGO SUR
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
21:NILLO BORON
S/O CHONDRO MOHAN
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 4/52
22:BOSSOMBOR
S/O BONGA CHONDRO
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
23:NOTUNYA
.
S/O CHAGONIA
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
24:GOBINATH
S/O SANDU
DEVASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
25:BUDDHA MUNI
S/O SOMDU MUNI
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
26:NILA RANJAN
S/O ANANDA KUMAR
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
27:BIRO LAL
S/O SURESH KUMAR
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
28:PESENA RANJAN
S/O HENA RANJAN
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
29:HEMA MUKHI
D/O LUSHAI CHAND
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
Page No.# 5/52
30:MINKY
S/O PRITI CHAKMA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
31:RUPA KUMAR
S/O SAUMUNI
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
32:PRIYO DHOR
D/O LUSHAI CHAND
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
33:CHETORANJAN
S/O LAKNA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
34:NILO MONY
S/O MADAN KUMAR
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
35:BUSHAN KANTI
S/O ANANDA KUMAR
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
36:SUR PRAKASH
S/O DESI KUMAR
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
37:TORONI SEN
S/O KALA CHAND
MALSURI
Page No.# 6/52
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
38:NILO RONJON
S/O ANONDO KUMAR
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
39:RATNA DEVI
D/O CHITTO RONJON
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
40:SUDIR MOY
S/O DOYAL KUMAR
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
41:CHANDRA KELA
S/O HEMANTOLAL
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
42:PREMA RONJON
S/O GEDORAM
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
43:GORUL CHANDRO
S/O JUGENDRO
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
44:BINI MOY
S/O SINGHO MUNI
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
45:BIMOL KANTI
S/O SURESH KUMAR
Page No.# 7/52
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
46:SANTI MUNI
D/O SAMBOMONI
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
47:ROSIK DHAN
S/O MAJANGHALA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
48:SANTI RONJON
D/O BISHNA RAM
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
49:DULAL CHANDRO
S/O KAILASDHON
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
50:ANIL JOBON
S/O RUPA KUMAR
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
51:PROMA RONJON
S/O KALASOKA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
52:ANONTO KUMAR
S/O MONGOL JOY
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
53:OKAY KUMAR
Page No.# 8/52
S/O SISURAM
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
54:GURUL CHANDRO
S/O JUGENDRO
MALSURI
LUNGLEL DISTRICT
55:VC CHAKMA
S/O PK CHAKMA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
56:SUPARNA
W/O PROSANTI
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
57:PATHORI KUMAR
S/O ROBI MOHAN
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
58:MAJANGALA
S/O BATATCHIA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
59:NILLO ROTON
S/O JOY KISTO
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
60:NIROTH KUMAR
S/O PHODO KUMAR
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
Page No.# 9/52
61:KRISHNO
S/O JOY KISTO
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
62:AMAR CHAND
S/O TORONISEN
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
63:NOBIN CHAND
S/O JUPENDRA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
64:GULPEDA
S/O BORPHEDA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
65:KALA SELA
S/O SARENDRO
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
66:RAJ KINGKOR
S/O KHESBOLI
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
67:SUBO KUMAR
S/O MAJANGHALA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
68:NIBARON
S/O RAJENDRO
Page No.# 10/52
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
69:BOGYO DEVI
S/O DULAL CHONDRO
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
70:UGADI
S/O SUNILMOY
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
71:HEMO BINDU
S/O BHIGONIA
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
72:OMAR CHONDRO
S/O MOROTI MOHAN
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
73:SSA P. SCHOOL
C/O VC
MALSURI
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
74:PROTI RONJON
S/O BEHARI LAL
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
75:NILO KUMAR
S/O AREIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
Page No.# 11/52
76:SNEHO KUMAR
S/O DOILIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
77:MAYA DEVI
D/O PHORIYA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
78:NILOBI
S/O SUKROMUNI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
79:BOKUL MUNI
S/O PROMOD BIKASH
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
80:LOKHYA
S/O SUBO CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI
81:LOKHI CHANDRO
S/O TARBUA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
82:SUKROSARJYIO
S/O CHIGONA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
83:SNEHA RONJON
D/O MONGOL MOHAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
Page No.# 12/52
84:DEVI SINGH
D/O. SOBAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
85:ANURODRO
S/O NOTTON CHONDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
86:SANTI BIKASH
D/O OBIMOIMIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
87:CHITTORONJON
S/O PRENAMOY
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
88:BADRO SINGH
S/O PUINO MUNI
TABLAAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
89:PERSINGH
S/O PUINIA MUNI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
90:MONGA DEVI
D/O MONGAL MOHAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
91:GYANO RONJON
S/O RAJ CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
92:PHULESWARI
S/O ABNI RONJON
Page No.# 13/52
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
93:BISHWANATH
S/O MEYARAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
94:KINA RAM
S/O SILA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
95:CHANDRO KUMAR
S/O DINO CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
96:PROTIMOY
S/OPHOREYA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
97:BUSHAN KANTI
S/O ANONDO KUMAR
TEBLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
98:NIDORIA BOLI
S/O DRONO MOHAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
99:TRIDIP CHAKMA
S/O GOPAL MONGOL
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
100:DAYAMOY
S/O PHORIYA
Page No.# 14/52
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
101:PREMO RONJON
S/O ROY CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
102:DIRENDRO
S/O BUDIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
103:NIDIR CHAKMA
S/O SANTI ROY
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
104:CHIGON MOHAN
S/O CHITRO KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
105:DRUNO MOHAN
S/O BAMA CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
106:RONJON
S/O PHIDAHUMUA
TALABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
107:PHULO KANTI
S/O MUKTO SINGH
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
Page No.# 15/52
108:BIJOY DHOR
S/O KHANDA RA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
109:BISWAMITRO
S/O NUTAN CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
110:CHITORONJON
S/O PREMAMOY
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
111:BADIA ROTON
S/O BISWANATH
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
112:PVT. E.M. SCHOOL
C/O VCP TBLG
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
113:SUNIL KUMAR
S/O HENGOTIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
114:JOY CHANDRON
S/O PORAK CHONDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
115:SOBHA MITRO
S/O PROTIMOY
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 16/52
116:SANTI PRIYO
S/O MEGANATH
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
117:JAMMURUA
S/O PURUNDHAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
118:RAJ CHONDRO
S/O SANDU
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
119:POISARAM VICP
S/O NOBIN CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
120:BABUNIA
S/O LUSHAI MOHAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
121:BAJYA CHONDRO
S/O BOGOTGAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
122:KALABUA
S/O INDROJOY
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
123:SURJO LAL
S/O KORMO DHON
TALLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 17/52
124:MUKU CHAKMA
S/O DEBONA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
125:TOTEHA
S/O KANCHAND
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
126:MONGOL MOHAN
S/O PUINOSEN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
127:ANONTO
S/O BANUARAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
128:LOKSARO
S/O EKANIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
129:PURO MOHAN
S/O PUINOSEN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
130:DANESHWARI
S/O RAGONI KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
131:BASU DEP
S/O SAMMIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 18/52
132:DONO
S/O. RAJ KUMAR
TALABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
133:BABUNIA
S/O ANONDO KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
134:ROBIR KUMAR
S/O LUSHAI MOHAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
135:SIGONIA
S/O RAMONI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
136:BEHARI LAL
S/O KHULOMUNI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
137:NOLINI KANTO
S/O POISARAM
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
138:SURESH MUGI
S/ORAM CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
139:BISHWA MITRO
S/O NOTUN CHONDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 19/52
140:ARUN KUMAR
S/O LUSHAI KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
141:SAMDAR
S/O PUNYN CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
142:BIMOL CHANDRO
S/O DEVA MOHAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
143:KALA CHAND
S/O PULSYASEN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
144:ANGANWADI
C/O NAGURI (WK)
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
145:DONO
S/O SAROTI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
146:SONIRAM
S/O NABIN CHANDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
147:JORNA
S/O RONJIT
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 20/52
148:ABONI RONJON
S/O ALLYA CHAKMA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
149:GULPHEDA
S/O KODORAM
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
150:HENGOTIA
S/O TILOK MUNI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
151:ANONDO MALA
S/O BONORAM
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
152:BUDDHA MAJI
S/O TILOK MUNI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
153:DURNO MOHAN
S/O BAMA CHORAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
154:KAMALA RONJON
S/O GULSOKA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
155:MUKTO SINGH
S/O DURNOMUNI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 21/52
156:RETIKA CHAKMA
D/O RM. CHAKMA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
157:TORONI KANTI
S/O POISARAM
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
158:BANURAM
S/O LUSHAI KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
159:BAZAR SHED
C/O POISARAM VCP
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
160:SUKRO SEN
S/O KOMODRIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
161:CHITO RONJAN
S/O NISHI KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
162:MANYA
S/O HORIMON
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
163:BOKORA
S/O KINARAM
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 22/52
164:SARAIYA
S/O LOKHI MUNI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
165:PHULTARA
S/O MAKKABA (L)
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
166:NAION SINGH
S/O NAKKABA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
167:SOMOTI RONJON
S/O BEHARAI LAL
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
168:ANRATI
S/O SURJO KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
169:KONUNGO SINGH
S/O ALLYA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
170:JOTIRMOY
S/O GODHASAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
171:SANDOX
S/O TOTHIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 23/52
172:JOTRO SEN
S/O PHULA KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
173:CHIGON CHAND
S/O KENYARAM
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
174:ROI PHUDI
S/O RATARAM
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
175:LOKONA
S/O LUSHAI MOHAN
TALLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
176:GURIKA
S/O BICHOSEN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
177:SORIYIBON
S/O KALENDOR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
178:MARTINA
S/O RUPA YAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
179:IDRO KUMAR
S/O NOBIN CHONDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 24/52
180:KINA RONJON
S/O SARUJIBON
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
181:GRAVEYARD (TABLAB)
C/O YCA PRESIDENT
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
182:SANTI RONJON
S/O BEHARI LAL
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
183:BUBAN BIJOY
S/O SUKROSATGYIO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
184:DAYAL
S/O DARBUA CHONDRO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
185:SONGKOR
S/O AMRITA ROJON
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
186:ANONDO SINGH
S/O NAKKABA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
187:BIJOY SINGH
S/O NAKKABA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 25/52
188:SANTI MOY
S/O TONYARAM
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
189:RAMESH
S/O SELA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
190:BEGADI
S/O KHANDARAM
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
191:PRODIP
S/O DEBONA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
192:DILIP KUMAR
S/O DOILIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
193:LOKHI LODA
S/O RUPA MOHAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
194:NISHI MOHAN
S/O PUINOSEN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
195:SURESH
S/O INDRO
TABLABAGH
Page No.# 26/52
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
196:PRETI MOY
D/O DHARMA DHON
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
197:COMMUNITY HALL
C/O VCP (TLB)
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
198:NOTIA
S/O KALA CHAND
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
199:GYANO RONJON
S/O PUSPO KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
200:CHANDRO MOHAN
S/O RONJONIA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
201:LUSHAI KUMAR
S/O NOMO
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
202:SIJI
S/O BENGA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
S/O BENGA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
Page No.# 27/52
203:SSA P/SCHOOL
C/O VCP
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
204:OSUK KUMAR
S/O ADIDHON
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
205:BEGAN PHUDI
S/O DULUM KUMAR
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
206:NILO MUGI
S/O RAMMUNI
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
207:KATTYA
S/O DHONONJON
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
208:ANUK BARAN
S/O TARA CHARAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
209:BHAGHYANIDI
S/O KARNA
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
210:DINESH CHONDRO
S/O PURANDHON
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 28/52
211:PAVILION (TBLB)
C/O VCP
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEI
212:KAMINI MOHAN
S/O RAJONI MOHAN
TABLABAGH
LUNGLEL DISTRICT.
213:PROMOT KANTI
S/O SUBA RAJ
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
214:KHANDOR SINGH
S/O BOLI
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
215:PRIOSURAM
S/O PHULESWAR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
216:SOBNO KUMAR
S/O PHULETSOR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
217:LAHKSMI PRASAT
S/O SOPRIO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
218:SANTI BIJOY
S/O ROJONIS
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 29/52
219:ROBINDRANATH
S/O BINESWAR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
220:ANIL KANTI
S/O KADUNNS KUMAR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
221:PHULETSOR
S/O TILAK MONI
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
222:ZAMZAM
S/O ROHUL CHONDRO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
223:BOTLA
S/O NETEI CHORAN
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
224:ROTAN KATI
S/O JUBNAKNO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
225:BIRO KUMAR
S/O SESSENDRO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
Page No.# 30/52
226:KONEKSOR
S/O AMORTIA
BIDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
227:SUSIL KANTI
S/O PULIN BIHARI
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
228:SANTI LODHA
D/O SATURGON
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
229:MODHON
S/O PROSORAM
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
230:GOMESINDU
S/O INDROJIT
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
231:RAM CHONDRO
S/O BENGA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
232:BABUL
S/O DONGKOR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
233:SONOKO
S/O ARUN
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 31/52
234:OSUK KUMAR
S/O KORNO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
235:BONGA
S/O SORKO
BINDOSORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
236:JUJENDRO
S/O KALA CHAND
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
237:RONJANIA
S/O RANGABIJOY
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
238:CHANDRO MUNI
S/O DIRENDRO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
239:SODIL KUMAR
S/O RAJ MOHAN
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
240:CHANDRO MALA
S/O KENIA RA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
241:GOHINI
S/O NISI KUMAR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 32/52
242:SEJO KANA
S/O ROTHO HARAM
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
243:KOMOLENI
S/O TILAK MONI
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
244:GHANDI
S/O ONDO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
245:UDAI SANGBOR
S/O NIBILIA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
246:RAHUL CHONDRO
S/O BAGA SEDA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
247:PRIVATE P/S
C/O PRIO RONJON
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
248:BOLI
S/O PHULO MUNI
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
249:ARUN KUMAR
S/O KORNO
BINDASORA
Page No.# 33/52
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
250:KAMALETSOR
S/O TILAK MONI
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
251:ANIL BORON
S/O SADONIA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
252:DONO KUMAR
S/O KAMALETSOR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
253:GYONO RONJON
S/O BUDHU MUNI
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
254:SUBO NAKSO
S/O RANGA BIJOY (L)
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
255:MEYA LAL
D/O CHONDRO NATH
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
256:GYONO ROTON
S/O PRATAP CHONDRO
BIDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
257:JORAT CHORON
S/O PROTI RONJON
BINDASORA
Page No.# 34/52
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
258:PRIYA RONJON
D/O K.MOHAN
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
259:BATTYA
S/O KRISHNO CHONDDRO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
260:SUBO RAJ
S/O MAGURA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
261:GOVINDA
S/O PROSURAM
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
262:PRATAP SINGH
S/O PROSURAM
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
263:SANJOY KANTI
S/O JOLOBAG
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
264:SNEHA KUMAR
D/O MISI KUMAR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
265:KANJAN KUMAR
S/O PHULITSOR
BINDASORA
Page No.# 35/52
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
266:KHANDORA
S/O SURENDRO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
267:PHELABI
S/O PROSURAM
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
268:BIRO SINGHO
S/O SUERENDRO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
269:BUDDHIST TEMPLE
C/O SUBANAKSO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
270:SUSEN
S/O ROBINDRANATH
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
271:SUKRO SATJYO
S/O SADONIA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
272:DORMO ROTTON
S/O NISHI MOHAN
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
273:ZABIKA
D/O MAYA LAL
BINDASORA
Page No.# 36/52
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
274:NATTUA
S/O PURNO MUNI
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
275:SUBOL KUMAR
S/O TARMIDIA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
276:BOZARAKA
S/O BAITI
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
277:JOY SEN
S/O ROBINDRANATH
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
278:AKANIA
S/O RAMYA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
279:SUJOL KANTI
S/O JOBUNAKSO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
280:DILLIP KUMAR
S/O ROY KUMAR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
281:DOSOROT
S/O KOMELETSOR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
282:SOROBOLA
S/O KOMELETSOR
Page No.# 37/52
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
283:DONO KUMAR
S/O NILIDIA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
284:PROBHAT CHONDRO
S/O BENGA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
285:HRIDOY RONJAN
S/O DONO KUMAR
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
286:GOVT. P/S
C/O LAKHSMI PRASA
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
287:SUSANGKO
S/O SURENDRO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
288:PHULIN BIKASH
S/O RANGA BIJOY
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
289:KALAPUNA
S/O SURENDRO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
290:BIMAL KANTI
S/O SUBANAKSO
Page No.# 38/52
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
291:RUKBANU
S/O PRIO RONJON
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
292:RANA
S/O JINON JOY
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
293:JITENDRA
S/O MAYA LAL
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
294:TRIDIP
S/O UDOY SANKO
BINDASORA
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
295:PURNA KUMAR
D/O SUNADHON
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
296:KRISNA RONJAN
S/O SOLIA HOZI
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
297:RAJ MOHAN
S/O KALABADI
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
298:GYANO ROTON
S/O RAJ MOHAN
Page No.# 39/52
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
299:PUINASEN
S/O MON CHONDRO
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
300:BIROSEN
S/O KALBADI
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
301:ANANTA
D/O NATTA CHODRO
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
302:DONIARAJ
S/O SODHON MUNI
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
303:BANGLA JOY
S/O PUINOSEN
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
304:NOTUN JOY
S/O POINOSEN
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
305:MALA
S/O SONADHON
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
306:PRITIJOY
Page No.# 40/52
D/O POINOSEN
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
307:DHARMA JOY
S/O DAKKORAM (L)
NUNSURY
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
308:BUDDHIST MANDIR
C/O MANDIR COMMITTEE
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
309:CHONDRO MOHAN
S/O LOKHI MOHAN
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
310:JOINTO KUMAR
S/O OKIL CHONDRO
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
311:PHALKUNIA
S/O CHITROSEN
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
312:BUBAN BINOY
S/O OKIL CHONDRO
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
313:AKAY MUNI
S/O CHONDRO MOHAN
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
314:SANTI BORON
Page No.# 41/52
S/OMILIA SOKA
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
315:UDAYON CHAKMA
S/O ROBINDRANATH
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
316:NAION RONJON
S/O SANGPULA CHAKMA
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
317:KHULOMUNI
S/O RAIMUNI
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
318:MILIASOKA
S/O KABOLIA
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
319:PRITI KUMAR
D/O SANGPULA CHAKMA
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
320:GUNOMUNI
S/O JUNURAM
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
321:OKAY SINGH
S/O SARAT CHONDRO
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
322:OBILASH CHAKMA
Page No.# 42/52
S/O ROJONI MOHAN
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
323:BIMOL MITRA
S/O KALI KUMAR
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
324:RONJON KUMAR
S/O INDRO CHONDRO
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
325:KALABI
S/O SURAT CHONDRO
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
326:SUNDAR MUNI
S/O PHUKORAT
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
327:GOVT. PRIMARY SCHOOL
C/O BOLORAM VCP
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
328:MILON CHAKMA
S/O MONO VCP NUNSUR
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
329:TORONI MOHAN
S/O SUDHA CHAKMA
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
Page No.# 43/52
330:JITA RANI
S/O PRITI KUMAR
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
331:MONA
S/O BORPEDA
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
332:TRISUBUA
S/O SUKROSATZYA
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
333:AMOLA
S/O BORPEDA
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
334:SOBRA RANI
S/O KHULOMUNI
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT
335:KULUNGIA
S/O SURODHON
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRICT.
336:BOLORAM CHAKMA
S/O KRIPADHAN
SILGUR
LUNGLEI DISTRIC
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. W SHARMA,
Advocate for the Respondent : ASSTT.S.G.I., MR. C LALRAMZAUVA (R-319,326,336),MR. A R
MALHOTRA(R-319,326,336),GA, MIZORAM,MR. S K MEDHI (r-4)
Page No.# 44/52
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE ASHUTOSH KUMAR
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY
For the Appellant(s):
Mr A Phukan, Advocate,
Mr P Sarma, Advocate
For the Respondent(s): Mr C Lalramzauva, Sr. Advocate
Mr S Lalbuatsaiha, Advocate
Ms P Bhattacharya, Addl AG, Mizoram
Mr KK Medhi, Advocate for Respondent No. 4.
Date on which the Judgment was Reserved:17.07.2026
Date of the pronouncement of the
Judgment
:31.07.2026
Whether the pronouncement
is the operative part of the
Judgment:
NA.
Whether the full
Judgment has been pronounced: Yes.
Page No.# 45/52
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(A.D. Choudhury, J)
1.
The present appeal arises out of the judgment and order dated 17.06.2022 passed
by the learned Single Judge in WP(C) No. 87/2018, whereby the learned Single
Judge directed the Deputy Commissioner/collector to calculate the statutory
benefits under LA Award No.1/2009 and forward the same to the acquiring
authorities for release of the entire awarded compensation together with admissible
solatium and interest to the landlords.
2.
The facts are not in dispute.
The respondents /writ petitioners are landowners, whose land situated in Silgur-II,
Nunsuri, Bindasora, Tablabagh, Malsury and Devasora villages in Lunglei district
was acquired for construction of Indo-Bangladesh border fencing.
3.
Notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 was issued on
06.11.2006 pursuant to which the Collector prepared draft Award No. 1/2009
determining the compensation. The draft award received the approval of the
Government of Mizoram on 08.05.2009, under the first proviso to Section 11(1) of
the Act, 1894, and thereafter, the Award was forwarded to the acquiring agency for
deposit of the awarded amount.
4.
Since the awarded compensation was not released, proceedings were initiated
before the Reference Court seeking statutory benefits under the Land Acquisition
Act. Although the Reference Court initially granted solatium and statutory interest,
the matter was subsequently remanded by a Single Judge in WP(C) No. 2/2015 on
the ground that the acquiring agency had not been impleaded in the proceeding.
Upon remand, the reference proceeding ultimately came to be dismissed primarily
for the reason that the Reference did not have any authority to determine the dispute
raised.
Page No.# 46/52
5.
Thereafter, the respondent instituted WP(C) No. 87/ 2018 seeking a direction for
payment of the compensation determined under Award No. 1/2009 together with
solatium, statutory interest under section 23 (1)(A) and 23 (2) and interest for
delayed payment under Section 28 and 34 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.
6.
The learned Single Judge, under the impugned judgment, held that the Collector's
award had never been challenged in any proceeding known to law. Relying upon the
decisions of the Honourable Apex Court in Union of India and Another vs
Pushpavathi and Others reported in (2018) 3 SCC 28 and Santosh Kumar and Ors.
vs Central Warehousing Corporation and Another reported in (1986) 2 SCC 343,
the learned Judge concluded that the writ petition was maintainable for enforcement
of statutory entitlement arising from the Award.
7.
Accordingly, the Deputy Commissioner was directed to calculate the statutory
benefits and forward the same to the acquiring authorities for release of the entire
awarded compensation together with admissible solatium and interest to the
landlords.
8.
Mr Phukan, learned counsel for the Appellants, assailing such determination,
contended that the writ petition ought to have been dismissed solely on the ground of
unexplained delay and laches, as the respondents approached the writ court nearly
nine years after passing of the award. It was submitted that respondents had an
efficacious statutory remedy by way of execution of the award and therefore,
invocation of extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 was wholly unwarranted.
9.
Reliance was placed on State of MP & Ors. v. Nandlal Jaiswal, and Ors., reported
in (1986) 4 SCC 566, and Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage
Board & Ors. T.T. Murali Babu reported in (2014) 4 SCC 108 to contend that stale
claims should not be entertained in exercise of discretionary jurisdiction.
10.
It was further argued that the award passed by the Collector was executable as a
decree and that the High Court ought not to assume the role of an executing
Page No.# 47/52
court. Reliance in this regard was placed upon Rampal Jadhav and Another vs.
State of Haryana and Others reported in 2021 SCC OnLine P&H 3358, Banamali
Katu and Ors. vs The State and Others reported in 2000 SCC OnLine Cal 570 and
B. Govinda Reddy vs Revenue Divisional Officer -cum- Land Acquisition Officer,
Kurnool, reported in 1997 SCC OnLine AP 602.
11.
Placing reliance upon Executive Engineer, Nimna Dudhna Project, Selu, District
Parbhani, Maharashtra vs State of Maharashtra reported in (2020) 3 SCC 255, it
was also argued that interest ought not to be awarded for the period attributable to the
respondents' own delay in approaching the court.
12.
An additional contention advanced by the appellants was that they had no
knowledge of the award and that certain factual irregularities relating to the
acquisition process, including excess acquisition of land, had escaped consideration
of the Collector as well as of the learned Single Judge. It was therefore submitted that
the learned Single Judge proceeded on equitable considerations without appreciating
the factual and legal objections raised by the appellants.
13.
Per contra, Mr C. Lalramzauva, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
respondents, submitted that the writ petitioners did not seek enhancement of
compensation nor did they question the acquisition proceeding. The limited
grievance was that statutory benefits already determined under the Land Acquisition
Act had been unlawfully withheld.
14.
It was argued that payment of solatium and statutory interest is not a matter of
discretion but a statutory obligation. Failure to discharge such obligation gives right
to a continuing cause of action amenable to correction under Article 226 of the
Constitution.
15.
Reliance was placed upon the decision of a co-ordinate bench in Young Lai
Association (YLA) & Anr vs State of Mizoram & Ors reported in 2017 (3) GLT 382,
the decision of the Supreme Court in Vidya Devi vs State of Himachal Pradesh and
Page No.# 48/52
Others reported in (2020) 2 SCC 569 and Ultra-Tech Cement Limited vs Mast Ram
and Others reported in (2025) 1 SCC 798 to contend that Constitutional guarantee
under Article 300A obligates the State and its instrumentalities to pay lawful
compensation together with all statutory incidents attached to it and that technical
objections relating to delay or alternative remedy cannot defeat an admitted statutory
entitlement.
16.
We have bestowed our anxious consideration to the rival submissions and carefully
examined the records of the case. The principal objection raised by the appellant is
that the writ petition itself ought not to have been entertained on account of
unexplained delay of almost nine years and that respondents, if at all aggrieved,
ought to have sought execution of the award instead of invoking the extraordinary
jurisdiction of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The
appellants have also attempted to question the award itself by contending that they
had no knowledge of the award and that the award suffered from several infirmities.
17.
In our considered opinion, none of the aforesaid contentions merit acceptance.
18.
At the outset, it deserves to be noticed that acquisition proceedings themselves are
not in dispute. The lands of the respondents stood acquired for the benefit of the
appellant. The statutory procedure contemplated under the Land Acquisition Act,
1894 culminated in the preparation of a draft award by the Collector, which the
Government thereafter approved. Upon such approval, the award attained finality.
Admittedly, the award was never challenged by the appellant before any competent
forum.
19.
The legality and validity or correctness of the award, therefore, cannot now be
permitted to be questioned collaterally in a proceeding initiated by the land owners
only for enforcement of the statutory consequences following the award.
20.
The plea that the appellant had no knowledge of the award is equally devoid of
merit.
Page No.# 49/52
The acquisition itself was undertaken exclusively for the benefit of the appellant. The
statutory scheme required Governmental approval before the award could attain
finality. It is, therefore, difficult to accept that the beneficiary of the
acquisition remained completely unaware of the very award determining the
compensation payable.
Significantly, except for making a bold assertion, no contemporaneous material has
been produced to establish either the absence of knowledge or the date on which such
knowledge was allegedly acquired. Even thereafter, no proceedings were instituted to
date challenging the award. The conduct of the appellant is thus wholly inconsistent
with the plea now sought to be advanced.
21.
Once the award attained finality, the acquiring authority and the beneficiary cannot
selectively accept part of the award which suits them while refusing to discharge the
statutory liabilities imposed by the very same award. Such a course would strike at
the finality attached to the statutory adjudication under the Land Acquisition Act.
22.
The next submission relates to the delay and laches.
There can be no dispute with the proposition laid down in Nandlal Jaiswal (supra)
and Chennai Metropolitan Water Supply and Sewerage Board (supra) that the writ
jurisdiction is discretionary and stale claims ordinarily ought not to be entertained.
Those decisions, however, were rendered in entirely different factual settings and
cannot be applied divorced from the nature of the right sought to be enforced in the
writ petition.
23.
In the present case, the respondents are not seeking enhancement of the
compensation nor are they questioning the acquisition proceedings.
The award has already determined the compensation payable. The grievance of the
respondents is confined to non-payment of statutory benefits which automatically
flow from the award under the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Failure
to discharge such statutory obligation gives rise to a continuing cause of action.
Page No.# 50/52
24.
Mere lapse of time, therefore, cannot extinguish a liability imposed by statute, more
particularly in the absence of any such statutory prescription.
25.
The constitutional dimension of the controversy cannot also be overlooked.
Article 300A mandates that no person shall be deprived of his property save by
authority
of
law.
Lawful
acquisition
necessarily
carries
with
it
a
corresponding obligation to pay lawful compensation together with all statutory
incidents attached thereto. The Supreme Court in Vidya Devi (supra) empathetically
reiterated that the State cannot retain private property without paying due
compensation.
More recently, in Ultra-Tech Cement Limited (supra), the Supreme Court observed
that once the land is acquired under the power of eminent domain, the acquiring
authority is under a bounden statutory obligation to ensure prompt payment of
compensation to the landowners. The Court further deprecated attempts by
acquiring authorities to avoid or delay discharge of such statutory obligations.
26.
Equally unsustainable is the submission that respondents ought to have
pursued execution proceedings instead of invoking Article 226.
Availability
of
alternative
remedy
undoubtedly
remains
an
important
consideration governing exercise of writ jurisdiction. However, it is equally well
settled that such remedy is not an inflexible bar where enforcement of an undisputed
statutory obligation is involved.
27.
The respondents have not sought adjudication of disputed private rights. The
entitlement flows directly from a statutory award which has attained finality. The
Coordinate Bench decision in Young Lai Association (supra) correctly recognised
that in appropriate cases involving enforcement of statutory compensation arising out
of compulsory acquisition, exercise of writ jurisdiction cannot be declined merely
because another remedy may also be available.
28.
We are also unable to accept the attempt made by the appellants to assail the
Page No.# 51/52
correctness of the award by alleging excess acquisition or procedural irregularities.
Such issue, even if assumed to exist, could only have been raised by instituting
appropriate proceedings questioning the award itself.
The award having attained finality long ago, such objections cannot be re-agitated
indirectly while resisting payment of statutory benefits. Permitting such collateral
challenge would defeat the entire statutory framework governing land acquisition and
unsettle concluded proceedings.
29.
Reliance has also been placed by the appellant upon Executive Engineer, Nimna
Dudhna Project (supra) to contend that interest ought not to be granted for the
period attributable to the respondent's delay.
30.
The principle enunciated therein is well settled.
Interest being compensatory in nature may in any appropriate case be regulated
having regard to the conduct of the claimant.
However, that principle cannot be stretched to deny the substantive statutory benefits
themselves. The liability to pay compensation, together with the statutory incidence
attached to the award, remains unaffected. At best, the question regarding
computation of interest, in a given case, for any identifiable period attributable solely
to the beneficiary of an Award may be examined while implementing the award, if
the fact so justifies; it does not furnish a ground to interfere with the judgment under
appeal.
31.
Viewed from any angle, we find ourselves in agreement with the conclusion
reached by the learned single judge that the respondents cannot be deprived of
statutory benefits attached to an award which has attained finality and has never been
questioned in accordance with law.
The objections founded upon delay, alternative remedy, alleged lack of knowledge
and collateral challenge to the award do not persuade us to take a different view.
Page No.# 52/52
The opinion rendered by the learned single judge can neither be termed as perverse,
nor is the decision rendered ignoring any settled principle of law, warranting
interference at the hands of an intra-court appellate forum.
32.
We accordingly find no error either in law or on facts warranting interference with
the impugned judgment.
The appeal being devoid of merit deserves dismissal.
Accordingly, the writ appeal stands dismissed; parties to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review