Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No.02 of 2024
The Divisional Manager,
The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
B.C. Dharmanagar Branch, Raj Bari, P.S. Dharmanagar,
District-North Tripura. A company registered under the
Companies Act, 1956, represented by the Assistant Manager
cum Officer in Legal Hub/Authorized Signatory, Agartala,
Division Office, H.G.B. Road, (Near Sarkar Nursing Home),
Agartala, West Tripura.
----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Surja Kumar Das,
S/o: Late Swarbananada Das,
F/o: Late Sarajit Das.
2. Smti. Aparna Das,
W/o: Sri Surja Kumar Das,
M/o: Late Sarajit Das.
3. Sri Sukanta Das,
S/o: Sri Surja Kumar Das,
Brother of Late Sarajit Das,
All are the residents of Kabiraj Tilla,
North Kachucharra, P.O. & P.S. Salema,
District Dhalai, Tripura.
Presently residing under the C/o Sri Apurba Poddar,
Pratima Bhavan near Jogesh Mahal,
Dhaleswar Road No.13, Agartala, West Tripura.
---- Respondent/Claimant(s)
4. Sri Sushanta Debnath,
S/o: Sri Mahesh Debnath,
Resident of village Salema,
P.O. & P.S. Salema, District-Dhalai, Tripura.
(Owner of the vehicle bearing No.TR-04-B-0779)
Along with
CO (FA) No.06 of 2025
1. Sri Surja Kumar Das,
S/o: Late Swarbananada Das,
F/o: Late Sarajit Das.
2. Smti. Aparna Das,
W/o: Sri Surja Kumar Das,
M/o: Late Sarajit Das.
3. Sri Sukanta Das,
S/o: Sri Surja Kumar Das,
Brother of Late Sarajit Das,
All are the residents of Kabiraj Tilla,
North Kachucharra, P.O. & P.S. Salema,
District Dhalai, Tripura.
Presently residing under the C/o Apurba Poddar,
---- Respondent (s)
Pratima Bhavan near Jogesh Mahal,
Dhaleswar Road No.13, Agartala, West Tripura.
---- Respondent Petitioner/Cross Objector
Versus
1. Sri Sushanta Debnath,
S/o: Sri Mahesh Debnath,
Resident of village Salema,
P.O. & P.S. Salema, District-Dhalai, Tripura.
(Owner of the vehicle bearing No.TR-04-B-0779)
----Owner Respondent(s)
2. The Divisional Manager,
The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.
B.C. Dharmanagar Branch, Raj Bari, P.S. Dharmanagar,
District-North Tripura.
A company registered under the Act, 1956,
represented by the Assistant Manager cum
Officer in Legal Hub/Authorized Signatory, Agartala,
Division Office, H.G.B. Road (Near Sarkar Nursing Home),
Agartala, West Tripura.
----Appellant Respondent(s)
In MAC App. No.2 of 2024
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Karnajit De, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Adv.
Ms. Sarama Deb, Adv.
For Cross Objector(s)
:
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Soumyadeep Saha, Adv.
Ms. Sarama Deb, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Karnajit De, Adv.
Date of hearing
and delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
15.09.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
In CO(FA) No.06 of 2025
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Both the appeal and the cross-objection are taken up together
for hearing and decision, and accordingly, by this common judgment the
appeal and the cross-objection are disposed of.
2.
is
The appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
preferred
by
the
appellant-Insurance
Company
challenging
the
judgment and award dated 05.07.2023 delivered by Learned Member,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No. 1, West Tripura, Agartala in T.S.
(MAC) No.250 of 2019 and the cross-objection is filed by the respondentclaimant petitioners under Order XLI, Rule 22 of CPC, 1908 for
enhancement of the award delivered by the Learned Member, MAC
Tribunal No. 1, West Tripura, Agartala.
3.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. Karnajit De appearing on behalf of
the appellant-Insurance Company. Also Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr.
Debalay Bhattacharya assisted by Learned Counsel, Ms. Sarama Deb
appearing on behalf of the respondent-claimant petitioners and the crossobjectors. None appeared on behalf of the owner of the offending vehicle
bearing number TR-04-B-0779.
4.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Counsel for the appellant-
Insurance Company first of all has drawn the attention of this court
referring Exbt.B, i.e., the insurance policy certificate containing two
sheets, from which it appears that the policy was issued only for personal
use and not for any commercial purpose/use because in the policy it was
clearly stated that the policy covers use of the vehicle for any purpose
other than: a) Hire or Reward b) Carriage of goods (other than samples or
personal luggage) c) Organized racing d) Pace making e) Speed testing f)
Reliability Trials g) use in connection with Motor Trade. But, here in the
case at hand, on the alleged day the vehicle was being driven by the
driver along with passengers, which was not permitted by the terms and
conditions of the policy. However, Learned Tribunal below at the time of
delivery of judgment did not consider the same. Learned counsel has
further drawn the attention of this Court referring point No.23 of the claim
petition, which runs as follows:
“23. Any other information :
that may helpful in
disposal of the claim petition;
The fact of the case in brief is
that on 13/07/2019 at about
hrs,
S.I.
Sri
Sujit
Rudrapal of Kamalpur PS (Duty
Officer) received a
telephonic information from one unknown caller that one road
traffic accident incident occurred at Erarpar on Ambassa to
Kamalpur main road. Accordingly on this information, SI Jakir
Hussain, along with staff rushed at Erarpar to verify the
information. On arrival at spot found that one vehicle TR04-B0779 (Honda Xcent) had fallen down into the nala (right side of
the road). The I.O. also found that the Fire Service Staffs are
trying to bring out the passengers and including driver from the
said vehicle. Thereafter Fire Service team shifted total three
passengers i.e. travellers and driver of the said vehicle from
Erarpar to Kamalpur BSM Hospital for immediate medical
treatment. Due to this accident all the passengers including
deceased Sarajit Das (23yrs) succumbed while undergone
treatment at Kamalpur Hospital. On enquiry I.O. learnt that on
13.07.2019 at 16.30 hrs the deceased Sarajit Das was travelling in
vehicle bearing registration number TR04-B-0779 (Honda Xcent)
from Kamalpur side to Ambassa side and the said vehicle was
being driven very rashly and negligently with high speed by the
driver and the vehicle while reached at Erarpar then hit the road
side tree and fallen down into the nala.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that from the
above relevant portion of para No.23 it appears that on the alleged day,
the driver of the vehicle had carried passengers, which was not permitted
by the policy coverage. The same was not considered by Learned Tribunal
below. Learned Counsel has further drawn the attention of this court
referring para No.12 of the written statement wherein it was stated as
under:
“12. That in reply to the statement made in col. No. 13, 14, 15, 16
and 17 of the claim petition, the answering -opp.-party submits
that though the vehicle was insured with Oriental Insurance
Company Ltd. at that material time, but there is violation of terms
of policy in as much as the policy prohibits the use of the said
vehicle for carrying hire passengers for commercial purpose
concerned. The driving license of the driver of the said vehicle
namely Shri Litan Das had not been possessing valid driving
license who drove the said vehicle. Therefore, the answering
opposite e-party cannot be held liable to indemnify the claimantpetitioners and as such the instant claim petition is liable to be
dismissed in favour of the answering-opp.-party No.2.”
Referring
to
the
same
para,
Learned
Counsel
further
submitted that there was breach of terms and conditions of the policy, and
as such, the appellant-Insurance Company could not be fastened with the
liability of payment of compensation. Learned Counsel has further drawn
the attention of this court referring para No.3 of the Examination-in-Chief
in affidavit filed by one Surja Kumar Das, wherein it was mentioned as
under:
“3. I say that, on 13.07.2019 at about 4.30 p.m. my son Sarajit
Das (now deceased) along with other passengers was returning
home at Salema by boarding the vehicle bearing Regn. No.TR-04B-0779 (Hondacent) from Kamalpur side towards Ambassa side
and when the said vehicle reached at Erarpar, then hit the road
side tree and fallen down into a nala and the accident took place.”
Referring the said paragraph, Learned Counsel submitted that
in the said paragraph also it was clearly stated that the deceased along
with others had boarded in the said vehicle as passengers and since it was
a clear admission on the part of the claimant petitioner that the vehicle
was used for commercial purpose, not for personal use, which was not
covered by the policy. As such, the insurance company i.e. the present
appellant is not liable for making payment of compensation to the
respondent-claimant petitioners.
4.1.
Learned Counsel again drawn the attention of this Court
referring Examination-in-Chief in affidavit of another witness, Sukanta Das
wherein in para No.3 of his Examination-in-Chief, said witness also
reiterated the same fact.
4.2.
Thereafter,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant-Insurance
Company further referred the cross-examination of OPW-1, Sri Susanta
Debnath i.e. the owner of the vehicle, wherein it was clearly admitted by
him that the vehicle had a private registration certificate and the
insurance policy was issued by O.P. No.2 i.e. the present appellant herein
as a private car. He further admitted that as per terms of the policy
certificate there was clear bar to give the vehicle on hire to any
person/passenger. In such a situation, where there was clear violation of
the terms and conditions of the policy, according to the Learned Counsel,
Learned Tribunal below without appreciating the evidence on record
awarded compensation and fastened the liability upon the Insurance
Company for which the interference of this Court is required.
4.3.
Learned Counsel, Mr. De again drawn the attention of this
court referring the suo moto complaint laid by one S.I. Jakir Hossain on
13.07.2019 to O/C Kamalpur PS from which it was clear that the deceased
of this case along with others boarded in the said offending vehicle as a
passenger and the said document (i.e. the F.I.R.) has been relied upon by
the respondent-claimant petitioners but the Learned Tribunal below did
not consider the same and asked the appellant-Insurance Company to pay
compensation to the respondent-claimant petitioners. Moreso, no valid
driving license of the driver was produced and proved by the owner in this
case. Situated thus, according to Learned Counsel for the appellantInsurance, the judgment and award delivered by Learned Tribunal below
suffers from infirmity which needs to be interfered with.
4.4.
In
respect
of
cross-objection,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant-Insurance Company submitted that Learned Tribunal below
considering the evidence on record determined the monthly income of the
deceased as because the claimant-petitioners before the Learned Tribunal
below
could
not
adduce
any
cogent
evidence
on
record,
both
oral/documentary, to substantiate the monthly income of the deceased.
So, Learned Tribunal below rightly determined the monthly income of the
deceased and there is no chance to enhance the award in absence of
evidence on record. So, Learned Counsel urged for dismissal of the crossobjection filed by the respondent-claimant petitioners and also to allow
the appeal by setting aside the judgment and award of the Learned
Tribunal below.
5.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Bhattacharya
appearing on behalf of the respondent-claimant petitioners first of all
drawn the attention of this Court that here in the case at hand, before the
Learned Tribunal, the appellant was not a noticee rather, the appellant
contested the case by filing written statement. Learned Senior Counsel
further drawn the attention of this Court referring para No.6 of the claim
petition wherein the monthly income of the deceased was shown as
Rs.25,000/-. Learned Senior Counsel further drawn the attention of this
Court, referring the Examination-in-Chief in affidavit of PW-1, Surja
Kumar Das wherein para No. 5 he stated that the monthly income of the
deceased was Rs. 25,000/-. Similarly, PW-2, Sukanta Das also in his
Examination-in-Chief in affidavit, in para no. 5, reiterated the same fact.
The appellant-Insurance Company by the style of cross-examination, save
and except denial, could not dismantle the evidence on record of the
respondent-claimant
petitioners
regarding
monthly
income
of
the
deceased. But, the Learned Tribunal below at the time of determination of
the monthly income of the deceased, in para No. 16 of the judgment and
award dated 05.07.2023, only determined Rs.10,500/- as monthly income
which was too less, so the same needs to be enhanced.
5.1.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
further
submitted
that
as
per
notification of the High Court of Tripura dated 04.08.2023 since the
accident took place after 31.12.2015, the monthly income ought to have
been determined at the rate of Rs.18,000/- per month but the same was
not taken into consideration by the Learned Tribunal below. Learned
Senior Counsel also submitted that as referred by Learned Counsel for the
appellant-Insurance Company, the information as mentioned in point
No.23 of the claim petition was based on the report of police because at
the time of accident, the claimant petitioners were not present at the
place of occurrence and it is the police who laid suo moto complaint of the
accident and on the basis of suo moto complaint the case was registered.
5.2.
Again, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the appellant-
Insurance Company before the Learned Tribunal below did not adduce any
oral or documentary evidence on record to substantiate that the insurance
package does not cover the present liability and as such, the appellantInsurance Company is not liable for making payment of compensation to
the respondent-claimant petitioners as per direction of the Learned
Tribunal below. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that since the
monthly income of the deceased was not rebutted by adducing any
contrary evidence on record so, the award needs to be modified and
enhanced by setting aside the judgment and award of the Learned
Tribunal below. In support of his contention Learned Senior Counsel
further drawn the attention of this court referring another judgment of the
co-ordinate Bench of this Court dated 20.07.2023 in connection with MAC
App. No.82 of 2022 wherein a co-ordinate Bench of this Court affirmed the
award delivered by Learned Tribunal only reducing the rate of interest and
directed the payment of compensation upon the Insurance Company i.e.
the appellant herein and that case arose out of the same accident on the
basis of same police case bearing Kamalpur PS Case No. 61 of 2019
registered under Sections 279, 338, 304(A) of IPC read with Section 184
of MV Act. The said judgment has not been challenged by the appellantInsurance Company and at the time of hearing of argument of that
appeal, no such plea was taken by the appellant-Insurance Company
which has been taken in this case. Furthermore, Learned Tribunal below in
in Para No. 25 of the judgment and award dated 05.07.2023 made a clear
observation in this regard. According to Learned Senior Counsel for the
respondent-claimant petitioners, at this stage, the appellant-Insurance
Company be estopped from making assertions on the ground of violation
of the terms and conditions of the policy by the owner of the offending
vehicle and finally, Learned Senior Council urged for enhancement of the
award by dismissal of the appeal filed by the appellant-Insurance
Company.
6.
I have heard argument of both the sides at length and
perused the judgment and award delivered by the Learned Tribunal below.
7.
The subject matter of the claim petition was that on
13.07.2019, at about 1717 hours, SI Sujit Rudrapaul of Kamalpur PS
received one telephonic information from an unknown person that a road
traffic accident took place at Erarpar on Ambassa-Kamalpur main Road.
Accordingly, on receipt of information, SI Jakir Hossain along with staff
rushed to Erarpar to verify the information and on arrival to the PO, they
found a vehicle bearing registration No. TR-04-B-0779 had fallen down
into the roadside nala (right side) and the fire service staff after rescuing
the passengers including the driver shifted them to Kamalpur BSM
Hospital for their treatment wherein all the passengers including deceased
Sarajit Das succumbed to their injuries except the driver while undergoing
treatment at Kamalpur Hospital. On enquiry, the I.O. came to learn that
on 13.07.2019, at about 1630 hours, the deceased Sarajit Das was
travelling in the said vehicle from Kamalpur towards Ambassa which was
driven by the driver very rashly and negligently with high speed and when
the vehicle reached at Erarpar, it dashed against the roadside tree and fell
down into the roadside nala (right side). The accident took place due to
rash and negligent driving of the said vehicle. After the accident, the
victim was taken to Kamalpur Hospital by the fire service personnel
wherein
victim
succumbed
to
his
injuries.
The
post-mortem
was
conducted over the dead body of the deceased and in this regard,
Kamalpur PS Case No. 61 of 2019 under Sections 279, 338, 304(A) of IPC
read with Section 184 of MV Act was registered. In the claim petition it
was stated that the monthly income of the deceased was Rs. 25,000/- and
the deceased was 23 years old at the time of his death. So, the claim
petition was filed.
7.1.
The OP No. 1 i.e. the owner contested the same by filing
objection denying the assertions of the claimant petitioners. However, it
was stated that the OP-owner had valid registration certificate, driving
license of the vehicle on the day of the accident and the vehicle was
insured with the appellant-Insurance Company on the day of the accident.
It was also stated that if any compensation is awarded, that should be
borne by the Insurance Company. The OP No. 2 i.e. the Insurance
Company, the appellant herein also contested the case by filing written
statement denying the entire assertions of the claimant petitioners. It was
stated that though the vehicle was insured with them, but there was clear
violation of the terms and conditions of the policy. The vehicle was used
for carrying passengers for commercial purpose without making payment
of any extra premium for carrying such passengers and the driver of the
vehicle had no valid driving license and as such, the Insurance Company
had no liability to make payment of any compensation to the claimant
petitioners.
8.
Upon the pleadings of the parties Learned Tribunal below
framed the following issues:
(1) Did deceased Sarajit Das die in a road traffic
accident occurred on 13.07.2019 at about 1630
hours at Erarpar on Kamalpur Ambassa main road
under Kamalpur P.S. out of use of vehicle bearing
registration No. TR-04-B-0779 (Honda Xcent) due to
rash and negligent driving by the driver of said
vehicle?
(2) Are the petitioners entitled to get compensation
as prayed for and if so, to what amount and who is
liable to pay the same?
(3) To what other reliefs are the parties entitled ?”
9.
To substantiate the issues, from the side of the respondent-
claimant petitioners, two witnesses were examined as PW-1 and PW-2 and
certain documents were marked as Exbt.1 to Exbt.9. The owner of the
vehicle was examined as OPW-1 and the documents relied upon were
marked as Exbt.A to Exbt.D. But, no oral/documentary evidence was
adduced
by
the
appellant-Insurance
Company.
For
the
sake
of
convenience, the exhibits of the parties are mentioned hereinbelow:
“Exhibits of the claimant-petitioners:
Exbt 1: FIR alongwith Complaint petition.
Exbt 2: Final Form
Exbt 3/1, 3/2, 3/3,3/4: Seizure List
Exbt 4: Post Mortem Report
Exbt 5: Family Ration Card
Exbt 6: Aadhar Card of Sarajit Das
Exbt 7: Death Certificate
Exbt 8: Voter's Identity Card
Exbt 9: Certificate of Birth
Exhibits of the owner of the vehicle:
Exbt A: Tax Token of the vehicle
Exbt B: Insurance Policy Certificate
Exbt C: Aadhar Card of Sushanta Debnath
Exbt D: Registration Certificate”
However, the Learned Tribunal below, after conclusion of
enquiry, allowed the claim petition filed by the claimant petitioners. The
operative portion of the judgment and award runs as follows:
“O=R=D=E-R
It is, therefore, held that the claimant petitioner
no.2 is entitled to get compensation of Rs.16,64,600/(Rupees Sixteen Lakh Sixtyfour Thousand Six Hundred
only) with interest @ 7% per annum with effect from
21.12.2019 i.e. the date of filing of the claim petition till
the date of actual payment. The opposite party no.2
namely, the Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. will pay the
amount of compensation with interest within 30 days
from today in terms of Section 168(3) of M.V. Act, 1988.
Out of the awarded amount of compensation
inclusive of interest, 50% shall be kept in fixed deposit
scheme in the name of the claimant petitioner no.2 in
any Nationalized Bank of her locality for a period of five
years and the remaining 50% shall be paid to her
through her bank account. The claimant petitioner no.2
shall however be at liberty to withdraw monthly interest
from her fixed deposit account to meet her day to day
expenses. No loan or withdrawal shall be permitted from
the fixed deposit certificate without prior permission of
this Tribunal.
Supply copy of this award free of cost to the
parties.
The
claim
petition
stands
disposed
of
on
contest.
Enter the result in the relevant Register as well
as in the CIS.”
10.
Challenging the said judgment and award, the present appeal
is filed by the appellant-Insurance Company and the cross-objection is
filed by the respondent-claimant petitioners.
11.
I have gone through the record of the Learned Tribunal below,
including the oral/documentary evidence on record as well as the
judgment and award delivered by the Learned Tribunal below.
12.
Admittedly, in this case, there is no dispute on record in
respect of the fact of accident on the alleged date and time at Erarpar.
Now, here in this appeal and the cross-objection, it is to be seen whether
the
appellant-Insurance
Company
is
liable
to
make
payment
of
compensation to the claimant petitioners or not, and whether the claimant
petitioners are entitled to get enhanced amount of compensation or not.
13.
To substantiate their contentions, both the parties placed their
oral arguments as already stated. Learned Tribunal below at the time of
delivery of judgment and award in para No.16 came to the observation
that in the year 2019, a day labourer could easily earn Rs.350/- per day
and thus, the Learned Tribunal below assessed the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs. 10,500/- per month (Rs. 350 x 30).
14.
At the time of hearing of the argument, Learned Senior
Counsel, Mr. Bhattacharya drawn the attention of this court referring
notification dated 04.08.2023 of this High Court of Tripura regarding
determination of notional income but the said notification is regarding
determination of monthly income during Lok Adalat. Here, in the case at
hand, it was the plea of the respondent-claimant petitioners that the
deceased was a businessman but in this regard no documentary evidence
could be produced and proved by the respondent-claimant petitioners as
to what type of business the deceased used to deal in and what was his
daily income. Nothing could be explained by the respondent-claimant
Petitioners.
Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Bhattacharya although tried to
draw the attention of this court that the appellant-Insurance Company,
save and except denial, did not dispute the monthly income of the
deceased but this cannot be a ground for accepting that the monthly
income of the deceased was at Rs. 25,000/- because each case is to be
decided
according
to
its
facts
and
circumstances
on
merit.
The
respondent-claimant petitioners before the Learned Tribunal below could
not adduce any cogent evidence on record to substantiate that the
deceased used to earn a considerable amount of money to support his
livelihood.
15.
However, Learned Tribunal below treating the deceased as a
day labourer, determined his monthly income at Rs. 10,500/- but since
the accident took place in the year 2019 so, in my considered opinion,
there was no perversity or infirmity in the decision of the Learned Tribunal
below regarding determination of monthly income of the deceased at
Rs.10,500/- per month. As such, after hearing Learned Senior Counsel for
the respondent-claimant petitioners-cum-objector, I am not inclined to
enhance the monthly income as determined by Learned Tribunal below.
16.
Now, in respect of violation of terms and conditions of the
policy as alleged by the appellant-Insurance Company, it appears that at
the time of delivery of judgment and award in para No.25, Learned
Tribunal
below
Company,
to
gave
the
substantiate
observation
their
that
the
appellant-Insurance
pleading,
did
not
adduce
any
oral/documentary evidence on record and failed to prove that the vehicle
was used for commercial purpose though it was a private car. Learned
Tribunal below did not agree with the plea simply on the basis of
submission made in the written statement and oral agreement that the
owner of the offending vehicle violated the terms and conditions of the
policy.
17.
It is the admitted position that since the Insurance Company
did not adduce any oral evidence on record to rebut the claim of the
claimant petitioners, so, the plea taken by the Insurance Company that
the vehicle was used for commercial purpose cannot be taken as a sound
argument for accepting the plea taken during the stage of hearing of
argument.
18.
Learned Counsel, Mr. De, at the time of hearing of argument,
relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Bajaj
Allianz General Insurance Company Limited vs. Mukul Aggarwal &
Ors., reported in (2024) 2 SCC 344 wherein in para No. 17, the Hon’ble
Apex Court observed as under:
“17. As far as the interpretation of an insurance policy is
concerned, in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Chief Electoral
Officer [National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Chief Electoral
Officer, (2023) 6 SCC 441 : (2023) 3 SCC (Civ) 41] , this
Court reiterated that an insured cannot claim anything more
than what is covered by the insurance policy. The terms of
the contract have to be construed strictly without altering
the nature of the contract. Moreover, the clauses of an
insurance policy must be read as they are. The terms of the
insurance policy, which determine the liability of the
insurance company, must be read strictly. This Court also
held that the rule of contra proferentem is not applicable to
a commercial contract like a contract of insurance. The rule
of contra proferentem contemplates that if any clause in the
contract is ambiguous, it must be interpreted against the
party that introduced it. For the contract of insurance, the
applicability of the said concept is ruled out. The reason is
that the insurance contract is bilateral and mutually agreed
upon, like any other commercial contract.”
Relying upon the same, Learned Counsel intended to draw the
attention of this court that the principle of law laid down by the Hon’ble
Apex Court be taken into consideration in this case.
19.
In this regard, at the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel
for the respondent-claimant petitioners as already stated, drawn the
attention of this Court to another judgment dated 20.07.2023 of a coordinate Bench of this Court in MAC App. No.82 of 2022 which arose out
of the same police case wherein at the time of hearing of argument, no
such plea had been taken by the appellant-Insurance Company which is
taken by them at this stage before this court. Even, if it is assumed that
the insurance policy of the vehicle did not cover the commercial use of the
vehicle, still in this case, it was the responsibility and liability of the
Insurance
Company
to
rebut
the
contention
by
adducing
oral/documentary evidence on record.
20.
As already stated, there was no dispute on record in respect
of the fact of accident on the alleged day and that due to the accident on
the alleged day, the alleged driver sustained injury and the other
boarders/passengers succumbed to their injuries. But, the Insurance
Company, at least by oral evidence on record could not project their
defense theory to substantiate that the vehicle was used for commercial
purpose. Although, Learned Counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company
drawn the attention of this Court referring the cross-examination of OPW1, i.e., the owner of the vehicle, who in course of his examination stated
that his vehicle has registration certificate and the insurance policy was
issued as a private car and as per terms of the policy certificate, there was
bar to give the vehicle on hire to any person/passengers, but again in the
rest part of the cross-examination, he denied the fact of carrying any
passengers by his vehicle on that relevant point of time, violating the
terms and conditions of the policy.
21.
In this regard, I have also seen the charge-sheet/Final Report
submitted by I.O.
It appears that on the alleged day, the vehicle was driven by
one Litan Das along with three passengers/travellers namely Sarajit Das,
Ashim Debnath and Rabindra Debnath and those three travellers
ultimately succumbed to injuries. The driver also got injuries on his person
and referred to Dhalai District hospital for better treatment. Due to the
accident, Sarajit Das and Ashim Debnath succumbed at the spot and
another Rabindra Debnath succumbed while undergoing treatment at
Kamalpur Hospital. This has been relied upon by the respondent-claimant
petitioners and was exhibited before the Learned Tribunal below as Exbt.2
containing six sheets along with other documents. Until and unless it is
proved on record that those passengers/travellers boarded inside the
vehicle either by hiring the same or by making payment of fares to the
driver, the plea taken by Learned Counsel for the appellant-Insurance
Company cannot be taken as a sound and legally accepted ground to
substantiate that there was violation of the terms and conditions of the
policy by the owner or driver, here the alleged driver. Alternatively, if it is
assumed that the vehicle was meant for private use also in that case,
there was no bar to claim for compensation in the event of accident by the
owner or his family members.
22.
Here, in the case at hand, since there is no contrary evidence
on record that the vehicle was used by the driver for commercial purpose
so, there is very least scope to accept the argument taken by Learned
Counsel for the appellant-Insurance Company at this stage since to
substantiate their pleading, the Insurance Company did not adduce any
oral/documentary evidence on record. Furthermore, before the coordinate Bench as already stated, no such argument was made in this
regard on behalf of the appellant-Insurance Company that there was
violation of the terms and conditions of policy and that judgment by this
time has attained finality also. Situated thus, after hearing both the sides,
it appears to this court that there is no merit in the appeal filed by the
appellant-Insurance Company. At the same time, there is no merit in the
cross-objection filed by the respondent-claimant petitioners i.e. the cross
objectors.
23.
However, it appears that Learned Tribunal below at the time of
determination of delivery of judgment and award determined the rate of
interest @ 7% per annum with effect from 21.12.2019 i.e. from the date
of filing the claim petition till the date of actual payment which in my
considered view, the same should be modified and be enhanced to 7.5%
per annum which was also awarded by the co-ordinate Bench of this Court
in MAC App. No.82 of 2022.
24.
The citations as referred by Learned Senior Counsel for the
respondent-claimant petitioners appear to be not relevant for decision of
this appeal and accordingly the same is not considered for the decision of
this case.
25.
In the result, there is no merit in the appeal filed by the
appellant-Insurance Company. Accordingly, the same stands dismissed
being devoid of merit. At the same time, the cross-objection filed by the
respondent-claimant petitioners also bears no merit, save and except that
the rate of interest awarded by the Learned Tribunal below at the rate of
7% per annum be enhanced to 7.5% per annum in favour of the
respondent-claimant petitioners to be paid by the appellant-Insurance
Company w.e.f. 21.12.2019 i.e. from the date of filing the claim petition
till the date of actual payment.
26.
The appellant-Insurance Company shall deposit the amount of
compensation along with interest @ 7.5% per annum as indicated above
within a period of 60(sixty) days from the date of judgment passed by this
court to the Learned Tribunal below after intimation to the respondentclaimant petitioners.
A copy of this judgment be furnished free of cost to the
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant-Insurance
Company
for
information and compliance. Also a copy of this judgment be
supplied to Learned Senior Counsel for the respondent-claimant
petitioners free of cost for information. Send down the LCR to the
Learned Tribunal below along with a copy of this judgment and
order.
Pending application(s), if any also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2025.09.16
A DATTA Date:
18:02:00 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review