The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. 07.2023 YES/NO HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AM ARNATH GOUD _F_I_N_A_L O_ R_ D_ E_ R_ Heard Mr. Alik Das, learned counsel appearing for the appellantinsurance company also heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel and Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondents. [2] This application has been filed under Section-173 of the Motor Vehicles Act against the judgment and award dated 24.06.2022 passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with case No. T.S. (MAC) 133 of 2019. [3] Brief facts leading to this case is that on 05.11.2018 the deceased was proceeding towards Agartala from Jirania as a pillion rider in a motor bike bearing registration No. TR-01-AD-5413. In course of proceeding as such when the motor bike reached in front of Ranirbazar Vidya Mandir H. S. School on Assam-Agartala road, at that time the offending vehicle proceeding from same direction dashed the motor bike from back side as a result, the deceased sustained grievous injuries on the various parts of his body including head, chest, left upper limb etc. Immediately after the occurrence deceased was taken to AGMC & GBP Hospital where he was declared dead by the attending Medical officer. It is alleged that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving on the part of the driver of offending vehicle. In this connection Ranirbazar PS Case No…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
MAC. App. No.79 of 2022
The Divisional Manager, New India Assurance Company Ltd.
.....Appellant
V_E_R_S_U_S
Smti. Kulu Rani Debbarma & 3 Others
.....Respondents
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of hearing and delivery
Of judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. Alik Das, Advocate.
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. R. Datta, Advocate.
19.07.2023
YES/NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AM ARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
Heard Mr. Alik Das, learned counsel appearing for the appellantinsurance company also heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel and Mr. R. Datta,
learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This application has been filed under Section-173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act against the judgment and award dated 24.06.2022 passed by the
learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.2, West Tripura,
Agartala in connection with case No. T.S. (MAC) 133 of 2019.
[3]
Brief facts leading to this case is that on 05.11.2018 the deceased
was proceeding towards Agartala from Jirania as a pillion rider in a motor bike
bearing registration No. TR-01-AD-5413. In course of proceeding as such when
the motor bike reached in front of Ranirbazar Vidya Mandir H. S. School on
Assam-Agartala road, at that time the offending vehicle proceeding from same
direction dashed the motor bike from back side as a result, the deceased sustained
grievous injuries on the various parts of his body including head, chest, left upper
limb etc. Immediately after the occurrence deceased was taken to AGMC & GBP
Hospital where he was declared dead by the attending Medical officer. It is alleged
that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving on the part of the
driver of offending vehicle. In this connection Ranirbazar PS Case No. 73 of 2018
u/s 279/338/304(A),IPC and 184 of the MV Act was regarded.
[4]
The owner of the offending vehicle through his written statement
apart from denying all the allegations in the claim petition contended, inter alia,
that he is the registered owner of the said offending vehicle and it was duly insured
with the appellant insurance company, therefore, urged for fixing the liability of its
insurer to pay the compensation, if any. The appellant through their written
statement denied the strict proof of their respective claim. It is also specific claim
of the appellant that at the time of alleged accident driver of the offending vehicle
was not the holder of valid driving license and as such the owner has violated the
condition of insurance policy and, therefore, the insurer is not liable to pay the
compensation as claimed.
[5]
After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
having gone through the material evidence on record, the learned Court bellow has
observed as under:
“In the result, claim is awarded in following terms:
(i) Claimant petitioners are entitled to get the award of Rs.56,50,660/- (Rupees
fifty six lacs fifty thousand six hundred sixty) only with 9% Simple interest
per annum from the date of registration of claim i.e, w.e.f. 26.06.2019 till the
date of realization thereof.
The petitioner No.1 exclusively shall be entitled to get the amount of Rs.
40,000/- as consortium, the petitioner No.2 and 3 exclusively shall also be
entitled to get the amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- in equal share as awarded under
the head loss of love and affection. The claimant petitioners Nos. 1,2 and 3
shall have equal share on the rest amount.
(ii) 50% of the share of the claimant petitioner No.1 in the award be invested
by purchasing separate Fixed Deposit certificate from any Nationalized Bank
at least for the next 5 years and no loan or advance or pre-mature withdrawal
shall be allowed without prior sanction of this Tribunal.
75% of the share of the claimant petitioner No.2 and 3 in the award be
invested by purchasing separate Fixed Deposit certificate from any
Nationalized Bank at least for the next 5 years or till attaining the age of 21
years whichever is applicable and no loan or advance or pre-mature
withdrawal shall be allowed without prior sanction of this Tribunal.
Remaining part of the shares of claimant petitioners shall be paid to them
directly to their individual bank accounts.
Claimant petitioners shall have the liberty to withdraw the monthly interest
from the amount to be kept under fixed deposit.
Needless to say that the amount so ordered to be paid to the minor claimant
petitioner shall be incurred only for the welfare and benefit of herself.
The OP No.2, i.e., the New India Assurance Co. Ltd. shall deposit the awarded
amount along with interest thereon within one month to this Tribunal.”
[6]
Mr. Alik Das, learned counsel appearing for the appellant-insurance
company has contended that from the side of the insurance company evidence was
produced regarding the issue of driving license. On the date of accident, the driver
of the offending vehicle Sri Samprai Debbarma had no valid driving license, but,
the learned tribunal did not consider the issue saying that the issuing authority i.e.
the Transport Authority was not examined as a witness, though the report was
obtained from the Transport Department. The report was also exhibited as Exbt.F.
[7]
The learned tribunal though discussed the issue of pay and recovery
as the owner violated the condition of policy but, in the operative portion of the
judgment, the learned tribunal did not give any verdict of any pay and recovery
and as such, the judgment and award is liable to be set aside. The tribunal below
assessed the income of the deceased person more than that of actual salary and as
such calculated the compensation on the higher side. The tribunal has awarded
compensation towards love and affection is highly excessive and beyond the guide
line of the Apex Court.
[8]
It has been further averred that the driving license of the offending
was fake but the learned tribunal did not consider the fact, though in support of
that, evidence was also adduced from the side of the appellant insurance company.
The learned tribunal has awarded interest in the higher side, than that of normal
bank interest, and as such, the judgment and award is liable to be set aside or
modified.
[9]
In view of above submissions and having gone through the evidence
on record it reveals that there is no dispute between the parties that the death of
deceased Ashrai Debbarma was caused as a result of road traffic accident. Save
and except simple denial at the time of cross examination, no material came out
which may qualify rejection of the evidence of PWs 1 and 2. In support of the oral
evidence the claimant respondents have also proved the charge sheet [Exbt 3(1) to
3(viii)] in connection with said police case from where it revealed that the accident
occurred due to rash and negligent driving on the part of the driver of offending
vehicle. This Court, therefore, left with no option but to conclude that the accident
occurred due to rash and negligent driving on the part of driver of the offending
vehicle.
[10]
It has been established beyond any shadow of doubt that the death of
deceased was caused due to rash and negligent driving of the rider of offending
motor bike. Therefore, the claimant respondents being the legal heirs of deceased
entitled to have the compensation under the beneficial legislation, namely the
M.V. Act. Now the question arises is what should be the quantum of compensation
and who is liable to pay the same. In order to decide and calculate the amount of
compensation we find it apposite to have a reference to a recent judgment of the
Honble Supreme Court reported in AIR 2017 SC 5157 (National Insurance
Company Limited Vs Pranay Sethi and others) wherein In Para-61 of that
Judgment it was observed thus:
'”61. In view of the aforesaid analysis, we proceed to record our conclusions :(i) The two Judge Bench in Santosh Devi (AIR 2012 SC 2185) should have
been well advised to refer the matter to a larger bench as it was taking a
different view then what has been stated in Sarla Varma (AIR 2009 SC 3104 )
a Judgment by a coordinate Bench. It is because a co-ordinate bench of the
same strength cannot take a contrary view then what has been held by another
co-ordinate bench.
(ii) As Rajesh has not taken note of the decision in Reshma Kumari (AIR)
2013 SC (Supp) 474), which was delivered at earlier point of time, the
decision in Rajesh is not a binding precedent.
(iii) While determining the income and addition of 50% of actual salary to the
income of the deceased towards future prospects where the deceased had a
permanent job and was below the age of 40 years, should be made. The
addition should be 30 percent, if the age of the deceased was between 40 to 50
years. In case the deceased was between the age of 50 to 60 years, the addition
should be 15 percent. Actual salary should be read as actual salary less tax.
(iv) In case that deceased was self -employed or on a fixed salary, an addition
of 40 percent of the establish income should be the warrant where the
deceased was below the age of 40 years. An addition of 25% where the
deceased was between the age of 40 to 50 years and 10% where the deceased
was between the age of 50 to 60 years should be regarded as the necessary
method of computation. The established income means the income minus the
tax component.
(v) For determination of the multiplicand, the deduction for personal and
living expenses, the tribunals and court shall be guided by paragraphs 30 to 32
of Sarla Varma which we have reproduced herein before.
(vi) The selection of multiplier shall be as indicated in the table of Sarla
Varma read with paragraph-42 of that Judgment.
(vii) The age of the deceased should be the basis for applying the multiplier.
(viii) The reasonable figures on conventional heads, namely loss of estate, loss
of consortium and funeral expenses should be Rs.15,000/-,Rs.40,000/- and
Rs.15,000/- respectively. The aforesaid amounts should be enhanced at the
rate of 10% in every 3 years.”
[11]
PW-1 in her examination in chief stated that at the time of death her
husband was 38 years of age and he used to earn Rs. 29,337/- per month. As per
Post mortem report [Exbt.2(i) to 2(ii)] at the time of death deceased was at this age
of 38 years. The Salary certificate of the deceased so proved vide Exbt.7 shows
that the deceased used to draw an amount of Rs.29,337/- as a permanent employee
in the GA(S.A.) Department, Govt. of Tripura. Indisputably the deceased was at
his age group of 36 to 40 years at the time of his death. So, applying the ratio of
law as declared by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pranay Sethi’s case (Supra) an
addition to the extent of 50 percent should be added to the income of the deceased.
In view of the law laid down in Sarla Varma's case (AIR 2009 SC 3104) for the
age group of 36 to 40 the appropriate multiplier is M-15. Besides where the
number of dependent family members are less than 4 (three in the case at hand),
deduction towards personal and living expenses would be one third (1/3).
[12]
In the case at hand, the evidence as to driving the offending vehicle
without valid driving license by the driver Sri Samprai Debbarma. Such evidence
stands beyond pleading since no averment in this regard was made in the written
objection. That apart, the appellant has proved a copy of letter dated 01.09.2020
(Exbt.E) which was supplied from the office of Joint Transport Commissioner,
Govt. of Tripura, Agartala on an application under RTI Act. Information furnished
under RTI Act meant for information only. Since the author of such letter was not
produced to prove it, this Court declines to place reliance on it to hold that the
driving license was fake. It is, therefore, held that the appellant being the insurer of
the offending vehicle is liable to pay the compensation.
[13]
The learned tribunal under the head of love and affection has
awarded Rs.3,00,000/-, to which learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
rightly averred that tribunal has awarded compensation towards love and affection
is highly excessive and beyond the guidelines of the Apex Court. As such, this
amount should be reduced into Rs.40,000/- following the principle laid down in
Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd v. Nanu Ram Alias Chuhru Ram, equally
distributed to the claimants i.e. 40,000 x 3 = Rs.1,20,000/- therefore, under the
head of love and affection instead of Rs.3,00,000/- as awarded by the Court
below, it would be computed as Rs.1,20,000/- others shall remain unaltered.
[14]
Accordingly, the present appeal stands partly allowed with the above
modification. The insurance company shall deposit the awarded amount as
assessed by the learned tribunal within a period of one month, from the date of
receipt of the copy of this order, if not already deposited. Consequently, the
claimant is at liberty to withdraw the same as per procedure. As a sequel,
miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed. Draw the
award accordingly and thereafter, send down the LCRs forthwith.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2023.07.25
13:01:37 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review