Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
$$
% &
'
% &
'
()
$$
$$
*
% &
'
$$
+
% &
'
$$
+,
% &
'
% &
'
$$
(
)
Digitally signed
by LUCYGRACE
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
"!
-2-
"
!#
$
!%
&
'
()*$ +
)
+
"
*
&
()*$ +
'
&
()*$ +
"
#!*
"
*#$$
%
&
()*$ +
"
"
#*!
*#$$
!
'
+# !+!
$,
)
%
%"
'
!# + !+!+
-3-
) !+ *
'
(
)
&
'
()*$ +
'
+
"
(*
&
()*$ !$
!
()*$ +
"
'
&
()*$ !)
"
(#!*
"
(*#$$
$
&
()*$ !)
"
(#!*
"
(*#$$
-4-
)
"!
!#
%
!%
&
'
()*$ +
!,
!* +
!+!
"
$
%"
'
!# +
!+!+
'
) !+ *
* (
)
)%
&
'
()*$ +
'
+
-5-
"
(*
&
()*$ !$
!
()*$ +
"
'
&
"
(#!*
"
(*#$$
$
&
()*$ !)
"
(#!*
"
(*#$$
)
!%
!*
&
'
()*$ +
!,
*
! !+!
"
$
%"
'
!# +
!+!+
'
$ !+ *
-6-
+ (
)
)%
!
!%
"
!*
&
'
()*$ +
$
+
"
*
&
()*$ +
)
'
&
()*$ +
"
#!*
"
*#$$
-7-
&
()*$ +
"
#*!
!
'
+# !+!
"
*#$$
",
$
)
%"
'
!# +
$ !+ *
'
+,(
)
)!
!
!%
!+!+
-8-
"
!$
$
!+
)
*
&
'
()*$ +
+
" ( *
&
()*$ +
%
'
&
()*$ +
"
#!*
"
*#$$
*
&
()*$ +
"
#*!
!
"
'
+# !+!
*#$$
),
%
*
%"
-9-
'
!# +
!+!+
!+ *
'
(
)
)!
&
'
()*$ +
'
+
"
(*
&
()*$ !$
!
()*$ +
"
'
&
()*$ !)
"
$
(#!*
"
(*#$$
- 10 -
&
()*$ !)
"
(#!*
"
(*#$$
)
!%
!$
%
!+
*
*
&
'
()*$ +
!,
+* +! !+!!
"
*
%"
'
!# +
!+!+
'
!+ *
'
- 11 -
-
'
#
./0/ 122/130 14/ 1450567 89: 8; :./ <8==86 '9>7=/6:
16>
?14> >1:/> !# +
16>
!+ *
86 :./ ;53/ 8;
'9>7/ 16>
!
!+!+ 56
1:
>>3
$ !+ *
) !+ *
50:45<: 16>
/005860
15<.94 1?14>567 <8=2/601:586
: 50 :./ <10/ 8; :./ <315=16:0 :.1: :./ <315=16:0 ?/4/
:41@/33567 56 1
41<:84 16>
16>
("
015>
41<:84 16>
:5=/
:./ >45@/4 8; :./
4153/4 A/14567
(*#$$ 4/02/<:5@/3B 86 !#
4153/4 4/1<./> 6/14
("
(#*!
!+ % 16> ?./6 :./
9>713
53317/ 1: :.1:
A90 A/14567
("
(*
<1=/ ;48= 822805:/ 05>/ 16> >10./> :8 :./
41<:84 16>
16> 86 1<<896: 8; :./ 01=/ :./
41<:84 16>
4153/4 :94:3/> 16>
10 09<.
:./ 56=1:/0 8; :./
41<:84 16>
.5@1221
9357/==1 16>
1331==1 090:156/> 56C945/0 16>
:./4/1;:/4
09<<9=A/>
56C945/0
:8
4153/4
/6</
4/24/0/6:1:5@/0 .1@/ ;53/> :./ 1;84/015> 4/02/<:5@/
A/;84/ :./ 45A9613 0//D567 <8=2/601:586
4153/4
61=/3B
:./54
3/713
<10/0
- 12 -
"
;:/4 0/4@5</ 8; 68:5</ 4/0286>/6:
16> ! 56 :./
<315= 2/:5:5860 /6:/4/> 122/1416</ 16> 4/0286>/6:
$ ?/4/ 231</> /E(214:/
80 " 16>
: 50 :./ <10/ 8; :./ 4/0286>/6: F
842841:586 :.1: :./ 133/7/> 1<<5>/6: 8<<944/> 86 1<<896: 8;
:./ 410. 16> 6/7357/6: >45@567 8; :./ >45@/4 8; :./
4153/4 16> :./4/;84/
41<:84 16>
0897.: ;84 >50=50013 8; :./ <315=
2/:5:5860
$
6 84>/4 :8 /0:1A350. :./54 <10/ <315=16:0 56 133 :./ <10/0
.1@/ /E1=56/> :.4// ?5:6/00/0 10
248>9</>
"$ >8<9=/6:0 ?.5<. 14/ =14D/> 10
/0286>/6: F
E0
E0
" 16>
:8
"$
842841:586 .10 /E1=56/> :./ >45@/4 8; :./ A90
16> 248>9</> # >8<9=/6:0 ?.5<. ?/4/ =14D/> 10
:8
#
./
45A9613 1;:/4 <8605>/4567 :./ =1:/4513 86
4/<84> AB 5:0 '9>7=/6: 16>
<8=2/601:586
! 16>
8;
! $+ +++ ( 56
?14> >1:/> !# + !+!+ 1?14>/>
0 * )! $++ (
) !+!+ 16>
$ !+!+
! $+ +++ ( 56
!+!+ ?5:. 56:/4/0: 1:
G 2/4 1669= ;48= :./
>1:/ 8; <315= 2/:5:586 :533 >/2805:
//3567 17745/@/> AB :./
1?14> 8; <8=2/601:586 10 561>/H91:/
:./ <315=16:0 .1@/
- 13 -
24/;/44/>
80 !+ + + !+!+
!++ $# !+!
16>
!++%++ !+!
)
//3567 17745/@/> AB :./ 8A0/4@1:586 =1>/ AB :./
10 :8 351A535:B
80 !++#%
/14>
:./ 4/0286>/6: F
!+!+ !++ *
=:
!+! 16> !++ *" !+!
4//:5
122/14567 ;84 :./ 122/3316: F
1:.
1:53
/3D96>5
842841:586 16>
3/146/>
<8960/3
101@141C
3/146/> <8960/3 122/14567 ;84 :./ <315=16:0 ?.8 14/
122/3316:0
%
842841:586 24/;/44/>
4/0286>/6:0 56 :./0/ 122/130
: 50 <86:/6>/> AB :./ 3/146/> <8960/3 ;84 :./ 122/3316: F
842841:586 :.1: :./
45A9613 .10 <8==5::/> 16 /4484 56
;10:/6567 351A535:B 86 :./ >45@/4 8; :./ A90 56 H9/0:586 >/025:/
:./ ;1<: :.1: :./ >45@/4 8; :./
41<:84 16>
4153/4 >48@/ :./
01=/ 56 1 410. 16> 6/7357/6: =166/4 16> <86:45A9:/> :8?14>0
:./ 133/7/> 1<<5>/6: 16> 1<<84>5673B 0897.: ;84 56:/4;/4/6</ 8;
:.50
894:
: 50 ;94:./4 1479/> AB :./ 3/146/> <8960/3 :.1: :./
56=1:/0 ?/4/ :./ 2100/67/40 56 :./
41<:84 16>
4153/4 16>
:./4/;84/ 0897.: ;84 56:/4;/4/6</ 10 ;14 10 351A535:B 50 <86</46/>
- 14 -
*
/4 <86:41
101@141C
1:. 3/146/> <8960/3 ;84
:./ <315=16:0 56@5:/> :./ 1::/6:586 8; :./
248>9</> 1:
894: :8 :./ 0D/:<.
E " 16> <86:/6>/> :.1: :./ 1<<5>/6: 8<<944/> 86
1<<896: 8; 083/ 6/7357/6</ 86 214: 8; :./ >45@/4 8; :./ A90 56
H9/0:586 16> 1<<84>5673B <896:/4/> :./ 1479=/6:0 1>@16</>
AB :./ 3/146/> <8960/3 ;84 :./ 122/3316: F
842841:586
/146/> <8960/3 1308 =1>/ 09A=5005860 0//D567 /6.16</=/6:
8; <8=2/601:586 :8 :./ <315=16:0
#
1@567 ./14> :./ 3/146/> <8960/3 122/14567 ;84 :./
214:5/0 86 <14/;93 <8605>/41:586 8; :./ ;56>567 4/<84>/> AB :./
45A9613
?893>
56>5<1:/
:.1:
!+ %
.5@1221
9357/==1 16>
1331==1 ?/4/ :41@/33567 56 :./
41<:84 16>
4153/4 A/14567
(*#$$ 16>
("
16>
("
?./6 :./ 015> @/.5<3/ 4/1<./> 6/14
9>713
53317/ :./ >45@/4
8; :./
(*
A90 A/14567
05>/ 16> >10./> :8 :./
(#*!
!#
("
41<:84 16>
<1=/ ;48= 822805:/
4153/4 16> 01=/ 50 /@5>/6:
;48= :./ 028: 216<.161=1 13867 ?5:. 0D/:<. =12 248>9</> 1:
E "
6 :.1: @5/? 8; :./ =1::/4
;56>567 4/<84>/> AB :./
1= 8; :./ @5/? :.1: :./
45A9613 ;10:/6567 :./ 351A535:B 86 :./
>45@/4 8; :./ A90 56 H9/0:586 .10 :8 A/ 1<</2:/>
./4/;84/
- 15 -
>8 68: ;56> ;84</ 56 :./ 09A=500586 =1>/ AB :./ 3/146/>
<8960/3 ;84 :./
+
842841:586
6 08 ;14 10 1?14> 8; <8=2/601:586 50 <86</46/> :./
<315=16:0 56
$ !+ * 14/ :./ 3/713 4/24/0/6:1:5@/0 10
>/2/6>/6:0 8; >/</10/>
.5@1221
./ 17/ 8;
)* B/140 10 86 :./ >1:/ 8; :./ 1<<5>/6:
.5@1221 ?10
./4/;84/ :1D567 56:8
<8605>/41:586 :.1: :./ 1<<5>/6: 50 8; :./ B/14 !+ % 10 2/4 :./
795>/356/0 8; :./
1461:1D1
:1:/ /713
=86:.3B 56<8=/ 8; :./ >/</10/>
/4@5</0
.5@1221 50
9:.845:B :./
+ !)+ (
B
1223B567 :./ 122482451:/ =93:5235/4 8; # 56 :/4=0 8; :./
'9>7=/6: 8; :./
86-A3/
924/=/
&
894: 56 :./ <10/ 8;
&$
$
4/284:/> 56
16> AB 1>>567
#
+
+G :8?14>0 ;9:94/ 24802/<:0 56 @5/? 8; :./
'9>7=/6: 8; :./
86-A3/
924/=/
894: 56 :./ <10/ 8;
$
&- $
4/284:/> 56
#
! >/>9<:567
"4> :8?14>0 .50 2/408613 /E2/60/0 :./ <315=16:0 14/ /6:5:3/>
;84 <8=2/601:586 8;
0*
*++ (
! "
:8?14>0 3800 8; >/2/6>/6<B
16>
:./4/;84/
8;
+!)+ I
+G E
! E # E
./4/ 14/ :.4// >/2/6>/6:0
<86084:59=
>/:/4=56/>
1:
- 16 -
!+ +++ (
0 $+ +++ E "
) +++ ( :8?14>0 3800 8; /0:1:/ 16> 168:./4
:8?14>0 ;96/413 /E2/60/0
0 ) +++ (
./ <315=16:0 .1@/ 56<944/> =/>5<13
/E2/60/0 :8 :./ /E:/6: 8;
<315=16:0 56
./ <315=16:0 14/ /6:5:3/> ;84
$* *)+ (
<<84>5673B
:./
$ !+ * 14/ 7416:/> <8=2/601:586 10
68:/> A/38?
/1>0
800 8; >/2/6>/6<B
*
800 8; /0:1:/
=896:
92//0
*++ ++
) +++ ++
800 8; <86084:59=
!+ +++ ++
4160284:1:586 J ;96/413 /E2/60/0
) +++ ++
/>5<13 /E2/60/0
$* *)+ ++
8:13
+
6 08 ;14 10 1?14> 8; <8=2/601:586 56
<86</46/>
4/24/0/6:1:5@/0
:./
<315=16:0
>/2/6>/6:0
:./4/56
8;
)+ ++
14/
>/</10/>
:./
) !+ *
3/713
9357/==1
9357/==1 ?10 17/> 1A89: $* B/140 10 86 :./ >1:/ 8; :./
1<<5>/6:
1D567 56:8 1<<896: :./ =86:.3B 56<8=/ 8; >/</10/>
9357/==1 1:
+ !)+ (
10 2/4 :./ 795>/356/0 8; :./
- 17 -
1461:1D1
:1:/
/713
/4@5</0
9:.845:B
:./4/ 14/ ;894
>/2/6>/6:0 16> AB 1223B567 2482/4 =93:5235/4 8;
'9>7=/6: 8; :./
86-A3/
&
16> AB 1>>567 !)G :8?14>0 ;9:94/ 24802/<:0
09241
924/=/
" 10 2/4 :./
894: 56 :./ <10/ 8;
10 2/4 :./ '9>7=/6: 56 :./ <10/ 8; $
>/>9<:567
$:. :8?14>0 ./4 2/408613 /E2/60/0 :./ <315=16:0
14/ /6:5:3/> ;84 <8=2/601:586 8;
E
! E
09241
" E " $
$ ## + ! (
+!)+ I !)G
:8?14>0 3800 8; >/2/6>/6<B
./4/ 14/ ;894
>/2/6>/6:0 16> :./4/;84/ 3800 8; <86084:59= 50
0 $+ +++ E $
./ <315=16:0 14/ /6:5:3/> ;84
:8?14>0 3800 8; /0:1:/ 16> 168:./4
/E2/60/0
+ +++ (
0 ) +++ (
) +++ ( :8?14>0 ;96/413
<<84>5673B :./ <315=16:0 56
) !+ * 14/
7416:/> <8=2/601:586 10 68:/> A/38?
/1>0
800 8; >/2/6>/6<B
=896:
56 92//0
$ ## + ! ++
800 8; /0:1:/
) +++ ++
800 8; <86084:59=
+ +++ ++
4160284:1:586 J ;96/413 /E2/60/0
) +++ ++
8:13
*# + ! ++
- 18 -
!
6 08 ;14 10 1?14> 8; <8=2/601:586 56
<86</46/>
:./
<315=16:0
:./4/56
4/24/0/6:1:5@/0 10 >/2/6>/6:0 8; >/</10/>
14/
!+ *
:./
3/713
1331==1 ?.8 >5/>
1: :./ 17/ 8; $* B/140 >9/ :8 :./ 1<<5>/6: 56 H9/0:586
56:8 1<<896: :./ =86:.3B 56<8=/ 8; >/</10/>
+ !)+ ( 10 2/4 :./ 795>/356/0 8; :./
/4@5</0
1331==1 1:
1461:1D1
:1:/ /713
9:.845:B 16> 10 :./4/ 14/ ;894 >/2/6>/6:0
1223B567 2482/4 =93:5235/4 8;
86-A3/
1D567
924/=/
AB
" 10 2/4 :./ '9>7=/6: 8; :./
894: 56 :./ <10/ 8;
&
09241
16> AB 1>>567 ;9:94/ 24802/<:0 :8 :./ /E:/6: 8; !)G 10 2/4 :./
'9>7=/6: 56 :./ <10/ 8; $
09241
>/>9<:567
$:. :8?14>0 ./4 2/408613 /E2/60/0 :./ <315=16:0 14/ /6:5:3/>
;84 <8=2/601:586 8;
" $
$ ## + ! (
+!)+ I !)G E
:8?14>0 3800 8; >/2/6>/6<B
!E
"E
56</ :./4/ 14/ ;5@/
>/2/6>/6:0 3800 8; <86084:59= 50
0 ! ++ +++ (
)
0 ) +++ ( :8?14>0 3800 8;
./ <315=16:0 14/ /6:5:3/> ;84
/0:1:/ 16> 168:./4
<<84>5673B
0 $+ +++ E
) +++ ( :8?14>0 ;96/413 /E2/60/0
:./ <315=16:0 56
<8=2/601:586 10 68:/> A/38?
) !+ * 14/ 7416:/>
- 19 -
/1>0
=896:
56 92//0
800 8; >/2/6>/6<B
$ ## + ! ++
800 8; /0:1:/
) +++ ++
800 8; <86084:59=
! ++ +++ ++
4160284:1:586 J ;96/413 /E2/60/0
) +++ ++
8:13
"
% !# + ! ++
6 :./ 4/093:
!++ *
./
!+!
2100 :./ ;8338?567
50</3316/890
16> !++ *" !+!
540:
22/13
80 !++#%
;53/> AB :./
!+!+
842841:586 14/
./4/AB >50=500/>
;84
./ <315=16:0 56
:8:13
<8=2/601:586
8;
0 * )! $++ ( 1?14>/> AB :./
$ !+ * 14/ ./3> /6:5:3/>
+
45A9613
)+ (
171560:
?5:. 56:/4/0: 1:
G
2/4 1669= ;48= :./ >1:/ 8; <315= 2/:5:586 :533 4/135K1:586
;84
./ <315=16:0 56
:8:13
<8=2/601:586
8;
) !+ * 14/ ./3> /6:5:3/>
*# + ! (
171560:
- 20 -
! $+ +++ ( 1?14>/> AB :./
45A9613
?5:. 56:/4/0: 1:
G
2/4 1669= ;48= :./ >1:/ 8; <315= 2/:5:586 :533 4/135K1:586
5@
./ <315=16:0 56
;84
:8:13
<8=2/601:586
! $+ +++ ( 1?14>/> AB :./
8;
!+ * 14/ ./3> /6:5:3/>
% !# + ! (
45A9613
171560:
?5:. 56:/4/0: 1:
G
2/4 1669= ;48= :./ >1:/ 8; <315= 2/:5:586 :533 4/135K1:586
@
6 133 8:./4 4/02/<:0
2100/> AB :./
45A9613 0.133 4/=156 56:1<:
<8==86 '9>7=/6: 16>
$ !+ *
50:45<: 16>
:./ '9>7=/6: 16>
?14>
<<84>5673B
:./
?14> >1:/> !# + !+!+ 56
) !+ * 16>
!+ * 86 :./ ;53/ 8;
/005860 '9>7/ 16>
1:
>>3
15<.94 0.133 0:16>
=8>5;5/>
@5
!++ *
./ 1=896: 56 >/2805: 56
!+!
16> !++ *" !+!
80 !++#%
0.133 A/ :4160=5::/> :8 :./
<86</46/>
.(
%
'
#
01<
50:
"+
!+!+
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review