Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ii
13448 |
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR
THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE SIXTH DAY
OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND rWEr.r*'SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
E
S
L
Appeal Under section 173
of Motor vehictes Act against
Decree in o'P'No 2g3 ti-)oob"o"ted
the Judgment and
12-01- zili on the fire
chairman Motor Accident cr;;;
of the court of the
iriornrr-"r, pri".ipat District Judge,
warangal.
Between:
The Divisionar Manager, United
M.G.Road, pochamm, i4rid"n,
rndia rnsurance co.Ltd, p.B.No.
Warangal
AND
1.
;ff::Hffi
saritha, Wo tate Muratidhar
3::,8[XlT,Jhansi
...Appellant / Respondent
No.2
Reddy, Ased about 32 yrs,
occ:
Reddy, D/o rate Muratidhar
3' charabuddi Varsha Reddy,
,'J::.",ll,,[:il:;3il1 *i,::
Reddy, Ased abour 15 yrs,
D/o rate Muraridhar Reddy,
x[: *i:;
All are R/o H.No. 5_2_176,Kothur
Aged
yrs,
:',i1,,, ;;, ;;; abouto 12
a, ra
h
",rn
Hanamkonda, Warangal
...Respondents
4.
n
u
District
1 to 3/petitioners
1 to 3
,T:,,, Buchi Reddy, S/o Ramakri na
H- No. 2-2-26,
Reddy, ag"d_,6,^1.
N" i,
|
yrS, occ: Bus
in ess R/o
warangal District
s. The Managing Director,
ApSRa"'*on,,
6. charabodi nr,., o^r-^].^::^lt' RTc office, Hyderabad
Reddv, s/o ch
nro u.uo]'2';::
ss,
Lug.gr, Ased_ 65 yrs, occ: B
nazipet,
Business
wrr"n!rldo[?,f'
nrg:r;;;ff
F;;;;;;"J,:?i1-
...Respondents
75,
4 to G/Respondents
1,3 and 4
F
151 0f cpc
praving that in the circumstances
,n" J,fl":ffi,ff,f'section
stated in
o p e ra t o n c r t h e
Tj: ".::H ? j t". T:o? _"rfi f n"L 1f
thr-" file of the chairman,-,vncr-"rm-erincipar
X
District
i
a
I
f
l
,
m#ryj
d?,ffi
3?rff,,
Judge, at warangar
Counsel for the Appellant: SRt
COUNSEI fOr thE RESPONdENT
NO.S: SRI N CHANDRA
(sc FOR RTc)
,
;
i
,|
:
.
:
i
A RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
The Court made the following:
JUDGMENT
SHEKAR
THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF
TELANGAITA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HON,BLE JUSTICE B.R.TUADHUSUDHAN
RAO
MACMA.No.644 of 2O16
Between:
The Divisional Manager,
United India Insurance Company
Limited,
P.B.No.75, M.G.Road, pochamma
maidan,
Warangal.
... Appellant - Respondent
No.2
And
l.Charabuddi Saritha
2.Charabuddi Jhansi Reddy
3. Charabuddi Varsha
Reddy
. Respondent Nos. I
to 3 _
Petitioner Nos.1 to
4.Nalla Buchi Reddy
S.The Managing
Director, APSRTC,
6.Charaboddi Ram
RTC Office, Hyderabad.
Reddy
... Respondent Nos.
4 to 6 _
Responaent lVos.t,-S
*O +
JUDGIT{EITT
1'
This memorandum
Section 173 of
of civ, Miscelraneous
the Motor vehicles
Appeal is fired
Act, 19gg (for short, .the
\
\
under
yy Actl
2/8
BRMR,J
MACMA.No.644 of 2016
assailing the award passed by the learned Principal Motor Accidents
Claims Tr!.bunal, Warangal (for short, the Tribunal') in M.V.O.P.No.293
of 2006, dated l2.Ol.2OLO.
Appellant is the respondent No.2, respondent Nos.1 to 3 are the
2.
petitioners and respondent Nos.4 to 6 are the respondent Nos.1, 3 and 4
in the O.P.
Respondent No.1 - petitioner No.1 is the divorced wife, respondent
3.
Nos.2 and 3 - petitioners Nos.2 and 3 are the daughters
No.6 - respolldent No.4 is the father of the late
and respondent
Muralidhar Reddy'
4.Notice.gotissuedtorespondentNo.4intheappealisserved,none
appeared for,rim'
5.ResponrlentNos.lto3-petitionershavefiledclaimpetitionunder
Sections163-Aand166ofMVActreadwithRule455ofAPMVRules,
Lgsg,ctaimingcompensationofRs'8'00'000/-withinterestattherate
the petition till the date of
filing
of
date
the
from
of L2%per armum
realization'
6.
18'30 hours Ch'Muralidhar
On 07'0:2'2005 at about
Reddy was
boardingthebusbearingNo.AP-36-U-S40ltoattendhisduties,allof
suddenthedriverofthebusmoveditrashlyandnegligentl},dueto
whichCh'MurrrlidharReddylosthisbalance'felldownfromttrefoot
BRMR,J
MACMA.No.644 of.2016
board, the bus ran over him which caused injuries to his head, hands
and chest and he died on the spot. The deceased ch.Muralidhar Reddy
was aged about 38 years as on the date of accident and was earning an
amount of Rs.6,500/- per month as a cleaner in APSRTC, warangal-I
Depot.
7.L Respondent No.4 - respondent No.1 remained ex-parte before the
Tribunal.
7.2 Appellant - respondent No.2 filed counter and denied the manner
in which the accident has taken place.
7.3
Respondent No.S - respondent No.3 has also filed counter stating
that it is the driver who drove the bus in rash and negligent manner and
RTC is not liable to pay any compensation.
8.
Respondent No.l - petitioner No.l is examined as pWl and got
marked Exs.Al to A7. Respondent No.5 - Respondent No.3 has got
examined Rwl - E.Mallaiah - RTC employee. Appellant - respondent
No.2 has got examined its officer as RW2 - V.Sainath. Respondent No.6 -
respondent No.4 is examined as RW3, got marked Exs.Bl andB2.
9.1 The learned Tribunal after analyzing the evidence adduced by the
parties has partly allowed the claim petition and awarded an amount of
Rs.7,54,260/- with simple interest at the rate of 60/o per annum from the
4/8
BRMR,J
MACMA.No.644 of 2016
date of hlirLg the petition i.e., 28.01.2006 till the date of realization from
respondent No.4 - respondent No.l but indemnifiable by appellant respondent No.2 and directed to deposit the entire compensation amount
together with interest thereon.
9-2 Petition against petitioner No.l (respondent No.1 herein) and
respondent No.3 (respondent No.S herein) is dismissed.
10. Learrred counsel for the appellant - respondent No.2 submits that
the learned Tribunal railed to appreciate Ex.B2 - copy of policy wherein
the insurecl has not paid any premium as required under IMT No.44,
therefore in the absence of said endorsement, the insurance company is
not liable to pay the compensation to respondent Nos.l to 3
petitioners. The Tribunal also failed to appreciate the fact that the
insurance c:ompany examined its officer and brought to the notice of the
Tribunal with regard to the policy violations and in spite of the same,
Tribunal h;1S erroneously passed the award. The Tribunal failed to
appreciate the fact that the insured vehicle was hired by APSRTC,
therefore APSRTC alone has exclusive control over the vehicle and
vicariously tiable to pay the compensation for the tort committed by the
driver. The Tribunal also failed to appreciate the evidence of RW1
wherein it u'as categorically brought to the notice of the Tribunal that the
deceased in order to board the bus in hurried manner, dashed a person
s/8
BRMR,J
MACMA.No.644 of 2016
by the side of the bus, fell down near the tyre of the bus and there is no
negligence on the part of the Driver of the bus and the accident occurred
only due to recklessness of the deceased Muralidhar Reddy. The
Tribunal failed to look into the evidence of PWl and RW3 in proper
perspective. Tribunal ought to have deducted l/3,a towards personal
expenses but wrongly deducted 1 /4tn which is contrary to the law and
prayed to allow the appeal.
11. Learned counsel for respondent Nos.2 and,3 - petitioner Nos.2 and
3 and respondent No.6 - respondent No.4 contended that the Tribunal
has rightly appreciated the facts of the case in proper perspective, no
interference is called for and prayed to dismiss the appeal.
L2. Learned Standing Counsel for respondent No.5 - respondent No.3
submits that the matter is covered by the decision of the Supreme Court
in the case of uttar Pradesh state Road rransport corporation Vs.
Kulsum and Othersr.
13. Appellants have challenged the multiplier and the vicarious
liability of respondent No. 5 - respondent No.3 in the appeal.
L4. The learned Tribunal observed that in the absence of any rebuttal
evidence on behalf of the contesting respondents with regard to rash and
'1zorr;8 scc r42
BRMR,J
MACMA.No,644 of 2016
negligent driving on the part of the driver of the bus, investigation made
by S.I. of Police, P.S.Madikonda, leading to the prosecution of the driver D.Prabhakzrr for an offence punishable under Section 304-A of IPC, for
causing de,eth of Ch.Muralidhar Redy, by rash and negligent driving of
the bus anrl arrived that it is the driver of the bus, who drove vehicle in
rash and nr:gligent manner and caused accident.
15. In so far as the liability is concerned, the learned Tribunal has
observed at paragraph No.13, which reads as under:
13. No dc,ubt, RW2 was examined to prove Ex.B2-insurance policy valid from
26.3.2004 to 25.3.2OO5 and the accident had occurred on7.2.2OO5 during the
validity period of Ex.B2-insurance policy but as testified by RWl, R1 entered into
an agreement with R3 under Ex.Bl dated 3.4.2oo4 valid from 19.3.2oo4 to
18.3.2005 and as per clause 5 (iv) of the agreement, Rl-owner would be
responsible for all claims that might arise due to an accident payable under the
provisions cf the M.v. Act, 1988 and R3 is not liable to pay any compensation
and Rl-owlrer of the said vehicle is responsible for all claims that arise and under
no circumstances, R3 be made liable or responsible to pay compensation that
may be awerded by the Motor Accidents Claims in-respect of accidents and in the
absence ol any tripartite agreement between Rl-owner, R3-hirer and R2insurance oompany excluding the liability of R2-insurance company, a bipartite
agreement tike Ex.B1 between Rl-insured owner and R3-hirer, which does not
absolve the liability of R2-insurer from its liability to indemnify'R1, as held by the
High Courl of A.P. in APSRTC, MUSHEERABAD, HYDERABAD V. KANCHE
NAGABHUS;HANAM @ BHUSHANAM (2008 (2) ALD 602), rhe decision relied on by
the learned counsel for R2 reported in NATIONAL INSURANCE co. LTD. v.
DEEPA DE\/I (2008) 1 scc 414, is clearly distinguishable and does not apply to
the facts of the case on hand. So, R2-insurer is liable to indemnify R1-insured
owner by depositing the compensation amount, as is being determined, in the
following O^r*r^r{
'/
BRMR,J
MACMA.No.644 of 20L6
16. The learned Tribunal has taken the age of the deceased
Muralidhar Reddy at 38 years as per Ex.A2 - C.C of inquest report,
Ex.A3 - C.C. of PME report and Ex.AS - charge sheet and applied
multiplier '15'. The Tribunal has taken the income of the deceased at
Rs.5,476/- per month, arrived annual income at Rs.65,712/- deducted
7l4tn towards his personal expenses and applied multiplier '15', arrived
at Rs.7,39,2601-; awarded Rs.10,0oo/- towards loss of love and
affection, Rs.5,000/- towards funeral expenses and arrived at
Rs.7,54,260 l-.
L7. tn Kulsumt the Supreme Court framed the question of law at
paragraph No.3 as under:
.3. The question of law that arises for consideration in the instant and
connected appeals is formulated as under: if an insured vehicle (in this case a
mini bus) is plying und.er an agreement of contract with the Corporation, on the
route as per permit granted in favour of the Corporation, in case of an accident,
whether the Insurance Company would be liable to pay compensation or would it
be the responsibility of the Corporation or the owner?'
and observed at pa-ragraph No.41 as under:
,4!.
In the light of the aforesaid discussion, the appeals of the Corporation
are allowed. The impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court qua the
Corporation are hereby set aside and quashed and we hold that the Insurance
company would be liable to pay the amount of compensation to the claimants.'
t
\
\
MACMA.No.644 of 20t6
18. The Tribunal ought to have deducted L/3ra towards the personal
expenses of the deceased, but has deducted 1f 4th, as the appeal is filed
in the year 2016, no major difference will be arrived if t13,a of the
personal expenses of the deceased is deducted, hence, this Court is not
interfering with the same. In view of the decision of the Supreme Court
stated sul)ra appellant respondent No.2 is liable to pay the
compensation.
rg- Interr:st awarded by the Tribunal is at the rate of 60/o per annum
from the date of filing the petition till the date of realization, this Court is
not disturb.ng the same.
20. Appellant respondent No.2 has not made out any case to
interfere with the orders passed by the learned rribunal, there are no
merits in the appeal and the same is liable to be dismissed.
21. In thr: result, MACMA.No.644 of 2016 is dismissed. There shall be
no order as to costs.
As a sequel miscellaneous application/s pending if any shall stancl
closed. No ccsts
SD/. N.SRIHARI
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
I
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Charirman fVlotor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-Principal District Judge,
Warangerl.
2. One CC to SriA Ramakrishna Reddy, Advocate IOPUC]
3. One CC to Sri N Chandra Shekar, SC For RTC, Advocate [OPUC]
4. Two CD Copies
ABK /PSL
w
\
HIGH COURT
DATED: OGlO2l2O26
(
t
/.
.5
o
JUDGMENT
a:
i
MACMA.No.644 of 2O16
DISMISSING THE MACMA
WITHOUT COSTS
b
2o
q
^L
AT E OF
ttt T6
o'
:>
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE SIXTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL N O: 644 OF 2016
Between:
The Divisional Manager, United lndia lnsurance Co.Ltd, P.B.No. 75,
M.G. Road, Pochamma Maidan, Warangal
...Appellant / Respondent No.2
AND
1. Charabuddi Saritha, Wo late Muralidhar Reddy, Aged about 32 yrs, Occ:
Household
2. Charabuddi Jhansi Reddy, D/o late Muralidhar Reddy, Aged about 15 yrs,
Occ:Student
3. Charabuddi Varsha Reddy, D/o late Muralidhar Reddy, Aged about 12 yrs,
Student (Respondent No.2 to 3 being minors rep.by their mother and natural
guardian Respondent No.1 i.e., Ch. Saritha)
All are R/o H.No. 5-2-176, Kothur Hanamkonda, Warangal District
...Respondents 1 to 3/Petitioners 1 to 3
4. Nalla Buchi Reddy, S/o Ramakrishna Reddy, Aged 61 yrs, Occ: Business R/o
H.No 2-2-26, Naimnagar, Hanamkonda Warangal District
5. The Managing Director, APSRTC, RTC Office, Hyderabad
6. Charabodi Ram Reddy, S/o Chenna Reddy, Aged 65 yrs, Occ: Business
R/o H.No. 24-7-53, Fathimanagar Kazipet, Warangal District
...Respondents 4 to 6/Respondents 1,3 and 4
Appeal Under Section 173 of Motor Vehicles Act against the Judgment and
Decree in O.P.No. 293 of 2006 dated 12-01-2010 on the file of the Court of the
Chairman Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-Principal District Judge, Warangal.
ORDER: This appeal coming on for hearing and upon perusing the grounds of
appeal, the Judgment and Decree of the Tribunal and the material papers in the
MVoP and upon hearing the arguments of Sri A Ramakrishna Reddy, Advocate for
the Appellant i:nd of Sri N Chandra Shekar, SC For RTC, Advocate for the
Respondent No 5.
This Court doth Order and Decree as follows:
1. That :he MACMA be and hereby is dismissed.
2. That :here shall be no order as to costs in this appeal
SD/. N.SRIHARI
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
S CTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Chairman Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum_ rincipal District Judge,
Warangal
2. Two CD Copies
ABK/PSI,
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0610212026
DECREE
MACMA.No.6,44 ot 2O16
DISMISSING THE MACMA
WITHOUT CO$TS
fw.,
5fl^n
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review