Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34e1 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMl BHATTACHARYA
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN
KUMAR
WRIT APPEA LNO:1 528 0F 2017
writ Appear under crause 15-of the Letters patent against the order passed
dated
02-06-2017 in W.p. No. 26495 ot 2011. on the fite oi tne
Hign Court.
Between:
1. The District Collector,Hyderabad, Nampally Station Road, Hyderabad
2 Deputy Director of Survey & Land Records, Hyderabad oistrict, at iyderabad
3. The lt4andal Revenue Officer, Golkonda Mandal, Hyderabad, Districi
AND
...APPELLANTS /PET|T|ONERS
1. Sri Ayub Kamal, S/o Gulam triloinuddin, Aged 65 years, Occ Land Lord
Represented by his GpA Holder IVA Jabbar STo.Late tr,4ohd.Khaja,
aged about
50 years, Fyo.1-5-13/1 , Krishna Nagar Cotony, Bholakpur, lVtusieerabad,
Hyderabad
.....RESPONDENT/PETITIONER
2. M/s. Sandesh Estates (p) Ltd., company having his registered offices at prot
No.1112, MLAs Colony,.Road No.12, Banjara ni,s, nfOeraOaO, representeO
by their Director Sri.G-.Madhusudhan Reddy, S/o.G.Ram Reddy,'"q"J A
years, Occ Director of Company, R/o.plot No..l 112, MLAs Coionyi
Road
No..l 2, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
l\//s Gajjala Ram Reddy properties (p) Ltd., company having his registered
offices at Plot No.1 1 12, MLAs Colony, Road No.12, Banjara Hr:[s, Hyd-erabad,
represented by their Director Sri.G. Madhusudhan Reddy, S/o.G.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of company, Rr/o.plot trto.t t tz, rvllAs corony,
Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
4 M/s.Mouna Estates Private Ltd., company having his registered offices at plot
No.1112, MLAs Colony, Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, represented
by their Director Sri.G.tVladhusudhan Reddy, S/o.G.Ram Reddy, aged 4g
years, Occ Director of Company, R/o.ptot No.1112, MLAs Colonyl Road
No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
5 fVl/s.Sandesh constructions pvt. Ltd., company having his registered offices at
Plot No.1112, MLAs Colony, Road No.12, Bantara Hills, Hyderabad,
represented by their Director Sri.G.lVladhusudhan Rerl, y, S/o_G_Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of Company, Rt/o.plot lJ , 1 1 12, MLAs Colony,
Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
6. M/s.GVR Properties Private Ltd., company having hrr registered offices at
Plot No.1112, MLAs Cotony, Road No.12, Banla a Hills, Hyderabad,
represented by their Director Sri.G. Madhusudhan Rerk y,, S/c.G.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years Occ Director of Company, R/o.plot Nr . 1 .l 112, It/LAs Colony,
Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
7. lv1/s.Mouna Properties Private Ltd., company having lri ; registered offices at
Plot No.1112, MLAs Colony, Road No.12, Banj,r a Hills, Hyderabad,
represented by their Director sri.G.tr,4adhusudhan Recr y, S/o.G.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of Company, Ri/o.plot N( .l.l 12, MLAs Colony,
Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
B. It4/s G.s.R.Properties Private Ltd., company having h r registered offices at
Plot No.1112, tvllAs Colony, Road No.12, Banjzr a Hills, Hyderabad,
represented by their Director Sri.G. Madhusudhan Red: r Skr.G.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of Company, Fl/o.plot Nc - 1.12, IVLAs Colony.
Road No.12, Banjara Hrlls, Hyderabad
9. tt4/s.Gailala constructions private Ltd., company havin,; his registered offices
at Plot No. 1 1 't 2, t\,4LAs Colony, Road No.1 2, Barrja .a Hills, Hyderabad,
represented by their Director Sri.G.Madhusudhan Red i ,, S/c,.G.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of Company, Rl/o.plot Nr 1112, MLAs Colony,
Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
10. M/s.Life Style Homes private Ltd., company having h s registered
offices at
Plot No.1112, MLAs Colony, Road No.t2, Banlar I Hilts, Hyderabad,
represented by their Director s ri. G.lr4ad husudhan Rerirl , S/o G.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of Company, Rfo.plot N. .l 1.12, tvtlRs Colony,
Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
1'l .lv/s.GMR constructions Private Ltd., company having hi: registered otfices
at
Plot No.1112, I\,4LAs Cotony, Road No..12, Banja.r Hilrs, Hyderabad,
represented by their Director sri.G.Madhusudhan Redc, , S/o G.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of Company, Rl/o.plot Nc,. t.l 12, MLAs Colony,
Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
12. M/s.Harini Resorts & Properties private Ltd., company erving his registered
offices at Plot No 1112, N/LA. Colony, Road No.12, Barj rra Hiits, UyO"eraOaa,
represented by their Director Sri.G. Madhusudhan Reddi S/o.G.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of Company, Rt/o.plot Nc. .l 12, tULAs Colony,
Road No.12, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad
13. lv/s.GGR Properties Pnvate Ltd., company having hrs ergistered offices
at
Plot No.'l 112, IVLAs Cotony, Road No.12, Banjarz Hiils, Hyderabad,
represented by their Director Sri.G. Madhusudhan Reddy S/o.G.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of Company, Rl/o.plot No - 12, MLAs Colony,
Road No.1 2, Banjara Hitls, Hyderabad
14.M/s.Mouna constructions pvt.Ltd., company having his egistered offices at
Plot No.1112, tMLAs Colony, Road No.12, Binjarr Hills;, Hyderabad,
represented by their Director Sri.G.l\iladhusudhan Redd,r rs/o.13.Ram Reddy,
aged 48 years, Occ Director of Company, Fyo.plot No . .l 12, tr,,llAs Colony,
Road No.'l 2, Banlara Hitls, Hyderabad
15. Mrs.Punnam Premaleela, wife of Punnam Satyanarayana Reddy, occ
House-
wife, R/o.Buznoor Village, Huzoorabad, Karimnagar District
tO.Snair Yousuf, S/o.Shaik Mahmood, Occ: Business, R:/o'Himayath Nagar'
Hyderabad
tZ.av.Jagan Mohan Reddy, S/o.A.Venkat Reddy, Occ: Business, FVo'H'No'
'1 -33, tr/lalkaram Village, Chevella, Hyderabad
(Respondents 2to16 are impleaded as per court order dated 25.O9.2012 in
WPTVPS 655312012, 16417 I 201 2,227 9512012 respectively)
...RESPONDENTS /RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2017 (WAMP. NO: 2826 O F 20171
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
suspend
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to
passed in
the operation of the orders of Learned single Judge dated: 02-06-2017
W.P.No.26495 of 2O11, pending disposal of the Writ Appeal
I.A. N O: 2 OF 2018
B TWEEN
Sri Ayub Kamaal. S/o. Gulant MoinLrddin.
Aged about 65 years, Occ t_and t,ord
Represenred by his GpA Ilol(icr, \,1.A Jabbar,
S/o. Late Nlohd. K_haja. Aged abour 56 years,
Urc. l-5- l:/1. Krishna \ag.rr( olonr.
Rholakpur. Mrrshcerahad. IIrdcrrbrJ.
I',DlIl tO:. r t/ttEst,oNt)t:\.1
A\-D
l. The Distnct Collector. I IYderahad Disrricr.
Officc at Nampalh sration Road.
Hyd.:rabad.
2. The Deputy Director ofsurvc.r, & Land Rccords,
I{yderahad Disrricr al I l1 dcrabad
3. The Mandal Revenue Olficer.
Golkonda Mandal, Hyderabad District.
RESPONDENT -( r\ppEtLLANTS
4.
iVJ/s. Sandesh Esrares (1,) t_rd..
5.
M(..Gajala Rarn Reddy propenies (p) LlJ.,
6.
7.
8.
9.
t0
II
t2
I]
l4
t5
l6
l1
I8
l9
Ws.Mouna Estates private Ltd.,
M/s. Sandesh Constructions pvt. Lrd.
Ivl/s.CVR Propenies privatc [,td_.
Nfls. Mouna Properties privare Lrd
M/s. G.S.R. Properties privare Ltd.,
M/s. Gajjala Constructions private Ltd
M/s. Life Sryle tlomes l)rivare LILJ..
M/s. CMR Construclions pnvilc Lld..
Mh. Harir:i Resorts & l,ropenics pri\arc Lld
,
M,/s. GGR Propenies privale Lrd..
M/s. Mouna Construcrions p!,1. L;d..
Mrs. Pulrrant Premaleela, W/o. puruam Safy^nara),ana
Village. HuzoorabaJ, Kxfl tnnaAar Di5trrct.
Shaik.Yousuf, S/o. Shaik Mrlrrnood. Occ:
O;., ;;;1;r:';i":'i;.i
(Respondcnts No 4 to l9 are nor nccessarv pa(ies
(
f:, R/6,. !n2166r
Brrsirrcss, R-/o. IJimayath Nasar. Il\ I r,rbad
A.V. Jagan Motran Rcddv. S,o A Vg6ti31 R.ddi.
Villagc. Chevclla, HrcJeraiad.
Reddy, Occ: Ilotr;t.u
.
-31. Malkararn
in tlris petitior)
.. RESPONDENT:j R lsPor.rD[NTS
I
i
;
Petition under Section 1 51 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
Collector, Hyderabad District, to take all steps necessary for giving effect to the
report submitted by Deputy Director, Survey . Land record vide Letter No.
44139212002 dated 05. 09.2009
Counsel for the Appellant SRI P. SRIDHAR REDDY SPECIAL GP
THE ADVOCATE GENERAL
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRl. VEDULA VENKATARAMANA
SENIOR COUNSEL REP SRI VEDULA SRINIVAS
The Court made the following: ORDER
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TEL/\ {GANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHAT'T ICHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN - (UMAR
WRIT APPEAL No.1528 OF 201?
DATE: LO.O4.2O26
Between
The District Collector,
Hyderabad District, arnd 2 others
. r\ppellants
And
Sri Ayub Kamaal, Hydcrabad ancl 16 others
Respondents
Mr- P. Sridhar Recldl , tl.rc learned Spccial Govcrrlnrent Pl,. 1:r r(presentins
the learncd Advociltc Ger.lcr.rl appeanng lor the appellauts.
Mr. Vedula Vcnl(atarant.lnl, learnccl Scnior Cour-rscl
respondent No. 1/rvrit pet it roncr.
JUDGMENT:
1.
r ')rescnting thc
(l)er Ilon'blc Justi('c Moushuml Bhattaclt.r l]l
The Writ Appeal ariscs out ol an order da..< ) 02.06.2017
passed by a learned Single Judgc of this CoLlrt, rrs llis Lordship
then was, in W.P.No.2(r495 ol 2O11.
2.
'I'he responclent No. 1/writ petitioner filccl \V '.No.26495 of
2O11 sceking ir Writ of Manclarnus agilinst tltc :ilure of the
appellants, namely, thc District Collector, IJ., l,:ratrad, the
Deputy Direr:tor o[ Snrvcy al)d Lan(l Record s, ll ,, lerabad, and
the Mandal licvenue OiTiccr, Colkonrla Manclal. F vclerabad, ir-r
amending the concerned Revenue and Survey Records by
recording the petitioner,s name, in compliance with the order
passed by a learned Single Judge of this Court in W.p.No.3766
of 1997 and aflirmed by the Division Bench in W.A.No.435 of
7997. The writ petitioner also challenged the appellants, failure
to conduct peg marking on the writ petitioner,s land,
admeasuring 6403 squz\re meters in Survey No.144,
corresponding to TSLR No. i2/ 1 of Shaikpet Village, Golconda
Mandal, Hyde rabad District, as illcgal and arbitrary.
3.
By the impugncd ordcr datcd 02.06.2017, the learned
Single Judgc allowecl W. p.No.26495 of 2011 filed by the
respondent No. l/u,rit
petitioner and directed the
appe llants / State of Tclangana to amcnd the concerned Revenue
and Survey Records by recording the name of the writ
petitioner. The learned Single Judge further directed the
appellants to put peg-marks on the writ petitioner,s land as per
the Survey Report of thc respondent No.2/Deputy Director,
Surr.ey and Land Records, Hyderabad (appellant No.2 herein)
dated 05.09.20O9 forthu,ith.
Several Writ Petitions were disposed of by the impugnecl
Common Ordcr. Thc preselt t Writ Appeal challenges the
impugned Common Order insofar as it relates to r /.p.No.26495
of 2O1l filed by the respondent No. 1
5.
.
The learned Speciat Government pleader a;;p rrring for the
appellants argues that the respondent No. 1/r., it petitioner
played fraucl on the Court bv misrepresenting r,l .r facls. It is
contended that the petitioner's entire claim is lrased on a
Certihcate of Sale dated ,2.04. 199 i for an cxt(.r L. of hcs.3_37
guntas of land in Suruey No.l29 /T I ancl thert th,. I)ctrtioner is
mischievously claiming Acs.6-37 guntas in thc : unc Survey
Number without any documentary evidence. [t is a r r, contended
that the petitioner sold the entire Acs.3-37 gunl r; of lancl in
Survey No.i44 to one RVS Chowdary under a Srr : Deed uide
document No.l 192 o[ 1962, there by e_\tinrr ishing the
petitioner's title.
The Special Government plc: ler further
submits that the petitioncr concealed this alien:rri ,rr frcm the
Writ Court and that the Surveyor submittecl ar . tlse Rcport
without any authority or direction from thc Cour.t It is zrlso
argued that the petitioner is attempting to grn r th,: 12r,16
belonging to the Government since the property sr I , r.ycd forms
part of Survey No.403.
6.
Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the -:spondent
No.1/writ petitioner places relevant paragraph:; frorn the
counter-affidavit filed by the appellants to the Writ Petition
averring that'the Court may pass such other orders as it deems
ht and proper and in the interest of justice'. Senior Counsel
submits that this averment shows that the appellants are not
seriously challenging the impugned Common Order. Senior
Counsel further refers to the Surve_v Report dated O5.O9.2O09
and urges that the said Suruey Report does not confer or divest
the State/ appellants of any subsisting title and that the sole
objective of sunrey and demarcation is the physical
identihcation of the land through pcg marking.
7.
We have heard tl-re competing submissions made on
behalf of the appellants and thc respondent No.1/writ
petitioner
8.
The facts relevant to the adjudication of the Writ Appeal
are as follows:
9.
The writ petitioner purchased Acs.6,37 guntas of lancl in
Survey No.l29/7'1, subsequently renumbered as Survey No.144
of Shaikpet Village, Banjerra Hills, in .rn auction held by the
Settlement Custodian of Evacuee Property, Bombay, on
22.04.7961. Pursuant to the said auction, a Sale Certihcate was
issued in favour of the writ petitioner specifically delineating the
boundaries of the property.
10. One Narain @ Narayan Bhavanani filed C.LNo. 118 of
1968 before the III Additional Judge, City { ivil Court,
Secunderabad, seeking perpetual injunction agi]:r st the writ
petitioner in respect of the land admeasuring Acs . . 15 llurltas,
bearing Plot No.7, Municipal No.8-2- l2O/1O2. ;itr-rated in
Survey No. 151/4, Road No.3, Jubilee Hilts, H1.tt, r abad. The
Suit was decreed on 20.03.1971. Challenging ,lr, s21'',., ,n.
writ pctitioncr hled an Appeal (C.C.C.A.No.94 o1'1)72) bcfore
the High Court. The Appeal was disposed of on I I.0:r.1975,
whereby the decree was modified by adding lre rvords:
'exclu ding the tiangular cone added in pencil
t me
usuring
Ac.O.16 gts onla and uhich ls said to be ouerlappirtg it Sy.No. 144
in Ex.B-19' at the e nd of Clause No.1 of the decrr:r' r;f the Trial
Cou rt.
1. Narayan Bhavanani then filed E.P.No.45 l 1975 for
exectrtion of the decree in O.S.No.1 18 of 1968 ancl f r clelivery of
possession of Plot No.7 bearing Municipal No.8 t-12O / t02.
During the pendency of the Execution Proceedin: ; . Nirrayan
Bhavanani passed away and his legal representati,, :i came on
record. The decree was executed and possession r,. i s cle livered
to thr: legal representatives of the plaintiff includin.i lu4rs. Laxmi
Bhavzrnani, wife of Narayan Bhavanani.
12. The writ petitioner hted E.A.No.38 of 1976 in E.P.No.4S of
1975 seeking redelivery of possesslon of property in Survey
No.144 to him contending that the Civil Court granted
permanent injunction and therefore the question of delivering
possession to the piaintiff does not arise. The E.A. was allowed
and redelivery of possession of property u,as ordered in favour of
the writ petitioner. The writ petitioner thereafter hled E.P.No.33
of 1981 for execution of the order passed in E.A.No.38 of 1976
and the said E.P. was also allowed.
13. Laxmi Bhavanani filed C.R.P.No. 1535 of 1972 against the
order of redelivery passed in E.A.No.38 of 1976. The C.R.P. was
dismissed and the said order became tinal. Accordingly, a
portion of the land in Survey No. 144 rvas delivered to the writ
petitioner.
14. Subsequently, Laxmi Bhavanani filecl E.A.No.15 of 1984
in E.P.No.33 of 1981 lor redelivery of possession of Acs.3.15
guntas of land (described as Plot No.7 lorming part of Survey
No.151/4) asserting that the said land belongs to Narayan
Bhavanani. The Executing Court found that the r,vrit petitioner
had taken possession of Acs.2.39 guntas of land belonging to
Narayan Bhavanani over and above Acs-O,16 guntas of land,
which was already delivered. Consequently, the trxecuting
-
Court allowed tr.A.No.15 of 1984 directing the wril retirioner to
redeliver the possession of Acs.3.15 guntas of lit I I in Suney
No. 151/4, exclucling a triangular portion admeasu- rg Acs.0. 16
guntas overlapping with Survey No. 144.
15. Challenging the order passed in E.A.No. 15 c - 19!)4. the
writ petitioner filed C.R.p.No.317 of 199O and tht sarlrc was
dismissed. The writ petitioner carried the matter t() : rt Slrpreme
Court in Civil Appeal No.5024 of 7991which was rlis ;ost.rl of on
I 8. I 2. 199 1 u,ith
a clarification that the triangula r porr ion of
Acs.O. i6 guntas of land shall be treated as the prr,1 r.rt,1, of thc
writ petitioner and it should be in his possession.
16. The Writ Petitioner filed W.p.No.3766 of 1997 r irestioning
G.O.Ms.No. 461, by which the Government allottr r 9Oli9 sq.
mts. of surplus land belonging to Mr. Narayan llh r.yanirni in
favour of the Andhr:r pradesh Film Development ::rporation
("Film Development Corporation.). The State, rl r: Special
Officer, Urban Land Ceiling (,ULC), the Collector, lyclerabad
District, the Mandal Revenue Officer, Hyderabacl iL Lrl ttre Ap
State Film Development Corporation were parties r the said
Writ Petition.
17. The Writ Petition was allowed on 21.O3.1997 rrlyirLg on
the view taken by the Supreme Court in Civil Appeal I o.5O24
of
1991 that a part of Sy.No.15L /4 in Plot No-7 juts into Sy.No. 144
in a triangular shape and cannot be treated as the land of
Narayan Bhavanani. The Writ Court also held that the
Government of Andhra Pradesh or any of the respondents to the
Writ Petition cannot have any claim in respect of the land in
Sy.No.144, which belongs to A)'ub Kamal.
18. The Special Ofhcer, ULC, along with three others, filed
W.A.No.435 of 1997 , which was dismissed on 04.O7 .1,997 . A
Review Petition Iiled against the aforesaid order was also
subsequently dismissed.
19. The Writ Petitioner hled W.P.No.26413 of 20O I against the
Government and Smt. Laxmi Bhavanani and her family
members questioning the FIR registered by the Station House
Olficer ('SHO'), P.S. Banjara Hills and for a direction to refrain
the respondents from interfering with his possession of the land
in Sy.No.129l71 (o1d Sy.No.144).
20.
A compromise was entered into betvveen Ayub Kamal and
Smt. Laxmi Bhavanani during the pendency of the Writ Petition
and the Writ Petition was hence disposed of on I ),.1O.2OO2
directing the District Collector, Hyderabad and the
Commissioner, Survey, Settlement and Land Records, to
conduct a Survey and demarcate Plot No.7 in Sy.No. 151/4
I
belonging to the Bhavanani family ald the land rr Sy'.No. 144
(old) belonging to A]rub Kamal
21 .
The Dcputy Director, Survey and [,2 r rl
Iiecords,
conducted tlie Survey as per the directions of thr: I igh Court in
W.P.No.26413 of 2001 and submitted a Il 'lrort dated
05.09.2009 to the Collector, Hyderabad.
22.
The Survey Report stated , inter alia, that th,'r : is no piece
of Government land between Plot No.7 and Sy.No. L 14. Furthcr,
the southern part of Sy.No.144, after excluding t te road and
buildings, was demarcated as 6403 sq. mts. (irr lruour of thc
petitioner) and 76O sq. mts. as Government land.
23. Ayub Kamal accordingly hled W.P.No.26495 'tf 2C)11 (the
Writ Petition in the present Appeal) seeking impl,: nent.ation of
the Survey conducted by the Deputy Director ,r r f,5.09.2o09
and for putting peg-marks in his land in accorcllr. r:e vzith the
Su rvey Report.
24. The family members of Narayan Bhavanl r i al:;o filed
W.P.No.l7503 of 2O15 contending that the Survey I .r:port clated
05.09.2009 cannot not be implemented. However, 1te srLid Writ
Petition was dismissed by the impugned c -ler
02.06.2017.
clated
r0
25. It would be clear from the above narration of facts that
the issue in the Writ Petition was essentially a dispute between
the Writ Petitioner (A1'ub Kamal) and Narayan Bhavanani.
However, in the present Appeal, the State has contested the
impugned order essentially on the ground that it could not urge
these points before the Division Bench in W.A.No.435 of 1997
and that the Writ Petitioner's claim for demarcation of land
cannot be sustained.
26. It is also significant that Narayan Bhavanani is no longer
in the picture as the Writ Appeals hled by his family, namely
W.A.Nos.166O of 2077 and 7646 of 20L7 , were subsequently
dismissed as withdrawn by orders dated 19 .O3.2O24 and
07.06.2024, respectively. Hence, there is no contest made by
Narayan Bhavanani's family to the claim of the petitioner in
respect of the subject land of 6403 sq. mts., as found in the
Survey Report, as on date.
27.
Moreover, the objections raised by the appellants / Statc in
respect of the Survey Report of O5.09.2OO9 have been raised for
the frrrst time in the Writ Appeal rn 2017. The appellants havc
in fact disputed the authority of the Deputy Director, Survey
and Land Records, to conduct the Survey or referred to a
Revenue Survey Village Map for demarcation of Sy.No.144
ll
without challenging the said Survey Report by an ndependent
Writ Petition. The State has also disputed the hr Jings of the
Supreme Court with regard to Ex. B 19 (described t [- : exhibit) as
not being binding on it.
28. [t is further significant that the appellants dil notpray for
dismissal of the Writ Petition even though thelr rere parties
before thc learned Single Judge and in fact have ma le a specific
statement in their Counter Affidavit that the Appe a Cotrrt may
be pleased to pass any orders as it deems fit in tl-r ' intr:rest of
justice. The appellants have not filed any Additit ral Oounter
therealter to modify their stand.
29.
Hence, u,e are of the considered view that th . appellants
cannot disown the Survey Report of the Deputy Dir: ::or, Survey
and Land Rccords, dated O5.O9.2O09, since the zrid Survey
Report has not been challenged by the State or st terst:ded at
any point of time thereafter.
30. The contentions raised on behalf of the erp.,r:llants are
also untenable since the only direction given by lre learned
Single Judge was to implement the Survey Report { rrd nothing
more. It is worthwhile to mention that implemer tation of a
Survey Report would not confer or denude the appel ants of any
right in respect of title to the land. The object < f a Survey
t2
-
demarcatron is only to locate the land for the purpose of
identihcation by putting peg marks.
Hence, it
is
incomprehensible as to how the appellants would be
prejudicially affected by the directions given in the impugned
order since they have not claimed any title to the subject land of
6403 sq. mts. in R.S.No.144/129/71' In any event, the
impugned order does not prevent the State from making a claim
with regard to its title. The appellants have in fact admitted to
their failing to bring facts and documents before the High Court
in the earlier Writ Petition and Writ Appeal'
31.
We also cannot ignore the settled position in law that the
Appellate Court must restrain itself and interfere with the
judgment passed by a learned Single Judge in intra-Court
Appeals only if the judgment is perverse or suffers from an error
apparent in law1.
32. On the other hand, S.P. Chengaluarayo Naidu (dead) by
LRs u. Jagannath (dead) bg LRs and others2 does not assist the
appellants since paragraph No.5 of the said decision dwelt on
the abuse of the process of Court by property grabbers, tax
evaders and other unscrupulous persons. We fail to see how
the respondent No. 1/Wrlt Petitioner can Lre categorized under
Airports Authority Of India v. Pradip Kumar Banerjee, (2025) 4 SCC 11 1
' (1994)1scci
I
l3
any of the aforesaid descriptions. Similarly, R. Htt, ttmaiah and-
another u. SecretarA to Gouernment of Karnate :o., l?euenue
Department and others:r observed that Courts o.:r: a duty to
remain vigilant to ensure that public property is I )t converted
into private property by unscrupulous elements. TL: apltellants
have not shown any act or evidence which would p: s;uacle
label the petitioner as unscrupulous or as ha,r ng
us to
6;rabbed
public property through illegal means.
33. The Survey Report, which forms the basrs :f the Writ
Petitioner's claim, makes it evident from the very firs , paragraph
that the Survey was conducted by the Deputy Dirr: tor, Survey
and Land Records on the specific instructions :ss red by the
District Collector, Hyderabad by letter dated 20.O5.! Ct09 for
the
purpose of demarcating land belonging to Ayr : Karnal
in
Sy.No.129/71, correlating with Revision Sy.No. 144
)r. Sh.aikpet
Village. Hence, admittedly, the Writ petitioner did rr ,1
have any
role in the conduct of the Survey or the findingsT
r
c,nclusions
arrived at therein. The Survey Report remains ar
z
i tabl,: with
the Olfice of the Deputy Director as on date.
34. Therefore, our reasons for conhrming the imp:
of the iearned Single Judge may be summed up
(zoro) s scc 2o3
thus:
lned order
t4
35. The Survey Report dated 05.09.2009, which formed the
subject matter of the Writ petition filed by the respondent No. 1
with regard to demarcating the land belonging to the writ
petitioner in Sy.No. l29/71 (old) corresponding to Revision
Sy.No. 144 pursuant to
the orders passed by this Court,
remained un-challenged by the State frorn 2OO9 till 2Ol5 (tilt
hling of the Writ Petition). The Survey was done at the behest of
lhe Stale respondenls, namely, the District Collector,
Hyderabad and the Deputy Director, Survey and Land Records.
Hence, the State cannot ignore, dispute or seek to disown the
Survey Report. Further, the Survey Report clearly mentions
that 6403 square meters falling to the share of the petitioner is
distinct and different from 76O square meters which was
described as 'Government Land,. A map was enclosed with the
Survcy Report.
36.
The only dispute made to the Survey Report came from
the Bhavanani family in the form of W.p.No.17503 of 20 15
which was dismissed by the impugned order dated 02.06.2017.
The Bhavanani's Appeals from the dismissal were subsequentiy
withdrawn on 19.O3.2024 and, 07.06.2024. Hence, the
recordings in the Survey Report attained hnality by reason of
being un-challenged from 2009 to 2O1S.
t5
37.
The weakness of the appellants' argument 'r tuld also be
evident from the specihc stand taken in the Countt'; I,hat several
points could not be urged before the Division il'nch of this
Court in W.A.No.435 of 1997. [t is relevant that t te said Writ
Appeal hled by the Special Officer, Urban Lr nd Ceiling,
Hyderabad, was dismissed on 04.O7.1997. Aclr tLttedly, the
appellants clid not carry the challenge from t te order of
dismissal to the Supreme Court. This Corrr t also finds
substance in the argument made on behalf of the .r -it pctitioner
that the appe llants failcd to challenge the Survey . :port- within
the statutory timeframe of The Telangana Land F evenue Act,
13 17-Fasti.
38.
Last and most important, the appellants ha,, ' not shown
any fundamental prejudice to the order passed l;'the Single
Judge whereby the concerned Authorities were rlir:r:ted to put
peg-marks on the land as per the Survey 1l ,port dated
05.09.2009.
39. As already stated above, implementation of r-he Survey
Report would not denude the appellants of any vt:l-rabl<: rights
with regard to title to the land in question. 1'1rr app6llanl"
cannot be permitted at this belated stage to contes the Survey
Report dated 05.09.2009, when the concerr ed private
l6
respondents (Bhavanani's family) withdrew their Appeal to the
impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge' Hence,
there is no private party dispute in respect of the subject land of
6403 square meters claimed by the writ petitioners, as on date'
40. The above reasons persuade us to uphold the impugned
order dated 02.06.2O17 and conclude that the appellants have
not been able to establish any case against the said impugned
order to the extent of the directions issued by the learned Single
Judge in W.P.No.26495 of 2O1 1.
47. W.A.No. 1528 of 2Ol7 , along with alt connected
applications, is accordingly dismissed. There shall be no order
as to costs
SD/. N.SRIHARI
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To,
TwoCCstoTHEADVoCATEGENERAL'HighCourtfortheStateof
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
2 one cc to sRl. VEDULA SRINIVAS Advocate [oPUC]
3 Two CD Copies
BM
PSK
CCTODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1010412026
o 1EL,
.\
L. i,
i$,
+*
ty
(_)
LL
JUDGMENT
.,1
(L,l
JS
.{.
WA.No.1528 ol 2017
ti0i
DISMISSING THE WRIT APPEAL WITH(: UT COSTS
lLr;
1,.,,1+.ltt
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review