The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
21. Let us take the first question first - whether these transaction had been carried out in accordance with the provisions of Section 187(1) of the Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms Act, 1960. The answer must be in the negative inasmuch as the society as registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 by any stretch of interpretation cannot be treated firstly as individual or collectively as tribal. The entities which are exempted under Section 187 of the TLR & LR Act are clearly stipulated. Barring those entities, none else can be permitted to engage themselves in transfer of land from a tribal person by the soute. Even coming in the possession after 01.01.1969 over the land belonging to a tribal person by a non-tribal person or entities shall be grossly illegal. By way of 6th Amendment Act in the TLR & LR Act, 1960 has been made a punishable offence, subject to the notification. In view of this observation, the contention as raised by Mr. K.N. Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel are reflected in the question No.2 above, shall fall through inasmuch as the “society” in terms of the Societies Registration Act, 1860 holds their movable or immovable property if not in the name of trustees but in the name of the board of governments the governing body, in terms of their own memorandum of association and by laws. No individual is permitted to hold any property by the name o…
27. 07.2013 are set aside and quashed. But the matter would not end here. This court would further direct the Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Revenue Department to remit the matter to the Sub Divisional Magistrate, the designated authority, for deciding whether the land in question should be restored or not, in terms of the petition filed by the Page - 12 of 16 petitioners [Annexure P/3 to the writ petition] within a time frame what shall be laid by the Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Revenue Department.
22. Before parting with the records, it is to be noted that this court would be failing in its duties, if it is not mentioned that any transaction which is carried out in violation of Section 187 of the TLR & LR Act even by the registered instrument as is in the present case by the registered gift deeds, shall be treated as void for all purposes. Having observed thus, this writ petition stands allowed to the extent as stated above………….” [13] Heard Mr. Soumendu Roy learned counsel appearing for the appellant as well as Mr. M. Debbarma, learned counsel appearing for the respondents. [14] Mr. Roy, learned counsel for the appellant has argued that the society represented by the appellant is engaged in promotion of education and welfare of the tribal communities. The members of the governing body of the society of the appellant are mostly tribals and more particularly the recipient of the gift deeds was also tribal and appreciating these facts the District Collector as well as the Secretary to the Revenue Department held that the transfer of land between respondents No.1 & 2 and the appellant was a transaction from tribal to tribal and as such there was no application to Section 187(1) of the TLR & LR Act. Counsel submits that there is no error in the findings of the District Collector and that of the Secretary to the Page - 13 of 16 Revenue Department which should have been upheld by t…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page - 1 of 16
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 50/2017
The Director,
Don Bosco Centre, Bishramganj, PO and PS- Bishramganj,
District- Sepahijala, Tripura.
………. Appellant(s).
Vs.
1.
Smt. Putul Rani Debbarma.
wife of Sri Sashi Kumar Debbarma, Resident of Dhaleswar,
Kalyani, P.O.- Agartala College, P.S.- East Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura.
2.
Sri Sashi Kr. Debbarma,
Son of late Surendra Ch. Debbarma, Resident of Dhaleswar,
Kalyani, P.O.- Agartala College, P.S.- East Agartala, DistrictWest Tripura. (Represented by their constituted Attorney
son Sri Madan Debbarma having the same address)
3.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary, Government of Tripura,
Revenue Department, New Capital Complex, P.O.Kunjaban, P.S.- East Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin799010.
4.
The Secretary,
Government of Tripura, Revenue Department, New Capital
Complex, P.O.- Kunjaban, P.S.- East Agartala, District- West
Tripura, Pin- 799010.
………….Respondent(s).
BEF0RE
HON‟BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
For Appellant(s)
:
Ms. Soumendu Roy, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing
:
30th March, 2022.
Date of Judgment & Order :
30th March, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
YES
:
Page - 2 of 16
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (Oral)
(Per S.G. Chattopadhyay, J.)
The present writ appeal is directed against the judgment
and order dated 04.09.2017 passed by the learned Single Judge in
WP(C) No. 306 of 2013.
[2]
Appellant is a registered society engaged in running
vocational training centres, schools and residential boarding houses
for tribal students. It is represented by the director duly appointed by
the society. Respondents No.1 and 2 who were the petitioners in
WP(C) No. 306 of 2013 executed gift deed number 1-8912 dated
02.11.1999, gift deed No.1-11315 dated 26.12.2003 and gift deed
No. 1-572 dated 17.01.2004 transferring a tract of land in favour of
the appellant society. Subsequently, the said respondents by filing a
petition approached the Revenue Court of the District Collector for
restoration of their land under section 187B of the Tripura
Revenue and Land Reforms Act,
1960 (TLR & LR
Land
Act, 1960 for
short) which was rejected by the District Collector. Appeal against
the order of the District Collector was also rejected by the revisional
authority. Thereafter, by filing WP(C) No. 306 of 2013 respondents
No.1 and 2 claimed that the transfer of land made by them in favour
Page - 3 of 16
of the appellant by executing the aforesaid gift deeds was illegal, void
and dehors the provisions of section 187 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960
and order passed by the District Collector and the revisional
authority were completely erroneous. The respondents sought for the
following reliefs in their writ petition:
”(i)
Issue notice upon the respondents;
(ii)
Call for records;
(iii)
Issue Rule calling upon the respondents to show
cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari not be issued calling
upon the respondents to produce all the records relating to
the restoration proceeding before this Hon‟ble Court and on
consideration of the records set aside the order dated
27.07.2013 passed by the Secretary, Government of Tripura,
Revenue Department in connection Revenue case
no.12/Rev/Revision Secy/2011 and the order dated
07.06.2011 passed by the Ld. Presiding Officer of the Ld.
Court of District Collector, West Tripura, Agartala, in
connection with the Revenue Case No.375/09,
AND
(iv)
Also pass an order/direction by way of issuing a Writ
of Mandamus to restore the land in favour of the petitioners
by way of declaring the deeds of transfer as illegal and void
and dehors the provisions of Section 187 of the TLR and LR
Act, 1960
AND
To pass any other order/orders as Your Lordship may
deem it fit and proper………….”
[3]
The grievance of the respondents as unfolded by them in
their writ petition was that they had approached the Jurisdictional
Sub-Divisional Magistrate at Bishalgarh under Section 187B of the
TLR & LR Act, 1960 for restoration of the land as purportedly
Page - 4 of 16
transferred by those gift deeds. Since the Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Bishalgarh who is the designated authority did not take any action,
the respondents had approached the District Collector of the
concerned district (now Shepahijala District) by filing a petition under
Section 95 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 which was registered as
Revenue Case No. 375 of 2009. The District Collector by his order
dated 07.06.2011 [Annexure P/4 to the writ petition] passed in
Revenue Case No. 375 of 2009 held that respondent No.1, Smt. Putul
Rani Debbarma transferred her land to the appellant who was also a
tribal. Therefore, bar under Section 187 of the TLR & LR Act,
1960 in respect of transferring of land owned by tribal to non-tribal
would not apply and accordingly, the petition of respondent No.1 was
rejected by the District Collector by the following order:
“07.06.2011
............Heard both sides Ld. Advocates. Perused SDM
Bishalghar enquiry report. Hon‟ble High Court order. Others
documents produced by the parties.
Hon‟ble Gauhati High Court order & direction dated 9/3/2011
upon the D.M. & Collector, West Tripura was as follows:“ the D.M. & Collector, West Tripura, Agartala will
dispose of the application of the petitioners at an early
date in accordance with law providing opportunity to
the respondent No.4 also. As the petitioners filed the
application in the year 2009 this court further hope and
trust that the respondents statutory authority will try
for disposal of the petitioners‟ application preferably
within six months from the date of receipt of this
order.”
Page - 5 of 16
Accordingly Law cell of this office sent the Hon‟ble High
Court Order dated 09.03.2011 to the SDM Bishalgarh vide
No.F.DM(W)/Law Cell/W.P.(C) 67 of 2011/1061-63 dated
18th April 2011 for compliance of the same within a period of
6(six) months positively. SDM Bishalgarh was also requested
to furnish a status report about the action taken on the
application under section 187(1)(2) & (3) of the TLR & LR Act
1960 of the said party. A copy was also sent to Revenue Court
Case Cell for similar action.
Accordingly institute a Revenue Case U/S 95 of the TLR & LR
Act, 1960. An enquiry report is also received from the SDM
Bishalgarh vide No.2665/F.4(42)/SDM/BLG/REV/09 dated
09.03.2011. It appears from the enquiry report that the
entire impugned was allottee. The land was mutated in
favour of the representative of the Director, Don Bosco
Centre. Ld. Advocate for respondent stated that the
impugned land was gifted land by the petitioner. However on
scrutiny it appears that the petitioner filed her petition U/S
187 of the TLR & LR Act 1960. Her petition was wrongly
admitted U/S 95 of the TLR & LR Act 1960. Power of U/S 187
of the TLR & LR Act 1960 is vested to SDMs by the Revenue
Department Vide No.F.83(2)/REV/73(S) dated 07.12.2001.
It also appears that the matter in between the parties is and
are both Tribal so U/S 187 of the TLR & LR Act is also not
applicable in the instant petition.
Under the above circumstances the petition of Smti. Putul
Rani Debbarma filed U/S 187(1)(2) & (3) of the TLR & LR Act,
1960 is rejected.”
[4]
Aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the order of the District
Collector, respondent No.1 (writ petitioner) filed revisional application
before the Secretary to the Government of Tripura in the Revenue
Department. Her application was registered as 12/Rev/Revision/
Secy/2011 which was dismissed by the Revenue Secretary by his
order dated 27.07.2013 on the ground that the transfer of land was
from tribal to tribal as the donor was admittedly a tribal and the
Page - 6 of 16
recipient of the gift deed was also a tribal. The order of the Revenue
Secretary reads as under:
Sl.No. &
Date
27.07.2013
Order & Signature of the Officer
Note of
Action
taken on
order
Ld. Advocate Sri Arijit Debnath is present on behalf of
appellant. Father K.K. Joseph appeared as respondent. Ld.
Advocate for the 1st party raised the point that the transfer of
land concerned is illegal and invalid, U/S 187 of TLR & LR
Act, 1960.
On the other hand the respondent declared that the transfer
was from tribal to tribal as the recipients of the deed was Sri
Uttam Molsom who belongs to tribal community.
Hearing the parties I find no reasonable ground for
interfere with the order passed by the Collector.
Hence revision petition is dismissed.
Inform to all concerned parties.
Typed to my dictation
& corrected by me.
Sd/(S. Saha)
Secretary, Revenue
[5]
Sd/(S. Saha)
Secretary, Revenue
As stated, the respondents being petitioners challenged
the said order dated 27.07.2013 passed by Revenue Secretary by
filing WP(C) No.306 of 2013.
[6]
The appellant (respondent No. 3 in the writ petition)
contested the case by filing counter affidavit. It was contended by
the appellant (respondent No.3) before the learned Single Judge that
after the execution of the gift deeds by respondents No.1 and 2 (writ
petitioners), the right title and interest of the respondents over the
Page - 7 of 16
land of those deeds were extinguished. The appellant became the
possessor and absolute owner of those land which was being used by
the appellant for promotion of education to all particularly the
Christians and for promotion of peace and harmony in society. The
appellant further contended that the respondents executed the gift
deeds voluntarily in free exercise of their will and moreover, the
institute run by the appellant was managed by St. Xavier’s
Bishramganj, a society registered under the Societies Registration
Act, 1860 which was always represented by a tribal as its director.
The appellant (respondent No.3) asserted that since, it was a transfer
from tribal to tribal, the bar under Section 187 of the TLR & LR Act,
1960 would not apply in this case. Respondents No.1 and 2 i.e. the
State respondents of the writ petition by filing separate counter
affidavit also opposed the contention of the writ petitioner and
asserted that the District Collector by his order dated 07.06.2011 in
revenue case number 375/2009 quite correctly rejected the claim of
the petitioner on the ground that both the parties were tribal
whereas Section 187 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 deals with the matter
with regard to transfer of land between tribal and non- tribal and
therefore, the said transfer does not come within the purview of
Section 187 of TLR & LR Act, 1960. The State respondents also
Page - 8 of 16
supported the order dated 27.07.2013 passed by the Revenue
Secretary in revenue case number 12/Rev/Revision/Secy/2011
rejecting the revisional application of the writ petitioners.
[7]
Counsel appearing for the writ petitioners argued before
the learned Single Judge that barring the entities curved out in
Section 187(1)(c), no other person can be exempted from the rigours
of section 187(1) of the TLR & LR Act, 1960. Counsel argued that the
procedure followed by the Sub- Divisional Magistrate as well as the
District Collector in deciding the disputes between the parties was
grossly erroneous and unsustainable in law. Counsel also argued that
a society in terms of the Societies Registration Act, 1860 cannot be
put into the jacket of a tribal for the purpose of Section 187 of the
TLR & LR Act, 1960. Counsel argued before the learned Single Judge
that there is no question to hold that the property if purchased by a
society even if being represented by a tribal person, can be treated
that the transaction was made to a tribal person.
[8]
Counsel who appeared for the appellant (respondent No.3
in the writ petition) argued before the learned Single Judge that from
the composition of the governing body of the appellant, it would be
apparent that most of the members of the said governing body
Page - 9 of 16
belonged to tribal community and since majority of the members
were from tribal community, the society must be treated as having
the trappings of tribal society and thus, it should be treated as the
“tribal entity” for the purpose of Section 187(1) of the TLR & LR Act,
1960.
[9]
The counsel for the appellant also argued that the
appellant (respondent No.3 in the writ petition) was working
dedicatedly for the development of tribal community and as such
they were also protecting the interest of the tribal community in line
with the fundamental object of TLR & LR Act, 1960.
[10]
Counsel
appearing
for
the
State-respondents
(respondents No.1 and 2 in the writ petition) argued before the
learned Single Judge that the writ petition was not maintainable
because the petitioners should have approached the Civil Court
before approaching the High Court in a writ petition. Counsel argued
that there was no breach of Section 187 (1) of the TLR & LR Act,
1960 in the alleged transaction since the transaction took place
between two tribals. Counsel relied on the following averment made
by the State-respondents in their counter affidavit:
“It is pertinent to mention here that it was also observed by
the learned District Collector that the subject matter of the
case for which the petitioner had sought relief is not related
Page - 10 of 16
with the Section 187 of the TLR and LR Act, since both the
parties concerned of the case were tribal whereas case
under Section 187 of the TLR and LR deals with the matter
between tribal and non tribal. As such, the learned Collector
rejected the claim of the petitioners in accordance with law
and within the ambit of the TLR and LR Act, 1960.”
[11]
The Learned Single Judge on appreciation of the
submissions made by the counsel representing the parties arrived at
the conclusion that the alleged transfer of land was not carried out in
accordance with the provisions of Section 187 (1) of the TLR & LR
Act, 1960. Learned Single Judge also held that in terms of the
Societies Registration Act 1860, the movable or immovable property
of a society are held in the name of the society and no individual can
be permitted to hold any property by the name of the society.
Therefore, the question of the person representing the society being
a tribal was irrelevant.
[12]
It was further held by the learned Single Judge that the
order dated 07.06.2011 passed by the District Collector in revenue
case number 375/ 2009 and order dated 27.07.2013 passed by the
Revenue
Secretary
as
revisional
authority
in
case
number
12/Rev/Revision/Secy/2011 were passed wholly on a wrong premise
that the transaction was between two tribal individuals. Observation
of the learned Single Judge is reproduced herein below:
Page - 11 of 16
“……20. Having appreciated the submission made by the
learned counsel appearing for the parties the pertinent
questions those require answer from this court are as under :
1. Had the transaction been carried out in violation of
Section 187(1) of the TLR & LR Act, 1960?
2. Can the Don Bosco Centre be treated as „tribal‟ for
purpose of Section 187(1) of the TLR & LR Act, 1960? and
3.Are the orders passed by the District Collector and the
Secretary to the Government of Tripura, Revenue
Department are sustainable in law?
21. Let us take the first question first - whether these
transaction had been carried out in accordance with the
provisions of Section 187(1) of the Tripura Land Revenue and
Land Reforms Act, 1960. The answer must be in the negative
inasmuch as the society as registered under the Societies
Registration Act, 1860 by any stretch of interpretation cannot
be treated firstly as individual or collectively as tribal. The
entities which are exempted under Section 187 of the TLR &
LR Act are clearly stipulated. Barring those entities, none else
can be permitted to engage themselves in transfer of land
from a tribal person by the soute. Even coming in the
possession after 01.01.1969 over the land belonging to a
tribal person by a non-tribal person or entities shall be
grossly illegal. By way of 6th Amendment Act in the TLR & LR
Act, 1960 has been made a punishable offence, subject to the
notification. In view of this observation, the contention as
raised by Mr. K.N. Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel are
reflected in the question No.2 above, shall fall through
inasmuch as the “society” in terms of the Societies
Registration Act, 1860 holds their movable or immovable
property if not in the name of trustees but in the name of the
board of governments the governing body, in terms of their
own memorandum of association and by laws. No individual
is permitted to hold any property by the name of the society.
Therefore the said contention is rejected. As regards the final
question that whether those orders dated 07.06.2011 passed
by the District Collector, West Tripura, Agartala in Revenue
Case No.375 of 2009 [Annexure P/4 to the writ petition] and
dated 27.07.2013 passed by the Secretary to the Revenue
Department in Case No.12/Rev/Revision/Secy/2011 are valid
or not, it has to be clearly stated that those were passed
wholly on a wrong premise, holding that the transaction was
between two tribal individuals. Such observation has
emanated from the fact that the society was represented by a
tribal person for purpose of accepting the gift. But in the gift
deed, the society is the donee. It is unfortunate that senior
functionaries of the state administration who are entrusted
with the powers to be exercised under the statute are
deciding the matters in such a casual manner without
applying their mind and having no regard to the provisions of
law. Thus both the impugned orders dated 07.06.2011 and
27.07.2013 are set aside and quashed. But the matter would
not end here. This court would further direct the Secretary to
the Government of Tripura, Revenue Department to remit the
matter to the Sub Divisional Magistrate, the designated
authority, for deciding whether the land in question should be
restored or not, in terms of the petition filed by the
Page - 12 of 16
petitioners [Annexure P/3 to the writ petition] within a time
frame what shall be laid by the Secretary to the Government
of Tripura, Revenue Department.
22. Before parting with the records, it is to be noted that
this court would be failing in its duties, if it is not mentioned
that any transaction which is carried out in violation of
Section 187 of the TLR & LR Act even by the registered
instrument as is in the present case by the registered gift
deeds, shall be treated as void for all purposes.
Having observed thus, this writ petition stands allowed
to the extent as stated above………….”
[13]
Heard Mr. Soumendu Roy learned counsel appearing for
the appellant as well as Mr. M. Debbarma, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents.
[14]
Mr. Roy, learned counsel for the appellant has argued
that the society represented by the appellant is engaged in promotion
of education and welfare of the tribal communities. The members of
the governing body of the society of the appellant are mostly tribals
and more particularly the recipient of the gift deeds was also tribal
and appreciating these facts the District Collector as well as the
Secretary to the Revenue Department held that the transfer of land
between respondents No.1 & 2 and the appellant was a transaction
from tribal to tribal and as such there was no application to Section
187(1) of the TLR & LR Act. Counsel submits that there is no error in
the findings of the District Collector and that of the Secretary to the
Page - 13 of 16
Revenue Department which should have been upheld by the learned
Single Judge.
[15]
The State-counsel appearing for the State-respondents
supports the contention of the counsel of the appellant and argues
that since both the parties to the transaction were tribal, the bar
under Section 187(1) of the TLR & LR Act would not apply in this
case.
[16]
Counsel appearing for the private-respondents (writ
petitioners) argues that the learned Single Judge has correctly held
that the transfer of land was in violation of Section 187(1) of the TLR
& LR Act. Counsel contends that there is no reason to interfere with
the impugned judgment and order of the learned Single Judge.
[17]
Before the gamut of the facts of the present case are re-
appreciated, it would be appropriate to have a cursory glance of
Section 187 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960. Section 187 of the TLR & LR
Act, as it stands today, reads as under:
“187 (1)
No transfer of land belonging to a person who is a
member of the
Scheduled Tribes shall be valid unless(a)
the transfer is to another member of the Scheduled
Tribes; or
(b)
where the transfer is to a person who is not a member
of the Scheduled Tribes, it is made with the previous
permission of the collector in writing in the manner to
be prescribed by rule, or
Page - 14 of 16
(c)
the transfer is by way of mortgage to a Co-operative
Society or to a Bank or to the Tripura Housing Board, or
to the Central or the State Government or any other
financial institutions or Corporations as may be notified
by the Government in the Official Gazette from time to
time for the purpose.
Provided that the land so mortgaged in pursuance of
clause (c ) shall not be transferred by such mortgage
to a person who is not a member of the Scheduled
Tribes.
Explanation-In this sub-Section, the expression, „a bank‟
shall have the same meaning as in section 109.
(2) (a) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882, but subject to the provision of
section 187A, no transfer of land belonging to a person
who is a member of the Scheduled Tribes shall be valid
unless made by a registered instrument.
(b) No transfer or instrument of transfer including a
decree or order
passed by any court, Tribunal or
Authority, made in contravention of sub-section (1) shall
be registered or in any way recognized as valid in any
court, Tribunal or Authority.
(3)
No decree or order shall be passed by any court,
Tribunal or Authority in any case other than the cases
as specified in Clause (c ) of sub-section (1) for the sale
of the land or any portion thereof,
of a person
belonging to scheduled Tribes nor shall any such land
be sold in execution of any decree or order”
[18]
From a plain reading of Section 187, it would appear that
transfer of land from tribal to non-tribal is invalid unless it is done in
accordance with the procedure laid down under Section 187 or such
transfer falls within the exceptions provided under the provisions of
Section 187 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960. The District Magistrate and
Collector as well as the Revenue Secretary committed error in
treating the appellant society as tribal and holding that the
transaction was between two tribal individuals on a wrong premise
Page - 15 of 16
that recipient of the gift deeds who was representing the appellant
society was a tribal.
[19]
We are in complete agreement with the learned Single
Judge that in terms of Section 5 of the Societies Registration Act,
1960, the property, movable and immovable, belonging to a society
registered under it, if not vested in trustees, shall be deemed to be
vested for the time being in the governing body and such property in
all proceedings, civil and criminal, may be described as the property
of the governing body of such society for their proper title in all civil
or criminal proceedings. Therefore, even if the property is purchased
by a society represented by a tribal person from a tribal person, the
same cannot be treated a transaction between two tribal persons for
the purpose of Section 187 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960.
[20]
Therefore, we are of the view that the learned Single
Judge correctly directed the Secretary to the Government of Tripura,
Revenue Department to remit the matter to the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate, the designated authority, for deciding whether the land in
question should be restored or not in terms of the petition filed by
the petitioner (Annexure P/3 to the writ petition) within a timeframe
that may be laid by the Secretary, Government of Tripura, Revenue
Department.
Page - 16 of 16
[21]
Resultantly, the appeal stands dismissed and the matter
is disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY), J
Sabyasachi G.
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review