Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
L.A. App. No.25 of 2022
1.
The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction), N.F. Railway, Badharghat
Railway Complex, P.O. Siddhi Ashram, P.S. Amtali, Agartala, District:
Tripura West.
…..Appellant
-V E R S U S-
1.
Smti. Hena Das, wife of late Nibaran Chandra Das,
2.
Sri Sudip Das, son of late Nibaran Chandra Das,
Both are residents of Charipara, P.S. Amtali, District: West Tripura.
3.
Smti. Jhuma Das, daughter of late Nibaran Chandra Das, wife of Sri
Mithu Das, resident of Siddhi Ashram, P.S. Amtali, District: West
Tripura.
4.
Smti. Ruma Das, wife of Sri Sanjoy Das, daughter of late Nibaran
Chandra Das, resident of Narayanpur, P.S. Airport, District: West
Tripura.
5.
The Land Acquisition Collector, West Tripura, Agartala.
…..Respondents.
CO(FA) No.14 of 2022
1.
Smti. Hena Das, wife of late Nibaran Chandra Das aged-60,
2.
Sri Sudip Das aged-31, son of late Nibaran Chandra Das,
Both are residents of Charipara, P.S. Amtali, District: West Tripura.
3.
Smti. Jhuma Das aged-39, daughter of late Nibaran Chandra Das, wife
of Sri Mithu Das, resident of Siddhi Ashram, P.S. Amtali, District:
West Tripura.
4.
Smti. Ruma Das aged-35, wife of Sri Sanjoy Das, daughter of late
Nibaran Chandra Das, resident of Narayanpur, P.S. Airport, District:
West Tripura.
…..Claimant-respondent-Cross Objectors
-V E R S U S-
1.
The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction), N.F. Railway, Badharghat
Railway Complex, P.O. Siddhi Ashram, P.S. Amtali, District: West
Tripura.
2.
The L. A. Collector, West Tripura, Agartala.
…..Respondents.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. Asutosh De, Advocate.
Mr. P. Gautam, Advocate.
Mr. D. Deb, Advocate.
Mr. D. Debnath, Advocate.
20.07.2023
YES/NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. A. De, learned counsel appearing for the appellant,
Also heard Mr. P. Gautam, Mr. D. Deb, and Mr. D. Debnath, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
The present appeal has been filed under Section-74 of the Right of
Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation & Resettlement Act, 2013, hereinafter referred to as the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 against
the judgment and award dated 22.02.2022 in connection with Land Acquisition
Case No.50 of 2017 passed by the learned Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation & Resettlement Authority, Tripura, Presiding Officer, wherein, the learned Presiding
Officer awarded Rs.16,00,000/- only per kani along with solatium and other
statutory benefits which is not proper and against the spirit of law. Further, the
cross-objection on behalf of the claimant respondent-cross objectors under OrderXLI, Rule-22 of CPC has also been filed against the cross appeal under Section-74
of the Right of Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation & Resettlement Act of 2013 preferred by the opposite party No.1
appellant respondent, N.F. Railway against the judgment and award dated
22.02.2022 in connection with Land Acquisition Case No.50 of 2017 passed by
the learned Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation & Re-settlement Authority, Tripura,
Presiding Officer, wherein, the learned Presiding Officer awarded Rs.16,00,000/only per kani along with solatium and other statutory benefits.
[3]
The brief facts behind the appeal are that the government of Tripura
acquired the land in question belonging to the respondents. By a notification dated
28.01.2017 under Section-11 of the RECTLARR Act, 2013. The land was
acquired for the purpose of construction for new rail line from Agartala to
Akhaura Rail Construction. The acquired land fallen under Khatian No.2481, Plot
No.6910 of Mouja Charipara, Sheet No.1 and 2/P, Tahashil Badharghat, land
measuring 0.060 acres, classified as Bastu (Tilla). The learned L.A. Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala awarded Rs.4,50,000/- only per kani and awarded total
compensation amounting to Rs.2,09,956/- only for the acquired land which is
mentioned in page-2, table No.1 in the judgment passed in connection with Land
Acquisition Case No.50 of 2017.
[4]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the award, the claimant
filed an objection and prayed for referring the case to the Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Re-settlement Authority Tripura, hereinafter called the
authority for proper determination of compensation and adjudication of the case.
The L.A. Collector subsequently referred the case to the authority. The authority
served notice upon both the parties and respective parties and counter claim
statement. After hearing both the parties on the basis of documents and statement
of facts, the authority awarded an amount of Rs.16,00,000/- only per kani along
with other statutory benefits.
[5]
After hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
having gone through the material evidence on record, the learned Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation & Re-settlement Authority, Tripura has observed as
under:
“44.(i) The Referring Claimants is entitled enhanced market value of his
acquired land measuring 0.060 acre under plot No.6910 of Khatian No.2481
@ Rs.16,00,000/- per kani (0.40 acre) instead of Rs.4,50,000/- per kani (0.40
acre) determined by the L.A. Collector at apportionment Sl. No.118. (ii) The
market value of the acquired land as determined at the above rate be
multiplied with factor “1.5’ as per Section-26(c) and as contemplated in first
schedule appended to Act, 2013 to get the value of the land (iii) The referring
claimant in addition to value of land is entitled to get compensation u/s.29 of
Act 2013 as determined by the L.A. Collector for the things attached to the
acquired property viz. crops. (iv) The referring claimant as per section 69(3)
of the Act 2013, in addition to the market value of the land is entitled 100%
solatium over the total (value of the land + cost for damage for the things
attached to the acquired property viz crops) compensation amount. (v) The
referring claimants as per section69(2) of Act 2013, is entitled 12% pa on the
market value from the date of publication of notification under Section 11 to
the date of award of the L.A. Collector or taking of the possession of acquired
property, whichever is earlier. (vi) The referring claimants u/s.72 of Act 2013
is entitled for interest at the rate of 9% p.a. from the date on which the L.A.
Collector took possession of acquired property to the date of payment of the
excess amount into the authority from 21.08.2017, for the first year and
interest at the rate of 15% p.a. for subsequent years, till deposit of entire
amount. (vii) The amount already paid by the LA Collector shall be deducted
in the excess compensation now awarded to the acquired property.”
[6]
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment and award,
the appellant and the cross-objectors have preferred this appeal and the cross
objection.
[7]
Mr. A. De, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
submitted that the authority manifest error in law in determining the market value
of the acquired lands as the authority failed to apply the correct principle of law in
the matter of determination of the market value of the acquired land and as such
the judgment and award passed by the authority is liable to be set aside and
quashed. The judgment of the authority is cryptic and the authority has not
assigned any reason for determining the correct principle of law for deciding the
quantum of compensation for the acquired land but passed whimsical judgment
and award which is without any basis and against the spirit of law and as such
liable to be dismissed and set aside.
[8]
The acquired land in question is situated far away from the road and
abandoned class of land but the authority without considering anything passed
whimsical judgment without any basis and as such the judgment passed b y
authority is liable to be set aside. The claimant petitioners on the time of adducing
evidence some exemplar deeds has been submitted for showing the present market
value of the land. But the deed submitted by the claimant petitioners is far away
from the acquired land.
[9]
Moreover, the deeds submitted by the claimant petitioners is on the
road side and no way connected with the acquired land, so consideration of the
said deed is no basis and stand in the eye of law for determination of quantum of
compensation. But the authority passed whimsical judgment by consideration of
the said deeds which is against the spirit of law. The authority did not mention any
reason in his judgment for which the authority enhanced the award from
Rs.4,50,000/- to Rs.16,00,000/- per kani and as such the judgment and award
passed by the authority is liable to be set aside.
[10]
He has further contended that after construction of the railway line,
the area surrounding thereon became highly developed automatically but, the
authority never deducted the development charge from the compensation amount
passed. There are not at all modern facilities like water supply, transportation,
electricity, market, school and hospital etc. But, the authority did not consider the
same and passed and whimsical judgment which is liable to be set aside. The
whole claim of the referring claimant respondent herein, are imaginary and
without any grounds.
[11]
Claimant No.1 Smt. Hena Das, the respondent No.1 herien,
appeared and submitted claim statement and represented the other respondent
Nos.2 to 4 by dint of Registered General Power of Attorney bearing No.IV-382
dated 18.09.2017. In the claim statement it was stated that the acquired land is
Bastu (Tila), situated at 'Mouza': Charipara nearby the Agartala Municipal
Corporation area and also nearby Palanpara to West Charipara pitch road. It is
pleaded that all modern facilities like water supply line, electric connection, road
communication, school, local offices of various deptt. of Govt of Tripura
including TMC & Dr. B.R.M. Teaching hospital and Badharghat Railway Station
are within one & half km. from the acquired land. At the time of acquisition the
market value of the acquired land was more than Rs.2,00,00,000/- per kani. It is
also stated that the acquired land which are classified as Bastu (Tila), can be easily
converted to viti/vastu class of land for construction of building.
[12]
On the other hand, the Opposite parties No.1 & 2, the appellant and
the respondent No.5, herein, contested the claim of the referring claimants. But
did not deny and dispute the fact that the aforesaid land was acquired for the
purpose of the project of railway as stated herein before. However, it was denied
and disputed that the compensation to the referring claimant was insufficient or
inadequate. The value of the acquired land was assessed as per market value of the
land of the area and the referring claimants are not entitled to get any further
compensation for the acquired land. O.P.No.1 in the counter statement has
specifically pleaded that the award was passed by the LA Collector taking into the
consideration of factors: (i) plot wise value of land,(ii) recent sale deeds of same
mouja, (iii) variation of value of land near to the road side and back side, (iv)
variation of value of land near to the market, school and other Govt. establishment
and vice-versa, (v) accessibility to the roads, surface of acquired land, size of area
etc. O.P. 2 (L.A. Collector) in the counter statement specifically denied the claim
of the claimant that there are any modern amenities available within the walking
distance of the acquired land.
[13]
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that the
sale instances produced by the referring claimant and marked as exhibits cannot
be the basis for determining the market value as the sale instances are not similar
type of land and the referring claimant has no personal knowledge about the
transaction of the land under sale instances. The L.A. Collector considered the
physical verification report of the expert committee, constituted by the D.M. &
Collector of the District, headed by the SDM. Thereafter, he determined the
market value of the acquired property taking consideration of sale instances of
similar class of land situated within 200 mtrs. of the said acquired property and
thus the market value determined by the LA. Collector is rational and acceptable.
[14]
The argument of the learned counsel shows that the dispute in the
reference is about the rate of market value determined by the LA Collector. The
case law referred by the respective learned counsels are on the principle of
determination of market value for the acquisition of land is all under the old Land
Acquisition Act i.e. the Act of 1894. In the present case, the reference by the LA
Collector is under Section-64 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 and the market value
of the acquired land is to be determined under Section-26 of the said Act, 2013
which prescribed a specific procedure and guidelines for determining the market
value of the acquired land.
[15]
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Land Acquisition Officer
v. Karigowda reported in (2010) 5 SCC 708 at paragraphs 32, 33 & 34 it was
observed:
32. Where a statutory provision confers rights and also states mandatory or
implied conditions which would have to be satisfied before the claim, can
culminate into a relief, such considerations or conditions are relevant for the
purposes of interpretation as well. A power conferred by the statute, often
contains an express condition for its exercise and, in absence of, or in addition
to the express condition, there are also implied conditions for exercise of
power. Exercise of statutory power in breach of express or implied conditions
will be illegal, if the conditions breached are mandatory. This principle, to a
large extent, is applicable to exercise of rights arising from beneficial
legislations, when an owner claims benefits under statutory provisions, it is
for him to show that what is contemplated under the conditions attached
thereto has been satisfied, particularly when such legislative intent is clear
from the bare reading of the provisions. Like the cases in hand, it is for the
claimants to show that, to award the compensation payable under the statutory
provisions, they have brought on record, evidence to satisfy the criterion and
conditions required to be fulfilled for such a claim.
33. The provisions with which we are concerned primarily are the provisions
of the statute which are coupled with obligations and limitations specified in
them. The power is vested in the Collector to grant compensation; in courts to
enhance the same in favour of the claimants whose lands are acquired, in case
they are aggrieved. But, this power has to be exercised while keeping in mind
the settled guidelines and parameters stated in Sections 23 and 24 of the Act.
It will, thus, not be permissible for the authorities to go beyond the scope and
purview of the provisions or the pre-requisites stated in these provisions for
determination of the fair market value of the land.
34. The statutory law as well as the judgments pronounced by the courts has
consistently taken the view that compensation has to be determined strictly in
accordance with the provisions of Sections 23 and 24 of the Act. The matters
which are to be governed by the terms of Section 24 of the Act cannot be
taken into consideration by extending discretion referable to the matters
which should be considered by the courts in terms of Section 23 of the Act.
To put it in another way, the court should apply the principle of literal or plain
construction to these provisions, as the Legislature in its wisdom has not
given to the court absolute discretion in matter relating to awarding of
compensation but has intended to control the same by enacting these statutory
provisions.
[16]
Therefore, it is well settled that the statute law and the case law
would go side by side to interpret the statutes. Perhaps keeping in mind of the
various guidelines setup by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, the legislator prescribed
the specific and detail methods for determination of market value of land in
acquisition under RFCTLARR Act, 2013 which are more clear and specific in
comparison to the methods prescribed in the old Land Acquisition Act i.e. the Act
of 1898. As such, I shall be refrained myself to discuss the case law unless it is
required in interpretation of the provisions under RFCTLARR Act, 2013. The
methods for determination of market value are prescribed under Section- 26 of the
said Act, 2013 read as follows:
"Section 26 Determination of Market Value of land by collector: (1) The
Collector shall adopt the following criteria in assessing and determining the
market value of the land namely:(a) the market value, if any, specified in the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 for the
registration of sale deeds or agreements to sell as the case may be in the area,
where the land is situated; or
(b) The average sale price for similar type of land situated in the nearest
village or nearest vicinity area or
(c) Consented amount of compensation as agreed upon under Sub-section (2)
of Section-2 in case of acquisition of lands for private companies or for public
private partnership projects, whichever is higher.
Provided that the date for determination of market value shall be the date on
which the notification has been issued under Section-11.
Explanation I-The average sale price referred to in clause (b) shall be
determined taking into account the sale deeds or the agreements to sell
registered for similar type of area in the near village or near vicinity area
during immediately preceding three years of the year in which such
acquisition of land is proposed to be made.
Explanation 2- For determining the average sale price referred to in
Explanation 1, one-half of the total number of sale deeds or the agreement to
sell in which the highest sale price has been mentioned shall be taken into
account.
Explanation-3 while determining the market value under this section and the
average sale price referred to in Explanation 1 or Explanation 2, any price
paid as compensation for land acquired under the provisions of this Act on an
earlier occasion in the district shall not be taken into consideration.
Explanation 4-While determining the market value under this section and the
average sale price referred to in Explanation 1 or Explanation 2, any price
paid, which in the opinion of the Collector is not indicative of actual
prevailing market value may be discounted for the purposes of calculating
market value.
(2) The market value calculated as per sub-section (1) shall be multiplied by a
factor to be specified in the First Schedule.
(3) Where the market value under sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) cannot be
determined for the reason that(a) The land is situated in such area where the transactions in land are
restricted by or under any other law for the time being in force in that area; or
(b) The registered sale deeds or agreements to sell as mentioned in clause (a)
of sub-section (1) for similar land are not available for the immediately
preceding three years; or
(c) The market value has not been specified under the Indian Stamp Act, 1699
by the appropriate authority, the State Government concerned shall specify
the floor price or minimum price per unit area of the said land based on the
price calculated in the manner specified in sub-section (1) in respect of similar
types of land situated in the immediate adjoining areas:
Provided that in a case where the Requiring Body offers its shares to the
owners of the lands (whose lands have been acquired) as a part compensation,
for acquisition of land, such shares in no case shall exceed twenty-five per
cent of the value so calculated under sub-section (1) or sub- section (2) or
sub-section (3) as the case may be:
Provided further that the Requiring Body shall in no case compel any owner
of the land (whose land has been acquired) to take its shares, the value of
which is deductible in the value of the land calculated under sub- section (1):
Provided also that the Collector shall, before initiation of any land acquisition
proceedings in any area, take all necessary steps to revise and update the
market value of the land on the basis of the prevalent market rate in that area:
Provided also that the appropriate Government shall ensure that the market
value determined for acquisition of any land or property of an educational
institution established and administered by a religious or linguistic minority
shall be such as would not restrict or abrogate the right to establish and
administer educational institutions of their choice"
[17]
A careful reading of Section-26 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 it
would be seen that provision is governed the methods of determination of the
market value of acquired land. Section 26 (1) of the said Act in clause (a), clause
(b) and clause (c) prescribed three different methods for determination of market
value applicable in three different situations. Section-26 (1)(a) states that the
market value, if any, specified in the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 for the registration
of sale deeds or agreements to sell as the case may be in the area, where the land is
situated Specific criterions have been fixed to determine the market value of
acquired land. In the case at hand LA Collector in his 'Assessment Note' opined
that the value chart prepared in the year 2011 for the purpose of registration of
sale deed is far below the prevail market rate in the locality. Therefore, the
methods for determination of market value laid down in Section 26(1) (a) of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013 is not applicable in this case. Again, Section-26(1) (c) of
the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 is also not applicable here as the land was not acquired
for public private partnership project.
[18]
In the instant case sale instance under Exhibit-2 and 3 are classified
as bastu /Viti class land and the land under sale instance Exhibit-A is classified
comprising of three classes land viz. Bagan (Tila), Chara (Tila) & Bastu (Tila).
Therefore, the sale instances under Exhibit-2 (Bastu/viti), Exhibit-3 (Bast/viti) and
Exhibit-A ((Bagan (Tila), Chara (Tila) & Bastu (Tila)) are also not exactly similar
to the acquired land (Bastu-tila). However, land classified as Bastu (Tila) is also
used for the purpose of construction of residential house. But the potential value
of Bastu (Tila) land lower than the Bastu (Viti) class land due to surface and other
facilities attached to the earth. However, the acquired land could have been
converted to 'Bastu/viti land after necessary development. Therefore, sale
instances classified as Bastu (Viti) class land may be taken into account with a
suitable discount of the value of the instances subject to satisfaction of other
condition laid down in the statute. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Special land
Acquisition Officer and another vs. Sidappa Omanna Tumari and anothers
reported in 1995 Supp.(2) SCC 168 said, “14. Therefore, where a sale deed or an
agreement to sell relating to a small extent of land is produced by the claimant, in
the enquiry held for determination of compensation payable for his large extent of
land, the court is not always bound to determine the market price of such large
extent of acquired land on the basis of the price fetched or to be fetched by small
extent of land covered by such sale deed or agreement to sell.”
[19]
So, before taking into account of sale instances under Exhibit-2,
Exhibit-3 and Exhibit-A as comparable sale instances the quantum or area of the
lands are to be looked into. The area of acquired land plot No. 5513/p is 0.300
acre. On the other hand the area or quantum of lands of three sale instances under
Exhibit-2, Exhibit-3 and Exhibit-A respectively are 0.03 acre, 0.01 acre and 0.140
acre. The above observation shows that the area/quantum of land of sale instances
under Exhibit-2 and 3 is very small in comparison with the acquired land. Every
prudent man knows that for construction of a house building minimum 0.02 acre
area of land is required. However, it is common at Agartala and its adjoining area
to sell and purchase less than 0.02 acre land on the roadside at a very high rate for
using in commercial purpose. In this case no evidence led by the claimant to clear
the doubt. So, I have no hesitation to hold that the land of Exhibit-2 and 3 might
have been purchased at a high rate for commercial purpose.
[20]
There are two crucial differences in the acquired land under plot No.
6915 and exemplar Exhibit no.2 and 3. First, the land under Exhibit no 2 and 3 are
bastu/viti class land whereas land pertaining to plot No. 6910 is bastu (Tilla) and
finally, the area/quantum of land. In Exhibit No.2 quantum of land is 0.03 acre
and the area of Exhibit No. 3 is 0.10 acre. Both are of small area in comparison
with the acquired land (0.060 acre). The area of land under Exhibue-3 (0.010 acre)
is so small that no residential house could be build except a very small building
for running commercial unit like a store or a shop. Therefore, this Court has no
hesitation to consider that land under Exhibit-3 was purchased for running of
commercial unit fetching high price. Interestingly, both the sale instances under
Exhibits No.2 and 3 were registered on 22.03.2013 i.e. on the same day. Land of
sale instance under Exhibit No.2 (Sale deed No. 1-1728 dated 22.03.2013) was
sold @ Rs 40,00,000/- per Kani (0.40 acre) whereas land in Exhibit-3 (sale deed
No. 1- 1729 dated 22.03.2013) was sold @ Rs. 2,00,00,000/- per Kani(0.40 acre)
though both the land classified as Basu/viti land. It is question why the two plot of
land registered on the same of the same locality has such a huge difference of
price.
[21]
The probable cause may be that land fetching high price is situated
at market area or near to the market of developed area and suitable for running
business unit. The buyer may have purchased the same at a rocket high price to
establish business unit. No map is produced to show the exact location of the plots
to show that the land is situated very near to the acquired land. No evidence is
adduced by claimant by examining the vendor or vendee as witness to clarify the
reason of such difference of price at same mouja. So the sale instance under
Exhibit-3 is not at all comparable sale instance to determine the market value and
thus kept outside of consideration for the reasons stated above.
[22]
The main contention of the counsel for the appellant is that the
appeal is filed on the ground that the land acquired is far away from the main city
and the developing areas. It is just attaching the Bangladesh border and since it is
the remote place the amount of compensation which has been awarded by the
concerned authority is unjust and the table No.2 which is placed on record needs
to be reconsidered and table No.3 of the LA Collector is just and proper. Nothing
has been placed on record by way of any evidence or pleadings to show that the
subject land is on the Indo-Bangla border.
[23]
In view of overall reasons given by the learned authority and going
through the evidence on record and the arguments put forwarded by the learned
counsel appearing for the parties, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
authority
has
decided
the
matter
and
calculated
the
amount
of
compensation/award as per the principle laid down by the Apex Court as
aforementioned and on the basis of the relevant documents. Since, it is already
considered and the award has been passed, it is not a case for passing any further
order. Accordingly, the findings as arrived at by the learned authority are just and
proper and do not require any interference and thus, affirmed.
[24]
Accordingly, the appeal and the cross-objection preferred by both
the parties, stand dismissed. Consequently, the judgment and award passed by the
learned authority stands affirmed. Draw the decree accordingly and thereafter,
send down the LCRs forthwith. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications
pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2023.07.28
18:24:04 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review