Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
LA.App. No. 100 of 2023
With CO(FA) No. 01 of 2024.
1. The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction -2)
N.F. Railway, Badharghat, Agartala
-----Appellant.
Versus
1.
Smt. Minati Das,
Wife of Late Dhirendra Ch. Das.
2. Sri Bablu Das,
Son of Late Dhirendra Ch. Das
3. Sri Litan Das,
Son of Late Dhirendra Ch. Das
4. Smt. Parthana Das
D/o of Late Dhirendra Ch. Das.
5. Smt. Biba Das,
D/o, of Late Dhirendra Ch. Das,
All are resident of Sarashima, P.S Belonia,
District, South Tripura.
----- Respondents (Referring Claimants)
6. The Land Acquisition Collector,
South Tripura, Belonia.
…………..Respondent.
CO(FA) No. 01 of 2024
1. Sri Bablu Das,
S/o- Late Dhirendra Ch. Das
2. Sri Litan Das,
Son of Late Dhirendra Ch. Das
3. Smt. Parthana Das
D/o of Late Dhirendra Ch. Das.
W/o. Priyalal Nama.
4. Smt. Biba Das,
D/o- Late Dhirendra Ch. Das
All are resident of Sarashima, P.S Belonia,
District, South Tripura.
……………Cross- Objector (Appellants)
Versus
1.
The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction -2)
N.F. Railway, Badharghat, Agartala, having his office at
Badharghat, Agartala, Pin- 799003.
2.
The Land Acquisition Collector,
South Tripura, Belonia having his office at Belonia.
…………Respondents.
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy.SGI.
For the Respondent(s)
:
For Cross- Objector (s)
:
For the Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
Whether fit for reporting
:
:
Mr. S. Kr. Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Datta, Advocate.
Mr. S. Kr. Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Datta, Advocate
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. SGI.
27.01.2025.
:
:
30 / 01/2025.
NO
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. SGI appearing for the
appellant in LA. App No. 100 of 2023 as well as for the respondent in CO(FA)
01 of 2024 . Also heard Mr. S. Kr. Deb, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
S.Datta, learned counsel appearing for the referring claimants (respondents
herein) in LA. App No. 100 of 2023 and for the Cross-Objectors in CO(FA) 01
of 2024.
[2]
This present appeal has been filed under Section 74 of the Right
to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013 against the Judgment and Award dated 30.01.2023
passed in L.A Case 71 of 2019 by the Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Authority, Tripura along with this appeal a Cross-Objection has
also been filed by the Cross –Objector (Respondents herein) under Order XLI
Rule 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure read with Section 74 of the Right to Fair
Compensation
and Transparency in Land Acquisition Rehabilitation and Re-
Settlement Act, against the Judgment and Award dated 30.01.2023 passed in
the LA Case No. 71 of 2019
by the aforesaid authority. Hence, both the
appeals are taken together for a common disposal.
[3]
The brief facts of the case is that, the referring claimants
(respondents herein) Smt. Minati Das and her husband Late Dhirendra Ch.
Das were the owner and possessor of land under Khatian No. 2025, plot No.
6025/6433/p in Mauja Sarashima under Belonia Sub-division, Dhirendra Ch.
Das died on 05.04.2013 and on his death his son and daughters became the
owner of the land along with their mother. The Government acquired the land
measuring 0.70 acres owned by the referring claimants (respondents herein)
under aforesaid Khatian No. 2025, plot No. 6025/6433/p for construction of
new Railway line vide notification No. F.09 (01)/REV/ACQ/XII/15 dated
3.08.2015. The LA Collector, South Tripura determined the market value of
acquired land @ Rs. 5,00,000/- per kani and to arrive the land value of
acquired land applied multiplication factor 1.5, cost of damage of trees on the
land and also awarded 100% solatium over the total compensation and 12%
interest w.e.f. 03.08.2015 to 02.03.2016 (for 7 months). That, being
aggrieved by the amount of compensation awarded by the LA Collector the
respondents herein (claimants) sought for reference. Accordingly, the matter
has been referred to the Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Authority, Tripura for determination of appropriate compensation. Thereafter,
the Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority, Tripura by its
judgment and award dated 30.01.2023 enhanced the award passed by the LA
Collector and assessed the value @ Rs. 10,00,000/- per kani. The relevant
portion of the Judgment and Award dated 30.01.2023 passed in LA Case No.
71 of 2019 is quoted herein below:“ORDER / AWARD
16. (1) The Referring Claimant is entitled enhanced market value of her
acquired land measuring 0.70 acres under plot Nos. 6025/6433/p@ Rs.
10,00,000/- per kani (ii)The market value of the acquired land as determined at
the above rate be multiplied with factor '1.5' as per section 26 (c) and as
contemplated in First schedule appended to Act 2013 to get the value of the
land (iii) The referring claimant in addition to value of land is entitled to get
compensation u/s. 29 of Act 2013 for 100 rubber trees amounting to Rs.
4,50,000/-(Rs.4500x100) (iv) The referring claimant as per section 69(3) of the
Act 2013, in addition to the market value of the land is entitled 100% solatium
over the total (value of the land cost for damage for 100 rubber trees)
compensation The referring claimants as per section 60(2) of Act 2013, is
entitled 12 p.a. on the market value from the date of publication of notification
under section 11 to the date of award of the LA Collector or taking of the
possession of acquired property, which-ever is earlier. (vi) The referring
claimants u/s. 72 of Act 2013 is entitled for interest at the rate of 9% p.a. from
the date on which the L.A. Collector took possession of acquired property to the
date of payment of the excess amount into the Authority, for the first year and
interest at the rate of 15%p.a., for subsequent years, till deposit of entire
amount. (vii) The amount already paid by the LA Collector shall be deducted in
the excess compensation now awarded to the acquired property.
Advocate fee is fixed at Rs.1000/-. The parties are directed to bear their own
cost in this case. Draw award accordingly”.
[4]
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the order dated 30.01.2023
passed in LA Case No. 71 of 2019 by the Learned Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority, Tripura, Agartala, the appellant
herein approached this court seeking the following reliefs:“(i) Admit the appeal filed by the appellant;
(ii) Call for the records of L.A. case no. 71 of 2019 from the court of the Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority, Tripura;
(iii) Issue notice upon the respondents;
AND
(iv) After hearing both the parties kindly set aside the impugned judgment and
award dated 30.01.2023 passed in L.A. case no. 71 of 2019 by the Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority, Tripura; “
[5]
On the other hand, Cross- Objection has been filed by the Cross-
Objectors (Respondents herein) in CO(FA) 01 of 2024 seeking the following
reliefs:
“i. Admit this appeal.
ii. Call for records.
iii. Issue Notice upon the respondents and
iv. After hearing the parties be pleased to allow this Cross-Objection.”
[6]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy.SGI appearing for the appellant
submits before this Court as per requisition of the appellant, land measuring
0.70 acres appertaining to plot no. 6025/6433/p Khatian No. 2025 situated at
Mouja –Sarashima under Belonia Sub-Division were acquired for the purpose
of construction of new railway line. The LA Collector assessed the value of
the acquired land @ Rs. 5,00,000/- per kani and applied the multiplying factor
1.5 to determine the value of the acquired land as provided under Section 26
of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 and awarded total compensation of Rs.28,46,250/.
Thereafter, the respondents (referring claimants) sought for reference and the
matter has been referred to Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Authority, Tripura and by a judgment the said authority determined the value
of the land @ of Rs. 10,00,000/- per kani along with other benefits. Learned
counsel prays before this Court that the learned Court below failed to assessed
the value of the land and the judgment and award is liable to be set aside.
[7]
Mr. S. Kr. Deb, learned senior counsel submits before this Court
that the respondent No.1
was the owner and possessor of the half share and
all the other respondents (referring claimants) were the owners and
possessors of the half share of the acquired land measuring 0.70 acres. The
husband of the respondent no.1 and father of the other respondents namely
late Dhirendra Chandra Das son of Late Prakash Chandra das during his life
time got some land measuring 2.70 acres by way of allotment along with one
co-sharer Smt. Minati Das, his wife, appertaining to Mauja- Sarasima of
Sarasima Tehashil Kachari under Belonia Sub-Division comprising khatian No2025 and said Dhirendra Chandra Das died on 05-04-2013 in his own resident
leaving behind the respondents as his surviving legal heirs. Until death the
predecessor-in-title of the respondents (referring claimant) namely, Dhirendra
Chandra Das and the other respondents were in peaceful possession on the
acquired land and after reclaiming the same transplanted rubber plantations
covering all those 2.50 acres of land appertaining to Mauja Sarasima and after
death of late Dhirendra Chandra Das the instant respondents (referring
claimants) were in peaceful possession and enjoyment of the said land and
income of rubber plantation situated thereon.
[8]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel further submits that for the
public purpose of construction of new Railway line from Agartala to sabroom in
mouja sarasima under Belonia sub-Division in South Tripura District, several
plots of lands, path and ponds were notified for acquisition by the Government
through its agents, namely the Land Acquisition Collector, South Tripura
District, Belonia for materializing the purpose as aforesaid. The proposed
acquisition was notified after publishing notices and notifications in the official
Gazette under section 11 of the RFCTLARR Act-2013 being the No. F.09(01)REV/ACQ/XII/2015 and dated 03-08-2015 proposing thereat to acquire 0.70
acres of land which comprising in khatian No-2025 and stated in RS(new) plot
No-6025/6433 appertains to Mauja Sarasima of Sarasima Tehashil Kachari
under Belonia Sub Division. That the referring claimants were informed by a
letter through Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Belonia that L.A. Collector acquired
some landed property for construction work of new Railway Line from Agartala
to Sabroom and awarded an amount of Rs. 28,46,250/- for the said proposed
acquired land measuring 0.70 acres including all standing rubber trees in
number 100 thereon and directed to receive the awarded amount from the
S.D.M. office, as on 17-05-2016. That the referring claimants perused the
notice and find that there is no mention in the notice the quantity and
description of the proposed acquired land. Later on the referring claimants
came to know that the L.A. Collector proposed to 0.70 acres Tilla (presently
after reclaiming and transplanting said tilla became a Bagan Tilla) class land
appertaining to Mouja & T.K. Sarasima, comprising khatian No-2025 RS (new)
plot No-6025/6433 under Belonia Revenue circle and Belonia Sub-Division for
the above noted construction work. It is mentionable here that all the
respondents are the owners of the 50% share of the acquired land by way of
the
survivor/successor
of
deceased
Dhirendra
Chandra
Das
and
the
respondent no-1 is the owner of the remaining 50% land as per the
description of the khatian.
[9]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel also submits that the land
acquisition Collector awarded Compensation for acquired land on the basis of
the rate chart of land published by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Belonia in
the year 2009 without any physical verification of the present market value of
land and also not follow the guide line of "The Right To Fair Compensation And
Transparency In Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation And Resettlement Act, 2013".
That the L.A. Collector awarded compensation for the land of respondents
(referring claimants) @ Rs. 5,00,000/- per käni (per 40 decimals) of land,
Which is too below the market value as is prevailing in the locality. To
substantiate their claims, the referring claimants have submitted three sale
deeds bearing No-1-1372 dated 20-10-2009 and bearing No. 1-1667 dated
16-12-2009. on perusal of the two sale deeds, it will be seen that in the year
2009 land was sold at a price of Rs. 40,00,000/- to Rs. 60,00,000/- per kani
and in this way on a comparative tally with the adjacent Revenue village that
is Belonia Mauja the referring claimants submitted a sale deed bearing No. 11683 dated 20-07-2006, where land was sold at a price of Rs. 84,21,052/-per
kani of land, but the collector could not adopted the mandatory provision of
section 26 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 during assessing and determining the
market value of the land. On the other hand the land Acquisition Judge, South
Tripura, District, Belonia, pronounced judgment in connection with the market
value of the land in the same Mauja Sarasima which acquired in the year 2011
and earlier for the same project. In those judgment the Hon’ble judge
awarded enhancement rate of compensation of those acquired land @ Rs.
10,00,000/- to Rs. 50,00,000/- per kani. That on being encouraged by the
sector officer of Rubber Board, the referring claimants in the year 2006 started
rubber plantations, after doing reclamation being expending in huge amount of
money covering all those 2.50 acres of tilla land. As per instructions of sector
officer of the Rubber Board, now Belonia, the respondents transplanted 140 x
2.50 = 350 nos. of Rubber graft in their land (140 per acres) and due to
acquisition of land measuring 0.70 acres the 100 numbers of matured rubber
trees had been destroyed during construction work. That the L.A. Collector
arbitrarily and whimsically awarded for a matured rubber tree @ Rs. 800/only without following the directions made in section 29 of the RFCTLARR Act,
2013.
As
per
analysis
and
in
description
of
the
Rubber
production
Commissioner in the year 2011 that 1. no rubber tree during its life time
produced total net income at Rs. 10,000/. As per Rubber Board chart, if a
mature rubber tree destroyed in the 11 years old, loss sustained by grower as
Rs. 8,000/- and in different acquisition cases L.A. Judge also directed to pay
an amount of Rs. 8000/- as compensation for a mature rubber tree to the
claimant by the L.A. Collector. It was done in utter incredible manner. The L.A.
Collector with a view to cause loss to the claimants had done these acts of
misfeasance and malfeasance. It was unfelt and insensitive.
That the
respondents crave the indulgence of the Honorable court to give the details of
the claim animated by to justify their claims.
That the acquired land is
situated adjacent boundary of Belonia Municipality area and it is heart of the
Belonia Rail station as well as excellent for the commercial purpose. Land per
kani Rs. 40,00,000/- (Rupes Fourty Lakhs) so far the acquiring of 0.70 acres
that is one kani fifteen gandas of land of the referring claimants, the claimants
demands Rs. 70,00,000/-(Rupees seventy lakhs) only for land measuring 0.70
acres on the basis of recent transaction and market-value of land along with
the solatium and interest.
[10]
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel appearing for the respondents as
well as for the Cross-Objector in CO(FA) 01 of 2024, lastly submits that as per
the assessment of the Managing Director, TFDC A corporate body formed by
the State of Tripura the assessment of every mature rubber tree provide its
total income at Rs. 10,000/-. As such uprooted and demolished 100 nos.
mature rubber trees x Rs.10,000/- = Rs. 10,00,000/- (Rupees ten Lakhs). The
respondents demand Rs. 10,00,000/- for the demolished 100 nos. matured
rubber trees which are situated their acquired land, along with solatium and
interest. That no compensation has been awarded for the rehabilitation after
acquisition of land and no compensation has been awarded for the damage
sustained by the claimants for the reason of acquired land being severed from
their home-stead other land.
[11]
To support his arguments, Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel
appearing for the respondents placed reliance on the following judgments of
the Hon’ble Apex Court which are as under :
1.
Bhag Singh and Others Versus Union Territory of
Chandigarh reported in (1992) 4 SCC 692.
2.
Land Acquisition Officer Revenue Divisional Officer
Chittor Versus L. Kamalamma (Smt) Dead by LRS and Others K.
Krishnamachari And Others reported in (1998) 2 SCC 385.
3.
ONGC
LTD. Versus Sendhabhai Vastram Patel and
Others, reported in (2005) 6 SCC 454.
The relevant portions of the aforesaid judgments of Hon’ble Apex
Court are extracted as under :-
1.
Bhag Singh and Others Versus Union Territory of
Chandigarh, reported in (1992) 4 SCC 692.
“8.No doubt, a judgment of a Court in a land acquisition case
determining the market value of a land in the vicinity of the acquired land, even
though not inter parties, could be admitted in evidence either as an instance or
one from which the market value of the acquired land could be deduced or
inferred. There will be no difficulty in accepting such judgment as one furnishing
the basis for determining the market value of the acquired land under
consideration, if the opposite parties do not genuinely dispute the position that
the judgment relied upon, could be acted as basis for determination of the
market value of the acquired land. In fact, in Krapa Rangiah's case (supra) this
Court was considering a case where the High Court had reduced the
compensation which had been awarded in appeal by the reference Court. It was
not disputed before this Court that the High Court had granted an extra rate of
Rs. 2 per square yard for a similar land which adjoined the acquired land and
had been acquired under the same Notification. It is in the said set of admitted
facts, this Court enhanced the compensation payable for the acquired land
under consideration before it by Rs. 2 per square yard. This decision, therefore,
cannot lend any assistance to the petitioners claim for grant of compensation
which could be higher than that granted by the High Court. The petitioners in
the present petitions, it has to be noted, though have been granted
compensation by the High Court exceeding that granted by the Reference Court
was seeking grant of further enhanced compensation from this Court. But such
claim for enhanced compensation is contested by learned Counsel appearing for
the Land Acquisition Collector, by urging that the judgment of the High Court on
which reliance is placed on behalf of petitioners cannot form the basis for
determining the market value of the acquired lands of the petitioners, in as
much as, there is absolutely no evidence adduced by them to show that in the
attendant facts and circumstances of the cases, it would be just and reasonable
to grant the compensation for the acquired lands of the petitioners at a higher
rate in which compensation has been granted to the claimant concerned in a
stray case where subsequent judgment has been rendered by the High Court.
Judgments of the High Court given in a large number of cases determining the
market value of lands in a huge tract at uniform rates cannot be revised, in our
view, solely on the basis of claim made on behalf of petitioners that a learned
Judge of the same High Court in a subsequent stray case has awarded a higher
compensation for a piece of land said to be in the same tract of the acquired
lands. If recourse is taken to such procedure, the market value already
determined in a large number of cases at uniform rates may go on requiring
either enhancement or reduction, whenever subsequent judgment of the Court
in a stray case brings about a variation in the market value of land concerned.
To say the least, such procedure if is resorted to by Courts in determination of
market value of lands lying in large tracts based on previous awards or
judgments can never reach finality. Besides, recourse to such procedure could
give ample scope for making of arbitrary and fanciful awards in land acquisition
cases. Hence, we consider it unsafe to act on a subsequent stray judgment of a
High Court in a land acquisition case to disturb its earlier large number of
judgments, where uniform rate of market value of the acquired lands in same
vicinity are fixed. Consequently, no interference with the judgment of the High
Court against which present SLPs are filed, is warranted. The SLPs are,
therefore, liable to be dismissed.”
2. Land Acquisition Officer Revenue Divisional Officer
Chittor Versus L. Kamalamma (Smt) Dead by LRS and Others K.
Krishnamachari And Others reported in (1998) 2 SCC 385,
“6.The general trend in the prices of land is on the rise ad the judicial notice of
the same had been taken by the High Court correctly and therefore, cannot be challenged.
Puttur is an urban area and the Lands in question are abutting the main road leading from
Tirupathi to Ankonam via Puttur and the acquired land was in the heart of Puttur town. To
the north of the land was in the heart of puttur town. To the north of the land in question
there is a famous Venkateswaraswamy Temple and to the immediate south, the famous
Tiruthani, one of the abodes of Lord Subrahamanyaswamy. Therefore taking into
consideration, the topography of the land we may safely proceed on the basis that the
High Court had correctly noted the Situation of the land in question which has the
potentiality of being developed as urban land. Exb. B-30 is a sale deed dated 9th August,
1976, the transaction having taken place prior to eight months from the issue of
preliminary Notification for acquisition of land in the present case. Having found that that
piece of land refereed in Ex. B- 30 is situated very close to the lands that are acquired
under the Notification in question the Reference Court and the High Court relied upon the
said document and, in our view, rightly. Further when no sales of comparable land was
available where large chunks of land had been sold, even land transactions in respect of
smaller extent of land could be taken note of as indicating the price that it may fetch in
respect of large tracts of l and by making appropriate deductions such as for development
of the land by providing enough space for roads, sewers, drains, expenses involved in
formation of a lay out, lumsum payment as also the waiting period required for selling the
sites that would be formed.”
3.
ONGC LTD. Versus Sendhabhai Vastram Patel and
Others, reported in (2005) 6 SCC 454.
“11.While determining the amount of compensation payable in respect of the
lands acquired by the State, indisputably, the market value therefore has to be
ascertained. Although, there exist different modes for arriving at market value for the land
acquired; the best method, however, as is well- known would be the amount which a
willing purchaser of the land would pay to the owner of the land as may be evidenced by
deeds of sale. In absence of any direct evidence on the said point, the court may take
recourse to other methods; viz. judgments and awards passed in respect of acquisitions of
lands made in the same village and / or neighbouring villages. Such a judgment and
award in absence of any other evidence like deed of sale, report of expert and other
relevant evidence, however, would have only evidentiary value.”
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel, therefore, urges before this
court to dismiss the appeal.
[12]
On the other hand, Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy.SGI, appearing
for the appellant further submits that the learned Trial Court solely relied upon
the earlier judgments and no other issue has been taken for appreciation. And
that judgments were passed in view of the earlier act and for earlier act whole
appreciation has been taken and based on this earlier act award cannot be
passed. And so far the issue is concerned only 2 issues were framed which are
quoted as under :-
i. Whether the value of the acquired land assessed by the LA Collector
is inadequate ?
ii. Whether the referring claimant is entitled enhanced compensation
of the acquired land ? if so, what would be the compensation ?
Except that no other issue has been framed and so far the value
of the rubber tree is concerned no issue has been framed. And there is no
material on record on what basis the award has been given, assessing value
of the rubber tree. He also said that this is the basic principle without any
evidence on record only on the assumption and presumption nothing can be
awarded.
[13]
Mr. Majumder, learned Dy.SGI, thereafter submits that in the
case in hand except the exhibit 7 i.e. the earlier judgment nothing has been
taken for consideration, so in that view of the matter this judgment cannot be
stand. One can get higher amount what he has placed on record and that
should be appropriate evidence and only after appreciating the evidence on
record Trial Court is entitled to enhance or reduce the compensation. So,
straightway without any evidence one cannot get single penny. Even the
assessment which has been given by the rubber board that also not been
exhibited. At last he prays before this court to allow his appeal.
[14]
On a careful observation of the submissions of learned counsel for
the appellant, this court is of the view that there is no embargo on the part of
the appellant to make his submission before this Court
when the matter
involved public money which is to be disbursed to the claimants. Accordingly,
the matter remanded back to the lower court to frame an issue on the point of
ownership without referring to the earlier award which has attained finality. It
is seen from the order passed by the learned Court below that no proper
reasoning is given for enhancement of compensation and no issue has been
framed on the point of title deed and mark exhibits on the point of rubber
trees/woods.
Since, the issues are not framed
and there is no justification
given for considering the same for compensation issue needs to be framed and
the claimants make out the case beyond reasonable doubt on the point of
claiming compensation for the rubber trees/woods. It is needless to observe
that, if the claimants are not the owner of the land and has no authorization to
possess the land, it is meant that they are not the owner of the land and an
unauthorized occupant being a trespasser cannot claim any benefits or
compensation on land and the structure or any plants saying that he is raising
any plants. In the absence of the same, this Court feels that the Court below
needs to look into this aspect. Accordingly, the order passed by the Court
below is set aside, and the matter is remanded to the learned Court below for
framing issue on the point of
title deed and providing an opportunity, if
required, to amend the pleadings and mark the title deeds if any, and decide
the matter as per procedure as expeditiously as possible by giving an
opportunity to both sides.
[15]
In the event, if the court is convinced that the claimants are
having valid documents and are the owners of the land then appropriate
compensation under the act and rules for land as well as in terms of rubber
wood notifications issued from time to time be marked as exhibits and on the
strength of said documents such as notification of the rubber plants appropriate
compensation be granted. If
the claimants are not able to convince the Court,
on the point of ownership, it is needless to say that they would not be entitled
for a single rupee from the public money by way of compensation. The
Judgments cited by the counsel for claimants are not applicable to the facts of
the case.
[16]
With the above observation the matter stands remanded back to
the court below for fresh adjudication and, accordingly, the appeal is allowed
and the same is disposed of. Resultantly, the Cross Objection filed by the
Cross-Objector in the connected CO(FA) 01 of 2024 also stands dismissed. As
a sequel, miscellaneous application(s) pending, if any, shall stand closed.
JUDGE
Paritosh
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
SABYASACHI GHOSH
Date: 2025.02.04 16:21:57
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review