Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
L.A. App. No.26 of 2023
The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction-1),
N.F. Railway, Badharghat, Agartala.
……….Appellant
Versus
1. Sri Ashutosh Sarkar
Son of Dasarath Sarkar,
P.S. Amtali, District- West Tripura.
……Respondent (Referring Claimant)
As per the Hon’ble Court’s order dated 20.02.2024 passed in I.A. No.03
of 2024 (petition for direction), the legal heir of respondent No.1 has
been incorporated as per schedule.
2. The Land Acquisition Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala
…………Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, DSGI.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. I. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
10.07.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
15.07.2024
YES
HON‘BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment &Order
This is an appeal under Section 74 of the Right to
Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 challenging the
judgment and award dated 11.07.2022 in connection with
case No.L.A. No.109 of 2017 delivered by the Presiding
Officer, Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Authority, Tripura, Agartala.
02.
Heard
Learned
DSGI,
Mr.
Bidyut
Majuder,
representing the appellant and also heard Learned Counsel,
Mr. I. Chakraborty, representing the sole-respondent.
03.
At this stage, Learned DSGI, Mr. Bidyut Majumder
for the appellant drawn the attention of the Court referring
para No.3 of the judgment and award delivered by the
Presiding Officer of the Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Authority, Tripura and submitted that in the
said paragraph, it was specifically mentioned that the
acquired land was land measuring was 0.300 acres classified
as ‘Tilla’, appertaining to Plot No.6594, Khatian No.2562
situated at Charipara Mouja, Sheet No.1 and 2/P under
Badharghat Tehsil, P.S. Amtali and referring para No.14 of
the said judgment and award. Learned Counsel further
submitted that considering the legal provisions as mentioned
in the aforesaid RFCTLARR Act, 2013, the Learned L.A.
Collector assessed the market value of the acquired land
rightly at the rate of Rs.4,50,000/- per kani (0.40 acre) but
the Learned Presiding Officer of the Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation
and
Resettlement
Authority
without
considering the relevant provision of Section 26, enhanced
the market price of the acquired land at the rate of
Rs.11,60,000/- per kani instead of Rs.4,50,000/- per kani
which was too high.
Thereafter,
Learned
DSGI,
Bidyut
Majumder
referred para No.25 of the said judgment and submitted that
during
the
proceeding
before
the
Land
Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority, the claimantappellant relied upon sale instances which were marked as
Exhibit-1 and Exhibit-2 and the land of those sale instances
are classified as Vastu/Viti class of land and land under
Exhibit-3 was classified as Nal land but in the present case,
the land of the claimant was ‘Tilla’ class of land. He further
referred the said para No.25 of the judgment and submitted
that the Learned Presiding Officer of the Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation
and
Resettlement
Authority
in
the
said
paragraph stated that since the lands of Exhibit-1, 2 & 3 are
not similar types of land, so, those could not be taken into
consideration and again came to the observation that the
sale instances under Exhibit-B, D & F are also classified as
Nal. So, the sale deeds also could not be taken into
consideration being not comparable with the acquired land.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant,
further
referred para No.26 of the judgment and submitted that
Learned Presiding Officer relied upon Exhibit-C and finally,
came to the observation that the sale instances under
Exhibit-4, A, C and E are found to be comparable instances
for determination of market value of the acquired land
subject to potential values of each sale instances. In this
regard,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant
drawn
the
attention of the Court that the said observation of the
Learned Presiding Officer of Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Authority was erroneous for which the
present appellant has preferred this appeal.
04.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
appellant again referred para No.31 of the said judgment and
submitted that the determination of compensation reducing
60% of Exhibit-4 by the Presiding Officer of Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority is found to be nonapplication of mind and erroneous and on the basis of that
the determination of market price of acquired land cannot be
sustained in the eye of law and prayed for allowing this
appeal by setting aside the judgment and award of the
Learned Presiding Officer of Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and Resettlement Authority.
05.
Learned Counsel for the appellant further drawn
the attention of the Court referring provision 26 of Right to
Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 and submitted
that the Learned Presiding Officer of Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation
and
Resettlement
Authority
failed
to
appreciate the relevant provision Section 26(b) of the said
Act and gave an erroneous finding which were perverse and
urged for interference of this Court.
06.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel for the
respondent-claimant, drawn the attention of the Court that
the
Learned
Presiding
Officer
of
Land
Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority after considering
oral/documentary evidence on record rightly determined the
value of the acquired land at the rate of Rs.11,60,000/- per
kani which is also too less. Because according to Learned
Counsel for the respondent-claimant, the acquired land is
nearby Agartala Municipality and its present market value is
much higher than the amount determined by the Presiding
Officer of Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Authority and after elaborate consideration of the relevant
provisions of law, the Learned Presiding Officer of Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority rightly
determined the compensation of the acquired land and
furthermore, due to filing of appeal, the referring claimant is
suffering from huge financial hardships being a poor lady and
this appeal is nothing but to drag the delay of payment in
respect of acquisition of land and urged for dismissal of this
appeal with costs.
07.
Further,
respondent,
in
Learned
course
of
Counsel
hearing,
for
the
submitted
claimantthat
the
acquired land has/had potential value and it is nearby
Agartala Municipal Corporation. In addition to that the same
is also nearby Tripura Medical College, Badharghat Rail
Station is also nearby the acquired land and furthermore,
according to Learned Counsel, the acquired land is situated
within a developing area and presently, in the said area, the
cost of any classification of land is not less than 1 crore of
rupees.
But
the
L.A.
Collector
only
determined
the
compensation to the tune of Rs.4,50,000/- per kani which
was later on enhanced to Rs.11,60,000/-. In this regard,
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in U.P. Awas Evam Vikash
Parishad
vs.
Asha
Ram
(Dead)
through
Legal
Representatives and Ors. reported in (2021) 17 SCC 289,
wherein Hon’ble the Apex Court in para No.29 observed as
under:
―29. The potentiality of the acquired land is
one of the primary factors to be taken into
consideration to determine the market
value of the land. Potentiality refers to the
capacity or possibility for changing or
developing into the state of actuality. The
market value of a property has to be
determined while having due regard to its
existing conditions with all the existing
advantages and its potential possibility
when led out in its most advantageous
manner. The question whether a land has
potential value or not primarily depends
upon its condition, situation, use to which it
is put or its reasonable capability of being
put and also its proximity to residential,
commercial or industrial areas/institutions.
The
existing
amenities
like
water,
electricity as well as the possibility of their
further extension, for instance whether
near about town is developing or has
prospects of development have to be taken
into consideration. It also depends upon
the
connectivity
and
the
overall
development of the area.‖
08.
After hearing both the sides, it appears to me that
there is no dispute on record in respect of acquisition of land
belonging
to
the
referring
claimant
by
the
Requiring
Department for the purpose of construction of Akhowrah
New Rail Line Project (Indian Project) under Sadar Subdivision of West Tripura. It is on record that the L.A.
Collector determined the market value of the acquired land
at the rate of Rs.4,50,000/- per kani. It is also on record that
the Government, i.e. the L.A. Collector acquired
land
measuring 0.300 acres appertaining to C.S. Plot No.6594,
under Khatian No.2562 at Mauja- Charipara, Sheet No.1 and
2/P along with some other lands for the purpose of
construction of Akhowrah New Rail Line Project (Indian
Project). In para No.3, 14, 25 and 31 of the said judgment,
Learned Presiding Officer of Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation
and
Resettlement
Authority
referred
the
following
observations:
―3. The LA Collector assessed and awarded
the compensation for the acquired land of
the Referring Claimant amounting to
Rs.10,77,980/- (Rupees ten lakh seventy
seven thousand nine hundred eighty) only
and
vide
notice
No.DM/W/LA/SDR/18/2014/3601-3768
dated 11-08-2017 asked to receive the said
compensation.
Being
dissatisfied
with
amount of compensation, she asked for
reference. On receiving the notice Claimant
Smt. Rikta Sarkar appeared and submitted
claim statement. In the claim statement
she stated inter alia that she was the owner
of acquired land measuring 0.300 acres
classified
as ‗Tilla‘ appertaining to Plot
No.6594 under Khatian No.2562 situated at
Charipara mouza, sheet No.1 & 2/p, Tehsil
Badharghat P/S Amtali, District, West
Tripura. According to claim statement, the
acquired land is situated at ‗Mouza‘.
Charipara nearby the Agartala Municipal
Corporation area besides Pallanpara to
West Charipara pitch road. It is pleaded
that all modern facilities like water supply
line,
electric
connection,
road
communication, school and local offices of
various deptt. Of Govt. of Tripura including
TMC & Dr. B.R.M. Teaching hospital and
Badharghat Railway Station are within one
& half km. from the acquired land. The
acquired land which are classified as ‗nal‘
can be converted to viti/vastu class of land
by developing the same with earth filling
and minimum expenditure. At the time of
acquisition the market value of the
acquired
land
was
more
than
Rs.1,40,00,000/- per kani and he claimed
compensation
amounting
to
Rs.1,05,00,000/-.
14. Indisputably, Govt. acquired 0.300 acre
land classified as ―Tilla‖ appertaining to
plot No.6594 under the khatian No.2562.
The L.A. Collector assessed the market
value of acquired land @Rs.4.5 lakh per
kani (0.40 acre). The Referring claimant
claimed that the rate of market value
determined by the LA Collector is much
lower than the prevailing market value of
the land in the area and entitled to get
enhanced compensation. So the dispute is
only about the market rate of land
determined by the LA Collector.
25. Keeping in mind of the above law and
the relevant facts this Authority has to
consider the sale instances produced by the
parties which are similar type land as
acquired land of the referring claimant i.e
Tilla class land. The evidence shows that
the land under three sale instances
produced by the claimant (Exhibit-1 and 2
are classified as bastu/viti class land and
the land under Exhibit-3 is classified as
‗Nall‘.
Besides
that,
in
the
cross
examination the claimant has admitted that
on the southern side of land under sale
instance bearing deed No. 1-1728 dated
22.03.2013 (Exhibit-1) and 1-1729 dated
22.03.2013 (Exhibit-2) respectively are
bounded by Government Road (public
road). So the above sale instances
produced by the Referring claimant are not
only classified are not only classified as
‗Bastu‘ land but also have some special
advantages having its boundary of the
public road. Similarly, on the western side
of land of sale instance bearing deed No. 11609 dated 25.08.2014 (Exhibit-3) has also
a
Government
Road
(public
road).
Therefore, the land under the sale
instances (Exhibit-1, 2 and 3) are not
similar type of land and not comparable.
Now, the sale instances under Exhibit-B,
Exhibit-D and Exhibit-F are classified as
‗Nal‘. Therefore, aforesaid sale instances
are also not similar type of land and thus
not comparable sale instances.
31. Keeping in mind to the above facts and
provision in law I am of the opinion that
the price of the Exhibit-4 (Sale deed No.157 dated 04.01.2017) should be reduced by
60% towards the high potential value in
comparison with the acquired land. In
Exhibit-4 land measuring 0.050 acres was
sold
for
Rs.6,00,000/i.e.
@
Rs.48,00,000/- per kani. If the price is
reduced by 60% then the market value of
land in Exhibit-4 per kani would come down
to Rs.19,20,000/- (40% of Rs.48,00,000/). Now, we have 4 sale instances viz;
Exhibit-3 (price reduced by 60%), ExhibitB, Exhibit-D and Exhibit-F. In view of the
Explanation-2 to section 26(1) of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013 one half of the total
number of sale deeds or agreement to sell
in which the highest sale price has been
mentioned shall be taken into account.
Amongst the 4 comparable sale instances
the price is Exhibit-4 and Exhibit-E are of
the highest sale price. Now, the rate of the
land per Kani (0.40 acre) under Exhibit-E
after
60%
discount/reduction
stands
Rs.19,20,000/- and the rate of Exhibit-F
per kani is Rs.4,00,000/-. Therefore, the
average
price
(per
Kani)
stands
(Rs.19,20,000/- + Rs.4,00,000/-) ÷ 2=
Rs.11,60,000/which
would
be
the
reasonable market price of the acquired
land.‖
09.
Further, for the sake of convenience I would like
to refer herein below the relevant provision of Section 26 of
Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013:
―26. Determination of market value of land
by Collector.–(1) The Collector shall adopt
the following criteria in assessing and
determining the market value of the land,
namely:—
(a) the market value, if any,
specified in the Indian Stamp Act,
(2
of
1899)
for
the
registration
of
sale
deeds
or
agreements to sell, as the case may
be, in the area, where the land is
situated; or
(b) the average sale price for
similar type of land situated in the
nearest village or nearest vicinity
area; or
(c)
consented
amount
of
compensation as agreed upon under
sub-section (2) of Section 2 in case
of acquisition of lands for private
companies or for public private
partnership projects,
whichever is higher:
Provided that the date for determination of
market value shall be the date on which the
notification has been issued under Section
11.
Explanation 1.—The average sale price
referred to in clause (b) shall be
determined taking into account the sale
deeds or the agreements to sell registered
for similar type of area in the near village
or near vicinity area during immediately
preceding three years of the year in which
such acquisition of land is proposed to be
made.
Explanation
2.—For
determining
the
average
sale
price
referred
to
in
Explanation 1, one-half of the total number
of sale deeds or the agreements to sell in
which the highest sale price has been
mentioned shall be taken into account.
Explanation 3.—While determining the
market value under this section and the
average
sale
price
referred
to
in
Explanation 1 or Explanation 2, any price
paid as compensation for land acquired
under the provisions of this Act on an
earlier occasion in the district shall not be
taken into consideration.
Explanation 4.—While determining the
market value under this section and the
average
sale
price
referred
to
in
Explanation 1 or Explanation 2, any price
paid, which in the opinion of the Collector is
not indicative of actual prevailing market
value may be discounted for the purposes
of calculating market value.
(2) The market value calculated as per subsection (1) shall be multiplied by a factor to
be specified in the First Schedule.
(3) Where the market value under subsection (1) or sub-section (2) cannot be
determined for the reason that—
(a) the land is situated in such area
where the transactions in land are
restricted by or under any other law
for the time being in force in that
area; or
(b) the registered sale deeds or
agreements to sell as mentioned in
clause (a) of sub-section (1) for
similar land are not available for the
immediately preceding three years;
or
(c) the market value has not been
specified under the Indian Stamp
Act, 1899 (2 of 1899) by the
appropriate authority,
the State Government concerned shall
specify the floor price or minimum price per
unit area of the said land based on the
price calculated in the manner specified in
sub-section (1) in respect of similar types
of land situated in the immediate adjoining
areas:
Provided that in a case where the Requiring
Body offers its shares to the owners of the
lands (whose lands have been acquired) as
a part compensation, for acquisition of
land, such shares in no case shall exceed
twenty-five per cent of the value so
calculated under sub-section (1) or subsection (2) or sub-section (3) as the case
may be:
Provided further that the Requiring Body
shall in no case compel any owner of the
land (whose land has been acquired) to
take its shares, the value of which is
deductible in the value of the land
calculated under sub-section (1):
Provided also that the Collector shall,
before initiation of any land acquisition
proceedings in any area, take all necessary
steps to revise and update the market
value of the land on the basis of the
prevalent market rate in that area:
Provided
also
that
the
appropriate
Government shall ensure that the market
value determined for acquisition of any
land or property of an educational
institution established and administered by
a religious or linguistic minority shall be
such as would not restrict or abrogate the
right
to
establish
and
administer
educational institutions of their choice.‖
10.
This present appeal has been preferred by the
appellant under Section 74 of the aforesaid Act. For the sake
of convenience, further, I would like to refer the relevant
provision of Section 69 of the said Act which reads as under:
―69. Determination of award by authority.–
(1)
In
determining
the
amount
of
compensation to be awarded for land
acquired including the Rehabilitation and
Resettlement entitlements, the Authority
shall take into consideration whether the
Collector has followed the parameters set
out under Section 26 to section 30 and the
provisions under Chapter V of this Act.
(2) In addition to the market value of the
land, as above provided, the Authority shall
in every case award an amount calculated
at the rate of twelve per cent per annum on
such
market
value
for
the
period
commencing on and from the date of the
publication of the preliminary notification
under section 11 in respect of such land to
the date of the award of the Collector or the
date of taking possession of the land,
whichever is earlier.
(3) In addition to the market value of the
land as above provided, the Authority shall
in every case award a solatium of one
hundred
per
cent
over
the
total
compensation amount.‖
11.
From the aforesaid provision, it appears that in
determining the amount of compensation, the authority
concerned
shall take into consideration as to whether the
Collector in determining the amount of compensation had
followed the parameters set out under Section 26 to Section
30 and the provision of Chapter-V of the aforesaid Act 2013
or not.
12.
I have gone through the records of the Learned
Presiding Officer of Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Authority and also perused the judgment. To
substantiate the case, both the parties have reproduced
oral/documentary evidence on record. Referring claimants
have adduced 5 nos. of documentary evidence which were
marked as Exhibit-1 to Exhibit-5, on the other hand, the O.P.
No.2 i.e. the L.A. Collector relied upon sale instances which
were marked as Exhibit-A to Exhibit-F. Certain issues were
framed by the Learned Presiding Officer of Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority and in determining
the amount of compensation, it appears that Learned
Presiding Officer of Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Authority has relied upon Section 26(b) of the
said Act and also relied upon few citations:
i. Land Acquisition Officer vs. Karigowda reported in (2010) 5
SCC 708.
ii. Lal Chand vs. Union of India reported in AIR (2010) SC
170.
iii. Printers House Pvt. Ltd. vs. Saiyadan reported in (1994)
SCC (2) 133.
iv. Revenue Divisional Officer-cum-Land Acquisition Officer
vs. Shaik Azam Saheb & Ors. reported in (2009) 4 SCC 395.
v. U.P. Awas Evam Vikash Parishad vs. Asha Ram (D) Thr.
LRs & Ors, Civil Appeal No.337 of 2021 (arising out of SLP
(Civil) No.4445 of 2020).
13.
Further,
in
determining
the
amount
of
compensation, Learned Presiding Officer of Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation
and
Resettlement
Authority
relied
upon
Exhibit-4 and Exhibit-E and in both the sale instances, the
classification of land was Chara (Tilla) and Tilla/Chara (Nal).
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for the
appellant has drawn the attention of the Court that Chara
(Tilla) class of land cannot be equated with ‘Tilla’ class of
land. In this regard, this Court is of the opinion that in Tilla
class of land, the same may be used for the production of
forestry, horticulture and production of minor crops. So,
there cannot be any basic difference in respect of Chara
(Tilla) class of land and ‘Tilla’ class of land.
14.
Learned Presiding Officer of the Land Acquisition,
Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority in para No.31 of
the aforesaid judgment deducted 60% towards high potential
value in comparison with the acquired land in pursuance of
the judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Lal
Chand vs. Union of India and Anr reported in
(2009) 15
SCC 769. In para Nos.13 and 14 of the said judgment,
Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
―13. The percentage of 'deduction for
development' to be made to arrive at the
market value of large tracts of undeveloped
agricultural
land
(with
potential
for
development), with reference to the sale
price of small developed plots, varies
between 20% to 75% of the price of such
developed plots, the percentage depending
upon the nature of development of the lay
out in which the exemplar plots are
situated.
14. The 'deduction for development'
consists of two components. The first is
with reference to the area required to be
utilised for developmental works and the
second is the cost of the development
works. For example if a residential layout is
formed by DDA or similar statutory
authority, it may utilise around 40% of the
land area in the layout, for roads, drains,
parks, play grounds and civic amenities
(community facilities).‖
15.
Further in U.P. Awas Evam Vikash Parishad
vs. Asha Ram (D) THR. LRS and ORS (supra), Hon’ble the
Apex Court in para No.31 observed as under:
―31. The sale instances of a smaller area
have to be considered while keeping in
view the principle that where a large area
is the subject matter of acquisition,
suitable deduction is required to be made
as no prudent purchaser would purchase
large extent of land on the basis of sale of a
small extent in the open market. The Court
thus has to consider whether the willing
vendee would offer the rate at which the
trial court proposes to determine the
compensation.
This
Court
has
even
provided
for
50%
deduction
for
development
charges
on
the
price
mentioned in the sale deed.‖
16.
Relying upon the aforesaid citations, the Presiding
Officer of Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Authority as already stated deducted 60% from Exhibit-4 i.e.
as per Exhibit-4 land measuring 0.050 acre was sold for at
the rate of Rs.6,00,000/-, i.e. at the rate of Rs.48,00,000/per kani and after 60% deduction, as per Exhibit-4, the
valuation of land per kani comes to Rs.19,20,000/- i.e. 40%
of Rs.48,00,000/- and as per explanation 2 of Section 26 of
the aforesaid
Act, the Learned
Presiding Officer
after
comparing the 4 comparable sale instances came to the
observation that sale instances of Exhibit-4 and Exhibit-E are
of the highest sale price and as per Exhibit-4, the Learned
Presiding Officer after deduction determined the amount per
kani Rs.19,20,000/- and the rate of Exhibit-E per kani was
Rs.4,00,000/-. Thereafter, Learned Presiding Officer of Land
Acquisition,
Rehabilitation
and
Resettlement
Authority
determined the average price per kani as (Rs.19,20,000/- +
Rs.4,00,000/-) ÷ 2 = Rs.11,60,000/- per kani for the
acquired land which in my considered view appears to be
more reasonable and justified in accordance with law as
much I do not find any infirmity in the judgment delivered by
the
Learned
Rehabilitation
Presiding
and
Officer
Resettlement
of
Land
Authority.
Acquisition,
Thus,
after
hearing both the sides, it appears to me that the appellant
has failed to satisfy the Court any satisfactory grounds for
interference.
17.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant
under Section 74 of the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency
in
Land
Acquisition,
Rehabilitation
and
Resettlement Act, 2013 stands dismissed being devoid of
merit. The judgment and award dated 11.07.2022
in
connection with case No.L.A. No.109 of 2017 delivered by
the Presiding Officer, Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement
Authority,
Tripura
is
hereby
upheld
and
accordingly, it is affirmed. The appellant be asked to deposit
the awarded amount as per award of the Presiding Officer of
Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority,
Tripura immediately to the appropriate authority, so that the
payment may be disbursed to the referring claimant at an
earliest.
Send down the LCRs along with copy of the
judgment.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA DATTA DATTA
Date: 2024.07.16 16:30:29 +05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review