Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
LA App. No. 28 of 2023
The Deputy Chief Engineer (Construction-1),
N.F. Railway, Badharghat, Agartala.
...... Appellant
VERSUS
1) Smt. Sandhya Rani Deb,
Wife of late haripada Deb, resident of Charipara,
P.S. Amtali, District- West Tripura
2) Sri. Rajesh Deb,
Son of late Haripada Deb, resident of Charipara,
P.S. Amtali, District- West Tripura.
….Respondents (Referring claimants)
3) The Land Acquisition Collector,
West Tripura, Agartala.
...... Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. B Majumder, Dy. SGI.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. R. Choudhury, Sr. Adv.
Mr. D. Deb, Adv.
Along with
CO (FA) No. 10 of 2023
1. Smt. Sandhya Rani Deb (aged 62 years)
W/O Lt. Haripada Deb
2. Sri Rajesh Deb (aged 40 years)
S/O Lt. Haripada Deb
- Both residents of Charipara, P.S.- Amtali
District-West Tripura
…..Referring-Claimants-Respondent-Cross Objectors
VERSUS
1.The Deputy Chief Engineer, Con-1
N.F. Railway, Badharghat, Agartala
P.S.- Amtali, District- West Tripura
……..O.P. No.1 – Appellant
2. The L.A. Collector
West Tripura, Agartala
Pin.- 799001
......O.P. No.2-Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. D. R. Choudhury, Sr. Adv.
Mr. D. Deb, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B Majumder, Dy. SGI.
Date of hearing
:
08.12.2023
Date of Delivery of judgment :
25.01.2024
Whether fit for reporting
YES
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. D. PURKAYASTHA
ORDER & JUDGMENT
Both the appeal and cross objection have arisen from the award
passed by Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority of
Tripura (for short, “the authority”) on 23.08.2022 in LA Case. No.85 of
2017.
2.
An area of 0.43 acre of the land of the claimant-cross objectors
(hereinafter referred as the Claimants) was acquired by the government
vide notification No.F.09(05)-REV/SEQ/VI/16 dated 28.01.2017 issued
under Section 11 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in
Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (for short, “the
Act”) for the purpose of construction of Agartala–Akhaura new railway line
appertaining to the following RS plots with respective areas:
Acquired Land
Khatian No.1031 of
mouja- Charipara
Plot No.
Quantum of Land
acquired
0.06 acr.
Class of Land
Chara (Tilla)
0.27 acr.
Chara (Tilla)
0.10 acr.
Bastu (Tilla)
Total- 0.43 acr.
3.
The LA Collector awarded compensation @ Rs.4.50,000/- per
kani for both the classes of land and thereafter, applied the multiplier of 1.5
to reach out the quantum of compensation apart from other statutory
interests. On reference, the authority enhanced the compensation and
made it @ Rs.30,40,000/- per kani with other statutory reliefs, including a
similar application of the multiplier of 1.5.
4.
The original owner, Smt. Sandhya Rani Deb, transferred the
said acquired land to her son Rajesh Deb and therefore, Rajesh Deb was
also made a party before the authority.
5.
Claim of the claimants for the land valuation before the
authority was @ Rs.1,50,00,000/- per kani. According to them, the
acquired land was located at Mouja Charipara under Tahshil Badharghat
nearby the Agartala Municipal Corporation area conjoined with
present-
time facilities like water and electricity supply, road communication,
existence of different Govt. offices in that locality etc. According to them,
TMC & Dr. B.R.M Teaching Hospital and Badharghat Railway Station were
also situated within the range of 1.5 km therefrom.
6.
LA Collector contested the proceedings before the authority
supporting
their
award,
stating
that
after
considering
several
sale
exemplars available for the adjacent lands and also considering the market
price prevailing at the relevant point of time, the compensation was duly
determined by them.
7.
From the side of the claimant, Sri. Rajesh Deb examined
himself before the authority and also proved four numbers of sale deeds
and one map to support their claim, whereas from the side of LA Collector,
one Narendra Chandra Deb was examined and six numbers of sale deeds
were proved into evidence. The appellant NF Railway, did not contest the
claim by submitting any counter objection.
8.
During hearing, Mr. B Majumder, learned Deputy SGI, argued
that the award passed by the authority was exorbitant and that even the
authority enhanced the compensation six times more than the award
passed by the LA Collector.
9.
According to Mr. Majumder, learned counsel, the authority
relied on the Exbt.-1 and Exbt.-4 to determine the compensation and
Exbt.-1 relates to Bastu class of land and not similar to the acquired plot of
Bastu (tilla) class of land and therefore, the authority misapplied the
provision of Section 26 of the Act which envisages that the sale deeds in
respect of similar class of land should be taken into consideration and
moreover, Exbt.-4 was executed just few days prior to the date of
notification. Learned counsel further tried to bolster his submission, stating
that the land of Exbt.-4 was not traceable in the map (Exbt.-5) indicating
thereby, that it was far away from the acquired land.
10.
Mr. Majumder, learned counsel further challenged the award on
the ground that nowhere the distance of the sale exemplars from the
acquired land were mentioned but the authority lost sight of the same.
11.
Mr. D. Deb, learned counsel for the claimants, refuted the
submission, pointing out that the lands under Exbt.-1 and Exbt.-4 were
similar in class as of the acquired land, and there the transaction took place
at a much higher rate and illegally the authority while determining the
compensation reduced 20% from the sale price of Exbt.-1 and 40% from
the sale price of Exbt.-4 on the ground of development costs and also on
consideration that the area of the plots under Exbt.-1 and Exbt.-4 were
smaller than the acquired land. Therefore, according to Mr. Deb, learned
counsel, higher price ought to have been awarded by the authority to the
claimants.
12.
Before
re-appreciating
the
evidence
on
record
and
the
observations made by the authority, the basic principles underlying in the
Act for determination of market value of land, are required to be referred
to. Sub-Section (1) of Section 26 of the Act, therefore, is reproduced
bellow:-
“26. Determination of market value of land by Collector:-
(1) The Collector shall adopt the following criteria in assessing
and determining the market value of the land, namely:(a)
the market value, if any, specified in the Indian Stamp
Act, 1899 (2 of 1899) for the registration of sale deeds
or agreements to sell, as the case may be, in the area,
where the land is situated; or
(b)
the average sale price for similar type of land situated
in the nearest village or nearest vicinity area; or
(c)
consented amount of compensation as agreed upon
under sub-section (2) of section 2 in case of acquisition
of lands for private companies or for public private
partnership projects,
Whichever is higher :
Provided that the date for determination of market value shall be
the date on which the notification has been issued under section
11.
Explanation 1- The average sale price referred to in clause (b)
shall be determined taking into account the sale deeds or the
agreements to sell registered for similar type of area in the near
village or near vicinity area during immediately preceding three
years of the year in which such acquisition of land is proposed to
be made.
Explanation 2- For determining the average sale price referred to
in Explanation 1, one-half of the total number of sale deeds or the
agreements to sell in which the highest sale price has been
mentioned shall be taken into account.
Explanation 3- While determining the market value under this
section and the average sale price referred to in Explanation 1 or
Explanation 2, any price paid as compensation for land acquired
under the provisions of this Act on an earlier occasion in the
district shall not be taken into consideration.
Explanation 4- While determining the market value under this
section and the average sale price referred to in Explanation 1 or
Explanation 2, any price paid which in the opinion of the Collector
is not indicative of actual prevailing market value may be
discounted for the purposes of calculating market value.”
13.
To determine the compensation basing on the sale exemplars,
the provision, therefore enumerates that the average sale price for a
similar type (emphasis laid) of land situated in the near village or near
vicinity area should be taken into consideration. Therefore, the land under
sale exemplar, even if not situated in the same village of the acquired land,
is also permitted to be taken into consideration. Explanation 2 of Section 26
further stipulates that one-half of the total number of the sale deeds shall
be taken into account in which the highest sale price (emphasis laid) has
been demonstrated.
14.
The provision of Section 26 further cast a duty on the Collector
to consider the sale price of similar type of land. The words „similar type‟
cannot be equated with the words „same type‟. As per Oxford Advanced
Learner‟s Dictionary, 8th Edition, the word „same‟ denotes „exactly the one
or ones referred to or mentioned‟ whereas, the word „similar‟ means „like
but not exactly the same‟.
15.
Explanation
No.1
provides
that
the
sale
transactions
or
agreement to sale of similar types of area of preceding three years should
be taken into consideration, and the same may be made the basis for
determining such compensation after taking average sale price of one-half
of the total number of sale deeds or sale agreements which were on
highest side. The words „similar type of area‟ as mentioned in Explanation 1
do not confine only to take into consideration of the sale exemplars
involving similar quantity of land, like the quantity of the acquired land.
Otherwise, on many occasions, it may not be possible for the acquiring
authority to collect such types of sale exemplars having similarity with both
class and quantity of the acquired land.
16.
The authority in the impugned award has also given a tabular
demonstration of the sale exemplars relied upon by both the parties in
table 1 and table 2 which for useful references are reproduced hereunder:-
Table-1 (Exhibited Sale deeds and map)
Sl.
Exhibit
Sale Deed/Map
No.
Type/Class
Quantum
Value
of Land
of Land
(Rs.)
Rate per kani
Sale
Deed
Bastu
0.030 acre 3,00,000/40,00,000/No.11728,
dated
22.03.2013
Sale
Deed
Bastu
0.010 acre 5,00,000/- 2,00,00,000/No.11729,
dated
22.03.2013
Sale
Deed
Nal
0.060 acre 4,50,000/30,00,000/No.11609,
dated
22.03.2014
Sale
Deed
Chara
0.050 acre 6,00,000/48,00,000/No.1- 57, dated
(Tila)
04.01.2017
Settlement Map of mouja Charipara (sheet No.2) showing Plot No.
6876,6898 and 6907.
Khatian No. 1031 in the name of Rajesh Deb.
Table-2 (Exhibited Sale deeds of OP No.2)
Sl.
Sale Deed
Sale
Deed
No.1- 3185,
dated
08.04.2016
Sale Deed
No.1- 4537,
dated
13.05.2016
Sale Deed
No.1- 7952,
dated
10.09.2015
Sale Deed
No.1- 0405,
dated
21.01.2014
Sale Deed
No.1- 647,
dated
31.01.2014
Sale Deed
No.1- 1756,
dated
13.03.2014
Type/Class
Quantum
Rate per
Value (Rs.)
Exhibit No.
of Land
of Land
Kani
Bagan (Tila),
Chara (Tila)
&
Bastu
(Tila)
NAL
0.140 acre
Rs. 1.5
Lakh
RS. 40, 000/-
A
0.200 acre
Rs. 1.60
Lakh
Rs. 80, 000/-
B
TILA
0.040 acre
Rs. 3
Lakh
Rs. 30,000/-
C
NAL
0.310 acre
Rs. 1.3
Lakhs
Rs.
1,00,000/-
D
Tilla/Chara
(Nal)
0.030 acre
Rs. 4
Lakh
Rs. 30,000/-
E
NAL
0.630 acre
Rs. 1.77
Lakh say
Rs. 1.8
Lakhs
Rs.2,80,000/-
F
17.
The authority while appreciating those sale exemplars observed
that the acquired plot Nos.6867 and 6898 are connected with one road and
the land was not far away from the Agartala city area.
18.
The reasons, as assigned by the authority, for determination of
the land valuation after appreciation of the sale exemplars, are referred by
extracting para 35 of the impugned award:
“35.
Now
coming
to
the
acquired
land
measuring
(0.060+0.270+0.100)=0.430 acres classified as Bastu (Tilla),
and Chara (Tilla) is to be compared with the similar class of
sale instances under Exhibit-1, Exhibit-2, Exhibit-4, Exhibit-A
and Exhibit-C. According to the provision in section 26 of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013 and the guideline of the Hon‟ble Supreme
court in Special Land Acquisition Officer and another vs.
Sidappa Omanna Tumari and another (supra) it is necessary to
consider the area or size of the acquired land. The quantum of
land under Exhibit-2 (Sale deed no.-1-729) dated 22-03-2013 is
0.010 acre only. The size of this plot is so small that it is not at
all suitable for construction of any house or building except for
a shop in the market area. The said land perhaps purchased for
construction of shop in the market area or to extend of any
adjacent area for construction of building. It is not the case of
the claimant that the acquired land is located at market area.
So the sale instance under Exhibit-2 is discarded as it is not
similar type of land in view of the reasons as stated above. On
scrutiny
of
the
sale
instances,
it is
transpired
that
the
transaction value of land measuring 0.030 acre classified as
„Bastu‟ under Exhibit-1 is Rs.3,00,000/- i.e. Rs.40,00,000/- per
kani (0.04 acre). Again land measuring 0.05 acres under
Exhibit-4, classified as Chara (Tila) was sold for Rs.6,00,000/i.e. Rs. 48,00,000/- per kani. The quantum of land in Exhibit-1
and Exhibit -4 are very small as compared to the acquired land.
Therefore, sale price of instance under Exhibit-1 should be
reduced by 20% and the sale price of land under Exhibit-4 be
reduced by 40% (towards small size and Development cost). So
the discounted price of land under Exhibit-1 per kani (0.400
acre) is reduced to Rs.32,00,000/- and the price of Exhibit-4
per kani reduced to Rs.28,80,000/-. The price of sale instance
under Exhibit-A is Rs.1,14,000/- and Exhibit-C is Rs.3,00,000/-.
In view of the Explanation – 2 to section 26 (1) of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013 one half of the total number of sale deeds
or agreement to sell of the highest sale price shall be taken into
account. So, to determine the market price Exhibit-1 and
Exhibit-4 are taken into consideration. On calculation, the
average market price per kani of land under Exhibit-1 and
Exhibit-4,
is
Accordingly,
(32,00,000+28,80,000)/2
the
market
value
of
=
Rs.
30,40,000/-.
land
measuring
(0.060+0.270+0.100) = 0.430 acres classified as Chara (Tilla)
and Bastu (Tilla), under plot Nos. 6876, 6898 and 6970 is
determined at the rate of Rs.30,40,000/- per kani which is to be
multiplied by factor 1.5 to determined the value of the acquired
land.”
19.
The authority therefore, apart from Exbt.-1, Exbt.-4, Exbt.-A
i.e. of Bastu, Chara(tilla), Bagan (tilla) with chara (tilla) and Bastu (tilla)
class of land respectively, also took into consideration Ext.C i.e tilla class
of land, and the land under Exbt.-2 was discarded by the Authority on the
ground that the area of the land (0.1 acre) was too small assuming that it
was perhaps purchased for construction of any shop with commercial
intent.
20.
Ext.1 and Ext.2 were executed beyond the preceding 3 years of
the year of acquisition. Only Ext. 4 and Ext.A are of Chara (Tilla) class of
land like the acquired land. Land under Ext.C is of Tilla class i.e. more or
less similar to some of the acquired plots. Therefore, if these 3 deeds are
taken into consideration, one-half of the exemplars on the higher side are
Ext.4 and Ext.C.
If, average of the rate involved in Ext.4 and Ext.C are
taken into consideration, it comes to Rs.25,50,000/-.
21.
Situated thus, the value of the acquired land is determined @
Rs.25,50,000/- per kani. The claimant-cross objectors are, therefore,
entitled to get compensation for the land @ Rs.25,50,000/- per kani and
along with the same, they will be entitled to get further compensation by
multiplying such land value with the factor 1.5, 100% solatium and
additional compensation/interest under Sections 69 and 72 of the Act as
awarded by the authority. In addition, a cost of Rs.1000/-, as awarded by
the authority, will also be paid by the LA Collector to the claimants.
Accordingly, the appeal is partly allowed and the cross
objection is dismissed.
No order as to any other cost(s). Pending application(s), if any,
also stands disposed of.
Send down the LCR‟s forthwith.
JUDGE
SATABDI DUTTA
Satabdi
DUTTA
Date: 2024.01.29 13:45:26 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review