Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC011024552017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3548]
MONDAY, THE FIFTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 3352/2017
Between:
1. THE DEPOT MANAGER, APSRTC KAKINADA EAST GODAVARI
DISTRICT
2. MANAGING DIRECTOR APSRTC, MUSHEERABAD, HYDERABAD.
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. PACHIPULUSU MARUTHI SHYAM KUMAR
SYAMBABU S/O
VENKATESWARA RAO, D NO 6-93 VINAYAK NAGAR COLONY
ELURU, WEST GODAVARI DISTRICT
2. CHERUKURI LAKSHMIPATHI RAJU S/O SATYANARAYANA RAJU,
THARANGI, KAKINADA, EAST GODAVARI DISTRICT
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal filed under Order 41 of CPC praying thet the Highcourt may be
pleased to
IA NO: 1 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
grant stay of execution of Decree passed by Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal
(Principal District Judge) West Godavari at Eluru passed in M.V.O.P.No. 402
of 2010 dated 08.08.2017 pending disposal of the above M.A.C.M.A.No.
/2017 and pass
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.3352 of 2017
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. .
2. K SRINIVASA PRASAD SC For APSRTC
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. SRINIVAS EMANI
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.3352 of 2017
The Court made the following:
JUDGMENT
Heard Sri Y.Chakradhar Raju, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
Sri K.Srinivasa Prasad, learned Standing Counsel for APSRTC appearing for
the appellants and Sri B.Sanjaiah Gandhi, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of Sri
Srinivas Emani, learned counsel for the respondent
No.1/claimant.
2.
Dissatisfied with the order passed in M.V.O.P.No.402 of 2010 by the
Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-cum-Principal District Judge, West Godavari,
Eluru, the present appeal is filed by APSRTC and the 1st respondent herein is
the claimant and the 2nd respondent herein is the RTC Driver.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties will be referred to as they are
arrayed before the Tribunal.
4.
The facts leading to the case, as raised in the present appeal as well as
before the Tribunal, are as follows:
The injured petitioner was aged about 20 years and was working as a
Computer Mechanic in the Global Computer Centre, Eluru and was earning
Rs.10,000/- per month as on the date of accident. The accident took place on
11.09.2009 while the injured was going on motor cycle bearing No. AP 37 AR
5095 to fix camera in the ATM centre of Union Bank, Suryarao Street,
Kakinada and when reached near Satyanarayana Swamy Temple, the
accident vehicle i.e., APSRTC bus bearing No. AP 10Z 9333 came in a rash
and negligent manner and dashed the motor cycle, due to which the bus has
ran over his leg, resultantly sustained fracture to his left leg and also received
certain injuries lacerated to his right hand elbow joint. The injured was shifted
to the Government General Hospital, Kakinada and from there, he was shifted
to the Government Hospital, Vijayawada and thereafter, to Royal Hospital,
Vijayawada, where he underwent operation on 12.09.2009, to his left leg and
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.3352 of 2017
on 21.09.2009, he was later shifted to Peoples Poly Clinic, where skin grafting
was done and finally, discharged on 07.10.2009.
5.
A crime was registered in crime No.177 of 2009 for the offence under
Section 338 of Indian Penal Code, 1860, against respondent No.2. The main
assertion of the claimant is that due to the injuries, he sustained permanent
disability and lost his earning capacity and prayed for joint and several liability
to pay the compensation by the respondents.
6.
The respondent Nos.1 and 2 remained ex parte in the Court below and
respondent No.3, who is the appellant herein refuted the contentions of the
claimant in the MVOP by filing a written statement stating that there is no
negligence on the part of the respondent No.1 and the accident occurred only
due to the rider of the motor cycle who could not control and fell down.
7.
Basing on the pleadings before the Court below, three issues were
framed.
1. Whether there is any rash and negligent driving on the part of
the driver driving APSRTC bus bearing No. AP 27T 5477?
2. Whether the petitioner is entitled for the compensation as
claimed and to what relief?
8.
The first issue was answered in favour of the claimant by the Tribunal,
after elaborate discussion of the evidence adduced by the claimant. The
Tribunal has come to the conclusion that there is rash and negligent driving by
the 1st respondent-driver, after examining the witnesses P.Ws.1 to 3. The
Tribunal has taken note of Ex.A4, which is the charge sheet, confronting that
the Police found fault with the 1st respondent and alleged that the accident
occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the 1st respondent.
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.3352 of 2017
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant before this Court has placed reliance
upon the judgment, T.O.Anthony vs. Karvarnan and others1 to fortify his
arguments that when there is a composite negligence by both the parties,
awarding of compensation cannot be loosely taken note of. The judgment of
the Tribunal, as seen, in its holistic reading, can be noted that there is any
contributory negligence or composite negligence and the Tribunal concluded
that it is only due to the rash and negligent driving of the Driver of the 1 st
respondent and did not rely upon the judgment as it is distinguishable. Having
held that there is rash and negligent driving established, the issue No.1 was
answered in favour of the claimant.
10.
Insofar as the issue No.2, the claimant placed the salary slips issued by
of the employer, Global Computer Centre, Eluru, to establish that he was
earning an amount of Rs.10,000/- per month as on the date of accident, which
occurred on 11.09.2009. The claimant further placed strong reliance upon the
treatment slips/bills of the Hospital, where he spent an amount of
Rs.2,50,000/-. To prove the statement, he got examined two doctors, P.Ws.4
and 5. P.W.4 is the Doctor of the Royal Hospital, who stated that the claimant
was admitted in the Hospital with the injuries of facture left femur and vascular
injury to left thigh and on 12.09.2009 the petitioner underwent surgery and
during surgery interlocking nail of femur and repair of left papliteal artery with
vein graft was done. The bills were marked by the claimant as exhibits from
Exs.A6 to A87 to establish that he has incurred an amount of Rs.2,50,000/-.
The Tribunal, after considering the said exhibits-bills, awarded Rs.2,20,000/under the head of Hospital, Medical and other expenses. In support of the said
awarding of compensation, the Tribunal has relied upon the judgment of this
Court in Managing Director, Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport
Corporation v. Kathavath Gopal2, which held that the compensation towards
expenditure incurred and transportation cannot be denied even though the
2008 (3) SSC 748
2003 (5) ALD 198
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.3352 of 2017
treatment was given in the Government Hospital and one cannot be expected
to produce the evidence proving the actual expenditure, and, hence some
reasonable hypothesis cannot be ruled out. Towards transportation, incidental
charges, future expenditure and other expenses, a sum of Rs.20,000/- was
awarded.
11.
Now, coming to the salary certificate adduced as Ex.A5, purported to be
issued by the employer of the claimant, the Tribunal has not considered the
said certificate merely on the ground that the salary certificate was not proved
by examining the employer and on hypothesis basis, an amount of Rs.6,000/was awarded and further he was out of work for six months. So, in total, the
Tribunal has awarded compensation of Rs.36,000/-. The Tribunal, under the
Head-Injury, Shock, Pain and Suffering, awarded a sum of Rs.1,50,000/-,
under the Head-Hospital, Medical and other expenses awarded an amount of
Rs.2,20,000/-, Rs.36,000/- under the Head-loss of earning, past and present
and Rs.20,000/- under the Head-Transportation, Incidental Charges, Future
Expenditure and others. In total, a sum of Rs.4,26,000/- was awarded as
compensation to that of Rs.10,00,000/- as claimed by the claimant.
12.
The expenditure said to have been incurred by the claimant by
adducing the evidence and marking all the bills issued by the Hospitals and
other treatment agencies, was of Rs.2,50,000/- asserted by the claimant.
When coming to the aspect of earning capacity, it is seen that the salary slip is
of Rs.10,000/- per month issued by the Global Computer Centre, where the
claimant was working as Computer Mechanic. It is an established law that a
salary slip indicating the amount, which is the earning, issued by the
competent authority, should not be loosely denied except when there is a
strong opposition by the respondents or the insurance company. Nowhere in
the judgment of the Tribunal this Court finds that there is refutal by the
appellant herein regarding the said salary, being salary towards monthly
income issued by the employer and as stated above, the Tribunal has taken
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.3352 of 2017
on hypothesis basis as Rs.6,000/-. This Court finds that the Tribunal recorded
erroneous findings by picking holes in the evidence when there is no strong
rebuttal by the appellant-APSRTC. Taking into consideration the facts and
circumstances, this Court is of the opinion that an amount of Rs.8,500/- would
be reasonable in awarding compensation towards loss of earnings, past and
present and under the Head-Hospital, Medical and other expenses, taking all
the bills into consideration, the total amount would be Rs.2,50,000/-. The
Tribunal has not taken note of the judgment of this Court in Managing
Director’s case, where un-debatable grounds held that compensation
towards expenditure and transportation cannot be denied. Admittedly the
claimants placed all the necessary bills issued by the authorities towards
treatment and in view of the said observation by this Court, there is no
justification for the Tribunal to deviate from the above ratio and hence the
amount of Rs.2,50,000/- as claimed is justified.
13.
For the above reasons, this Court is of the opinion that the claimant is
entitled for enhancement of Rs.30,000/- under the Head-Hospital, Medical and
other expenses and Rs.8,500/- for six months (Rs.8500 X 6 = Rs.51,000/-)
under the Head-loss of earnings, past and present. Therefore, the total
compensation is as under:
S.No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
Head
Compensation under the Heads injury,
shock, pain and suffering
Compensation under the heads
Hospital, Medical and other expenses
Compensation under the Head of Loss
Earnings, Past and Present
Compensation under the Head of
Transportation, Incidental Charges,
Future
Expenditure
and
other
expenses
Total:
Compensation
Awarded
Rs.1,50,000/Rs.2,50,000/Rs.51,000/-
Rs.20,000/Rs.4,71,000/-
GTK,J
M.A.C.M.A.No.3352 of 2017
14.
In fine, the Motor Accidents Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is dismissed.
However, the order passed by the Tribunal is modified, enhancing the
compensation granted to the claimants from Rs.4,26,000/- to Rs.4,71,000/with interest @ 9% per annum. The appellants and 2nd respondent herein are
directed to deposit the aforesaid enhanced amount of compensation before
the Tribunal, within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of a copy
of this judgment, after deducting the amount, if any, deposited earlier. On such
deposit, the claimant is entitled to withdraw the same.
15.
As a sequitur, Interlocutory Applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
_____________________________
JUSTICE TUHIN KUMAR GEDELA
Date: 05.01.2026
MDP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review