Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP NO.66 OF 2022
Shri Hari Sankar Kurmi
(No.01030562-CT/DVR,E-Coy 03 Bn. TSR)
S/0. Late Bhagatbat Kurmi,
Resident of –Sonaray, P.O.- Marcharra,
P.S- Kamalpur, Dist- Dhalai-Tripura.
Present address:C/o. Deo Kumar Kurmi,
S/o- lt. Laxmi Prasad Kurmi,
Vill & P.O: Paschim Champamura,
P.S. Bodhjungnagar, Dist-West Tripura,
Pin-799 008.
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. Commandant,
130 Bn, Border Security Force, Sundarbani,
P.O- Sundarbani, Dist- Rajouri, J & K,
Pin-185 153: Email: comdt130@bsf.nic.in
(Owner of Vehicle No.TR-01-J-1661.
Bearing Model & Make- Tata 5-TONNER).
2. H/C- Naresh Kumar, (No.94005758)
S/o. Sri Kanwar Singh, 130 BSF,
130 Bn. Border Security Force, Sundarbani,
PO- Sundarbani, Dist: Rajouri, J & K,
Pin-185 153
(Driver of the Vehicle No.TR-01j-1661 TATA 5-TONNER.
3. The Inspector General of Border Security Force,
Tripura Frontier, Salbagan via Agartala,
West Tripura, Pin-799 010.
(Head of BSF, Tripura & controlling authority of the
Commandant 130 BSF-the owner of the vehicle No.TR-01J1661 TATA 5 TONNER.
……. Respondent-O.P(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. P.K. Pal, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI
MAC APP NO. 6 OF 2023
1. Commandant,
130 Bn, Border Security Force, Sundarbani,
P.O- Sundarbani, Pin-185 153
Dist- Rajouri, J & K,
(Owner of Vehicle No.TR-01-J-1661.
Bearing Model & Make- Tata 5-TON).
2. H/C- Naresh Kumar, (No.94005758)
S/o. Sri Kanwar Singh, 130 BSF,
130 Bn. Border Security Force, Sundarbani,
PO- Sundarbani, Pin-185 153
Dist: Rajouri, J & K,
(Driver of the Vehicle No.TR-01j-1661 TATA 5-TON.
3. The Inspector General of Border Security Force,
Jammu Frontier, Paloura,
Jammu(Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir), Pin-181124
(Head of BSF, Ftr HQ Jammu & Present Controlling Authority
of the Commandant 130 BSF-the owner of the vehicle
No.TR-01-J1661 TATA 5 TON).
……… Appellant.OPs(s)
Vs.
Shri Hari Sankar Kurmi
(No.01030562-CT/DVR,E-Coy 03 Bn. TSR)
S/0. Late Bhagatbat Kurmi,
Resident of –Sonaray, P.O.- Marcharra,
P.S- Kamalpur, Dist- Dhalai-Tripura.
Present address:C/o. Deo Kumar Kurmi,
S/o- lt. Laxmi Prasad Kurmi,
Vill & P.O: Paschim Champamura,
P.S. Bodhjungnagar, Dist-West Tripura,
Pin-799 008.
………Respondent-Claimant(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy SGI
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. P.K. Pal, Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 20.04.2023.
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT AND ORDER(ORAL)
Both the appeals are heard, tagged, and taken up
together for disposal since the fact of both the cases are related
and the same Judgment and award as passed by the learned
Tribunal below is under challenge.
2.
Both the MAC appeals are filed under Section 173
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988(as amended upto date) against
the judgment and award dated 01.06.2022 passed in T.S.(MAC)
08 of 2018 by Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West
Tripura, Agartala (Court No.4).
3.
The fact of the case of MAC App. No.66 of 2022 is
that on 26.03.2017 at about 6.30/7.00 a.m. claimant Harisankar
Kurmi was proceeding towards his workplace at 3 Bn. TSR
Camp, Sukiabari by riding motor cycle bearing No. TR-04-A-
5396 from his house(Sonarai-Basti) to join his duties after
enjoying leave. When he reached near the said TSR Camp he
noticed that a vehicle bearing No.TR-01-J-1661 was coming
from the opposite direction at a high speed in a negligent
manner. Seeing the vehicle, the claimant stopped his motorcycle
but unfortunately, the vehicle dashed the claimant for which he
fell down and sustained severe injuries on his person. Instantly
he was shifted to Kamalpur Sub-Divisional Hospital in an
unconscious condition by the local people and TSR jawans
wherefrom he was referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala
where after some medical tests, the attended doctors advised to
shift the claimant to National Neurological Sciences, Kolkata for
better management. Hence, on the same day, he was taken to
National Neurosciences Centre, Kolkata and according to the
advise of the doctors of said hospital, the patient was treated at
Peerless Hositex Hospital and Research Centre Ltd. Kolkata
where an operation of his brain was conducted and he was
admitted there from 26.3.2017 to 02.04.2017 for his treatment.
Thereafter as per the advice of said hospital, the claimant again
went to that hospital on 17.05.2017 for follow-up treatment.
Later on 09.08.2017, he had to take treatment from that
hospital. It is further alleged that the accident occurred due to
reckless and irresponsible driving of the offending vehicle by its
driver. It is also contended that being Rifleman GD under TSR
the claimant used to draw a monthly salary of Rs.33,917/-.
3.1.
Therefore, the claimant filed an application for
grant of compensation of Rs.13,77,635.86/-. The claimant
produced necessary documentary evidence in support of his
claim and the learned Tribunal heard the of both sides and
perused the evidence on record. The claimant also took a leave
for 208 days from his leave account due to said accident.
3.2.
Thereafter, the learned Tribunal by Judgment and
Award dated 01.06.2022 passed in T.S.(MAC) 08 of 2018 awarded
compensation of Rs.5,82,365.00/- to the claimant herein.
3.3.
Being aggrieved with the quantum of compensation
and observation of the learned Tribunal vide Judgment dated
01.06.2022, passed in T.S.(MAC)08 of 2018, the appellantclaimant preferred the appeal before the Hon'ble Court seeking
the following reliefs:“ a) Admit the appeal.
b) call for the records of T.S.(MAC) 08/2018 from the
Court of Ld. Tribunal, Court No.4, Agartala, West Tripura;
c) Issue notice upon the Respondents-Ops to show
cause as to why the appeal should not be allowed.
AND
e) After hearing the parties, Your Lordship would be pleased to
allow the appeal and modify the award passed in the impugned Judgment
dated 01.06.2022 in T.S.(MAC) 08/2018 by Member, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal(Court No.4), Agartala, West Tripura and would very
kindly enhance the quantam of compensation by granting the balance
amount of Rs.7,95,270.00/- only (Rupees seven lakhs ninety five
thousand tow hundred seventy) only in favour of the appellant-claimant.”
4.
The fact of the case in MAC Appeal No.6 of 2023, is
that on 26.03.2017, the claimant was driving his motorcycle
while taking over his mobile and without helmet in a rash and
negligent manner. The motorcycle bearing Registration No. TR04-A-5396 collided on the front side mudguard of BSF vehicle
TATA 5 Ton near the TSR camp. The claimant herein fell down
on the road and sustained injuries on his head. The accident
occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the motorcycle by
the respondent-claimant, who was taking over his mobile phone
while driving the motorcycle by holding a phone between his
neck and shoulder and was not wearing helmet as the same was
hanging on the handle of the motorcycle. The accident occurred
due to the loss of control over the motorcycle by the
respondent-claimant
herein.
A
criminal
case
was
initiated
against the driver of the said BSF vehicle TATA 5 Ton, Sri
Naresh Kumar but the same was disposed of by the learned
CJM, Khowai, Tripura by its judgment dated 09.04.2019 wherein
the accused-Naresh Kumar was acquitted.
4.1.
The Trial Court by its Judgment and Order dated
01.06.2022 allowed the application filed under Section 166 of
the M.V. Act, 1988 and held that the claimant is entitled to a
sum of Rs.5,82,365/- only as compensation and further held
that the Ops are jointly and severally liable to pay the
compensation amount to the claimant and accordingly directed
to make the payment within 30 days from the date of award and
further directed that the amount of compensation shall carry
interest @ 9% per annum from the date of presentation of the
claim petition before the Tribunal on 10.01.2018 till realization.
4.2.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the
judgment dated 01.06.2022 passed in T.S.(MAC)8 of 2018, the
appellants herein preferred this
MAC Appeal No.6 of 2023
seeking the following reliefs:“ i) Admit the appeal.
ii) Call for the records from the Court of learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal (Court No.4) West Tripura, Agartala.
iii) Issue notice upon the opposite party-respondents.
AND
iv) After hearing both the parties may kindly quash/set
aside the impugned judgment and award dated 01.06.2022 passed in
T.S.(MAC) No.08 of 2018 by the MAC Tribunal No.4, West Tripura, Agartala.
AND
v)
Pass
such
other
order/orders
and/or
direction/directions as seem fit and proper having regard to the facts and
circumstances of the case.”
5.
Heard Mr. P.K Pal learned counsel appearing for the
claimant herein as well as Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI
appearing for the respondent-OPs in MAC App No.66 of 2022
and appellant-OPs in MAC App no.06 of 2023.
6.
Mr. P.K Pal, learned counsel appearing for the claimant
submits
that
the
learned
Tribunal
below
arbitrarily
and
whimsically and without applying its judicial mind came to a
wrong finding. The learned Tribunal below in passing the
aforesaid impugned judgment did not take into consideration the
documents and failed to consider the depositions made by the
P.W.-1 in respect of the income of claimants. The claimant lost
due earned leave for 208 days from his credit which would have
been counted for pensionary benefit at the time of his
retirement for Rs.2,35,157/-. The impugned judgment dated
01.06.2022 passed by the learned Tribunal is T.S.(MAC) No.08
of 2018 is required to be modified and the compensation be
enhanced by a further amount of Rs.7,95,270/-.
7.
On the other hand, Mr. B. Majumder, learned
Deputy SGI appearing for the Opposite-party submitted that the
impugned Judgment and order passed by the learned Tribunal is
bad in law and is liable to be set aside. The motor vehicle driven
by the claimant collided with the BSF vehicle bearing No.TR-01J-1661. At that time, the claimant was talking over his mobile
phone and was not wearing helmet as per traffic rules,
therefore, the same is liable for contributory negligence. The
same is proved in the criminal proceeding as per the evidence
on P.W.-7, Sri Rajpal Singh, Inspector of BSF. Vide judgment
dated 09.04.2019, passed by the learned CJM, Khowai in
PRC(SP) 45 of 2017, OP No.2 who was the accused of the said
case has already been acquitted from the charge leveled against
him. The learned Tribunal below wrongly held that the OPs are
jointly and severally liable to pay the compensation to the tune
of Rs.5,82,365/- to the claimant. The claimant did not approach
the learned Tribunal with clean hands and hide the fact that he
had already claimed Rs.1,41,581/- from his department i.e. 3rd
BN TSR as reimbursement of his medical bills and without
disclosing this fact to the learned Tribunal reclaimed said
amount in his claim petition. The claimant being employed with
3rd BN TSR, is entitled to make reimbursement of his medical
bills from his department but ignoring the above fact, the
learned Tribunal also awarded Rs.50,000/- as future medical
expenses.
8.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on
record.
9.
As per the leave sanction memo (Exbt-11), the
claimant availed leave in the following terms:-
“No.Pers/TSR-3/Estt/HSK/01/7485
Dated, the 22 April, 2017
SANCTION OF LEAVE
Sanctioned 77(seventy seven) days Commuted leave
w.e.f. 25.03.2017 to 09.06.2017(AN) on medical ground and 13(thirteen)
days Earned Leave w.e.f. 10.06.2017 to 22.06.2017(AN) in favour of
No.01030562 Rfn(GD) Hari Sankar Kurmi of „Adm-Coy‟, 3rd Bn TSR at his
own request vide application dated 16.04.2017. This is in cancellation of
1(one) day C/L on 25.03.2017 granted earlier.
2. He will resume duty in HQr 3rd Bn, TSR, Kachucherra on
22.06.2017(AN).
No.Pers/TSR-3/Estt/HSK/01/13888 Dated, the 22 April, 2017
EXTENSION OF LEAVE
Sanctioned 30(thirty) days Earned leave w.e.f. 22.08.2017 to
20.09.2017(AN), in favour of No.01030562 Rfn(GD) Hari Sankar Kurmi of
„ Adm-Coy‟ 3rd Bn TSR at his own request vide application dated
16.08.2017. This is in extention of 77(seventy seven) days Commuted
leave and 73(seventy three) days E/L granted earlier up to 21.09.2017.
2. He will resume his duties in HQr 3rd Bn, TSR Kachucherra on
20.09.2017(AN).”
10.
So as per the record the claimant took leave for a
period of 208 days and since the said leave is earned
leave/commuted leave, and he is entitled to the said leave, it
cannot be said that the claimant would face any loss of salary
during that period. Hence, it is declared that the claimant is
entitled to 208 days' salary as per procedure after considering
all deductions.
11.
against
In so far as the appeal filed by the appellant-OPs
the
said
impugned
Judgment
and
Order
dated
01.06.2022 is concerned, it is brought to the notice of this Court
that the claimant had the benefit of future medication from his
own department and he has not incurred any future medical
expenditure. This Court sees force in the argument of Mr. B.
Majumder, learned Deputy SGI, and accordingly, the benefit of
Rs.50,000/- towards future medical expenses awarded by the
learned Tribunal is deducted.
12.
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Deputy SGI appearing for
the appellant-OPs in MAC Appeal No.66 of 2022 contended that
as indicated by P.W.-7, Inspector Rajpal Singh in the order
dated 09.04.2019 in PRC(SP) 45 of 2017 before the learned
CJM, the accident occurred due to contributory negligence. He
further argued that the same needs to be deducted and
submitted that the said judgment of the Court below is part of
the record before the Tribunal. In view of the same, he prayed
to reduce the compensation, holding the principle of contributory
negligence, by the respondent-claimant.
13.
This Court is not inclined to consider the said
contention of the learned Deputy SGI since the P.W.-7 who was
a so-called eye witness before the Court below in the said
PRC(SP) 45 of 2017 was not examined, before the learned MAC
Tribunal. More so, when pleading on the point of contributory
negligence is taken, nothing prevented the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal from examining the P.W.-7, Inspector Rajpal
Singh. Though the proceedings are different before the 2(two)
separate Courts arising out of the Common Criminal Case, but,
before the Tribunal, the concerned party could have prayed for
an opportunity to cross-examine Inspector Rajpal Singh, P.W.7.
Since no steps were taken by the Commandant and other
appellants for examining P.W.-7, Mr. Rajpal Singh, so, credence
could not be given to his evidence in this matter. Accordingly,
the said contention stands rejected.
14.
With the above observation, both appeals are
allowed in part to the extent indicated herein-above. As a
sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any
also stand closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review