Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3486 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3867 OF 2023
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of lndia aggrieved by the order
dated 26-12-2023 passed in OS.No.11 ot 2014 on the file of the Court of the
Principal District Judge, Nizamabad.
Between:
'l
. The Church of South lndia Trust Association, (Medak Diocese) (wrongly
shown as Medak Diocese, it is only The church of South lndia Trust
Association), having its registered office at 5, Whites road, Royapettah
Chennai rep.by its Director / authorized signatory Prof. Dr. B. Vimal Sukumar,
S/o. Rt. Rev. Dr. B.P. Sugandhar, aged about 51 years having its Diocesan
office at '10-3-t65, Diocese office, Old lancer lane, Secunderabad
2. Bishop at Medak, Church of South lndia Trust Association, Medak Diocese at
10-3-165, Diocese office, Old lancer lane, Secunderabad rep.by
Rt.Rev.K.Padma Rao s/o Late.f\/anikyam, aged about 63 years, Bishop in CSI
Dornakal Diocese and Moderators Commissary and Bishop (i/c) of Medak
Diocese
...Petitioners
AND
1. Vttay Sahara Naveen Shailender, s/o Late.V.S.Surya Prakash James, 40
years, Business rlo 11-2-238 Christian colony, Kanteswar Nizamabad
2. Samala Ranjit Reddy, s/o S. Raja Reddy 40 years, Business r/o 6-26,
Gangastan Phase-lll, Gupanpally (v) Nizamabad Mandal and District.
...Respondents/Plaintiffs
lA NO: 2 OF 2023
Petition under Section '151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Gourt may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings in OS.No.1112014 passed by the court of Prl.District
Judge, Nizamabad, pending disposal of CRP.No.- /2023.
Counsel for the Petitioners: Sri J. Prabhakar, Senior Counsel representing
Sri A. Srinivas
Counsel for the Respondents: Sri Ch. Siddhartha Sarma, Counsel representing
Sri B. Shiva Teja
The Court made the following: ORDER
HIGH couRr
"?I;+3fffi"XrF
TELANGANA
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAI(RISHNA REDDY
CML REVISION PETITION No.3867 of 2ot23
Date: L3.O2.2O26
Between:
The Church of South lndia Trust and others
Petitioners
AND
Vtjay Sahara and others
....Respondents
ORDER:
This Civil Revision Petition is filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India by the petitioners/defendants assailing the docket
order dated 26.12.2023 in O.S. No. 11 of 2024 on the file of the learned
Principal District Judge, Nizamabad (for short the learned Trial Court).
2.
The respondents/plaintiffs instituted O.S. No.11 of 2OL4 on the
file of the learned Prl. District Judge, Nizamabad seeking the relief of
specific performance of contract in respect of subject property. The said
suit was initially disposed of by judgment dated 12.02.2015.
Subsequently, the suit was restored on 29-08-2023. Thereafter, notices
'were issued; written statementwas taken on record, issues were frarned
on 13.IO.2O23 and the matter was posted for trial. The petitioners
examined PW- 1 and PW-2. Upon completion of evidence on behalf of
plaintiffs, the learned Trial Court, by docket order dated 26.03.2023,
posted the, matter to 09.01 .2024 under the caption 'hearing for
judgment'.
3-
The grievance of the petitioners/defendants is that the suit was
posted under the caption hearing for judgment' without affording them
an opportunity to cross examine the witnesses examined on behalf of
the plaintif[s and also to adduce evidence on behalf of the defendants.
Hence, the: present civil Revision petition has been filed by the
defendants against the docket order dated 26.03.2023 passed by the
Trial Court.
4.
Hearrl Sri J. Prabhakar, learned Senior Counsel representing Sri
A. Srinivas, learned counsel appearing for the revision petitioners and
Sri ch. Siddhartha Sarma, learned counsel representing Sri B. Shiva
Teja, learne d counsel for the respondents.
5.
Sri J. Prabhakar, learned Senior Counsel representing the learned
counsel ap,pearing for the petitioners/defendants submits that the
learned Tri;rl Court failed to adhere not only the principles of natural
justice, which are inherent in all judicial proceedings, but also to the
mandatory procedure prescribed under the Code of Civil Procedure and
the civil Rules of Practice. It is contended that though the junior
counsel appearing for the petitioners/defendants was present before the
Trial Court on 26.L2.2o23 and sought to file an adjournment petition,
while bringing to the notice of the Court certain serious procedural
f
r
irregularities, the learned Trial Court declined to receive the same,
treated the arguments of the plaintiffs as heard, and posted the suit for
judgment on 09.o 1.2024, despite the fact that the adjournment petition
was thereafter filed in the concerned section/office of the learned Trial
Court.
6-
The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the Trial Court
proceeded on an erroneous assumption as if the petitioners/defendants
were set ex pafte and that the plaintiff was leading exparte evidence. In
fact, the earlier ex parte decree dated r2.o2.2o15 had already been set
aside, pursuant to order passed in cRp No.22o4 of 2022 dated
ol.o2.2o23. Thereafter, the w,ritten statement was liled and issues
were also framed on 13.Lo.2o23, from which date the matter was
posted to O1 .Ll.2023 for trial. [n such circumstances, the defendants
were entitled to participate fully in the trial.
-
The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the learned
Trial Court also declined to hear the representation made on behalf of
the petitioners/defendants on 26.12.2Cr23 and proceed further thereby
completely denying them an effective opportunity of participating in the
trial, leading to a clear denial of fair opportunity and violation
9f the
principles of natural justice.
8.
The learned Senior Counsel also submitted that the affidavits of
evidence, namely the chief affidavits of pw-l and pw-2, were not served
either on th3 defendants or on their counsel, thereby causing serious
prejudice to their defence.
9.
Learnt:d counsel for the respondents, while uot seriously
disputing the factual sequence, would submit that the learned Tribial
Court was justilied in proceeding with the matter, as adequate
opportunities had been afforded earlier and the petitioners cannot seek
to protract the proceedings.
10. In the light of the above submissions the only point that arises for
consideration is:
Wheth,er the revision petitioners/defendants were denied a fair
opportunity to contest the suit in O.S.No.11 of 2Ol4 in accordance with
Iaw?
1. It is pertinent to note that on 27.12.2023 this Court granted stay
of all further proceedings in O.S.No.11 of 2OI4 pending consideration of
the present revision. A perusal of the record discloses that the suit was
initially disposed of on 12.O2.2OL5. Thereafter, defendants filed I.A.
No.51 of 2O'),O in O.S.No.11 of 2Ol4 along with written statement before
the learned Trial Court seeking to condone the delay of 1739 days in
filing the application seeking to set aside the exparte decree dated
12.02.2015 in O.S.No.11 of 2014. However, the learned Trial Court
dismissed I.A.No.S\ of 2O2O on 28.07.2022. Aggrieved thereby, the
defendants filed C.R.P.No.22O4 of 2022, which w,as allowed by this
(
r
court on 01.o2.2o2s. In pursuance thereot, the learned Trial court
issued notices to the parties, framed appropriate issues
and
commenced the trial by examining pws 1 and 2.
However, no
opportunity was afforded to the defendants either to cross
examine pws
1 and 2 or to adduce evidence in support of their case.
Instead, the
matter was posted for "hearing for judgment,.
12' As rightty contended by the learned counsel for the defendants,
the learned Trial Court proceeded with the suit proceedings
as if it was
an ex parte proceedings. In the instant case, the defendants filed
written statement and the learned Trial Court also posted
the matter for
trial after framing certain issues. In such circumstances, the Trial
court ought to have given an opportunity to the defendants to rebut
evidence put forth by the plaintiffs. It is the specific contention
defendants that despite expressing the intention of filing
so as to
examined on
behalf of the plaintiffs and also adduce evidence on their
learned Trial Court erroneously proceeded further without
of the
a petition by
the junior counsel for the defendants to adjourn the case
enable the defendants to cross examine the witnesses
the
behalf, the
affording any
such opportunity to the defendants.
13' It is trite that once a written statement is filed and issues are
framed, the proceedings cannot be treate d, as exparte.
The defendant
has a valuable and surbstantive right to rebut the plaintiffs,
evidence
both by way of cross-examination and by leading independent evidence.
Denial of such opportunity strikes at the root of fair trial.
14. A cour-t cannot generally post a suit for hearing on judgment
immediately after recording the plaintiffs evidence without giving the
defendant art opportunity to lead evidence, as the Same would amount
to violation of principles of natural justice and the procedural law under
Orders XVIII and XIX of the Code of Civil Procedure. A defendant cannot
be denied spch a valuable and substantive right to rebut the plaintifls
case, unless such right is forfeited by operation of law or by deliberate
defalt. The right to cross examine or to adduce evidence is not a mere
formality, it is an integral component of fair trial. If such valuable right
is denied, it inevitably results in causing any amount of prejudice, as to
the deflendernt is deprived of an opportunity to establish his o\'vn
contentions.
15. ln Arraaubkhan Noorklnn Pathan u. State of MaharasLfiral the
Honourable Supreme Court after referring to earlier constitution Bench
and other decisions observed as under:
"23.AConstitutionBencho.fthi.sCourtinStateofM.P.u.
Chintt1g4n@,AIR1961SC1623,leldthat giuen the
tn" *7"" ii not rolfi@'requiie tiat a paitl riust be
opportunitu to ad.duce all releuant euidence upon which he relies,
and fitrther that, the euid.ence of the opposite partq should be taken
in hk presence, and. tLtat he should. be giuen the opporhtnitu of
cross-examininq the uitnesses examined bU that parU"t' Not
cross-e&amine utitnesses, would
prouiclinT
'uiolalz the s,aid" opporfunitU tojustice.
(See also: Union of India
principtes
of
nahtral
the
' lzot:;4 scc.t65
(
f
{ ^i
16.Inthepresentcase,thedenialofopportunitytothedefendantsto
cross-examinePw-landPW-2andtoleadevidenceinsupportoftheir
and
principles of natural justice
defence clearly amounts
to violation of
itconstitutesanerrorapparentonthefaceoftherecord.Hence,the
impugned order of the learned
Trial Court cannot be sustained'
LT.Intheresult,thecivilrevisionpetitionisallowed.Thedocket
orderdated26.|2.2023ino.S.No.1lof2024onthefileofthelearned
PrincipalDistrictJud.ge,Nizamabadissetaside.Consequently,the
Trial court is directed to afford
the defendants a reasonable
opportunity
tocrossexaminethewitnessesexalninedonbehalfoftheplaintiffsand
alsotoadducetheevidenceonbehalfofthedefendantsinaccordance
withlaw.Consideringthatthesuitpertainstotheyear2ol4,theTrial
Courtshallmakeeveryendeavourtodisposeofthesuitasexpeditiously
aspossible.Boththepartiesshallextendfullcooperationforearly
disposal. There shall be no
order as to costs'
shatl dtand closed:
pending miscgl anegus_appli:ations, if any'
sDr_ L.vtJAyA LAxMt
SISTANT REGISTRAR
,,TRUE
To,
1. The PrinciPal District Judge; Nizamabad
IOPUCI
2. One CC to SriA- Srinivas' AdvocateAdvocate
IoPUCI
Sarma,
. 3. One CC to Sri Ch.Siddharta
&fr,{:"
CD CoPies
SECTION OFFICER
HIGH COIURT
DATED:131021202G
ORDER
CRP.No.3;86T ot 2023
ALLOWING THE CRP
v il,
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review