Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~74 & 75
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 9207/2017
THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER,
PRASAR BHARATI & ORS
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Rajeev Sharma, Sr. Adv.
with Mr. Uddyam Mukherjee, Mr. Swapnil
Pattanayak, Ms. Kratika Kushwaha, Mr.
Nishant Kandpal and Ms. Arunima Singh,
Advs.
versus
GUNJAN VARSHNEY AND ANR
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Adv.
Mr. Bhagvan Swarup Shukla, CGSC with
Mr. Dashmesh Tripathi, Adv.
Mr. Ashish K Dixit CGSC with Mr Umar
Hashmi, Mr Ayush Kumar and Ms Iqra
Shiekh, Advs. for Union of India
+
W.P.(C) 11383/2017
THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER,
PRASAR BHARATI AND ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Rajeev Sharma, Senior
Advocate with Mr. Uddyam Mukherjee,
Adv.
versus
SRISHTI SHANKER AND ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Bhagvan Swarup Shukla,
CGSC with Mr. Dashmesh Tripathi, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VINOD KUMAR
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
21.07.2026
%
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
1.
These writ petitions are directed against a common order of the
Tribunal dated 10 July 2017.
WP (C) 9207/2017
2.
The respondent, Gunjan Varshney was engaged by the
petitioner Prasar Bharati on contract basis by order dated 22 July 2014
to work as Regional Sales Head (Delhi) in the office of the Directorate
General, Doordarshan. The following clauses of the appointment order
are relevant:
“1.
Tenure: This contract is initially for a period of two years
with effect from the date of joining. The contract will automatically
come to an end on the expiry of contract period unless specifically
extended subject to continued good performance;
2.
Remuneration: Your consolidated annual remuneration and
other allowances(s) are as under:
a)
Remuneration (Base Salary) : Rs 28.75 Lakh.per
annum (P.A.)
b)
3000 litres of Petrol Reimbursement : Actuals
The payment shall be disbursed on monthly (pro-rata) basis and
shall become due on the completion of the month.
3.
All incentive scheme based on annual accrued revenue has
been worked out to drive aggressive deliverables; The target is
valid for one year and will be reviewed in August, 2015. The
details of incentive scheme are as given below:
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
a)
A 40 Crore would be the base revenue target from
Corporates (Non-Govt.) in Delhi & North India.
b)
The incentive shall start at Rs 40 Crore Corporate
revenue from North India/Delhi.
c)
If the base target is achieved, then certain percent
of your base salary (fixed) as an incentive is applicable as
per details below:
Corporate
achieved from
North Region
₹ 40 Crore
₹ 50 Crore
₹ 75 Crore
Revenue
Delhi /
Percent
of
base
salary(fixed) offered as
incentive
50% of base salary(fixed)
100% of base salary(fixed)
200% of base salary(fixed)
*****
6.
Termination of Contract : The contract could be terminated
by either side by giving one month’s notice or pay in lieu thereof
without assigning any reason.
7.
The contract is subject to performance and the actual
performance against the set deliverable will be evaluated from time
to time.”
3.
On 23 February 2015, the services of the respondent were
terminated by the following communication:
Dated : 23.02.2015
“To,
Ms Gunjan Varshney,
402, Judge Colony,
Vaishali,
[1811gunjan@gmail.com]
Subject : Disengagement of contract regarding.
Madam,
Reference is invited to your engagement in this Directorate
as Regional Sales Head, on contract basis w.e.f. 05.09.2014, vide
communication number 912/5/2014-Scor dated 22nd July, 2024 on
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
the terms and conditions mentioned therein.
2.
You are hereby informed that in terms of Para-6 of the offer
of engagement letter dated 22.07.2024 your services are no more
required by Doordarshan and this letter may please be treated as
one month’s notice for discontinuation of your services on and
from the expiry of the one month from the date of issue of this
letter.
3.
You are request to submit No Dues Certificate to Scor
Section from A&G and the concerned Library.
4.
This issues with the approval of Competent Authority.
Yours sincerely,
[S.Muthukumar]
Dy. Director Admn.(Scor)”
4.
The
respondent
approached
the
Central
Administrative
Tribunal1, challenging her termination, by way of OA 951/2015.
5.
The Prasar Bharati advanced a preliminary objection regarding
jurisdiction, contending that the Tribunal was coram non judice as it
had no jurisdiction over the contractor through whom the respondent
had been engaged.
6.
Substantive replies on merits were also advanced by the Prasar
Bharati.
7.
The Tribunal passed two orders, the first on 2 May 2017 and the
second on 10 July 2017. By the first order dated 2 May 2017, the
Tribunal rejected the argument of want of jurisdiction and held that it
had jurisdiction in the matter. Mr. Rajeev Sharma, learned Senior
1 “the Tribunal”, hereinafter
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
Counsel for the petitioners, very fairly submits that though he would
still argue on principle that the Tribunal has no jurisdiction, this issue
stands decided against the petitioners by certain authorities of the
Supreme Court and that, therefore, it did not survive for consideration
on merits in the present writ petition. We, therefore, affirm the order
dated 2 May 2017 passed by the Tribunal.
8.
The real challenge before us is to the order dated 10 July 2017
which addressed the challenge raised by the respondent on merits.
9.
The Tribunal, predicated on the following reasoning, proceeded
to allow the OA :
“31. It is quite apparent that all the applicants in these OAs.,
except the OA. No.2256/2015, who were engaged as Interns, were
engaged on contractual basis to work in positions, which are in the
nature of regular posts in a Broadcasting Organization. On the
question of jurisdiction of the Tribunal to adjudicate service
matters relating issues of these contractual engagees, we have
observed in our order dated 02.05.2017 as under:“21, Section 14 (3) (b) read with Section 3 (q) of the Act
read in the light of the judgments of Hon’ble Apex Court in
Deepa Chand Pandey2 (supra), Kumari Shrilekha
Vidyarthi3 (supra), Keshab Deb4 (supra) and Shri Kanak
Chandra Dutta5 (supra), make it absolutely clear that this
Tribunal has the jurisdiction to adjudicate service matters of
contract employees also who are engaged to discharge such
functions that are central to the object for which an
organization referred to in Section 14 (3) of the Act, has
been set up. Resultantly, we hold that this Tribunal has
jurisdiction to adjudicate all these O.As.”
32.
As observed by us in the preceding paragraphs, the
2 UOI v. Deep Chand Pandey, (1992) 4 SCC 423
Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi v. State of UP, (1991)1 SCC 212
4 Telecom District Manager v. Keshab Deb, (2008) 8 SCC 402
5 State of Assam v. Shri Kanak Chandra Dutta, 1967 AIR 884
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
respondent - Prasar Bharati earlier had a system of interviewing the
contractual engagees every year and based on their performance, it
used to decide continuation or discontinuation of their services.
Later on, the Prasar Bharati dispensed with the interview system
and switched over to performance appraisal format on the scale of
0-10. Obviously, in the new system, there was no opportunity
provided to the adversely affected contractual engagees to explain
their position. The decision of Prasar Bharati to continue/
discontinue the services of the contractual engagees, as also to
revise the monthly remunerations based on their performance
appraisal, was not at all transparent. On the contrary, the appraisal
system has provided scope of subjectivity. The principal of natural
justice have not been followed in such performance appraisals and
thus the affected employee were denied the opportunity of being
heard. Hence, we are of the firm opinion that any decision taken in
violation of the principles of natural justice cannot be legally
upheld. As we have already noticed, the Prasar Bharati and the
Central Government have failed in their duties and obligations in
formulating regulations to deal with the service conditions of the
employee of the Prasar Bharati as also in establishing Recruitment
Boards for future recruitments, as contemplated under Sections
9&10 of the Prasar Bharati Act, 1990. Such regulations would have
spelt out transparent and legally valid system of regulating the
service of the Prasar Bharati employees. Be that as it may. The
Prasar Bharati has been managing its affairs by engaging
contractual employees on large scale against various regular posts.
Hence, it is Only prudent that they follow the principles of natural
justice while dealing with the services of such contractual
employees. We only hope and expect the Prasar Bharati and the
Central Government would take action to discharge their
obligations under Sections 9&10 of the Prasar Bharati Act, 1990
sooner rather than later. Needless to mention that any delay in this
regard is only going to confound the service matters of the
employees of Prasar Bharati and would be detrimental to its
smooth functioning in future.
33.
Pertinent to mention that it is settled law {See State of
Haryana & others v. Piara Singh & others6, that one set of
contractual employees cannot be replaced by another set of
contractual employees. If some contractual employees are found to
be non-performing or under-performing, their services can
definitely be dispensed with by following the principles of natural
justice, which, inter alia, envisages issue of show cause notice,
providing opportunity of being heard to the concerned employees,
getting their side of the picture through their written
6 (1992) 4 SSC 118
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
representations and then decide their continuation in service or
otherwise, by passing a reasoned and speaking order in individual
cases. Unless this is done, any action taken would smack of
arbitrariness and hit by the principle of audi alteram partem.
Hence, we are of the view that the impugned orders of Prasar
Bharati in all these O.As., sans O.A. No. 2256/2015, are not
sustainable.”
10.
Following the above reasoning, the Tribunal directed, in the
concluding paragraph of the judgment thus:
“35. In the conspectus of discussions in the foregoing
paragraphs, we dispose of these O.As. as under:*****
ii)
O.A. Nos. 3165/2015, 2167/2016, 821/2015, 931/2015,
951/2015,1668/2015, 2422/2015 and 3166/2015 are allowed and
the impugned orders, i.e., letter dated 20.08.2015 in O.A. No.
3165/2015, order dated 12.05.2015 in O.A. No.2422/2015, order
dated 27.02.2015 in O.A. No.931/2015, order dated 23.02.2015 in
O.A. No.951/2015, order dated 20.08.2015 in O.A. No.3166/2015
and order dated 28.06.2016 in O.A. No.2167/2016, respectively,
are quashed and set aside.
The respondents are directed to follow principles of natural
justice in regard to continuation / discontinuation of services of
these applicants, which would include issuing of show cause
notices, receiving their representations against such notices,
provide them an opportunity of being heard and then pass a
reasoned and speaking order in each case individually in regard to
continuation / discontinuation of their contractual engagements, as
also in regard to revision in their monthly remunerations.”
11.
Assailing the aforesaid order, the Prasar Bharati is before us in
the present writ petition.
12.
We have heard Mr. Rajeev Sharma, learned Senior Counsel for
the petitioners and Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned counsel for the
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
respondent, at length.
13.
Mr. Sharma submits that the respondent’s termination was
squarely in terms of Clause 6 of her contract of employment dated 22
July 2014 supra. The clause enabled the petitioners to terminate the
services of the respondent at any time on giving one month’s notice
without assigning reasons. The respondent’s contract was terminated
as her services were no longer required. He submits that the Tribunal
is signally in error in holding that such a termination had to be
preceded by adherence to the principles of natural justice. This issue,
he submits, is no longer res integra as it is covered by para 17 of the
judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in Union of India v.
Satish Joshi7, which reads thus :
“17. While considering the contention that principles of natural
justice have been violated by not affording the respondent, an
opportunity of making any representation with regard to his
performance, it would be important to bear in mind that the
performance review conducted by the external committee on
28.12.2011 was not for the purposes of inflicting any punitive
measure on the respondent but to only consider the suitability of
his contract being extended. The decision to not extend the contract
of employment of the respondent cannot be considered to be a
dismissal from service by way of a punishment. It is a discharge
simplicitor on the employment contract coming to an end by efflux
of time. An employee will not have a right to be heard where an
inquiry is made merely for the purposes of considering the
suitability for extending the contract of employment.”
14.
The aforenoted enunciation of law in para 17 of Satish Joshi
stands followed by another learned Single Judge of this Court in Dr.
7 2013 (137) DRJ 548 (DB)
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
Praveen Singh v. Dr. Ashish Goyal8, from which para 14 is relevant:
“14. Be that as it may, elementary as it may seem, the petitioner
had no vested right to seek renewal of his contract dated 6th May,
2014 which had not been renewed apparently in the backdrop of
his reported his misconduct by the colleague doctors, nursing staff
as well the patients besides gross negligence resulting in death of
three patients by the various Committees. It can be safely said that
on expiry of the contract period, the decision not to renew the
contract was based on rational, tangible and objective grounds.
Reference can be had to decision in the case of Union of
India v. Satish Joshi, wherein it was held that there is no right to
renewal of the contract once the contract has expired and there is
no obligation on the part of the appointing authority to issue Show
Cause Notice.”
15.
Ergo, submits Mr. Sharma, the Tribunal was in error in setting
aside the termination of the respondent and granting consequential
relief.
16.
Responding to Mr. Sharma’s submissions, Mr. Bhattacharya,
learned counsel for the respondent, has placed reliance on paras 3 and
7 of the contract of service of the respondent to submit that the
contract was performance-driven. He submits that there was nothing at
any time to indicate that the performance of the respondent was
wanting. Rather, he has drawn our attention to the following e-mail
addressed by the petitioner to the respondent on 7 August 2014 :
“FW: Minutes of the Meeting held on 27th June 2014
Gunjan Varshney <gunjan,varshney@focustvgroup.com>
Thu, Aug 7, 2014 at 8:49 PM
To:”1811gunjan@gmail.com”1811gunjan@gmail.com
Sent from my Windows Phone
8 2024 SCC Online Del 6993
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
From: ravindra joshi
Sent; 04-08-2014 16:08
To: Gunjan Varshney
Cc: Khyli Sardana; Amarpreet Sandhu; Priyank Pal; Hitu
Mahanjan; Surajit D. Chaterjee; Jaganath Das; Harjit Singh;
Ramswaroop Das; Shahsank Narayan, Tiwari; Chairman Positiv
TV; Neeraj Sanan; avadhsharma@hotmail.com; Mukund Setlur;
gargee bardoloi; Chief
Subject: Re: Minutes of the Meeting held on 27th June 2014
Gunjan, that you and your team have consistently achieved and
often exceeded your goals is highly commendable. We are
fortunate to have such energetic and talented sales persons amidst
us. Keep up the good work.
Regards
Sent from my BlackBerry 10 smartphone.
From: Chief
Sent: Monday, 4 August 2014 15:50
To: Gunjan Varshney
Cc: Khyati Sardana; Amarpreet Sandhu; Priyanka Pal; Hitu
Mahajan; Surajit D. Chatterjee; Jaganath Das; Harjit Singh;
Ramswaroop Das; Shahsank Narayan, Tiwari; Chairman Positiv
TV; Neeraj Sanan; avadhsharma@hotmail.com; Mukund Setlur;
gargee bardoloi;
Subject: Re: Minutes of the Meeting held on 27th June 2014
Congratulations and keep it coming again and again”
17.
Mr. Bhattacharya would submit that, in such circumstances, the
petitioner could not suddenly, even before the period of two years for
which the respondent had initially been appointed on contract was
over, terminate her by the laconic communication of 23 February
2015.
18.
The Tribunal was, therefore, in his submission, correct in
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
setting it aside.
19.
We have considered the submissions of both sides.
20.
The right of contractual employees to regularization stands
recognized in several recent authorities of the Supreme Court and of
this Court including Jaggo v. Union of India9, Vinod Kumar v.
Union of India10, Shripal v. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad11, Dharam
Singh v. State of UP12, Bhola Nath v. State of Jharkhand13, Pawan
Kumar v. Union of India14, Pawan Sharma v. Govt. of NCT of
Delhi15 and New Delhi Municipal Council v. Kalpana Sharma16.
These, however, are all cases in which persons had worked on contract
for long periods of time. In such cases, the Supreme Court has held
that, even by dint of their continuous and uninterrupted service
without complaint, a right to regularization enured in favour of the
employees and has rejected any opposition to that principle on the
ground that their appointments were not against sanctioned posts, or
that they did not possess the requisite qualifications for the post, or
that their services were no longer required. The only case in which the
Supreme Court has held such employees to be liable to termination, is
where their initial appointment on contract was illegal, in that it was
made without any selection and through the back door. The Supreme
Court has clearly held that the judgment of the Constitution Bench in
9 2024 SCC Online SC 3826
10 (2024) 9 SCC 327
2025 SCC OnLine SC 221
12 2025 SCC OnLIne SC 1735
13 2026 SCC OnLIne SC 129
14 2026 SCC OnLIne SC 200
15 2025 SCC OnLIne Del 8313
16 Judgment dated 13 April 2026 passed in WP(C) 4646/2026
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi17 was intended to deal only with
surreptitious “back door appointments”, and not with candidates who
had been appointed after a due process of selection or consideration.
21.
This Court has recently, in its judgment in Pawan Sharma,
followed the decisions in Jaggo and the judgments which followed it,
and our decision stands affirmed by the Supreme Court by dismissal
of the SLP preferred thereagainst vide order dated 14 May 2026.
22.
The beneficial reach of Jaggo, the decisions following it, and
Pawan Sharma cannot, however, extend to a case such as the present,
where the respondent was engaged on contract only for one year, the
contract specially contained a clause which enabled her contract to be
terminated at any time without notice and, by a non-stigmatic order
on the ground that her services were not required any further, her
contract was terminated within a period of one year. If we are not to
countenance even such a termination, it would mean that no employee
could ever be taken on contract and that, if any employment took
place on contract, it would never be terminated, irrespective of the
length for which the contract subsisted, even by a non-stigmatic order,
without strict adherence to the principles of natural justice.
23.
We have also perused the reasoning of the Tribunal. With
respect, it appears that the Tribunal has proceeded on abstract
considerations, rather than on an interpretation of the legal position.
Observations such as want of transparency in the decision of the
17 (2006) 4 SCC 1
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
Prasar Bharati to continue or discontinue services of contractual
engagees, scope of subjectivity in the appraisal system, absence of any
transparent or legally valid system for regulating services of the Prasar
Bharati employees, and the like, cannot be considerations on the basis
of which the termination of the respondent’s services could be set
aside.
24.
Mr. Sharma has also pointed out that the Tribunal has erred on
facts in holding that the appointment of the respondent was against a
regular post. He submits that there was no regular post of Regional
Sales Head in the Prasar Bharati and this was a post which was merely
created for being filled by the respondent on contract basis.
25.
In as much as the discontinuation of the respondent’s services
was not stigmatic but only on the ground that her services were not
required any further, we are unable to subscribe to the view expressed
by the Tribunal that the termination had to be preceded by compliance
to the principles of natural justice or audi alteram partem, much less
issuing of a show cause notice, inviting a representation thereto and
granting of an opportunity of personal hearing.
26.
We are of the opinion that the impugned order of the Tribunal
has proceeded more on equity than in law. While it is always desirable
that the approach of a Court should be equitable, equity cannot be
made the sole basis of a judicial decision, innocent of the law.
Uninformed by law, equity would be an unruly horse.
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
27.
In view of the fact that (i) the contract whereby the respondent’s
services were engaged specifically provided that it could be
terminated at any point without notice, (ii) the order of termination
was passed within less than a year of the contract, and (iii) the order of
termination was non-stigmatic in nature and terminated the
respondent’s services on the ground that they were not required any
further, we are unable to sustain the impugned judgment of the
Tribunal to set aside the termination order dated 23 February 2015.
28.
Resultantly, the impugned judgment of the Tribunal is quashed
and set aside.
29.
The writ petition stands allowed in the aforesaid terms with no
orders as to costs.
WP (C) 11383/2017
30.
Srishti Shanker, the respondent in this writ petition, was
engaged on contract as Output Editor on 5 April 2013 on a monthly
remuneration of ₹ 1,35,000/-. The following clauses of her contractual
appointment are relevant:
“WHEREAS the First Party as an electronic media is broadcasting
various programmes including news bulletins to inform, educate
and entertain people.
WHEREAS the First Party proposes to engage Ms. Srishti Shanker
as Output Editor the News & Current Affairs Wing of
Doordarshan.
WHEREAS the Second Party has expressed her desire to provide
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
the nature of services as stated above to the First Party under this
Agreement. The Second Party has also represented that she
possesses the professional capabilities to perform the above
functions and such other functions as may be assigned to her under
this agreement by the First Party from time to time.
*****
Nature and Description of Engagement for services
1.
Tenure: The contract will be valid for a period of two years
and will take effect from 14th Feb 2013. The contract would
automatically come to an end on the expiry of the two year period
from 14th Feb 2013 unless specifically extended.
*****
8.
Termination of Contract: Any misconduct negligence /
dereliction of duty on your part of the engages during the contract
period shall lead to the termination of the contract. The contract
could be terminated by either side by giving one month's notice or
pay in lieu thereof without assigning any reason.”
31.
The period of two years envisaged in the contract dated 5 April
2013 expired in or around April 2015. Prior thereto, on 16 February
2015, the Prasar Bharti extended the contract of the respondent till 30
June 2015 on the same terms and conditions.
32.
Mr. Rajeev Sharma submits that, thereafter, there was a
Performance Appraisal Committee (PAC) set up in the Prasar Bharti
to examine the performance of various contract employees and
suggest rationalisation of their work.
33.
Suggestions were advanced by the PAC in respect of all the
contract employees. In respect of the respondent Srishti Shanker, it
was suggested that she could be continued, but at a reduced
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
remuneration of ₹ 95,000/-.
34.
Following the said decision, on 20 August 2015, the Prasar
Bharti offered continuation of the respondent’s service, but as Output
Editor on a remuneration of ₹ 99,750/- per month with effect from 1
August 2015.
35.
Thus, it is clear that there was no mid-term reduction of the
respondent’s remuneration and that it was after the expiry of her
extended period of contract on 30 June 2015 that the respondent was
offered a fresh contract for two years with effect from 1 August 2015
as Output Editor, but on a reduced remuneration of ₹ 99,750/- in terms
of the recommendations of the PAC.
36.
The respondent chose to challenge the aforesaid communication
dated 20 August 2015 before the Tribunal by way of OA 3165/2015
which, too, stands allowed by the impugned judgment. Unfortunately,
the Tribunal has not dealt with the merits of the individual OAs.
37.
The respondent’s OA has also been allowed on the basis of
paras 31 to 33 of the impugned judgment, which already stand
reproduced supra.
38.
To our mind, the finding of the Tribunal cannot sustain either in
law or on facts.
39.
This is not even a case, unlike the case of Gunjan Varshney,
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
where the respondent’s contract was curtailed mid-term. She was
initially appointed on contract for two years as Output Editor at a
remuneration of ₹ 1,35,000/- per month. That contract, on the same
terms, was extended, on 16 February 2015, till 30 June 2015. The
Prasar Bharti did not in any way interfere with the terms of either of
these contracts. It was after the term of the second contract had come
to an end that the respondent was offered a fresh contractual
employment as Output Editor at a monthly remuneration of ₹ 99,750.
40.
It was for the respondent, if she so choose, to accept or refuse
the said offer. No occasion, however, arose for the respondent to
challenge the offer before a Court.
41.
It goes without saying that the Tribunal could not foist, on
Prasar Bharti, the terms of the contract on which it chose to engage its
employees.
42.
The reasoning of the Tribunal, as contained in paras 31 to 33 of
the impugned judgment, reproduced supra, does not even address this
aspect. The factors noted in the said paragraphs are of no relevance,
whatsoever, in examining the validity of the offer dated 20 August
2015 which was extended to Ms. Srishti Shanker, for engaging her as
Output Editor at the rate of ₹ 99,750.
43.
As a result, we are of the opinion that the Tribunal was in error
in allowing the OA of Srishti Shanker and setting aside the order dated
20 August 2015.
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
44.
Resultantly, the impugned judgment, in so far as it allows OA
3165/2015, is quashed and set aside.
45.
The OA itself would stand dismissed.
46.
Applying the principle of actus curiae neminem gravabit,
however, we direct that no recovery should be made from the
respondent on the basis of the present judgment.
C. HARI SHANKAR, J.
VINOD KUMAR, J.
JULY 21, 2026/yg/dsn
KUMAR VATS
W.P.(C) 9207/2017 & W.P.(C) 11383/2017
15:47:04
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review