Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34881
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE NINETEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTTCE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
D
THE HONOURABLE SR! JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
oF 20
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters patent Against the Order Dated
O3lO7l2O25 in W.P. No. 9397 of 2010 on the fite of the High Court.
Between:
1. The Central Power Dishibution Company of A.
Southern
Power Distribution Comvpany of Telahgana
by its
Chairman and Managing Eiireclor, Mint Co-mpo
2. The.Superintending Engineer, APCPDCL, (presenfly TGSPDCL), Operation
Circle, Medak at Sanga Reddy
3. Thg^_Divisional Engi-n-ee1,. EJechical, Operation, APCPDCL (presenfly
TGSPDCL), Toopran, Medak District.
E
AND
!!Q[amq S^pinners Pvt. Limited, Rama Towers, 2nd Ftoor, 5-4-83, TSK Chambers,
V.e.Bp"-0, Secunderabad, Represented by its Managing Director Sri Gopal Agarwi,
S/o M L Agarwal
...RESPONDENTS
77itn
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
receive the following documents viz. copy of the counter Affidavit filed in w p
No. 9397 of 2010. Copy of relevant General Terms & Conditions of Supply, as
Additional Material Papers in the above Writ Appeal, in the interest of justice and
pass such other or further orders.
lA NO: 2 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the o;)eration of the Order dated 31712O25 passed in W P No. 9397 of
2010, pending disposal of W.A.No. of 2025.
lA NO: 4 OF
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
receive the cop'/ of the inspection report with regard to inspection conducted on
25.11.2OO9 on the writ petitioner
/ respondent's service connection, as addl
material paper in the above writ appeal, in the interest of justice.
Counsel for the Appellant : SRI N.SREEDHAR REDDY, (SC FOR TGTRANSCO)
counserrortheRespondents:?$.1;t;i,5tll$I"t^'rtriitiniorcounser
The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
,. ,,
IN THI HIGH COUF(r r1ORII{E STATE OF TEI.ANGANA
AT ITYDERABAI)
THE HON'BI,E THE CHIE,F JUS"UCE SRI APARESH XI'MAR SINGH
AND
TIIE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT AppEAL No.88 of 2O26
DATE:L9.o.2.2o126
Between:
The Central Power Distribution Company of A.p. Limited
(presently southern Power Distribution company of relangana
Limited (SPDCTL))
represented by its Vice Chainnan and Managing Director,
Mint Compound, Hyderabad and 2 others
...Appellants
And
M/s Rama Spinners Private Limited
Respondent
JUDGMENT
Heard sri N.Sreedhar Reddy, learned standing counsel for
Transmission corporation of relangana Limited (TGTRANSCO)
appearing for the appellants and Sri M.p.chandramouli, learned
senior counsel representing sri ch.satya sadhan, learned counsel for
the respondent.
2-
This writ appeal, preferred under clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, assails the order dated og.oz.2o25 passed by the learned
single Judge in w.P.No.9397 of 201o. By the said order, the learned
single Judge allowed the writ petition filed by the respondent herein
and set aside the demand proceedings dated 2s.o3.2olo issued by
the 2nd appellant, whereby a sum of Rs.2,gs,4ool- was demanded
from the respondent towards back-billing charges on the allegation of
.'.:_'
r.-* --*y :4F"6Fq-.:r:- . -'
"_-'"-
-.*..::._::
I:..
-",'ffi-,-";l;-:.Tl-"
i.",il.el}...,."::i'''"'
t-
low re:ording of eners/ consumption due to a defective potential
Transfrlrmer (PT). The appelants have assailed the said order
on the
grounds that the learned single Judge misapplied the provisions
of
the Ge'eral rerms and conditions of Supply (GTCS) to the facts
of the
case, which primarily involved a defective pr and not a defective
meter
per se.
Factual background {in brieff
3.
The respondent (writ petitioner) is a High rension (HT)
consurrrer availing power supply under service connection No.MDK_
755. Ttre dispute arises out of a demand raised by the appellants
towards. back-billing charges on the allegation of under-recording
of
eners/ <:onsumption.
4-
oa 21. 1 1-2009, while recording the monthry meter reading, tJre
oflicials of the appellant-company noticed that the consumption for
November, 2oo9 was 5,s1,7o0 units, which was substantially
rower
than th. average consumption of the preceding three months (August,
septemtrer and october 2oogl. A suspicion was recorded that t].e
low
recording might be attributable to absence of y, phase voltage.
consequently, on a provisional basis, a shortfal of r,o3,4so units was
assessecl based on the average consumption of three consecutive
months ;end added to trre November, 2009 bill. The respondent
paid t].e said bill, including the additional
units so assessed.
herein
5.
Thereafter, on 25.11.2009, a detailed inspection was conducted
by the Divisional Engineer (DPE/HT) at the respondent's premises.
During the inspection, it was found that the Y' Phase PT was
defective, and the voltage in the Y'phase was recorded as zero both at
the Test Terminal Box (TTB) and on the meter display. The defective
PT was replaced on the same day. The relevant portion of inspection
report is reproduced hereunder:
'9. Inciminating Points obserued at th.e time of inspection
1) Y ph uoltage is z.ero at TTB and in meter.
2) MRT data allected.
3) Gilled Gate to be prouided."
6.
On analysis of the Common Meter Reading Instrument (CMRI)
and data retrieved from the meter, it was concluded that the defect in
the Y' Phase PT persisted from O3.10.2OO9 to 25.LL.2OO9. The
appellants, invoking Clause 7.5.1 of the GTCS, undertook a back-
billing assessment for the said period and issued a notice dated
L9.L2.2OO9, initially determining the additional liability at
Rs.3,89,3L7 /-.
7.
The respondent submitted its objections to the notice, and a
personal hearing was afforded on 24.O2.2OLO. Upon consideration of
the objections, the 2nd appellant passed final proceedings dated
25.03.2010, reducing the demand by allowing eligible Load Factor
lncentive and determining the net payable amount at Rs.2,85,4OO/-.
Aggrieved ttrereby, the respondent herein instituted the writ petition,
which came to be allowed by the learned Single Judge.
Contentions on behalf of the appellants
8.
Learned Standing Counsel appearing for the appellants,
assailec[ the order of the learned Single Judge and has raised the
contentions as under:
i.'l'hat the impugned order proceeds on an erroneous
interpretation of Clause 7.5.L of the GTCS. The procedural
requirements contemplated under Clauses 7.5.1-1 to 7.5.1.3;
rramely, preparation of an inspection report in the prescribed
lbrmat, testing of the meter in the Meter Relay Testing (MRT)
I.aboratory in the presence of the consumer, and issuance of
notice within the stipulated time, are attracted only in cases
rvhere the recording meter itself is found to be defective.
ii. That in the instant case, the defect was not in the meter but
in the Y' Phase PT, which is only an associated component of
l.he metering circuit. A PT, being a voltage transformer, merely
r;teps down high voltage to a level that the meter can safely
record. If the PT is defective, particularly where a phase
rroltage is absent, the meter *ouid consequently record lower
<:onsumption; however, the meter itself cannot be termed
"defective" in the sense of being inaccurate. The defect, in
siuch circumstances, lies in the circuitry. Therefore, the
provisions applicable for sending the meter to the MRT
Laboratory were neither warranted nor practicable, as the pr
alone required replacement, which was done on 25. Lt.2oog-
iii-
That the assessment was made on the basis of CMRI
data, which is an objective electronic record of the meter,s
internar diagnostics and has established tl.at the y, phase
voltage was absent from 03.10.2009 to 2s-LL.2oog. since no
laboratory testing of the meter was required, the question of
issuing a two-week advance notice to respondent for such
testing under Clause Z.S.L.2 did not arise.
iv. That the principles of natural justice were duly complied with.
A detailed notice dated 19.L2.2oo9 was issued, the respondent
submitted objections, and a personal hearing was afforded on
24.o2.2olo. The frnal order dated 2s.o3.2olo was a reasoned
order which was passed after considering the respond.ent's
specific objections, wherein even the benefit of Load Factor
Incentive was granted, thereby reducing the demand to
Rs.2,85,4oo/-.The learned single Judge erred in interfering
with a lawful assessment made in accordance with t].e
applicable terms and conditions of supply.
Contentions on behalf of the respondent
9.
Learned senior counsel appearing for the respondent has
supported the order of the learned single Judge and raised the
contentions as under:
i. That the GTCS, having been approved by the Andhra Pradesh
Electricity Regulatory Commission (APERC), mandate strict
adherence. Clause 7 -5.L governs the entire field of defective
metering equipment and cannot be narrowly construed by
segregating the meter from the PT'
ii. That the appellants failed to comply with the mandatory
sal'eguards under Clauses 7.5.1.1 to 7.5.1.3, including
prerparation and service of inspection report in the prescribed
forrnat, testing in the presence of the consumer, and issuance
of lotice within the stipulated period. Such violations are not
mere procedural irregularities but substantive violations that
vitietted the entire assessment and rendered the consequential
demand unsustainable.
iii- That the right of the consumer to witness the testing of the
equioment to veriff the alleged defect, is a substantive
safe65uard to ensure transparency and fairness, and denial of
such opportunity amounts to violation of principles of natural
justic:e. The plea of absence of prejudice is misconceived, as
breach of a statutory procedure is itself prejudicialiv. That the respondent had already paid for the additional units
provisrionally added in the November, 2oo9 bill; and the
subsequent demand for a much larger amount was an attempt
a7 -'
to lev3'double charges, which is impermissible in law.
1(). We have taken note of the respective contentions urged and
perused the material on record.
Consideration by this Court
11. The main controversy revolves around the interpretation of
Clause 7.5.1 of the GTCS and its sub-clauses. The learned Single
Judge has proceeded on a strict and literal construction of ttre said
provision. While it is undoubtedly settled that procedures prescribed
under statutory regulations must ordinarily be adhered to, it is
equally well established that such provisions must receive a
contextual and purposive interpretation so as to advance the object of
the regulation and avoid impracticable or unintended consequences.
12. It is pertinent to note that Clause 7.5 of the GTCS bears the
heading "Replacement of Meters", and Clause 7.5.1 deals specifically
with "Defective Meters". A plain reading of Clauses 7.5.1.1 to 7.5.1.3
would indicate that the procedural safeguards contemplated therein;
namely, preparation of inspection report, dispatch of the meter to the
MRT Laboratory for testing, issuance of a test report, and
consequential notice within the stipulated time are structured around
a situation where the meter itself is suspected to be defective. In
particular, clause 7-5-L-2 expressly stipulates that the meter found
defective shall be sent to the MRT laboratory for testing and the
subsequent steps are clearly predicated upon such laboratory
\ i
examination. clauses 7.5 to 7.s.I.3 of the GTCS are extracted
hereunder:
?.5 Replacement of Meters
7.5-7 Defectiue Meters: Trrc foilowing procedure shan be ad.opted by the
atmpany in respect of defectiue meters (other than stuck up meters
which do not inwlue ang dispute)
7-5-7.7 T?rc authorbed Inspecting officer as per Designated. officers,
Nc'tification slnll reard the obseruations mad.e at tlre time of Inspection
bg prepaing the Inspection Report o.s per the format prescibed in
Appendix M (Appendix IV A for LT ansumers or Appendix IV B
for HT
o*sume(s) and serue a copa of the same to the ansumer at trc end. of
the inspection. The autharised inspecting olficer shail send a opy of
su<'h Inspection Report bg trc nert working daa to the officer aul/n,i.sed
for preparation of tlrc assessmenf notice in case of defectiue meter.
7.5.7.2 Tlrc a.ssociated ciranitry tncluding cr/yr shall be tested. at the
pre;nises of the @nsuffLer. In addition wherever the ansumer dbputes
or otherwise ansidered necessary, the Inspecting olfier shail arso
ensltre that the mater, which is found. to be defectiue at the time of
insp'ection, is sent to tte MRT raboratory
for testing after repracement
witf,. a cnrrect meter. The testing at MRT shall be and.ucted bg
an officer
notiJied by tle @mpana as per Designated. olficers Notificition in
the
presence of the onsumer (or his authaised representatiue) wlw
shoutd.
be giuen atleast two weeres aduance notice bg the @mpana. He shail
senci the Meter Test Report to the officer authorised. as per Designated.
Offia"-rs' Notification fo Issue assessmenf notice, within 3 d.ays
from
date of testing with apy to @nsumer and. all oth.er concemed.
7-5-1.3 such Designated olfier shall issue fhe Assessment Notice as
per ttie format prouided in Appendix vll, to the ansumer within two
dags from the date of receipt of the Meter Testing Report from the MRT
labonttory, whereuer applicabte.
13. In the present case, the material on record discloses that the
inspection conducted on 25.1 1 .2oo9 revealed that the 1(' phase
Potential Transformer (PT) was defective with the voltage in that phase
registering as zero. The defect was thus not in the recording
mechanism of the m7,ter. A PT is an external component forming part
of the assoc:iated metering circuitr5r, whose function is to step down
high voltage to a measurable level. If the pr fails, particularly by loss
of phase voltage, the meter may consequently record lower
consumption; however, the meter's internal accuracy or calibration is
not thereby rendered defective- The fault, in such circumstances, lies
upstream in the circuitry and not in the metering instrument.
L4. It is also to be noted that to mechanically apply the procedure
meant for a defective meter to a case of defective pr would be
misconceived, as the MRT Laboratory is intended for testing the
accuracy and functionality of meters; it is neither designed nor
required to diagnose or repair high-voltage transformers such as pTs.
A defective PT is ordinarily replaced, as was done on 2s.Ll.2oog,
rather than subjected to Laboratory testing in the manner
contemplated for meters. consequently, the insistence on sending the
meter to the MRT Laboratory and issuing prior notice for such testing
would be inapposite in the underlying circumstances of the present
case. Therefore, a purposive reading of clause 7.5.1 makes it clear
that the prescribed procedure applies where the meter itself is
defective, and not where an associated component of the circuitry,
such as a PT, has failed and thereby resulted in under-recording of
consumption.
15. on perusal of the inspection report, dated 2s.Ll.2oo9, it clearly
discloses that the defect was in the y' phase pr and not in the
recording meter. In such a case, the demand for strict compliance
with clauses 7.5.1.1 to 7.s.1.3, as urged by the respondent, cannot
be accellted. The aforesaid provisions apply to cases where the meter
itself is found defective and is required to be sent to the MRT
Laboratc'ry for testing.
16. Further, the substantive basis for assessment in cases of
defective metering equipment is provided under Clause 7.5.1.4 of the
GTCS, which deals with the computation of assessed units for the
period during which the system remained defective. The object of the
provision is to determine, on a rational basis, the quantum of energr
that escaped proper recording. In the present case, the appellants
relied upc'n the CMRI data, which constitutes an objective electronic
record of the meter's parameters, to ascertain the precise period
during which the Y' Phase voltage was absent, namely from
03.10.200') to 25.LL.2OO9. Thereafter, in terms of Clause 7.5.1.4.I,
the appelkmts computed the average consumption on the basis of the
preceding:nonths during which the metering system was functioning
normally. The methodolory adopted is identifying the period of defect
through electronic data and applying the prescribed average
consumption formula, which cannot be said to be arbitrary or
contrar5r to the GTCS. Clauses 7.5-L.4 and 7.5.1.4.1 of the GTCS are
extracted hr:reunder:
7.5.7.4 When a meter is found to be defective during meter reading
or on inspedion or othenaise, th.e following guidelines shall be
folloued for amputation of tle. assessed units
,f
7.5.7,4.7 Thenarpb.er of units to be billed during tlrc period in which
the rleter n@{ b function or became defectiue, sl,r;Llt be
detennined bg taking tlre auerage of the electicity supplied duing
tlw preeding tlvee billing cycles to the bilting cgcle in whichthe said
meter eased to function or became defecttue prouided ttwt ttte
qndition with regard to use of electricity during the said.
ttvee biiling
cades raere not different from *ase which preuailed. during the
period in uthtch the Meter ceased to
function or became defeaiui.
17- It is also borne out from the record t],at t].e appellants did not
proceed in a mechanical manner. A detailed notice
was issued; the
respondent submitted objections; and a personal hearing was
afforded
on 24.o2-2olo. The final proceedings dated 2s.og.2olo constitute
a
reasoned order, wherein the objections were considered,
the defect
was confirmed with reference to the cMRI data, and the
benefit of
Load Factor Incentive was extended., thereby reducing the
initial
demand. Thus, the process complies with the prescribed procedure
before issuing an assessment notice.
18. The respondent's contention that the subsequent demand
amounts to double charging is misconceived. The additional
units
added in the November, 2oog bill was only provisional, pending
detailed verification. upon inspection and analysis of the
cMRI data, a
final assessment was made for the entire defective period,
in which
the earlier provisional addition stood adjusted. Thus, there is
no
attempt to lery double charges.
19. The learned Single Judge observed that no inspection report in
Appendix IV-B format was served upon the respondent
petitioner). However, the record discloses a detailed
(writ
"HT Inspection
Report" dated 2s-rL.2oo9 prepared by the inspecting
officer, which
L2
contains atl material particulars of the inspection; namely, the
following:
i) T,re readings at tl-e TTB and meter display
ii) T.re specific observation that the Y'Phase voltage was zero'
a:rd
iii) The signature of the respondent's representative i.e',
M. Narasimha Rao, Stores Incharge'
Furtlrer,thesubstanceoftherequirement,suchas,recording
the defect and communicating the same to the respondent also stands
duly complied with by the appellants. Thus, mere non-adherence to a
particular format or a Form with a particular nomenclature, in the
absence of demonstrated prejudice, cannot vitiate the proceedings'
2f,. At t.:ris juncture, it is pertinent to note that the principal
reasoning rrf the learned single Judge, based on the absence of MRT
test in the presence of the respondent, overlooks the clear distinction
between a defective meter and a defective PI. Since the meter itself
was not fotrnd to be defective, there was no requirement to send it to
the MRT L:rboratory- The assessment was made on the basis of the
on-site inspection and the CMRI data, which established the
period of
under-recor.ding. Therefore, the requirement of issuing notice
testing or passing arl assessment within two days of a test
for MRT
report does
not arise. The demand, having been frnalized after nolice and
personal ht:aring, cannot be interfered with on a purely technical
interpretation
'
.,,,;-
Conclusion
21. For the foregoing reasons, this court is of
the considered view
that clauses 7-5.L.1 to 7.5.1.3 0f the GTCS,
laboratory testing, apply only where the
meter itself is defective and
not where the defect ries in an associated
Potential Transformer (PT). The impugned
w'P'No.9392 of 2oLo, having proceeded
component such as a
order, dated o3.o..2o2s in
on an erroneous apprication
of the relevant provisions of the GTCS, cannot
22'
relating to MRT
be sustained.
Accordingly, tJre writ Appear is a,owed.
dated o3-oz -2025 passed in w.p.No .g3gr
of 2o1o by the learned
single Judge is set aside, and the wr.it petition
demand proceedings dated 2s-o3.2oro for
The impugned order
stands dismissed. The
a sum of Rs.2,gs ,4oo/ - are
upheld' The respondent shall pay the said
amount, if not already
paid, within a period of eight (g) weeks
from the date of receipt of a
copy of this judgment, failing which the
appellants shall be at liberty
to recover the same in accordance with
law.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending
if any, stand
closed. No costs.
//TRUE COPYII
SD/-M.RAMANA KRTSHNA
JOINT
FFICER
To,
1.
Director, Central power Distribution
Southern Power Distribution
Mint Compound, Hyderabad.
2.
fh" Superintending Enqineer. APCPDCL,
operation Circle, Medak atbangd Reddy
(presently TGSpDCL),
3. The Divisional Engine-er, .Electrical, operation, ApcpDCL (presenfly
TGSPDCL), Tooprah, Mecjak Diiirict.
4liiflixi:iT,iJl"fi"{#.[1t;f;
Agarwa, S/o M L Agarwal
f
sHff
rvuv' t".",fr
vvvqr rvsrqwcr(r'
[?l,F,f, t3,,T?[?fi
\)lr \ruP i
5. one cc to SRI N.SREEDHAR REDDY, sc FoR TG TRANSCO.
topucl
6. One CC to SRt CH.SATYASADHAN, Advocate. tOpUCl
ry. 7. Two CD Copies.
HIGH COURT
DATED:1910212026
irti S
o
.J
2 5 l4At{ /lJ26
L.
JUDGMHNT
WA.No.88 of 2026
ALLOWING THE WRIT APPEAL
THOUT COSTS
)
b
*
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review