The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. In view of the foregoing discussions, calculation, and the law laid down by the Apex Court in Harshadbhai Amrutbhai’s case (supra), the claimant is entitled for the - 16 MFA No.103486 of 2018 compensation of Rs.71,620/- as against Rs.3,61,150/awarded by the Commissioner.
28. In the result, this Court proceeds to pass the following:- (i) This appeal is allowed in part. (ii) The judgment and award dated
03. 08.2018, in ECA No.96/2014 on he file of the M.A.C.T. No. III, Bagalkot is hereby modified. (iii) The claimant is entitled for the total compensation of Rs.71,620/- as against Rs.3,61,150/- awarded by the Commissioner. (iv) The appellant–Insurance Company shall be liable only to pay the said amount and shall not be liable to pay medical expenses or interest, the liability towards medical expenses and interest, - 17 MFA No.103486 of 2018 if any, being fastened exclusively on respondent Nos.1 and 2. (v) The appellant–Insurance Company shall deposit Rs.71,620/-, if not already deposited, within four weeks, and any excess amount deposited shall be amount shall be refunded to it. (vi) On deposit, the released in favour of the claimant, in accordance with law. No order as to costs. Sd/(DR. K.MANMADHA RAO) MBS, CT:VP
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1MFA No.103486 of 2018
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
®
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.103486 OF 2018 (WC)
BETWEEN:
THE BRANCH MANAGER,
NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD.,
MELLIGERI COMPLEX, BAGALKOT.
NOW REPRESENTED BY ITS AUTHORIZED OFFICER,
RESP.NO.3.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. SURESH S. GUNDI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally signed
by
MOHANKUMAR
B SHELAR
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka,
Dharwad Bench
1.
SABU S/O JOSEPH
AGE: 47 YEARS,
OCC: MECHANICAL LABOUR (NOW NIL),
R/O: NEHRU NAGAR, BELAGAVI-590010.
2.
SHRIKANT S/O SHANKREPPA MIRJI
AGE: 44 YEARS, OCC: CONTRACTOR,
R/O: HOSUR-587117, TQ/DIST: VIJAYAPURA.
3.
THE MANAGING DIRECTOR,
NANDI SUGAR CO-OP SOCIETY LTD.,
KRISHNA NAGAR, R/O: HOSUR-587117,
TQ/DIST: VIJAYAPURA.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. S.B. NAIK, ADVOCATE FOR R1 (ABSENT);
R2 & R3-SERVED)
THIS MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
30(1) OF THE EMPLOYEES COMPENSATION ACT, PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE/MODIFY THE JUDGMENT DATED 03.08.2018 PASSED IN ECA
96/2014 ON THE FILE OF THE MEMBER MACT NO.III BAGALKOT & ETC.
THIS MFA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR
JUDGMENT ON 30.01.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT
THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:’
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE K.MANMADHA RAO
-2MFA No.103486 of 2018
CAV JUDGMENT
The present appeal is filed by the Insurance Company
under Section 30(1) of the Employees Compensation Act,
1923 (hereinafter referred to as "the EC Act" for short) to
modify the judgment and award dated 03.08.2018, in ECA
No.96/2014 on the file of the M.A.C.T. No.III, Bagalkot
(hereinafter referred to as "the Commissioner" for short).
2.
The
appellant-Insurance
Company
herein
is
respondent No.3, respondent No.1 herein is the claimant
and respondent Nos.2 and 3 herein are respondents No.1
and 2 before the Commissioner.
3.
For convenience, the parties herein are referred to
as per their rankings before the Commissioner.
of
4.
The claimant filed claim petition under Section 22
the
EC
Act
against
the
respondents
claiming
compensation of Rs.7,50,000/- with interest at the rate of
18% per annum with cost till the date of realization of
award amount.
5.
The brief facts of the case are that:-
-3MFA No.103486 of 2018
The petitioner/claimant was employed as a helper
under
respondent
respondent
No.2
No.1,
a
contractor
factory, and
engaged
was earning
with
wages
of
Rs.500/- per day. At the time of the incident, the claimant
was aged about 43 years and was hale and healthy.
On 08.08.2014, while discharging his duties as a
mechanical labourer on the upper roof of the factory
premises as per the directions of respondents No.1 and 2,
at about 5.00 PM, the claimant slipped and fell, resulting in
grievous injuries to both his legs. He was immediately
provided first aid at the hospital of respondent No.2 factory,
thereafter referred to Galagali Primary Health Center, and
subsequently to Sai Adhar Hospital, Mudhol, where he
underwent surgery involving insertion of rod and screws. He
remained admitted as an inpatient for about 30 days,
incurred medical expenses of approximately Rs.2,00,000/-,
and continues to take treatment as an outpatient.
The claimant further states that due to the injuries
sustained in the accident, he has suffered permanent
disability, resulting in total loss of earning capacity. He was
-4MFA No.103486 of 2018
the sole breadwinner of his family and sustained the injuries
without any fault on his part, leading to severe financial,
physical, and mental hardship. Respondents No.1 and 2,
having knowledge of the incident, visited him in the hospital
and
assured
payment
of
medical
expenses
and
compensation. However, they failed to honor the said
assurance. Consequently, the claimant issued a legal notice
on 26.09.2014 to respondents No.1 and 2 demanding
compensation, which was duly served.
Respondent No.1, in reply, admitted the employment
and contended that he had insured the risk with respondent
No.3, while denying liability to pay compensation. The
claimant asserts that the accident occurred during the
course and out of employment, that the insurance policy
with respondent No.3 was valid on the date of accident, and
therefore, all respondents are jointly and severally liable to
pay compensation.
6.
through
After service of notice, respondent No.1 appeared
his counsel,
filed
his
written
statement
and
admitted with respect to the employment, employer-
-5MFA No.103486 of 2018
employee relationship, daily wages of the claimant, time of
the accident. He further admitted that the accident had
taken
place
during
the
course
of
the
employment.
However, respondent No.1 contended that he had insured
the employment risk with respondent No.3 and therefore,
denied personal liability to pay any compensation to the
claimant.
7.
Respondent No.2, despite due service of notice,
failed to appear before the Commissioner and was placed
ex-parte.
8.
Respondent No.3 - Insurance Company, entered
appearance through counsel and filed its objections denying
the material averments made in the petition and disputed
its liability, and prayed for dismissal of the claim petition
with costs.
9.
evidence,
Based on the pleadings, oral and documentary
the
Commissioner
partly
allowed
the
claim
petition and awarded the compensation of Rs.3,61,150/with interest at the rate of 12% per annum after one month
-6MFA No.103486 of 2018
of accident till its realization of full compensation amount to
the claimant from respondent No.3 – Insurance Company.
10. The learned counsel for the appellant-Insurance
Company would contend that the claimant is a resident of
Belagavi, the contractor is functioning at Hosur, Vijayapura,
and the insurance policy was issued by the Vijayapura
Branch Office. In spite of this, the claim petition was
instituted before the Commissioner in clear contravention of
Section 21 of the EC Act. The Commissioner, upon noticing
the absence of jurisdiction, ought to have either dismissed
the claim petition or transferred the same to the competent
Commissioner as contemplated under Section 21 of the EC
Act. Failure to do so vitiates the entire proceedings.
11. It is contended that the impugned order is
opposed to the Employees’ Compensation Insurance Policy,
including its Schedule, Terms, Exceptions and Conditions,
issued to respondent No.2–contractor. The policy is purely a
contract of indemnity, under which the primary statutory
obligation to pay compensation within thirty days from the
-7MFA No.103486 of 2018
date of accident rests upon the employer/contractor, who
may thereafter seek indemnification from the insurer. The
policy specifically excludes liability towards interest on
compensation and reimbursement of medical expenses, and
no premium was collected for the said heads. The actual
policy containing the applicable terms and conditions has
been produced before this Court by way of an Interlocutory
Application, which unequivocally establishes that medical
expenses and interest are outside the scope of coverage.
Hence, fastening liability on the insurer for interest and
medical expenses is contrary to the contract of insurance.
12. Further, in terms of Exclusion Clauses (d) and (e)
of the policy, the insurance company is expressly absolved
of
liability
under
compensation
any
amount
law
and
to
pay
medical
interest
expenses
on
the
incurred
towards treatment of any injury sustained by an employee.
The
Commissioner
has
misconceived
the
provisions
governing contracts of insurance as codified in the policy
and has erroneously directed the appellant/insurer to pay
amounts expressly excluded under the policy.
-8MFA No.103486 of 2018
13.
It is also contended that the insurance policy
covers four helpers with a declared annual wage of
Rs.1,92,000/- for all four employees, which works out to
Rs.48,000/- per annum and Rs.4,000/- per month per
employee, based on which the premium was paid. Contrary
to this declaration, the Commissioner assessed the wage at
Rs.280/- per day and arbitrarily rounded it off to Rs.300/per day without any legal or factual basis.
14.
The learned counsel for the appellant-Insurance
Company had raised the below substantial questions of law
for consideration of this Court:-
(i) Whether the judgment and Award passed by
the Commissioner for Employee’s Compensation is in
accordance with Section 4(2A) of the Employees’
Compensation Act, as much as imposing liability of
the medical expenses on the appellant in view of the
Exclusion clause contained in the contract of policy?
(ii) Whether the Commissioner is justified in
coming
to
the
conclusion
that
the
Respondent
No.3/appellant is liable to pay interest as per Section
4-A of the Employees’ Compensation Act, as against
exclusion clause in the policy condition?
-9MFA No.103486 of 2018
(iii) Whether the Commissioner is justified in
considering the wage of the claimant as Rs.9,000/per month which is against the provision of section 4
(1-B) of Employees’ Compensation Act and as against
the wage shown in the policy as per the insured i.e.,
Rs.4,000/- per month on the basis of which insurance
premium is collected.
15.
In support of his contentions, learned counsel for
the appellant-Insurance Company has placed reliance on
the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of New India
Assurance
Co.
Ltd.
V.
Harshadbhai
Amrutbhai
Modhiya and another reported in (2006) 5 SCC 192.
16.
Heard
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
appellant and perused the material available on record.
None appears for respondent No.1.
17.
Upon
hearing
the
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant and on a careful examination of the impugned
award, this Court finds that the liability of the insurance
company under the Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923 is
required to be examined strictly in accordance with the
- 10 MFA No.103486 of 2018
statutory scheme of the EC Act and the terms of the
contract of insurance.
18.
Further, Section 4 of the EC Act prescribes the
manner of computation of compensation, while Section 4-A
mandates that the employer shall pay compensation as
soon as it falls due and provides for interest and penalty in
the
event
of
compensation
default.
Thus,
the
obligation
together
with
interest
and
to
pay
penalty
is
statutorily fastened on the employer alone.
19.
The EC Act does not contain any provision
analogous to the MV Act compelling the insurer to satisfy
the entire award in favour of the claimant. The right of the
claimant under the EC Act is to recover compensation from
the employer, and not directly from the insurer. The liability
of the insurance company arises only by virtue of a contract
of insurance entered into with the employer and is therefore
one of indemnification, governed exclusively by the terms
and conditions of the policy.
- 11 MFA No.103486 of 2018
20.
The Apex Court in Harshadbhai Amrutbhai
Modhiya’s case (supra) while interpreting Section 17 of the
EC Act, has categorically held that the said provision merely
prohibits a contract which absolves or reduces the liability
of the employer vis-à-vis the workman, but does not
prohibit the employer and insurer from entering into a
contract limiting the extent of indemnification. It has been
clearly laid down that, in the absence of a statutory
mandate, contractual exclusions in an insurance policy
excluding liability towards interest or penalty must be given
effect to. The Apex Court in paragraph 24 held as under:
“24. Section 17 of the Workmen's Compensation Act voids only
a contract or agreement whereby a workman relinquishes any right
of compensation from the employer for personal injury arising out
of or in the course of the employment and insofar as it purports to
remove or reduce the liability of any person to pay compensation
under the Act. As my learned Brother has noticed, in the
Workmen's
Compensation
Act,
there
are
no
provisions
corresponding to those in the Motor Vehicles Act, insisting on the
insurer covering the entire liability arising out of an award towards
compensation to a third party arising out of a motor accident. It is
not brought to our notice that there is any other law enacted which
stands in the way of an insurance company and the insured
entering into a contract confining the obligation of the insurance
company to indemnify to a particular head or to a particular amount
- 12 MFA No.103486 of 2018
when it relates to a claim for compensation to a third party arising
under the Workmen's Compensation Act. In this situation, the
obligation of the insurance company clearly stands limited and the
relevant proviso providing for exclusion of liability for interest or
penalty has to be given effect to. Unlike the scheme of the Motor
Vehicles Act the Workmen's Compensation Act does not confer a
right on the claimant for compensation under that Act to claim the
payment of compensation in its entirety from the insurer himself.
The
entitlement
of
the
claimant
under
the
Workmen's
Compensation Act is to claim the compensation from the employer.
As between the employer and the insurer, the rights and obligations
would depend upon the terms of the insurance contract. Construing
the contract involved here it is clear that the insurer has specifically
excluded any liability for interest or penalty under the Workmen's
Compensation Act and confined its liability to indemnify the
employer only against the amount of compensation ordered to be
paid under the Workmen's Compensation Act. The High Court was,
therefore, not correct in holding that the appellant Insurance
Company, is also liable to pay the interest on the amount of
compensation awarded by the Commissioner. The workman has to
recover it from the employer.”
21.
In the present case, the insurance policy placed
on record expressly excludes liability towards payment of
interest under Section 4-A of the EC Act, and it is not
disputed that no additional premium was paid to cover such
liability. In view of the law declared by the Apex Court, the
Commissioner committed a clear error of law in fastening
liability on the appellant–Insurance Company to pay interest
- 13 MFA No.103486 of 2018
on the compensation amount. Consequently, the liability to
pay interest under Section 4-A of the EC Act rests solely
upon the employer not on the insurer.
22.
Similarly, the EC Act does not treat medical
expenses as a component of “compensation” payable under
Section 4. Reimbursement of medical expenses is not a
statutory liability imposed on the insurer under the EC Act.
Where the insurance policy specifically excludes liability
towards medical expenses incurred for treatment of injuries
sustained by an employee, and no premium is paid for such
coverage, the insurer cannot be fastened with liability
contrary to the terms of the contract. Any direction
requiring the insurer
to reimburse
medical expenses,
despite an express exclusion in the policy, is therefore
unsustainable in law and beyond the scope of the insurer’s
contractual obligation.
23.
With regard to the determination of wages,
Section 4(1)(b) read with Section 2(1)(m) of the EC Act
requires compensation to be computed on the basis of
- 14 MFA No.103486 of 2018
wages proved in accordance with law. In the present case,
the insurance policy and its schedule disclose that coverage
was obtained by declaring specific wages for the category of
employees concerned, and premium was paid on that basis.
In the absence of reliable and legally acceptable evidence
adduced by the claimant to establish wages in excess of
what was declared and insured, the Commissioner was not
justified in arbitrarily assessing higher wages without any
supporting material.
24.
In view of the above, the coverage was obtained
by declaring annual wages of Rs.1,92,000/- for four helpers,
which works out to Rs.4,000/- per month per employee,
and that premium was paid on that basis alone. Hence,
considering the wages of the claimant at Rs.4,000/-, 60%
of Rs.4,000/- comes to Rs.2,400/- (Rs.4000/- x 60%). In
respect of loss of earning capacity of the claimant is taken
into consideration to multiply the same from the relevant
factor
i.e.,Rs.2400/-
x
17%
disability=
408.
As
per
Schedule IV of the EC Act, for the age of 43 years, the
relevant factor 175.54, taken by the Commissioner is just
- 15 MFA No.103486 of 2018
and proper. Considering the same, the loss of earning
capacity of the claimant is re-worked as 408 x 175.54 =
71,620/-.
25.
In view of the aforesaid statutory provisions and
the binding declaration of law by the Apex Court, the
impugned award insofar as it fastens liability on the
appellant–Insurance Company beyond the terms of the
policy is legally unsustainable and warrants interference to
that extent, while leaving the employer’s statutory liability
under the Employees’ Compensation Act intact.
26.
When the liability of the insurer is contractually
restricted to indemnification based on the declared wages
under the policy, the Commissioner was bound to compute
compensation strictly in accordance with such declared
wages.
27.
In view of the foregoing discussions, calculation,
and the law laid down by the Apex Court in Harshadbhai
Amrutbhai’s case (supra), the claimant is entitled for the
- 16 MFA No.103486 of 2018
compensation of Rs.71,620/- as against Rs.3,61,150/awarded by the Commissioner.
28.
In the result, this Court proceeds to pass the
following:-
ORDER
(i)
This appeal is allowed in part.
(ii)
The
judgment
and
award
dated
03.08.2018, in ECA No.96/2014 on he
file of the M.A.C.T. No. III, Bagalkot is
hereby modified.
(iii)
The claimant is entitled for the total
compensation of Rs.71,620/- as against
Rs.3,61,150/-
awarded
by
the
Commissioner.
(iv)
The appellant–Insurance Company shall
be liable only to pay the said amount
and shall not be liable to pay medical
expenses
or
interest,
the
liability
towards medical expenses and interest,
- 17 MFA No.103486 of 2018
if any, being fastened exclusively on
respondent Nos.1 and 2.
(v)
The appellant–Insurance Company shall
deposit
Rs.71,620/-,
if
not
already
deposited, within four weeks, and any
excess
amount
deposited
shall
be
amount
shall
be
refunded to it.
(vi)
On
deposit,
the
released in favour of the claimant, in
accordance with law.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(DR. K.MANMADHA RAO)
JUDGE
MBS,
CT:VP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review