The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
25. 02.2021, Parameshwar Roy was coming towards his house from Karailong Chowmuhani on foot maintaining left side of the road and on the way when he reached near a godown at Karailong, suddenly one Yamaha (R15) Motorcycle bearing Model No.YZF155-A, Chassis No.ME1RG5259K0047935 coming with high speed dashed him from back side. Consequently, Parameshwar Roy (now deceased) sustained grievous multiple injuries on his person. After the accident, he was at first shifted to Teliamura hospital with serious condition wherefrom the injured was referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital for better treatment and got him admitted there but during treatment, on 08.03.2021 at about 2 PM he died in the said hospital. It is stated that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent riding of the motorcycle by its rider. Concerning the accident, a police case was registered at Teliamura Police Station vide Teliamura P.S. Case No.29/2021 U/Ss.279/304-A of I.P.C and Sections 184/187 of the M.V. Act. As stated, deceased was 60 years old and as a mason by profession, he used to earn Rs.15,000/-, per month. Finally, they claimed compensation to the tune of Rs.35,35,000/- under different heads. [5] Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties, the learned Court below has observed as under: “It is, therefore, held that the present claimant petitioners namely; Smti. Saraswati Roy and Sri Tapas Roy are e…
08. 03.2021, Sri Tapas Roy (son of the deceased) lodged the ejahar with the O/C, Teliamura PS alleging, inter alia, that on 25.02.2021 in the afternoon at around 5.30 pm, his father Parameshwar Roy (now deceased) while coming towards his house from his house on foot maintaining left side of the road, one unregistered motorcycle suddenly dashed him from back side near LPG Godown at Karailong and knocked him down. The local people then shifted his father to Teliamura Hospital but considering the gravity of injury, his father was referred to G.B Hospital and got him admitted there but during treatment, on 08.03.2021 at 2 PM his father died in the said hospital. It is alleged that due to rash and negligent riding of the motorcycle the accident had occurred. On the basis of that ejahar, a police case was registered at Teliamura PS vide Teliamura P.S Case No.2021TLM029 under Sections 279/304A of IPC and Sections 184/187 of the M.V. Act. Police, thereafter, investigated the case and submitted a charge-sheet (Exbt.4 series) under Sections 279/304A of IPC and Sections 177/184 of the M.V Act against the rider of the motorcycle namely, Sri Mohan Das. [14] In the report, I.O has also stated that during investigation it was revealed from the statement of the witnesses, mechanical inspection report, post mortem report and other circumstantial evidences that the accident occurred due to rash and …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
MAC.App. No.42 of 2026
1.
The Branch Manager, the Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., a company
registered under the Companies Act, 1956, represented by the Assistant
Manager cum officer in legal hub/authorized signatory, Agartala, Division
Office, HGB Road, (near Sarkar Nursing Home), Agartala, West Tripura.
…..Appellant
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
1.
2.
Smti. Saraswati Roy, wife of late Parameshwar Roy.
Sri Tapas Roy, son of late Parameshwar Roy, both are residents of
Teliamura, P.S. Teliamura, District: Khowai, Tripura.
…..Claimants/respondents
3.
Mohan Das, son of Rabi Das, village: Sukantapally, Ward No.3, P.S.
Teliamuar, District: Khowai Tripura.
…..Respondent
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. Biswanath Majumder, Advocate.
None.
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
_F_I_N_A_L_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
20.04.2026
Heard.
[2]
The present appeal has been filed under Section-173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 against the judgment and award dated 07.01.2026 passed by the
learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Court No.1, West Tripura,
Agartala, in connection with T.S. (MAC) 193 of 2021.
[3]
The appellant has prayed for the following reliefs:
“i. Admit this appeal.
ii. Issue notice upon the respondents.
iii. Call for records of the case from the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/Court
No.1, Tripura West, Agartala, in case No. T.S. (MAC) 193 of 2021.
iv. Stay the operation of the impugned judgment and award dated 07.01.2026,
passed by the Ld. Member Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/Court No.1,
Tripura West, Agartala, in case No. T.S. (MAC) 193 of 2021.
v. After hearing the parties at length, be pleased enough to dismiss/set
aside/quash the impugned judgment and award dated 07.01.2026, passed by the
Ld. Member Motor (Namely Sri Ashutosh Pandey), Motor Accieent Claims
Tribunal/Court No.1, Tripura West, Agartala, in case No. T.S. (MAC) 193 of
2021.”
[4]
The case of the claimant respondents herein in brief, is that on
25.02.2021, Parameshwar Roy was coming towards his house from Karailong
Chowmuhani on foot maintaining left side of the road and on the way when he
reached near a godown at Karailong, suddenly one Yamaha (R15) Motorcycle
bearing Model No.YZF155-A, Chassis No.ME1RG5259K0047935 coming with
high speed dashed him from back side. Consequently, Parameshwar Roy (now
deceased) sustained grievous multiple injuries on his person. After the accident, he
was at first shifted to Teliamura hospital with serious condition wherefrom the
injured was referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital for better treatment and got him
admitted there but during treatment, on 08.03.2021 at about 2 PM he died in the
said hospital. It is stated that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent riding
of the motorcycle by its rider. Concerning the accident, a police case was registered
at Teliamura Police Station vide Teliamura P.S. Case No.29/2021 U/Ss.279/304-A
of I.P.C and Sections 184/187 of the M.V. Act. As stated, deceased was 60 years
old and as a mason by profession, he used to earn Rs.15,000/-, per month. Finally,
they claimed compensation to the tune of Rs.35,35,000/- under different heads.
[5]
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties, the
learned Court below has observed as under:
“It is, therefore, held that the present claimant petitioners namely; Smti.
Saraswati Roy and Sri Tapas Roy are entitled to get compensation of
Rs.8,48,960/- (Rupees Eight Lakhs Forty Eight Thousand Nine Hundred Sixty)
only with interest @ 7.5% per annum from 08.11.2021 i.e. from the date of
filing of the claim petition till the date of actual payment. O.P No.1 i.e. the
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. shall pay the amount of compensation with interest
within 30 days from today in terms of Section 168(3) of M.V. Act, 1988.
Out of the awarded amount of compensation inclusive of interest, the claimant
petitioner no.1 (wife of the deceased) will get 60% and the claimant petitioner
no.2 will get 40%. Out of the respective share of claimant petitioners no.1 & 2,
50% each of their respective share shall be kept in fixed deposit schemes in
their respective names with any Nationalized Bank of their locality for a period
of five years and the remaining 50% of their respective share shall be paid to
them through their respective bank account. However, liberty is given to both
the claimant petitioners to withdraw monthly interest from their respective
fixed deposit to meet their day to day expenses. No loan or withdrawal shall be
permitted from/against any of the fixed deposit certificates without prior
permission of this Tribunal.”
[6]
Being dissatisfied with the observes made by the learned Court
below, the appellant insurance company has preferred the present appeal.
[7]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
insurance company has submitted that all the averments made by the claimantrespondents in their claim petition are not trustworthy. They have also denied the
age, occupation and monthly income of the deceased. It is further stated that in case
of violation of any terms and conditions of the insurance policy, they would not be
responsible to indemnify the insured owner. According to the appellant, they were
not aware of any criminal case being registered concerning the alleged accident.
Moreover, the owner-cum-rider did not inform anything to them about the alleged
accident.
[8]
It has been submitted that the learned Court below did not apply its
judicious mind and with flagrant disregard of law and justice and in a pervasive
manner, has imposed the liability of payment of compensation of Rs. 08,48,960/only upon the appellant Insurance Company and as such, it is not only sustainable
and tenable in the eye of the law but of excessive and harsh and as such, it is liable
to be dismissed/set aside in limine.
[9]
The learned Court below, believe the deposition of P.WS. 1 & 2 who
were not eye witnesses and they concealed the incident. But solely basing on their
deposition, the learned Court below has awarded the liability of payment of
compensation upon the Appellant. In this regard, there is no any whisper in the
impugned judgment and award under what manner and what is the basis of such
belief. The learned Court below, has been inspired to rely upon the deposition
rendered by the witnesses without any corroboration of any other witnesses and
what had been stated in their evidence on affidavit of the claimant respondent that
has been vividly accepted and appreciated as a real truth by the learned Court
below, having ignored the evidence came out through cross examination of
themselves. So, the impugned judgment and award shall be modified to that extent.
[10]
The alleged accident was not proved by adducing cogent evidence at
all, basing on the claim petition, wherein, the claimants purposefully and
intentionally described their story in order to get compensation. The entire claim
proceeding had been advanced with the erroneous belief of facts and the learned
Court below ultimately ahs passed the judgment by awarding the liability of
payment of compensation upon the appellant insurance company having ignored
the other relevant materials.
[11]
The learned Court below, has failed to appreciate that as per
provision of Section 158(6) of the M.V. Act, 1988, it is stated that as soon as any
information regarding any accident involving death or bodily injury to any person
is recorded or report under this section is completed by a police officer, the Officerin-charge of the police station shall forward a copy of the same within thirty days
from the date of recording information, or as the case may be, on completion of
such report to the claim tribunal having jurisdiction and a copy thereof to the
concerned insurer and where a copy made available to the owner, he shall also
within thirty days of receipt of such report, forward the same to such claim tribunal
and Insurer, due to non-compliance of the above statutory provision of the M.V.
Act, the impugned judgment is liable to be dismissed.
[12]
The learned Court below, has failed to appreciate that, wherein, the
facts and circumstances involving therewith in the alleged accident have not been
established but on the basis of some decisions has arrived at the conclusion that the
claimant respondents are entitled to have compensation at the tune of Rs.
08,48,960/- only including interest to be accrued thereupon to be paid by the
appellant insurance company. It is respectfully submitted that all the decisions of
the Hon'ble Apex Court, cited by the learned Court below for awarding
compensation are not matching and relevant in the instant claim proceeding, since,
facts and circumstances of the alleged accident have not been proved and
established by any cogent evidence as well as relevant materials.
[13]
On perusal of the FIR and Ejahar (Exbt.1 series) it reveals that on
08.03.2021, Sri Tapas Roy (son of the deceased) lodged the ejahar with the O/C,
Teliamura PS alleging, inter alia, that on 25.02.2021 in the afternoon at around 5.30
pm, his father Parameshwar Roy (now deceased) while coming towards his house
from his house on foot maintaining left side of the road, one unregistered
motorcycle suddenly dashed him from back side near LPG Godown at Karailong
and knocked him down. The local people then shifted his father to Teliamura
Hospital but considering the gravity of injury, his father was referred to G.B
Hospital and got him admitted there but during treatment, on 08.03.2021 at 2 PM
his father died in the said hospital. It is alleged that due to rash and negligent riding
of the motorcycle the accident had occurred. On the basis of that ejahar, a police
case was registered at Teliamura PS vide Teliamura P.S Case No.2021TLM029
under Sections 279/304A of IPC and Sections 184/187 of the M.V. Act. Police,
thereafter, investigated the case and submitted a charge-sheet (Exbt.4 series) under
Sections 279/304A of IPC and Sections 177/184 of the M.V Act against the rider of
the motorcycle namely, Sri Mohan Das.
[14]
In the report, I.O has also stated that during investigation it was
revealed from the statement of the witnesses, mechanical inspection report, post
mortem report and other circumstantial evidences that the accident occurred due to
rash and negligent riding of the rider of motorcycle bearing Chassis
No.ME1RG5259K0047935 and out of that accident Parameshwar Roy sustained
injuries on his person and died subsequently on 08.03.2021 when he was under
treatment in AGMC & GBP Hospital. Seizure lists (Exbt.3 series) shows that
motorcycle of O.P No.1 was seized by police along with its relevant documents in
connection with the aforesaid police case.
[15]
Therefore, it is evident that Parameshwar Roy (now deceased)
sustained injuries on 25.02.2021 at 5.30 pm in a road traffic accident arising out of
the use of the offending motorcycle bearing Chassis No.ME1RG5259K0047935.
As such, the claimant-respondents have prima facie discharged their liability of
proving that Parameshwar Roy died subsequently following the injuries sustained
due to accident caused by the negligence of the rider of Yamaha (R15) motorcycle
having the Model No.YZF155-A and Chassis No.ME1RG5259K0047935.
[16]
It is stated that as a mason by profession, deceased used to earn
Rs.15,000/-, per month but the petitioners side failed to adduce any documentary
evidence regarding profession and monthly income of the deceased. Thus, a lenient
view is to be taken for assessing the monthly income of the petitioner. As per
Notification dated 04.08.2023 issued by the Hon’ble High Court of Tripura, the
monthly income of skilled workers were shown at Rs.12,000/- per month involving
accident which had taken place after 31.12.2015. Since the accident took place on
25.02.2021, the monthly income of the deceased is assessed at Rs.12,000/- @
Rs.400/-, per day.
[17]
In view of overall analysis made by the learned Court below and after
going through the material evidence in its entirety, this Court is of the view that the
assessment of compensation as awarded by the learned Court below is just and
proper and needs no interference thus, the findings as arrived at by the learned
Court below stands affirmed. Consequently, the present appeal stands dismissed.
[19]
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
DR.T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
A. Ghosh
ANJAN GHOSH Date:
2026.04.27 11:57:56 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review